Skip to main content
Loading video...

Innovation in Wargaming: Past, Present, & Future

Transcript 59:42

There we go.

Hey, we weren't worried at all.

The bus was about to leave. We were going to leave you behind.

Oh, man. The ship was heading off the dock. I'm sorry.

All right. I think that we're actually live. So, I think what you just said is live on this.

Oh, all right.

Greetings all.

Yes. Greetings everybody. Hello. We are

on time and under budget.

Yes. Yes, we are all set. So, welcome everybody to our conversation. We were just having some last minute preparations as we started out here. Uh thank you everybody to joining from uh SD Histcon. Our topic for today is innovation in wargame and I am honored to have our panel members here with us. Um what I'm going to do a basic framework is I'm going to just kind of give a little bit of an outline for the session and then I'm going to let our panel members introduce themselves and then we have a bunch of prepared questions. We're going to go through them. uh this is a large topic so we in no way are going to be able to be comprehensive about this. Our goal really is to be more uh fun and interesting and we'll talk about the things that seem to go there. Um we do have some prepared questions but at the same time feel free to drop some questions into the chat as you are uh listening to to us talk here too. Um a couple of things about just to ground us a little bit. I mean we could spend a lot of time word smithing a definition of innovation for the sake of we the idea that most of us understand a pretty good idea what it is. I'm going to use a basic definition that I got from Mariam Webster Webster which was a new idea method or device that generally is an improvement over the way things that are done. Um it can also be a process right?

So it it could be a lot of times innovation is referred to the process of making things better rather than an artifact. And with the idea of an artifact, it could be a thing, for example, better printing. Or it could also be an idea. One of the things that when I was working as an innovation facilitator would use an example was crop rotation. There was nothing created in the world. It was just a different way of doing things. So it doesn't necessarily have to be anything tangible. It could be just a concept that drives change, too. Um, with the idea, a big part of this too is that innovation is iterative. So we're always building off the giants that came before us. So oftent times an idea isn't entirely created create creative of its own. We take a look at something else that we like and we think oh if I tweak this or tweak that I could make it better. So just some grounding thoughts on on innovation as we go forward here.

Uh but with that in mind too we're going to try to make this conversation beginner friendly. So I know we have a lot of people watching on YouTube that may have various levels of wargaming experience. It won't be a wargaming tutorial, but we will try to explain concepts that come up that might be a little bit more intermediate or advanced. And with that, I think I would love to turn it over to our panelists to give a brief introduction about themselves and then we'll jump right into the questions. Grant, do you want to start us off with the introductions?

Sure. Uh, I'm Grant Lindberg. I'm the host of the Pushing Cardboard podcast. I also have a Pushing Cardboard YouTube channel and pushingboard.com. Uh, a war gamer of about 40 years. Uh and uh I'm happy to say that uh I've uh on my channel I've intro interviewed both these fellas and uh so I'm uh I'm odd to be here included uh along with them in this conversation.

Vocal, would you like to go?

Uh sure. Thanks Mike. Thanks for doing this. Um I'm Vocar. I'm a retired US uh federal foreign affairs analyst. Um, I've been designing um, board war games for about a quarter century. Um, most of my um, designs are published via GMT Games, but I have on the way designs also via Fort Circle Games and, uh, Failank Games.

Jerry. Uh, my name is Jerry and uh I I guess I've been wargaming since what the late 1970s, early 80s. I guess the last few years I've been designing some uh and I guess by now it's like boy 15 years I think I've been designing at least published games mostly through GMT as well.

Great. All right. Thank you very much. And I'm Mike aka Zillow Blitz. I host a a YouTube channel about board war gaming and computer wargaming as well. I've been back in wargaming for about 5 years now and I'm extremely excited for this conversation. With that in mind, I think we are ready to start. Uh so one thing I thought we could start out when we if we could take a look back for example where we are in the present and look back on human history we can think of innovations for example electricity uh the printing press even something maybe the internet that have really redefined the human experience. What if we take that same approach to wargaming, thinking about where we are right now and we look back to say as a starting point 1950s, 1960s Avalon Hill, we could go back 2000 years to chess and other games too, but let's go back to that point in time. Uh, what have been some of the defining innovations in wargaming when we look back on its history? And I'll let whoever wants to go jump in and start.

Well, I Yeah, I think the first one was hex's, right? that the first the first games were on grids and uh u I guess Charles Roberts saw some hex's maybe at the Rand Corporation or somewhere and switched from from grids to hex's and uh really freed up movement uh and made it less uh we didn't have to think about Pythagoras and the amount of uh uh movement points we were giving away if we didn't go on the diagonal once we changed to hex's. Right.

Yeah, you could probably even go back, if we're only going back to say uh mid 20th century, post World War II, the entertainment side of the industry, you could go back to rise vets and so on. And there were experiments with tiles, which was the grid, but then they also went off the grid on a map and they use gauges. Can think of the hex hexagonal grid as maybe freeing, but it's also very constraining at the same time. And I think when you're designing a Hex Encounter game, you definitely feel that that form imposes on your design. It's interesting though. Both of those together makes me think of as a you know a groundbreaking innovation for our hobby is you know the idea of a commercial um military simulation tabletop military simulation that is self-contained comes in a box ma you know mass-produced and that there's a market for that and so you know Jerry mentions Ricewitz we're talking there about the original Prussian Creek spiel which was a military training tool in the 19th century and it involved you know kind of kits of fancy blocks but it was professional it was very specialized in the in the Prussian army and it was facilitated as well it wasn't just okay I could you know buy this thing and play at home myself um we had toy soldiers of

course going back centuries we have Herbert George HG wells little wars so you know a A little over a hundred years ago, war games meant miniatures games and there were rules and clubs and enthusiasts. But again, that involves a lot of, you know, um, uh, interpretation and developing your own thing. You know, you have to assemble your own armies, for example, of painted miniatures or whatever you're going to have. That's obviously a thriving hobby, but, you know, related, but distinct from board war gaming that we're talking about here. But uh you know I guess Char Charles Roberts in the in the 50s says well you know professionals are doing this I can borrow from that you know you mentioned Grant you mentioned Rand Corporation um was doing that for you know for analysis national security analysis I can I can have a rule set you know printed paper pieces paper maps or hardmounted maps and like a uh a game like Monopoly which is simulating in in some way economics I can do that for military history and people will like that. You know, I can I can have a company that that sells that product commercially and you know, here we are 60 um 70 years later. Um and that and that's still going, right? So that seems to be something that didn't, you know, I mean, you can still, you can find military simulations that are hobby games before Avalon Hill, but to

actually create a, you know, a self- sustaining hobby and and market like that, I think that was the innovation that I would consider most groundbreaking for for the hobby specifically. And I guess I would build off of that too in thinking just with the technological advances in printing and publishing how we have so it's so much easier point of access for a designer now. You could self-publish a game you can do print and play. you know, talking to people back that were designing in the 1970s, they would say, "Well, I took my game to Avalon Hill and SBI and they rejected it, so I I couldn't do anything, you know, and so but now that it so that whole that the the exponential growth of board game and war game companies, too, is probably part of that, you know, that evolution of that process."

I was thinking for Oh, sorry. Go ahead, Grant. Yeah. Well, I was just going to say that I sort of think when we think of evolution of innovation in the hobby, it's we sort of think of those early uh Charles Roberts Avalon Hill games as a baseline. And so everything that takes us away from Hex Encounter, CRT terrain effects, anything that takes us away from that feels like a uh an im an innovation of some sort. Like I think of um well, somebody mentioned area impulse games. Courtney Allen's great idea that impulse system that breaks up the iggo yugo. Same thing with the the first chitpole games like that was a huge innovation because some of the the games had started to get so big that the I go yugo on the yugo part I could go away and have a pizza right and come back and so the things like area impulse and chit pull keeps us both at the table uh watching each other at the same time. I think those were huge innovations. Mhm.

[clears throat] You know what I had for my answer to go in a little bit of a different direction. I was going to throw this out there at us.

The evolution and of solo wargaming and just the I the the the wealth of innovation that's transformed the war game industry from being a game where people would play with somebody else to where you now are you so many systems and innovation has been built around the solo game. I remember back when I was playing first like if you had a solo game meant you didn't have friends right there was at least in my head there was a stigma attached to playing a game solo and that's gone now to the point where you know designers and companies almost are required in many cases or obligated to build a solo mode you were talking about race to revolve and the conversation with fallank about we don't want to put a solo mode in here it's a conversation about every game I think that to me seems like a a trending innovation that's really that shaped the hobby in many ways over the past 50 60 years too.

Yeah. And just to you know correct the record um less there be any spursions you know it was from failank we're not going to require you to design a solo yet you know we'll go ahead and play you know for two to four players that's okay. Um it's not that they I'm sure if I said oh well here's a solo version I'm sure they'd be delighted you know to include it for because of what you just said

right let's um let's shift forward in time a little bit let's take that same question but how about we apply it to the last five to 10 years more recent what have been some define and and again we have a lot of domains for this question too right so there is topical innovation you know if we think about the types of war games that are created in terms of what they cover historically thematic IC elements too. So we have even the evolution of war game learning and teaching and rule books. So feel free to take this any which way you want to. But to remind everybody watching as well too, there are lots of side quest side areas we could explore with this. But thinking back on the last 5 to 10 years, how might we we answer that question for that?

Well, I mean, you know, look at the two guys we have. Talk about the last

there is a reason they're here.

Yeah. I mean, Jerry's great innovation about trajectories in uh Pacific Ch, sorry, Atlantic Chase, uh, tackling the idea of hidden information or unknown information. That was huge. Nobody had done that before. And likewise, Vocalo's got a game coming out called Ghost Watchers that tackles a similar problem, but in a totally different way. Again, he's talking about he's looking at hidden information and he's got this mechanic that just has you looking away from the board for a minute while your opponent do does something. It's so incredibly simple, but it's going to it's going to break open this whole idea of of of what we can and can't know. And and and more importantly, like there's stuff that we couldn't know before, but we we knew the other guy didn't know.

like with Volko's way of doing it, you don't even know what you don't know, which is the way it should be.

Yeah. And I I could add to that. Um, since Mike, you're also opening things up uh to different areas, so to speak. I think Coast Watchers is the first time that I'm aware of that as a war gamer, we're really going to be thinking about the observation, the the the very critical gathering of information and then disseminating it, zooming down to those coast watchers. And I think that also is quite innovative. And I think there ha there is we are in a period where it feels to me like uh designers have license to explore topics that haven't been touched on. I mean I'm sure we're still going to get two dozen Gettysburg games uh next year, but and I wouldn't I'm not sorry that we'll have more Gettysburg games, but it is nice to have a Coastwatchers game all of a sudden.

Yeah. [snorts] Yeah. So I thank you um for for for that and I want to just draw a connection in terms of innovation between Atlantic Chase and Coast Watchers and a and a couple of I think huge innovations that go back before 10 years and going back to what you said Mike about iteration um that so there's um I hope I get his name right a British technology journalist his name's Matt Ridley I believe and he wrote about you know innovation. He writes and talks about the nature of innovation and one of his lines was that all actually all human progress all innovation is a matter of ideas having sex. That is to say there actually is not any innovation that is just not based on anything else not based on anybody else's ideas right it's all a matter of what ideas already there how can I take and put them together synthesize in new ways to new purposes maybe you know twist it this way a little bit you know you use the word tweak um and then sometimes that new fusion of ideas is indeed adds up to a fundamental new new new new thing or breakthrough right and so I love war game genealogy, right? Like you you know just tracking the development and evolution of the ideas along certain themes and the theme I think the simulation aspect um that connects the games we've just been talking about is how do we handle how do we model for

players uncertainty, right? The lack of information whether it's secrets or mysteries. And you always have if you're playing um if you're playing not salt or if you're playing against human opponents well there's always in their mind some intentions right what they understand what they're thinking what they might do and that's always secret from us right so that kind of is humans simulating the uncertainty of of military command but then we have mechanics that enhance that and give us more opportunities to simulate and therefore react to and take advantage of so I think about from my int intelligence career, denial and deception, you know, take advantage of the fact that there are unknowns and what are their nature? Um, and so some big innovations over the decades, standup blocks, right? So you there were there were absolutely early Avalon Hill games where you have faceown counters that are so you can't see what the enemy has. But the problem there, especially as the game grows, is you can't see your own stuff without a lot of annoying flipping. So, here's the innovation. You put it on a wooden block and you stand it up. Colia Games, of course, is is famous for this. And now I can see all my forces easily at a glance and all you see is plain backs of blocks.

But that that isn't is that really a recent innovation? I mean, I remember

1970 or something, right? Strateggo.

Yeah, sure. Exactly. It comes from Exactly. being right. Exactly. It borrows directly, does it not? From Strateggo, which goes even back. So, so I mentioned,

but if I may, if I may continue my interjection, sorry. No, go for it.

Because my wife likes to say, don't interrupt me when I'm interrupting you.

Fair enough. But if we go back to Rise again, because Strateggo is just giving us a rise without because sometimes with Creekspiel, they would do shorter games where they had a screen between the players that would they would lift up from time to time. So Strateggo is just having a permanent screen basically.

Yeah, exactly. It comes from somewhere, right? And it solves the problem in a way Strateggo again, no facilitator. It's all there in the box, right? just set rules and you can buy the box, never meet the designer and and learn to play and uh and so now exactly now let's take strateggo let's take that idea of handling secrecy right secrecy about which units are where the identity and strength of units and apply that to historical situations and you have Colombia block games and we're still I mean I still play regular comic book block games I love it it's great but It's it's an old old technology in the span of commercial board wargaming.

I think that was a fundamental step forward. Then cards, how board war games use playing cards. We can think of um upfront, which is like 1980. Now you've got well what you know it's not um it's not just the uncertainty of what will I what dice will my opponent roll when his squad attacks mine or something like that but you know what are what is the enemy holding in their hand what am I going to draw next so cards have a lot of uncertainty both mysteries and secrets very handily built in to the mechanics and then of course come forward what 14 years or so with with Mark Herman determines we the people and what that has spawned that is still going strong

building on again you know I don't know if consciously or unconsciously games like upfront that where cards and what hand of cards you're holding is integral to your strategy of gameplay and then putting that but then combining that with a point-to-point board game right there's a synthesis right a new fusion that was I think a breakthrough in fundamentals certainly influenced my design deeply. Um, and then we have new ways of using cards as well. Well, the the coast watchers that you mentioned, I'm just using Colombia blocks in a slightly different way, right? Where it's instead of them being forces that move around the map, it's just location information. And then as you as you pointed out, um, Grant saying, "Well, if we want to allow you to find something out about me without me knowing, secret reconnaissance, which has been a kind of a a problem of how to do that, okay, then you just look at my block location while I'm not looking."

I wanted to add what uh pile on to what Vocal was talking about, the evolution of blocks. I think the the next evolution that I thought was great was uh Brian Asv's game uh Napoleon's Fateful March, which is one-sided blocks except the units aren't on the blocks, the orders are. So, you're putting out blocks, your opponent doesn't know what's on the other side, and and those orders get uh revealed in a certain order. They don't just all get plunked over at once. So, uh, it's it's just a like, like you said, everything's building on the shoulders of everything else and changing the hidden information to orders from what from the where the generals are. I thought that's just brilliant. I love that.

Yeah. Very neat. And then they, you know, just made me think of another one, Grant, which is Christianit's PQ7 where you have um standup blocks. You also have um um ident, you know, formations behind a screen. So another kind of a secrecy thing where you have you know there's a this block or marker represents a task group and the identity that task group is behind a screen so you can't see

and then if you remember Colombia block games they also used the blocks for attrition. So you had four up to four strengths of a unit and whichever edge of the block is facing up that's the strength. So you could very handily have a four step to dead reduction system with this block. Well, um, Chris in PQ7 takes that and it instead represents not just that, but it can represent the recency of the information. So now you reveal a block, right? Let's say it's a a submarine or convoy or something and it starts out maybe at four and it counts down to one and then it stands up again. Something like that. Basically, the information is decaying.

Um, right. It it includes right in the block in a very handy way the idea of of that temporal idea of I got information but it's old information, right? That's different than I just spotted them recently. And then unless you're shadowing them. So now if you shadow them that it stays fresh anyway. Just another way. But again, it's just using the block in a very similar but not quite exactly the same way as the original Colombia.

Yeah. Yeah. And I I was thinking too just talking about you know I know Vocal we've had some conversations in other places about the uncertainty of warfare and I've been thinking about that a lot too and we think about you know the war game experience as it's been traditionally developed and what you sit down and the amount of knowledge you have as a war gamer when you sit down playing a game compared to what the actual commanders had. And I was thinking you know I've been playing a lot of Pats of Glory lately and I'm thinking almost perfect knowledge right we know where the armies are and what's going on. And I was just reading a world undone which is you a massive 700page book that over it's a broad picture of World War I. And at one point in that book, you know, they're talking about how German armies and Russian armies are marching around Prussia and Russia. They have no idea where the enemy is. You know, entire armies of hundreds of thousands of men that have no idea

where they're supposed to go, right?

Command and control is completely broken down. And how that's different. You know, we spent so much energy trying to simulate conflict and yet in some domains we completely miss. It's just not there or or it's a fraction of the reality,

right? Until we have the tools to do it and that's innovation. So returning to Atlantic Chase. So the so the the the key insight there to me is sometimes in some cases not only do you have no idea where your enemy is, you don't have a good grasp on where your own forces are either and how do we handle that in war games and so um so the the you know Jerry's trajectory system of course h handles that in a very very cool way and it's appropriate right to that setting where I presume these task force forces and convoys, they have to be radio silent, right, to not reveal their location. And so now we're kind of, you know, we're sort of estimating, well, they would have left there. They would be going here. We think they're here and there, but but both sides are trying to actually cope with a lack of concrete information about their own forces. And I just ran into another, you know, case like that that's land warfare, which is um uh the the the Tannenburgg, the East Prussian campaign in 1914. Tanberg in the Missuran lakes and there's reconnaissance is just absolutely huge.

Um you know and the few little airplanes flying around in 1914 were critical to that and Cavalary of course is critical of that and the the Russians just had a much less um um solid grasp of where the Germans were than the Germans had of the Russians which allowed the Germans to pull their you know their maneuver of of defeating two armies with just one army. Um, but not just that, the Russians had trouble knowing the state of their own forces. Like their communications were so poor in that case that they presumed a core would be holding some town. And in fact, it had been defeated the day before and was on the run and the army general just didn't know it. Right. So, I've been thinking about like how can we It's not just hidden information about the enemy, but but how do we and I I don't know. It's I don't I don't know if I know Jerry you started with land warfare for your trajectory system and you know presumably silver similar problems in the um the American civil war and you you know you've gone naval but how do we you know could we apply that somehow to time I don't know I haven't figured it out but that's like maybe future innovation you know is to is to better represent uncertainty even about our own forces

yeah no I find it interesting that you know the game design process process is all about trying to uh put focus on uh one or two or maybe more but that's that gets dangerous uh features that you're trying to simulate because you know it's an abstraction there on your table. Uh so to be practical to be able to play this thing you have to abstract so much but you want to reveal you want to and also give some agency to the player in certain ways. And I know some players uh sometimes feel miffed if they have more control over their forces than what their historic what they perceive their historical counterpart to have been which I don't often feel myself because I like that it can be very satisfying to have that omnisient view even though I know it's so artificial. It never ex it didn't exist historically for any you know living being. But yet it is to be able to see like you were saying you know you flip over with coast watchers you know you don't have to flip anything. It's you can see all your forces all at once and of course that's so artificial but yet it is necessary to play that game. So really half the time I think game design is about interfering with the player's omniscience

in certain careful ways while while still giving them full control.

And I I just and you're right about Atlantic Chase and where it came from. I I was doing a lot of reading

about land warfare during the American Civil War and there are so many episodes where the commanding general is giving orders to troops that aren't where he thinks they are. and he is expecting to hear the guns, you know, on the left flank start to fire away and he's getting nothing because his courier is scrambling to try to figure out where is the ninth core and it could be 30,000 men and horses and wagons that have gone missing.

So, how do you do how do you put the player in a situation where you're going to where you lose track of your ninth core?

Yeah,

we have spent a good bit of time talking about this topic and it's a fascinating one for sure, but let's take a step back just to kind of to talk for a moment. First of all, thank you very much for everybody that's putting comments in here. I'm kind of peppering them up as we're talking about a lot of interesting comments going on in the feed too. I'd like to change directions just a little bit uh and still entertain, you know, staying on our topic of course of innovation here too. Um there was a question earlier on uh when we think about innovation in wargaming what's one or two games that pop to your mind and you know we've talked about Atlantic Chase so maybe thinking ones we haven't talked about so far

well well Courtney Allen is my favorite unsung designer and he gave us upfront and storm over arnum which were both giant innovations in their time standing on the shoulders but still uh he just took like he went four shoulders forward in in both cases. So, those are two of my all-time favorite games that jump things forward.

Um, yeah, I c I could say um Empire of the Sun. I know that's kind of cheating because we already talked about CDGs, but that one is innovative because we have hexagons. Okay.

So, for instance, I ri my first CDG that I encountered uh was passive glory and then it was wilderness war. Uh and both of those are amazing. But, um Empire and when I was and I was just starting to get into game design myself um and I was so fascinated by CDGs, but I thought, "Oh, this would never work with Hex Encounter. There's just no way like you can make that work." And you know, Mark Herman, you know, it's not surprising it's Mark Herman who came up with the CDG to begin with. He then took it the next step.

And just big hat tip on that one because that is one of my all-time faves.

Yeah. Uh, I mean, I guess I I will answer from, you know, influence on me. And if you, you know, if you know any of my games, all of them use playing cards in a big way, you know, integrated with a board game. That's almost like all I do. And so, I have to go back to to We the People and and Mark Herman in that regard. you know, Mark Simonich and Ted Racer and what they did with that initial um breakthrough from Mark uh as well um you know and and and there there are many others. I think it's um in a way with with hex's but in a very different way perfected by um Chad Jensen um in Combat Commander. Uh, you know, the cards are so powerful as a as a design tool and it I just have to go back to I I didn't um play we the people first. I played uh Hannibal Rome versus Carthage um first from Mark Simonich classic CDG.

And I I think back to how I approached that game purchase back then in the 1990s. And it was, you know, I was a I was a dad and I'm like, "Okay, this can't be a very serious game. It doesn't have hex's, you know, it's playing cards or whatever, but it'll be should be fun to play with my boys, you know, whatever." And and I got it and I started playing. I'm like, "Wow, this is a really great simulation of the Second Punic War, you know." And it was almost like from then on it was like if I'm playing a game that doesn't use a lot of playing cards in it. It's almost like watching black and white TV again or something. I don't know. It's just missing something.

I'm going to throw a few out there for [clears throat] enemy action or densreing in terms of trying to create algorithmic systems for solitire play. I would also throw out Kenzer Blitz. [clears throat] [snorts] I've been reading about how absolutely groundbreaking that was. First game with geomorphic maps. First game really to dig into more tactical elements that it wasn't just a set battle. Here was a system. It invited people in to create their own scenarios. Foundation of advanced squad leader. I feel like there is so many leaps forward when I think of wow how panzer blades defined almost an entire trajectory of wargaming [clears throat] that wasn't there before it happened. Um and I would also throw out the coin. I would also throw out the coin series too because as we were talking before and you know a domain I feel like oftentimes war games were cleancut events we looked at traditional battles and really the coin counterinsurgency takes events that where it's not just the battles that are happening there's a lot of other factors that are sliding into the conflict and so I would throw those out there as ones that strike me as been particularly innovative

you know can I just bounce off of panzer bits blitz quickly because that was one of the first war games I played it was our second one

and I will tell you I think if it wasn't for Panzer Blitz I might not be a a board war gamer today

um and the way that and the way that it did it's this is it's I saw it at a friend's house didn't really understand what it was my friend had got it you know we were you know grade elementary school right you know and but the way those boards fit together the geomorphic boards and you could make these different combinations and it would always fit together just was like it's like it seemed so fun, you know, and this is the thing.

It was a sandbox, right? I mean, they g it was a sandbox and we were invited to create and games hadn't done that before.

Yeah. It in other word and if you think about it like a toy like as a kid would think about it, right? That is just so appealing. It just invites you in and fascinated me and got me curious about what were these things, you know, that I was seeing in in the boxes in the stores. And so a lot of times, you know, the innovations, it might not just be what's a better way to simulate something or what's a better, you know, loss curve on our CRT or something substantive like that. It might just be what makes this a more immersive experience, what makes it more fun, what makes it more attractive, you know, how can we do art in a way that transports us more into the game or functionally makes it, you know, easier or more appealing to to learn the rules. Those kinds of things are also just a such a key because it's really a very visual medium, you know, that we've got. And it's also um tactile in the sense of like how pieces fit together and things like that, you know, and so yeah, geomorphic map boards, I mean, hooked me.

I wanted to mention um Angola as well because I know it had a big uh a big impact on Vulco and the Lebian campaign series. And what's cool about that game and Brian Train has a game that addresses the same problem. Brian Train's uh uh shel campaign, he he addresses it a different way, but both of them what they do is they they make it so that the orders that you're trying to uh give your units, you can't react instantly in both both the systems of Angola and and Vocals Levian campaign games or Brian's game. You you decide what you're going to do. then your opponent is going to do some stuff and then you're going to you're going to have to do what you said you were going to do. You can't instantly go, "Oh, I see what you did. I'm going to do this now." And I think that was a big uh a big innovation that I I foresaw Angola and now it's kind of exploded with Vocals Levy and campaign games.

Yeah, I think that's a good connection. Um, and that reminds me of DSIG. Actually, if to go back to tactical, um, both his Civil War brigade series and then his tactical combat system, which was originally just World War II. Um, he has you writing orders on pieces of paper, often very graphically, especially with the TCS, which appealed to me greatly. Um, I think that was for me personally was incredibly um innovative. But I also know now that I've learned more about game history that that is also very rise vitzian, you know. Uh, and even panzer blitz with the geomorphic I think is very much the sandboxiness is reminiscent of u miniatures where basically you just have a table and you just say okay this coffee cup is going to be I don't know is going to be a stand of really dense trees or whatever.

I mean that's how simple that could be. And I think that by the time of um squad leader and so on and panzer I think they were channeling that. Yeah, I think you know for me with Angola this is the issue of um how do we get across the feature that no plan um survives contact with the enemy the importance of friction from Kovitz [clears throat] you know uh that we have our intentions but you know there's the complexity of everything the dynamism out there is going to is going to tend to defeat that and we need to to adapt as best we can And a absolutely the the the gamers the written orders then there's a delay then you have to try to carry out those orders as best you can when they reach the command. It's rise vitzian because it's real lifeian right I mean this is it's very closely modeled on communications that take time that are not instant you know and uh that that that are then limited by what words you write down but then for me it's sort of like well do I want to do writing and all this you know it seems like a burden and so the magic of Angola's column cards was it's so quick and simple I'm just stacking these little cards And then when it's my turn, I flip the top card. There's no debate or discussion. Whatever column I flipped over, A, B, C, or D, I I move them or do nothing. That's it. You know, it's it's

it's quick. It's easy. No writing involved. And and yet very cleverly with, you know, there's a little bit of abstraction in that because when that column is activated, you can do, you know, whatever you want with it, right? But it gets across that that tempor that delay of orders and the fact that in a dynamic uh battlefield situation your original plan probably is not going to look so great after your enemy has intervened.

I think the first place I ran that into and I think we talked about this is in the Levian campaign series, right? When when you're you stack your orders up and you have this plan to do stuff and then you pull the card and you realize, well, I don't want to do that thing anymore. Erectly stolen from Ragnar Brothers Angola,

right? Exactly. I know we've talked about that before.

Not simply an application of an earlier one. Yeah.

Now it occurs to me, you know, the old game Robo Rally

to venture away from wargaming, but Robo Rally, you had to stack up your your moves, your little robot trying to get out of the labyrinth or whatever. I don't know if you ever played that,

but anyway.

But same same concept, right? Yeah.

Yeah. Yeah. Just which I I I don't know who knows which came first or and of course innovations can come in independently in different places.

Um let's change gears a little bit. Uh there's one topic that is particular a little bit of a selfish topic. Okay. I'm particularly interested in this one too. Uh but I I would like to talk for a moment about innovation as it applies to the teaching and learning of war games

with rule books. Um, how are we doing? Um, what are some that might be a loaded question maybe? Okay, question.

I I have some thought, but anyway, yeah.

What are some innovations in the learning experience that you've seen and liked and and why?

And also, what's potential ground fruitful ground we could go forward into?

I'll just go quickly because I think these two guys are are are the are the perfect guys to have. Um, I think there's always this tension between rule books that are that teach you how to play the game and rule books that are a great reference uh for when you're playing the game. Uh, I like the latter, but the perfect rule book does both. And I I think uh Jerry in Atlantic Chase, he hearkened back to the old Avalon Hill programmed instruction method, but he did it in this new way where everything was just a single beautiful page or or or two pages. there were you weren't getting lost. he did this beautiful thing and the and also this thing with the uh page numbers like if you're looking for something there's these big round circles with the page number takes you exactly where you need to go and I think Jerry was really trying to solve that problem and I think I know that Vulkar was so uh inspired by Jerry's rule book that when we finally see Coast Watchers I think the Coastwatches rule book is going to be uh an homage to the uh Atlantic the chase rule book because you know I think you're right

which is you know homage is a very polite word for theft. Well, I and I find this ironic because I was telling Vulco, I think it was in San Diego very briefly that, you know, when I I look to if I could write a sentence as succinctly and razor focused like Vocalo, I wouldn't have I would not have had to write and create that rulebook the way I did. So, I just find this terribly ironic. Yeah, it's um I think this is a is a is a I I think it's a it's a tough area for board war games in part because of what the traditions are, you know, where the hobby came from some path dependency there and we've we are innovating. I think we're all, you know, all all of us here are conscious of this challenge and are trying and coming up with with hopefully with new things and trying things out and experimenting. I think there has been some very beneficial borrowing from other parts of board gaming to try to um see how do we do rulebooks, how do we do tutorials? Um it you know the um objective of a rulebook to serve both as a reference and as a um accessible learning experience I mean I would say hadn't even occurred to me until recently because that's become the standard. You know fashion has changed and with a broadening of the hobby I

think our standards are getting higher. You know the expectations are higher. This is a good thing. Um uh and and it's I find it's very challenging to do. I mean tutorials are really hard I find to write well um and um you know examples are already hard and tutorials where there's a flow through the game even harder and they're extremely fraught because if you make an error you know in there you've not only um thrown sand in the gears of learning the game you've actually removed the entire purpose of the tutorial which is to help you learn because you've hurt the learning and you may as well you know it would have been better just not to have it at all. So the the quality standard there needs to be very high um high as well. And um yeah, I gosh, I I hope um board games are getting board war games are getting better along with the rest of the the industry do in doing that and and yeah, I'm actually very curious to see because I've so I had like 20 25 years ago, I got a lot of positive feedback on my rules writing.

Lately, I have not been getting the feedback like I've not gotten the feedback on the rule books in the Levian campaign series that I would have liked. To me, I'm like just doing the same thing. You know, maybe I'm 20 years out of date, but the standards have changed. The fashion has changed, but you know, in a way that, you know, is is now pressing us as writers to be more inviting and more helpful um you know, in in our product. And I I think that's a tremendous thing and I'm trying to catch up. So, I'm curious to see. So, I've Yes. I've I've copied as best I can, you know, Jerry's style and Coastwatchers and and I'm very curious to see, you know, how that goes.

You know, that's really

Go ahead.

Go ahead.

I just want to

I was just going to follow up what he's saying because we we mentioned uh Atlantic Chase. You know, one of the reasons why it was formatted in that way with the you know, asking a question and then answering it was because I was spending so much time on BGG. So what the I think this is maybe goes to the topic of innovation what forces the designer to um really out of self-defense in some ways self-defense of your time after a game gets published um then BGG starts lighting up you know if you're lucky if you're lucky that the people are playing the game they're going to start asking questions and you could write a rule that you think is perfectly clear how could you misunderstand this but of course people are coming at it from different. You know, I know I I've spent quite a bit of time professionally as a teacher, so I know that what can seem simple to somebody and obvious to somebody is not so to somebody else. And it is not helpful to be difficult as a teacher and as a designer, you're a teacher and simply say, go back to the text and read it again, you know. So I you just get used to the question and then an answer.

And then on BG, I try to never answer the question the way that it's formatted in the rules because I figure they've already looked at that and it didn't work. So that prompts me to come at their question in a different way. And I thought with Atlantic Chase said, let's just try this as an experiment. I'm going to put basically a rule kind of in a couple different ways so that the question presents it in one way and then the answer in some ways repeats what the question is doing. But I mean you it winds up getting fatter which isn't so great. Uh but hopefully becomes more complete for more people.

Yeah. I it's it's so interesting that because I had this conversation with a a gaming buddy just the other day and sometimes you know the the idea is well we should be consistent like consistency is a virtue and so if we're going to spell out something and there's a reason in the rules or the charts to spell it out using the same words put together in the same way in two different places just do it the same because otherwise it'll be confusing and I've actually gone in in that direction Jerry that just you just mentioned I've said well I know if I say things in a certain way that it's only going to make sense to some portion of the readers. So, let me if I've got anyway a need to spell out the same relationship in two different places of the rule book because they refer to two different things, you know, they tie two things together, I'll just try and say it in a little bit different way the other time just because then maybe I capture for clarity a larger portion of readers

and now every reader can compare those two things and have through that synthesis maybe an even better chance of of of understanding my meaning. So, you know, I hope that works

and doesn't just

go ahead, Mike.

I'd like to throw out just a couple of things. I think we've touched on a couple of things that there's been some comments, too. One that I thought was uh pretty funny here. I think if I can find it here, too, which the greatest innovation someone's the greatest innovation would here it is would be a rat and a rat free rule book. But a couple people mentioning here uh Brooklyn Wargaming and TK mentioning using AI assisted rule search which I think brings us to innovation in postp production learning you know innovation on the players part where we're now things like notebook LM to look up rules I know Jerry you had mentioned it in some of the notes as we were preparing for this session but even the advent of board gamegeeek where you have a rules forum and there's almost a common community where you can to a certain degree with a lot of games expect a designer to be present you know I remember back in the days, the pre-in days when if you had a real question, it's just like, well, I don't know what to do. And, you know, you'd have to send a self-addressed stomped envelope to the publisher and hope for an answer. I mean, you know, the way we post the way we consume and learn afterwards is good.

And the only other thing I'd say that I think, you know, as someone who's had a background in education, I really like to see the delineation between the learning pathway as someone who's making their way through to getting fluent at the game and then the reference documentation, which is I know how to play, but I forgot this thing.

And I think when when we start to, you know, we we're seeing that we're seeing more, I think, games that really say, okay, how am I going to help someone and make it fun, right? So you're learning and playing at the same time, introducing rules gradually because I think that learning process, you know, we call it the learning papa is a big part of wargaming. And I think wargamings traditionally have taken almost a mechanical like a a user manual type experience, which is let's get all the rules nice and clear so you can look them up. And I think those things are fundamentally different experiences. I wanted to mention one innovation that's happened that uh that nobody only one company's doing it uh and everybody could be doing. We all we all have uh PDF rules. Now the ASL electronic rule book is completely hyperl.

So when you're reading a rule, you can click on a a term or or a a reference to another rule. You just you're not flipping pages. you're just like clicking and it takes you can find everything. You know, I know a lot of people are afraid of that rule book because it's so huge and it's written in the old case style which you know has its ups and downs. But the I think more more companies should invest in this idea of actually hyperlinking their PDFs and it it would make their books much more friendly.

Interesting.

Yeah, that's a great point. Yeah, I just wonder

Oh, sorry. Go ahead, Jerry. Yeah,

I I would just, you know, talking about and thinking about AI, I'm just wondering as a rules writer, you know, there's a voice inside my head that is just wants to lean into AI, not to write the rules. I wouldn't I mean, I have no desire to use AI to write the rules, but I could I could take a completely different tack where I don't have to worry maybe I don't have to worry about teaching. I can let the player AI do that. So, I could imagine condensing the rules to the bare minimum because I know that the player is going to be, you know, using their notebook LM or whatever it's called to, you know, call things up and figure out the game that way. And I'm just wondering if, you know, I I think I'm exaggerating here about that, but um I'm wondering what impact it's going to have on rules writers and how we learn games.

And and we are not to cut this conversation off, but we've got about seven minutes left. We're supposed to finish up a couple minutes early, I think, too. And I want to point us towards the future for the last seven minutes. Um, thinking about where we are right now, and I'll take it a couple of each ways. Maybe we can go around in turn. You know, what's something maybe perhaps annoying that we think we can fix with innovation in the future? or what's a big thing where where isn't a ripe area of wargaming innovation as you think about where we are right now going forward and some of we may have touched on some things already but I'll let you take either one of those ideas and run with it and maybe we can hear from each of us as we as we wrap up here

um I I'll I can go first and kind of bouncing off this issue of role for AI and um free rule books and and the like. Um, and uh, and this is a a prospect that a friend of mine raised. It's not my own idea, but you know, we love these physical games for certain reasons. There's just something that a um a physical game that you yourself understand the rules and operate the system that it delivers you that let's say a computer game where there's a lot of code happening behind the scenes you know it that computers do certain things really well but you what it can't deliver I think is the fact that you really do know exactly why what just happened happened because you are operating the system yourself so you know any fears that we had that computer games were going to completely replace board games. Clearly that's not happening and I don't think it will happen for that reason. Um but we now have a lot of um fusion and hybrid of these two media right. So we have you know vassel to play you know um uh board games remotely you know we have some ports to to um to electronic games. We have tabletop simulator and so forth.

And there is an absolutely um um wonderful one called Rally the Troops which is um was created by a single very dedicated enthusiast and now is building a core of people and they are implementations of of board games es especially historical board games and war games that is rule enforced you know and free you know o open code and I've had the um the privilege of working with um that creator Tor Anderson on some of my games that are hosted here on Rally the Troops. It is a fantastic way first of all to learn a game because you cannot play it wrong. You know that it tells you what the options are. But here's the uh here's some more magic um that I think might be an area where we could improve the the quality of game design, development, and rule books itself. to go through the experience of having Rally the Troops implement your game, you discover so many gaps in your rules because the implementation in in in steady hands of of of of tohort has to cover everything, right? They turn up questions like, well, what if the player does this in this situation?

What is the rule? And we went through that for Wilderness War, which been out on the market and being played and successful for 20 years, more than that, right? It's a 2001 game and and the process of converting it to rally the troops I was like I don't know I don't think the rules cover that you know it's in in effect right so the idea is what if we got fast enough in creating these kinds of rule enforced systems because it's a lot of work of course to do that now but maybe with AI or as we build our cadre of people who create those kinds of um rules and forced modules what if we had that during development, right? What if I had rally the troops race to rebal now, you know, the the the quality control on the on the on the rule set, you know, would be almost absolute. I could discover all those gaps or things that could that could happen that I didn't anticipate before the thing is printed.

That's amazing.

Yeah. So, it's just something to think about if it becomes practical, you know, computationally. And we've got about four minutes left, so make sure both Grant and Jerry have a chance to to voice in on this one. Yes. Thank you.

Go ahead, Grant.

Uh well, uh uh we've already talked a lot about rule books. I think that's a place where we could use a lot of innovation. Uh that, uh combined with user interface, I think, uh some designers are great about thinking about the user experience and some put all their energy and their innovation into making their game and they forget about the players. the I really appreciate um uh designers who who really focus on the user uh interface. So, one thing I'd like to see more innovation on is is is more clever ways to keep markers off the off the map board where we just have the more counters, less m less markers would be my thing. I'd also like to say, hey, I see uh uh Ricardo Msini out there. I I just read your book this year. I loved it. I'm glad to see you watching this chat. I'm glad you said that, Grant, because that was going to be mine. I feel like we make these beautiful maps and beautiful counters and then we drop these ugly counters on top of you can't see anything anymore.

And so that whole change of state of a of a unit and change of state whether you know all those kinds of things. But Jerry, go ahead.

No, I I I really don't have any uh anything else to add. I think um that except to think more about AI and I I don't know maybe we can get to a state even beyond Rally the Troops where we just have the AI like a program script that can run through the games and find problems.

Yeah.

Um I mean that would really extend the monkeykey's reach there, you know, because that is especially with wargaming. I mean, trying to play test case blue, you know, there's no way they play tested that enough. It would have been humanly impossible. And that's true of most war games. The complexity and the length, it's just impossible. So,

yeah,

been a new possibility that would be marvelous.

Well, we are uh at the end of our time here. We've touched on a lot of things, a lot of ground we didn't cover. One of the questions I had, for example, was comparing wargaming with Euro gaming or traditional board games and a criticism I hear where war games aren't innovative. So, I think we could go on for another hour. So, I apologize if there were topics of interest for people that are out there watching that we didn't get to, but hopefully today's discussion was interesting for everybody. Any last words uh Grant Vocal or Jerry to our audience, people watching uh as we as we wrap up?

Uh the answer is yes. War games are innovative.

Yeah, the the answer is also uh adding adding Euro mechanics to new war games doesn't mean we take away that we quit making hex encounter uh CRT games. Like adding new things doesn't mean we take away the old things. We there's plenty of room to do everything.

Yeah. And even some of the new things are really quite old.

Yeah. There's nothing new under the sun. Ecclesiastes, right? Thank you very much everybody. This will be live on both the uh this will be kept on both the SD Histcon channel and Zilabitz channel for future viewing so you can get back to this anytime. I'd like to thank Vulco Grant and Jerry for their time and their energy and their their focus and their to make this a good session. So I really appreciate you gentlemen taking the time to be part of this today. Thank you everybody for watching and have a great rest of the conference.

Thanks a lot. Thanks all.

Progress saved