The 10 Commandments (for Board Gamers)
Transcript
Last time I made a video all about the seven deadly sins in board game design. And that was all about the product, the design on the box, the rulebook, the game's mechanics, all the decisions made by all the various people involved in the actual complete design process from the inside out. It was a critique on things that just felt wrong to me that made my skin crawl and made me want to look away in disgust. But today, I come to you with a new message on stone tablets you aren't allowed to see. And these are the 10 divinely sent commandments from whatever board game higher power you choose to believe in. Whether that's Reiner Canitzia or Alex Randolph or Sid Saxon. Let's all open our rule books and do a little self flagagillation. Thou shalt not intentionally cheat. I'm starting with the obvious one, the one I think most of us can agree on. If you're playing a board game, even simply for pure fun, you should follow the rules of the game to the best of your ability. I think when people sit around a table and actually play a game, we enter into a collective set of new rules. No longer bound by normal societal rules, but instead the rules of the game itself.
It's a magical place where betrayal can be enjoyable and where you're allowed to explore new facets of social interaction. You can look into your friend's eye and say, "I want to destroy you." And that's endearing instead of insane. But the vast majority of games still have guardrails. There is a salt circle that keeps us in the magic. But if you break it by fudging a number or taking an extra resource or anything like that, you are piece by piece licking at the salt and eroding the circle. And nobody wants to play games with someone who licks these salt circles. In my own game, Sunlet's Eulogy, the rounds are partially pre-programmed by all players simultaneously. And one of the aspects of the pre-programming is that players also set down a card to score at the end of the round. But you don't always want to score. Sometimes it's actually really, really bad to score. So depending on what card you put down to score, it can make or break the round for you. But it's just so easy. You could just shift another card into that position on your player board when everyone else is engaged somewhere else on the table. But that just breaks the deal we all agreed upon when we sat at the table. And that's why thou shalt not intentionally cheat. Now, I can already hear the uproar. What about house rules?
I think there's a subtle but really key difference. House rules are the creation of new custom original set of rules that everyone agrees to follow for whatever reason to make the game faster or more balanced or whatever. There's a difference between modifying rules and cheating. Thou shalt not intentionally cheat is to say that whatever the agreed upon rules are, those are the ones that should be followed. It doesn't matter if the rules are in a rule book or if they're made up on the spot, but it's to adhere to the agreed upon base of play. So, don't freak out. I really don't care if you play Root by having everyone do their bird songs before moving to daylight actions and then evening actions. Yeah, it would be a completely different game that probably sucks, but if you all agree to do it, that's all that matters. So yeah, that logic also follows into solo board gamers. If everyone is only you and you agree to bend the rules, then obviously this doesn't apply. It's about the rules between all the players. So if you're the only player, then you're the only person who needs to make that call. And heck, some games actually use cheating as a mechanic. For example, cheating moth explicitly wants players to cheat, and there's even a guard player who catches these cheaters. But this is still part of the game's rules. It isn't cheating if the game allows for for it to exist. So yeah, thou shalt not cheat is a narrow commandment. It's all about preventing players from eroding what is the communal agreement of play.
Thou who brings the game to the table must know the game. Now, this one is a bit trickier. And the reason why I phrase it as the person who brings the game to the table is because it's not always the host or even the person who owns the game. I'm talking about the person who's like, "Let's play this one game in particular." That person, the one who actively convinces others to play the game, that person should learn how to play it. And look, I'm not a perfectionist when it comes to playing games. I personally get errors all the time in so many games. So many experienced gamers do. It's normal. But there is a certain base of understanding. How a turn works, what actions are possible, how to score points, how the game ends. Those should be understood before the game begins.
I'll give a super quick example. Recently, I've been practicing the Homeland expansion for Root. We've got some really weird new factions with the bats and the frogs, but I'm the guy who wants to play it. I'm the one who's like, "Everyone, come on over. Let's play this new Root stuff." So, it's my obligation to be the knowledge giver when we play it. Ultimately, this commandment says if you really want to play a specific game, it's on you to understand how to play it. It should not be the expectation for willing participants to learn it for you and then regurgitate it back to you like a bird feeding its offspring. This also means that you should actually attempt to learn the game before people arrive. There are few more painful experiences than watching someone unwrap a game, hand you a rule book, and then say to someone, "You read this as I punch the tokens, and we'll be all set." That is pain. Thou shalt be engaged in the teach. Okay, look, I know learning a new board game can be tough. Just recently, a friend of mine got the 2007 Starcraft game with the Brood War expansion, and I've played Starcraft before. I know about those minerals and the gas and the protos and still it was such a slog going through the rules. And it wasn't because it was a bad teach. It was because I was dead. I came to a game night after a busy day of work and I was losing focus. And I knew I was losing it because as soon as he started teaching about those little module upgrade tokens, I was fully disconnected from reality as we know it. I know that they gave some kind of power up, but I had no
idea what they gave or even how to get them or even where to put them on my player mat. My brain had become a microwaved pile of glue sticks that only mimicked the gray matter one would expect to find in my cranial cavity. And we played and I struggled during those first two rounds because I wasn't fully engaged in the teach. I was weak and my weakness reverberated like for 2 hours. And it's not always intentional. We lose interest. We glaze over. But really, this commandment is just about trying our best. The person teaching the game has already done us a favor by learning it, and the least we can do is try to lock in when going over 20 different tokens on your playerboard. We shouldn't derail into another conversation or check our feeds or ask for the game just to start up already. The teacher likely spent a lot of time preparing for this.
So, yeah, let's be engaged in the teach so that it keeps the gameplay as smooth as possible. Thou shalt let others make mistakes. Okay, we all love a great teach. When the game clicks over the words and examples of an experienced teacher, that's always an accomplishment. But there does exist a problem. Sometimes people don't let others make mistakes. This usually comes from a place of good intentions. Some games have strategies that are more likely to succeed if you start down the right path early, and a helpful nudge can save a new player from a miserable first experience. Since I've been playing so much Root recently, I'm going to stick with it as an example. In Root, the eerie player shouldn't start with the builder leader, except in some rare circumstances, it's generally considered the weakest one by a significant margin. And a helpful teacher might say it's generally best to start with the charismatic leader if your decree can handle it. Now, is this crossing the line from helpful teacher to preventing other players from making their own decisions? Maybe. I think it's a case at the border. It's true that starting as the builder leader typically clips your wings and a good teacher might want to advise the death spot or the charismatic leader dependent on the initial board state. And it raises the question to me is it kindness to give someone agency and then watch them fly on a path of failure. Maybe it's probably fine in the context of a board game, right? But then let's say in the same game if the teacher says, "Well, you should add fox cards to your
recruit, bird cards to your move. That way you have this perfect first turn. I think this kind of advice, it's crossing the line from helpful suggestions into playing route against yourself. It's just installing a physical person as you play another player's seat. And I know there's no hard line where helpful tips for stern players start to become playing the game for someone else. But that's why I often believe you should just let people make mistakes. Even the builder leader, even that is a step too far for me. And I think this kind of behavior leads to a classic problem we've all felt before. The quarterbacking issue. Some cooperative games, like I was playing Fate of the Fellowship, are just so prone to quarterbacking. A game like this is all open knowledge. Everyone is truly on the same team. It's almost like a joint puzzle. But still, you want people to have agency, to feel like their choices mattered, even if they mattered in a detrimental way. Part of the joy is recognizing a mistake and improving from it. But that's impossible if you never let anyone make a mistake to begin with.
Let players fail. Let them select the builder and have them go into turmoil turn two as they start to realize how the game's choices connect to the game's consequences. That's a huge part of play. Thou shalt set up before the expected play time if it takes longer than 15 minutes. Imagine with me for a moment. You go to your buddy's house and they have the hot new game. You marvel at all the artwork, all the beautiful tokens. It's the hottest new thing and you know you're going to indulge in some primo gameplay. But then they're like, "Okay, let me set this thing up." Half an hour later, 45 minutes later, and you're starting to see things come together, but you've aged. You've changed as a person. You came in optimistic and full of hope that you're going to have a great game night. And now you're just watching a confused person sort tiny colored wooden cubes into piles while you're quietly raging inside. And I think a ton of games suffer from this.
TI4, Starcraft, Gloom Haven are the three I think of right away. And they're just a tiny fraction of games where this whole array of tokens and piles and cards and maps and chits that need to be organized before the play even starts. I usually host the TI4 games. And when I do, I always always fully set up the night before. I have people pick their factions. We have a map already decided and everything is exactly where I want it to go so that it's ready as soon as people arrive the next morning. And even for me, someone who has a system in place with organizers and experience, it still takes easily an hour or two for a six player game. It's not something I can expect people to sit down and wait for or even necessarily to do with me. On the other hand, other games really do only take a few minutes to set up. Just a few plops on the table and you're done. And it's up to you to find that duration you can tolerate. I say 15 minutes, but that's arbitrary. The commandment still stands. Set up early if you're expecting people to come and start a game at a specific time. Thou shalt play to win. Okay, this one is a bit weird if you don't come at it the right way. Almost all games, not all mind you, but almost, are designed with the idea that it wants players to win.
This isn't about ruthlessness or some form of aggression or some kind of winning is all that matters declaration. It's the idea that the game play, the vision of the game is best fulfilled when players have intent to win. Let's reflect a moment. A lot of games play with the idea of winning. They'll tinker with secret hidden objectives or try to be a game that's all about the feelings that come from engaging with the game. Like you might have a game that makes you conduct morally dubious actions in the name of winning in what might be an exercise in feel bad selfishness. And that's fine. It doesn't matter what the idea of winning is. Playing to win means to engage with the game on its terms and to accept that it only works when players choose to play within its constraints. Let me give a super simple straightforward example. In the new Lords of the Rings trick taken game, you win tricks by placing the highest card in the leaden suit. Super easy trick taken basics, but the game applies conditions onto each character. You might only want to win one or two tricks or the least amount of tricks or win tricks only under certain situations.
The game constantly applies a new win condition and expects you to engage with it. It can be in any number of forms. And each of these 36 chapters in these boxes force you to engage with the win condition the game applies in each scenario. And if you just say, well, my idea of fun is to win all the tricks. The game breaks apart. Its mechanisms are built on the core principle that players are trying to win. not your version of winning, the game's version of what it is to win. And I think this commandment extrudes outwards a bit, maybe not all the way, but to what some might call self-made arbitrary win conditions. Like, let me give you an example. When I play with my brother, since his brain is so large and deeply riged, some people will explicitly say, "I am simply playing to make him have a bad time. That is my personal win condition." And that's fine if you're playing some games. If we're playing Root or Zuvatis, that's part of the table dynamic. The game can accommodate that rivalry and almost celebrate the tenacity between individuals. Your own personal win condition can be molded into a somewhat palatable experience in certain games. But if we're playing Lord of the Rings trick taken, that doesn't work anymore, right? The game's win condition takes priority over our own demands. Simply put, we can work within those conditions, but we can't supersede them. You can't impose your own terms over the game and expect the game to
accept them. You need to work within the confines of the win condition. And you might say, "Duh, one game is competitive and the other is cooperative." But that's my point. Every game is something. Every game has a specific intended mechanism of interaction. and games that have constraints that define what it is to win or lose or even what it is to play. You can't just put your own terms on how a game should play and expect it to trot along properly. To actively play to win, whatever winning is is to engage with the mechanics the way that the game wants you to engage with them. You're respecting the design and you're respecting the players with you. On a quick tangent, maybe I'll talk about this more in another video, but the reason why this commandment is so critical is that playing to win is really just an extension of saying it's important to recognize endogenous value.
It's this whole idea that a game creates meaning from within itself. The trick in Lord of the Rings is functionally worthless, but in the context of the game, it's a step forward in the narrative. If it's properly played, it means you're fighting the Balro and winning or escaping from some orcs. And by playing to win, you're keeping that internal meaning intact. You're communicating, "Yes, I agree. This trick matters and this card matters." And when you disengage with the game's version of what matters and start imposing your own, the internal world deflates. The trick goes back to just being a stack of cardboard and ink. I think there is an added layer as well. Playing to win doesn't necessarily mean playing optimally every time. I would argue that it broadly means accepting the game's own definition of what matters.
Sometimes when you import exogenous goals that override the game's internal value structure, that's where the conflict with this commandment arises. Someone planning on playing specifically to ruin my day is an exogenous goal. And sometimes a game system can absorb it and sometimes it can't. Like sometimes I really just want to give the clue noodle in a game of code names. And it might be suboptimal and confuse my team, but it's not always about playing the most optimal way. Even weird or personal strategies can still count as playing to win as long as the game's internal values are still intact. I think a popular example of this is something like a Nuzlocke run. the imposing of new rules on top of an already created system that made its own win condition that didn't conflict with the endogenous values of the game. You could modify and adjust what it means to win within the constraints. What the game values, the party composition, the moves capturing, it's still held valuable. Even more extreme, some people play a variant where the person can knock out all of their Pokémon in a team will win. But the game can still accommodate that. But if the idea of winning was to see who can make the prettiest tableau of cards in their warmspan mat, well then the game has no value of prettiest. Its mechanics are disconnected from the exogenous goal you've imposed and the game's internal meaning has nothing to grab onto. You're no longer playing to win within the constraints of the game.
And look, if you really want to play prettiest tableau wins, that's totally fine. More power to you, but you're not really playing Wormspan at that point. You're disengaged from the value system the game has created and instead just using cards purely for their aesthetic form. Wars span the game as a system is not generating the meaning for you anymore. And you've denounced the structure it has formed which again is fine but it is not the game. Thou shalt be graceful in defeat. And on the flip side of playing to win, you have to know how to lose. And look, many people are ultra competitive or have that spirit of victory that needs to be fed at the altar of the board game table. And if you know the type, you know the type. The air gets thick.
Someone shuffling their cards a little too aggressively. Those vibes can poison an otherwise healthy table. The reality is when you play a game, there is a large chance that you are going to lose the game. In a four-player game with equally skilled players, you'll likely win only 25% of the time. That means that three out of the four game nights statistically you're going home a loser. And if losing makes you miserable or actually angry or sulky or bitter, then that's something you need to work on outside of game night. Not something to inflict on your friends. And sometimes, worst of all, sometimes losing is not fully in your control at all. Tons of games involve kingmaking or randomness or some form of team. And if that isn't something that you can handle, it just makes for a worse time for everyone involved. I think the conflict is that we want to be invested in the game. We want to feel the highs and the lows. But the thing is, once the game is done, once we all return to normal life, it's important to just put what happened at the table to stay at the table. I talked about this extensively in a previous video, but let me go back to an example.
In Zuvatis, 95% of the game is above the table. It's between people. It's between deals and it's between broken promises. You are playing one another far, far more than you're actually playing the board. But what this means is that it's completely possible for some to shut you out. Even if you offer them the best deal, the deal of a lifetime, they can flat out refuse against their own self-interest, against your own interest. Just refuse whatever deal you have. It can be spiteful and it can lose both of you the game. And that's fine. That's Zuvatis. That's the design of the game. And at its most pure, it's simply a negotiation between people. But to lose in it often, it will feel personal. It will feel like you never had a choice and it was left to someone else. It's a game that really isn't great for someone who holds grudges or becomes frustrated by that experience in real life. So, it's important to remember that it's in the design of the game to make you a little bit mad. But that's the point.
feeling frustrated or cranky. When we experience something within the magic circle, we can appreciate it and then we can let it go. And that's why we need to be graceful in defeat. Thou shalt make moves in a reasonable amount of time. Okay? But now we don't want to lose. I just mentioned how you should play to win. And sometimes that takes time. Sometimes you need to sit down and focus and lock in. And that leads us to the next commandment. The commandment to not succumb to the demon in your mind. Analysis paralysis. I know the impulse. Some games give you dozens of options in a given moment, each with a branching pathway of consequences. And if you pick wrong, it will all cascade you down into a spiral staircase of misery. It's a difference between a narrow victory and a humiliating defeat.
Your head is a pressure cooker of ideas, but also it's a board game and your friends are decomposing while they wait for you. There is a limit. There just is a functional time frame where you need to let go, put a piece down, and let it fall into place, wherever that fall might take you. I think the key word is reasonable. It's up to interpretation. But I believe there are true signs, like when everyone is just silently waiting on their phones, or when the game's magic circle is dissolving as people start chatting about how a pizza is a pie for the past 5 minutes. This commandment exists because people want to make the perfect move at the cost of the sanity of everyone at the table. But more often than not, making a 70% optimized move in 30 seconds is way, way better than making a 90% optimized move in 10 minutes. That extra 20% of optimization is not worth the 9 minutes and 30 seconds of everyone else's lives.
In a game like Worms, it's mostly a head-to- table optimization engine building game. It's a game you play 90% by yourself, and it's not a bad game. It works. It's fun, but when it's not your turn, your engine is at a standstill. And of course, a wait of a minute or two, it's not that bad. But when that table becomes stagnant because someone's turn is taking 10 minutes, it's just not fun anymore. And the thing is, a game like Worms is a competitive game. You want to win, but there's a sadness I find. When you do make a brilliant move or a complete misstep, nobody really cares because all they care about is their own little turn. From this perspective, it's important to remember nobody cares how smart your move was.
They just want to play the game. And different games have a different tolerance for this issue. A reasonable time to take a turn in TI4 is dramatically different than a game like Boop. It's not just like I can decree that 30 seconds is all you get for all your games at all times. The saddest truth is that time is limited. We only exist for roughly 800,000 hours. And I don't think it's very nice to expect people to burn those hours just waiting for you to make the perfectly optimal move. So just make a move. It probably won't be perfect, but at least it will be a move. The game expects you to play imperfectly and your table will appreciate it. Thou shalt not let rule checking consume the game. Okay, rule checks. This is a normal part of the game. I rule check all the time. But there is a problem. It's when the rule check becomes this Corbin Russwin pyramid pin lock that needs to be picked by people who are just trying to reach a single jelly belly. And I know why this happens. It's not really about the specific rule in the specific scenario that makes us circle around the drain of rules. No, it's about this anxiety we have that if we play something wrong, the game itself doesn't count. Like, I didn't really play the game because we misunderstood or couldn't resolve an edge case with the precision of three falcons layered on top of one another.
There's this need for the game to be played correctly that can completely override the need of the game to be played at all. I'm going to give a classic example. Betrayal at the House on the Hill is a fun little game. It's all about exploring this haunted mansion until eventually the game reveals a haunt and a traitor. It's a classic little romp of fun events and situations. But this game is notorious for its messy rules. It's essentially 50 fun little mini games in one big package. And because each haunt is so varied, the fairly basic rules simply can't accommodate every single edge case perfectly. It inevitably leads to situations where the rules can't always provide a clear answer every time. At that point, you can either pause the game and try to perfectly parse out how a certain interaction works, or you can just make a judgment call and keep having fun with what the game wants you to do. And look, betrayal is it's notorious for this. But a ton of games have this problem. In Thunder's Edge, TI4's latest expansion, there's a new mechanic for one of the factions called coexist. And this mechanic breaks one of those core principles of the game that only one faction units should be on one planet. And I actually think coexistence, it's a really cool mechanic. It spins the game in a new direction, but there are just so many situations that aren't 100% clear. Older mechanics never had this new mechanic in
mind. So, you really do have to think about those edge cases that aren't explicitly spelled out in the rules. And there's a tension here with what I said earlier about playing to win. The player who insists on looking up every single rule will argue that they're respecting the game by getting it 100% right. That's the honorable thing to do. But the constant pausing, the momentum killing, that's killing the game more than just making a reasonable call and moving on. Games don't want to be constantly litigated. They want to be played. So, this all raises the question, what should you do when the interaction isn't explicitly covered? My process is I flip through the rule book for at most a minute. Then I do a quick search online and if it's not immediately clear, we make what we think is the most logical call and we move on.
And you might have another strategy and that's fine. But this commandment is all about saying that you can't sacrifice the game at the altar of the rule book. You must let it live, even if it's slightly misunderstood. You can't spend 30 minutes of every hour trying to find an exact quote on how to proceed for a slightly unusual situation. If it really bothers you, just research it deeper after the game is done and implement the fix for the next game. Thou shalt not damage the pieces. And finally, the sacred 10enth commandment. This one is all about the physicality of the games. Board games are meant to be played and sometimes played till they just naturally fall apart with bent cards and crumpled corners. Meeples with true marks from your dog when they fell off the table and nobody noticed. This is the natural aging of a well-loved game. Like when I pull up my copy of Camelup or Root, people know they've been played and played and played. But I think there's something to be said of our destructive tendencies. There is a difference between normal wear and desecration. Bending cards because you need something to fiddle with or eating greasy chicken wings and then handling someone's pristine copy of Grass Pittsburgh. That's just not cool. And different people care for games differently. Like for me, my copy of Skull, it's mostly disposable. If
they're used as coasters, I don't really care. I can always get another copy of it if I wanted to. My copy of TI4 and its expansions is legitimately one of the most expensive things I own. I took all the time sleing it and making it last as long as I can. So, it does bother me slightly when someone is bending an infantry unit while waiting for their turn. If someone has trusted you enough to bring their $1, $150 game to the table, that's money and time they spent to share an experience with you. And it's important to have common courtesy with training games with some basic level of care. And I know, I know many legacy games have you physically destroy or alter pieces. That's fine.
That's not really damaging the pieces without reason. This commandment is more about keeping things that should stay intact in good condition. So just wash your hands after eating. Don't damage the components if you don't have to. And treat the physicality as something that someone might actually care about. Board games are physical objects in an increasingly digital world. That's part of what makes them special. Every scuff, every worn edge tells a story about games played and memories made. But there's a difference between a story and some kind of crime scene and just destruction. And there we are. The ten commandments of board gaming. Now remember, these are specific for board gaming, not life.
This isn't life advice. It's board gaming advice. So things like be nice to people aren't included in this list. Anyways, at the start I said these were carved in stone, but I lied. They aren't. They're carved right here, carved on a slightly damp piece of cardboard. They have no real power over you. They just exist as pen on cardboard. So, I can't stop you if after a playthrough of Slay the Spire, you rip up all your cards just for fun, or if you never even read the rules at all and you just try to figure out these games as you play. These are just 10 commandments written on cardboard that I find useful. If you have other commandments, let me know. That's why we have a YouTube comment section. And one last thing, a hidden 11th commandment.
If thou wants to support this channel and my future projects, don't forget to go to Gamefound and hit follow on my own game for Sunlet's eulogy. You get a $5 discount and I gain some more algorithmic traction. A rare win-win. We're working hard right now to make that rule book pristine. And we're doing more and more play testing. We're adjusting mechanics. We're fine-tuning the systems to make the game as best as we can. And this channel, we don't have a Patreon. We don't have YouTube memberships. So, simply following us is the single best way to help things move along further. So, anyways, thank you as always for watching and bye.