Top 10 Board Games of 2023 (Retrospective) - What Changed?
Transcript
it doesn't matter it's in the past yeah but it still hurts hi there I'm Lor and this is the broken me a show where I devote my time to Raven and branting amount board games but M more the ranting part we'll get on with this top 10 list in just a moment but first I want to say a quick word on behalf of my sponsor as Gamers we find it hard to deal with empty shelves some worse than others you therefore want a supplier that has what you need at affordable prices and delivers on time for me that supplier is Kender they offer a discount on bulk purchases as well as a point scheme for future Acquisitions down the line if there's a hot title you're after chances are kender's got it Wings man mine Arc no mine Eclipse actually I hate that game it's terrible but you might like it if you use the referral Link in the description below and sign up for a new account you'll get 5% discount on your first order over £60 so let's make gaps in your collection A F of the past get down to Kender and start saving today thank you for listening and enjoy the rest of the video get on with it so I got some ideas for top 10 list this year and obviously I'm going to be doing my top 50 I decided not doing a top 100 it will be a top 50 and that's all in the works but I'm a little overdue for this one I tend to try and do these in the summer but I got a bit sidetracked and this is my retrospective list for the previous year because the idea is is that I do a top 10 list pretty much
straight after the year is finished I mean and some people will do it before the year is finished but I I you know I've done my top 10 of 2024 and obviously as of now those are my 10 favorite games of that year but this time last year I did the top 10 of 2023 now a year has passed since then so some of these games have been played more often some of these games have been played less than before you know some new games have been played that came out in 23 that I couldn't play before I did the list so these top 10s do tend to fluctuate a little bit not always drastically although there have been one or two occasions and so what I like to do is about a year later kind of revisit that original top 10 redo it and see where the movers and shakers have come it kind of gives an impression of like you know games that stand the test of time or it gives some you know some shout outs to some unsung heroes who didn't get the linelight back then so not much else to explain without further Ado let's crack on
my number 10 I believe was six last time so this one has not quite fallen off the list it just hasn't had as many plays as it used to but this is still a very cool train game what yeah know what train game well it's not exactly a train game it's just train themed but honestly you could theme this around anything that involves carrying something and delivering it somewhere and it would work just fine this is a small little card game come Dr the games called I Love Trains and the idea with this is that your deck is it's one of those games a bit like San one where the deck of cards is everything it's the currency it's what you're building it's what you're delivering it's everything and so you've got to micromanage these cards so multi-use cards already love the aspect theme wise couldn't really care less okay yes it's trains delivering cargo to places whatever I know the theme BS me to death but mechanically and just Tim lengthwise you know this is not a complex game takes about 45 minutes to play and involves you building up your train Carriage with these different trains some with special abilities or just different types of cargo fulfilling these little contracts or delivering passengers You' kind of got a choice of the two but the idea is is that you can actually you know interact with the other players by going you know what I wouldn't say no to that bonus that your car gives me there you know what you can have this green passenger well you know what go on take this take this bit of Timber or I forget what you deliver oil or something yeah take this can of oil and you know for that I get a couple of points and some extra bonus like draw more cards and so this isn't a multiplayer solitire game you actually do interact with players and you don't want to obviously give too much to one
player you got to sort of spread the love a little bit but it's very quick very simple very straightforward and yet gives a decent amount of De for what is essentially a 45 minute game you know not quite F length but still short enough that you're like well I need to kill some time until 6:00 what have we got ol of trains yeah cool and it's portable comes in a little boxes produced pretty well you know it's just a niy little game and it took me a while to get to this one you know because the whole joke with me and the owner of trer games is that yeah I am not a train game fan so maybe don't put a train game near me but it's not always the case I mean you know there are other train games that have done okay but yeah you know suffice to say that this one just kind of won me over not because of its theme but just because of some cool mechanics this man is over
gasped number nine has dropped from five so just like the last one fell four places so has this one this one just simply hasn't got to the table much and it's not because I don't enjoy it as much as last time I still enjoy this game quite a bit but it's not the most practical game to get to the table it just crosses that borderline between maybe just being a little bit too long for what it is so I tend to play it you know solo now and again but it's cool to bring Redwood out for a little bit of zany fun this is a cool theme that's you know it's been done in some other card games but to actually take it and put it on a map with like little dexterity elements you know using the template like where you going to point your camera and that is pretty cool the idea being that you are photographers taking pictures of Wildlife and scenery your Miniatures are on this sort of circular map but in order to move somewhere you have to use a template that you kind of have to kind of guess what you know what length it's going to be and what curve it's going to have move your character and then use another template for wide lens you know fisheye lens narrow lens wide angle you know that kind of thing and take pictures in the best view possible to collect tokens and get points but you got to watch the players because they might photob bomb your shots you're trying to do little mini objectives get out of the way I'm sorry am I annoying you yes you are you can't possibly to be that close it's nothing like you know crazy in terms of it you know what it is you're doing to get points but I love this theme it's so pretty it's such a cool idea to have yourself like move around and it generates quite a lot of laughs because it's not to be taken seriously this is clearly meant to be kind of like not a
silly gimmick but you know it's a gimmick that works I suppose you could say but it's just a neat game that is just light-hearted light-hearted and fluffy but maybe just crosses that line of being a little bit too long and I think that's where it's faltered a little bit as the year's gone on where sometimes I want a game that's not going to take more than an hour and Redwood sort of takes a little bit longer than that at times by the time you've got it out explained it done the whole game especially with four players I do recommend maybe playing this with three but you know it's still good fun it's just dropped a little bit it's not your fault
dropping a single place to my number eight literally only from Seven is the weakest in The Tigress Trilogy and I say weakest none in a bad way because this entire Trilogy of Garfield games has been really solid it's just this one is the eight out of 10 of the bunch whereas the others easily hit nine out of 10 plus if not 10 out of 10 this is Scholars of the South tiger this is the one where you're trying to translate a language from Step a to step B to step C effect L hello bour crazy gibberish but you're interacting with other players with the the translators themselves and you're using the dice mechanic with colors mixing them together to create different dice you know like well not different dice literally but you go right I need to do this action I need a green and a blue well if I combine the two that makes you know that makes whatever color brain farting a bit there but you get the idea you you're using the different color dieses to make do the various actions it's dry as a bone as always with the Garfield games up theme is not their strong suit but it's a decent game I enjoy the thinkness of it the interaction with players where you're utilizing a shared resource is always a good thing it means it's not entirely like multiplayer solitire and you know there's a good amount of variation in the game there's some elements of different strategies you can pull off it's a great game all around but it's definitely the weakest in the trilogy I mean it's not exactly shifted much on this list one place whoop he do but yeah where way fair is it was never going to measure up to the quality of that and recently if you check out my review for inventors of the South
Tigress that one easily beats this one as well not quite to the same level as Wayfair as it would say be my second favorite but Scholars just ends up being you know the weakest of the trilogy but compared to something like Architects and VI counts which are two of like really great games and paladins which I found me or kind of average this one is more Wayfarers inventors and Scholars you know Scholars is still pretty good I still really like it it's still one of my favorites of the year it'll just probably see the table a little bit less often in the other two but still really solid I'm just glad to see that the tigerish trilogy turned out to be a free for free
hooray okay it is time to break the fraking internet yes uh this one I never thought would ever see a top 10 list ever at least not in a positive note you know I have previously hated on the original incarnation of this game and I still don't like the original incarnation of this game the second edition improved matters to the point where I'll actually play and get some enjoyment out of it but I haven't played the one after it I've played the previous one with an expansion I wonder if you can guess it by now but the latest one is what clicked it just did everything right it did everything that I needed the original to do and that it wasn't doing I saw my friends play at convention and I said to them look I am willing to play this game I'll try anything once come on let's try it and see if it wins me over I tried it at a gridon and love it this is I'm shocked to say hold on to your keyboards Great Western Trail New
Zealand yes a Great Western Trail game is on my top 10 of the year and I don't think I'm going to live this one down this one just worked you and it's not to say it's perfect there are problems with it you know I mean everything has got problems and this one is mainly the fact that it's quite a front-loaded teach particularly if you've never played a Great Western Trail game before but frankly do not jump into this one as your first go but also because it is one of the biggest table hogs in gaming history this thing has a ton of table space for its requirement with the cards and the tokens and the the money and the board and the sub board and your player boards oh my God you need a big table but this one mechanically just fixed a lot of the problems I had with the original it feels looser than the than the original Incarnation there are more Paths of Victory it's not just those free people it's not just the Train the conductor the Builder and the cow rustlers or whatever they're called you know I forget what what do you call it when it ranchers yeah whatever um but it's not just those three careers of which two of them pretty much link into the same thing therefore you kind of have to go with at least one of them I just felt a bit pigeon hold in the original game I've not tried Argentina I would like to try it but from what I've heard about it it's going to the weat link of the free but I'll try anything once so I'd like to give it a shot but New Zealand four different characters each that can be approached uniquely so I could happily diversify into different characters or I can go for one of those four characters munching it to high
heaven and still win the game and I have done so I have done it with the Shepherds I've done it with the builders the sailors and the shearers all four of them you could do nothing but those one of those four and still come out on top but then you've still got grabbing all the hazards you've got the bonus tiles which have loads of cool effects that you can try and aim for you know selling the Sheep at the end doesn't feel quite as painful to do as it did in the original you know you actually get some of the money back it's it's your choice as to whether you spend some of it on certain targets but you can also decide well you know what I'm not going to spend all my time selling the Sheep at at Washington or whatever it is at the end uh Wellington sorry you know instead I'm going to decide I'm just going to make my money by shearing wool and so I use that Strate and you can get points that way but then you can go sail around in your ship you know and just say you know what I don't need to sell that many sheep but I'm going to all these different ports and laying my houses down that's getting me bonuses there's a lot of different paths to take and as a result this feels like more of a not quite sandbox but definitely a more open version of Great Western Trail a more looser version and yet still thinky still you know high on the variation with the buildings that can come out in different you know parts of the board which radic change how the game progresses and I do mean it I mean remember my Shackleton bass review where I said those Corps don't really change the flow of the game they really don't that to that extent but trust me you put you do something as simple as putting the building where you buy characters at the very end of the track or the one where you buy all the the Sheep at the
very start of the track just do that little small thing and watch how the game suddenly changes dramatically from what it normally is and in fact we had a similar setup last game we played at Handy con but yeah this one just seems to work and it's even got to good solo mode to boot not that complicated bit long but still gives me the good feeling of the game I never thought I'd say it but yeah Great Western Trail yes it took you a second edition and two separate Integrations to get it right but at least you got it right you produced one that I like and you know sheeper I don't know sheep Gren and cows I don't know I like all animals so maybe I'll just glass them equal but I'll still play the original Great Western Trail with the expansion I want to try ER I'll never touch first edition ever again I still think the first edition was just I don't know felt too tight too painful the exploit of going to Kansas and take it like it was mandatory to go to Kansas and take the worst possible bit to get acceleration in the game it just felt like it was like a you know a null thing at that point I don't know I digress I've I've gone on too long just to try to justify the fact that this is on my list but yeah I do really like this game it's in the collection on my shelf and what can I say
my number six was my number four this one's just dropped a little bit I mean it still gets the play so I still really enjoy this one do not put this game on its side when you store on the Shelf trust me with that you're going to have a bit of a heart attack when you open the box again but the box is a great insert for this game I gave it a 10 out of 10 when I reviewed it I mean that's not to say it's a like oh my favorite game ever but in terms of it just getting everything right it did you know maybe if I was to go by personal enjoyment it'd be closer to a nine but you know it ticked a lot of axes and I never thought I'd say that about anything that was called something as Bland as art Society art Society is a really good you know 1hour game of kind of semi polyomino it's not quite the tetris Malarkey that you've seen a million times you know it's squares and rectangles but the the cool thing with this one is the bidding system for how you get the tiles or the paintings in the first place and what your scoring for because whenever you have a turn the players can select whichever well the active player can select whichever shape tiles they want and whatever size and they put a bunch of them out depending on the number of players and then players have these little cards that they use to bid on the various items like one to 20 and it's like simultaneous reveal okay go but you are concerned about at least four different things with these tiles will it fit on my board will it fit on anybody else's board what color frame does it have what color you know what color type is it you know is that going to clash with anything else I've got and you know those those four things by themselves is
already like really really good and and and you know you do this in order to get like little Decor tokens to fill up spaces and to eventually fill out your board but you know the cool thing with the scoring is that the one that is left over and this is the fourth thing you got to bear in mind is that the one that's left over increases a track that tells you how many points that particular color type is likely to score so you have all these different things to consider and can influence the end game scoring based on what you take it's just got some really cool neat mechanics in it and yet it is a breeze to set up and a breeze to play not difficult to teach the rules I've probably made a bit of a hash of it myself wait I've been at work all day give me a break but the this one just is a really solid game and I do recommend you give this one a try especially if you passed it by thinking oh well this title doesn't seem like much even though people are always picking at the cover because it's you know it's got different layers to it but honestly this one really surprised me probably one of the biggest surprises of the of the previous year 2023 well two years ago whatever I forget we're still in 2025 now but uh yeah this one just really really like took me by surprise and showed me it was a good game so by all means check it out for yourself check out my review for more details oh Jesus oh god oh oh Jesus God okay from number five we have another new game on the list this one I did not get to play until probably at
least Midway through 2024 it took a while and yet it is 2023 on the box I think it mainly got some distribution in the US I certainly didn't see it in the UK that much but I've now got the game I've even bought an expansion for it you know at Essen last year the expansion I can kind of take or leave more more stuff more variety is good but I was kind of surprised by how this CKY little 1H hour engine buil game you know really did win me over and I wonder if I can see it on the Shelf from where I am I feel like I should be able to but uh assuming that I can't nope doesn't look like it nope H well what a shame maybe I took it in the box somewhere that is the veil of Eternity veil of Eternity is kind of compared to a lot of games like resar Conor and similar like very short engine builders with not much of a theme it's mostly just a case of how to get points as quick as other people but resar Conor I just found kind of there you know seasons was already as good was already a lot better than playing resar with the whole draft of cards at the start and work with that mechanic but then in terms of just taking a you know an engine builder point game that takes about an hour to play veil of Eternity still beats that one out it's you know again simple rules you've got a bunch of cards these different creatures that you can summon with different abilities different types different costs but your your currency is effectively four Power Stone of varying values but you're only allowed up to four Stones so you could have four ones you could have four sixes but you
don't get changed when you spend them on creatures so you got to micromanage that to some extent but especially once you've shov the expansion in you have got a lot of variety of those different creatures and can create all sorts of different cool Combos and paths to Victory to make each game feel quite fun and there's always the turn Ang stuff right I want to draft this particular card but I'm going first that means I get first pick and last pick so I definitely want that but is that other one going to come back around maybe I should grab that one you know and every time you're waiting for someone to decide what they want to draft from the center it's like don't take that card don't take that card you know that classic thing we've seen in other drafting games you know you don't literally draft it's an open draft but you know that thing is still there but the Simplicity of this one you know it takes barely any time to teach at all the only thing I hate about it is the fact that you use a stupid terminology for some of the actions that you do I mean you've got sum them and then you've got like a you know lure or I don't know instead of just take a card they call it something else like taming a creature and then you know in terms of how many cards are allowed to play they call it areas what the hell are you talking about whoever wrote the ru but probably dropped the ball a little on that one but it's simple rules whatever throw in the artifacts expansion if you want a little bit more think just be very wored about playing this with four players I do think this game is best suited to two and three but it's a really good solid game I thought you know it was getting wied up a little bit too much but then I played it a few times and thought yeah this is quick simple but still with a decent amount of dep and a good amount
of variation that's all I need okay we've seen a couple of new entries we've seen most of the games fall on this list this one has risen Yep this one has risen quite considerably I liked it already it was already at number eight last time but now I'm really loving this game this one has has shot up in my expectations it has definitely seen a lot of play since then my friends who I introduced to it loved it so much they ordered me to get them a copy you know when I went next went to a convention and then ordered me to get them the expansion when I last went to Essen and with the expansion more variety more cool stuff more you know player Powers I'm really surprised by how good even fall has done for me this is probably saying that going from games like res likeor and a ve of Eternity and I mentioned before kind of like the next step up this is another one of those multi-use card style games of building an engine with all sorts of different past of Victory available but this one's got some really quirky elements to it you've got like two rows that you manage with the cards one generates you resources but the other one is what's going to generate you points you've got characters that can give you special abilities as you play them out but some of them give you end game scoring and there are two different ways that they can be played but then you've also got these rituals that you can play on cards and depending where you play them and what tokens you put on them and you know all things like that again different what different actions you can do different parts to Victory and then you got these little witch me meeples that
you put out on the center of the board to generate bonuses and do a kind of little combat at the end of the round I say combat it's more just the case of who generated the most power in a particular area it's you know the theme is kind of neither here or there but it does lend itself to some really nice artwork and a cool stylistic look to the cards in general but it's just such a good amount of variety there's a lot of different cards and you know you might play this advisor as you know this particular ability but then if you play this advisor underneath your board as an endgame thing it's a different thing entirely so all the cards have got multiple uses but all the cards are cool to use anyway and I've tried a lot of different strategies add player Powers you know you can have the basic set of the player powers or you can have the asymmetric ones each of these pretty sweet I mean granted they did have to balance one of them but they fixed it in the expansion so fair play you at least address it I wish you didn't have to address it with a sticker but fine but even the expansion throw was it the crystal path throw that in again more variety more freedom with the cards more stuff to aim for and of course just more cards in general what more do you need but I've really enjoyed this one a solid solo mode to boot works well with two three or four granted it's a bit long with four but it still works at those player counts the only SL downside is that apart from the whole middle of the board combat round thing which again is not much of a conflict I wouldn't say that this one has a ton of interaction I mean some of the cards let you copy other players stuff or send a meeple over there a and vice versa but a few
and far between you kind of are playing a semi solitire game but as as engine builder card games go it's a really solid one and it is gone up we have found a witch may we burn H for my number three we are going into intellectual properties now I have talked a on about about how intellectual properties just kind of sell games based on the IP how a lot of games don't play faithful to their IPs and how some games when they really take their IP seriously um actually turn out a really solid product well this is the best example of that from 2023 this is still in my collection it takes up an entire Cajun drum bag in order to actually carry this with the expansions that I you know this was one of the last few kickstarters that I actually went all in and spent the money on it because I really wanted this game now that's not to say that biased my opinion or anything because trust me if I hated the game I would have sold it within seconds but you know the publisher of the video game worked with the game developers to make this and it shows Deep Rock Galactic is a brilliant poster child example of how to treat your IP right and to put out a solid Skirmish game this is a co-op game where you are working for you know the the whole premise of the setting is that you are dwarfed in space working for a mining company you go into asteroids in space you mine out Precious Minerals and
Gems and you know find specimen you know eggs and stuff like that but the idea is is that the place is inhabited by a mly crew of spiders and bugs and various all like Critters none of which well apart from one that flying dragonfly thing or either the screecher thing yeah that freaks me out but you know all the other ones despite being arachnophobic don't really freak me out they they look alien enough that you don't really recognize them but it's just a really good co-op game I can literally just Walt onto the PC load it up and in seconds and play a quick quarter of an hour 20- minute game with some randoms online and the community is friendly like people actually work together you know if you're you're heading towards the drop POD at the end and somebody falls down you know you will run out and go get them even though you could just stay in there safe thank you brother you're a true friend you the cam camaraderie online is fantastic fantastic with this game but the board game faithful representation through and through it looks the part the Miniatures are as they are in the game one or two are slightly weird exceptions but you know just because you don't see much of them in the game but the way the four dwarfs act the driller the Gunner the engineer and the Scout the different missions you can do the expansions now use the different biomes and and like the slightly more harder missions like the you know connecting the uh was it like fueling the the pipe fuels or whatever they are the ones where got to connect pipes up to a Central Station in order to pump a you know liquid morite from the planet you know another one where you've got to escort this tank drill thing across the area and even just the other normal scenarios you know collect
these gems find these mini mules uh find these eggs you know deal with swarms it's it's a very easy game to teach has a few FAQ moments now and again I mean the game is not perfect by any means and it's going to take a while to play and set up and sort of get going you know it's a little bit of an event game shall we say but man whether I played a solo or two three or four player cuz you can just control multiple characters or just use less characters it doesn't really matter this one just it takes me into that world you know it really does you know it it just works for me by taking the IP that I already like and putting it into board game form and it's been so long that I've since I've liked a skirmish Co-op game because you got all the zombie sides in the world I me I literally went on Kender today to see if there was anything else I wanted to buy and the first half of the page is littered with zombicide variants there's like a Teenage Mutant inja turtles one there's like a white U I don't know white Saga thing I can't remember what it's called there's a another bunch of them with like you know random IPS thrown on it's just like I am bored to death with zombicide all right I never was a fan of it in the first place and now it's just Jumping the Shark but this one is a skirmish game of Miniatures versus Miniatures and chucking Dice and shooting guns and stuff that works it works even if you know nothing about Deep Rock Galactic you can jump into this and just have a good fun Skirmish game granted you'll enjoy it more if you know the IP or enjoy the IP but yeah and certainly that works to some extent for me but even if you know nothing at all
which to be fair the free players I played with Andy con two of them I don't think even knew the IP at all they just literally saw me putting a game out for Deep Rock Galactic and decided to join and they had a good time so it it is a game that works and this is because the care was taken to make the IP work you know there are some little blemishes here and there they could have ironed out but you know as is the case with a lot of kickstarters and new Publishers but seriously the fact that they did this one so well the fact that they're doing valheim next another Survival game that I have played on online a lot with friends over the years they did such a good job with deep rock I hope I hope so much that they do a good job with Bim I am definitely anti anticipating that one so you've done a good job once don't mess this one up okay don't suddenly become like the others carry on doing what you're doing right and you'll go places certainly with me
anyway so those of you paying attention from last year would notice that de Rock Galactic was my two before so it dropped to fre so what happened to my number two now well the two effectively swapped places and to be honest I might have even said this last year where I said that these two could have easily swapped places and based on the number of plays the ease of getting this one to the table and how good it's been still even before the expansion is fully made I mean I've tried the Prototype but honestly even if the Prototype sorry even if the expansion didn't exist I would still love this game and I know it's not for everybody but Earth is still just in my collection and getting played whether it's Solo or two three or four player never with five I think it can do five yeah to hell with that but this is just a really good engine builder card game and I know it's not going to be everybody's cup of tea some people have played it and gone well it doesn't really feel like much you know and that's fine I've said that about plenty of other games you know there are some games that work for people and some that don't this one does I love multi-use cards and games where you have a bunch of cards that are all unique they do different things but you can't get attacked to them and it so it has you micromanaging the cards effectively as a resource and you know the cards can become multiple things I mean they can become the the compost deck they can become cards that you play they can be ones that you discard you know they it's definitely got that almost a feel to wingspan it's definitely com compared to wingspan but it's different enough from
wingspan and I love both games you know both of those games are like really high in my you know in my collection but Earth just gets played a lot because it's a lot of people have played it and even if you've never played it before it's not that difficult to get into yeah you probably won't do very well for your first game and you're going to get your butt kicked by me and anybody else who knows what they're doing but the rules themselves are not complicated if you're used to playing card games with different abilities it really isn't that really it in that hard and the actions are pretty straightforward and the graphic design is pretty decent across the board it's just the speed at which this can go when you play it with people who have played it before we can have three or four of us and it's like right this action right everybody do what they do okay next person red right okay I'm going to get some compost going to do this trigger this ability right let's go across W trigger that one but we trigger this one it gets me some cards now I'm going to use those on my compost and then right I fancy doing I'm going to do blue this time right give me some of those Sprout cues put them there trigger that ability trigger this damn I'm possessed wonder if I can play the accordion too you are just constantly on the go with this game downtime is kept to a minimum now players can drag it out if they take forever to do this Tableau or decide what they're going to do but that's not often you know a lot of games can fall victim to that but this one because the turns are simultaneous you know where one person will choose the action but then everybody resolves the action you are most of the time engaged with the game and a lot of games just aren't able to do this anymore but this
one was a great example of doing it and even if it's a a game where one action isn't that good for me you know I haven't got that many red abilities okay you're choosing red right I'll get some of these I'll do that one and that one and that's kind of me done while you do the rest of your turn I've still done something I haven't just sat there doing nothing and then that's going to make up for itself as soon as it gets to my turn I go right we're doing yellow guys give me all the trees it's just a really good solid engine builder with a lot of different pass Victory a lot of different angsty decisions of I really want to play that card but then I need to play this card I need that for the objective do I go for it are you going to beat me to the objective but I want to play them both but I can't I need need to get the soil I can only play one of these first which one do I do I need to compost some cards in my hand well you know I mean do I keep this one do I you know there's a lot of good decisions like that and a little bit of cool angst to go with it it's just it's just great it's you know it has its clunky moments every now and again but it you I think it's partially because so many people have played it and once you've played it you get how it works and it doesn't take forever to play the game like an hour to to from start to finish and you know it's nice to actually get games that can finish in an hour and still give you a decent amount of depth during that time granted takes a little bit to score the game but at least the score pad is laid out in layers it's not like Forest Shuffle you know where I need I need to use an app to actually score The Wretched thing and if you have sleeves it's going to be problematic in doing so but yeah this one just solid game and I
know not for everybody some people really bounced off Earth that's fine but I certainly didn't am I so out of touch no it's the children who are wrong so my number one game on the retrospective 23 list didn't change from last year nope I mean I actually feel sad that I didn't get to play this at Handy con I even put up a game saying I want to play this at Handy con and only two people signed up and then one person pulled out and I couldn't really get people on short notice it was a shame shame but handy con is not really the best place to play this game whereas if I take this to other ones like gridon or manaon or bacon or anything like that oh this gets played and even other handy cons I have managed to get it played down again it's just that it's I've finally broken the chain after what like 10 plus conventions I love this game it is wonderfully formatic it is FY as hell it is interactive as hell it is mean as I'll get it at times it's a 4H hour Bonanza and I know I'm usually the person doesn't like games that go too long for what they are but hemony is not too long for what it is yes it's long it's an event game it's going to take you the whole evening it's going to be a 4-Hour experience for the most part but you are engaged always you are constantly looking at what the other players are doing you are seeing the board shape you know develop over time like what companies come out what are
the policies now what is the state trying to do to help all the different players is the working class starting to get a little bit aggressive now is the you know is you know are the goods available from the capitalist and the middle class to buy be as the state I'm watching all three other players thinking hm well you're getting a little bit up yourself you're struggling a little bit I'll try to help you but I can't help you too much but I need to keep very you know I love playing the state for that reason but all four classes are enjoyable to play some are harder to play than others for sure but you know the social political theming of this game works so well the classes behave like you would expect them to behave the interaction with the players that go you know you know some people are collaborating some people are going at each other's throats it is never a dull experience now the the caveat though is that I need to play this with people who know what they're doing see my top 10 games I don't want to play with Noobs list this is certainly one where every time I take it to a convention I say experienced players only you know and that means you need to have played it a few times so that I don't have to teach you the fun FAL basics of the game at most I just need to reiterate how a particular class works that's fine but yeah it's not a game I want to teach to a brand new player unless I really like the person I'm doing it with because it's a bit of a chore to do that but you get four people or even free it works great at free and it's even got an interesting little solo mode in it as well but three or four people who know the game well it is one of the most fun convention games
I can take and it never fails me it's never been you know a terrible experience one or two occasions have been slightly scuppered by a brand new player doing something really stupid despite you telling them it's really stupid which kind of King makes someone else throw yourself in next time and rid us of your stupidity not to say the game is Flawless and certainly not to say the game can't get moments like that but this is one of those reasons I don't want to play it with Noobs so you know when you play it with experienced players you don't get that problem it's it's just such a surprise I mean it took me a long time to get this one reviewed I had to give this one the beans a lot and it's not a short game I probably have never put so much time and effort into a review as I did with hemony but God was it worth it this is a great game it is going to be in my collection for life I've bought an Raptor you know art insert for it I've got you know I take clay chips with me the the bras clay chips every time I play it it's just such a good experience and I can remember stories of how certain games went even like years ago and I love hearing about other people's stories and every time I see at convention I walk by and go oh let me all right I just want to have a look and it's and I look at the board State seeing what the policies are what the classes are doing and it's telling its own story I only wish I was that excited about World Order I've only demoed it but uh suffice to say the demo didn't win me over but you know I'll will try World Order properly when it comes out and hopefully do a full review
but yeah don't play world order thinking it's going to be hity 2.0 they are very different games you know you can certainly see there's a little bit taken from one to the other in terms of its asymmetrical but yeah world order for me just felt like an asymmetrical Twilight Struggle which is not really the kind of game I was hoping for but even if that one doesn't win me over pemy certainly did this is a keeper for
sure so there you are that is my retrospective 23 list as you can see the list didn't Chang to a great extent you know the top of the list remained about the same but the bottom half jiggled around a bit and we got two new entries 2023 was not the greatest year either and I know I sound like a bit of a broken record when I say that but you know 23 was a little bit better I thought than 24 for me honestly I mean yeah it was difficult to sing the Praises of 10 games to the point where they were all nines out of tens but you know there was a lot of good games maybe not great games but a lot of games that were like yeah I'd play these or I'd still play them they just weren't Keepers in the collection whereas 2024 had a smaller conglomerate of that but you know there's still a few on my short list which you know I did look at but just couldn't meet the Mark I mean in terms of new games I've played since I did the original list uh there was a world wonders and Far Away Now world wonders decent game from Arcane wonders it's fine I like it it's just Not Top 10 material really don't like the solo mode in it but far away was another game that I'll talk about on the next podcast show in more detail but people have told me to play far away all the time since I did my castle combo review well I got to play it several times at Handy con and yeah it's a good quirky card game I'll talk a bit more about my first impressions on the podcast but uh yeah I enjoyed it it's a good solid game but other ones that I just didn't consider even from last time though I mean well which ones fell off the last list there
Siberian the uh solo game it's still over there in my collection you know the Shady Tor Omni was it Omniverse is it Omniverse only verse or whatever they call it but basically you know those solo games still really solid uh Leaf weird City Games still solid game um what else uh did everything else fall off no I think I think there was only a couple that actually fell off the rest of them just kind of jiggled around in favor of a couple of new ones but yeah people will talk about games like the White Castle and freeway circus free Wing circus was really man the White Castle was good but it doesn't have a lot of variation so it was good at first and now it's quickly sort of become a bit boring apiary meh evacuation not a fan check out my review nucleum certainly a lot better than brass but you know I like it I just don't love it uh books of time cool different game from Bard and dice Spellbook cool little engine builder game down there just not top 10 material Fox experiment too clunky and too fiddly for its own good uh what else we got on here oh station 4 big game epic I do like playing it with some mates of mine but it is a bit long it's front loaded and pretty much I'm only playing it with one single group uh void fall decent enough game if you play it solo way too long than thought when you play it multiplayer especially as it mostly feels like a solitire game but it's just too impractical too big too expensive too many rules too much too much to deal with from a solo perspective for it to be like worth it for me um what else we got uh
Pirates of mar Kaio fine just nothing amazing series decent on the Shelf cut the horror decent again not top 10 material I think it's kind of gone down a little bit since I reviewed it uh path of civilization still on my still on my shelf still pretty decent but again not top 10 material um and I think that's pretty much it from a short list perspective yeah and a couple of little trick takers and stuff like that so there was a lot considered in terms of games but at the end of the day there can be only 10 and in this case it was basically eight of the previous 10 just in different orders but uh hopefully I broke the internet with some of you with particularly the Great Western Trail pick that is definitely going to get some feedback I am sure so anyway I'm going to sign off next time probably be the top 50 that I end up doing but also I want to do a list of top Euros to play with four players this is something that I constantly am a broken record of saying that three players is the way to play most Euros cuz four just ends up being too long well there are some Euro games where four players is actually worth doing and I hope to come up with a decent list of 10 to explain in more detail but that's for another time so that's it for me on this episode of the broken me if you like what we see then please leave a thumbs up but also consider subscribing to the channel your views and your engagement are what keep this channel going subscribing to the channel will help keep you notified of more videos but also consider the patreon campaign where you know your financial support is what helps to keep the channel running from a money's perspective because there's a lot of outgoings that the channel has to deal with in terms of subscriptions and
conventions and that and because of you I'm able to keep this channel going and review a lot of the games that you want me to cover but of course let me know your comments down below do you like the 10 games that I S on this list are you sad that those two uh leaf and Siberian had to leave the list are those games in the short list that you think I am mad for not putting on the top 10 of the Year by all means let me know your thoughts it will be great to read them as always so until next time remember regardless of whether 23 was a year to remember or to forget it's still just a year of games so take care bye for now