My Top 50 Games OF ALL TIME! | #10-1
Transcript
hi everyone welcome back to the channel i've been to gen con and back and i played a lot of really great games but i think it's safe to say that hasn't changed my top 10 games of all time and i know that's what you're all looking for so let's not waste any time so if you want to know what my top 10 games of all time are then might i suggest hi i'm alex from midas suggested game a channel devoted to helping you find your perfect board game now i know i said i was going to get straight into my top 10 games of all time but don't forget there's a giveaway involved so without further ado ladies and gentlemen the comment picker
congratulations to krista unlen for winning your brand new copy of takaido when you see this send me an email at my suggested mindysuggestedgame gmail.com so i can get your info and get you your game asap and for all you viewers that aren't christa onland don't worry there's still one more chance to get an awesome game after i go through my top 10 games i'm going to open up one last giveaway at the end of this video and i don't want to give away any spoilers but it's one of my favorites oh brother this guy stinks anyways if you want to enter that giveaway all you have to do is comment a wine glass emoji on this video and if you want one more bonus entry all you gotta do is suggest a game that you think i would like based on the games that i talked about it's really pretty simple so what do you have to lose anyways i'm blabbering on again let's get right into it will one of my top 10 games of all time be the perfect game for you let's find out shall we all right starting off strong number 10 on my top 10 games of all time list is the crew the crew the quest for planet nine and also the follow-up the crew mission deep sea are two of my most played games of all time and for a good reason first off they're super easy to get to the table the crew uses a really simple trick taking mechanic plus it's all cooperative so if you're from the midwest like me and grew up on games like euchre and hearts this one's a no-brainer both my family and my in-laws love this game and we've gone deep into the night playing this one the second reason why it gets to the table so much is because it kind of has this ongoing
campaign mechanic as you go along they have missions in a log book that increase the difficulty of the game not only does this give you a sense of accomplishment when you complete a level and make you feel like you've really progressed since the beginning but it also eggs you on so that you're always saying oh maybe just like one hand more and i love that in the game the crew is one of those games where if you have a table of committed folks you could really play all night long and not get tired i also will say that i appreciate the improvements that they made in the second version which make the game a little bit more accessible even though it's definitely not easier which i feel like is pretty hard to do i really just love everything about this game and the only reason why i might not get it to the table is if someone was a little bit against trick taking but once you understand the trick taking mechanic the crew is simple it's easy to teach it's easy to learn and it is a blast to play i've talked about the crew multiple times on my channel including the list of top games that are under 20 so if you see this one on the shelf at a target or your local game store and you haven't played it before i'd snatch it up right away give me that what give me that so if you're looking for a cooperative trick-taking card game that emphasizes teamwork and uses missions to increase your difficulty but also increase your satisfaction as the missions get harder then might i suggest the crew the next one on my list number nine is awkward guests now here's a little spoiler alert this one is the first in a bit of a run of deduction games i love deduction games and i think the
mechanics of awkward guests really make it stand out in a pile of deduction games that i really love now i will say one thing the art in this game does not make it stand out awkward guess is a very drab beige brown and gray color scheme and that really kept me from checking it out for a really long time but once i did check it out i was so glad that i did because i think the mechanics that they use in the game using what they call the brilliant deck system is some of the best game design that i've ever experienced luckily i backed and recently received a copy of megacorp and game's new project called scandalo which uses that brilliant deck system in awkward guests but simplifies it a bit and adds a lot of colors to it so you don't have to worry about having that drab box on your shelf either way though awkward guess did it first and i think it did it super well so what makes this game so good well first of all i think that awkward guess is what clue wishes it could be clue or cluedo is a household staple but i think the deduction element leaves a little bit to be desired but an awkward guess when you get the perfect piece of information to help you make a leap of deduction ah it just feels so good when i play awkward guess i really feel like i'm in the investigation and i get super invested in figuring out the answer the other thing i like about awkward guess is that there is a little bit of strategy to how you give out information now in the game you'll have these clue cards that you'll be trading to other players to barter for more information but there's some clue cards that are so good that you really don't want anyone to get their hands on because of this you have to be really clever about what information you're willing to trade and what information you'll discard at the end of the round if you don't give out any of your information you won't get any back
and you won't be any closer to finding the killer so it's a very delicate back and forth of giving information receiving new information and hopefully being able to make leaps of deduction that'll ultimately lead you to the killer every time i play this i start the game being completely clueless it all boiled down to one inevitable conclusion i was just totally clueless the first couple rounds i feel like i'm just shooting in the dark but then you'll get that killer clue that links a bunch of information and you'll be one step away from finding the killer and you just hope that you're the first one to get it even when i don't win this game i still really enjoy it though because for me i think it's all about the thrill of the chase the excitement of finding that perfect clue the disappointment of getting information that you've already received and the exhilaration of finding the correct solution just make this game so fun even though it's a little bit of an older title if you ever see it around you should definitely check it out because despite its drab appearance the gameplay itself is shall i say brilliant so if you're looking for a strategic and pure deduction game that promises to be what clue wishes it was then might i suggest awkward guests all right number eight on my list of top games of all time is so clover now despite the somewhat cheesy theme so clover is definitively my favorite party game of all time and in some ways you could consider it a deduction game so it keeps the streak alive anyway so clover is an amazing hidden word party game for three to six players that every time i
play it ends in hysterical laughter one way or another the concept of the game is simple everyone is going to start with this funny clover-shaped board and on that board they're gonna put these square clue cards that have clues all along the edges now when you place them on the four spots on your clover board you'll notice that there are two words on each edge of the board now your goal is to write one word that connects those two words in some way so that when you take the clue cards off add an extra one in and shuffle it together your teammates will be able to identify which two words go where on your board the concept is super simple but coming up with the words is harder than you think and it certainly leads to some ridiculous answers honestly some of the best clues are given when your brain completely shuts off and you can't think of anything and you just throw a random word in there hoping that someone will get it then when your teammates eventually guess it correctly you've got a built-in inside joke i love inside jokes love to be a part of one someday the nice part about this one as well is that the gameplay is completely cooperative so everyone's working together to try to guess the words on each clover i love that because sometimes these party games split each other into teams and things can get a little contentious but in so clover the stakes are low and if you give a ridiculous clue for one of them it's gonna end in laughs instead of anger and to me that's the sign of a great game so clover is one that i'm always recommending to my friend group and if anyone ever asked to borrow some games for a cabin trip or for a weekend away so clover is number one on the list of games that i give to them it really is just a blast and i think it encapsulates
everything i want a party game to be it's super fun it is hilarious it has the potential to get a little rowdy and after a good round you'll have things to talk about for weeks there are so many different iterations of this hidden word party game but so clover to me rises all the way to the top so if you're looking for a great party game to spice up your next game night and you want to have inside jokes with your friends for years to come then might i suggest soak clover all right lucky number seven on my list of top games of all time is mind management now the subtitle for mind management is the psychic espionage game in quotation marks and if that sounds mysterious it's because it is mind management is one of the most unique games that i've ever played if you've watched any of my videos before then you'll know that i'm kind of a sucker for games that bring out new mechanics or are unlike any games that i've seen before and mind management definitely lives up to this building mind management at its core is a hidden movement deduction game where one player is playing against up to four other players and notice how i said deduction game there that makes three in a row anyways in the game itself one player is behind the screen playing as the mind management agent scouring the map for recruits meanwhile the other players will play as rogue agents trying to track down the recruiter and expose them before they complete their objective now this is easier said than done the recruiter has some special abilities and they also move in silence
like lasagna so it takes some great teamwork and some savvy deduction skills to try to narrow down where the recruiter might be this game is super close and exciting the whole way through no matter which side of the screen you're on and to me that makes a great game in my place of mind management the game has been decided more often than not on the last turn where rogue agents are making last-ditch efforts to try to figure out where the recruiter is and the recruiter is desperately trying to evade them or keep a straight face if they know they're right on them it is just a thrilling experience all the way through and i don't think any other game has gotten my heart rate as high as this one another cool thing about this game is there is a little bit of a legacy component as well based on who won the last round the losers of the round get to choose a special power that'll even the playing field a little bit for the next time up i thought that was a really cool addition to the game and it makes you want to play it over and over and over to try out all the different powers now if that was it i think the game itself would be so solid and would probably still be in my top 10 but one thing that really puts it over the top for me is that this game doesn't just exist in a vacuum the world of mind management is based off this amazing graphic novel series from artist matt kint i got a chance to read some of the graphic novels before i played the game and that just made the experience so much more rich for me i think it's a standalone hidden movement deduction game this game would have been great but the fact that it's super thematic as well definitely solidifies it in my top 10. so if you're looking for one of the most thematic games that i've ever played that uses hidden movement and deduction to craft an incredibly immersive experience and you're looking for a set of graphic novels to pick up then might i suggest mind management
oh man this guy's got three deduction games in a row in his top ten he must be done with his favorite deduction games right coming in at number six on my top 10 games of all time list is detective a modern crime board game now i remember hearing about detective when it first came out and i thought man this feels too good to be true i mean it promises to be this immersive detective experience where you really feel like you're solving a case and there's so much information to sift through and clues to follow that it's physically impossible to follow all the clues in the case that to me sounded like it could be an upgrade from sherlock holmes consulting detective that is a very immersive game but still very play at your own pace but when i finally got my hands on detective and got a chance to play that game boy let me tell you i was obsessed i remember being at my in-laws and spending three to four hours with them really trying to nail down the details of this case it really felt like we were in the back room at the police station sharing evidence and digging through clues to try to figure out who the culprit was and at the end of those four hours i couldn't believe the amount of time that i'd passed because i was so invested in the game that it felt like it was 30 minutes now i will say detective is not for everyone this one requires a lot of focus and a lot of investment by the people involved to really get into this game but if you've got a group of folks that are really excited to dig into a mystery and solve it even if you don't have all the clues then this one is gonna be a perfect one for you i've played all the cases in detective i've played detective season
one and i've played a lot of the auxiliary cases as well and every time i play it i'm just reminded why detective is one of my favorite games of all time as soon as i open up that database on my phone i know i'm about to buckle into a super immersive ride where i really have to be intentional about the clues that i take and the places that i go to so that i can make sure that i can solve the case at the end of it in this game every decision feels like it's the most important decision that you've ever had to make and i love the pressure of that because it really makes you feel like you're solving a real mystery i'm a mystery buff and obviously a deduction game fan and so even though i had really high expectations of detective before it came out those expectations have been totally shattered for the better so if you're looking for a pure deduction game that really makes you feel like you are in the situation being a detective and solving a true mystery then might i suggest detective all right all right enough with the deduction games here we are in my top five games of all time so number five is bonanza ah what can i say about bonanza this classic uve rosenberg card game about bean farming is not the typical theme that you'd see on my shelf but despite the theme bonanza is one of those games that sticks around in my collection and just simply never gets old for me the game is super simple it's all about set collection and knowing when to sell your beans and when to hold on to them you got to know
when the whole beans know when the beans but there's always this little element of negotiation in it that can add a little spice to the game depending on who you play with when i play this game with my family let's just say the deals are flying around the table and usually i get the raw end of the deal but i still have a blast playing the main tension of bonanza is the fact that you have to keep the cards in your hand in the same order that they were drawn you'll draw cards into one side of your hand but you'll play them from the other side of your hand meaning that in order to get your beans in the correct order that you want them to be in you'll have to do some rearranging by getting rid of some cards and giving them to other players the whole concept of the game is super simple and really easy to teach to new players but just ends up being a blast every time i play it with no matter who i'm playing it with this game is probably one of the oldest games on my list it came out in 1997 but for a game to have lasted that long and still be so good i just think that's a testament to the quality of the gameplay now i will say those crazy little bean illustrations on the game are somehow endearing but definitely not something that gets people to take it off the shelf but if you can get past the weird illustrations and the let's just say unique theme of bean farming then i promise you you'll really enjoy this one so if you're looking for a fun card game for your family that plays up to seven players and i'll have people yelling across the table and laughing all night long then might i suggest bonanza
all right the next one on my list number four is a game that i kind of picked up on a whim i like the production and i really like polyamino games but i'm really glad that i did pick this one up it's the isle of cats now i'm about to say something that might make a lot of board gamers not so happy personally i'm not really into cats i'm more of a dog person and plus i'm allergic to cats so they're not even allowed in my house now before you unsubscribe don't worry i have nothing against these cats because they don't make me sneeze plus they add to the theme for my favorite polyamino game so i guess they're not so bad anyways i really like the space that the isle of cats occupies in my collection yes it is a polyamino game and i love the puzzle that it presents but i'd definitely consider it a medium weight version of the game so it's not as heavy as something like a feast for odin but it's also a little bit more thinky than something like baron park both of those games are great in their own right but i think the isle of cats occupies its own space and that's one of the reasons why i like it so much i really love the tetra c element of putting those cat pieces together in your boat but i also love the fact that you can add certain objectives as you go through the game as well as collecting treasure that'll give you points at the end of the game all while trying to balance the baskets that you need to rescue the cats and the fish that you need to pay for them the isle of cats is definitely a game that you need to plan a few turns ahead for and that ability to have a little bit of foresight in the game is one that i really appreciate i'm always thinking one step ahead like a carpenter that makes stairs the production quality of this game is great but i remember
when it was first coming out from kickstarter and this production quality was considered off the charts now in 2022 the productions of games has kind of caught up but i feel like the isle of cats was one of the first to really do it big anyways the art in the game is great and even though the game has a few different mechanics going on at any given time everything is fairly simple to explain which gives new players the opportunity to pick it up fairly quick also i've recently started playing this game more on board game arena and that has really shot it up my list because i remembered how good of a game it was because it's sort of a bigger box it's a little bit harder to get to the table sometimes so i'm really happy to be playing multiple turn-based versions of this at the moment anyways i think the isle of cats is a really complete game that utilizes polyamino in a way that's really engaging and fun so if you're looking for a game that's all about cats that combines a tetris-like puzzle with some simple drafting mechanics and some amazing art that might i suggest the isle of cats all right we're in the top three so these games have got to be good right anyways number three in my top 10 games of all time is xayah legends of a drift system now if you watch my recap this was my favorite game that i played all of last year and for good reason xayah is an amazing sandbox game that allows you to choose your own adventure as a space pilot now if that doesn't sound fun to you then clearly we weren't raised the same way because for me when i heard the description i just imagined all the different star wars universes
that i could go to i think in my mind i'd be a bounty hunter but more than likely i'd probably just be like a cargo freighter or something you know whatever pays the bills anyways xayah is a fantastic game and one of my favorite things about it is that you can really tell that this game was a passion project from designer cody miller every single detail of this game is super well thought out and you can just feel the passion that comes from all the extra content in the game the production of the game even the concept of the game i just feel like this game might have been in cody miller's head since he was born and the fact that he was able to get it out of his head and make it into a real thing i just think is amazing plus far off games is actually not far off from where i live so they get a little bit of hometown advantage but speaking strictly about the gameplay i think my plays of xayah have been some of my most exciting board game experiences i've ever had in xayah you're a space pilot but you can pretty much do whatever you want do you want to deliver rare minerals to different planets across the universe do you want to be an explorer who goes out into unknown sectors do you want to be a bounty hunter who hunts down bad guys or maybe good guys you could really be any of those in xayah plus more which means that every time you play it feels like a different experience this game is also a game about knowing when to push your luck the nice part about it is when your ship explodes because inevitably your ship is gonna explode
the game doesn't really punish you that much and you can get started again pretty quickly that means you can be a little bit more reckless when you try to get through that asteroid field to pick up some cargo or you could try to roll that perfect number on the die when you're trying to break through the shield wall of a new planet either way every turn feels like there's something exciting happening to someone and you're all just waiting with baited breath on the die roll to see what happens the possibility of successfully navigating an asteroid field is approximately 3720 to one never tell me the odds because of the die rolls and the ability to take different paths it really kind of feels like some sort of space d and d but the rule set even though it is more overarching definitely keeps you within its parameters which means that the game still progresses onward at a decent pace xayah is definitely one of the largest and heaviest games that i own and so admittedly it doesn't get to the table as much as i would like but every time i do get a chance to play it i'm reminded of how fun it is to just choose your own adventure and be your own space pilot i mean who doesn't want to be han solo for a day right hey it's me anyways i've heard this one is pretty tough to come by so if you see a copy of it somewhere or if you know someone that has a copy get it out to the table as quick as you can because you will not regret it zaya is one of those games that i just want to thank the designer for making because it is just a fantastic experience so if you want to start your journey as a brash young space pilot and you want a game that will immerse you in its universe for hours then might i suggest zaya legends of a drift system
alright we made it to my number two game of all time and i feel like i might catch a little bit of flack from those hardcore board gamers out there with this one but to them i say there's no gatekeeping here on this channel people can like what they like and so my number two game on my top 50 games of all time list is wingspan now i didn't realize until recently that there was a large group of people online that actually really don't like wingspan i was reading some comments on the game recently and some of those comments were just filled with hate and vitriol for the game and i remember thinking come on this game is about birds and bird watching you need to chill out a little bit all right everyone chill so anyways i thought that i would try to balance out some of those mean comments with some of my top reasons why i love wingspan alright reason number one wingsman is beautiful we can all agree that the birds in the game are beautifully illustrated and all the components are really nice even in the base game wingspan is one of those games that just invites you to take it off the shelf you don't even really need to explain what the game is about all you have to do is see that beautiful illustration on the front of the box and people want to play it which brings me to number two of the reasons why i like wingspan not only do they see this game and they want to play it when they do play it they really enjoy it now i can see why a seasoned gamer might not be thrilled with the depth of gameplay in this game but to its target audience which i think are people that don't play a lot of board games or that are new to the hobby this game checks all the boxes it's inviting the components are really nice and tactile which makes you want to
play with the game and even if you're just there for the birds the illustrations will not let you down plus the gameplay although it's a little bit of a step up from most family games is fairly easy to grasp once you get into it and as long as you have someone explaining you the game that knows what they're talking about then this one is going to be a fun experience for everyone which brings me to point number three this game is a learning experience the first time you play wingspan you may not understand what all of the bird cards are gonna do or how important the objectives are or how important the birds on your board will be but the game does such a good job of teaching you those things during the game that after your first play you really want to play again it's definitely one of those games that takes a few plays to really get the hang of but once you do it becomes really easy to get to the table because it has great replayability i mean in just one game you don't go through nearly enough of the bird cards so you need to play again just to see more of those birds plus the mechanics and the way you build up your tableau in front of you change from game to game which means that there's never one strategy that's always gonna work i love all the different mechanics included in the game like set collection and drafting and tableau building and i love that it opens the eyes of newer gamers to these types of mechanics which brings me to my fourth and final point i love that wingspan is a great gateway game one of the best of all time in my opinion because not only do people who play wingspan want to play wingspan again they want to play games like wingspan as well wingspan shows people that don't play board games that board games are actually cool and wingspan shows people that are new to the hobby that board games can actually be this fun once
they've played wingspan they can then take their favorite parts of it and look for games that use those same mechanics the tableau building and the drafting and the set collection all have great iterations throughout the board game universe and if you like any one of those mechanics you could probably find 10 more games that use it in a different and exciting way i love seeing videos of people like mandy patinkin trying to learn wingspan i've talked one of the cards you drew on your last turn behind it's just nonsense it's incomprehensible i love playing this game with my family it's definitely one of the few games that i can explain without looking at the rule book once i played this game a ton of times and i probably lose more than i win but i simply don't care just because i just want to see those birds get those birds on my board and see if i can try a new strategy that might pan out this time i like that as a person who plays a lot of board games this one feels pretty light but as a person that doesn't play a lot of board games this one feels like it has a lot of meat to it so people of varying degrees of experience can meet in the middle somewhere and have a great time playing this one oh and i forgot to mention that the wingspan eggs are definitely my top 10 list for board game components that i like to eat the most but that's a different list for a different time so if you're looking for a great gateway game with amazing art and simple mechanics that give an amazing opportunity to introduce new players to the hobby then might i suggest wingspan
all right it's the moment you've all been waiting for my number one game of all time are you ready let's get a little drum roll all right my number one game of all time is side and let me tell you why now i think scythe is a great game i love the smorgasbord of different victory conditions i love all the different mechanics mashed up together i love the efficiency puzzle that you have to create on your board in order to build your engine and maximize your actions but that's not the reason why scythe is number one on my list scythe is number one on my list of top 50 games of all time because scythe was the game that got me into the hobby so picture this new year's 2017 maybe and i'm with my in-laws at a cabin at lake michigan we're completely snowed in as you can imagine and all we really want to do all day is play games now we brought a number of different games and i'll say that probably at this point the heaviest game that i played is probably cranium but my brother-in-law matt bless his heart brought a copy of scythe with him and i remember seeing that box for the first time in my jaw dropping to the floor that's better i was like what is this thing i've never seen anything like it then i remember going down into the basement of our rental house and setting up this massive sprawling board with all these different components on this table and just being completely overwhelmed with all the
different rules and mechanics and components and everything and let me say we did our best in that game i tried to figure out what was going on i tried to build an engine even though i had never played an engine builder before and i don't really even remember what the final scores were although i'm sure i lost by a lot but what i do remember from that is thinking wow this is what board games can be
to me up to this point it was clue it was scrabble it was boggle it was cranium it was categories it was just kind of party games that were light and scratched your brain a bit but never really did anything for me but as soon as i played scythe the only thing i could think about was how i could get better at this game as soon as we got back to portland i put a price alert on this game and at the first sign of a discount i went ahead and pulled the trigger on it scythe is absolutely one of those games that i'm never gonna say no to and part of that is because it is a little bit harder to get to my game table these days however almost every year i do coerce either liz or some of my friends to play it with me for my birthday it's crazy to think about but i think that if i had never played scythe i wouldn't be here right now making this video about board games scythe is absolutely the game that got me into the hobby because it showed me that board games could be more than just a party game or a trivia game or something like that when i got my copy aside i played through the atoma a bunch of times just to get a hang of the game and even still my grasp of the game changes from game to game certainly so you can say what you want about the massive combination of different mechanics in the game or games that have come after it that have built on the system but scythe will always hold a special place in my heart because it's pretty much the reason why i'm doing what i'm doing i also think that it's funny that when i played scythe it was by far the heaviest game that i had ever played and i thought man this game takes a couple hours this game is crazy but now when i play scythe i think oh yeah this is like medium to heavy this isn't too bad it's amazing how much your perspective can change
over the course of a few years but my journey started with scythe and so my list here ends with scythe so i know that you probably don't have as nostalgic of a connection as i do with this game but if you're looking for a heavier game that combines a ton of popular board game mechanics and uses this amazing dystopian concept art and some really cool minis to really immerse you in its world then might i suggest scythe well that was really fun i just got to talk about my 10 favorite games of all time and you listened right uh either way i hope you enjoyed this list if you didn't get a chance to see the other ones in my top 50 feel free to go back and check those ones out as well but i don't want to end this video with you thinking that i forgot my giveaway so without further ado the game that i'll be giving away for my top 10 games of all time is well you know it had to be this one it's scythe i'm giving away a copy of my number one favorite game of all time so if you want to win a copy of this game and make your own nostalgic memories with it then all you have to do is subscribe to this channel drop a wine glass emoji in the comments and if you want a bonus entry drop a suggestion on a game that you think that i would like based on my top 10. we're really close to a thousand subscribers so tell your friends and family so you all can get a chance to enter the giveaway anyways thank you so much for checking out this video especially those that have been with me through my whole top 50. i really appreciate the support and i can't wait to keep making more content for you please don't forget to like comment and subscribe so i can keep growing this channel and keep helping you find your perfect board game once
again this has been a mighty suggested game production and i'm alex your board game sommelier signing off you