Skip to main content
Loading video...

12 Most Disappointing Games of 2024 ►►► The R&R Show Episode 106

Transcript 1:44:46

Christmas is coming. It's true. And Santa needs assistance. Old and new. These goblins from a village far away are just who he needs to save the day. Hello everybody. Welcome to the RNR show. My name is Ruel Gabiola as always joined by the amazing Chris George. Hello amazing Chris George.

Oh hello amazing Ruel. I was so lonely in our starting soon screen because we couldn't talk to each other or I couldn't talk to you. But now we're back and all all my excitement is bursting forward. And Ruel, we we had um actually somebody redeemed game Somalier over on the Twitch chat. They said they said uh this from uh Ran Roman Bardi Reviews says, "Yeah, something like that says, "Hi, Ruel. I'm feeling like a Christmas game about goblins. Do you have any suggestions?"

Oh, thank you, Roman board. I I appreciate that.

Sorry for not pronouncing that that right. Yeah,

we're not. Yeah. So, our apologies to I'll also just call you Ruben board for

Ruben board. Yeah, something like Ruben board that. But I'm glad you asked. Uh Christmas is coming around the corner here. We are getting close to the Christmas season. Well, you know what? I'm going to give you a fun fact. Uh Chris, this is actually a true thing. Um I am u my heritage is a Filipino. I'm Filipino American. And in the Philippines, we start celebrating a Christmas in the in September. Like literally any month that starts with BE or ends in BER Burr like Burr September, October, November, December, we celebrate Christmas. So this is a game for everybody, but especially for my folks, my peeps in the Philippines, I'm thinking of you as we celebrate Christmas. Now, you know what, Chris? Goblins don't like Christmas apparently.

Yeah, goblins hate Christmas as we just saw. And we want to give a huge shout out to Goblins Hate Christmas for sponsoring this episode of the RNR show. If you don't want coal in your stockings, if you don't want to be disappointed, like the theme of this episode, well, you should go get yourself a little Christmas treat. Uh, huge shout out to our friends over at Goblins Hate Christmas. Uh, apparently goblins hate September, October, November, and December.

Yeah, those goblins, what are you going to do?

The Phil the Filipino goblins, that's what that's what they hate.

We know what you're doing. The Filipino goblins. Um, we are It's a card game that's for two to four players. It's a quick uh playing game up to about 20 minutes or so. Folks, uh click on the links uh if you're watching this on the VOD. Uh click on the links below for more information. You can follow the campaign on Kickstarter. And for those of you watching live, hello and thank you for joining us. This is episode 106 of the RNR show. You may notice uh one of our hosts is uh not with us today. Ray is um taking care of business. So, it's going to be Chris and myself. And of course,

it's the biggest disappointment. It's number one on the list is that Ray is not here joining us.

I love that. I sort of set you up for that even though I didn't mean to. But yeah, that is the biggest disappointment, Ray not being here, friends. You know what's also disappointing? Technology. We had all kinds of tech issues beforehand. Um, so boo on tech, but we are here just a few minutes late.

And you know what? We we hope that tech uh we we hate all technology here. We don't ever want technology to exist. That's the official stance of the channel. We're putting it out. We want all the technology to cease to exist. That's what we want to say cuz we hate it.

We do. At least what's it doing for us right now?

Not much.

Absolutely nothing.

It's giving me a headache. That's all I can say. Friends in chat who are watching live, I've just dropped the link to the uh Chris Goblins Hate Christmas campaign. You can click on that. And again, if you're watching the VOD, click on the show notes below. Um, but Chris, it's been um well, it hasn't been too long since we last uh hung out here on the show. Uh, anything new to report on your end?

No, it's a couple weeks. I'm back. I'm back finally in Toronto for one week and then I will be heading to the World Series of Board Gaming uh for another week in Vegas to to run their stuff.

The World Series of Board Gaming. What's that, Chris?

Well, uh yeah, I work for the World Series of Board Gaming. It's an event that happens in Las Vegas every year. We're going into our fourth event. I'm their director of production dealing with all the streaming and the commentary. Uh and we are going to go down and and run our our fourth event. And uh every you can't get tickets for it anymore because uh all the spots are signed up for. We closed tickets in September, but you can um uh check out some of the stuff that's happening on the live streams or you know, check out the WPG's YouTube channel for more updates. And I believe Ruel should be there at some point in time. Uh and you might see a familiar face of RUL commentating on some games that when I whenever I decide on a whim to throw Ruel in there,

Chris is going to just throw me to the wolves there, folks. Um yeah, I will be there at some point. Uh, you know what? If you haven't seen the WS uh BG before, folks, definitely check out the coverage because Chris and the team there do a fantastic job of producing it. And I'm not just saying that cuz, you know, Chris is, you know, part of the show and everything. Just

and cuz I'm right here

and you're right there. I've got to say nice things in front of your face. But no, seriously, it is it's a massive undertaking to do something like that live. You know, you got all the competition. You've got to everything you got to cover. I mean, it's you know, y'all know I'm a sports ball fan. Go Dodgers. It's it's a production like that where it's a lot of moving parts and Chris again kudos to you and the team for actually producing really high quality stuff and coverage.

Yeah. Um I appreciate it. Thanks. Thanks. Well, I I didn't mean to say yes, I'm amazing. Uh but I

was looking

John Trip in the chat. Uh I'm not having any tech more tech issues. I snapped this photo of myself recently. It's my new favorite thing um to show whenever I'm having tech issues. That's That's me trying to send a text message. What?

Um that was from that was from when we did the unrehearsed uh Romeo and Juliet. My Capulet was Daddy Capulet of like Emperor Palpatine style.

Uh that's that's Frier Lawrence's Gandalf.

Wow.

And then there's, you know, Tibultt, the king of cats. Um which is a pretty good one.

Yeah.

Pretty impressive makeup. Nice. I just thought I just thought it was a a relevant photo based around anyone who's having tech issues. Don't worry, we understand. We we we get it. We get it.

Exactly. Uh by the way, next to Moon says, "Nice to see some cons talked about as well as pros for board games. Makes for more well-rounded viewpoints." I agree. Um

that's what this list is all about.

Yeah, that that's it. And you know, I'm more of a I I'd like to keep the positive about things, but you know, there are not everything is rosy, folks. So, um, you know, before we get into the list itself, we can talk a little bit about our process, Chris, right? How did we go about this? We've done this list before, folks. If you haven't seen them before, again, click the show notes below for our previous disappointments, but how did you approach this, Chris? Did you just look for games that you didn't like or games that you were looking forward to and just

Yeah, I looked deep inside myself and I thought, "Wow, when have I experienced the most trauma when I should have been experiencing joy?" Uh, and I and I really took a a very long reflection and I was just, you just day after day after day. Honestly, I was like, "Oh, no. This is not this is that was probably a bad way to approach this, but now I'm in it." Uh, and I found some board games in there. Uh, just in the corners in the corners of it. Uh, and so then I was like, well, I guess I'll talk about these. Um, no, for me, for me it's essentially like you mentioned, some of these things are I had high expectations for and they didn't meet those expectations. Some I had incorrect expectations based around the publishing company themselves. Um, and then some are just uh horrendously bad and shouldn't exist at all. And I would love to um counsel the world and make sure that nobody ever uh touches these atrocities and abominations again. So some are, you know, some are some are definitely and and we'll clarify which is which as we go through. Or maybe we won't. Maybe we won't. Maybe we won't.

Maybe it's all of them. Maybe it's every game from here on out. Uh yeah. So uh show us the doll from the board game hurt you. Yeah. That's what next to Moon said. Yeah. Tell me. Would you like me to get my doll? I can. I'll be back. Uh, just vamp Rule cuz I'm going to go get the doll.

Wait, there's an actual doll. I love it.

Jade.

Yes. All right. So, we're going to see Chris's doll. Hey, I see some dolls right there. I see a Darth Vader. I see a Princess Leia. Um, as you know, you know, those of us who grew up playing with these, these weren't dolls. They were action figures. But yeah, we're going to see Chris's a doll real soon here, folks. And as we continue the show, be sure to let us know what games you've been disappointed by lately as well. Drop them in the comments. We'll hit those up. What doll is this, Chris? Oh my gosh,

this is Jade.

Yeah, her name is Jade. Um, named after my uh soon to be Amazing Race partner. Me and my friend Jade are actually trying to get on the Amazing Race Canada. Uh, you can go follow us on Instagram, Christian Jade Chase the Race. Um, but uh yeah. Yeah, Jade. Jade. Uh, you had something to say af.

Yeah, Jade. Jade wants What's that? What's that, Jade? Oh, she's shy. Oh, she's shy. Yeah, Jade, tell me. Tell me. Yeah. Okay. Okay. No. Speak speaking of my good ear. Speaking of my good ear, Jade. Okay. Yeah. Jade. What's that? Ever every game Roto likes. You know, Kai, we can't say that. Jade. Jade. Roto is wrong about whatever anything he said. No. Well, we know that. Jade, but what? It was Roto who hurt me the most. I don't Jade, please. The games. The games. Jade. Uh. Yeah. Oh, okay. Um, she she forgot the question. She forgot the question. What was the question? Oh, Jade has been my co-host. Jade has been my co-host a little bit um on my on room and board. And of course, I needed to to pull her out. And

oh my god.

And the the board games had hurt Jade in fact when uh they when they promise something different, you know, when they when they promise something and they don't deliver. Uh and this is only 2024's board games. Who knows what what 2025 will have in store, but I think it's always good to talk about things and expectations and

and having some clear stay away froms.

And your your channel, you've always been really good about that on your channel, right? You've always balanced like, okay, here's the latest Kickstarter I'm excited about, but then here's some stuff you probably don't want to, you know, put your money behind as well. By the way, that that doll was absolutely creepy. That was like Chucky.

Don't say that. Don't say that about Jade. That's very

Oh, Jade's still there. Oh my gosh. Sorry, Jade. Jade, please. No, Jade. Stop. Jade. Jade, it's okay. Royal didn't mean it.

Didn't mean it.

I did it. Sorry, Jade. Uh, by the way, we did see the Darth Vader and Leia um dolls behind you. And I was saying Yeah, I was saying when I was a little kid, they were called action figures, but they're those are dolls, you know. Those are dolls.

Those are actually 3D printed uh not by me, but by my a friend and patron, George. Yeah, he 3D printed these. W.

So, they're 3D printed and they're Lego versions. Um,

they're like little Lego things.

Yeah. So, he 3D printed these.

Mind blown.

Which are so cool. I don't think he 3D printed the cape, but he just made these and he made them for for everybody. Uh, he came up and and it was on May the 4th and so he gave everybody like a Darth Vader.

That is perfect. Oh my gosh. And then we played a game we played a game of Las Vegas, the dice game, and we had um

uh you know, like where you're just rolling dice and you're you're trying to bid on stuff. And the winner won a secret prize, which was like a 3D printed BB-8. It was sick. They were sick.

Whoa. That is that is some pretty awesome uh 3D printing there. Oh my gosh.

As you can see, I did not win. I did not.

Okay. Well, why don't we uh get into the list, Chris? Again, we just talked about our little process here of how we go. I went about it as well. Same type of thing, like things that didn't really hit with me uh for whatever reason. But we'll talk about that as we jump in here. Um why don't we lead it off with number 12, which is going to be your pick. Uh Chris.

Yeah, I'm happy to start off with number 12. And number 12 comes again from that sort of like really broken expectation because it comes from Mind Clash Games. When I think of Mind Clash Games, I think of like Crunchy. I think of Crunchy Euro, you know? I think of Anacrony. I think of Voidfall. I think of Tracarion. Uh, Septima is it still has a lot of moving point parts to it and whatever, but I certainly don't think of Ironwood. And Ironwood was sort of the game that was coming out from Mine Clash that I played

at last year or at PAX Unplugged two years ago actually um before before it had come out. They were doing they had just announced it, they had launched it and whatever. Uh, and I I think Ironwood is is a sort of good concept as a game. Um it it is only on this list by merit of disappointments because it comes from Mind Clash and I expect a certain type of game from them and this was not that type. And I think that is sort of relevant information in terms of this being uh a a head-to-head two-player clash of uh resources. You have your your miners who are trying to drill drill out the ironwood. Uh, and then you have the people in the woods who are kind of existing in the pockets of forest trying to stop the drills essentially. Uh, and you're you're kind of picking off each other. It feels a lot like a tugof-war mechanism. It feels a bit like a two-player card driven route. Um, but I think I would prefer root more.

I don't know. There there there are a lot of my memory of this is is a little bit fuzzy. Honestly, I I did have to struggle a bit on this 2024 list because I was looking back. I was like, nah, like that, like that, like that, like that. And so it was harder to to to find things that that I could I could talk about, but I really remember being so excited, like I'm always so stoked when a new Mine Clash game comes out. And I also had like done a preview of Voidfall at that packs as well. And I was like, "Oh, yeah, let me dive into everything Mine Clash." And then I got to this and I was like, "Oh, okay. This is just such a deviation from the brand." Um, that it it felt it felt like there was a disconnect there. And I think that's interesting too because I I I know one of the board game publish companies that I know of that is very specific about branding and I think it it is to a benefit is Burnt Island and KTBG, right?

Like they're run by the same people but the KDBGs they're more like family weight kids style games and then Burnt Island are their like more complex games, right? And and so I think like Awaken Realms tried to do that with like Awaken Realms Light and then they kind of stopped doing that. But I I I I because I think the light sort of devalued their brand and I don't know if if Mine Clash was going in a similar direction as well, understanding that it doesn't like mesh with the current brand of like chunky chunky euros that they've put out, right?

Um

but yeah, it was fine. It was okay. It was a a fine head-to-head battler game. Uh it just didn't blow me away. And when all other Mind Clash titles do blow me away, I think that then is relevant. So that's why I ended up putting Ironwood on the list. not uh uh it is last on the list because I'm I'm the least disappointed by it because I can see its merits, but um I it just to me wasn't what I was expecting again because I went in blind. So perhaps that's that's on me as well.

Yeah. Yeah. That it's and I I came up like as we're putting together the list, I came across a bunch of those as well, Chris, is where I mean I felt like 2024 was a pretty good year for games. So I didn't come across anything I was like really super disappointed by. I there were some that just didn't meet my expectations, which I think is the case here with Ironwood. Yeah. Um again, the pedigree of um you know, Mine Clash and you get this and it's like more like light clash I guess, right? Not you know, super heavy and

Yeah. but I I've really I was curious about Ironwood as well. Um because I know Mine Clash's reputation, Tracarion, amazing experience. Um I have not played Voidfall yet, but I do want to see what their you know, how they approach a lighter type game. You know, you mentioned Awaken Realms and actually Chip Theory Games as well has done some super light games recently like like Fight Five. Yeah. Um so I like seeing these heavier companies that are known for heavier games sort of delve into this and

but with varying degrees of success like do you think they should follow the kids table board gaming where they do separate the brands like that or I

I think it's tough too, right? cuz you then have to establish a whole new brand and people are like okay well if you don't know that conceal board gaming and burnt highland are run by the same people like that that's about the only connection like they both have good production quality but like so do a lot of board games right and and so I think it is I think it is also like a hard thing to just basically establish a new company is what you would really need to do to make me happy which I don't think is a sensible business decision um but I think like I don't know Ironwood was uh it was interesting but it's not one that I was like ever gravitated to to return to and I was like, "Oh, yeah." That that kind of finally came out in 2024 and I was I kind of was hit with a Yeah. Okay. Yeah.

I'd rather play any other Mine Clash game, which are which are great.

Yeah, that's fair. Cool. All right. Yeah. So, that's number 12 on our list of 12 most disappointing games of 2024. Uh well, let's move on to our number 11. And I've got the call for this one.

You know, this actually fits in right with what we are talking about right now, Chris. Um our my pick for our combined list is number 11 stamp swap uh from um Stonemire Games and pretty much for the reasons that you're describing you know Stonemer again they're not they don't publish uh heavier games like Mine Clash but they do have a certain standard right I think of a stone cl a stone meer game and I think of a certain uh game and stamp swap while I thought it was a good game it didn't resonate with me for whatever reasons um just it wasn't the stone I mean it was it was a fine game. Um, but it just didn't really hit with me. It just sort of felt flat to me. Um, I love the theme and actually we're watching Amy and Maggie's run through here on uh Roto's channel. I sort I agreed with Amy and Maggie. Like I was so excited about the theme. It's about collecting stamps which is super nerdy and it's got tile laying as a mechanism. I love like laying down tiles like the Polyominos. Um, you have multiple scoring objectives. You are collecting stamps and you're going to um like a stamp expo to show them off. But it has this I cut you choose mechanism which I I I know Amy and Maggie aren't a fan of it. I I I'm sort of like on and off with it. Uh I can run hot or cold with I cut you choose. Um but it just it felt off to me in this. So, you have this eye cut you choose where you have the stamps that come out and then you're going to select which ones are going to go to everyone else or well actually you set them up in little groups hoping that everyone takes the piles that you want them to take while you end up with the one you you like. Now, that's always a

tough thing and for first time gamers and again this is something Amy and Maggie point out which I totally thought of when I played the game. It's really tough to like quantify or value like what I should be putting in each little group. Especially as a first-time gamer, first time to this game. Like I don't know what's worth more or whatever. And eventually, you know, it eventually turns into this thing where like you're going to get a bunch of stamps for your board that you don't want. And then that just makes for me the fun part of the game is doing the puzzle of laying down all the tiles everywhere. And that that's that part right there makes it like, well, I got a bunch of tiles I didn't really want and now I'm gonna place them here and hopefully do the scoring goals. But the scoring goals are cool. You know, you can do different uh shapes, you can do different colors, sizes, or whatever. Then there's like the main objective. Um I think it's really that I cut you choose that didn't feel satisfying to me. And I also played it solo. And you know, the the um the solo bot works great. I I still think Stonemer Meer for my taste do like the best type of Ottoa or Solo box out there because it's really low maintenance. But overall, while I like Stamp Swap, I didn't love it. And that's why I went with the huge expectations and it's like, okay, it's fine. But it didn't it didn't really resonate with me um uh for that. And you know, I was thinking about other I cut you choose uh games that I prefer. Um, now this is a fine game, but I think it the mechanism is done a lot better in Hanamakoji, a two-player card game, and also the great split, which is sort of I

feel like really flew under the radar a couple of years ago, and that to me is a fantastic I split or I cut you choose game. So

yeah, stamp swap, Chris. It was it was good. It was fine, but it just didn't live up to what I expect from a Stonem game. I was looking up on my shelf because I know I have shakurerie right here which is which is a great I cut you choose game and you're just making a little shakuterie board in terms of unique themes. Stamp swamp literally

uh if I've heard about it immediately left my brain and that's it's so shocking to me that this is a Stonem game because usually I pay attention to everything they release. I this is literally the first time I'm ever hearing about it in my life.

Wow. And I will swear on that even though in my email there's probably an announcement that says stamp swap's coming out. Nah, deleted it. It's gone gone from my mind. Like it it is sort of a testament to you probably weren't the only person who was disappointed by it. I imagine uh Stonemer might be as well based around nobody talking about it.

Yeah. And that's such a it's such a bummer because I really want to like and that's part of it too. Some of these a lot of the games that I chose, I really wanted to like them more than I did just because whether it's the theme I thought was cool or maybe hey these mechanisms look neat. No, I really want to like this cuz you know as a little kid I mean well at least for me back in the day I collected stamps for for a hot minute and this was seemed like the perfect nerdy thing that you know I feel like there's some parallels to uh nerdy stuff like collecting stamps and playing board games, right? We all collect board games as you can see. But yeah, just such a bummer. But, um, that's our number 11, Chris Stamp Swap.

Yeah.

Um, why don't we find out what Richard thinks and we're going to turn it over to him for number 10.

Hey guys, good to see you again. As we sit down to talk about Heartbreakers from last year, I've got a few. In fact, um, after we get down to this countdown and we get to the, uh, you know, the post list, I'm going to do a full top 10 of games that did not work out very well for me and Jen in 2024. But for starters, we are going to hit the highlights. Chris, Ironwood, I have to admit, I don't know anything about it cuz it's a dueling wizard game. It was never one I was going to like, but sorry to hear it didn't work for you. Well, Stamp Swamp, you know, I'm kind of with you because well, I don't know if it's the game itself, but I am not a big fan of split you choose at all. And honestly, I think those tend to be better with more than two. Jen and I did try it. Um, you'll notice I did not cover it on the channel because again, I didn't like it. Amy and Maggie covered it though and they did like it. So, I'm really looking forward to hearing what your problem with it was. Um, but anyway, uh, we've got those are number 12 and number 11. Uh, number 10, you know, before we get to that, I am here in Ireland in my new filming studio and that camera's on a selfie stick. Let's go on ahead and give you a quick tour of where I film these days. Let me switch to my other more stable hand there. Hey, that's what I'm looking at while I'm filming. And here's the thing I just filmed yesterday. And there's stuff I've recently filmed or that has to be filmed or what have you. And right there are a couple of dog beds because they sometimes like to sit in here and snooze while I'm filming and whatnot. And there's my big lights. And and this is a very tiny room. It used to be a bathroom. This house when we got it had

three bedrooms and five bathrooms and that was ridiculous. So one of the first things we did was turn this bathroom into a fourth bedroom. So we have four beds, four baths instead. This house effectively used to be a hotel for all intents and purposes or Airbnb style hotel. But anyway, it is now my little filming room. I barely got any room, but it's just enough to get the job done. And I'm going to give some more tour stuff as we get to the later ones. But now I put it off long enough. Number 10 on our list is STI: The Search for Extraterrestrial Life. And that's going to be uh triggering some gasps, I think, because I mean, this game was hugely popular. It made several best of the year lists. I think it was the Dice Tower best game of the year, and maybe uh the board game, Golden Geek best game of the year, too. But not for me and Jen. And I'll tell you why I was disappointed. Uh last year, new designer Thomas Hollock had three games come out.

Um Tea Garden, uh Gali, and STI. I had played the first two before Essen and I thought they were both phenomenal. Uh Tea Garden was my favorite. Galileo Gali was Jensen's but they were both really great. So I didn't get a chance to play Si until after Essen, you know, near the end of the year. But I was months I thought those other two games were so great. Si from CG is going to be the best of the bunch. And so I waited and waited and waited down in Mexico. I was finally able to get a chance to play it. And boom. I don't think the game works that well for two. I don't think it was anywhere near as good for a two-player game as um his other two designs. And so I was crushed. Crushed, I tell you. I got rid of the game. Now, as I understand it, uh he is putting together there is an expansion for it coming out this year that I think will fix my problems and make it a much better two-player experience. But um with the game out of the box, it just wasn't there and it broke my heart. I mean, I could see as a higher player count game, it would work great. Uh, but as a two player, Sedi, the search for extraterrestrial life, uh, was very disappointing for me. And that's our number 10 on the list. Okay, back to you guys.

Wow, STI. Um, I just got my copy in recently. I'm looking forward to it, but um,

earn it, I guess.

Yeah, I I'm I'm interested to see if it really is. Well, if it's disappointing to me as well. I

Richard is wrong. Oh my god.

Richard is wrong.

Oh, Jade, please. Please, Jade. Jade, please. Oh,

I've gonna have

I'm sorry. I've I've actually never played SEI either. Um, but I've just heard really good things and apparently Jade is very passionate about it. I hope uh I hope Richard gets the other three right and that Jade doesn't come back.

Jade is going to give me nightmares tonight. Thanks, Chris.

Um, Sean in the chat says, "I also like set a lot at two. And honestly, I I value Sean's opinion a lot." So, I think Richard I think Jade and Shawn are correct. It's two versus one. Two versus one. Sorry, Richard.

Um,

and it's number 35 on Board Game Geek right now. Like, I haven't seen a new game shoot up that many charts since Ark Nova. You know what I mean? Like, it's just it just keeps climbing.

That's so interesting. Um, I I love Tea Garden, so I'm wondering, you know, how it compares to Tea Garden cuz I thought Tea Garden was phenomenal. I just played that for the first time a couple months ago. So, STI folks, uh, Richard was disappointed by that. Uh, let's continue with the list. Uh, Chris, what were you next disappointed by?

Um, I kind of forget what I put on my list, but I think I have it right. Uh, I think it's uh Cthulhu Death May Die.

It is Fear of the Unknown. Phew. Perfect. I knew that. I knew it's it's it was either that or that's the next one, but I think I I thought it was Yeah, I have it sitting above my head right now. I haven't gotten rid of it. Um, and I intend to play more of it, but I was just expecting a heck of a lot more. Like, I love Eric Lang. I love uh Come on Games. um you know and this one still is a come on game I feel uh I know some some are being being sold off to different different um other properties but I think come on still has this one uh I I just I expected I I really enjoy Zombide I I really enjoy the others um and I just expected to really enjoy this one and I found that I wasn't prepared for the flow of the game a and I don't Like I've only played the first scenario still of or the first two I forget. Um of this, but the the initial scenarios, but it only comes with six scenarios. It only comes with six chapters. So I don't think there's any excuse of it be being like, well, it's the first scenario wasn't as good. I don't care if you only have six chapters. All of them better be bangers, right? Like every scenario better be faking fun and better be replayable. And I just found it really boring. Uh I I found that the the threats weren't there as much as I wanted them to be. Like in Zombide, everything's kind of creeping and creeping and you feel that pressure and then in uh I expected to feel a similar sensation with death may die and it isn't and because it's a different game, right? And so again, that's the the idea

of expectation versus what are you actually getting, but I I found that like the threat wasn't there as much. It was more about searching and and drawing from uh uh trying to uncover these different clues and and hit these different objectives and playing the scenario kind of the way the scenario wants to be played. Uh and then also with the activations of certain people, I'd be I'd be like, "Oh, I expect them to move and attack me." And they're like, "Ah, they didn't move." I'm like, "Okay, well, they're going to move on the next one, right? No, they didn't move." Okay, well, they're gonna move on the next one, right? No, they didn't move. And like that could just be the card draw, but um I I don't know when when when there are tendencies, when there are abilities for that to happen, I just kind of was was less excited about the things affecting me. I didn't find that the AI worked in a as fun a way as I was hoping for it to uh to feel that sensation of of danger and whatever. And that and that the main danger comes from you just going insane on your own and then taking handicaps because of you hitting these different insanity thresholds. Um, so yeah, it it's still like it's one of those things where like I I'm it's still on my shelf because I have to play it and and and I want to give it another shot. Like I purchased this game. I backed the Kickstarter. I was really excited. Um or this one was on Game Found. I convinced myself to not get four season 3 and four. I was like, "No, just get season 3. Like just try it out. See if you like it." And I'm very glad that I followed my own advice on that. um would way rather play Massive Darkness or Zombicide or the others. And so it it's

in a it's in a tough space for me because I want to I want to play it again, but I don't really want to play it again. That's why it's still sitting on the shelf because I'm like, h kind of sucked. Like maybe it gets better. Um but I don't really I would if I'm spending time doing something if that is just supposed to be for fun. Well, it's it's hard now to get off the shelf. Uh, I still want to give it another try, but I'll have to do it when I'm in a productive space of no, I I'm working my way through my shelf or uh trying to give second chance games a try so then I can get rid of them and make more space and all that sort of stuff. Um, let's see. Let's see uh what the chat is saying. Hexra says, "Death may die tugs and my sunk cost fallacy bone. I wish I liked it more." That's exactly where I'm at, Extra. That's Yeah. Okay.

Yeah. Um, Next to the Moon says, "Come on. has that FOMO that makes you buy the extra boxes full of more content that complete the games. I don't think I don't think so with Death May Die. Like I I agree with the FOMO machine, but but I don't think that a season 4 would complete the game because it's just more scenarios, right? If the scenarios are middling at best, they're going to be middling in season four and they're going to be middling in season 3. Uh and maybe it'll just take a little bit more for me to unlock and see what happens and see different I I only played one Elder God. Maybe the other Elder God. Well, maybe there'll be an aha moment, and I'm hoping for there to be an aha moment. Maybe we we missed a minor thing in the rules, you know, maybe we didn't add in this card or when I add in the the randomized unknown monsters, maybe that will be the thing that unlocks it for me. There's there's some stuff in the box that I haven't yet engaged with that I'm, you know, leaving

Yeah.

leaving uh hope for. Yeah. But, um, yeah, I'm really I'm really curious about this because I have a box of the the the base game that's been sitting on my shelf for a little while and I haven't gotten to it, but I'm like you, Chris, I'm a huge Eric Lang fan, but I

I have heard some mixed things about um, you know, the the ongoing Cthulhu Death May Die series here. So,

yeah, I mean, I guess you can only, you know, go back to the well so many times before it's like, okay, it's sort of stale now, maybe. I I don't know. Um, but

yeah, I think Sean says says some good things, too. The real pressure of the game is from the ticking clock of foiling the Elder One, not the monsters coming for you, right? And I I think I definitely agree with that and and that now now knowing that mentality, it might be the mentality shift that I need to enjoy the game as well, which is what I'm hoping. Yeah.

Um, that was the mentality shift I needed to enjoy Dune Imperium was knowing that the intrigue cards are are w wildly variable in efficacy depending on when you get them. and knowing that and I was like great, love that. Now I know what those are.

Boom. Love the game. It's in my top 10. You know what I mean? But

and I'm so glad you brought that up. Like uh friends as you watch this, you know, we may be disappointed by these games, but we're also open to other opinions and maybe we have seen it in a in a different, you know, way and maybe we are wrong and um so let us know again either in the comments or here live in chat. Let us know your experiences and uh we may, you know, give these games another shot like Chris is going to do with Cthulu, Death May Die. Yeah. fear with the unknown.

And and I'd also like to say that my openness stops now.

Of my next two, I'm not open to.

I love it. What about Jade? What does Jade think?

Well, um

I hate everything. I hate everything you love. I hate everything you love. I never will love. Jade. Jade. Please.

You know, I just got to say this. I am sure that many years ago, many moons ago, when Roto decided to start his channel, he knew that there was going to be a doll eventually stalking his channel. Did he know? Or is this the last time you see Chris George on an R&R show? Who can tell? Who can tell? Big The biggest disappointment is Jade Jade recurring in this, but at least it's not the whisperer. Um, who's this stupid little character that I have on my channel as well.

I love it. Bring them all over here to the channel. That's

Yeah. Sorry. Sorry for everybody's ears. Jada knocked over my mic. So sorry everybody. I'll I'll ask Jade to be more respectful.

Okay.

Who who knows what she'll do.

While Chris is talking to Jade, why don't we move on to our number eight on the collective list of most disappointing games of 2024. Uh this is mine. My number eight is a game called Umbrella. Um I was really looking forward to this one because of the designer. The designer is someone named Benois Torpin. And you may that game a name from the game Welcome to. It is a modern-day Rolland Wright Classic or Roll or Flip and Wright Classic. And he was the brains behind Umbrella. Uh, which is again a fine game. Uh, this is a game about Umbrellas that you see on um basically on a New York sidewalk. You are viewing them from above. And honestly, this is the thing that disappointed me honestly was like the theme really doesn't come through this game. This is an abstract game in its heart, folks. You have these discs or all the different colors. You're going to take them and um as you can see here in the video, you're just placing them on your playerboard, the ones on the left and right there, and you're trying to line them up to make patterns to match the patterns, and you're going to score those patterns as you match them up. Um what you do is you're going to take either from your left or right in a two-player game one of those uh disc or umbrellas um from your opponent and either slide it to the left or right, or you can take one vertically. So, you can go up or down. And as you slide them in, you're going to push one out and that's going to go on the other player board.

So, they have different choices. And then as you complete patterns, um, you're trying to be the first to do them, you know, to get the most points. You're going to sl uh take those off of your board and then place them on uh another player's board. There are different colors that you can match up as well. Um, one thing I did like about the game, I don't want, you know, again, I try not to be too negative. I do appreciate the colorblind accessibility in this game. the different colors. They do have different patterns, so it's easy to tell. But overall, Chris, I was uh Oh, it was it was a fine like little abstract puzzle, I guess. And I actually preferred it as a solo game where I can just, you know,

do it real quick. And I played it a few times, and it's one of those games that it was fine, but it just did not, you know, I I don't want to play anymore. I just don't have any reason to. But, which is the complete opposite of Welcome 2. Like, when I first played Welcome 2, I could not stop playing that game. Literally, I was playing it like every day, multiple times a day. Umbrella

just did not hit with me or uh my gaming group. And that's why it's our number eight on the list of most disappointing games of 2024.

Yeah, that uh yeah, I hadn't heard of it. Again, it's it's one that uh sort of has flown under the radar. Um yeah, you can't st it can't stand under your umbrella. Elmo, Ella, A.

I'm so glad you made that reference of

Elmo. I guess we'll go to Richard now.

Yeah, let's go to Richard. But I got to say the same reference. If you if you're not tired of Chris reference, go check out my solo playthrough of Umbrella for the exact same joke. Okay. Um, speaking of Richard, Richard, what do you have for us at number seven? Okay, continuing on. Chris Cthulu, Death May Die, Fear of the Unknown. H, I don't know. Definitely not a game for me. Interesting. You put an expansion on here. I had one expansion, which I'll talk about in my extended list, that literally made one of my favorite games actually worse. Is that what happens with Fear of the Unknown? I don't know. Uh, but it can't all be winners. And then Ruel, what was number eight? Um, Umbrella. I have not played this. I don't know much about it other than it was co-designed by Benois Turpin, you know, and that's the Welcome to guy. So, I would have definitely wanted to check this out because Welcome to is phenomenal. one of the best rolling rights out there, you know, especially welcome to um um the uh the space one. So, welcome to the moon.

Yeah. But anyway, uh I look forward to hearing what you have to say. Uh how uh you know, Benois broke your heart with umbrella. But anyway, uh now we got to move on to number seven. But before we do that, let's continue with the surroundings. I am in the sun room of this house that we have here in Ireland. It is amazing what we were able to get. We when we left America, we sold an old dilapitated uh broken down um what do you call it? Uh manufactured home. And the money we made off of that paid for this mansion or Irish-sized mansion. Um including this amazing sun room, which is where Jen and I spend all of our time. These are our views. Uh here is Jen just stopping to say hi, honey. Bye. Actually, I'm saying it wasn't a It was not a dilapidated manufactured home and everything. It was nice.

It was a nice manufactured home, but it was well worn, let's say.

Let's say it was, but we also pumped dollars or some insane amount of money into it when we sold it because we didn't do any maintenance while we were there.

Oh, that's true. Yes. Yes. Yeah. Yeah. We had Oh my gosh. So much stuff that had to be done and everything. Oh god. Anyway, but no, we lived in a nice place.

Yes. Okay,

we live in a much nicer place now.

Uh, anyway, continuing on the tour as Jen goes back to getting ready for our trip in and I and this Oh, that is an 82 in Samsung, which is crazy. It just barely fits on the wall. Um, I actually got that in a tradein because um I had a 60-in TV and it died. I took it to a repair shop and they said, "Yeah, I can repair it for you. You want to trade in though and upgrade?" And I did. So, this only costs like strictly speaking a couple hundred bucks this TV uh off the trade-in value. Um although it's so heavy we had to get some little um uh post to sit there. Uh this is Jen's favorite place to sit and look out at the uh landscape. Although she also loves sitting in that rocking chair and she loves sitting in that reclining chair. And this is the couch that I'm normally on. As you can see, Daisy likes it too. She is keeping an eye on the surroundings. Uh but anyway, the tour will continue, but I put it off long enough. Number seven on our combined list is Worms. And again, I'm sure there are collective gasps. Uh, this made a lot of people's top 10 for last year as well, but not mine. This one broke my heart. And I'll tell you why. Wingspan is one of the greatest modern designs of all time. It's absolutely fantastic.

Taking that design and turning it into a dragon game. Oh my gosh, I was so up for that because I like birds, but I love dragons. And all you had to do was just give me dragons and um not mess up the gameplay. They messed up the gameplay of Wingspan. They made Wingspan worse by introducing all these extra complicated elements to what was a very brilliant, elegant, um, you know, triple engine builder. Now, Worms is a triple engine builder where you're taking care of dragons instead of birds. But all the fun stuff of Wingspan, building the engine, running your engines, trying to synchronize your engines, you still get to do them all, but now there's all these extra steps in the way that prevent you from doing it as much as you used to get to do it. It was like a huge downer. Um, you know, I mean, a lot of people think it's the best, but I for me it just added complexity for no good reason and made one of the greatest games of all time just a oh, it's a good euro now. And uh oh, and then plus they totally blew it on the uh flavor text.

Don't get me started on that. But anyway, all that combined is why um Worms comes in at number seven. Ouch.

Ouch. Worms. Collective gasp everyone. Wow. I didn't see that one coming. And

no. Yeah. Have you played Worms Span?

I have not. And uh actually because I know at least three people in my gaming circles that they all pretty much said what Richard said. They're like, "It wasn't as good as I thought it was going to be." Yeah.

See, I've I've heard I've just heard good things. My buddy Zach played I haven't played it, but uh he liked the additional action economy. And uh I think people who think that the that Wingspan has an egg problem. Uh thinks that worms Worms fixes the egg problem. I love Worms. Richard's wrong. Richard's wrong.

Oh my god. Jade. Jade. Where? I don't know where she's coming from. I just last over over there and then she It's weird. I don't know. Um, yeah, but uh, yeah, Hexra saying, "Worms span was fun until I suffered through someone's 20-minute turn thanks to the extra coin mechanic." And to that, Hextra, I just have to say maybe you should get good and get that extra coin for yourself. I I don't know. I've never played Worms. I'm excited to try it. Uh, my buddy Zach liked it, so I am curious about now. actually. So, I've actually really enjoyed uh Finsspan, which is the slim down version of Wingspan, and I thought that was excellent. Again, it wasn't it's not a, you know, as heavy as Wingspan, or I definitely not as as much as Warp Span, but I felt like they just streamlined down the experience to what it was really a terrific game. So, maybe that's the one to check out, folks, if you want something, you know, streamlined and uh I thought it was a fantastic game, Finsspan. But um we're talking about disappointments now and uh on the RNR and J show today. Um

why don't we go back to Chris before he scares me with Jade again.

Hey, it's not me. It's not me. My hands are up here. Okay, my hands are Wouldn't it be great if Jade popped in the frame when I did that? That's what we're Richard through Richard's next uh next one. Um um yeah, we're on to me. Our number six is Fellowship. The dumbest title ever. Fellowship of the Ring tricktaking game. Get out of here.

Yeah. It's the trick taking game. It doesn't say Lord of the Rings. I think it's just Fellowship of the Ring tricktaking game. It's Isn't the trick-taking game? No, it's just ridiculous. Uh it somebody said, "Oh, you know what was good? The crew. Let's put um a Lord of the Rings IP on it and make it worse." Uh, and if they if that was your goal, then yes, you did it. Um, here's the thing. I I actually don't think this is is that bad of a game. I think it's fine. But but like when you have the crew as your baseline and the crew, which is sort of enjoyed by so many people and same with Crew Deep Sea, and then you come out with like, okay, we're going to do a trick taking game a as the Fellowship of the Ring. And you only have 21 scenarios in this uh because there's 21 chapters that you go on where you're adding in new new characters which are basically just new goals, right? Like if you're Frodo, you always have to win the trick of the one ring. If you're if you're Sam, you know, you'll pick a card and you have to win that type of card or you can't win that type of card, right? Like Mary can only win one trick. So they all just have different things. Um, and then like 10 of those 21 scenarios are boring and basic. Like what are you doing really?

It it it like how are you not crafting more interesting scenarios and you aren't even giving us the same size amount of scenarios as what the uh as what the game like was what as what the crew does. I'm getting distracted by John Trip who's saying uh lo fo t r ttg for sure but it's not Lord of the Rings. It's in fact it is specifically not Lord of the Rings the Fellowship of the Ring trick taking game. It is just Fellowship of the Ring trickt taking game. So if you're searching for it on BGG which I was I'm like Lord of the Rings Lord of the Rings trick taking and because BGG is still an archaic bad system that they don't even have an auto correct or they don't have like anything to implement. Did you mean this? If you make one like typo of mistake, well, this is more than just a typo. You're never going to find it. You're never finding it. And you're also never finding it buried under the amount of Lord of the Rings IP games there are. I I love Lord of the Rings.

It's great, but there can only be so many IP games. And and I want this to rise above the IP mess. You know, you get those games like Battlestar Galactica that are an IP, but are more than an IP. And like that's what we should be striving for, not just cashing in on uh on on an IP. And so while this is a good game and the production quality is very good, um I I still I had a fun time with it. We played our little card game. We Oh, yeah. Box says Lord of the Rings. BG does not. Yeah. Also, come on. Thank you. Thank you, John Trip. Um yeah, like I had a I again I had a fine fine time with it. It is a fine game. It is okay. it is worthwhile playing through. Sure. And passing on to someone else maybe. Um but like the resetting aspect, the crew does it better. You know, all everything I could say was like, "Oh, the crew does it better." There was one interesting scenario where you were playing against the big ant and a new set of cards got introduced and then like Tree Beard would flip up a card and that would be a random card that Tree Beard would add in. And so you're trying to like balance of okay, do we want Tree Beard to win these or somebody else that was fine, but it just like it just wasn't it's just you know what it was?

It was disappointing. Um beautifulity, but just ultimately disappointing.

Wow. That Okay, I I'm sure this is going to be generate a bunch of comments because

Okay, so I haven't played through the entire Fellowship of the Ring trick taking game, but I really enjoyed my experience with it. Uh, for the first couple of chapters, I thought it was super thematic. Um, I was very impressed by how they took the characters and made them feel like I mean, it felt like playing characters in a trick-taking game, which I guess I didn't really get that feeling in the crew. Chris, remind me. Was there were there characters in the crew that you played as?

No, you just you just divvy out your goals essentially, right? But but if you wanted to put a a person's picture on every one of those goals and say this is this is um Harry High card who wants the high card, you could like would that would that have elevated your crew experience? Cuz like to me that's what that name alone Harry card. Yeah. Yeah. Uh pinky uh pinky power nine. Pinky power pose. You know what I mean? Oh, he wants uh he wants the nine of pink. Oh, boy. Like,

wow. So, I have I I went further in the crew when I played the crew. I I didn't play Mission Deep Sea, but I did go through the original crew up until a certain point and then with Lord of the Rings or Fellowship of the Rings, I only went through maybe like about three or four chapters. I really enjoyed what I played, but you obviously played more than I than I have. So, just was it

but but let's be real, Ruel. You you you you did three to four chapters. They were all the same and then you put it down. And when when was that?

Um last year sometime. Yeah.

Yeah. Has it been pulling it? And it's a very easy game to get to the table. Has it been pulling at your heartstrings?

Well, good point, Chris.

It hasn't.

Yeah.

It is not.

Yeah. Okay. Well, as far as like the IP is concerned, I feel like I it captured the flavor of the IP. Now, I'm not the biggest Lord of the Rings fan. Admittedly, I'm not a L I'm, you know, I'm not a Lord of the Rings guy, but I felt like the the theme really came through in the gameplay uh for what it was. Um, you know, I mean, fair point or

Yeah.

Okay.

I mean, there there was the one ring.

Yeah. Right.

So, and rings were Trump.

Okay.

So, so there you go. Okay.

And Froto needed to get the ring,

right? Yeah. He needs to get

And there were there were the riders. There were the Nausegoul who were like, "Stay away from twos. Uhoh, twos going to get you." So, like, I guess there was that.

Oh my gosh. Well, I'm curious to hear what you all think. Let us know in the comments what you think of Chris's take because I had a good time with it. Um, but I think I Yeah, you know, I'm going to go back to my copy of The Crew and I want to put down Harry High number on one of

Harry High card. Yeah,

Harry High card. Yeah,

Harry High card.

Awesome. Thank you, Chris. Let's move on to our number five. And this is going to be my choice. Now,

as Okay, I'm I got to just be totally honest here. As we put together this list, this game came up and I started writing, I was like, "Yeah, this is really disappointing." But the more I thought about it, Chris, I'm like, I think I like this game a lot more than I gave it credit for originally. So, it's our number five. It's a game called Tower Up. Um,

I had heard about this game I think at either Gen Con or one of the conventions last year or the year before and it really did get hyped up and I was really looking forward to it. It is a um city builder. You're build you're actually literally have these little plastic pieces of buildings that you're going to stack on each other 3D uh 3D style and it's got a ticket to ride sort of element where you're going to do one of two things. you're either picking up cards for resources or you're going to actually build the buildings on the board. Um, it does has a really great table presence, especially at the end of the game. You have this, you know, downtown part of the city that's, you know, been renovated with all your buildings. And I don't know, it just it fell flat for me. Um, I I should say I've played this at two players, so maybe I'll like it better with more players. And I think part of it too was I had right before I played this, I played a game called Skyrise, which I thought was a phenomenal building uh type of game where you are using auctioning um an auction mechanism to build uh your buildings on on a city board. Whereas like this, and this is Kimberly Tolson of Tabletop Tolson of playing through it. Again, I I I'm looking at this and I I feel like I was disappointed that I didn't like it as much as other folks, but the more I thought about it and the more I'm watching this video, I'm like, "Oh, I sort of want to play this again." Um because it has that ticket to ride element that I really love where the turns themselves are really simple.

Either get more resources or build something, but then as you go, there are limitations to where you can build, like you have to have an open space adjacent to another building. And those like really um like especially in a two-player game, they got it got tight really quick. And eventually you're going to have to, you know, put a little roof on your building to end it there. So that's going to stop right there. And as you can see in Kimberly's runthrough, you have the player boards. So the different pieces that you place uh on the board, they go up and level. So each track and then when you get all four tracks lined up, like when they all pass like a certain point, then you get an extra turn. So that was really cool. And maybe that's part of my frustration, too, cuz I played with someone who was really good at this game. Darn you, Jake Michaels at Good Time Society. Um, he he like rocked it. Like he just had his timing down where every it seemed like he got extra turns when they're like really beneficial and I couldn't get that, you know? So, what I'm trying to say is I suck at this game, but I want to give it another shot because I feel like I like it. But, I was disappointed maybe in my my play, but also it just didn't live up to the hype. But again, this is the type of thing, folks, where I'm I'm willing to admit I need to try this one again. Chris, it it's got a great table presence and I want to give it another shot.

Well, it it it seems like it also could can suffer from that thing that like Hexra was saying with with Worms of like, oh, when somebody else gets all those like extra turns and then you don't and you're just sitting there watching, like that also doesn't necessarily lend itself to a great game experience as well too. If if it has the potential for someone to just be like, "Okay, at least with Everddale at the end, you can go off and get a snack cuz you're done." you know, if somebody's still got like a few more turns to play through. Um,

but yeah, like if it's mid game, you're like, "Okay, well, I got to pay attention to whatever this freaking guy's doing."

Yeah, it's like I have no snacks. I got to watch his extra turn. This is the worst of both worlds, you know? But yeah, so I I'm definitely going to give it another shot. I I think because I played it so like close to Skyrise, which I love Skyrise because it has this bidding mechanisms that's really clever where you use your buildings to bid on certain spots and if you win the building, you could build there, but if you lose and you get your building back. This didn't have that. It was a little more I I don't know. Well, it's definitely more familyfriendly. Um, but I don't know if I'd call it a family friendly or a family game because it's it's definitely heavier than Ticket to Ride. But still, I was

disappointed in my play and the expectations of this game, but willing to give it another shot, friends. So, that is our number five tower up. And um let's go back to Richard for our number four. Richard, take it away. Okay, continuing on. Chris, I'm surprised we agree. Uh, Fellowship of the Ring Trick Checker. It was fine. It was It was good. It was a very well done thing, but I went in hoping this was going to be my Tolken replacement for The Crew or The Crew in Middle Earth, and it is nowhere near as good as The Crew as a cooperative trick taker. Not that there aren't a lot of really good elements, and it's really nicely thematic, and the production is great, and I like the art. Uh there's a lot to recommend here, but The Crew is so much better because of one little trick um in the trick taking that uh token you can use once per round to give a little bit of extra information to your teammates. That one element so elevates the crew. And sadly, Fellowship of the Ring Trick Taker did not have anything even remotely like it.

Uh, you know, Kimberly liked it, but um, you know, a lot of people love it, but not not for me, unfortunately. I'll I'll take the crew or crew Mission Deep Sea especially over that one. And so I was a bit disappointed. And Ruel, what the heck again? um you know tower up from the design team of you know Botanic and um you know Anchor and Jaipur. What are you talking about? I'm I'm very surprised I didn't get a chance to play this one. I am really looking forward to hearing what you have to say, sir. Um but anyway, before we get to number four, let's continue with the uh um tour. There's our caravan. We're going to be a week from today. We're getting in it and going on a threemonth road trip heading over to Essence Spiel and then hanging all over the place in Europe. Um, very much looking forward to that. And uh, you know, actually Jen is in the process of loading it up right now because she always likes to load ahead of time. But that's not the view you want. You want this view.

Yeah, you saw it from the sun room. Here it is in person. It is absolutely amazing. when um we when November 7th happened and uh you know I heard the news, I got online, started looking at Irish real estate uh within a day found this thing and Jen and I knew we had to move. Uh and we are so happy here. It is so amazing every day. And again, oh I apologize by the way for the bleeping on the previous entry. Jen said after, you know, I don't necessarily want to tell people how much we had to spend to renovate the manufactured home. It was a lot. It was a nice little home. Uh, fortunately though, even with all that renovation we had to do to sell it. Um, still the profit we made off that manufactured home, paid for this thing, paid for all of this. It is amazing what you can get in Ireland if you're not trying to live in a big city. Yes, there is definitely a housing uh shortage crisis in Ireland in all the big cities, but if you go out into the country, this is what you can get for a relatively modestpriced American home. Uh, you know, and I highly recommend it. But anyway, enough of that. It's time for number four. Again, I don't like talking about this folks, but um Uve Rosenberg broke my heart in 2024 with Black Forest. And now this is uh basically a remake sequel to one of his all-time greatest designs um glass road still one of Jensen my favorites and I was looking

forward to um you know the uh the the the tile building and all of that but you know put into a new system that was really really cool this board traversal thing to get the tiles to build up rather than the really neat mind games of the original Glass Road. So, I was very excited especially because as I understand it, Glass Road was the or I'm sorry, Glass Road's original design was actually Black Forest, but the publisher thought, "Oh, this is too heavy. It's too complex. Let's do Glass Road, a simplified version of instead." So, I'm like, "Oh, already the Glass Road big uh box edition, you know, the the big brother, the big sibling." But, um, and it is great. It is great. I can see why so many people love it. But it broke my heart because to make it a two-player game, her Rosenberg made it an incredibly cut-throat thing where there's basically like an extra worker moving around on the board uh that you have to control in addition to your own and the only reason you make decisions for it is to move to places to block your opponent and screw with them. The game would be amazing at a higher player count. And there were so many ways that this game could have been done to tighten up the board for two player without having to make players constantly every turn think about how they can screw each other over. It was just ah such a way what do you call it in sports? It's a a self-inforced error or something like that. I mean they so missed it. I think in my original run through in my final thoughts I talked about they could have done it this way or this way or this way or this way.

They could have made it a positive thing instead of a negative thing. But instead, uh, it is one of, as a two-player game, one of the most cutthroat games that Uveu Rosenberg has ever designed, and that is why it broke my heart. Number four, Black Forest.

Wow. Her Rosenberg lets down Richard. I really enjoyed Blast Road, so that's a bummer to hear about uh Black Forest. Um, I had not played Black Forest, but yeah, I had heard about it. I heard good things about it, but apparently uh Richard didn't care for it. So

yeah, I I haven't I haven't heard um a guy get out of Oh my Oh my god, you sound my hands. Don't do it all the way. Don't you do it. Don't you do it.

Oh god. Good. Jade. Jade. Where did Where did she come from? You saw my hands were up here. You saw my hands were there. Oh my god. That's for Blackboard Gaming. Who said who said Roy? Chris, it's very rare they catch the show live. I'm loving Jade.

Yeah,

that's for you, Dwayne.

Uh, shout out to Stacey Everddale mentions. I'm so happy for Richard living such a wonderful life. Yeah, Richard, folks, those those clips right there. I'm like so envious of that view and um glad to see him and Jenner doing well and really a nice little treat for the RNR show to uh see behind the scenes what's going on with Richard there. And also, I'm going to have nightmares, folks, about Jade tonight. I'm

Well, Tyler's dad said Jade scared my dog. Sorry. Sorry, Tyler. Sorry, Tyler.

Sorry, D. Um, uh, Stacy also says, "I played Black Forest two player. I didn't feel it was cutthroat. I moved the merchant to benefit me, not to hurt other players. Not sure why Richard played it differently. Felt very helpful." Well, just Richard Richard's just uh going for that cutthroat. You can't you can't allow him to be cutthroat because he he's he's just too tempting.

Just can't help him.

Too tempting.

Can't help himself. That's what we've learned here. So,

that's it. Exactly. Yeah. Now, now you just talk about this game. Now, I want to play Glass Road. It's been way too long since I played Glass Road. I always love that um resource wheel or whatever. So, yeah. Cool, cool, cool. Why don't we move on? Uh Chris, you've got our next game on the list. Uh what is going on

with

I do. Unfortunately, I do.

Unfortunately, I do. Um this game, I'm very glad it was it came out in 2024 because I was having trouble with this list and then I saw that this came out in 2024 and I thought, "Oh, great. The worst game in the entirety of the world came out in 2024. That sounds I can definitely add that to the list.

Wow.

Um and and so I've gone off on this game in two of my two videos on my channel. Okay. Um one when I first played it and then one when I was talking about like games that I hated. My patrons maybe do a games that I hate deathmatch and uh pitted the games that I hate against each other. Um this is it's not it's don't worry Hextra. It's not that. Uh, it it is it is um the bad karmas and the curse of the zodiac. That's what it is. Wow. Because I have to have played it. So, I can't include a certain expansion that may have come out in 2024 because I haven't yet played that. Um, so the bad karma curse of the zodiac comes from the Tabaru or Taburu system which um is bad uh and it shouldn't exist and they were like this is the next gen thing for board gaming. No, you know what the next generation thing for board gaming is?

Just what what it's been doing or anything else probably. Just literally anything other than the Tabaru Taburu system. It is atrocious. So the Toru system is like whoa, we got this this magic map that you can just put things on. It's going to sense what those things are because it's electronic. And you can even play with people from afar because like they'll be able to see it and and the game knows what when you're moving things around. The game doesn't know. It doesn't work like that. The game actually makes you play a game for it is what happens. You have a big boss monster and it's like, "Yeah, now the boss monster turns and it's it goes. It's turning on the app." And then it's like, "Have you turned it? Have you turned your monster? Have you turned the monster on the thing? We're supposed to know if you have. That's literally the purpose of this system. But have you done it?" Okay, press okay. Okay, great.

And then it shatters you across the room. Yeah. Okay, everybody put put where all your people got pushed to on the room. Put that down. Nope. No, you didn't put it in the right spot. You didn't You didn't put it in the right spot. Did you do it? Did you do it? No. Did Okay. No, you didn't do it. You didn't do it. You didn't put it in the right spot. Put it in the right spot. And so you're playing this boss battler, which the game is constantly interrupting to to be like, "Look at this innovative system." And you can roll the dice and the dice knows that you're rolling it and you throw it on the on the table. It's like, "You've got this result." But you could, they're the easiest dices to just shake and then place down. And the game's like, "You did it." And you're like, "No." And it feels better to cheat this way because I'm tricking this stupid stupid system. Um, but all of that aside, the gameplay also sucks. It's a It's like, oh, this amazing boss battle you can get. You have 24 characters. They're all going to do cool different things. The characters are like you you have this app in front of you and you're just pushing these cards willy-nilly on this app. these cards which will tell you do an axe slash, do an axe throw, do an axe hit, what stance are you going to be? Does the game ever explain who cares about stances? Not really. It's just like you you know when you go to BGA and you're like, I'm going to try to learn a game through BGA and just punch at it like a monkey at a typewriter and then pretend I learned the game. That's what Bad Karma's full experience is. Even doing the tutorial is like this. It's like, ah, just hit things. Whoa, you know the you know the game now. It's like, no,

you don't. It's like, "Oh, I did damage to the monster. How much?" We're not telling. Which I actually like, I like that in theory, but then it's just annoying. It's like, "You're dead. How do I revive myself? We're not going to tell you." Um, wow. It's like, "Oh, okay. Now there are all these little cardboard things that you can put out, little little gems that you can put on the board, which we can't actually sense. Oh, no. We didn't think about that. Did you put it on the board? Great. Now those explode for no reason, and you take damage. Did we tell you they were going to explode?" No. Is any of this satisfying? No, it's like you can upgrade your cards if you hit people enough with them, but the cards do all the same thing. It's like, oh, six melee damage or seven melee damage with a chance to bleed yourself or eight melee damage with a chance to do like it's not these aren't innovative uh things.

They're not fun actions to go through. It's just absolutely horrible. It's so horrible. Cosmic Beef said, "Oh boy, a tear rant." You're freaking right. There is one. Everyone should stay away. Oh yeah, I was talking about it in my latest crowdfunding countdown, too. I'm so passionate that no one should get this system and it should die a horrible, horrible death. And I'm sorry to those of you who have had fun with the TERO system um because you must also have fun. Uh here, I've got a game for you. Why don't you come over to my house and I'll tell you where I want you to put all the pieces. You don't get to play the game. I'm going to play the game, but you're going to move it for me. Does that sound fun? Cuz then you can come on over and do that cuz that's essentially what Too is doing. And also, I'm not going to explain to you the rules of the game, and I'm not going to um like give you any dopamine hits whatsoever. I'm just going to have random things happen to you. And you know, in like a boss battler where you can start to learn the boss's behavior because you're like, "Oh, okay. That I'm sure I start out not knowing anything about it, but I learn its behavior. I dodge under here. I'm no, you're not going to learn that. It's not going to you're not going to learn anything.

You're going to learn that the boss has turned this way and its base is flashing red." And I'm like, "Okay, I'll try to get to the side where it's red so I can do a critical hit." And they're like, "Just kidding. Random event happened again. You get thrown across the cavern. I'm like, I spent my whole turn walking across here. Like, aren't you gonna let me like do a critical hit and feel good? Nope. The boss is now in the light for some reason. And whoa, that's the way to kill it. Oh, how did that happen? Cuz he just ran in there for no reason because I pushed him one space. Whoopity freaking do. Can I plan around doing that ever again? No. It's just like the game is boring. Yeah. Even if the system worked, the game is boring. 100% Sean, that's it. Um, the st so good game must buy. Yes. Yeah, that's what you should love. Taboo. Yeah. No, this this is just horrible. It's horrible. It's just bad.

Stay far away. It is so disappointing. Uh like and my expectations weren't high for this to be clear. Like disappointment means your expectations are high. My expectations were I guess this will be fine. It's probably too expensive for what it is, but I expect there to be a game.

No. No. my expectations were here and the game is in the the subterranean second level of Earth. That's how horror it is. It's just bad. Um so, you know, um ultimately I didn't like it that much.

Yeah.

It's funny because I'm looking at the trailer. The trailer actually looks really cool for this game, but

Yeah. Yeah. Because it's it's Well, it's like, oh, we're going to do all this cinematic stuff. No, you're not. You're going to look at cinematic things and then you're going to be like, "Can I do anything fun?" No. This is why trailers that don't ever show you gameplay, you're like, "Who cares?" You know,

just the little snippet of the components. I was like, "Oh, this looks interesting." With the little light up figure and and things, but I had I had never heard of this game, Chris, and just based on your explanation, I'm looking forward to backing it the next Kickstart. No, I'm like I I will stay away as well.

You know, I must have in a past life have gotten something to give me a ton of bad karma cuz that's all it is. If you want to gift somebody some bad karma, you know, if you want to say that you life has been bad to you or you deserve pain and suffering, you can give them this game.

Oh man. Yeah. How do you really feel about this game, Chris? No. Um,

lites got a rant. Yeah. Yeah. The gear is themselves a lite. They must be lites. The company creating them must be comprised only of lites because they clearly don't understand technology. Remember how we were saying that technology was was going bad at the beginning of this stream? Uh, you haven't seen Bad Technology until you've seen the TER system.

I I'm I'm curious though. So, because I haven't heard of this game, I don't know the reaction around it. Did it like really Was it a huge Kickstarter campaign? Did it really

It It did well. It's still doing well. It's like latest thing because the the software itself is so expensive. They're like, "Yeah, to even play this game, you have to buy our Toru system, which is like £150 or something."

Oh my gosh.

It's like or 150 euro, right? it it's like, yeah, buy this thing and then you can play a very mediocre game on top of it and maybe we'll give you something good eventually down the line. Maybe perfect for crowdfunding. Uh cuz that's the, you know, the mentality for a lot of it. But yeah, just just awful. Yeah,

I know this is this is um not new information to uh to anybody who's watch who watches Ruin Board, but um I hopefully it's the last chance I I have to talk. I had to do it on a different channel, team. I had to do it on Roto's channel, too. Spread the good news.

We are happy to hear your rant. Um, that was phenomenal. Um, and

I agree with everything Chris has said.

I'm just going to say, what's Jade think about? Oh my god.

Thank you, Jade. Jade loves it. Yeah,

also hates it.

Well, I'm going to We're going to move on to our number two, then Richard's going to follow after me. Uh, our collective number two is definitely not Bad Karma. U, it's a game. It's a cute little game that I was looking forward to. Our number two is called Zooies. Uh this is a tile laying game based on doggos. Uh cute dogs and you're laying down tiles and um that's pretty much it. It's uh just a well I don't know Carcassoneish. Uh you have a stack of tiles. You're going to draw two, place one, and then you're going to place a scoring token. The scoring tokens may score the bones that are on the dog tile or they're going to score a pack of dogs. You have leaders that can uh score different dogs that are adjacent. And that's pretty much it. You take turns.

This is a two-player runthrough that I did on my channel. It's a very It's a fine little simple game. Um, and that's pretty much all I have to say about it. It was It was disappointing in the fact that I love dogs. I have two pugs named Meeple and Mookie and we love our dogs. We are dog people here in this household.

I got this game. I was like, "Yes, dogs. We love dogs. Yes, Tile Lane. We love Tile Lane. We played it." Okay, that's pretty much it. That was a fine game. We're going to move on and play something else. Um it it was it was fine, Chris. Um but it's something did not compel me uh much and it didn't the expectations were high because of the theme and then after playing it um the theme was there but the game play was just a-ok okay um elements that are what we're all familiar with as gamers and um again if if if you never played a modern game I'm sure this would be fine but for those of us in the hobby that are deep in the hobby uh when we're not playing bad karmas we are definitely playing this and it it was Okay. Um, but

honestly, that's that's maybe the most brutal takedown I've ever heard from you in my life. For well, because I know you're so nice, you're like, you know, if you've never played a game, modern game before, maybe you'd like it.

That feels like the most brutal thing that you've that you've said. I was I will admit I was distracted throughout that because I was thinking I was wondering um if Hansen Gluke has ever uh has showed up at your door and tried to steal your pug from you, saying, "No, this is ours. Mele's ours. Well, you know, because I'm here.

Yeah. No, because I'm here in the US, the mele um word is actually copyrighted by Corey Thompson. And with Corey Thompson, all he asked for in the US is to use the word mele. Give him some candy. And I have given him candy so I can use the word mele. So, Hanslook did not come out here and try to get take my dog.

There we go. Yeah. Corey Thompson doing the doing the board gaming the US board gaming lord's work.

Exactly. Yeah. Shout out to Corey Thompson. But uh you know what? Yeah, Zoomies. Um that's pretty much all I have to say. I wanted to I really wanted to love this game, Chris. And you know, I feel like if they would have put a couple of pugs named Muki and Mele, maybe it would have made better. Who knows?

But honestly, let's blame Hans and Gluke then because they were gonna But Hans and Gluke were they got scared off.

That's right. Okay, we're no longer scared. We're going to move to Richard and find out what the number one game on this list is.

Okay, coming down to the big ones. And finally, Chris, I was getting disappointed that you were saying things that I agreed with, but bad karmas and the curse of zodiac. Oh man, Chris, you are so missing the boat on this. Now, I won't deny that, you know, there might be some teething with this game. You know, any first product, any kind of, you know, significant uh technological breakthrough is going to have some teething pains. I agree with that. Uh I and I only got to play with a prototype of it. I never actually tried the final version, but I think this game is incredibly important, its existence for the long-term health of the industry. And I don't know what you said here in this show, but I did watch what you said on your own channel about it because it blew my mind that you said this. And honestly, every complaint you had about this game in that video is literally just old man shouting at cloud stuff.

Quite frankly, everything you said um like what was your big complaint in that video that Oh, everything could have been done with an app. Hey Chris, that's true for every board game in existence. All of them could be apps. There's nothing new there. You had nothing interesting to say about it. Um complaining about how it recogniz you know the rolling of the dice. That was ridiculous. Um, I'm reminded of the when I have played this war of mine with a uh a very good board game designer, Gordon Ka, you know, the designer of um oh, Vengeance and Fate Forge and all of that. And I was explaining to him how this war of mine plays. And he complained about, well, I I need all the information. this game wants me to make decisions without knowing all the strategic um you know, you know, permutations or issues that I might face, you know, all the consequences of my choices. And I'm like, "Dude, you're in a war zone. You don't know that.

You're a civilian. Just make a choice. It's to do what you would do in real life." And he's like, "Oh, yeah. I don't have to play a game with peak super efficient strategy every single move. I can just go with the flow and see what the simulation does." That's what this game does. and you complaining about it just means you're a bit of a grogard. Is that the term? You're you're basically being a board game gatekeeper. Uh because this game, the number one thing that keeps board games from breaking through to the mass market is freaking rulebooks and how how hard it is with the barrier for entry. This game destroys that barrier for entry. And it seems like you're a bit frustrated by that because you can't know all the permutations of everything. and you're just supposed to go with the flow and you allow the app to help you through the game. It's not for you, man. It's for new players who would love to play something like um Gloom Haven but could never ever crack that code. This game allows for that. It is a bright, bold potential future for our favorite hobby.

Dude, you got it so wrong. Anyway, uh let's move on. Rel Zooies, I think this is three for three that you've covered games that I really want to try. Although actually I did like a look at zooies and I figured, oh, as much as I love dogs, I don't think that's going to work for me and Jen either. So that's a bit of a heartbreaker. But now we move on to number one. But before we do that, uh, hey, I'm in the caravan now. It's the tiniest little thing. Look at it. There's basically two benches. Um, they slide. There's a thing that slides out and then we can put a couple cushions down so it becomes basically one. Um, it's not a queen size. It's like a a twin, I think, or something like that. We've uh been doing some experimenting with. That was one of the reasons we were on that trip that we filmed last time um when we went over to the UK for a few days. We had to do some other stuff. And uh but anyway, yeah, this is the this is the spot. We've got um some nice overhead. We got some under um we've got a lot of light. Uh this thing has one, two big skylights. And oh, I'm so proud of this. I just have to show this off. Let me open this and let me see if I can get out here. I spent the last couple of months installing solar on the whole thing. This was all me, thanks to YouTube and AI um helped me walk through all this, how to install these, how to wire them up, and um it works great.

Five panels, each one of them was only 50 bucks uh from China, and they're really high quality things. Uh great job America giving the solar industry to China. I'm enjoying my Chinese solar panels. Um anyway though, uh what else? Oh, and then there's the kitchen. Like I said, Jen's in the process of loading up and we're trying to figure out how best to stack this thing. Here is a bathroom. It's one of the wet ones where, you know, it is the shower and the toilet. And there's this little thing that basically you put this door out to keep your toilet paper dry if you take a shower in here because everything else uh can just handle the water. And uh that's going to be our home. This little thing plus that car right out there with that roof rack is going to be us for the next three months. Wish us luck. I imagine next time you see an RNR, I'll be on the road u who knows where as we don't know when the next RNR is. Anyway though, tour over. Time for the number one most disappointing game of 2024.

Clank Legacy 2 Acquisitions Incorporated Darkest Magic. And before I get going, uh, as a counterpoint to how upset this game made me, my wife loved it to pieces. It was probably her game of the month, and she wishes we were still playing it to this day. But I got to say, folks, in my entire life of what am I now, 56 years old, I think, I don't know that I have ever been more furious at a game, board game, video game, you name it. um as I was trying to play through this uh 12 chapter legacy campaign based on the popular deck building dungeon crawl game. In fact, this game made me so angry I rage quit. We only made it three chapters in before I eventually said, "No, I am done with this thing." And I literally threw it away. And I felt so terrible about that. And I really have to apologize to, you know, all the people who work so hard on the production of this game. I mean, it's a beautiful production. The components are great. The the riding is phenomenal.

Laugh out loud funny. And of course, Clank mechanisms are are wonderful. Clank is a great little racing deck builder. But um it seems that it was incompatible with what a legacy game required because Clank is at its best when players are racing as fast as they can to get in and get back out. Um you know, with the treasure before the dragon gets us. this game because it is so overflowing with, you know, bonuses and side quests and a million little things. It'll put stickers on cards and on the board and and unlock envelopes and boxes and all the stuff you would expect. Um, it actively um encourages you or I mean I should say it fails if you are not spending a lot of time looking under every rock and dotting every eye and crossing every tea. It's fine. I mean, before we actually started playing, I had some friends who were who had played it and had quit halfway through. And I asked why, and they said, "Well, it was getting to where, you know, for the three of us, they were playing a three-player game. Uh, it was taking us four or five hours a session, and it just wasn't worth it. It just, you know, didn't have enough gameplay for that much time." I'm like, "What are you talking about? This is Clank. You must be playing something wrong." And then cut to a half year later, I'm playing Oen and yeah, it's taken us three plus hours to make it through a session.

Because if you just race in and race out, most of the stuff you'll miss. The game wants you to go to the far reaches of the board m travel much further than you normally ever would because oh, I've got some quest to make it all the way up there so that I can, you know, talk to the person or do the thing or whatever. And and if you don't do it, the stuff disappears. It goes away. There's timers on this stuff. So again, you are heavily encouraged to spend a lot more time in a given session than you would ever normally do. If you actually try to race to win the game, yeah, you might win the game, but you'll get nothing for it. And that was the thing that really frustrated both me and Jen. So much of the game we knew we were missing both because if we if we raced and didn't actually stop and try to explore everywhere and make the game take twice as long as it should that things would, you know, eventually go away because that you have a boss who if you don't do the stuff in time, your boss says, "Oh, I took care of that for you." It's like we want to do that game. Stop stealing the adventure from us if we're actually trying to play the game the way it's supposed to be played. But anyway, um you know, so that was one thing. And then the other thing was because we were playing only two-player almost without exception at the end of every adventure, there was like, "Oh, and what about that other subplot?" Yeah. You know what?

Since you're only playing a two-player game and you're not playing four players, the character who wasn't in the game, they took care of that. You didn't get to see how that story was resolved and that just and you know, the number of times that happened that actually frustrated Gen 2 that we kept missing out. We kept feeling like we were missing out on stuff and we didn't want to miss out on more stuff. So, we had to take forever. And now that would be okay. I mean, I've played long games before, but then the other problem was the unrelenting luck of the draw because there are so many cool fun things scattered all throughout the world. And, you know, you could go out of your way and spend like four or five turns trying to get from one side to the other, dealing with all the deck building um you know, puzzly nature to finally get there. and you make it all the way over there and wow, I found an entrance to a cave and I met a dragon and I did all kinds of stuff and I rode out of the cave on the dragon and now I've got this cool new card in my deck and it's awesome. Oh, that was worth it. Or you could spend an equal amount of time working so hard to make it all the way over there and in the in the process really kind of hurting the overall clank experience because the clank experience is supposed to be just get in and get out. It's a race. Except no, I'm doing all this I'm spending all this time at a pit stop. Um, and you get all the way over there and Oh. Oh, you're you're the you're this character. Yeah, you can have a couple of coins. That's it. And here was our exper the first session. We played game one. Um, which by the way, thanks to Rob's gaming table, I've got his video on screen because um I did try to record some of game one and I stopped recording halfway through and deleted that. I was already starting to get

pissed at the game. But anyway, in the first game, it was going great for me. I was having a blast. a bunch of neat stuff and Jen spent the entire first game just felt like she was spinning her wheels, achieving nothing. Um, and was very frustrated. But then we played the second game and the tables turned and now Jen is having these amazing awesome experiences opening up boxes and leveling up our character and no matter what I do, we both agreed. I was making the right choices. I was saying, "Oh, well, okay, I should clearly go over and do that. That's part of my character's backstory." And this, that, and the other thing. And inevitably, every single time, oh um I got there too late or oh um it's a couple of coins or oh uh yeah, you know what? You don't actually have a card like this. So the upgrade you get doesn't really do you any good. And the number of times that happened to me repeatedly over and over while meanwhile on the other side of the table, Jen's having these epic amazing experiences opening all kinds of cool treasure chests. And it's just we both agree it is dumb luck. Could have just easily gone the other way. And after three games of this happening to either me or her, I was done. Dunville. Uh it is just I mean I found that the game made me resent my wife's joy and happiness that she was having a great time and I was so miserable that it was making I mean I I hated that. I hated that the game brought that out of me because I don't like to think that that's the person I am. I'm definitely uh always trying to be positive and upbeat and make sure everybody's having a good time and I just couldn't do it.

And like I said, when the game is is clicking for you, oh, it's great. And when the game is not, it makes you miserable. And it's just total dumb luck which way it's going to go. And again, after three sessions of it, which was about 10 hours of gameplay, I had had enough and I tossed it and I never covered it. And my apologies again to Dyer Wolf and everybody else. Again, there's a lot of people out there who loved it. My wife, she raved about it. I think she gave it five out of five stars. I think it'll be in her top 10 of the year for the amount of time she got to play. She forgot all about her bad experiences. She only remembers the good experiences. All I remember is the bad. And suffice to say, folks, I found Clank Legacy 2, especially because Clank Legacy 1 didn't seem to suffer from these problems at all. But Clank Legacy 2, it was a bit of a disappointment and it makes the top of our list. Back to you guys.

Wow, Richard, I am so sorry to hear about that. I was I want to play Clank Legacy 2 because Clank Legacy 1 was one of my all-time favorite Legacy experiences. So to hear this, Wow. Wow. I'm pretty pretty shocked.

Well, you know, you know what it sounds like to me, Ruel? It just it it sounds like um you know this game is sort of pushing forward what board games could do. You know what I mean? Like it's giving it's giving like a lot of narrative. It's giving a lot of like randomness. And in fact, it seems like Richard had a problem with not knowing what was going to happen, which that kind of sounds like another game to me. But honestly, it just reminded me it just seems like an old man yelling at clouds to me. Uh because he just wasn't happy with not knowing the outcome of what was going to happen. But I think this game is pushing forward the board gaming industry, the innovation of the legacy experience. Uh and and and what and what can happen. But but ultimately it just seems like oh my Jade. Jade, how did you get up there? Oh my Jade. Oh, Jade. This is Jade. Where did you come from? What is this? What is attached to you? Oh my god. Richard. Richard. It's not it's not because things are unknown. In fact, if you cleared the wax out of your ears instead of talking about your Ireland home and its five bathrooms, you might have actually realized that that was the only good point of the Toro system. Uh the bad part is that it makes people do its play testing for them, that it's a system that doesn't work, that it's not innovative, and that it sells people a lie. Jade, please. Jade, please not. We don't want that sort of energy on this channel. Richard is a Richard is a

respected game reviewer and and wants to to know that it's okay for you to not know when things are going to happen. And that's actually and I agree. I agree with that. I agree that's that is the better part of the bad karma system. That is the better part of uh Clank Legacy 2. I think that's what you were you were saying um before it you know made you mad at your wife's joy. Oh,

two all time rants, folks. Let's give it up for folks.

Two alltime rants here on the RNR show. That was incredible. Also, shout out to special guest Jade as well. Wow. Uh yeah, Chris, I don't know what else to say after that. Amazing. I This has been an amazing show as we started at the start of the show. But you know what? We've got more games to talk about. We're going to give it back to Richard for a few more minutes. He's going to give us his entire top 10 list of most disappointing games of 2024. If you're watching live, be sure to drop in the comments, let us know which ones you would vote for for your biggest disappointments.

Yeah. Okay, I have calmed down now. Apologies got a bit ranty there at the end. One of the reasons I don't like going negative on the channel is a general rule because I can get dark when I do and I like being a beacon of positivity. I'd uh rather shine a light than curse the darkness. But I'm going to continue cursing the darkness right now cuz I'm now going to do a quick run through of the 10 biggest disappointments I had last year. You've already heard my top four. Uh what else was there? Well, at number 10, there was Slay the Spire. I was very excited about this because I've heard nothing but amazing things about it, but in all honesty, I was left unimpressed. It was fine. Um, so really this is just a disappointment because it failed to live up to the hype that I had had built up uh for me by others. It was just okay. Uh, let's see. Number nine.

Oh, this one broke my heart. Star Trek Lower Decks Buffer Time. I am the biggest Star Trek fan in the universe. Lower decks is my favorite Star Trek. Lower decks is my top favorite TV shows of all time in my top 10. So any board game based on it, I was going to have to check out. And then I really like the idea of a cooperative push your luck game. Um, you know, with all the humor and, you know, and all references to my one of my favorite shows and it delivered that. It's interesting. They don't even list a designer on this thing here on Board GameGeeek. Uh, and man, it's not sitting very pretty in the overall rankings. There's nothing to it. Now, maybe I should say maybe it's better with more than two because every player has a special power they can use to mitigate the pushing your luck. And at two, I'd say the biggest mistake they made at two players is, hey, there's only two of those special powers.

Instead, if I were playing four or five, there'd be four or five special powers, so we'd have more control over the push your luck. It It goes beyond push your luck to just coin flipping as a two-player game. And it really broke my heart. It could have been better. And maybe it is better with more players. If you got five people around the table and they're saying, "Oh, no, no, wait. Here, we can use my power to solve this problem." In a two-player game, they should have done the work. They didn't do the work. It broke my heart. Uh, number eight was AI 100% human. And remember, this is disappointments. This is not bad games. AI 100% human is a phenomenal design. It is a great card drafting, you know, seven wonders sushi ghost style. Hey, I pick one and hand the rest to my neighbors. But it does so many cool things so differently. And here's the deal. I played it at the Dice Tower West Convention, my final one, um, you know, before we uh, yeah, you know, moved. And uh I played it as a four-player game with Jen and two other showgoers and I was blown away. I thought, "Oh, this could be in my top 10 of the year." Cut to several months later, I finally get a copy of it. I tried to play it as a two-player game and oh no, the uh the way that they introduced the two player, made it more cutthroat than it needed to be and made it way more complex than it needed to be. I was not happy at all with how it was scaled to work with two players.

kind of shades of uh you know the glass road um black forest thing. Although uh you know it didn't become quite so cutthroat as that. But still I I this one I'm so disappointed because as a fourplayer game or three-player game literally one of the best games of 2024. Uh you know it's not just me. Uh Z Garcia of the Dice Tower agreed as well. But unfortunately as a two-player game for you know if you're a Mensa candidate maybe you would find it or if you were a super expert at the game. But for me and Jen, it became too burdensome trying to deal with the two-player scaling the way they did it. So I was a bit disappointed. Uh that was number 1098. Number seven was Denis, another legacy game. And I guess maybe I got to take back what I said before. I guess legacy games can work as a competitive game because Denis was working. Jen and I, we played through about half the campaign and we were having a great time with this um dice building uh you know game, you know, greatly sharp dice building tile game. There's a lot to like here, but I got halfway through the campaign and we ran into a problem that the rules did not have an answer for and we didn't know how to proceed in the campaign. So I asked on Board GameGeek and the designer, the publisher, nobody ever answered. I actually wrote to my contact in the publisher said, "Look, we're stuck. I can't keep playing. I don't know how to resolve this. The rules don't say what to do in this circumstance, which by the way is a circumstance that is much more likely to happen with two players. With four

players, it would never happen u because of the way the distribution of resources, but as a two-player game, it could definitely happen. I bet it happens to a lot of people." Um, and so I asked the publisher, they said, "Oh, that's a good question. We'll get back to you." I waited weeks, months, never heard back. And so eventually I said I'd say, "Okay, well I guess I'm never going to finish this game and I'm never going to cover it." And so I was very disappointed because Jen and I were both really enjoying our time up until that moment in Venice. Then we've got Beyond the Horizon. This is the sequel to Beyond the Sun, which I thought was a brilliant engine builder, which just suffered from being needlessly aggressive um in the uh area control game that as you're trying to colonize the galaxy and you're trying to muscle other people out of what they've invested in and like, oh, I love the engine building. I hate all this area control stuff. So, I was so excited when, oh, the engine building is back and now they've replaced the more aggressive stuff with civilization expanding. There's a little bit, but it's really it's much more live and let live. And in fact, me moving into your territory creates opportunity. So, I was so happy I was going to get all of the great engine building and now with the area control game that I like and I did like it, but in the in the time they did this, they also changed the engine building and made it much more simplistic, much more dumbed down and random. Actually, I should say they used the standard rules from Beyond the Sun.

Beyond the Sun had an advanced mode for the engine building which was phenomenal and they cut that advanced mode and so they severely neutered the engine building while fixing and so you can imagine I was disappointed. Uh then what else have we got? Oh the last one, the White Castle Matcha. Chris, you had a expansion. So do I. The White Castle Mcha. White Castle is in my top 50 of all time. Grew a phenomenal game and one of the main reasons it's so good is because it's so fast. It does so much with so little, just nine quick turns and yet the game is so rich and deep and, you know, evolves and escalates and it's perfect. It's a gym. It's one of the all-time greats. And so they bring an expansion and, you know, there's neat stuff. Hey, oh, there's this whole extra thing you can deal with, you know, going into the garden and geishes and yeah, that's all fine. But what did they do?

They turned it from a nine-turn game into a 12 turn game. Now it takes more than an hour to finish. And a big part of what made the game so special is gone. It's speed. It's you. I'm so desperate to get things done and I have so little time. Now with 12 turn turns, even though there's more to do because there's a whole extra section of the board, I feel like I can do anything I want. And and a lot of the pressure and tension has just dissipated. And so I mean they didn't have to do it that way. They could have said, "Hey, look, here's all these new things you can do, but you still have to play a nine-turn game. You just have to figure out and you feel even more tension as you try to get stuff done." But that's not what they did. They what they increased the game by 25% the length of the game and that hurt the game and it made it worse and so I was disappointed and then you already heard my number four STI my number three Worms my number two Black Forest and my number one Legacy Aquarian Incorporated Darkest Magic and Okay, that's it. What do you guys have?

W Oh, Jade, you're back.

Jade.

Oh, yeah. Well, Jade wanted to Jade actually wanted to come out. Jade uh J Jade was also uh uh Jade was also um uh yeah, Jade Jade just wanted to she's shy now. She's gone back to shy. She's wanted to give everybody a big hug were her words. Uh actually um

yes, let me give you a hug. We love Jade. Jade also felt like uh you know her aggressive side came out um and uh she just wanted to also just shout out Blackboard Gaming again the number one fan of Jade and don't don't think I I don't love that to to probably my biggest um excitement of the year is is Blackboard Games reception of Jade. I will be very I'm very serious. I'm 100% serious. I'm so happy we're we're now best buds forever. Um, yeah. Okay. I just didn't I wanted to make sure that you knew that a jump scare wasn't coming. That's what Jade wanted to do. I think I think that was a really uh interesting

I think it was a really interesting list from from Richard. Number the one thing that I wanted to talk about was uh was White Castle Matcha because I recently put that on on expansions that like I would want to pick up. I also love White White Castle. I think White Castle's so good and but that also was my concern. I I think that happens with a few expansions and uh where where they extend the game and like engine builders, the ones that find that sweet spot almost don't need those expansions to extend the game length because you're already in the pocket. You're already in that sweet spot.

So, while I still want to try Matcha, I I I also like that that definitely speaks to uh to the worry of that that sort of thing. And I think it is and I think it's good. I don't think Richard needs to apologize for getting frustrated either because I think it's nice to see Richard in particular who is probably the sunniest board gamer out there and like one of the most positive people. I think we're all pretty positive but um I I think it's great to see to see these things also not not hitting as well that there are a bunch of things that don't hit and often as like board gamers we will talk about the things naturally that we love and you'll you'll see that positivity. So it is I think these sort of lists are important to like be like oh yeah there are things that that fail and it's okay to not like a game. It's also okay to not like a game that everybody else seems to like as well which you saw on a lot of like Richard's picks with like Worms for example.

Exactly. Yeah. And as you know as we've done this list and Richard again did not like Clank Legacy 2 and he chose not to cover it and people forget that there's a lot of games that you and I don't cover and for me personally Chris I won't cover stuff that I don't like either. I just don't want to put the energy of like having to set everything up, film it, you know, do the video or live stream, whatever. I've got better things to do with my time. There's a ton of games out there that I do like that I will put on, you know, on screen. So, yeah.

Yeah.

So, I don't know.

I barely got time to cover the good ones. You know what I mean? Like, exactly. Yeah. It's hard.

Yeah. So, folks, let us know again in the comments what games disappoint you in 2024. And as we said at the start of the show, I feel like 2024 was actually a pretty strong year for games. There weren't it it was tough for me to put come up with games to put on this list um for for this show. Like I and even as you saw Tower Up, as much as I didn't like it at the time, the more I you know did my research and I thought about my experience. Like I'm going to give that one another shot. Who knows? Maybe we can start a a game next or a list next time like best comebacks of the year, you know, like maybe Tower Up's going to be my comeback game of the year where I didn't like it and all of a sudden it's like one of my favorites. Who knows? So,

yeah.

Yeah. Um, uh, Chris, any honorable or dishonorable mentions you want to

you want do you have any games that you want to talk about that?

No, honestly.

Yeah.

I feel like we Yeah, we might be out of sync from that last one. And it feels like I might be cutting in and talking over.

Yeah.

Okay. Well, well, we'll just give giant monster truck pauses after after after things. There you go.

For for me. For me. Or I'll talk try to talk in paragraphs.

Yes.

Um for me, I Yeah. Yeah. The only other one was um maybe because Santorini finally dropped and I love Santorini but I also like when I covered it I wasn't a huge fan of the the cooperative mode which is just a solo mode that they were pretending was a cooperative mode and I played it cooperatively and I was like nah it's it's not uh not for me. Um but yeah otherwise there are a lot of really good ones in 2024. That's the only sort of thing that I would I would cover and I will now end my speaking.

Okay. So yeah, Chris is talking about San Riddle of the Phoenix, I believe, is the uh one that has allows you to play solo. I just picked this up, so I'm looking forward to trying it because I do like Santorini, but I was curious, how are you going to make this into a solo game? So, but even even if it didn't, if it wasn't for you, I'm I'm going to give it a shot. Um I had one other one that might have made my list was a game called Hi-Fi uh from Smirk and Dagger, whose games I usually like. This one I enjoyed it. Again, it was perfectly fine. But I love the production of this. It literally looks like a turntable. It is gorgeous. And what you're doing is uh the the turntable is actually like a rondelle, which is sort of cool, right? And you're doing some set collection. Um you're managing hand management, placing the cards onto the different tracks as you create a song. Uh the cat is not included in the game as you see there in the picture. Um but I I I liked it. Uh I just I I wanted to love the game. Again, sort of like Zooies. I I came in expecting one thing and again it was the game was fine. It just didn't blow me away that like I thought because the production value was like through the roof. So um I would definitely play it again but um it was disappointing the fact that it wasn't like you know mind-blowing or whatever. But again that's our expectations and that's why it was disappointing. So friends in chat thank you so much for hanging out with us today and if you're watching the VA on YouTube thank you for checking out the show. Um, I'm going to give I'm going to pause right now to give Chris because again, technology folks, uh,

Chris, you got any final words? I'm going to keep talking till you start talking, my friend, and then I'm going to just going to stop talking. Um, do you have any final thoughts?

Okay. Yeah. So, so for my final thoughts as I come in here with some final thoughts, I think I said them I think I said them in that sort of big paragraph as I realized that we were out of sync. I was like, "All right, I just better keep talking, get them all out of the way, and then then I'll make space um so we don't have to worry about the back and forth." But yeah, for for me, um I I think these sorts of lists, they they come into two camps. I think they're they're also very valuable to see that uh you're not going to have good game experiences. And I think it's also important to be able to isolate and identify why. Uh and hopefully like that can then inform your decisions for for future games. like my neighbor and not friend you've all just came out with um uh his his first published game, How to Save a World. And like I played it with people over the summer and there was drastically different opinions. And so I was like, "Okay, I really want to like hone in and see like why did you why was this such a struggle for you? How can I like tailor that for like other games and and really figure out why this really broke your brain in a way that it it like other games that I thought were similar don't?" Right? Because there people are going to have such wildly different tastes. Uh, and I think it's um it's okay to take the bad with the good. It's okay to to to not like things and and have different opinions from other people as well. And so I I appreciate I appreciate that. And I I also appreciate uh our sponsor for getting us together. That's the thing I'm not disappointed about is that we have our our lovely sponsor Goblins Hate Christmas for sponsoring this episode.

Uh perhaps sort of a a darker themed episode, but not not not a bad episode, right? like these disappointments, we also know that we are not infallible. And if you love this game, we want to hear why. And we want to hear why you love it. And sharing that love is very exciting. Even though like I I may actively despise something other people could really love it. I think that's a very a very joyful thing to exist in this world.

Yeah, well said, Chris. Folks, again, drop those comments in the uh comments below here and uh be sure to check out our sponsor, Goblins Hate Christmas, now on Kickstarter. Okay, on behalf of Richard and Chris, this is Ruel signing off. We'll see you next time. So long. Take care. Bye-bye.

Progress saved