Top 10 Thematic Games - JonGetsGames
Transcript
welcome to junkets games today I'll be bringing you my top 10 thematic games list as of February 2019 and I would like to mention that this is the first bonus video that was not only specifically requested by but also voted on by the contributing producer level supporters over at patreon.com slash young its games now when it came to building out this top 10 list I had a bit of a challenge I had to really decide what my criteria would be because the idea of theme in games can be taken in a few different ways obviously I could have made this list for just my top 10 favorite games that are also thematic but when I decided to do here was I tried to make a top 10 list of games based off of just how well I think that theme is integrated into the overall mechanics and just how well that theme really pops off of the table and pulls you into the emotions of the game and all that so there are games on this list that I've actually gotten rid of because I personally am not that interested in playing them anymore but I can still accredit them for being incredibly thematic so without further ado I think let's jump into it so let's start things off with game number 10 and that one is not alone now the theming for this game is you have a planet that is just teeming with life and you have a spaceship that is crash-landed with a bunch of humans on it now most of the people around the table will be these humans and they are cooperating together to try and survive long enough for the rescue ship to come and pick them up now one player around the table is actually playing as this monster creature who is essentially the embodiment of the assimilating life of this planet and their one goal is to fully assimilate the humans into the overall ecosystem of the planet before that rescue ship
arrives so effectively the humans are not trying to not die they're just trying to stay as humans so that they can jump on that rescue ship and leave now the theming really comes through in a variety of ways here because the humans are all trying to cooperate together they all win and lose together and they all have to simultaneously decide what regions they're going to go to every single turn now the thing is they can talk as much as they want to but the creature player might hear them and after they've all decided that the creature player decides one region to go to and if they go to a spot with humans on it then the assimilation track will go forward as the creature is able to assimilate them a little bit more and maybe drive them crazy or make them feel like the less human or something like that now the creature player can definitely get a lot of benefit for doing this because the players when the creature goes to that spot will actually get to activate that location so you can find yourself in tricky situations if lots of players go to one spot and then the creature also goes there then that's really going to hamper the overall survival instincts and effects that the humans will have available to themselves now as far as the theming coming through with the mechanics you have a couple other things you have action cards which the human players can play and they feel very thematic to overall what they do it's not purely just like oh I do this and the creature can't go here it's like oh I do this and it says that there's like a force field now in this area you know and we barrier to off this spot so the creature can't go over to that spot so we can go over there or do stuff we want now the creature player also gets to play action cards that are also very thematic they might involve things like you know screeches in the night or you know SuperSpeed or that kind of thing and they would give them mechanical
advantages that also really match up to the theming of what they are doing and the human players as you're playing it you really feel like this stress of like is the case you're gonna find me in the spot like you're trying to sneak around and do various things and do smart things but like is the creature gonna think that you're gonna do that so maybe you'll do something else but maybe the creature will also think about your doublethink and I've also found when I'm playing as the creature player it can be surprisingly frustrating like you're trying to track down all these pesky humans you're trying to assimilate them into the overall ecosystem to make your planet better and you keep thinking they're gonna go to a spot and you go there and nobody went there it's amazing to me sometimes as the creature player that there might be six humans and you somehow managed to go to the one spot that none of them dead even though you really felt like you had a good reason for that and I think that the emotions that come through with like frustration and also excitement has a creature player when you do a really big hit really pulls you into that theming as well as the dread and fear that can come into play as the overall humans so I think that a not alone is a great overall thematic game and that's why it's number 10 on the list let's now move on to game number 9 and this one is legacy the testament of Duke Duke RACI now the theming of this game is you are in France a couple hundred years ago and you are in the aristocracy and you start off as either the husband or the wife in a married couple now right from the beginning of the game you are going to do things like trying to court various accolades for your family but also you're going to try to have as many kids as possible so these children will go down and below you essentially you have these two cards
in the front you have children underneath and you try to have a bunch of kids but the theming of this game when you have kids is kind of interesting because there is this baby sack and you just draw a random card from the top of that stack and it will tell you if you had a boy or a girl occasionally there will be something special in there like twins or something like that so you never really know exactly what you're going to get and unfortunately there are occasionally some awful things that happen in that deck which can actually cause the baby to not survive or to actually have the mother not survive and this is very thematic but also awful and it makes sense for the time period where you know infant mortality was high but also the mortality rate of mothers giving birth was far higher than it is in these days in especially Western countries so you have that going on you have that pressure and that stress as you are having these children but you also need to have as many children as you possibly can because at a certain point time will pass and then your children will grow up and now you have this handful of friends and you will try to marry your friends off to your children and then have them have children so you're starting to build out this pyramid and then time will pass and then those children will grow up and then you will try to marry those people off to your new friends and so you're just building this massive pyramid which is effectively your legacy as a family and it really pulls you into the overall theming of trying to cultivate this family here now this is definitely a euro style game a lot of these friends that you're putting down do various weight things to get you points and points is effectively you know how prestigious you are as a family some of them might give you extra points
based off of the nationalities of other family members that you have some of them might actually lose you points if there are two different specific nationalities like you know one person really hates people from this other nationality so you might lose points in that case so there is a variety of different things going on and these actual people that you are marrying off will do various things as well like you know some of the women can actually when they give birth they can do that better than others some of the men come with more money and some of them come with less there definitely is some somatic trappings that are not great that you can see here but mostly because it is trying to really match the time period like the women are definitely kind selected for having children and the men are selected for having prestige and trying to have lots of money and I'm you know that is a somewhat authentic thing to the time period and I think that mechanically the game does a good job of really replicating that out onto the the table as you're playing it like you can kind of feel a little awful as you are trying to pick and choose who is going to be a suitor based off of these these decisions that really we like to think that we don't have to deal with these days like you know people get married because they're in love these days but but back then it's really all about pairing things off so that it's best for your overall family and you know as far as the theming integration of the mechanics I do think it does a very good job of pulling you into that next up we have game number 8 and this one is mysterium now there are a couple different versions of mysterium that have come out and one of the bigger ones came out from Asmoday and that is not the one I'm talking about specifically the mysterium that I've played was published by portal games before the Asthma day version and there are some
mechanical differences but Ematic aliy what you're doing in all of these instances is you are either going to be a paranormal investigator in this old house or you're going to be a ghost that is trapped inside this house trying to free its soul from the house by showing people how its murder happened 100 years ago or something like that so mechanically what happens is you have this ghost player who is trying to give people different dreams these paranormal investigators they effectively go to sleep each night and then the ghost player will hand them these cards and then the paranormal investigators look at these cards when they wake up in the morning and they effectively thematically I'll talk about these crazy dreams that they had and they try to figure out how they're what happened in their dreams will actually apply to solving this ancient mystery murder mystery that is happening inside this house now the cards that you are being deltad that are these dream cards are very surreal there's like some pretty wacko crazy beautiful stuff going on on these cards and the ghost player can give you one or two or even more of these cards and what happens here is you if you get one card then you just try to find the important things on that card but maybe you will get two cards and now you're gonna try to find some correlations between the two cards so that you can see how they match up because there are effectively three things that happen for the murder it happened in a specific place it happened well specific person to murdered them and the last thing is there was murder weapon and so you were going through these in phases as you're playing the game and honestly depending on what version of mysterium play you will go through these in a different phase order but either way you are
either trying to find one of these three types of things and you know specifically which type it is and there are a variety of options in the middle of the table and you then just discuss with the other paranormal investigators which one you think they did now as an investigator it's very thematic because you just these cards are so dreamy and crazy and it's it's definitely fun to try and figure out the logic behind the madness that are these cards that you are getting but then as the ghost player you really have this feeling like you are like trapped in the walls and you're not allowed to say anything all you can do is give these strange dreams and then just sit there and watch as these investigators just do not get what you are trying to tell him I can imagine if I was a ghost trapped in a house for 100 years it would be a very frustrating experience overall and that is the overall emotions that you get for much of the game as you are playing now there are obviously moments of elation when people figure out what you were trying to tell them but I feel like those are few and far between the frustrating moments is people say okay we think it's this one right here now I guess the theming that's going on here where you say like I think it's this thing over here is maybe the the ghost knocks down a chair or thumps on the wall so that you know if it's right or wrong or maybe it's just that they make that guess and the next night you get these dreams and you know part of the dreams is like letting you know if you're right or wrong now the ghost player does just straight-up tell the players like that is correct that is incorrect but not everything can be completely thematically integrated I suppose overall so yeah I think mysterium does a great job of pulling in together collaboration amongst the paranormal investigators as they discuss
all these crazy dreams at the end of the day they can ask for everyone's opinions but it is their decision alone as to which one they think the dream wasn't really going towards and I think that it just works really well you just you feel like your paranormal investigator or you feel like you're a ghost and I think that mysterium is a highly thematic game because of that let's now move on to game number seven and this one is kitchen rush now this one came out a couple of years ago and the overall theming here is you are a your chef essentially in a kitchen everyone is it's a fully cooperative game and you are trying to cook as many correct meals as you can within a time limit so out in the middle of the table you have this board which is this kitchen and everything that you do involves moving essentially an action pawn around but I say action planning quotes because realistically it is a sand timer so what you do is if you want to start cooking something you take your same time or you flip it over and you put it on to the oven spot if there is an oven spot available and then you can't do anything until that sand timer goes all the way down now you might be discussing things with other players like what you're gonna do after you cook that thing because after you cook it has to go over here to get prepared in various different ways but you have this time crunch and that time crunch really pulls out the overall theme of being a super stressful kitchen trying to fulfill as many orders for customers as you can now it's not just like going to the oven or going to the refrigerator like you actually have to send somebody to the store and they have to buy various ingredients and all of this stuff is happening real time and you have other things going on like trying to get specific spices out of a bag and it has a dexterity element to it where
you were like trying to reach into this bag and pull out the correct spices and sometimes it takes a while and I think that somatically pulls in the idea of you're just trying to find your spice jars amongst the crazy clutter of this overall kitchen and it's just a loud experience it's a quick experience I can't remember how many minutes it is it's several minutes that you have to try and get as many of these dishes out and within a given timeframe and then you do this several times throughout the overall play and then you see if you were able to do well enough or not now another thematic thing that comes into this game is you get money for the dishes that you are able to make but you have to pay your employees and your employees their salaries are pretty high so you have this profit margin that you're trying to also eyeball and you might find yourself like at the end of a round feeling like you did really well and then you realize that once you pay out all of your costs you actually did not make that much money and I think that's certainly one of the reasons why it's such a challenge to run an actual restaurant I think most restaurants are nowhere near as frenetic as the kitchen is here in kitchen Russia it feels more like a TV show that you might see where like you know it's a competition TV show where everyone's running around and there's a big clock winding down on the wall except here it is fully cooperative as you were just discussing things and trying to make the best use out of your sand timers and you cannot move them until the sand goes all the way out so you might screw something up go to another and do that there and then really hamstring somebody else's planned because there are no more ovens left available and they have to wait until your sand timer goes away and suddenly this like whole supply chain gets halted and you know that's where the inefficiencies can really show through and I think as far as a theme and a
thematic experience is concerned this one really pulls you into that hectic kitchen next up we have game number six and this one is chronicles of crime now the theming of this game is going to vary a lot because realistically chronicles of crime is more of a game system than a specific game now what this game uses is a board as well as lots of cards but you also have to use a smart device of some form like a tablet or a smartphone because what you are doing in this game is you're trying to solve various mysteries now what you do is it's a fully cooperative game and everybody around the table is going to start off with a specific mystery and you actually load those up on your smart device and as you go through them you can do various different ones like the base set has a couple different options one of them is just kind of a straight-up murder mystery another one is all about something being stolen from a museum and you know as you play through all of these different things the theming really comes through from the mechanics because what you do in this game is you go to various locations and you talk to people and you look around now in some locations you literally look around you get out your smart device and you look around you might some of the boxes come with a VR type of oculus type thing so you can see in 3d or you just look around in a 2d image and you talk about what you see you know there may be a dead body over there there's a cake over there you might look in the ceiling there's various paintings and there's like a journal you see a backpack and as you see these things you vocalize them and everyone around else around the table is gonna be sifting through this stack of cards pulling out various things like oh he said cake that means there is you
know food oh we said books okay here's saying books and drawings or that kind of thing and every single card in this game has a QR code which is that kind of square code with a bunch of little black and white dots in it and then what you do is you scan these things to see what the relevance of those things are for the very scene and then you could use it those clues to talk to anybody about really anything every person that you talked to in this game is also a card with a cue our code so you actually scan that person with your smart device and then you might scan a clue over here and that specific person will tell you what they know about that specific clue and there are tons of clues in this game I don't know if it's over 100 there's definitely like tens and tens of them like well over 50 different clues that you can play as and as you were playing through these scenarios you will start to build out this web of like this person knew this thing about that thing and we should go over there and ask that person about a backpack because of this and the other thing so it's a highly collaborative experience as you are all just discussing all of the tons of information that is out there on the table now some of these things might be red herrings and also another really cool thing about this game is that because of the using smart device it kind of has a time sense to it like I'm not gonna give any spoilers here because I'm not saying any specifics but there are definitely some scenarios that you can do where a person might leave a location and go to another location or a person that you've talked to might end up dying and then be a new armored that you have to try and figure out so you can no longer talk to them because obviously they have died because you didn't do a thing before another thing or but maybe they were always gonna die in that certain point it's it's not super clear because I haven't played any of these repeated times but but all of
these things kind of make sense you know like a person can run out of a location in a hurry and you don't know where they are anymore so you can't talk to them because you don't know where they are but you might find them over here in this other part of the city now at a certain point you might say okay I think we've solved the mystery and I think we understand everything and then you'll go back to the police station and essentially give you a report and you will plug all these things into your smart device and it'll tell you if you had the murder person right but then it also might ask you some tertiary questions like when this happened was it this or that or various different things to see just how far and wide you were able to figure out different details like it might ask you questions that have nothing to do with the murder mystery or that piece of art that was stolen but it's just trying to see how well you did overall and it will give you a score now I suppose at this point I should mention that chronicles of crime in a lot of ways is a modern adaptation of the Sherlock Holmes consulting detective game that came out tens of years ago now I've played that one as well and I thought about putting that one here in this list and and honestly I feel like it should just Nestle right here in the same spot as chronicles of crime because in that one you did not have any smart devices so it's strictly a board game with cardboard but you have a similar situation where you have to read a bunch of information and then you will travel around London trying to ask people different things based off of different other clues that you might have now both of these are all about trying to pull out little clues from a large amount of text that you are reading whether that be someone talking to you on the phone as you read the text or if you're playing Sherlock Holmes consulting detective as you read newspapers or that sort of variety of thing but that game also ends in a similar way and I think both of these
games really pull you into this thematic idea of I'm just not knowing anything like starting the game off not knowing anything and then by the end of the game you just have this crazy web of connections and interactions and and plausible things and implausible things and it's just such a fun collaborative overall experience to talk all this stuff through and I feel like it really brings out to that theme of being an investigator very well let's now move on to game number five and that one is actually gonna be two games that's pandemic legacy season one and I'm gonna glove this in with pandemic legacy season two now these are both legacy style games so as you play them things will permanently happen to the table as you tear up cards and add stickers and I promise I will not give any spoilers in this section right here which means I'm not sure how detailed that I can actually go but but I do want to talk about why they're on this list and why I've lumped both of them here now the first version of pandemic like the one that came out a long time ago was just you have to plan earth and it's being afflicted by these four different diseases and you are trying to walk around and stamping down these diseases by collecting cards and passing them around and doing various puzzly type things now the thing with the legacy games is as you start playing them specifically season one the very first planet game you play in season one is like 95% identical to the original pandemic but then as you play through these sessions things will start to change rules will change significantly and you will find yourself in a very different somatic area near the end of these seasons than you do back at the beginning and the reason I have this on this list is because I really feel like
the game does a great job of pulling you on with this story as you introduce new mechanics that make tons of sense with the things you're actually doing out in the map and again it's kind of tough not going into some of these specifics here but I will admit that it's still somewhat abstract like you're still wandering around world in both of these seasons has you know a character and that character has a special ability and you just miraculously you know cross huge continents quickly curing entire cities single-handedly like you don't have to worry about that somatic disconnect suit as much because the reason I have it here is because of the emotions that these both of these seasons have been able to elicit you know there was a moment in season one where I was so angry because of how hard things had gotten and because of how messed up the world seen in beginning that I literally was like angry like I had to feel my pulse I was like oh my gosh like I need to calm down and we didn't play the game for like six weeks after that because I was so emotionally affected by the play and it wasn't like oh this game is bad I'm not having fun it was like I felt this stress like oh my god the world is going to hell and I'm trying to fix it as much as I can we're putting permanent stickers on the board and like that had his dress was just it really just pulled me in and made all of the decisions that I made feels so much more important which kind of makes sense when you're trying to stop the world from a humanity killing disease or to you know there's still a lot of these trying to wipe things out so I thought it was amazing that it was able to make me stressed like that and a big part of that and well actually pretty much all of that has to do with the fact that it was a legacy style game
so my decisions had permanence my failures had permanence and that's kind of a special thing we obviously came back and we ended up finishing the season there was some pretty amazing moments where you open up specific boxes and where you learn specific things that throw everything on its head and you're like how did I not see that coming and it really it feels like you are like watching binging a Netflix show or something like that as you are watching as you are playing these games and it also like really pulls you into the mechanics of what you're doing and in season two but there are some pretty significant mechanical differences to how you play pandemic in season two then season one even right from the very first session but I don't think that's really particularly important when it comes to my overall discussion here as far as theme is concerned because that one also still had that stress it still had those moment of elation and awesome combo moments where you realize you really pull things off and you really save different things and I think that altogether they're both exceptional games period like a couple of the best gaming's that I've ever had but also I do feel like they deserve to be on this list and they deserve to be at this pointless list because of the way they really pulled me into the theming of what was going on in those games all right let's keep on moving and the next game is going to be gloomy Haven at number four now gloomy Haven is essentially a campaign style game I know that some people think it's more of a legacy but from my perspective what you were doing in this game is for the most part you are inside various dungeon type levels they're not always dungeons but there are some times outdoors or in crazy elemental areas but what you were in is
a region and you are a specific character and you're wandering through this micro subset of a much larger area of terrain you might be in like a church or you might be in a forest or you might be underground in a dungeon and you are wandering around trying to defeat monsters and achieve various mission goals to get you to the end of the mission now this is a campaign style game with this massive book with like I think 95 different scenarios in it and the legacy aspect that can kind of come into play is that as you were playing through these scenarios you will unlock various things and sometimes you will unlock branching paths you might decide to help a person or hurt a person you might decide to you know go down below or go above or you know it might say like you know to move on to the next Bond you know go through that grade or go down the hole and it will unlock various different other things that you won't really be able to go back and do the other versions because you have made those overall permanent decisions for this overall campaign now the reason it's on this list at all is because I do think it's a very thematic game but the reason it's so far up this list has to do with the feeling that you get while you're playing it specifically while you are within the scenarios that you're playing now you are a specific character which again makes I think a little bit more thematic since then in pandemic legacy where you are a character who goes to a city and cures everyone here you are a regular sized character going up against regular ish sized enemies next to regular sized trees and whatnot and you are wandering around and you are doing a lot of attacking like this game is very much a tactical combat oriented game most of the goals that you are trying to do involve wiping out some or
all of the enemies that are within the various region that you are at but the way you do this is you play cards from your hand in pairs every card has a top and a bottom part to it and you play two cards and then you simultaneously reveal them with your companions around the table and then you do the top of one card at the bottom of another card now the theming really comes into play with the the time the initiative mechanic that exists in this game many dungeon crawlers have you take a turn you go over you whack monster then the monster takes a turn they go over and they whack you but in Glu Haven it really pulls in this idea that everything is happening simultaneously because you reveal your cards and then you have an initiative value that goes from 1 to 99 essentially and then you also reveal random cards for all of the monsters and they also have initiative values and then everybody does their action in ascending initiative order so that means that you are not sure if you're gonna be able to go over and whack that monster before they go and they might go to a different spot outside of your range or they might come right up next to you and immobilize you and now you can't actually move and so you have to plan accordingly around these things but you don't always know exactly what's gonna happen and I feel like if you were actually in a forest or a dungeon or an elemental plane trying to fight all these different things you're not gonna be able to plan things I would like to know that it's obviously you know if you pull yourself in to the theming of it you are running around you're swinging axes you're doing various different abilities and everything's happening all at once and I think the game does a really good job of pulling you into that because of this you're also not really allowed to discuss what you're gonna be doing that much with your opponents I'm sorry your companions around the table it's a fully cooperative game because you don't have
how much time you're running into the next room and you can't like go through a specific crazy play-by-play type thing you could just say as you're running into the room I'm gonna go after that skeleton or you know I'm gonna run over there and get that chest and you know that's pretty much all you could to matically do in that situation as you're running around trying to fight all of these different things now there's another thing I want to mention and that is that the cards themselves that you are playing do a astonishing variety of different things now most of them are oriented around you like doing damage in a variety of different ways or maybe healing things we're giving you some buffs or some debuffs on enemies but there are so many unlockable characters in this game and every single one of them seems to have a new card said that really matches up with a theming of what that character does I'm not gonna spoil any of them right now I'll just I guess talk about the the basic characters that you start the game with but one of them is kind of a rogue style character and if they do their best damage when they sneak around and do damned from like behind I'm not from behind but like from close quarters on different things you also have you know a character that is like a spell weaver that's very fragile but they can do damage that a snake from one character to next you have a variety of other things I don't want to go to the specifics but the cards themselves tell you what they do and if it says like I am breaking the chains and then you feel like you have done that in your swinging chains around the room or if it says like you are literally you know throwing a rock you feel like you just picked up a rock and threw it and the mechanics of what happens really makes it feel like you did that like you might throw a rock and now there's a rock on the floor it might be in the way for somebody to go around there you might have a way to like explode that rock and do damage to various different things and the theming
of the card of the action the specific action that you're doing really feels cool it just makes you feel like is powerful hero type character that's doing all of these crazy things when in reality you're just walking a couple spaces and doing a couple damage into various different things now I could probably talk about gloom having a lot more I should probably stop at this point I think I've think I've made a good case for why I think this is such a semantic overall game ok let's now move into game number three and this one is captain sonar now the theming of this game is you have two submarines that are out in the various oceans and you win if you and your submarine are able to destroy the other submarine and they win if they destroy your submarine now there are a few things going on here and the first most obvious one is that you are splitting up into teams and that you will be on a team with a couple other people who win or lose with you because you are literally inside that submarine with them and what you do is each person has a different skillset you might have a captain who is able to do various things you might have a navigator on type of communication person who is trying to track the through the radio or the you know the sonar pings where they think their opponent might be you have somebody who might be able to load up weapons that he can be launched and you have an engineer who's trying to patch up all of the different things that are breaking constantly in the game and the thing that really pulls you into this theme is the fact that it is real-time now I talked about real-time earlier when I discussed kitchen rush and I do think that in the right setting having a real time mechanic in a board game can very much pull you into the theme and I think if you are two submarines trying to destroy each other out in the ocean it makes sense that you wouldn't be like
oh I go once and then we'll just hang out while you guys go and then we'll go and then you'll go no you are going around you are ordering committing commands as the captain as you are you know sailing around I guess you know is it sailing with submarines either way as you are moving around the ocean and you will have suspicions about where you think the opponents are you can use sonar and various other abilities which really do thematically make that make sense and I think bringing myself back to the stress of being in the kitchen with kitchen rush this game also does have that stress because you start to learn information about where your opponent is but they might be able to go silent and then really kind of scramble your thought process on what you're trying to do or you have those moments where you decide to fire a missile and whenever you do this that's the moment where gameplay stops and you say okay we're firing a missile to the specific spot and then you see if you did damage first of all if you did damage then of course you had a pretty good idea of where they are and obviously these maps are pretty big so just hitting him hitting a person at all he's saying an amazing moment it's like oh my gosh all my theories they were actually right and if you hit them enough times then obviously they will lose but there is a catch to actually hitting them and that is that there is a specific range of which your missiles can go so by launching a attack you're actually telegraphing to your opponent about where you are you actually giving them information as you are trying to process a forum proceed forward towards your win condition and I've played this game and I think every single one of the different player types and I think all of them just really pull you into that feeling well honestly it's been a long time I forget the specifics of it but one of them is like a secondary captain and that one is
probably the weakest when it comes to theme I think that the engineer you definitely feel like his stuff is breaking all the time as you were trying to move in around different ways you're just you feel like you're in the battles of the summer range with a wrench just trying to smash things and wrench things down so that you can just keep it going along enough to actually win the game as the communications expert you really feel like you're trying to to input all of these different pieces of information to try and figure out where they might be and the captain is obviously you know the captain of the ship they say where you're gonna go and the but kind of stops with them - in a lot of different ways you know the ones who decide to fire they're the ones who decide to move and they are obviously discussing with all of the different other people on their team what is happening but everything you say can be heard by the opposing team but there may be so frantic over there trying to do their own stuff they might not necessarily hear everything so I think every time I play this game it's been a wonderful ether Matic experience I genuinely I felt like I was in this cramped pressure-filled crazy stressful submarine duking it out to the death with the other team and every time the game ends whether you win or lose there's this moment of like oh my gosh and that was stressful like fun stressful for sure but but then that stress that really pulls you in I think is one of the big selling points from a thematic perspective that captain stoner has alright we've reached game number two and this one is fog of love now somatically what's going on in this game is it's going to be you and just one other person and you are working through the trials and tribulations of a romantic relationship now you do not need to be in an actual romantic relationship with the other player that you are playing this game with in fact it's quite interesting if you're playing with just one of your platonic friends
but what you do in this game mechanically is you effectively go on a variety of different experiences like excursions or dates or different types of things and each player is going to kind of alternate what thing that you will be doing in this given round and then they'll both usually simultaneously decide on some sort of outcome now the way that that simultaneousness works is you then reveal the outcomes and if you are aligned with that then something will happen if you are not aligned then the degree of which you are not aligned in how you evaluate that specific scenario is going to dictate what the repercussions are gonna be and the reason I have this on this list is because this game really forces you to not only kind of embody the mindset of a fictitious person but you also really need to keep trying to get into the head of this other fictitious person that is existing on the other side of the table from you now I personally I don't like role-playing I don't really play role-playing games I get very nervous and anxious when it comes to trying to be something that I'm not and I feel like my creativity goes away and I just I'm just not a role-playing game type person at all but I want to say that because when it comes to fog of love it does not feel like you're role-playing because at the start of the game you effectively build out your character with a variety of different traits and most of these are hidden from your companion and they're trying to learn things about you and they're trying to learn how you work based off of these different traits now in the middle of the table there are a variety of different um traits I guess
that are printed out in the middle that have to do with like how giving you are how selfish you are or how you know outgoing or introverted you are and when you are trying to evaluate these different spots at the beginning of the game you don't know much and then you reveal and maybe you clash a little bit and that's fine a thing happens maybe one person becomes less happy and another person becomes more happy in their relationship or something like that but then you go on to the next excursion and you have to keep in mind what they decided to do on the last one because the theming of it like if you are selfish or you're nerdy or you know various different things that are hidden from your the companion across the table you need to play with those in mind I need to when I'm playing it I'm like I'm not like what would John do I'm like what would this character do like they have this and this and this well I think it would actually be a lot more selfish than then I am as an actual person so I'm gonna play to that selfishness and I found that when I played this game a couple times then when you get near the end of the game you'll have these these crazy awesome moments where like you reveal and you're like perfectly aligned because they knew that you would do that based off of your previous interactions with the various other previous end dates that you effectively have gone on but then you'll have other times where you will reveal you're like why did you do that you have been you've done this not in the past and they might show you the shoulders because they have other things you're going for because each player also kind of has these hidden goals and then at the very end of the game as you're playing through the game you are discarding essentially these endgame cards and then when the game comes to an end both people need to secretly decide on a way to conclude the game and that might be breaking up that might be trying to be together forever that might be other
things that are less great like you know one of them is like to be dominant like it to be way happier in the relationship than the other person to win and you reveal them and you see if both of you won if one person one or the other person didn't or if both of you have not won because there are these restrictions on those cards you know to be in a if you say I want to be a happy relationship going on and the other person breaks up then you're not gonna win because obviously that's not what you wanted and that breaking up person might end up winning because of the restrictions based off of how happy you are and various attributes that are going on so I'm trying not to go into the nitty-gritty of the mechanics too much here but I'm trying to say that from a thematic perspective I think this game does an amazing job of pulling you into acting like a person that you are not while still not making you feel like you are role playing in the traditional sense because I think there probably lots of people out there like me who really don't like good role playing but but I found it fascinating when I played that out in this game now I actually don't have my copy of this game anymore because in the end it was not something I wanted to keep playing but when I was building on this list I kept thinking about fog of love and the more I thought about it the higher up it went on this list because I was like yeah like from a thematic perspective this game really does an amazing job of turning you into a person that you aren't and also progressing you through a relationship that doesn't actually exist all right we finally reached my current number one somatic game and that one is spirit island now automatically what's going on here is you have an island way out in the middle of the ocean and everybody around the table is going to be a spirit that is on this island trying to foster
peace amongst the natives and trying to just you know live in harmony with the type of spirit that you are now this game comes with a pretty wide variety of different spirit types you might be the spirit of the ocean and you are the waves that are crashing up on the shore and then off again you might be the spirit of shadows and you are all about you know doing tertiary things on the outside like tiny shadowy type things you might be the god of the spirit of the earth and you are just this lumbering giant style spirit they can you know move things around and do massive really powerful things and then what happens is you have these invaders come these white European invaders effect essentially they start out as explorers on your Beach and then they explore inland and then will turn into little towns and those towns will turn into big cities and they will blight the land and then you as spirits need to cooperate and trying to expunge all of these settlers off of your Island to keep it back to its pristine former state now the reason I have this game is my number one the most ematic game is because the mechanics of this game truly make you feel like you are that specific type of spirit that you are playing now mechanically what you are doing is you are going to be playing different power cards from your hand and they do a variety of different things and each one of these cards tells you what it does in a similar way to Glu Haven that I talked about a few games ago where you play a card it does a mechanic action and the card also has an illustration and a name and that tends to really match up with the action that you do like you might just move a settler over here and pull up light off
but then you look at the specifics of the card and then you understand like it wasn't just move a settler pull up light off it's like you know you you know doing a horrifying rejuvenation or something like that and as you start to combo these cards together to do really powerful things you just feel like you more and more embody what the Spirit is trying to do for instance they the ocean that I mentioned before the ocean player cannot do anything to the middle of the island because there's the ocean they can only touch the outsides of the island but they have a mechanic where every other turn the tide is essentially coming in and then the tide is coming out and it just works like you really feel like the tide is coming in and out and the various powers and things that you can do as you're playing will be different if the tide is in or out if the tide is in then you have a lot more control you have a lot more power you have a lot more waves to you know wipe these settlers out to sea but if the tides out then other different things are gonna be better for you to do in that specific situation one of the promo spirits that I got to play is the spirit of blazing wildfire and in this one you just run around the island blinding things like crazy because again blight is kind of like a general term for destruction it might be settlers chopping down trees or in this case it might be you as this spirit of wildfire lighting everything on fire which blight things but fire also scares the settlers off and so you're just as crazy fast one you're trying to coordinate them off you're trying to use blight to a good extent but obviously not over by the island because then it's another way that you can overall lose the game and I felt like it was this crazy thing
you know running around you know lighting fires all over the place every time I played this game I just feel like I'm so sucked into the seeming of what my spirit does as it does all these mechanical things and at the end of the day realistically the way you win this game is by scaring the explorers so much that they flee the island now you can of course just destroy them in a lot of different ways there's lots of ways to do damage but the main way that you're gonna do this is by scaring them to the point where the more scare they are the easier your overall win can just gets and so the more figure you can do the better and speaking of here I think I've got to mention the spear of nightmares and dreams now I play this one once and it was an amazing experience now in this play when you're playing has this character you are literally just nightmares and dreams like you have no physical manifestation on anything like if you were to try and do damage with the card and that damage just turns into fear and you you just can't actually touch anything but the amount of fear and the amount of control that you have on these settlers is amazing because you were just getting into their dreams and they're just running all over the place and you can control just what they do in all these different ways you know you can get other cards that really kind of combo well like raining blood down which is obviously a horrifying thing and if I was a settler and blood rain down for this guy that would that would make me decide to maybe leave the island overall and and I think that the fact that the game can have characters like this lumbering earth giant that just like summons big you know boulders and that kind of stuff but then also of a character that just exists in the minds of the settlers that you were trying to
expunge is just an amazing feat of mechanical and somatic integration so I think I've probably talked about this one enough at this point I just think that the way that you get into this theme is the reason why it's so far up here I have to admit I think that spirit island is an exceptional game and it's hard to divorce that from from this list like what I'm thinking about it like obviously I'm trying to list these games out in order of how thematic they are and I do think that Spirit Island is the most thematic out of all of these but I'm sure that my by I'm being somewhat biased by the fact that I really really like this game as well so I think at this point I have said everything I need to about spirit Island now at this point we have reached the end of this list and I hope you have enjoyed it I would like to mention once again that it was a really cool making this bonus video I had no idea what it was going to be the contributing producer level of supporters they they nominated a bunch of different types of videos many of them were playthroughs and one of them was this top 10 list for thematic games and then they all voted on them and this is the one that they voted on and and I was actually pretty excited about it because I haven't done a top 10 list in a long time and I think that it's certainly possible that in the future they might select another top 10 list and we'll see what I'll be talking about about in that case but I think it's also very likely that I will end up doing some playthroughs for some older games and if you'd like to learn any more about and again please go to patreon.com/scishow Nets games to see how you could potentially also request specific videos and then vote on them and just like this there are a lot of ways to support the channel overall but I don't think I want to go into a crazy sales pitch right here I think at this point I'm going to wrap this up as always I'd like to thank everyone who's
been supporting this channel including all of these producer level patreon backers if you two would like to directly support the channel and the creation of videos like this one then please go to junkets Gamescom slash support to see a variety of ways with which you can do that also if you enjoy this video please click the like button down below as well as the subscribe button for the channel thanks for watching