Top 10 Best Board Games of 2023
Transcript
e
e
e
e e let's see if this works hopefully this works and you can hear me and you can see me okay but the chat is not appearing so I will have a bit of a fiddle around to see if I can get the chat working the chat is working yeah excellent um I've had a fiddle around and I've got a different layout for this year and this is the first year that we're doing it live so hello and welcome to everybody who is joining me for this this live stream uh the voice is a little distant it shouldn't be any different than it was the other day I've Got the Right microphone on yeah the Right microphone is on so and the other microphone is off so it is using this microphone it should be okay uh is it just Chrissy or is every do everybody else think the sound sounds a bit weird um yeah anyway we're here we are doing my favorite games of 2023 and the reason why it's a little different this year is I'm doing this as a live stream so for
those of you that are confused and wondering why I am doing my top 10 games or the best games of 2023 I've been doing this for quite a while now I traditionally do my top 10 games of the year way way way after everybody else and the reason for that is I personally don't feel comfortable at the end of a year telling you what the best games of that year were because for example there are about 10 to 15 games that I've brought back with me from Essen Spiel this year that I haven't played yet and some of them might make it into my top 10 so for me it's a bit too soon because I haven't played all of the games yet but also some of the games I've only played once so for example seti seti is very likely in my top 10 games of 2024 but I've played it once and there just hasn't been enough time to play it more times so traditionally for the last few years I have always done my top 10 games of the year sometime in the year after everybody else and I had a bit of an interesting year this year I was going to do this around Springtime then I was going to do it around summer then there was a phase where I wasn't going to do at all and then I said no I'm going to do it but I'm going to do it as a live stream and I made a promise to myself that I will get it done before the end of the year which is why I'm doing it today because today is the last day of the year and happy New Year to everybody for tonight or if you are one of my Australian followers you've already had happy New Year cuz you are a time
traveler from the future so yes um now what we're going to be doing is as you can see on screen we're going to be using the pub Meo ranking system now this is a great tool it is freely available but they do accept donations I will be donating to them again uh some money because I have used this platform myself in the past and it is a place where you can basically rank games so what I've done is I have already been through all of the games that were released according to Board Game Geek in 2023 that I have played that's what I've done so it is a list of as you can see 63 items but before we start I'm going to cause a little bit of controversy because I've been taking some advice from some of the other clickbait YouTube channels and apparently if you cause controversy and say things that upset people you get way more views so I've decided deliberately to cause a little bit of controversy even before we start and what I'm going to do is I'm going to go through this list and I'm going to remove two of the games from this list and the first one I'm going to remove is where is it where is it where is it it is L grona Deluxe Master set now this was technically a 2023 game but in my opinion it is just a new version of the same game there have been apart from lots of little modu expansions the game itself is the same game it's just a deluxe version of it with much much
nicer components so as far as I'm concerned that game is not a 2023 game so I'm going to remove it feel free to disagree gone the next one I'm going to remove is and people are going to be upset by this one the castles of burgundy special edition and I know that the special edition does come with The Vineyards expansion which is new but as far as I'm concerned that again is just a Super Deluxe well produced potentially overproduced version of the same game so I'm not classing that as a 2023 game okay so that's part of the controversy the controversy continues it's a two for one offer because I am keeping June Imperium Uprising now I am of the opinion that whilst June Imperium Uprising does does share a lot of similarities with the original June Imperium I'm classing it as a different game I I feel it is enough different even if that difference is only 10% 20% whatever I feel it's enough difference to class it as a 20123 game there you go I've lost James as a subscriber apologies James well no I'm not apologizing I am I am deliberately doing this to try and get more views and follow I'm joking about that of course but yeah and another game which I am also keeping on here is Great Western
Trail New Zealand and there are some people who think all of the Great Western Trail games are the same they are wrong those people they are scientifically proven to be wrong Great Western Trail New Zealand again it does share a lot of DNA with Great Western Trail but I'm classing that as a separate entity so there you go we are we we are done we we've gone through the stuff and these are all of the games that I played and I don't know how this is going to come out I have a funny feeling which one is my number one game of the year just for my good reaction but we'll see now I last used this system to rank my entire collection and if you haven't seen this video about two or three years ago over the Christmas holiday period I did a series of live streams where I used this system and I went through my entire collection it was a long video I think it was like three 2hour videos or something like that apparently it was a lot of fun it was a lot of hard work for me and I had to make some agonizing decisions and I never want to do that again I'm never going to rank my entire collection again but that is on the channel now go back a couple of years you will see it it's Paul ranks his whole collection and it was done in a very similar way uh graem is saying I would remove Jango as well is that on the list is that on the list Zang goo is on the list I am going to remove that one as well thank you Graeme I'd missed that one Jango the first Empire is a a new version of Jango but they did tweak some of the rules but
not many oh do I do I leave it do I get rid of it I'm G to get rid of it I yeah it's almost the same game as the original it's more different than cast of burgy special edition and L Gran had but I am going to remove Jango right so we're done we are down to 60 items so what happens is you can put in a list of items into pu me you can either add the items from BGG or you can add in a text list or however you want to do it and then what you do is you click Rank and it basically said there's going to be 196 comparisons so I don't know how long we're going to be here today it will start off and it just throws two games at you and it's got some clever algorithm running in the background but um it's going to start off quite slow because I'm going to be talking about these games a little bit but then as we go through it I will be selecting them uh a a lot quicker hopefully because I have about an hour and a half today Vicki is downstairs Vicki has been cooking all day yesterday literally all day all day today we have 12 people coming over tonight we are hosting a New Year's Eve party and Vicki is cooking three main meals three desserts a whole bunch of side dishes and I should be tidying the house now in my defense I think the house tidying is all done everywhere is all done but I've said that I will be about 90 minutes to get this done and then I will go and help her do all of the preparation so uh yeah we we will see
right first up and I'm going to try and keep an eye on the time today perspectives or sept now a lot of people have heard of sept from mind clash games and the general train of thought about September seems to a lot of people were disappointed by it I've not actually played it myself since the game came out and whilst I did enjoy playing it when it was a prototype I've never felt that I enjoyed it enough to go back to it so I have the final version of the game but I haven't gone back to it yet and to be honest I haven't played the final version of the game because they did tweak it since we played the proty perspectives not a lot of people will know about this so I need to talk to you about perspectives because this is a game from Space Cowboys it's created and designed by Dave Neil Dave Neil I am a fan of Dave um Dave do does a lot of narrative driven games he he did the shock homes Consulting detective box number four he's done a couple of unlock scenarios he's recently worked with David Thompson on the war story occupied France game perspectives is a really interesting game but what I will tell you is that box two of perspectives which I don't think he out yet but he's out soon it's got a blue box box two of perspectives is much better each box comes with three cases they are Play Once scenarios because once you've worked out the puzzle um you can't really replay them and box one was good but every single case from box two was better than all of the cases from box one so yeah if you like that kind of
game where there's a puzzle to solve but it's done in a really interesting way then check out perspectives and it's difficult for me to rank these because perspectives is a play once game once you have played the three cases in perspectives you you can't go back to it again whereas Septima is your standard Euro game but my personal preference and this is potentially because I am a fan of Dave Neil's puzzle style games I'm going to go with perspectives on this one even though I can't actually play that again Dungeons and Dragons trial of Tempest and zuv vardis now zuv Adis I do not own zuis that is a friends copy that I've played but what I can tell you is that Zu Aris designed by RNE kitzia is a rethe and a reimplementation of an old game which I do own called somebody in the chat remind me what it's called quard that's it quovadis and I think quovadis is a really interesting game it's heavily on negotiation between players which is not something that I normally do but it works really well in that game so Zu Aris is is an interesting game Dungeons and Dragons trial of tempus I have covered this on the channel this is a quite an expensive game and even more expensive if you buy the deluxe version with the painted Miniatures I really wanted to like this game I really did and unfortunately this game was a miss this game had and and the designer is a really nice guy the designer is a is a professional GM he does lots and lots of the role playing game and he's designed this board game
but the board game just had problems it just didn't work so I think the game was a bit of a flop I think it came out a few people got it the people who did get it and played it posted about all of the issues with it and they tried to fix some of those issues with some optional rules and variants but then the game just disappeared and I've not seen anybody talking about it or anybody playing it there could be a good game in there but I think it needs work so out of those two even though qu vardis and zaris are not my kind of games generally I think Trials of Tempest does have some fundamental issues that means it doesn't quite work as a game so we're going to go with zu Aris next up ah right these are both potentially top 10 games of me for 2023 I love both of these games I think I love world of world wonders more than Barcelona but I do not want Barcelona to be moved down this list because Barcelona is my favorite Danny Garcia game I really like Barcelona but world wonders is very special I have covered both of these on the channel if you're interested but world wonders for me was a was a big hit from last year so we're going with world wonders now this is interesting both of these games have gone from my collection so I I wasn't keen on either of these games let's start first of all with Legends of Andor the Eternal Frost I actually quite like the legends of Andor system I have the first box the original
box I have the second box I don't think I have the third one this was the fourth one in the series and I tried this and I actually did a live stream of this I don't know whether it was public or whether it was Patron only but JP came around and we played the tuto tutorial scenario from this game and I have to say I was a little disappoint OED but I didn't give it a fair crack the reason why I was a bit disappointed is the tutorial scenario from this game is pretty much the same tutorial scenario that's from the other games but there was wooliness in the rules and that's what bothered me is that this game has been around for quite a long time this is the fourth iteration of the game and it seems to be really popular in Germany which is why it's there's still stuff coming out for it but yeah I was a little disappointed in it so I moved it on because my house is limited size I can't keep everything but I am keeping the first two games in the series and I do want to get back and play them again at some point archaeologic now I really wanted to like this game because on the surface of it this is a game which is exactly the kind of game that me and Vicki would like to play and I remember that somebody gave me a copy of this not the publisher somebody else who'd been given a copy of the game at ESS in 2023 and he gave it to me at the end of the show and I said why are you giving it to me he says I've got it I played it I wasn't too keen on it I thought you might like it I thought sure bring it back with you uh and we hated it absolutely hated it I I I actually think this game does not work
fundamentally doesn't work now what's really interesting and I think this is by the same guy that designed touring machine that I've still never played but has apparently uh really good and a really good puzzle game this is also a puzzle game where you get given bits of information and you're trying to work out the answer to the puzzle but the reason why it doesn't really work is that you all pretty much reach the same conclusion at the same time and therefore it's whoever went first in turn sequence and the solo game which we then tried H the solo game was just like get a clue have we got enough to solve the puzzle no get another clue have we got enough to solve the puzzle no repeat repeat repeat get another clue have we now got enough to solve the puzzle yes try and solve the puzzle is it correct yes it is that was it that's that's the game so for me there was no game in there um and and that was a bit of a miss so out of those two definitely Legends of Andor but there's a little bit of story about them so void fall and 20 strong both good games but I've got to give it to void fall on this one for obvious reasons 20 strong is a nice little game it's solo only it's a dice based game which comes with 20 dice so it is nice whereas void fall a lot of people are already probably knowing that void fall is very likely to be my number one game of the year but the reason I'm giving it to void fall in this case is it canet be played solo cooperatively competitively and it's amazingly awesome so we're going with void fall now
evacuation and Star Wars the deck building game I can tell you a story about this um and I think a lot of people are actually tuning in for these stories rather than the actual ranking system I hope you're enjoying these little stories because this is my opportunity to just talk completely openly about these games Star Wars the Deb building game is based on the Star Realms system I absolutely hate the Star Realms game I think it is one of the worst games ever and I just think it's a complete another look Fest and anybody who says oh a quick game is a good game no no I'm sorry but a quick game is a quick game a quick just because it's a quick game doesn't mean it's a good game I found Star Realms awful I found the decision space very very minimal I found that the the the um the the choices were obvious about which card you draft and then it is just a complete look Factor now I have played Star Realms despite hating the game probably about 5 to 100 times on the app because there is an app and you can literally play a game in two or three minutes and the reason why I don't think it works as a game is I can play a game and in that game I could get an absolute lucky run of cards and win the game easily like absolutely easily then I can play the next game my skill level has not changed between those two games I am making the same choices that I made
in the previous game and yet I will lose it completely and that's my problem with the game just because it's quick doesn't make it a good game I can win or lose a game just based on to factors that are totally out of my control and I know I'm probably upsetting people here but I really hated Star Realms as a G Star Wars the deck building game is based on Star Realms and yet I actually enjoyed it now I enjoyed it for two reasons first of all it's Star Wars rather than just some random sci-fi races right so it's Star Wars it still does have some of the fundamental issues that I had with Star Realms but it has some tweaks and I think those tweaks make the game better so I actually enjoyed Star Wars the DAT building game and I've recently got the Clone Wars which I want to cover on the channel and you can merge them together to play a four-player game of it which I want to do let's move on to evacuation evacuation could have potentially been one of my top 10 games of 2023 I have played it five times I think and I do want to play it once more maybe twice more because I've still not used the advanced version of the cards and evacuation is a really interesting game cuz my first game I loved it my second game I still loved it my third game I really enjoyed it and by my fourth game I went wait a minute I'm doing exactly the same thing in every game the objective is that
you're trying to evacuate from one planet to another planet and you've got four rounds to do so and I think there is a kind of optimum way of doing it at which point you're kind of just doing roughly the same thing with some little tweaks here and there not sure not sure I have played both modules I actually personally think that both modes of play both the race mode and the points mode I think they're both valid I I think they both work as games I think I slightly prefer the points mode but I think the race mode is still a good game and yeah my only concern with it is that you end up in a pattern of in the first round you have to buy a ship and then you start moving stuff across and yeah I'm not sure out of the two I'm going to go with evacuation I don't know if anybody expected that but I am actually going to go with evacuation now then two games that I want to talk about here because I think both of these games are not that well known first of all mother of Frankenstein I only got a copy of this game because I have a good working relationship with the publisher and the publisher is not the original publisher of the game this is another one that Arcane wonders picked up and did the distribution of mother of Frankenstein is a three-part uh and each part comes in its own box but oddly enough there is only one BGG entry for the game but there are three boxes chapters one two and three each one will take you about five to six hours to play it is an escape room style puzzle Style game with quite a bit of narrative and the puzzles in it are
exceptional with box three was a little bit of a letdown but box one some of the puzzles in box one were fantastic and box 2 was really enjoyable as well and yes Rick you do need to play it CU it is really really good but I don't think many people know about this game and yeah I I we were really impressed by mother of Frankenstein we have played through all three parts of it as I say part three was a little weak but Parts one and part two really clever really well done spell book is a game that came out in 2023 which nobody else seems to like except for me I really like spell book and yet it didn't go down well and it wasn't popular and it hasn't had any of the expansion sets that I I think I was hoping it would get now I do play Spellbook with a house rule because one of the criticisms of criticisms of the game is that it's a bit too slow to get started which means everybody's first few turns you're playing for a few minutes and nothing's really happening so I have a house rule for that game which I believe I still haven't put up on my list so I have a geek list on Board Game Geek where I go through all of my house rules for games and I think I still have an outstanding taskade on my list of things to do is to update my house rule list with Spellbook but is basically a quick start that skips the first two turns of the game and gets everybody in and playing I really like Spellbook I think it's a very very good game but out of the two I'm G to have to go
with Spellbook oh this is a really difficult decision am I going to go with Spellbook or am I going to go with Mur of Frankenstein I want I want to oh this is actually the most difficult Choice I've got I'm going to go in mother of Frankenstein there you go done right now then Sky te horde and nuclear both good games nucleum many people's number one game from 2023 I very very much enjoyed nucleum and I was one of the people who was demoing nucleum at ESS in 2023 it is a great game there is absolutely no denying it's a great game however I'm probably about eight games into nucleum now and I have huge respect for the game and I think the game is a great game and I do think the game's a very very good game I don't think I will ever be able to play it well that's not a problem with the game that's a problem with me I'm just not good enough to be able to work out how to play that game well and it's just I don't know there's just something about it and as I say that's not a problem with the game Sky hord I really like now if you are sky tord is a one two or three player kind of Lane Defense Tower Defense card game but the three player
rules are that two players are playing together to try and um defeat The Horde and the third player is The Horde I have heard that nobody plays like game most people play sky tord as a solo game or as a Cooperative game and it is basically choose a particular enemy choose a fraction it's a card game you know a little bit like a lot of other card games but you have monsters coming forward and you're trying to block and everything else it is a good game I think Sky teod monoliths which was released the year after in other words this year is a better game so out of the two this this isn't a contest nucleum is the better of the two games but Sky te horde monoliths is is actually a really good game so we're giving that one to nucleum now then dice Manor and Halls of hegra okay Halls of hegra I've only played once uh friend of mine who's been on this channel many times Pete hello Pete if you're watching this video uh Pete I lent my copy of the game the publisher sent me a copy of the game I lent it to Pete Pete learned it he played it he came around and we've covered this on the channel in fact I've covered dce Manor on the channel as well Halls of hegra me and it's a solo game it's a solo game only but me and Pete played it together as one with him kind of teaching me how to play I did enjoy the game and what I really liked about the game is that I like games that teach me something about history and I also like games which um focus on a particular part of history
that I'd never heard of so this is all about the Norwegians building up the defenses in World War II from the invading Germans it's it's part of World War II that I knew absolutely nothing about and the game manages to capture not that I was there but it captures the struggle and the feel and the fact that you're having to dig out the Cannons which have been there for 10 years from the snow because the Germans are coming over the hill and struggling for provisions and everything else it really does do that my only issue with Halls of hegra as a game is that once the downward spiral starts there's no recovering from it and that might be realistic or it might be just be how the game goes I have only played it once but I've spoken to a few other people and they said yeah it's pretty much like that so if you're playing the game you might get to a point where you think oh okay we we've not done well enough at the start of the game therefore we already know now that we're not going to be able to win I I'm not sure how I feel about that from a game design point of view but the game is a is a good game and it's really welld designed now dice Manor and not a lot of people might know this I did a sponsored stream for this dice Manor is a really nice game it's a lightweight game this family weight game simply just placing dice in in a Manor and you're building up your Mana house and everything else and it plays really nicely and it plays really smoothly and really quickly these are both good games and I
do want to play H ofra again H ofra has not left my collection I made the decision two months ago do I want to keep this game and give it another go or do I want to move it on and I know it's sad to move a game on after only one game but I do have limited space I'm going to give it to Halls of hegra and I want to play it again age of innovation or Footprints this is an easy one this is a really easy one age of innovation is a fantastic game I personally feel it is an improved version of teror mytica I prefer Gia project to age of innovation I felt age of innovation was whilst a better game it was a little step too far in terms of the lexity and if I played it four or five times I'd be okay with it but every time I've played Innovation and I do want to play it more and it's on board game arena so that that will help but I feel a little bit lost like oh there's a whole part of the game that I don't understand how this bit Works whereas Gia project guia project is in my top 10 games of all time so Footprints was a good game now Footprints was let down and this is a bit of a shame because the publisher has done some really good games over the last few years and this is a good game but the graphic design of this game was it wasn't good it was like the graphic designer had gone on holiday to Greece and left somebody else in charge and gone oh I'll tell you what let's just put these colors here and this everything about the graphic design of this game was not good now I'm talking
graphic design here rather than artwork because the artwork was thematic it's about cavemen exploring and traveling along so the artwork is you know kind of drab and things like that but graphic design is how clear the iconography is and when you've got small black numbers over a brown icon it's just yeah so that let it down this is an Easy Choice even if Footprints had really good graphic design age of innovation is the better game shoes tactics and Earth this is another easy one Earth is a lot of people's number one game of 2020 23 and if it's not their number one I I think most content creators who have done top 10 videos for board games released in 2023 Earth is probably on there it was a huge hit and please bear in mind I have a personal and a professional relationship with the publisher uh Connor mcgoy the CEO of inside up games has been to this house with his family he has visited here with his entire family and we we are friends with him so please bear that in mind when I talk about I talk about this game shoes tactics was a print and play Kickstarter that they contacted me about and the designer of the game was a fan of my videos and wanted me to cover it on the channel I'm actually in shoes tactics Grogan the gay is a character from shoes tactics if you if you have that I don't know if you can still get it um but yeah it's there so based on that it's got to be shoes tactics because I'm in the game
no I'm kidding um out of the two I have only played shoes tactics a couple of times but I think Earth is the better game right anunaki dawn of the Gods and rebuilding Seattle okay I want to talk about anunaki because crano Creations have a bit of a bad reputation when it comes to their Kickstarter they kickstarters everything about running the kickstarter managing the kickstarter dealing with all of the customer service queries post Kickstarter and quality control issues of the game that was on Kickstarter now Crono Creations they are a client of mine I do various bits of work for them and I think I did a sponsored stream of anunaki when it was on Kickstarter the first time or the second time um but I I can understand the criticism that they get and they do a lot of really good games but every time they seem to use Kickstarter they're always seems to be something that goes wrong I know the barrage Kickstarter had all sorts of problems and I think the kickstarter for this didn't go smoothly the game is a really good game this is unfortunately a game that's in a big box and I want to keep this game because I want to play it more and it's a big box game and the problem with it is that it's taking up more space than it needs to but I want to play anunaki more um I think it's a really solid game and on the surface it looks like this could be a five six hour epic game it's
not it's like a two and a half hour game it's really streamlined I love the action selection mechanism and the game has it is pretty pretty streamlined despite looking like this big epic game with loads going on so I think anunaki is a very good game rebuilding Seattle I think is an amazing game I think rebuilding Seattle is an underrated game that not a lot of people know about and I think it is fantastic now again I have a good working relationship with Whiz Kids I did a little bit of work on the rule book for this game and I did a sponsored playthrough video of this game so just so you know both of these games I was professionally involved in but if you haven't tried rebuilding Seattle it is such a solid game I've got to give it to that one and I think rebuilding Seattle is actually going to be really high on my list so yeah I'm I'm definitely keeping that one rebuilding Seattle done FTW and Bot Factory now FTW is a little card game from freedom and freeer that I picked up at ESS in 2023 and it's great it's really really good it's really clever I really like it and I've played it a whole bunch of times bot Factory is a uh vit Lura co-design which is a sort of a like a 90 minute playing game and it's much lighter than his other games it's not like a super light filler game I think V called it a filler once and I I fell out with him because I said V it's not a filler game
a filler game is 15 to 20 minutes and V's opinion is that anything less than a three-hour game is a filler game so V calls it a filler game it's not um it's a light Euro well no it's probably a mediumweight Euro game it's it's lighter compared to all of his other games out of those two I think bot Factory is is the better game FTW though is a really nice little fun card game that just worked really well so we're going to give that one to B Factory just to keep V happy Dungeons and Dragons Onslaught and the warp right now I've got thoughts on both of these games first of all Dungeons and Dragons Onslaught this is another Dungeons and Dragons game from whiz kids so we've already talked earlier on in this video about uh The Dungeons and Dragons Trials of Tempest dungeons dragons Onslaught was another game that I was very excited about but it didn't hit the mark for me now one of the reasons why it didn't hit the mark for me is I I get really uncomfortable when I'm playing games and there's a rule question that I have which is not covered in the rule book I mean that happens and a lot of people just go oh well it's not clear in the rulebook let's make something up and let's just move on and carry on playing I would love to be like that however my personality makeup means I can't do that I just feel really uncomfortable and I'm like well no the there is a right rule out there somewhere I just and I need to
know what that right rule is I need to play this game the way it was intended um and I remember when I was playing dungeons of dragons Onslaught and they've probably fixed it now with various bits of FAQ and things like that um but yeah I I was having a number of those um a number of those issues with the game H but I was really excited about it and the reason why I was really excited about it is way way way back when this is when I was still playing D and D so going back 10 15 years ago now they released a Dungeons and Dragons Miniatures Skirmish game and what you did is you bought these packs of Miniatures and it was randomized it was like a ccg kind of thing it was randomized what minis you would get in these little packs and I spent hundreds and hundreds of pounds on these Miniatures not to play the game but because I used them for my role playing games so I've got a massive box filled with all of these prepainted DN D Miniatures which Rick has borrowed from me so Rick is using them at the moment when when he's playing D and D which is great that that they're actually getting used but there was a Miniatures game that was created for these Miniatures even though I I don't think many people actually played it most people just bought them to use in their role playing games and Dungeons and Dragons Onslaught I think was the next version of that it didn't come with packs that you were randomized or anything like that it came with fixed
Miniatures but I think it was that kind of game and it was a skirmish game roughly based on the D and D rules and I really wanted to like this game but something about it it just didn't quite hit the mark now I have kept this game this game is still in my collection and I know Whiz Kids contacted me about it sometime a few months ago and said we're going to try and get you to go back to Onslaught and I'm like okay well if the if the system has improved then I'm all up for for it I'm absolutely up for a D and D themed Skirmish game that you know me and Rick or whoever can play in like an hour an hour and a half or something like that but it it wasn't quite that at the time the warp is an interesting game and I have covered this on the channel I don't think I've done any sponsored coverage of this game but the warp is an interesting one and I think I've played it a few times I'm I'm trying to remember now I think it it it plays quite nicely and it's interesting and it's different and I I've covered it on the channel out out of those two I'm gonna have to give it to the warp although it's close neither of those games I think are great games Onslaught could be better if the rules issues were were sorted out and as I say they may have already sorted I'm really curious if you've played dungeons dragons Onslaught and it is a great game and I'm missing something let me know let me know but I'm going to give this one to the war next up oh God right could horor the city of Silvera CG's um game from
2023 I am personally friends with the designer of this game or one of the designers of this game I am personal friends with and I have shared a hotel room with many many a time heemy I have a professional working relationship with uh the publisher of this game and they sent me a Christmas card which is over there I'm going to give it to hemony and I don't think many people will agree with me on this one I I I don't think many people will disagree with me on this one I think even if you're a fan of C hor I think heremy deserves all the praise it gets from you know reviewers and games players and and everything else I think hermany is something special um and having played both I've played kahur three two or three times I've played hman about five or six times I think hermany is the better game out of the two okay kzco or Shipyard second edition now tell you what I probably should have removed Shipyard I'm going to remove Shipyard for the same reasons that I removed the other games early on Shipyard second edition came out in 2023 and I'm really glad it came out because Shipyard by vadir sui I think is a great game I got the original version of Shipyard when it came out in I want to say 2007 it was either 2007 or 2008 I think
it was 2008 I think League of six with 2007 but I'm going to remove it because Shipyard second edition is the same game just with a complete overhaul of of of graphics and components and everything else and kusco is really good but Shipyard is going out are you do want to remove Shipyard from the ranking process yes okay so side question Nemesis and amygdala so side quest is a series of games from Bard and dice and again full disclosure here I have a very good working relationship with bord and dice and their side quest series of games are escape room style puzzle games they've done a frost Punk one they've done a nemesis one they've done an Isle of cats one and they've done a one I've not played before what's the one I've not played um it's some role playing game swash bookling piratey role playing game seventh SE thank you gra side quest Nemesis is amazing so the these puzzle games all we've not played the 7th c one but the Nemesis one the frost Punk one amazing I wasn't fully 100% convinced by the is of cats one some of the puzzles in that were a little bit odd but we like puzzle games anyway and the puzzles in this one were really good and migdala I have covered this on the channel so I've done a sponsored playthrough of amigdala on the channel from game Brewer now game Brewer are sadly no longer with us but I will
be honest with you even though I did a sponsored playthrough of this game I wasn't keen on amigdala for a couple of reasons the first one um the colors and the style of the the the whole look and the whole feel of the game it it graded against me now it was supposed to be thematic but it just it looked a bit off-putting also the game is a completely abstract game now I don't mind some abstract games but this game was just a bit quirky and I was happy once I'd played it two or three times that I'm I'm done with it there wasn't anything in there that would made me interested enough to go back now if you do like a mcdill I want to hear from you because every game does have its audience one really interesting thing about the design of a migdala is that you started the game with a whole load of money which doesn't fit with the theme whatsoever but you have all of this money and you're spending this money in order to do various things and then the first time you play the game you get like halfway through the game and you're like right so how do I get more money again where's where's the income phase or what do I need to do to get more money and you're like no you don't you're like oh right that money that you have at the start of the game that is your resource that you will spend over the course of the game and that's quite interesting as it as it goes but anyway I didn't really like a M and I think side quest was great Great Western Trail New Zealand and pyramido now pyramido I played once at Essen
2023 and it was a really good game this is just I remember playing it it was in the hotel on the Wednesday night I think Luke Hector taught me how to play it now people in the chat remind me pyramido is a better version of what I said it at the time and I can't remember now what it's a better version of but there is a game where you're taking tiles and placing them and pyramido does that but pyramido plays over three rounds and in round one you're placing the base of the pyramid and then in round two you're placing on top the next layer and in round three you're placing the third layer King Domino thank you Chrissy yeah I think pyramido is a better version of King Domino that's it you've got these um Domino style tiles where you're trying to match them up and yeah I really liked pyramido I have only played it once Great Western Trail New Zealand is in my opinion the best of the Great Western Trail games I absolutely love Great Western Trail New Zealand and I would only ever play base original game Great Western Trail with people who hadn't played a Great Western Trail game before because I personally feel the Great Western Trail New Zealand well I personally feel I think it is a more complex game since Great Western Trail is already quite a complex game yeah I think Great Western Trail New Zealand for people who are new to the Great Western Trail series is is
quite a lot but I do really love Great Western Trail New Zealand I'm I'm not going to be surprised if that's in my top five so it's going with that one right how are we through we 45 minutes into the stream and we're not very far through okay Marvel Age of Heroes and plant a nubo so here's a story about both of these games Marvel age of hero is still in my collection planton nubo is no longer in my collection but I'm going to go with planton nubo the reason why plon nubo is no longer in my collection is I have played it either four or five times and whilst I think it is a good game every time I went back to playing it the overhead of having to relearn it again and then teach other people it it wasn't quite worth it it a very good game I do enjoy the game and I I think it is a good game but I felt it was just a little bit too much on the complex side and saying that it sounds weird me saying that because I do play complex games but there were parts of the games that there was parts of the game that were a little fiddly there were Auto issues with the rule book and things like that ah so I've got my money's worth out of PL nubo even though I got given the copy for free and I think it is a good game but I made a decision that I wasn't going to play this again I have had my plays of it I am now done with this game and I gave it to a friend of mine who really liked the game so
plantan nubo I got it it's to 2023 game but that picture there is the Deva cover and I believe Deva are publishing it either this year or next year something like that so yeah the version I've got is from the original publisher game Builders now Marvel Age of Heroes so we're here again this is is a whiz kids game and this is a game which I think kind of flopped it's another one unfortunately from wi kids I mean they had re rebuilding Seattle that was amazing but Age of Heroes didn't quite hit the mark there's there's two reasons for this on the surface there is a lot to like about Marvel Age of Heroes in fact not just on the surface if you go deeper down into Marvel Age of Heroes there's a number of things about it that are quite cool and I'm friends with people who are huge Marvel fans I'm a huge Marvel fan as well and it's really interesting because some people felt there's no theme in this game whatsoever and there actually is if you look at the individual cards and the characters the abilities on those cards represent what that character is known for doing and that was quite a cool thing in the game but the two issues I had with the game is first of all it wasn't cooperative and Not only was it not cooperative there wasn't a Cooperative mode so it feels really weird that you are all playing Marvel characters and you're all part of the X-Men and you're all going
to the same X-Men training grounds and you're all doing this but it's a competitive game and that that didn't sit thematically it was a game about trying to get the most points and the other issue that I had with the game is ultimately when you Stripped Away the nice theme and the parts of the game which were quite cool it was a I'm going to send my workers to this place and I'm going to gain these abilities and I'm going to increase my stats like my strength and my intelligence or my power or whatever they were called and then to go and fight the bad guys I need to spend those resources and I'm like oh wait a minute this is a recipe game and I I personally this year I've started to get a little bit Jaded by game Euro games with tracks where you move up a track and you land on a space and there's an icon on that space and that icon tells you to do a certain thing for no reason whatsoever I'm getting a little bit jaded with them and also I'm getting a little bit Jaded by recipe games and yeah games where and a recipe game is a game where you do certain things in the game to gain certain resources and then you do other things in the game to spend those resources to do things that gets points and there's a lot of games that are like that and just I'm just getting a little it's not it's not interesting for me the fact that I go there and get three red cubes and I go there to get two yellow cubes and now
that I've got those three red and two yellow I go over here to beat up this bad guy and what does he need he needs three red cubes and two yellow cubes so I go there get the resources go there and spend the resources to beat them up and what does it get me eight points I I want more in a game than that these days so out of these two I'm going to give it to plantan ubo the reason why Marvel Age of Heroes is still in my collection is that I'm hoping that they do a Cooperative mode for it but I don't think the game was that popular and I don't think it's going to get any more but we'll see planto it is even fall or the Glade now uh full disclosure here the Glade designed by Richard Breeze I am good friends with Richard Breeze Rich me and Richard Breeze we've been friends for about 10 years uh I've covered a number of his games on the channel I have covered this one on the channel I do some professional work with Richard I help him with his rule books and I do playthroughs for some of his games but I didn't get on with the Glade at all the Glade is a game which definitely has a niche audience it is basically like rumikub but with some tweaks but it's not for me I played it I played it a few times and it was okay but it is it is definitely not the kind of game that I would want to play personally myself even fall I think was fantastic I really enjoyed evenfall and if you are a regular follower of mine and you follow my channel I picked up the expansion for even fall at Essen
2024 and I will be getting to cover evenfall on the channel probably February 2025 so evenfall has already been covered on the channel if you're interested in that but I will be covering it with the expansion in 2025 so yeah evenfall I think is a great game really really good game I didn't quite get on with the Glade earthborne Rangers or myth wind now I have I have lots of thoughts on both of these games let's talk about myth wind first I was super excited by myth wind and one of the things that open ow Studios who I have a professional working relationship with and I have done a sponsored playthrough of myth wind one thing that they are doing at open owl Studios is that they are breaking the mold on games myth wind definitely broke the mold on games uh they've got a story book game which was talked about in my live show that I did with Derek the other day that's also breaking the mold on games and there was so much about myth wind that I was super super excited about this is a game which is just a leisurely it's basically like a computer game but you are farming or you are going off hunting or you're you're doing whatever but this is a game you can just play Forever there's no big bad guy there's no enemy boss there's no you know the game you theoretically you could play forever because it is about you know if you're the farmer running your farm and everything else now you're probably not going to play it forever
what you're probably going to do is you're probably going to play one character for maybe three Seasons Four Seasons Five Seasons and then go all right okay I'm going to put that character to one side for now and now I'm going to play a different character and I'm going to see how that character plays and the concept of this game is really good and they've done a really good job with the production quality of the game and it looks really nice and you've got these storage tro there's so much about this game that was there was to like however we run into some issues with the game and I believe those issues are going to be fixed in the next print run and some of those issues really disappointed me I'm like you've done this big Kickstarter you've made loads of money you've spent so much time creating this game and printing this game and it's gone out there to people and there are issues with the game and they are they those issues are all being fixed in the next print run and I'm hearing this more and more and this is another thing that bothers me about the state of the industry is that lots of games are coming out on Kickstarter which have issues in the first printing and then it's taking a second printing to fix those issues and I'm not talking a rata here I'm not talking typos or a rata I'm talking fundamental issues with the game itself and I'm Keen to go back to myth wind but only once they've released the update pack for the reprint because some of the characters really
didn't work uh and some of the characters were a bit broken and yeah I want to go back to it so it's still in my collection earthborne Rangers if I was to do my top 10 biggest regrets of 20124 and yes I I mean 2024 my number one biggest regret of this whole entire year games related is that I didn't get time to play earthborne Rangers I have dabbled with earthborne Rangers a little bit I have just seen the tip of the iceberg with earthborne Rangers and I loved it and it actually I'm getting a little bit emotional because I'm disappointed in myself I loved that game so much and we've got to the end of the year and I've not covered it I have allowed myself to get swept up by so many other things that have been going on that I haven't gone back to earthborne Rangers and that's really disappointing me I think the game is incredible at what it was doing and I have only just scratched the surface with it it is a kind of it's an open world exploration game but there is also a story and I played through the tutorial
of that game probably four times with different people while I was learning how to play the rule book's not great the rule book was a struggle in fact I would go so far as saying the rule book was bad it was a bad rule book and a bad tutorial but the game once you get to grips with the game was incredible and I will never forget JP came around here one evening and we sat down and I went right screw the tutorial I've played it five times I want to play the campaign I want to actually start playing the campaign and seeing what this game has to offer and we started playing it and it was again I've only just played that starting session but it was like wow this is great and we went somewhere and we got this little side quest and I felt that I was immersed in this world I had this map we could go wherever we wanted I had little side quests going on the main apparently there's a main story the main story doesn't start until day three we didn't get that far but everything that I saw about this game just ticked all of my boxes and made me want to play it more and I didn't so there you go I hope you're enjoying these personal stories earthborne rang is by far the better game hybrid disordered Cosmos or undaunted Battle of Britain okay so two more games that I was professionally involved in undaunted Battle of Britain is from Osprey games it is one of the games in the undaunted series it was the game that came out in 2023 I have a very good relationship
with both David Thompson and Trevor Benjamin and Osprey games are one of my clients and I did a sponsored playthrough of this Paul snugs came over and we played a couple of scenarios of undaunted Battle of Britain h disordered Cosmos I have covered on the channel I did a a tutorial and playthrough video that wasn't sponsored but I did the rule book for hybis dis orbited Cosmos and its expansion so I have a professional involvement with that game not from a video point of view but from a rule book point of view back in the day when I used to do rule book writing hybris was one of the rule books that I did and it was one of the hardest games that I did the rule book for and I don't quite know why because the game isn't overly comp licated but there are parts of it which definitely feel a little fiddly and that makes it harder to write the rule book for because you've got to kind of yeah write it in such a way that you know it's fiddly you know this is going to be hard to explain but I'll I'll try and explain it both of these games are still in my collection hybris is a is a really interesting game and I and I have to say again full disclosure here in the two and a half years that I think I was working on the rule book for this game I got to know the designer of this game and we became personal friends and I have absolute respect for the amount of effort and time that he's put into this game because it's a phenomenal achievement and the the artwork for the game is stunning and the production quality of the game is absolutely
stunning and it was another Kickstarter where there was like okay and then there's going to be this expansion and this expansion and this expansion and I was like I was having this conversation with somebody this morning about unconscious mind and I'm like I think the base game of unconscious mind is enough for me and I've got all of these expansions I'm probably never going to get to play them I felt the same with hybris I once I'd played the finished version of the game of hybris I'm like that that's it for me I'm happy with this I don't want anymore I don't want any extra complexity and yet we've got all of these extra modules with all of this extra stuff it's a game I want to go back to again I'm uncertain about it there are parts of hybis disordered hybis disordered Cosmos which I think are a really good game there are some parts of it which I wasn't too keen on the biggest problem with the game and I remember speaking to them and I think they said they're going to fix this in the reprint is the iconography was way too small it literally needed to be double the size that it was I struggled with the game and this might just sound like it's it's cosmetic but all of these factors contribute to my enjoyment when playing a game and if I'm struggling to see the icons which means a player might make a mistake because it looked like one thing and it wasn't and a couple of the icons are confusing that is going to detract away from the enjoyment of the game so my enjoyment of the game comes from a a holistic thing it's the rule book being clear the graphic design
being clear not just the game itself I don't know how many people agree with that I'm going to give this one to undaunted Battle of Britain I think it is the better game hybis is a completely different game though right we're going to have to speed up H Market remastered or oros I've covered both of these on the channel I have a good working relationship with looky do games I also have a very good relationship with chip Theory games oros I played it a few times and I have covered it on the channel and I thought it was a good game but it is not the kind of game for me I thought it was a nice game in the way that you moved you Tred you basically moving land around and when you crash lands together it makes a mountain and if it's more than five then it makes a mountain with a volcano that bit was really nice but I struggle with games where I need to sort of visualize oh if I move that over there that's going to push that there the board kind of represents a 3D globe and you can move things around on the go so I think oros was a good game hler Marcus remastered I think is an amazing fantastic game now you might say hopess h Markus remastered should not be a 2023 game because it is an updated improved version of the original hopl Marcus I'm keeping it in here because I have never played the original hopl Marcus and I know that's just making my own rules but this is my stream nobody's here to tell me off apart from Colin Colin can tell me off but I'm I'm keeping it in there and out
of those two this is not even this is easy hler Market remastered Forest Shuffle and Pirates of maraio okay I'll try to speed up both of these games are good I prefer Pirates of maraio and if you're interested Pirates of maraio will be the first stream that I do in 2025 on Friday of this week I'm going to be covering Pirates of maraio with the expansion I've already covered the base game of it and I'm going to be covering it with the expansion that's happening this Friday if you are interested in that there will be a practice game in the afternoon if you're a patron supporter and the public stream will be in the evening Forest Shuffle is a very good game pirates of maraio is a very good game I prefer Pirates of marabo although I do enjoy Forest Shuffle it does have the same problem that a lot of these games have is were you lucky to get the right cards or were you not lucky to get the right cards oh I'm going to do a butterfly strategy and I happen to have drawn lots of cards which are butterflies great or I've managed to draw No butterflies whatsoever so Pirates of marabo doesn't have that I think it's the better game for me flip town or Vienna interesting so flip town I've I've covered both of these on the channel I've covered flip Town it was a sponsored playthrough video it's a nice little roll well it's not a roll and right game it's a flip and right game which uses uses a deck of cards you're trying to make poker hands and Vienna is one of the city collection games which I covered when it was on
Kickstarter but I haven't covered no I did I I did the how to playay video for Vienna I don't think I've done a playthrough or maybe I did maybe I did anyway Vienna is the reimplementation of Le Isa the older Stefan Feld game fully updated it's not just a rethe they've added a lot more to it out of these two I actually prefer Vienna I did enjoy flip town but I've got two comments on flip Town first of all there is a variant rule to use Texas Holden poker instead of Poker always always always use that rule because it's making poker hands is a part of the game and you're trying to making a poker hand of anything other than two that just a pair I found very very difficult to do with just the normal rules of the game with the Texas holdom rules which are in the rule book as a variant you are more likely to make a more interesting poker hand and therefore I think it it improves the game the second thing I want to say about flip toown is the iconography was too small it's really small and people that I've played it with have struggled because the iconography is so small but it's a nice game and if you like flip and right games that are quite light and quite quick then flip town is definitely for you for me Vienna is a good solid Euro game it's not my favorite game in the city of collection but it's a good game it's a balloon and books of time now this is really difficult to compare because it's a balloon is a a a silly fun party game
and books of time is a a Euro game and I have covered books of time again books of time is bord and dice I did a sponsored playthrough of this game and I have a very good relationship with bord and dice I didn't get on with books of time I will be absolutely honest with you I've played it three or four times and it has now left my collection I I I didn't get on with it there were parts of the game that I liked but there were other parts of the game that I didn't like I felt I felt the rule book was bad I think the rule book was a bad rule book and there were a number of issues that I had with the rule book that I struggled to get through but once I'd got through them and I was playing the game the game I think was advertised at like 60 to 75 minutes it was a two and a half hour game and I've spoken to them about this and they said well everybody we've play tested with this with has been no more than 90 minutes a game and every time I've spoken to somebody who's played the game it's been like two two and a half hours so yeah I didn't quite go on with books of time and it has now left my collection it's a balloon is a fun party game it's a bit silly and for the right moment at the right time potentially New Year's Eve after I've had a Shandi it's a balloon might might uh might get played so it's a balloon is still in my collection books of time is not in my collection however I'm going to give it to books of time surprisingly I know but I think
books of time is the better game than it's a balloon but it just of the type of game books of time is I have hundreds of better ones that's why it hasn't uh stady mation and Richard also is in the chat says yeah books of time was too long yeah it's not just me H Marcus victorium or the White Castle now the White Castle is another game which is in a lot of people's top 10 games I'm a huge fan of is r and Shay the designers of White Castle and I do enjoy White Castle I think White Castle is a good game I don't again controversy time I don't think it's as good a game as people say it is a lot of people Rave about this game I thought it was a good game and I enjoyed it but I don't Rave about it hop Marcus victorum I think is a phenomenal game absolutely phenomenal and if you want to see an entire full campaign playthrough of hop Mark victorum go to my channel back to July in July this year um I on my birthday I did a live stream where my the plan was I would play an entire campaign of hop Marcus victorum it is a solo game only but I didn't finish it that day and in fact it took me two more live streams to finish it it is an incredible game and I want to play it more so hop Marcus victorum nightmare Cathedral or Jin right I've got stuff to say about these nightmare Cathedral again bord and dice
I have a very good relationship with bord and Di and I did a sponsored playthrough video of this when it was on crowdfunding JY is from Hall games I have a good working relationship with the owner of Hall games uh and I think jyn is an underrated game if you haven't seen it I did a playthrough of Jin on the channel I will always always Harbor bad feelings about that playthrough because I got a rule wrong and I hate it hate it when I get a rule wrong in a playthrough video but if you if you are interested in Jin it's a it's a a super smart Little mediumweight Euro game but it works really well and there is a rule something about the secret passages that I think I got wrong in the video If you do watch it and you can't find what I got wrong please let me know and I'll I'll find out and tell you nightmare Cathedral this was a difficult one because and and again complete honesty here some of the games that I have done sponsored streams for I have thought that's a good game I've enjoyed that but then I've not enjoyed it enough to then keep the game or to play the game again nightmare Cathedral I actively did not enjoy the game at all and I'm hoping that didn't come out in the in the video because it was a sponsored video and out my job with those sponsored playthroughs is to help you make a a decision about whether
it's a kind of game for you by us playing it but I did not enjoy nightmare Cathedral at all there were just it it I just wasn't my kind of game at all but yeah so Jin is a really good game and I think it's underrated so definitely check out that one next up perspectives or distilled well we've spoken about perspectives distilled is a really good game and distill is is a recipe game but it's not a problem that it's a recipe game cuz it literally is a game where you are getting the ingredients in order to brew different um spirits and perspectives we've spoken about earlier on i' I've enjoyed my four or five plays of distilled I'm not sure how much legs it has and it's it's a shame because I have a really good relationship with the publisher and their next game ler is really good and L is going to be delivered at some point in 2025 and the thing is when ler gets delivered I'm going to have a copy of ler and I'm gonna have a copy of distilled distilled is never going to get played because L I think is's a much much better game um but so so distilled in perspectives if that was perspectives box two uh which is so much better than box one box one is good don't get me wrong box 2 is just so much better I'm not
sure about this which one did I feel is the better game oh I can't do this one I want to be able to skip I'm sure there was a skip option um oh have a cup of tea the problem is as well these are very different games for different audiences that's a Euro game that is much more replayable I'm gonna go distilled made a decision right Zu vardis or world wonders easy world wonders Zu vardis or Barcelona easy Barcelona void fall or I mean why is it comparing those two I don't know why it's comparing those two but we'll go with void fall we're still it early in the rankings once we get later on with this ranking system what's going to happen is that it's going to start comparing ones that I've really liked together against ones that I haven't liked together um whereas at the moment it's still just throwing random things in so 20 strong or Legends of Andor returnal throst I've enjoyed 20 strong the few times that I've played it it is a bit random but there's a lot of decision space in 20 strong and I really like it as a system mother of Frankenstein or evacuation again we're comparing Play Once puzzle games with a Euro game I'm going to go evacuation whether of Frankenstein versus Star Wars Deb building game I'm going to go mother of
Frankenstein I'm going to go Spellbook right Pioneer rails is a new one this is drund games again I have a good working relationship with drund games and Pioneer rails is a good game it's another card-based uh flip and right game but it's got to be nucleum nucleum is is the better of those two games Pioneer rails versus Sky ter hord now again if that was Sky tord monoliths because I think monoliths is a much more improved uh version of the game so Sky te horde or Pioneer rails uh I think Pioneer rails age of innovation or Halls of hegra that's definitely age of innovation uh Footprints versus Halls of hegra well see Footprints is a one to six player game and HS of hegra is just a solo game but I'm going to give it to H of pgra yeah definitely want to play H ofra more dice Manor or Footprints I think dice Manor I think dice manner is the better of those two games rebuilding Seattle or Earth now I'm going to lose some friends here because Earth as I've mentioned earlier on hugely popular game lots of people's number one game of the year and in most people's top 10 and rebuilding Seattle I don't think many people actually know about the game but I do enjoy Earth I do think it is a good game but I have a
couple of issues with Earth which make it uh not one of my favorite games in that it's another game where you can get lucky or unlucky you know if the objectives are to collect six koala bears I'm making it up here um and you manage to draw koala bears and the other player doesn't then you know when you've got a game where you've got every single card is unique and every card is made up of so many different categories and icons and then you get scoring conditions that are oh for the player who manages to get seven cards of an Al numbered value yes you're drawing a lot of cards unless you're choosing a lot of cards but still there is the huge deck of cards issue with some people will get more lucky and and not lucky um it it is one of those things with the game but it is a good game I just think rebuilding sh is a phenomenal game so definitely rebuilding SLE anunaki or Earth honestly which one of those two would I play and the other thing is you can play Earth on board game arena and it's much much much better on board game arena than it is in real life because nobody's going to misread an icon or misplay a card ah I I I think I might be the only content creator that would say anunaki is a better game than Earth if if I do go with this if I do
say that I don't know I really don't know Earth is a good game Earth is enjoyable to play that that's the thing I do have fun when I'm playing Earth and because I play asynchronously on on boardgame Arena it's not taking up my my time on I think the fact that I'm uming and aring about a hugely popular game that so many people have rated like the best game of the year and a game which half flopped and went under people's radar H I'm going to go an anaki sorry inside up games right the warp or bot Factory it's going to be bot Factory the warp or FTW is going to be FTW I'm afraid I did enjoy FTW a lot hermany or June Imperium Uprising now J this is the first time that June Imperium Uprising has appeared and I am a huge fan of June Imperium and I've only played a June Imperium Uprising once and it was the six player version of it but hemony is a fantastic game really really solid game for me my personal preference is going to June Imperium and I I know I'm probably losing as many friends as I'm gaining with this but heemy as as I've said before heemy is a fantastic
game I I struggle to play hermany um and I think Junior imperum for me is is a more enjoyable experience side quest Nemesis or kusco kusco is fantastic game this is one of my favorite games in the Stephan Feld TI excuse me Stephan City collection this is a reimplementation of Bora Bora um out of those two is going to be kusco as much as I like the side quest series of games kusco is really good really really enjoy kusco very very much a Stefan Feld point salid game but really enjoy it plant a newo or Great Western Trail New Zealand It's Great Western Trail New Zealand plantan nubo or pyramido is plantan nubo pyramido or Marvel age of hero pyramida was such a light simple game and I've only played it once but it's such a different game to Marvel Age of Heroes but I think it was really good and it worked earthborne Rangers or evenfall I'm going to give this one to earthborn Rangers but evenfall is a good game evenfall or mywind I'm going to give it to evenfall myth wind or the Glade I'm going to give it to myth wind both very greeny tree games undaunted Battle of Britain or Star Trek Discovery black alert okay so here we go again it's another game from Whiz Kids and it's
another one which I don't think quite worked I really wanted to like black alert and on the face of it I thought the game was going to work really well and after two or three games of it I felt the game didn't quite work properly there is a thing that can happen in the game which is the burn which can be caused if too many players do too much warping around or something like that and the chance of that happening just seemed to be really really high I can't remember I have live streamed this and there were parts of this game that I thought were interesting and there were parts of this game that I felt worked well but then every game always ended up seeing uh happening with like the burn and everybody loses and I wasn't too keen on that and undaunted Battle of Britain so we're going with undaunted Battle of Britain hybris or Star Trek Discovery blacker will alert I'm actually going to go with hybris on this one pirates of maraio or hopler Marcus remastered I'm actually going to give this one to Pirates of maraio as much as I love the Hop Marcus system hop Marcus remastered is effectively a a skirmish it's a combat it's a tactical combat game and I'm not normally a big fan of those games I do like them when chip Theory games do them because they do them extremely well but Pirates of marabo I think is a more me Style game so we're going with that one Forest Shuffle or hop Marcus
remastered oh that's an interesting one I think I'm going to go Forest Shuffle and I said this again I'm going to have to speed up because I've got 10 minutes left and I'm only a quarter of the way through not going to happen books of time or Vienna easy Vienna books of time or flip Town that's probably going to be flip Town cuz it's it's shorter and quicker Jin or hop Marcus victorum two good games one medium weight Euro game plays in about an hour and a half the other one solo game takes 12 hours to play but out of those two games I prefer hop Marcus Victor Jin or the White Castle right now this might surprise people and it's been a while since I've play Jin but I think Jin might be the better game I'm I'm not sure about this one not because I can't decide but I haven't played both games enough so I'm going to go with Jin well this is an easy one White Castle that was White Castle or nightmare Cathedral uh world wonders or distilled is world wonders Barcelona or distilled is Barcelona Zu vardis or distilled is distilled Zu vardis or perspectives is perspectives zaris or Septima Septima evacuation or void fall void fall evacuation or 20
strong now as I say I have enjoyed 20 strong and I think I'm going to give it to 20 strong because the core system is interesting and you currently have 20 strong solar Sentinels 20 strong hop Marcus Victoria and 20 strong too many bones I haven't played the too many bones one yet um yeah It's tricky because 20 strong does have the dice rolling and is a little random I'm not sure not sure need to speed up pull need to speed up what am I going to do what am I going to do I'm going to go 20 strong I wasn't sure about that one this one is evacuation or Legends of VOR and we're going with evacuation mother of Frankenstein or Legends of Andor I'm going to go with mother of Frankenstein if if you can hear a wailing in the background it's Thor it's not a baby um it is Thor Thor has just been shut in and every day when he gets shut in he walks around the house wailing for about an hour so just in case you hear wailing in the background it is one of our cats spell book or Legends of Andor Spellbook uh Star Wars deck building game or Legends of Andor honestly I prefer to play Star Wars deck building game age of innovation or nuclear right we're getting two two of the big hitters here I've already spoken about nuclear I've already spoken about age of innovation both of these games are a little bit outside of my um ability to be able to do
well because both of them are I can understand them from a rules complexity point of view I'm fine I can understand both of these games and I could teach you both of these games and I would understand them from a rules mechanical point of view I don't think I could play either of these games well enough to do well at but which is the better game I don't know I really don't know what do you think on the chat I'm I'm I'm going to go with my decision or pick randomly but what do you think age of innovation or nucleum it's so easy just to give it to nucleum because it is very very good but age of innovation is is a try both arrows at the same time yes good idea Kevin good idea um okay I'm going to give it some nuclear on the grounds that age of innovation is a development of Terror mystica and nucleum is a new game age of innovation or Pioneer rails that's age of innovation Halls of hegra or Pioneer
rails I'm going to give this one to Pioneer rails just HS of hegra or Sky te horde both playable solo um I think Sky te hord just because of the the the the curve of the game that I mentioned earlier on with Halls of pgra whereas I think from my plays of Sky te horde you're kind of in it all the way through the end even if it might look bad you can still turn it around bot Factory or rebuilding Seattle sorry V but it's going to be rebuilding Seattle uh bot Factory or anunaki that's G to be anunaki bot Factory or Earth bot Factory is actually good I've not played it for a while but it is a good game I think I'm going to go with B Factory with this one I tell you what Earth is probably going to end up quite low on my list which is ah it's going to upset Connor if he ever watches this video FTW or Earth I'm GNA go with Earth on this one FTW is a fun game but I think Earth is the better game choose tactics or FTW I'm going with FTW shoes tactics or the warp we're going with the warp and shoes tactics or Dungeons and Dragons Onslaught ah yeah so I can't remember shoe tactics that well I do remember the onslaught just didn't work for me so we'll go with hu tactics kusco or June Imperium Uprising well I love both of these games kusco for me is one of the Pinnacles of stefen feld's um Point salad style games and I
do really really enjoy it but I also enjoy June Imperium I think I'm going to give this one to kusco based on the fact that oh no hang on a minute I'm I'm gonna contradict my I'm gonna say based on the fact that Junior Imperium is a kind of reimplementation of Uprising is a reimplementation of junior kusco is a reimplementation of um Bora Bora if I had the choice right now which one would I play kusco right there you go June Imperium or side quest June Imperium hegemony or side quest hegemony Kora or side quest uh right which one did I enjoy the most I actually enjoyed side quest more than cahora because I'm a big fan of the of the puzzle games and Matthew is in the chat saying is kusco really different than Bora Bora uh I don't believe it is so maybe I should have removed this game right from the start but I kept it no I think kusco is is an almost direct copy of Bora Bor in fact I don't know what the differences are if there are any differences at all amigdala or cahora this is cahora earthborne Rangers or Great Western Trail New Zealand right we're getting to the painful part now so earthborne Rangers or Great Western Trail New Zealand I'm going to give it to Great Western Trail New Zealand because I think it's the more polished game although earthborne Rangers as I say I loved it was fantastic there was a lot
of rules queries with it and there was a lot of things that I needed clarification on whereas Great Western Trail New Zealand was a smoother experience earthborne Rangers or planton nubo is earthborne Rangers evenfall or planton nubo I've kept even fall I've got rid of plantan nubo so even fall myth wind or plantan nubo I'm going to give that to plantan nubo myth wind or pyramido I'm going to give that one to myth wind pyramido or the Glade I'm going to give that one to pyramido Marvel Age of Heroes or the Glade well as I say sorry Richard if you are watching this but the Glade wasn't my kind of game at all and an Marvel Age of Heroes although has issues yeah parat of maraio or undaunted Battle of Britain I'm going with pirates of maraio forest Shuffle or undaunted Battle of Britain I'm going with I think Forest Shuffle is probably more fun to play h Marcus remastered or undaunted Battle of Britain both combat games I mean h Marcus remastered you can play with teams uh you can also play it solo so I'm going to give this one to hop Marcus yeah I think it's the better game than undaunted Battle of Britain oros or undaunted Battle of Britain that's undaunted oros or hybris I'm going to give that one to hybris oros or Star Trek Discovery black alert I'm actually going to give this one to oros because although Star Trek
Discovery uh yeah I just felt there were or oros worked as a game it just didn't work for me because of the spatial puzzle whereas Star Trek Discovery I think had some issues with the game itself so we're going to give that one to oros hop Marcus victorum or Vienna right the these are both good games but it's going to hop Marcus victorum Vienna or Jin ah
I'm going to give it to JY Vienna or White Castle haven't we had this one before how good was Vienna Vienna has has no theme at all it's another one like kusco it's a normal Stephen Feld mediumweight Point solid with no theme whatsoever um I'm GNA give this one to Vienna I I think Vienna is the better game out of those two it's quite quite a bit heavier but I think I would prefer to play Vienna rather than White Castle I probably would play White Castle over flip town and Nightmare Cathedral against Flip toown Flip Town nightmare Cathedral against books of Time Books of time nightmare Cathedral against it's a balloon it's a balloon void fall versus world wonders right now these are both excellent games and if I actually I wouldn't be surprised if both of these games aren't in my top 10 but void fall for me is yes fantastic World Wonder wers or 20 strong it's going to be world wonders 20 strong or Barcelona it's going to be Barcelona 20 strong or distilled I'm going to give it to distilled and I do want to give a shout out to David Digby who designed the solo mode for distilled it's a really good solo mode 20 strong or perspectives 20 strong is interesting because it's a solo game it has Dice and I have live streamed it I've done a couple of live streams of it and it's quite tense and it's exciting perspectives I haven't live streamed it
because it's a game that me and Vicki play tested together and I think perspectives is a game I enjoyed more 20 strong or Septima oh I really need to play Septima um since getting the final version of the game I'm not sure on this one what do you think what do you think in the chat 20 strong or septim as I say that the General consensus on September is that it hasn't been received that well I think a lot of people have been a bit May over the game now that it's come out I'm going to give it to 20 trun Septima or evacuation well based on what I said about evacuation earlier this is I can't make this decision because I haven't really played Septima whereas I have played enough of evacuation I can evaluate evacuation in my mind I can't evaluate evacuation compared to September so I don't know on this one I'm I'm just G to have to give it to something randomly and I'm going to give it to Septima evacuation or zuvis I'm giving that to evacuation mother of Frankenstein or zuis I'm giving that to Mother of Frankenstein Spellbook or zuvis is going to Spellbook Star Wars deck building game or zuvis I I I would enjoy playing Star Wars de building game more Legends of Andor or
zardes ah I mean zuvis is is okay it's a half hour game it does have negotiation between the players which is something I'm not a big fan of but I enjoy the game and the fact that it's 20 30 minutes the the the fact that it's negotiation um doesn't bother me as much as it would in other games Legends of Andor didn't give a proper go I played the tutorial I was disappointed and I decided to keep my original versions and move that one on so I don't know I don't know with this one I'm going to go zubis uh dungeons dragons Trials of Tempest I've spoken about this I am keeping that game because I am hopeful that there are fixes to make that game better so I'm going to go with Legends of Andor which does actually work now this one I've got two games which in my opinion just do not work I'm going to go with Char of Tempest because I felt there's potential there whereas archaeologic was just a big Miss rebuilding Seattle or nucleum it's given me two really really good games again and I tell you what I am going to give that to rebuilding Seattle I actually think nucleum is probably the better game no wait a minute o i mean i I'd go with rebuilding Seattle because it depends what we're doing here are we going with games that I would prefer to play or are we going with games which I
feel are better games nucleum is probably a better game than rebuilding Seattle I'm going to go reeling Seattle because I would prefer to play that than nucleum I really do like the game this one however I think as much as I want to play anunaki more I think we're going to go nucleon with this one anunaki or age of
innovation oh I'm going to go age of innovation anunaki or Pioneer rails I'm G to go I'm G to go anunaki bot Factory or Pioneer rails I'm going bot Factory we're over halfway through I pretty much have five o00 if I'm not done by 5:00 I am going to be in a lot of trouble well maybe 5:30 I'm still going to be in a lot of trouble Earth or Pioneer rails I'm going to give this one to Earth I think yes FTW or Pioneer rails I'm gonna give this one to I'm I'm gonna give this one to Pioneer rails Sky te hord or FTW I'm G to give it to Sky te horde Sky te Sky tier who knows Halls of hegra or FTW don't get me wrong FTW is a great game it's a little fun game that plays really quickly and it's really ever um I want to give HS of hegra another go so dice Mana or FTW is Dice Manor FTW or Footprints honestly I'd probably prefer to play FTW the graphic design of footprints and I know I've mentioned this before uh the warp or Footprints I'll go with the warp choose tactics or Footprints I I can't remember shoe tactics well enough I'm going to go footprints on this one there is a a good game in there he just needed better graphic design Great Western Trail New Zealand or kzco I'm going to go Great
Western Trail New Zealand it is the heavier game and I love both of these games I think both of these game games are going to end up in my top 10 but that's great West tril New Zealand kusco or earthborne Rangers now I'm going to go earthborne rangers even for or kzco k even fall or June Imperium Uprising June Imperium Uprising even fall or hegemony as I said which one would I prefer to play I would actually get more enjoyment out of playing even for because it's shorter it's uh less prone to other players playing by the wrong rules and you're not realizing it it's a bit of an issue that I have with asymmetric games is that I have played too many asymmetric games where it turns out one of the players was playing by the wrong rules and nobody spotted it because they've got their own rules and in some cases that player was me and that kind of spoiled the game for everybody so I think asymmetric games especially ones that are heavily asymmetric have a fragility to them which people don't talk about when they're talking about the game but I find it can be a bit of a problem so out of these two my my I would have a better time playing even fall because I know we'd all be playing by the same
rules we'd all be playing by the right rules and the overhead the mental overhead would be less I think hermany is a is a is an amazing game though plantan ubo or hegemony based on what I've just said about fiddly complex games I'm I'm going to give this one to us Germany plant ano or side quest nemesis
I think I had a better time playing side quest than plantan nubo because of the complexity it's nice to see even fall getting some uh getting some love in the chat and if you haven't tried even fall definitely check it out kunora or plantan nuo ah um yeah I think I enjoyed planter nubo more I think think but it's it's been a I'm not sure I'm not sure about this actually no I'm going to lean to cahor on this one right plantan nuo or amigdala that's plantan nuo myth wind or amigdala uh that's myth wind pyramido or amigdala that's pyramido Marvel Age of Heroes or amigdala Marvel Age of Heroes this is now this is now filtering out the bottom of the list because um I've got a migdala and and the glaz and and neither of these games I enjoyed neither of these games are games that I would choose to play but out of the two of them I would probably play the Glade more than a mdala hler Marcus now we're back to the top of the list hopler Marcus victorum or Pirates of maraio ah hop Marcus victorum has a very special place for me not because I played it on my birthday but there is something about the feel of the game and the amount of I I love the chip Theory games philosophy and the way that they
design games is that they throw in so much passion and so much thought and so much effort into their games parrat of maraio is a fantastic game but I'm giving this one to HBL Marcus Jinn or parrots of maraio well I haven't played parrots of maraio with the commander expansion yet but this is the base game um we're going to give this one I think to Pirates of marabo Jin or Forest chuffle um I I do have fond memories of Jin but it keeps asking me to try and remember it and I can't uh I think I'd prefer to play Jin and I think Jinn is one of those games again which not a lot of people know about Vienna or Forest Shuffle I'm going to go with for Shuffle Vienna or hopark is remastered I'm going to go Vienna White Castle or hopl Marcus remastered a probably White Castle uh flip town or hopl Marcus remastered hopl Marcus flip town or undaunted Battle of Britain we'll go with undaunted flip town or hybris I'm going to go I'm going to go hybris New Year's resolution play hybris again other New Year's resolution play Halls of hegra again oros or flip town I'm going to go flip town oros or books of time I'm going to go books of time oros or it's a balloon I'm
going to go it's a balloon nightmare Cathedral or oros I'm going to go oros uh nightmare Cathedral or Star Trek Discovery black alert I'm going to go Star Trek Discovery right we're back to the top of the list again void fall or rebuilding Seattle two of my favorite games from 2023 both great games but void B wins world wonders or rebuilding Seattle it's going to be world wonders it is the better game rebuilding satle or
Barcelona ah I'm gonna go Barcelona rebuilding SLE or distilled we're going to go rebuilding Seattle nucleum or distilled we're going to go nucleum age of innovation or distilled we're going to go with age of innovation anunaki or distilled I'm G to go see I also can't forgive Crono for the rule books for this game not being great I mean in this day and age with the amount of people who can do rule books and the amount of English native English speaking editors there were parts of the anunaki rule book and parts of the well the expansion Rule books which were awful really really awful and again in my in my sort of thing of holistically treating these games as a whole did that affect my experience of the game yes it did because if I'm struggling to learn a game from the rule book it's going to impact on my
enjoyment this is a tricky one because I don't like distill as much as a lot of other people do I think it's a good game I'm just not sure how much depth there is to distill once you've played it a few times and then you have that bit where there's the randomness which can completely screw you over I'm going to go anunaki bot Factory or distilled I'm going to go bot Factory bot Factory is a good game Earth or distilled I'm going to go Earth Pioneer rails are distilled I'm going to go pioner this is a good system this because it's it it's really interesting because you get oh this is obvious this is less obvious this is oh and then oh and because it knows it knows these games are now in the middle middle of my thing which one's going to win which one Pioneer rails or distilled do I want to upset Aiden or do I want to upset Dave this is the
question I'm going to go Pioneer rails with this one sorry Dave Sky te hord or distilled right again if that was Sky hord monoliths it would be higher but I'm going to go distilled sky hord or perspectives perspectives Sky hard or 20 strong 20 strong but it would be the other way round if it was monoliths sky hord or Septima uh again you're making me make a decision I can't make because I've not really played September since it came out so I'm going to go with September on this one evacuation or Sky aord I'll go with evacuation I'm G to go with mother of Frankenstein I'm G to go with Spellbook I'm going to go with Star Wars the deck building game but sky tord or zuvis I'm G to go Sky tord Halls of hegra or zuis I'm go Halls of hegra dice Manor or zuis I'll go D um ah I'm actually going to go zuvis on this one dice Mana all legends of VOR I'm going to go dice Manor FTW or Legends of VOR I'll go FTW the warp yeah we'll go with the warp Footprints or Legends of VOR I'm going to go Footprints shoes tactics or Legends of VOR I can't remember shoes tactics that well it was good though we'll go with that one D and D Onslaught or Legends of Andor I'm going to go Legends of Andor
right here we go so I've spoken about these games before these are both from wids kids they're both Dungeons and Dragons themed games and I felt they both had some issues however the issues I had with Onslaught were not that the game didn't work it's just there were parts of it that didn't quite work as well for me whereas Trials of tempus I actually think does not work as a game so Onslaught wins that one right hler Marcus victorium or Great Western Trail New Zealand a you're doing it to me you're doing it to me
right I don't know it's painful why did I agree to do this stream why should why didn't I just sit downstairs and read a book instead that would have been much more relaxing um I'm going to go Great Western Trail New Zealand although I have so much love for hop Marcus victorum Great West New Zealand is great and it's got a great solo mode as well earthborne Rangers or hopler Markus victorum now this is a difficult one this is a really difficult one one is a solo 12-h hour campaign game oh dear th sounds like he's in pain um earthborne Rangers as I've talked about fantastic game campaign driven card play System dodgy rule book and lots of rules queries on some of the cards
but I'm going to go earthborne Rangers kusco or hopl Marcus victorum again both great games I'm going to go hopo kzco all Pirates of maraio ah I'm G to go kusco I think I prefer kusco to Pirates of maraio June Imperium Uprising or Pirates of maraio I'm going to go June Imperium even fall or Pirates of marivo now these These are both um published sort of by DLP games Pirates of maraio is actually games up but through DLP games even fall is nanox through DLP games so DLP games are the main publisher for both of these but they're just sort of the redistributor out of these two games which do I prefer they're both a similar complexity level I think I enjoy both of them about the same and I haven't played either of them with the new expansion
chip I'm G to go pirates of my carbo even full or Jun I'm going to go even full just to balance things up a bit Jin or hegemony that's going to be hegemony uh Jin or side quest probably going to be Jin Forest Shuffle or side quest probably Forest Shuffle I think as I get tired my decision- making process starts to fall apart 10 minute warning I know I'm not going to get done by five if somebody can uh send an apology to Vicky for me um I'm going to be a bit later so Vienna or side quest Nemesis side quest Nemesis keep keeps popping up um cuz it's in the middle that's the thing Vienna or side quest Nemesis G puzzles were really good but I'm going to go Vienna uh White Castle hop Marcus remastered or side yeah H Marcus remastered undaunted Battle of Britain or side quest undaunted hybris or side quest I'm going to go side quest hybris versus Kora we're going to go cahora hbis versus planton nuo plantan nubo hybris versus myth wind if this was the reprint of myth wind that had all of the issues fixed it would be a different situation but myth wind at the moment I'm not going to say unplayable but I don't want to play it
until the fixes have come out even though they might only be minor fixes I'm going to go hybis with this one uh flip town or myth wind I think I'm going to give it to flip Town books of time or myth wind we'll give it to myth wind books of time or pyramido I'm going to give it to pyramido books of time or Marvel Age of Heroes I'm GNA go Marvel Age of Heroes I had less issues with that than I did with that one books of time or the Glade I'm going to give that one to books of time I did actually enjoy that more than I did the Glade but again that's just cuz the Glade is not my kind of game at all uh so this is going to go to it a balloon definitely I hope I'm picking the right one I hope I'm picking the one to stay rather than the one that goes otherwise the entire list is going to be back to front oros or the Glade I'm going to get rid of um H sorry I'm going to choose oros the glador Star Trek Discovery and we're going to go Star Trek Discovery right here we go two games that I did not enjoy at at all I I did not enjoy either of these games I just want to remove both of these games from the ranking system I could I could just press the trash button on both of them
um I liked the action selection mechanism in Nightmare Cathedral it was the only thing that I did like so we'll go with that one oh I've just clicked I clicked the wrong button didn't I I clicked the one to get rid of there the one I'm keeping right we we're in the top again Great Western Trail New Zealand or void Fall Again these are top two or three games for me of the year it's got to be void ball it has to be void void ball is always the answer right this is an interesting one because these games are very different world wonders is a what is it like a 45 minute game or a 1 hour game that's just really nice really accessible Simple Rules really clever and Great Western 12 New Zealand is a three-hour heavy Euro which of those would I prefer to play the most both of them at the same time I have two hands and two eyes um Great West and Trail New Zealand I'm angling towards the heavier side of games Great Western Trail earthborne Rangers or world wonders but F Rangers is going to give me such an experience when I do event get to play it hler Marcus Victoria Mo world wonders ah hppo kzco or world wonders ah probably kzco June Imperium or world wonders un
Imperium again world wonders is losing out here because of my tendency to go for slightly heavier games but world wonders is a fantastic game pirates of maraio or world wonders actually h honestly world wonders Pirates of marabo or Barcelona Barcelona Pirates of marabo or rebuilding Seattle rebuilding Seattle Pirates of marabo or
nucleum again this is the whole which one would I prefer to play well I'd prefer to play Pirates of maraio even though I know nucleum is the better game but I'd prefer to play Pirates of mar Kaiba because there is less brain intensity for me to
do oh yeah I'm I'm I'm struggling here because I know nucleum is the better game I'm trying to I'm trying it's been a while since I played Pirates of mar IO I do remember enjoying it it's my list I know okay we're going to go pirates of Maro oh David tury's just unfriended me oh no right even for or nucleum again again I'm going to go even fall I'm going to lose so many friends over this right here we go hegemony or nucleum both games which I've said are fantastic games I respect both of these games they are both amazing games but I won't ever be able to play either of these games properly hegemony because of the of the overweight um the over the burden of of of an asymmetric game and the worry that people are playing it wrong and stuff like that and nucleum just because I'm not good at it out of the two I'm going with nucleum nucleum is my choice hegemony or age of innovation age of innovation hegemony or anunaki I'm actually going to go with hegemony on this one Jin or anunaki I'm G to go Jin Forest Shuffle or anunaki I'll go Forest Shuffle Vienna or
anunaki I do have fond memories of Vienna but I also have fond memor memories of anunaki I'm going to go vieta White Castle or anunaki I'm gonna go White Castle uh hop Marcus remastered or anunaki I'm going to go I'm going to go anunaki with that one uh hopler Marcus remastered or bot Factory I think I'm going to go bot Factory I actually think hler Marcus remed is going to be quite low on this list but it is an exceptionally good game it is a really good game if you like chip Theory game style Skirmish combat games Earth or hop Marcus remastered now
out of these two again Earth might end up dropping out of my top 10 which is shocking I'm going to go hop Lamarcus remastered Earth or undaunted Battle of Britain um I'm going to say undaunted Earth or side quest Nemesis I'm going to go earth side quest or pioneer rails I'm going to go my my middle is going to be all yeah uh side quest or distilled I'll go side quest Kora or distilled I'll go distilled I'm less bothered about what's in the middle of the list because at the end of today we're going to have a top 10 uh cahora or perspectives perspectives cahora or 20 strong I got more excitement out of 20 strong so 20 strong Kora or Septima I'm going to give this one to cahora just because as say I can't really evaluate Septima at the moment I'm going to give this one to planton nubo I'm going to give uh hybis over Septima oh dear this is a tricky one I I can't this is one I can't do so we're going to go hybris flip town or septamer we'll go flip Town myth wind or septamer
I think I'm going to go septim evacuation or myth wind I'm going to go evacuation mywind or mother of Frankenstein going with mother of Frankenstein going with Spellbook going with Star Wars the de building game going with Sky te horde going with Halls of pgra myth wind or Zu Aris actually probably myth win pyramido or zuvis I don't own either of these games let's go pyramido uh Marvel Age of Heroes or zuvis let's go Marvel books of time or zuvis we're getting we're get bottom of the list again so I'm I'm just I'm just going to do these quickly because this is kind of near the bottom of the list and I'm and I'm less bothered about this one uh the one that disappears is the one that's staying and I'm and I'm doing this to try and speed up yeah yep uh yeah and Y and ah both games that I felt didn't work but that one worked less badly right these These are I'm pretty sure these two are the bottom two games on my list list um or maybe not uh yeah okay there we go we are done
it is 5 o'cl we are finished thank you very much for watching I'll see you next year no we we need to do the top 10 so here is the list and yeah they as I said I mentioned at the start Pub meeple it's a free system you can use it but they do take donations and I will be donating to them either today or in the new year so thank you very much to the pub meele team for doing this and let's start at the bottom so number 59 archaeologic well let let's just skip these bottom 10 because or even the bottom 20 the ones that are surprising me games games starting at the bottom that I would uh I would like to play again so no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no the warp I might give one other go FTW is a game I would definitely play again quick fun little card game dice Manor I would play again zuvis I would play again it's a balloon I would play again because it's a fun party game books of time I'm surprised that's there because I would actually go out of my way not to play that game again uh Age of Heroes I'm waiting on a tweak to that one pyramido I'd play again myth wind waiting for the second printing yeah then we have got the middle of the range so plantan nubo again I I evaluated it fairly but I I move that one on let's go to the top 10 okay so number 10 in Paul's top 10 games of all time and
the surprising ones so games which I would have absolutely guaranteed would have been in my top 10 games of the year if I'd have done this as a video myself and not as the P me ranking system nucleum nucleum would have been absolutely in my top 10 game of 2023 oddly it's not come out that way but it would be I think hermany I think hermany would probably be if I was to have taken all of these games and sat down and worked it out myself probably in my top five of 2023 I have that much respect for the game even though personally I might never play it again I've played it enough and I've experienced it World Order which is their new one that they've got coming out next year that's the one for me which is going to be the one that I play of their so hegemony and nucleum I feel bad that they are not in my top 10 so let's look at my actual top 10 Pirates of marabo it is a very good game and as I mentioned I am doing a live stream this Friday of Pirates of marabo with the expansion rebuilding Seattle number nine I'm glad that rebuilding Seattle is in my top 10 games of the year because I would have put it in there I think it is welld deserving I think rebuilding Seattle is a great game and uh yeah I I
think it's really really good Barcelona number eight doesn't surprise me Barcelona is a really good game and out of all of the games that bord and dice did last year I would have thought Barcelona would be in my top 10 I would have assumed nucleum would have been higher um um oh yeah let's just talk about Earth there you go Earth 23 do I feel bad about that yeah a little bit but I've played Earth a lot and I think the more and more I've played it although I enjoy the game and it's gorgeous production and they've done a fantastic job with the game I still find it a bit just random and what cards you get and things like that but yeah I I don't know as I said I feel a little like an outcast compared to so many other content creators that have rated Earth their number one game of the year and I've got it down as 23 sorry anyway where were we uh Barcelona at number eight yeah world wonders at number seven so that doesn't surprise me it surprises me a little bit that it's that it's that high but yeah world wonderers is a very very good game I really enjoy world wonders June Imperium Uprising yeah I had to give that um that's the only questionable one because I have only actually played June Imperium Uprising once and that was the six player version
but because I enjoy the junor Imperium system and I know quite a lot about junor Imperium Uprising I think it is a better game and therefore it's an improvement on something that I already find useful so that's the only one that I uh should it have been in there or not not sure now kusco that's a little bit of a surprise that it's that high I think the game is really good but would I have put kusco above world wonders would I have put it above Barcelona maybe I did um yeah kusco is a is a is a really good game I really enjoy that and interestingly enough I only played the original version of kusco which was Bora Bora once and I didn't enjoy it I obviously was not in the right frame of mind at the time because kusco is almost a direct conversion of Bora Bora and I really enjoy kusco hler Marcus victorum there's no surprise to me that that is in my top five earthborne Rangers that is a little bit of a surprise that it's that high up but I cannot underestimate the hugely positive feelings that I had after I played that game with JP where we started the campaign and that isn't on the public Channel I don't think it's on the public Channel if you are a patron supporter of mine it was a video that I did about a year ago maybe it was JP's aftershave
maybe he was wearing something that affected my emotions probably but I got such a good vibe out of it and I I have to make another New Year's resolution is that I need to get back to earthborne Rangers whether I play it Solo or not probably don't want to play it solo I probably want to play it with somebody else but I definitely need to play more earthborne Rangers Great Western Trail New Zealand we I have no no problem with that being second if that that that that was definitely going to be in my top 10 I I am surprised earthborne ranges is actually that high but all this top 10's all fluid it is all fluid but there is absolutely no surprise that void fall is my number one game of 20 23 and spoilers I'd already said void fall was my top 10 my my number one game of 2023 at the end of 2023 um and and that and that hasn't changed I think void fall is a masterpiece of a game yes it's complex yes setup takes you an hour but oh boy void fall has been an incredible gaming experience for me both solo multiplayer I haven't actually played the co-op version of it yet I have played the solo version which is very similar to the co-op version but void fall is a game which is just incredible and I I I I love it so there we go that is it now just before we wrap up my last live stream of the year I wanted to say a huge thank
you to all of my Patron supporters um this video has not been sponsored in any way neither was the three-hour live stream that I did a few de a few years ago few days ago with Derek so these videos have been created due to the support of my patreon campaign all of my ad Revenue goes to charity if you're watching this video and you think oh but Paul's going to make loads of money out of all of the ads for this video this video will probably get a lot of views um because top 10 videos tend to but all of my ad Revenue goes to charity every single penny of it and I normally give away about between 400 500 each month to charity that is how much money I make from advertising revenue on YouTube so and I if you think I'm crazy lots of people have said to me that I'm crazy for doing that and I should keep the money for myself and buy something nice I I don't want to um my Patron supporters fund my channel the the support that I get from them financially is is good and therefore I am able to give away all of that ad revenue for charity so that makes me feel good me feel good hopefully it makes you feel good if you are watching this video your view has raised a tiny tiny amount of money but all of those views added up together will contribute to yeah giving hundreds of pounds to a charity we haven't decided where what the charity is yet for December um but I will be announcing it in my next monthly video look so that is everything a huge thank you to everybody who's been watching today and yeah a big thank you to everybody who's watching afterwards let me know in the comments of the video which of these games which decision um
you you most disagreed with and also let me know which one you most agree with um but also I've enjoyed doing today it's been painful at times really painful getting into to make decisions I'm surprised by the results the P meeple system is good it's not perfect would it be different if I sat down and did it myself very probably but it's it's roughly right I think and I also hope that you've enjoyed the general chat today because these videos are an opportunity for me to share my true honest thoughts about games and let's not forget I have slated some games today and I have said that these games are not good games and these games are flawed and these games did not work for me at all and some of the games that I've spoken about today are from Publishers who are people who um uh clients of mine people who pay me I have a job thanks to these people and if they're watching this video they might be a little upset but I'm being honest I I take this opportunity to be honest with you and tell you my honest feelings on these games and other people might like these games I mean some some of these games down at the bottom of the list some people might absolutely love these games and that's fine they just they just didn't work for me we'll do the same next year but maybe I won't leave it as long as December 31st next year because to be honest I could have done this list in the summer so maybe that's what I'll
do maybe for my birthday next year now next year my birthday will be on a let me just look it up it's July 3rd for those people that want to get me a package after it's a Thursday so yeah let's let's let's do it let's do my birthday next year is I will do this book for 2024 it's a date set your reminders 8:00 in the evening Thursday the 3rd of July oh no I can't it's the games Club in the afternoon so 2 pm on Thursday the 3 of July 2025 I will be doing my top 10 games of 2024 but yes for now we're all done thank you for watching and I will see some of you on Friday for Pirates of marabo have a good New Year everybody take care