Skip to main content
Loading video...

10 Board Games that Should have just been Video Games.

Transcript 29:20

Hello. Welcome to Quacko. Thank you for being here. Today we're talking about board games. Well, I guess that's pretty normal. But we're talking about board games that shouldn't exist, at least in their current format. I have 10 games that I personally think would do better in a digital atmosphere, right? Whether it's overarching rules or the style of gameplay, there's some games that just don't seem like they fit on the table. Sometimes, literally. Now, you might think this list is just going to be composed of giant big box campaign games that are storytelling bliss and require you to read way too much flavor text, but I've thrown in a few surprises. a couple indie titles, a few small box games, and yeah, we still have some of the giant ones that you can probably anticipate, but I've got good arguments and reasons why the digital format would be better for them. So stick around. Let me know your thoughts and what other games you'd like to see cross between these two genres. Whether it's a digital game that you really think should be a tabletop experience, which it's sometimes hard for me to imagine and a board game or a collection that you really think should at least have another iteration in a digital format.

We've seen this in a number of areas. You have Wingspan and Root. You have uh Scythe that exists online. There's a lot of games out there that are very, very compelling. And the first game on our list is soon to be one of those because we're talking and adding Frost Haven to the conversation. Now, Gloom Haven is a fairly well-known game and and Frost Haven broke tons and tons of records when it launched on Kickstarter something like five years ago. And it delivered something like 2 years ago. And a number of us, myself included, have yet to play through and finish the campaign. This game is massive. It's ambitious. It iterates and complexifies, if you'll allow that to be a word, the predecessor. And the predecessor was a pretty darn big box in and of itself.

Between the time it takes to display, set up, create new tiles, play through a scenario, potentially replay the scenario if you play about as good as I do, which means you went for the treasure chest and you died along the way. This is a year years worth of gameplay content and potentially an equivalent amount of time setting up, organizing, and putting back away after you've had a really good 2 or threeh hour session. Frost Haven is coming to the digital world. this version of a game, RPG, Dn D campaign game with lots of intricacies, with tactical card play, a little bit of shuffling, and enemies that you really don't want to have to run the AI for, run the management systems for, this type of game works really, really well in a digital format. Whether you're playing solo, you know, double-handed, makes everything cleaner and easier to approach, or if you're playing digitally in person, like my wife and I have done, or across different states, different continents. You can actually experience, play through, see the story, solve the puzzles, which get more varied and comp and complex in Frost Haven than they did in Gloom Haven. And you don't have to worry about the time commitment of learning, iterating, refreshing on rules, on AI management, on how enemies, bosses, and terrain work. You have a game that's helping run it for you.

That's where digital really comes in hands to challenge the conventional board game experience. when a game reaches slightly above the players threshold to manage. And if I'm sitting around a table with four people committed to playing Frost Haven, we can all take a section of it and run it smoothly. But like a lot of other games that are coming up soon, there's a certain size and scale that when you're playing with one or two people, which is my typical gaming experience, especially for campaign games because they require such a dedicated amount of time and focus, it becomes a lot to run, a lot to manage, a lot of rules to remember, a lot of little details to refresh. and the digital space, the game doing that for you just makes the experience better in my opinion. Let's talk about the other nine titles that I have on my list that really should be made digital. The next one is a little bit of a gimme, and I'll be honest about that. There's a lot of people out there that uh wish that this had stayed digital in the first place. I know the other ones really should be converted to digital. I just can't help but put this on the list as a game that should have never left the digital space and should honestly be reverted back into the digital space as quickly as

possible. It's not just the bungled campaign and the 2020 pandemic fallout that happened around Mythic over the course of the production of Darkest Dungeon, but it's also just the game itself. Yeah, it is ambitious and complicated and fun, but if you watch our original gameplay video, I think we mentioned how intricate and complex and managey it is every couple of minutes while we sat down to experience it. If you're a player who absolutely delights in overly complex rules and hierarchy systems of numbers and dials and cards and terrain spreading out all over the table, you will probably love this. If you think to yourself when you're playing Darkest Dungeon, I would just like to run all the stats myself for all the enemies and all the characters, then you would probably love this. But for me, it's just too much to play. And I love Darkest Dungeon. I was and still am excited about the minis. Was thrilled to get this game to the table. Couldn't wait to discover what they were creating in the heart of it. But over the last few years, it hasn't really hit the table. Whereas The Darkest Dungeon, the video game, is still one of my most desired plays. It's one of the games that if I have time to sit down and go back to an experience or an adventure, I want to open it up and I want to dive

back into those dark, decrepit caves. This is a good example of where becoming a board game can go drastically wrong. My next one is going to be from a very large publisher and a publisher that I think puts out some very, very good games. I don't think all their games need to be digital. I don't think Nemesis needs to be digital, although it probably is or will be because of how successful it's been. I didn't think Tainted Grail needed a digital iteration, although it certainly now has one and some people really enjoy it. But Etherfields, I think, should have always just been digital. This combination of abstract puzzle, of weird, twisted worlds and environments, this dreamscape that you're exploring through, and a kind of hidden picture challenge as you're journeying through these vivid and beautiful images. Etherfields has always caught my imagination and pulled me towards it like a siren song in a way that other games have it, but the board game iteration of it is a little too finicky. It's a little too clunky. It requires a little too much positioning around the table, shuffling to see all the components. The game mat itself organizes things in a way that makes it kind of hard to play. Whereas, you know, Nemesis and Tainted Grail, they sit

nicely. They play well. And yeah, they're big and they're ambitious, but I don't think I want them digitally as much as I want a group to sit around and play. Etherfields isn't that way. I think the art, the style, the design, the ideas, the conceptualization of this game iterated into a digital space would be a much better and a very, very worthwhile experience for those of you that enjoy quirky puzzle solving adventures like it sets itself up to be. My next one is a game that is complex, is in our personal collection, my wife and I, is a game that we actually genuinely love. Coming from Mind Clash Games, it's Cerebria: The Inside World.

I understand why this game struggled when it came out. It was big and bulky, had a twisted sense of game design, creating an environment where players were mixing together, where players were kind of working together in some regards and absolutely working against each other in others, where victory was a weird mix of building this tower in this center, scoring points, and recruiting and upgrading the various cards that you had in play. But the world, the design, the storytelling, the artwork, the beauty of Cerebria, I think would have pulled, captivated, and played really well in a digital board game space. Kind of like uh what is it? Athell. That's not the right term, but there's other games that do this that move characters and pawns and set you out on an adventure as you're playing head-to-head against other players, as you're scoring points and constructing cathedrals. Cerebrate is that it's a beautiful game, welldesigned, and we enjoy it on the table. I just think a lot of other people would have enjoyed it more had the rules managed themselves digitally and the experience was brought to the forefront while you sat and played.

That's at least my opinion. Let me know. I I don't know if you've experienced Cerebra. I don't know how many people still have it as part of their core collection. For us, we have some good nostalgia, and we think it's a really solid two-player game. Moving on to the next one is a game that I actually don't think is good at all. I had two copies of this. The one that I had open, we ended up giving away. And so now we're just stuck with a sealed copy of Dogfight. And I should probably and will actually eventually get rid of this. This came in a series of games with Blitzkrieg and Caesar. Beautiful head-to-head, two-player tactical games, war games, choice games, simpletoplay, easy to learn, tons of beautiful strategy, and Dogfight just didn't work for us. It was simplistic and also a little finicky. It was kind of easy to predict. It didn't have enough iteration. It didn't have enough design to make the experience feel like it was doing anything better or unique or different or anything at all compared to the two that came before it. I would have rather just had Caesar rehashed into another time period, another place, another location, another set of battlefields to place tokens down on and face off against. Dogfight, however, as a phone app in a digital format would have allowed the game designers to add a little bit more intricate details to add a little bit more of that head-to-head

juice that you're looking for. Instead of managing tokens behind your screen and figuring out what you wanted to play out in the digital space, they could have had all of these different iterations of planes, the different way that you sweep and move, the the way you tail your opponent and get into the right position to pull the trigger and fire. I think it could have been more complex because the game engine would have been running itself, would have had more to work with overall. And so I think Dogfight with a little bit of tweaking to the game style to fit that digital space would have and still could make a really excellent head-to-head two-player digital phone game. But I don't think it worked or works in the board game setting. And sadly, as much as I like collecting and having full sets of things, it's one of those titles that isn't going to stay in my collection, even though both uh Caesar and Blitzkrieg will. Moving on to my next one. I don't have the box for this one, and that isn't evidence of what I actually think about the game. We really enjoyed this game and we got a chance to sit down and play it. We owned it at one point and after playing it at a friend's house determined we would never play it again. Not because we didn't like it, but simply because the math and the scoring algorithm at the end of the game was complex enough we didn't want to

learn how to do it. I'm talking about dominant species. It was really, really fun. It was really good. It was quirky and interesting in all the right ways and at the same time the friend that we were sitting around playing with or the friends we were sitting around playing with knew how to math and they went to town. I'm not sure where our scores came from or exactly what the split was, but I do know I did not follow along as they were adding everything up. And I do know that I I didn't want to go through the rule book and figure out how to do that ourselves behind the scenes. This is one of those that is a great game, highly strategic, worth playing, but maybe not worth managing. And so, a digital version fixes all of that. Sets the scene, creates the environment, scores the game for you, and you just get to focus on the most rewarding part of the game play, which is the strategy.

You have to know how to score for the strategy. Of course, there's end game in mind while you play, but knowing how to score and knowing how to make the most out of your actions in a Euro game isn't quite the same as running the numbers and tallying that final verdict. And if the final verdict for everyone's score takes 10 minutes a piece, that's just a lot to ask. So, I don't have the box anymore. I would love to play it again and I would be ready to play it digitally if anyone wanted to sit down and give it a go. My next one is that indie game that I was mentioning a little another another little small box style game. This is upside down possibly. Yes, this is Gearworks coming from Peacekeeper Games.

This game is lovely. It's lovely in a board game format. It's lovely every time I set it down and play it. One, two, three, four players. It stands up on its own. So, why should this not be a board game? Why should this be a digital game? Well, it's that satisfying style of puzzle that fits into the genre of Sudoku in a way. figuring out the right numbers to go into the right position, the right matching of symbols and images and component parts to build the machine that you're trying to put together. And I just think the digital format, a little phone screen or a tablet screen would give you an overall better experience with this very satisfying puzzle. This is one of those where I think everyone should have played the board game, but they didn't. So now I think there should be a digital game because more people might be able to play it and might be able to experience it. Digital games are prohibitive at the moment. It takes a lot to get them up and running. But soon, like a year or two, we'll be able to just upload all of Gear Works into an AI system. They'll create the game for us and we'll be able to play it on our phones in a single day. Make sure you get the copyright license and the IP and the publishers.

Go ahead. I'm not saying you should do it yourself without their approval, but things like this in two or five or 10 years have the opportunity to circle back around, to be played with or iterated on, to be renamed, reskinned, redesigned, and published in a new way. Gear Works has such a solid engine underneath it. I would love to see it implemented in a little puzzle that I could solve or I could play against friends one turn at a time slowly over the course of a day on my phone or on my tablet. I'd love to play it on the table as well, but it's just not as easy or common. Moving on to my next one. I think this is number seven, I believe. This game is a game that has digital iterations and they're by far the best experiences I've had with it. Now, not Doom specifically. This is just Risk, but the version of Risk that I currently own is Risk Dune, and I haven't played it yet. And some of the new Risk games have actually iterated on that classic system very well, very satisfyingly.

They are good to get to the table. But I'm one of those kids that grew up wanting to spend 18 hours bombing other players, harboring myself down in Australia or conquering South America and trying my best to stretch up into the Americas to get those sweet extra, believe five points or resources per turn. Dune is a game that has you doing a lot of the same thing turn after turn after turn. It has you rolling and killing and rolling and killing and rolling and killing and rolling and killing and at hour 8 or 13 or 16 assuming that the players that you're trying to play with haven't already abandoned ship and left which in my case when I was about 12 years old they did all the time cuz I was way overcommitted for the game that we were playing and I was willing to pull multiple all-nighters in order to ensure my victory. I was having a blast.

They were not. Risk is one of those games, like a few other many other games out there, where you do the same thing a lot, time and time and time again. And because of that, the joy of playing, the fun of moving troops, the positioning and repositioning just drag on for a long, long time. So run that digitally, stick it up onto a screen, and enjoy the puzzle, enjoy the war, enjoy the battle. I discovered a digital version of risk when I was maybe 15 or 16 years old and really really enjoyed it. I've even been known to watch risk competition videos on YouTube before. Trust me, they're out there just like, you know, squirrel squirrel raising videos and ant farming content. I've went down rabbit holes into caving and fish uh cultivating. I don't know why those are the things that I've listed, but I have. risk is right there at the top of that list of weird things that you could go down and find a significant amount of entertainment around. So, I think this and and most versions of Risk should be digital. I think it's actually a pretty fun game.

Let me know if you agree or not. It could just be the nostalgia speaking. Moving on to number nine. This is a legacy game. And I love legacy games. I really, really do. I like ripping cards. I like the stickers. I like marking things and changing the environment of the game as I play. I have a deep desire, no matter how good or bad they are, to play through every legacy game I ever come across. I'm even enjoying this one quite thoroughly, even though our third player hard noped out of it after just a few sessions. Clank Acquisitions Incorporated, especially number two, is very fun, and it's also plagued by a lot of upkeep. Sticker sheets after sticker sheets, things that you're hunting for, time-consuming little moments where you're attaching to the board and changing the environment. It bogs down the story. It slows down the game. And it makes people who don't care about the adventure at all, which maybe they shouldn't be playing it in the first place, but it makes them not want to sit around and play. Half the game is spent doing management of the systems that you're trying to explore through. I really do enjoy this on the table as a legacy game, but I do think many of the things that they're doing would be better done in a digital space.

transforming the map, expanding the cards that you're playing with, allowing you to choose, upgrade, and change the style of gameplay, letting you go back through and reexplore it after you've sat down and played with friends. I just think it would be quicker, cleaner, and more enjoyable storytelling in a digital format. So, unlike a lot of the other legacy games I've played, I would actually choose not to have sticker sheets in bulk here, not to rip up cards and, you know, adapt the game itself because it takes it to a level that is arguably a little bit unfun. Still fun in many regards. First 80% I loved it. There was like 20% there where other people were doing things that I just didn't care about and that that was painful.

Moving down to number 10. And this is probably a predictable one on the list. After all, I do have a tradition here at Quackaloupe that every list can and should contain Kingdom Death Monster. or whe whether I'm doing top 10 family games or simple games to start with your seven-year-old, Kingdom Death Monster can arguably find a way to exist on those lists. But here in this case, it really deserves to be here. Now, I'm not holding up, nor am I talking about core game KDM. Yeah, it's ambitious. It's big. It takes a lot to get set up into the table, but I think that experience is par for none when it comes to boss battling board games. big settlement building campaign style adventures.

So, if that's all you want to play, grab it and get it on the table. But when you start adding other things, expansions and iterations, and specifically the Gamblers Chest expansion, you run into two problems. First off, I think the Gamblers Chest expansion improves almost every aspect of Kingdom Death Monster at its core. I think you basically ought to play with it at all times. And at the same time, it makes Kingdom Death extremely hard, if not impossible to run with only two players, which again is my most common gaming group for large campaign games. So if you want to play the best version of this massive game game that brought me into the deep world of board gaming, you have to do it in either a nonoptimal way or in a way that is prohibitively complex and yet by far head over heels incredible.

So stick it on the computer, run it digitally. If you're playing one or two players, if you're trying to get through a full campaign and people don't live around each other or together, you got to go with a digital format because at this point it's so expansive and so widespread and so farreaching that the experience of play is taken down a notch due to the degree of management necessary, which is a theme we see across the board in many areas. So, there you have it. There's my 10 list. I thought long and hard through this. I really had a lot of side notes here, ideas of games that I thought should be on the list, but I never went through the process of confirming.

Guards of Atlantis, which I think is primarily played digitally on tabletop simulator or on uh other tabletopia style platforms, Through the Ages, which is an incredible game and everyone agrees is way better digitally than in the board game form just because of the amount of effort that goes into maintaining and working on it. I had games that are more fun on the table that I thought could make good board game or I thought could make good video games, but I thought they'd be more enjoyable in a tabletop format like Roads and Boats from Splatter and Death May Die by Seimon. Both of which I think would be great digital games, great games in general, but I think the tabletop experience makes them compelling and worthwhile. There's games that are too big, but they need to be for the experience. like Too Many Bones, where dice rolling is such a central theme, a digital format just wouldn't bring the joy across. We had games that are complex, but they're special in their own unique, quirky board game way, like Space Empires, which is the most chits I've ever seen spread across a landscape or organized into a box. And again, yet at the same time, it just exists in its weird, quirky way. And I love it for it. I never play it and I probably still wouldn't digitally, but I do love it for it. And finally, we have games that require a level of social element, a level of interaction between

the players that makes them not as good in a digital format because you can't sneak off to corners or hide another room. You can't give that person a glance in a week and change the entire dynamic and nature of the game moving forward. Twilight Imperium is one of those I see a lot of people saying digital is the way to go. It's so long. It's so complex. It's so asymmetric. It's wild. But you lose something when you move it into a digital space. These other games that I had on the list here, I think you gain something when you move them over. Yeah, there's losses and gains on both sides of the conversation, but the opportunity to actually play through and finish a campaign, to explore a world, to introduce a title to a larger group of people, or have a higher player base because it's easy to pop it open and take a few moves on your phone as opposed to always have the game living on the table and get people around to sit down and play it. There's a lot of good arguments for board game adaptations, and I think we're going to see more and more of them, and more and more of them coming back from uh history as the industry continues to move forward and the development costs for video games become a little bit more accessible. All that being said, if you've watched to this point, you have to swing over and pick up Frost Haven in digital format, especially if you haven't played through the box sitting on your shelf or already moved out of

your house. If you're one of those gaming groups that actually successfully played through and finished, I have all the respect in the world for you. I'm also jealous of your available time, commitment to rules, and accuracy, and active gaming group. For me, for my wife and I, I can't wait to explore all of the little details, nooks and crannies, characters, and adventures that Frost Haven has to offer. But like Gloom Haven for us, it has got to be done in a digital space. So on July 31st, we're going to be diving headirst into it, and we hope you'll join us. Remember, follow the link in the top of the video description. That's my wife giving me a call as she comes back from her shift at the hospital. And we'll see you later.

Progress saved