Skip to main content
Loading video...

Top Ten Board Games Overlooked by Spiel Des Jahres

Transcript 23:58

hi I'm Adam in Wales and this is my board gaming Vlog and over the next few episodes we're going to be exploring the history of the Spiel as yarz award and all the different games that have have come under that Banner whether they're nominations or recommendations ultimately winners and today I'm going to be looking at games that were overlooked by Las spiela yarz jury uh over recent is or or even further into the past so I'm looking at my top 10 games that I think would have fulfilled the criteria of this specific award but didn't even receive a recommendation let alone a nomination or win the award so what is the spielers yarz well it's the most prestigious gaming award in the world it's based in Germany they release currently three different Awards one is for essentially a family game a family style game one is for a connoisseurs game an experts game so essentially a Gamers game and then the third award is for children's games Sheriff of Nottingham is an unusual case it hasn't actually been released yet in Germany well in fact it's released in 2016 so it won't be eligible for the spiers yarz award until next year the reason that I put it on the list is because Sheriff of Nottingham has had several different previous versions um most notably there's a version called heart and deun Har and Deena I don't know how to pronounce that close to the Border it means and this

one was actually recommended by the spieles yarz jury back in 2006 so whether Sheriff of Nottingham has done enough to distinguish itself from its predecessor um I don't know uh certainly it's a good enough game to win the award it's the right sort of weight to win the award and Arcane wonders and dice tower Essentials have done some Stellar artwork and production on this game it's not unheard of for a game to win the award that has had a previous version recently um the connoisseur's choice was given to a game called broom service and that was a reworking of a previous game wi is Brew but that didn't stop it winning the award Sheriff of Nottingham is actually based on a 1950s game called Contraband um so it's been around for a long long time so it'll be interesting to see what happens with this game so far not many awards for Sheriff of Nottingham although it's made a big impact in the gaming world I see it been played a lot it's extremely popular it's selling well and so far it's only really been recognized by the board games Australia award which is a a slightly lesser known award but throughout this video I want to talk about these other awards that go on so board games Australia offer an award to uh the best International game uh from the Australian perspective uh the best game overall and the best children's game so in this case this has has won the the best International game in 2015 um can it go on to win a Spiel as

YZ I don't know we'll find out next year in Sheriff of Nottingham players take turns playing as the sheriff each other player selects cards from the deck and tries to maneuver sets of cards from their hands into their scoring piles easy enough to do when they're low scoring apples or chickens but more difficult to go unnoticed if the cards an illegal item or Contraband players Place their cards into a small pouch and declare its contents either truthfully or falsely to the sheriff the sheriff in turn can let their pouch go unchecked or accuse them of deception and open the pouch and players are encouraged to bribe the sheriff to make this decision a little easier for him if the sheriff is wrong then he pays the player gold if he's correct then the player pays him a fine after several rounds of bluffing and double bluffing players score their goods and the highest score is the winner of the game number nine on my list is a game which is by um the same designer as kazon which is one of the real Staples of the board gaming modern board gaming era so this is a game by clouse Jurgen Reda again I don't know whether I've pronounced that correctly but it's the downfall of Pompei now this game is an excellent tile laying game it's simple um it's it's got a lot going for it and yet it flew under the radar a little bit

you know it's hung around for a few years you still find it in print it comes back in new additions and this sort of thing but it's not heavy on the awards in fact the only award that I've got written down in my sheet here of any uh substantial sort of uh note is 2006 it won the games magazine award uh the family award for that now games magazine is a US publication um that chooses games each year so it is one of the more significant Awards um but whether that really has any any Major Impact in terms of sales I don't know but doubtful of Pompei seems to have been overlooked downfall of Pompei is a game of two halves in the first half of the game players take turns playing cards from their hands and placing citizens into buildings in the city of Pompei the different locations open up different strategic options for placement and on occasion players are given the opportunity to sacrifice their opponent citizens to the rumbling volcano dropping them into the cardboard crater at the midpoint of the game the volcano erupts and the experience becomes an aggressive game of drawing lava tiles from a bag placing them onto the board in the most devastating positions for your opponents who are simultaneously trying to find a clear route out of the city gates for their own citizens at the end of the game the player with the most surviving citizens win

wins the third game on my list and number eight is goblet by blue orange now goblet is an abstract strategy game and these have tended to do extremely well in the spiers yaras award in the past with games like um quarto and uh quidor and practically every game in the GF series getting some sort of Nod or recognition either a recommendation or a nomination um so it's odd to see that goblet which fits very comfortably into those categories of games specifically the gigamic wooden series um hasn't actually been recommended or nominated for any such award even though this game has sold I believe it's well over a million copies by now and it was the the game that that that founded the company blue orange which has gone on to be a major Force in this sort of family game market so it's an oddity that goblet didn't get an award and in fact hasn't won many awards apart from as far as I can tell toy Awards which uh I was I was sort of looking at for the first time today when when thinking about this video so goblet has won awards like the oppenheim toy portfolio uh and the Parents Choice Award which are awards that are given to toys so that's a whole other category that we could be looking at but no Spiel as yarz for goblet goblet is a game similar to tic-tac-toe whereby players attempt to form a row of four cups of

their own color the twist in the game is that the larger cups can move to a position where they cover smaller cups introducing a new layer of strategy and memory to the classic game game number seven is mysterium so mysterium uh is this was quite a big hit when it came out quite a lot of Buzz around this game it hung around for a while in its Ukrainian and polish versions t n de mosa I don't know I had that version sitting on my shelf for a long time and then this lovely liad and uh is it an asmay uh yeah this release um gave it lavish sort of production values really enhanced that original artwork and and turned it into a a real Mass Market game where previously it was a little bit of a niche um it's the right sort of weight for the spiers yarz I don't know quite how they feel about Cooperative games but Hanabi has won it previously a Cooperative game um so really it's surprising to see that it didn't even get a recommendation even though it has one other Awards so mysterium tends to have done quite well with the French jues so it's had a silver award from trick track which is a French uh website about board games that's very popular it's also one the um judan the the the game of the year award um from asdor which is is the major sort of

French board game award um I'm trying my best with these pronunciations you'll have to forgive me but at least I'm having a go so mysterium I think has been oddly overlooked I think with this actual uh this this production particularly the mysterian production as opposed to the Ukrainian and polish versions The Rules were a little bit overworked you know and and and they tried to fix a few problems that maybe didn't need fix fix ing or if they did need fixing I'm not sure they found the right approach so perhaps they over complicated things and that could have been one of the things that knocked it or otherwise perhaps it's the spooky sort of theme it's not like uh German families are averse to ghost themed games a lot of the children games see seem to um be based around haunted castles and things like this but this is a more adult spooky sort of game about murder and um and seances perhaps that just takes it slightly out of that family sort of field mysterium is a clever combination of the game's Dixit and cludo this Cooperative game sees all players work as a team one player plays as a silent ghost giving dreamlike cards representing Visions to their teammates these teammates play as psychics and collaboratively try and interpret the ghost's cryptic messages in order to establish the exact nature of the ghost's murder who was the cul where did it happen and what was the murder

weapon number six on my list is Dice Town a game by Bruno catala now this one really hasn't won any sort of award it's it's it it's right up The Spar Street simple effective um looks great plays in a quick amount of time uh great for families uh it won the the leasee grand public award which is a award a french- speaking award from Quebec um but but but that's about all I think dice town would have been a shoe in for at least a recommendation with the SPI asz but apparently not in dice town players simultaneously roll poker dice in noisy plastic cups slamming them down on the table to reveal their results they can pay money to reroll dice and once all results are revealed the player with the most of each dice result things in action related to various locations on the wild west Dice Town board rolling the most nines allows you to visit the gold mine claiming nuggets which will net you victory points the player with most tens robs the bank most Jacks Awards you special ability or scoring cards from the General Store most Queens allows you to steal from other players in the saloon most Kings Awards you the sheriff's badge and from here on you decide ties and you're welcome to accept IES from the other players the overall best poker hand wins Point scoring landscape cards and any player who has none of these locations still gets a bonus from Dr

badluck after several rounds the player with the most points from the cards the gold nuggets and the money wins the game now Sushi go has been through a few different versions and and actually Sushi Go is is designed by Phil Walker Hardy who is the designer of emote which is one of the the contenders for this year's spiers yarz award but Sushi go has become a staple of of most many gamers libraries it's a real simple introductory um card drafting game that's a real good lead on for things like seven wonders and stuff like that in fact I believe it was inspired by Seven Wonders just made much more simple um it sold loads and loads of copies as far as I can tell this is the original Edition but there was a later game right Edition that came in a tin that was very very successful now the German version of sushi go um they did something a little bit odd and this was from Zach which is uh one of my very favorite Publishers so they went with this weird slightly gross artwork which I I really really enjoy but perhaps that might be where this has fallen down so we've gone from sort of super cute to really quite disturbing sort of pictures of melting pudding faces and um and and little fat faces and and sushi that looks terrified to be eaten it it's it's not a pretty game I think it's quite funny the German

version um but I wonder whether that's that's part of what's what's killed its appeal um it's good to see that it was recognized again in the Australian board game awards where it it won the main award there it was also recognized as best card game at the UK games Expo Awards which first one I've mentioned those particular Awards but that's something that's given out each year and is growing in stature as uh as more of these awards are given out in the UK games Expo grows I believe it was also uh let me have a look at my sheet yes it won the best card game award for the origins award Origins being one of the big us board game conventions but again not even a nod from the spiers arez jewry in susho players have a hand of cards representing different types of Japanese food they select one card to keep and they pass the others to a neighboring player so that the dishes rotate around the table just like dishes in a sushi restaurant gradually each player is going to build up a collection of cards on the table in front of them and at the end of the round they score these sets of cards according to different criteria these vary depending on the different cards that are

collected now let a tycoon to be fair hasn't had a German release yet so it's not actually eligible for the awards which might explain why it hasn't had one but the spiers Yara Awards don't tend to recognize small Publishers um firsttime Publishers Kickstarter outfits that sort of thing this game is I mean it's ideal for an award light Builders yaras it's it's perfect in terms of its weight it's its duration its accessibility um and so I was really pleased to see that it has won an award which is the Mena select award so Mena select award is selected by members of Mena um clearly the sort of the organization for extremely intelligent or extremely high IQ individuals um and they've chosen this game as one of their games of the year in 2015 so I'm glad to see that I hope when it gets a German release we get to see this this game explode and and it should be everywhere this is this is a fantastic alternative to Scrabble it's got a little bit of economics in it wonderful game should be on the build as yar's um radar we'll see when it gets its German release in letter Tycoon players have a hand of cards each representing a letter of the alphabet on their turn they use these letters to make a word which will generate them coins depending on the length of the word these coins are subsequently used to buy patents which are unique tiles relating to each letter of the alphabet from here on whenever

another player chooses to use the patented letter the owner of the patent will claim additional coins from the bank some patents also offer special abilities which allow the players to break the rules in some way enabling them to create even higher scoring words when one player has purchased a set Target number of patents the game ends and players work out their total worth in coins and patents the wealthiest player is the winner formula D came out in 2008 now its original version was way back in 1991 and that was a game called formula day so I was expecting when I looked back at the old anals of spieler Zars to find a recommendation somewhere around there in the early '90s there can't have been that many great games around then that was not the Golden Era of gaming that we're in now and yet formula D was around and formula D is still a fantastic game to this day yet there's no sign of any sort of nomination and it's perfect for the award it's the right sort of weight it's perhaps a little bit long but uh but that didn't seem to be such an issue in the '90s uh it's it's it's ideal for families it's um it its theme works really really well um it it didn't the only award that I can see that it's one of any note is the ludka Luda ideal I think that's that is uh it's an Italian the Italian board game of the year award which it won in

2009 so I'm glad to see that for D1 something but I really think it should have been picked up by the sparez I think that's a potential winner certainly in 1991 what were they thinking formula D is a roll and move game that is players roll dice and move a corresponding number of spaces on the racetrack but the clever twist is that players start off rolling a four-sided D they're in first gear they move on to a six-sided die in second gear eight-sided die for third gear 12-sided die for fourth 20-sided for Fifth and a massive 30-sided die for sixth gear they can't just bomb around the track at maximum speed however because Each corner of the track has an allocated section where each car must land if cars bypass these sections by driving at Reckless speed their car starts to deteriorate losing tires brakes engine parts Etc which all essentially constitute hit points when a car runs out of hit points it's eliminated the first car to cross the finish line wins the

game and now with number two and number one we're on to some real Oddities that I think I I can't really believe that these things haven't been noticed by the jury so the first one is hecm or pamino my my this this is in the expansion box I haven't got the original box anymore but this is Rina kenia's classic dice game I think Rina kit has several master pieces but this is right up there um and yet pamino I can't see any awards won by this game at all when I'm looking online now I'm sure that that's just I haven't done enough research there must be something for this game because it's uh it's it's a classic already released in 2005 still constantly in print new expansion last year and uh it's it's great for families it's accessible it's it's perfect for the spielers YZ yet completely overlooked in pamino players attempt to claim worms from a so-called Grill which represent points at the end of the game on a player's turn they roll eight Dice and set aside all dice showing a single matching result they can then choose to roll and repeat or claim a worm from the grill showing a number equal to their total of the set aside dice however in order to claim a tile the player must have set aside at least one worm result if a corresponding tile is not present on the grid players may be able to steal such a tile from an opponent the game has a tricky push your luck aspect as players cannot set aside dice showing the same result as other

dice that they've already set aside hence players who roll Too Many Times May score big or may go bust once all worms are claimed from the grill the player with the most points wins now it's Beggar's belief that this hasn't had even a recommend recomendation let alone a nomination I can sort of understand why it might not win because it's maybe a little bit too complex and not quite complex enough for the kenis fielders as the connoisseurs award and yet takenoko is is it came out in 2011 with very little buzz it crept up it's had that M that that massive beautiful collector's edition it's still in print it's still extremely popular there are very few games as attractive as this one it's it's great for families it pulls in um players all around you know it's it's so cute you'd think it would be turning off some of the more Macho sort of Gamers but no everybody's happy to have a go Everyone likes the Little Gardener and the Little Panda and growing the bamboo it's so tactile and yet this game has only really managed to win any awards in France and the french- speaking world so it won the French award judan uh judan that's uh the the azdor award um the the designer is French antoan Bowser it won the French speaking award in Quebec the uh the least Grand public uh it did win the games magazine

G uh family game of the year which is a US award in 2013 I think this had a slightly unfortunate start in Germany in that its release was delayed for several years so it came out 2011 um but only in 2014 in Germany by which time perhaps its moment had passed in the terms of the jury's eyes and so it never got that nod that it rightly deserves in takenoko players Place tiles building a beautiful Japanese garden the garden is home to an antagonistic Gardener and Panda double act no player owns either of these characters but all players have the opportunity to activate them on their own Turn The Gardener causes bamboo to grow the panda eats bamboo players attempt to complete three different types of objective throughout the game gu Gardener objectives require certain quantities of bamboo to be present in the garden Panda objectives require the panda to have eaten certain types of bamboo and plot objectives require the tiles to be placed in certain patterns throughout the game players inadvertently help or hinder each other in achieving their secret objectives and at the end of the game the player with the most points wins so those are my 10 overlooked spiers yarz games of the year uh and uh things that really should have got a recommendation but didn't I'm going to go on to look at some other games that did get a nod from the spiers Urus jury SPI desar jury uh over my next few

videos uh I'm Adam in Wales uh if you want to follow my YouTube Channel Please Subscribe and if you want to follow me on Twitter I'm boardgame Wales and on boardgame geek I'm adam78 thank you very much for watching all the best

Progress saved