Skip to main content
Loading video...

Dave´s Top 100 Board Games of All Time Begins! (#100–91)

Transcript 26:10

Okay, let's go. Dave Luzapalooza Top 100 games of all time. Dave Luzapalooza Some are great, some just fine Dave Luzapalooza Here telling you just how it is. It's Matthew Jude.

Welcome to Luzapalooza My name is Dave Luza, and with me is Matthew Jude. We're going down my top 100 games of all times. It's board games, and how are you going into this? It feels weird to not add the word board games. How are you going into this, Matthew? I'm going in excited and ready to be ready to agree the heck, Alia. Just agree with you so hard here. I'm going to agree with almost everything you say. We have, okay, we have a similar taste in games. But we don't have... Do we have a, actually? No, I think about it. We have we don't have the most. Your love for Reiner, Knitzia is... wrong. unrivaled.

Even by others who claim to be the biggest fans. It's fine. He's got good games. Some of them might have made it into my top 20. Maybe. But it's just unhealthy. It is, it is. I just, yesterday, I saw something. Five different games with five different names that are all the same game. Yeah, that all that happened. annoys a heck out of me. A lot of reprints. I'm just, I just think, come on now. Let's calm down. So, I'm excited. I'm excited. Gift Siri, no. Here we go. Woo-hoo.

because I feel like it would have been out of spite. Between 2 cities, it is a game where you make a choice, you get tiles and you place them on the, you're making a city with your right neighbor and with your left neighbor. And you try to make them of equal value, because that would be beneficial, if you only make one good, and then the other one is worse, and you end up with a lower total, then your neighbor, because they will have that same city, but they have a better city on the other side. So, you need to, you need to make sure that, uh, they are both as great as they are, so... How do you bite the cities? Is it polyomino tiles? Is it what?

No, it's not polyomena. It's just square tiles. You just add squares to them. It's really fun. Between 2 cities, I think it's very underrated. It is a Stonemeyer game games game. I want to play this game, but I've not had the chance because I feel like you need a good bunch of people. More than three. It doesn't matter. I mean, of course it matters. If you play 2 player games. We both have the same cities next to each other. Not like a tiny man. Of course, with more people, it's better because you can compare to other people. There is a newer version of this game, which is between 2 castles of Mad King Ludwig, which is the same principle. Yeah, and I see how that game excites you more, but this was first, and I didn't want to put the other one on the list.

So I chose... change what's on the list because of your moral, like, a feeling. It is or it isn't day. No, you can. You can do whatever you want. is your list. That's what I did Number 100 between 2 cities. Then we go to number 99. I need to have some time to load the visual because here it is. Uh, river dragons. Now, river dragons. game not on anyone else's top 100 ever, I don't feel like. This game is we had the big version of this game. I think we played this once, the big version. And we played it together, Dice Tower Khan once, the big version. That's the only time I've ever played the game. It's fun. You try to cross the stream. the river.

and you're putting down stones and then put planks on those stones, and then you have your little maple walk across to the directly other side. That's why you can play it with up to six people, because the board has enough room for those people to move. You program your five moves ahead of time. So first, I'm going to put down this stone. I'm going to put this plank on that stone, then I'm going to move on that. Then, hopefully, you will have connected to that, so I will jump over you, and then I am at the other side. That's the plan. But then That's the plan else. Not at least.

that's not gonna happen. plank, then your man is not gonna walk onto that thing. So, that's what I really like about programming games. You have things ahead of you, that you really want to do, and then, in the end, everyone's plans fall into the water, literally, because there's water, it's river dragons. This is family appropriate as well, right? For a programming game. Yes. Yes.

I took this game to both school because I wanted to be one of those cool dads who said, I'll start a board gaming group here. So, we played, like, king of Tokyo, and this was the first big game I took out, because I had that big version, and they were all in awe when we were playing it, and I, we walk around, people have cards in their hand, the kids, and it's like, ooh, don't make sure you don't really bend the cards that hard, because that would just not be cool. No, don't do that. No.

And then I saw one of the cards, it had bite marks on them. And I look at the kid and he said, What are you doing? Stop doing that. I know we're not supposed to hit children, but I think if I would... That's a trophy rule, I feel. Yes. This is not cool. What's number 98? 98? Here we go. Whoop. The gang. Okay. Now the gang is a gang that came out recently. I'll allow this one. I'll allow it That's good. It is a poker game. We're playing poker, but it is a co-op poker game where the goal is for everyone to, um, to rank their poker hand comparing to the others.

But of course, you can't see the cards. It's Texas, hold them poker, so everyone's holding 2 cards. And then you look at your 2 cards and you say, ooh, we've got 2 aces. I think I have the best hand. So you grab the chip that says, that's the best hand. And someone else has 2 kings. So they think, no, there's probably not 2 aces in this game. I will take that 1st six. So you start the little tug of war. like, are you sure?

There's that moment where you have to say, I promise you, I have the best hand. What game we played recently a game like that where... Oh, we played it together where it was like, no, I guarantee ito. Ito, we played that. Oh, yeah, I was like, I promise you, I, this is where it should be. But gone. Yeah. Oh, no, power nap. How long should a power nap be? or a nap? And everyone would write down their own answers. And then we need to put them in order of each other. So like, I think, I nap longer than you. No, I promise you, my nap is longer than you are now. And that's also a fun way. In the gang, what happens is that you do at one time to see who's got the best hand, then more cards are revealed, just like in poker, and then you get to reevaluate the hands.

And Dave has a mathematical kind of the right correct way to do this. He doesn't go off vibes and fun. He goes off like logic and deduction, which are the 2 ways to play this game. What you should do. I mean, yeah, I yeah, I guess. It's a great game. I love this one.

not playing you're not playing poker with each other. You're not trying to beat each other. You're trying to convey the correct information. If there's a possibility on the street. straight. I'm holding out for a straight... I've got a flash. I guarantee I'm all in. I've got a 50% chance I did the math in my head. There's a 50% chance. I'll end up having the great best hand. That's fine.

know that you should have the best end. But until right is a fact. Who has this time right now? I can get very fierce in this game. You can't. good, though. It is a good one. So that's my number. 98. Next up is I have to have to look for the file before I remember what it was. Captain Click. Captain Flip. Now, this was one of the games that me and Ilka, we like to gift games that we think are good to families around us. And this was last year's gift to my colleague, Daniel, he's got a family. They don't play a lot of games, but this is one of the games that I gifted them last year, because it's that easy.

You can play this with a seven year old. So you've got a pirate ship in front of you. Everyone has their own ship. You draw one tile, and you look at it. Oh, there's a crewmate on the tile. Where do you want to place it? If you decide not to place this side, you then turn it around, and then you must play the other side. And it could be worse. Could be worse. And then you just keep on playing until the game's over. It's fast. It's a lot of fun. There are some surprises in there. There are some tactics in there. I really enjoy... I never seen a game of this go poorly. It's always hits. It's good for families. It's simple. It's yeah, it's a, and there's lots of variation.

There's different maps and stuff that you can play with. It's... Definitely, I saw that... already that that really makes opens the door to even more shenanigans. 96 on tour. This is what we call a role and write or no, it's a it's a role. Yeah, it's a role and oh, you also flip cards. Well, it doesn't matter. This game, you have the map of either the USA or Europe and Europe going on tour. Yes.

but you are only allowed to visit venues. You need to write a number in it, that 2 dice are making up, so you're real too nice to D tens. And you can combine them in any way. So you can, if you roll a 6 and a 7. No. And you either put 67 or 76 on one of the spots that is that you need to choose from the cards that you're drawing at the same time. The goal of the game is to have a continuous line of numbers that go up. Yeah, that's going to be your tour, which sounds amazing in the beginning, but at some point there's going to be this big burn of your brains, like, no.

It has a tipping point where this game just goes wrong for everyone, right? You have these plans. I'm going to go here, then here, then here. I've left perfect gaps. There's a 10 gap here. There 10 gap. It just goes horrendously wrong and it's cascade of failures. But it's fun. That sounds like... I just need to roll somewhere between a 22 and a 27. That will come up. That's easy.

It's a good one. such a fun, fun game. You can play it with as many people as you want. That's also a thing. and we played this on stream a lot during the pandemic. Yeah. is those kind of feelings, those memories behind the game, where it can, having a great experience at the right time. Oh, we played this like, I remember I went to China with my brother and we played Hanabi a bunch of times. And to me now, Hanabi's got this such a boosted feeling of, oh, but it's like, it's the experience of the time. All right. right, next, it was gone. Really good. Rumble Nation. This is an older game that just got a deluxe reskin. Yeah.

Talk about games that cascade into chaos. This is exactly that, right, in a board game. Yes. So no, I usually we do not, I do not like area majority games where you're putting out troops and you try to be have the most so you can get the benefit. Well, this is a game like that. Those area control area majority games usually take hours because there's a lot of thinking that goes into it. This is this is a 20 minute game. It has 2 phases. The 1st phase, everyone is rolling dice and they decide where you are allowed to place your troops on a map that has 12 distinct areas. And that's the first part. And then the second part is where all the battle is taking place.

So you start with the lowest number. Who has the majority there? Now, what the fun thing is, if you win a low numbered area, then you are allowed to send out reinforcements to adjacent areas that you already have a presence in there. So, if you are able to plan the best, then you have a cascading effect, and then you slowly gain more troops in those hired numbered areas that you were not winning before. And the higher number areas are worth more points, right? Yes.

like the eight. the lower scoring ones, but by the 8 area. I want to be winning it so then I can like carry on winning the rest of them. That's always my plan. But because the numbers are not in a sequence. You mind up your 8 being surrounded by loan numbers, meaning if everyone else wins those loan numbers, then they get to reinforce the 8 and you get nothing. That... I often do get nothing. This is great.

Yes. That is Rumble Nation. My 95. So let's go to 94. Here we go. The Guild of Merchant Explorers. Now, this... Sounds like a very highbrow game. The Guild of Merchant Explorers, Dave? Yeah, the name of the game, also the art of the game, does not do justice as the... It doesn't do justice. Yeah, I totally agree. This game maybe should have been a role in right? So, or a flip and write where something it flips and, but they instead chose to Matthew Dunstan, was it a co-creation? It doesn't really matter. Great, great board game designer. And, um, Instead of marking the things you get to put little cubes on the tiles and discovery tiles, and so you were discovering this map, and slowly getting more powers, which is awesome.

There are so many cards that you personally, oh, I get amazing powers that I can do over and over again. You build up... You kind of break the basic rules for the powers where you can place and you want to, there's certain things you want to do to score and you want to get to these different areas, get to these towers, do, there's lots of ways to score, get these gold and stuff, and the game continuously, it resets a bunch of times, doesn't it? But then you can start again from if you've managed to reach these different villages. If you've built cities or settlements. Yeah, on the map, then you don't have to start at your beginning, but you can... I've done it before.

game because it's going to get me lots of points and then I don't quite get there and my legs round, I'm starting from nothing again and it's like, oh, I'm losing this game now. Yeah, it's fun. a lot of fun. It was more vibrant. I wish it was more, and I wish it was called The Explorers. The just the, or the, the, something more than the guild of merchants because it doesn't feel like it feels like... is a boring word. Oh, we're in a guild. I'm not talking about D&D guild or something or a World of Warcraft guild. I see the benefit in this, but in a game about merchants, yeah, we do the bookkeeping together, we have the same, I don't care about that. So that's blend. Then you have merchants.

There's no trading in this game. You're not buying or selling anything. There's no reason for... You do kind of get coins, which could be seen as going somewhere and doing a bit of trading, but it's very abstracted. It feels like it should just, it should be the pirates of the new sea or something, you know what I mean? And then have a cover art that is like... We're doing this. We're discovering, you can call it anything, but please don't call it the guilt of merchant Explorers. It's great game, though. Yeah, it's really a great game and that's why it's on the list. So now we get to 93. Oh boy, we're we're we're flight. These are all amazing games. Wavelength, party games. It's a game where you're trying to, uh, one person knows a, uh, a spot on a scale from, I'm going to give it a number, but the game that usually has this cool toy that you can hold.

Yes, got toy factor. you get a scale that determines what is one to 10. So it's from, uh, loser to hero. I don't know. Yeah, so... I think you lose a hero. And then you've turned this machine, the wavelength machine, and it's given you where you need to get. So it's about, you know, 40% on the scale towards the loser side. So you got to think, okay, I need someone who is, so Walter Mitty would be the one to pick, right? Because that's like he's he's kind of a hero, but he's a bit of a, you know, loser. He's not like, you know what I mean? That kind of thing.

Yeah. He just zoned out. So yeah, that puts him... He's definitely a cool character, especially when you watch the movie, the season by the movie. It changed my life. So there we go. This is important. This is, yeah, we're doing tub on. Game has managed to permeate through to normies, I suppose, non-board gamers. Right? Lots of people play this.

yeah, it's fun. original. I can't say it's massive. We do it sometimes in our podcast where you say, okay, between hairy and smooth. Which board game is a 7 on that scale? You can do this for anything. You can do this for soccer players. from on a scale from, yeah, smooth the hairy. Yeah, you could totally do that. In fact, the game, smooth to hairy will be coming out soon and it's just that's the only question in the game. It's a good one though. This is a great party game and it just works and you can just dip in and out and it's quick and it's fast and it's funny. exactly. Yeah, and you can also do. to explain too much about it. Yeah.

So that's 93, 92, another great game. game that I really enjoy, jump drive. Now jump drive is a toned down version of race for the galaxy. It's a card-based game, where you're building your tableau, and you're getting points now, for whatever reason, me and Ilka stuck to this game, and this was our go to game for over a year. We just played this. two, 3 games in a row just to see who would win. You can, it's really a great game, and it's different from... So you play all games, which is... To see who always... That's the race for the galaxy is a little bit more, um, there are 2 phases in there that kind of confuses us.

I'd say, where you're producing things and then you're selling things, but you can get, and this game drops 2 of those phases. It's faster, it's cleaner. This is more of a family game where... You get the fun of the system, but in a quicker, easier, a more approachable way. And it's a fun system where I follow, I lead you follow kind of bonuses to go for and stuff. Yeah, I played this one time and I would like to play it some more. It is good.

Yes. We'd love to do that with games that we play a lot that when you open it up, we just take off the lid. There's a little... Yeah, ready to go. Just go shuffle the cards and we're off. Ah, jump, jump. I want to play this game right now. And the final game of this episode. Yeah, what is it? It's going to be a cliffhanger. No, we can't do cliffhangers.

That's just no noise. Okay. Oh, this is... this is such a... Fascinating. And all the other players are trying to find that treasure before anyone else does. You do that by playing cards that allow you to do specific actions, like using a compass to circle off a part of the area. And then whoever has hit the treasure needs to check on their smaller version of the map. They have a miniature secret map, where they have a scaled version of that circle, and then it's like, oh, the treasure is inside or outside of that map. So you were in...

It's not, yeah. Yeah. So good. games more than I think I like deduction games. I think this would be one that I would enjoy because I always say I don't like deduction because I've had some bad experiences. I don't like feeling stupid, essentially, and I was like feeling like a big domy. That's not the kind of experience I want and because I am that. A lot of games make me feel that. So I'm kind of shy away from it. But yeah, I'm interested in this and if Vincent you trade art and it looks lovely and yes. Yeah, it looks really lovely. Now, as I'm talking about this, It has been a while since I've played this game because, I mean, a 100 games, you're not repeating all of these games every year, then you would hardly have time to play any other games.

So I'm now wondering if it's a co-op game if you're working together to find the treasure. Guess I have to play this again soon. That's the thing. You can go, oh, I love this game, but not play it for 3 years and go, I know I love it. I don't, it's like a film. I know I love that film. I tried to keep my collections small, which means, yes, I do not own all of the games, even games that are on my top 100 of games. I've gotten rid of Treasure Island, just because it's a big box. I love playing it, but we rarely play it during the year. Um, I've seen people who mark all of their boxes at the beginning of the year, and if it still has a mark on it, uh, after a year, then I said, this has to go.

I have not played scythe in 2 years, I think. Good. It has 4 boxes. I think I need to get rid of side. I think everyone should get rid of scientist garbage. That's just my opinion, people. That's just me. If you love it, then you love it. That's great. that you love it. Go play. I advise you, try recall. Just saying, that's my opinion. I have a, anyway, that's a wild thing that we don't need to talk about now. But what we do need to talk about now is saying, hey, thank you, Dave, for having me on this. I might be here for the rest of these episodes. In fact, I will be.

from that man right there, there, him, then you can by subscribing, and we'd appreciate the heck out of you. If you want to hear our voices and just do a strange comedy podcast about board games, then you can do that as well, with This Game is Broken, wherever you get your podcasts. I don't know why I'm doing the outro. I think it's because we do a podcast together and sometimes I just do the outro, so I feel like Dave should be talking, but I'm talking. Dave, anything you want to say? Uh, we have a Patreon? Yay. All right, see you next episode, everyone. Let us know what you think below. We'll see you then. Bye. Bye. Dave Luzapalooza Top 100 games of all time. Dave Luzapalooza Some are great, some just fine Dave Luzapalooza Here telling you just how it is.

It's Matthew Jude.

Progress saved