Skip to main content
Loading video...

These 10 Games Have. It. ALL!

Transcript 45:26

These 10 games have got absolutely everything to them. Mechanics, theme, art, components, replay-ability, they've got it all. So, let's talk about them.

What's up everybody? I'm Mike. We are the brothers Murf. And indeed, we're going to talk about games that have got

so many boxes checked off because there are some games that have some.

There are very few games that have none. But when everything comes together with art, mechanism, theme,

uh, and all that, it's just so delicious. And so, these are going to be games that to us really,

they really have it all. They check all those boxes. Not necessarily our favorite games. I'll say there's some games, one game particular on here, I actively don't like, but we can't deny that they have it all. So again, the five kind of criteria that we're looking at, we'll talk about how it all is the mechanics, the mechanisms in the game, how the game runs, the things you do, the kind of things like that. Art, art's very, very important to game. Components. Components are a big part of game. The theme, the theme is a massive part of games, at least for me. And then lastly, the replayability. Hopefully, if you really like a game, it's got some decent replay-ability, but we threw it in there, too, because not every game has like the longest legs. We think all 10 of these have those in droves. Over on our Patreon, we're going to talk about 10 more games that we also think have these in droves. Let's get into it.

On the Brothers Smurf, I know we do a lot of really silly things to try to get you to subscribe, but realistically, we want you to subscribe because you are inspired to. We want you to subscribe for the great community. We want you to subscribe because you really feel like it's worth it for you to do. We want to be worth your time. We want to be worth your attention and we want to be worth your things because of all

number 10 is going to be Lord of the Rings the Fellowship of the Ring trick taking game or two towers the trick taking game but nonetheless Lord of the Rings the trick taking game.

This game came out a couple years ago and man oh man

we were recently playing the two towers.

This game as as we were talking about has it all. This is a uh cooperative trick taking game, kind of like The Crew. So, it's also relatively small, which is nice, but man, this game is just it's really really outstanding.

Yeah. So, uh the reason it made this list is because uh it obviously we into into the theme, right? Lord of the Rings, that's a no-brainer. uh we really are fans of cooperative trick takers and stuff. And if you have something like the crew, which is also fantastic, the uh you know, the missions you're on and stuff, what you need to accomplish as each player on the team are arbitrary. They're very abstracted. This adds in just a little bit of thematic tiein as you're progressing through the books and going through various chapters. The characters that are available to use and are sort of the the main characters you need to be using. in a particular chapter makes sense for the narrative that's going on in that part of the books and that is just very satisfying.

Yeah, it's great.

You know, if you open up in the Shire and stuff, you're going to be playing as the hobbits and things and then you're going to move on and oh, in this part of the story, Froto and Sam are elsewhere doing something like where where we are in the two towers. So, we're with Aragorn, Legalis, and Gimy and things and like I just think that that is

an extra layer of just like I don't know it makes me happy. Yeah. and you know, and then you just have the mechanical uh rules for this round that you need to be getting. So, that is super cool. The art of this game is really beautiful.

Everyone's super hot.

Everyone just can get it.

Everyone can absolutely get it. All the men, all the women, all the dwarves, everyone can get it in this game.

Yeah. And you know what?

Good.

Good. Good. The art's just really good. It's got this kind of like almost stained glassy kind of It's just got a cool unique style to it. Yeah.

Yeah. It's goting really beautiful art and then components. It is just a card game, but the components you do get in the game are very nice. And the box and the packaging are very nice. These are like separated. They're in like little boxes and stuff. Like you said, the whole presentation, the way they did this cuz The Crew is great. But again, they're like the small little cards. This one has more normal size playing cards.

It's just better. It's just great. And then on top of replay-ability, you think this is a game you can only play through once, but kind of like the crew, like you can do the same mission over and over and over again. It doesn't really matter cuz you're not going to be given the same hand of cards. That's the beauty of trick taking games. This is why people can play hearts and spades for literally their entire lives is because the game is always different because every single game you're given a different hand of cards which means you have a new puzzle. Exactly. So you could play a long expected party the very first chapter just over and over and over again and it would still be fun and different every single time. But in this case you have what 18 chapters?

Yeah, it's 18 chapters. 18 chapters and you can just go through them again and again again if you want to

and they really ramp up you know starts starts you off very simple and then there are chapters which actually play multiple rounds to uh accomplish everything so it gives you a lot of epic story and it's set in the world and this adventure that we have grown up with as well. So it's just it's so good.

Next up is going to be Kinfire Delve. Even small games can have kind of everything and I honestly think Kinfire Delve has got it all. Yeah, I I agree. And I think the price point is a factor here.

Yeah, it's like 20 bucks.

It's like 20 bucks. Like some of the games we're going to talk about today are not the cheapest and stuff. And so if you want that high quality components, art and everything, like it comes with a price, but it's really awesome when smaller games can accomplish that as well.

So Kinfire Delve is a cooperative game. Uh there are multiple sets. You can combine them and use characters in whatever set, but it's a uh a one or two player game per set uh where you're going to have these characters. You're running through this kind of dungeon that is uh comp [snorts] comprised of these cards that make up a deck. So, you're sort of delving literally down to the bottom uh and then overcoming your kind of main adversary. Uh and it's super fun. It's just a cool puzzle. It's a uh very co-opheavy co-op in a way that you can support other players on their turn by playing cards to kind of boost up their actions. Uh, so you're really rewarded for kind of working together in that kind of clever uh, card play. Uh, and for us, the whole Kinfire world, the art is just really good. Also, everyone in that can get it.

Super hot. Everyone, we had a we were in a mood when we made this list apparently.

Apparently. Yeah. Everyone's everyone super hot.

It's super awesome. It's got really fun art.

Uh, and on the production level, there's like gold foil on the cards and stuff. just like things that feel really lavish and then there's a $20 price tag and you're like those two don't seem to fit together. But they

again for for just a card game. It's got some dice. The dice are nice. You know, it's got some components that are just kind of normal, but it's like yeah, the components flare into it. You have just these again every card on its back has like this gold foil on it and it's just gorgeous. Like it's just again for a card game. Everything's within perspective, right? If we're talking about some giant ultra deluxe game, yeah, that game is more deluxe than this one. But for a $20 card game, this game has got incredible components, particularly those cards. They're just so nice. And then the game is just so fun. I love this game because as Mikey said, you're delving through this deck and you have essentially four enemies that you can fight and or one thing to encounter on a turn of those four. Yeah. If you beat that thing, you will then get some kind of reward. And usually that reward is delving, which means you're going to take the deck and then I' say it's delve five. You're just take the top five cards of the deck and just put them straight in the discard pile.

You don't get to look at them. You don't get to see them. You're just going straight down. Once you get to the bottom of the deck, you will then fight the big boss. And the three different versions of this game are three different bosses. Again, you can combine them. They're all work a little bit differently, but it's still all the same game.

Um, and then you fight this big boss. You can beat that big boss, then you win. It's really, really fun because not only is it replayable, because again, just like as you're going through a big deck of cards, there's always going to be different stuff, but on top of that, because you're delving, you're only seeing like maybe a third of the cards in the deck

ideally because you want to get through it quickly. Yeah. You are you are skipping over many, many cards.

Most of the deck you're skipping over. So even then, you will play this game multiple times and just never even see the same cards. And then even if you do start seeing them, it's not like it's going to be the exact same game. So it's got great replay-ability. Not to mention again, you can get these three separate games for the price of like one of these other games. Let's be honest, not even really because a lot of games are getting so expensive.

They're all cross-co compatible.

They're all cross compatible. And then you can play as different bosses. There's tons of different stuff. All these different heroes. Every hero is different. Again, talk about mechanics. It's just so fun. I think it's one of the most underrated games out there. No one really talked about this game when it came out. It feels like no one is still talking about it. It's so good. And then the art, the mechanics, the theme, it's just great top to bottom. Absolutely.

Next up is going to be a game that you'd kind

opposite side of this spectrum

expect to be on this level. This is Galactic Cruise. Now, this is a much bigger game, obviously, much more expensive game. Um, but Kinson Key did a really uh good job of of bringing that highlevel production. This is something uh this is a game where you're putting on these you're scheduling and and building rockets and things to put up these, you know, interstellar vacations

cruises. these Galactic Cruises. Um, and the designers and the team behind Galactic Cruise were very openly uh inspired by Vital Laser Games. Um, and you will see some DNA of of Lera's games in this one. But another piece that they also I think nailed that is on that Lera level is the production itself. Oh yeah, you have Eno Tool Art who does all of Laser's games. That's nice. um the components and everything, the organization, the inserts and everything is super high level. Yes. And that right there is just like the initial uh thing that I think will pull you in is obviously it's a unique theme, beautiful cover with kind of like, you know, shows this rocket uh mid construction and stuff. And you can see the types of silly uh amenities and things you're building uh for your guests.

Um and then there's just a really fun worker placement game uh in the middle of all that. So you get to enjoy cool art, interesting thematic, you know, stuff, and then you're just going about this big kind of a I don't know, machine to to produce these cruises and stuff. The things I really like about this game that keep me coming back is, yes, it's a very large game. There's a lot of things to consider. There's a lot of things to focus on. Um, but they make life a little easier on in small ways that I think are really meaningful. Like there are ways to get money. There are ways to get ads to be able to use for uh your turns and get your resources and stuff. You know, it's more of a kind of action time economy than anything else. Like you can get those other resources. It's not so labor intensive just to get those resources to do the other thing which is the main thing in the game, right? Uh, and that can be labor intensive. So, I like that they smooth out just a couple things. It's not like it's a gimme or anything like that. There's plenty to do and think about, but um I feel like other games sometimes would make just the simple gathering process a little more difficult and they're like, "Let's just make that a little easy so you can get to the fun part of like building rockets and, you know, sending people out and trying to maximize what you do in a game." So, yeah, for me, I just like I'm like so appreciative that like that little thing I think really adds up in a game that is of that scale. Yeah, it really is just again it kind of has it all. The the gameplay is super fun.

The mechanics are great. Again, it's a big crazy game. Worker placement, worker bumping. There's all these different places you can go to to build out these rockets, put on these cruises. Once you're on a cruise, the the guests that are on that cruise will be doing like activities and stuff that's kind of like small, not huge, huge stuff, but it's just really really good. I mean, it's just top to bottom. Like Mikey said, it has the ENO Tool art. It's kind of one of, you know, tools more,

I would say reserved things where it's like it's just kind of like a

nothing's like ostentatious in terms of the art and stuff. It just looks nice, you know? It's just, again, it [clears throat] doesn't have to be the best thing ever, but it just looks really, really nice. All the art on there is great. The cover is great, as Mikey said. Theme, it's one of my favorite themes ever. Um, it's just great. I we grew up watching the fifth element. I love the concept of floss in paradise. You know,

that's immediately what we picture when we're playing this game for sure.

And then components, as Mikey talked about, and then the replay-ability. The replay-ability is there. played it a whole bunch, not really getting tired of it. There's so many avenues you can go down. It's just really, really fun. Again, this is the kind of game I think a lot of people think of when they think of a list like this. One of the reason why we wanted to put things like Kinfire Delv on there, there be like we wanted to have try to have more of a wider range of stuff, but this is definitely one of those games you're like, "Yeah, of course. It's one of these big giant kind of deluxe Euro games. It's going to have it all."

Next up is going to be STI: The Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligences. I love SETI. Uh I will say uh um CGE has upped their component game. I will say

big time.

They CG used to be kind of known for having like the cheapest flimsiest boxes, just the cheapest, flimsiest cars of that. And they've really worked on that over over the years. Um they own their own I know uh production factory so they can really control everything

produce their own games locally and stuff which is like was part of that was like well they're doing it locally and stuff and this is the capacity they have but they have

absolutely

these are a little more expensive cuz they're making them in the Czech Republic which is great you know I think that's wonderful but nonetheless is a great game we just played it recently this weekend big old four player game it was so much fun I love SETI SEI I'm a big astronomy nerd SETI is a real thing the search for extraterrestrial intelligence it's basically this big old field of like um various satellite dishes and stuff like that.

Yep. They're out there just trying to pick up signals.

Yeah. Trying to pick up signals. In this game, you actually will. You are uh looking for signs of alien life. You will find them. And you will discover the two aliens in the game. The cool thing is is with the expansion, there are eight aliens. The base game has five. So, you don't know which aliens are in the game. They are face down. They're chosen randomly. Um and so, you will eventually find them, flip them over, and kind of see what they do, which is really, really fun. But what's beautiful about this game is the mechanisms in this game are just simple. Like this game I feel like for being a big very deep Euro game is pretty darn simple. Not to mention this game and also Galactic Cruise both have outstanding player aids. Yes, which is a part of the components maybe part of it. Both of them have outstanding player aids. Set you can basically teach the game and almost learn the game just from the player aid because the each individual actions in STI are very simple. One of the main actions you can do is to launch a shuttle. Launching a shuttle costs two credits and you put one of your shuttles on Earth in the main board.

That's the entire action. You can move around the solar system. You can orbit a planet. You can land on a planet. One costs energy, one costs energy. Um but both just cost energy. One of the things credits. Yeah. But it's like it just you pay the price and then you you start orbiting Saturn if you were at Saturn. All the different actions are very very simple.

But how you do them, when you do them, why you do them, what order, all this stuff. That's where the strategic depth comes into. And it's very, very deep. It's so much fun. But it's the absolute epitome of like a game that like

man is pretty simple in terms of like the various actions you can do. [clears throat] There's not much you can do, but gosh, it comes together in a great way.

Yeah, it's not hard to understand like what options are available to you each round in the game, but it is a very tight resource

game. So, figuring out how do I afford to do these things can be uh really tricky. There are a ton of cards as well. Yeah.

That you can play using money that are going to give you,

you know, alternate ways to carry out some of those main actions that you mentioned.

Uh they will often give you like a mission. So, it's like, hey, if you visit Mars on a turn, you will have completed this mission. You'll get a little bonus and then that will uh hang around and maybe go towards some endgame scoring potentially.

Yeah.

Uh there are, you know, games that give you endgame scoring. There are are cards that give you endame scoring. Um

you when an alien gets revealed, uh you kind of have this midame break where you set up that alien and then you kind of go through and figure out like what is this alien's thing? like what what avenues of scoring are now open. How do I interact with this alien to uh get more points? I love that at two points in the game, you have this big revelation. The game kind of opens up a new lane for you

uh to now try to maximize and do stuff. It's so fun not knowing what those are going to be. Uh they're all positive and stuff. There's no, you know, Independence Day situation where you're getting taken over.

Uh I just think that's really really fantastic. But I agree. It's like at its most core. It's fundamental

turns very simple. Yeah. But it builds up into this huge game. Yeah. Really big.

And on the production level, like you said, CG's been stepping it up. There's a really cool system where the solar system is spinning around throughout the game. And the way planets all line up and everything is really satisfying to use. And CG has started using uh a product that they created called Rewood

uh which is a way to recycle like wood pulp and things, sawdust uh you know what would normally be waste uh and and be able to form them into

injection molds.

Injection molds which is kind of like how you would make a mini. Yeah.

A plastic mini.

A plastic mini. So now you can do this with this renewable uh re you know it's it's recycled essentially

uh and get some like detail in there. So, it's not like a mele where you are cutting out wood and can and they've gotten really good at that, too.

But you can actually have some of that quality of a miniature, but with, you know, not having the ecological price tag of plastic, which is really cool. They have a little bit of a weight to them that I really like.

Um, and so I'm excited. We've seen that, uh, you know, for a couple of their games now. And uh even you know like Druids of of Adora uh was Robinsburg Ala they had the rewood and stuff. So I'm really excited for that as well. That's just something that's like a nice touch and they just those pieces feel nice.

Yeah, they're very cool.

Next up is a game that you could say has all Star Wars in it. It does

cuz it's Star Wars Rebellion in a box indeed. Star Wars in a box.

Star Wars Rebellion is great. Again, this is one of those big old honken games that again kind of has everything right. The mechanics are great. the theme of Star Wars. It's wonderful. The art is great, you know, it's just it's just art kind of of the movies. It's not like screenshots,

but it's like, but it's not just screenshots like it's elevated.

Yeah. It's like it's great. And then, you know, the components are great. There's like tons of minis. It's a very very big game. And the replay-ability is off the charts. This is absolutely one of the games.

Even really cool like standies and stuff are like nice.

Yeah. Well done.

It's all really really nice. But this is Star Wars in a box as kind of Mikey was saying. Uh, this is a game where this game and another game called War of the Ring, which is kind of like Lord of the Rings in a box. One thing they both do, which is really nice, it's like it's those games in a box, but you get to tell your own version of those stories.

You have beholden to the narrative.

Yeah. You're not playing through where it's like one side's Luke and one side's Vader. It's like one side is the Empire, one side's the rebels. But how that story plays out kind of ends up based off of you and what happens in the game. The Rebel Alliance is going to pick one of the many different planets on there to be their Rebel base. It doesn't have to be Endor. It could be anywhere. It could be Coruscant. It could be whatever you want to be. Kashit. Who cares? Um, and then the Empire is basically trying to find out where their rebel alliances and then basically surround it with their troops and take it out. So, the whole game is this big game of cat and mouse where again, you have your um your planet and then you're basically trying to do fakes the whole time as the rebel. You're kind of like, I'm going to put some troops over here on Kashik even though Kashik is not where like my device is. Maybe try to get Mike to think that that might be where it is when really it's over here the whole time. But the interesting thing is is all the planet card all the planets have cards. You have of course the one that is yours as the rebel. But then periodically throughout the game the empire is going to get to draw these cards which is basically eliminating planets on the board. But the thing is the rebel doesn't know what they've drawn. So there could be a situation where like I'm putting all these troops in Kashikas this big old like and Mike's like I know that's not the reel base. He obviously isn't going to tell me that,

but it's like great because like you have all these different characters, but they can get like turned into characters and stuff like that. Like you gave F3 people like a lightsaber at one point during your

and uh uh Obi-Wan got turned to the dark side in my game. So yeah, that was but as the rebels, I lost Obi-Wan, but I also took over Coruscant, which is like the Empire's like capital, and I was like that was awesome.

Uh yeah, so this is a game where like as a rebels, you're just trying to outlast the Empire. trying to stay alive long enough for uh you know the influence of the rebellion to to take hold and everyone to rise up against the empire. So you want to uh you know stay alive long enough to do that. But I think that's where the beauty uh comes in this game is that you can have a story that is so well known and loved and then have things happen that flip you know what you know on its head. Like again, when Obi-Wan got turned,

that was so mind-blowingly epic to me cuz I was just like, "Oh my gosh." And the story like,

"What this would have been? How would that have happened?" And it creates this like kind of this this it it sucks you into the theme so immediately uh when things like that happen. And I think that's a really a beautiful trick to be able to take something

and almost be like a little irreverent with it where it's just like yeah the things could go exactly as the story is I did blow up the Death Star on a like last chance role and I felt very on on message uh for uh the story and and and how it went down with Luke. But then I have other crazy stuff and I just think that's incredibly fun where they create a structure. They uh give you a sandbox that you all know and and love and then they just say like, "But now you can change it up wildly." And it feels like a magic trick to be able to do something like that.

Where is he? Slay. Okay. You're probably wondering what I've been up to this whole time, huh?

At this point, not really. NO.

OKAY, FINE. YOU'RE so eager. I'll tell you. I'm looking for a magical creature named Suge and I need to get him to the pub SO WE CAN START A REVOLUTION.

COOL. UH, if you could do the ad read first, that would be great.

Fantastic idea. I shall

normal voice.

All right, let's go do the ad read.

In Suge, players will be taking on the roles of different peasants as they are trying to find Suge to get him to the pub to begin the revolution if they don't just kill the king outright. In this game, you're going to be moving around. You're going to be fighting monsters or even doing real life tasks to possibly befriend these monsters to use in future engagements. There are chaos uh elements are going to be coming into the game. There are crazy characters to encounter. And this game uh is on crowdfunding right now. You can check it out. This is a passion project from two brothers that started drawing as kids now have an animation studio and have created a truly wacky wild world for this game to inhabit. So check out Suge and a big shout out to Wandering Games for sponsoring this top 10.

Number five is going to be Unconscious Mind. Unconscious Mind is really, really good. This is also why sometimes you should give games a second chance cuz I kind of bounce off this game originally,

but I really, really like it. Unconscious Mind,

again, it's kind of got it all. It's got one of the coolest artistic visions in any board game ever. Talking about the art where this is a game where you are a shrink, you're a therapist, and you are trying to heal people of their grief. It's a really really cool theme. Um that's honestly very very beautiful. Um and so that's what you're trying to do is you're trying to cure people of their grief and help them out. Um and it's got this really wonderful art mashup where everything that's set in the real world is done by Vincent Dutra, one of our best board game artists. But again, these um clients of yours are having these very vivid dreams. And those dreams are going to require you to have different symbols to kind of interpret them and stuff like that and again cure them of their grief. Uh interpreting those things is going to help cure these clients. And all of the dream cards are done by Andrew Bosley who did things like Everdell does very very like whimsical very good kind of like more on the cartoony side of art. And so you have this very grounded art that Vince Dra tends to do and then this very like whimsical art that Andrew

nonsensical at times like dreams can be.

Yeah. Exactly. And because it's those are two like kind of separate parts of the game, that kind of mashup works because a lot of games that mashup art just kind of don't work. It takes people out of it when you also you're switching art styles midway through. But this one, because there's that delineation between the two things, it just works really, really well. So from an artistic standpoint, this is just one of the coolest games on the planet. It's incredible. But then the game is really, really fun, too. You are curing these clients as a worker placement game. you're putting these little speech bubbles which are kind of like your workers out.

It's you sharing your idea. You're basically at the coffee shop with your your your all proteges of Freud and it's you and your contemporaries uh sharing your ideas, your learnings uh and stuff like that. And you're doing that to basically

gain uh resources which are are going to be insights insights into people's uh passions and their ability to grow and their fear and stuff like that. Uh, and then you're going to be using those insights in the process of those dream interpretations, which is again is a cool way to have a mechanical representation of uh, you know, getting into someone's head and and and you learning and then being able to impart that knowledge onto others. Yeah, it's really really cool. It's a very fun um, uh, mechanically driven game, but again, it's got this great theme, this great art. The components are incredible. It's by Fantasia Games. Fantasia Ma Games makes very high quality componentwise games. Um, so you have these like great little meeples and stuff that you have these like cool ink bottles that kind of dictate uh parts on your board that you get to activate just top tier components. It's one of the things that Fantasia Games is known for.

They do a good job.

Um, yeah. And it's just really really fun to play. Like it's just it's always a new puzzle with the different clients you have. We got to play the expansion which is really really good.

Nightmare expansion was really cool actually.

Yeah, it's just overall really really fun. And again, just like hitting checking all those boxes. Um, and it's just outstanding.

Next up is going to be uh the game Speak Easy,

a Laser game. We talked about Galactic Cruise, which is openly um inspired by Vital Lera. Uh so we have to have a Vital Lera game on here too because these games are known basically for this kind of list. They're these big robust heavy games have wonderful mechanics. Those mechanics always have really cool themes and Vitaliser is widely known as like the absolute king of making thematic her Euro games

thematic integration into heavy hero games.

The things that you're doing in the game makes it feel like you're doing those things. It makes sense. It's not just kind of pasted on. Um and then Eagle Griffin games and the Vitalicity games always have tool art and always have just crazy good components.

Yeah. And just like fantastic inserts that actually work well um and all that jazz. But yeah, I think I think what takes Speak Easy even to another level, this is one that we're really enjoying a lot. Um is that kind of thematic tie-in. You know, here you are

uh people running speak easyies in casinos in in uh Manhattan uh during prohibition. So obviously we are doing illegal activities. Yes, indeed. Um and uh we are you know gaining alcohol, supplying it to our uh establishments uh and providing for the people uh through this kind of card play uh action selection system. Uh and as you take these actions, you can really go all sorts of different directions with your your sort of engine that you build. Uh you can of course build those speak easys or your stills or casinos to bring in uh money and stuff from different uh actions. You can take uh if you have a distillery uh your stills, you can produce alcohol. You can then move it around on these trucks that are actually moving through these different locations uh throughout the city. But you also have this kind of ongoing threat of of outside forces, you know, other other families moving in on your turf. uh and trying to open up their own businesses and then also like an ever growing police presence as

they're trying to crack down.

Things are getting a little more rockous in town and and there's a yeah the police are cracking down on it and stuff. So you're kind of,

you know, trying to navigate. You can kind of the game is projecting what it's going to do in that regard. You're going to know where new people are going to pop up. You're going to know where the police are going to be and stuff, but there's ways to work around all these things. you can take out your kind of rivals or or sort of bring them into your fold. Uh you can get someone to watch out for your your speak easy and stuff. So even if the police are there, it's no big deal. You got someone out front who's who's taking care of things. Uh there's these uh boats running around. You can go rob the boats to get alcohol that way. Uh and all these things kind of feel like that classic like mafia uh 19s20s prohibition uh world that you're living in. And then Eno Tulle crushes it so hard with the art to really get you in that kind of

jazzy dark underbelly of society feel that is um I don't know kind of romantic the romantic uh cinema version of that time that we all kind of have in our minds.

That's probably not real.

Probably not. But it is sort of the

it's very romanticized. Yes. Um it's just great. I mean again like mechanics it's Vital Sera like Vital Sera is one of our best designers. This is also very like intuitive game. It's a big heavy game. Not easy to learn. I'm not trying to say it's a simple game, but just like it just makes sense. Like you're like, "Oh, I need to straightforwardness to it.

I need to make alcohol. I should probably build my stills. Oh, I need to produce that alcohol. Oh, I need to get it somewhere. I should probably move my trucks around to get it's like it's just very intuitive and kind of linear how you're doing stuff. But you can play the game in totally different ways. Uh I had a game where like Jimmy never built his stills."

Yeah.

He just like was just like rum running and got alcohol other ways and like crushed. You can play this game kind of however you want, but again, it's just like top to bottom. It's just VT is known for this kind of this kind of list. Like it's one of these games that's like everything top to bottom from mechanics all the way down to replay-ability, art components. It's just going to be top tier deluxe. Everything's great. Next up is the one that I first thought of when we were thinking about this list and wanting to do it, and that's going to be Spirit Island. Spirit Island is just great. It's got, again, obviously great mechanics.

Um, I really like the art. Probably the art is slightly more divi divisive,

which I was surprised the art was super cool.

I think the art's incredible. Yeah, I I love the art into this game. Apparently, it's more divisive than I thought.

I guess art is never going to be 100% evil, but I think it looks really awesome.

Nonetheless, this is our list. Um, components. It's like the components aren't super crazy, but one thing I like about the components in this game is that there are like these little kind of like armymen looking dudes that are very small and kind of like flimsy plastic. But one of the coolest things about this game that I love is that all of the natural parts of the game are wood and all of the invaders are plastic which I think is really really cool. So very purposeful in that way.

Very purposeful. Very very um intentional. Yeah. Because this is a game where you are spirits of this island and there are invaders. There are colonists coming to this island and you are trying to repel them off that island

to protect the people who have always lived here. The dhan

the dhan which are like the native people who live there. It's really really cool to see the other side of that coin. Usually games are about colonization, not about the people there repelling the colonist. And so it's really nice to see the other side of that coin represented in games and it's just really really cool. Yeah. So you have like your dahan which they have these little um

they kind of mushrooms. They're like little huts like they're they're housing.

And again all of those are wood and the invader pieces the little kind of armymen their little houses their towns are all plastic. It's a very cool

mix of those two things.

There's also a functionality with there's basically invaders are going to be coming in from the edges of the island and then uh they have a projected sequence that they're going to follow

from round to round. So, they're going to first try to get into a place and they're going to try to build in that place and then sort of multiply. Uh, and there are basically three levels of them. There's like the invaders, there's like these buildings, and then like cities and stuff. And they have, you know, the invaders are kind of one thing. The the houses have like two little chimney looking things. And the cities sort of have like three uh tops, which is also just a functional thing of like how much strength basically it takes to take those things out. One, two, or three. Uh, and I like that about it where it's just like, oh, at a glance it also does help you understand the game on a mechanical level. It's like that's a nice little touch.

Yeah, it's really cool. It's a cooperative game. Um, so you're working together. Also, this is one of the most popular solo games out there because again, you kind of every spirit, every player basically has like a quadrant of the island that they're responsible for for the most part. So, the cool thing is is if you're playing four players, there's four of these quadrants. If you're playing three players, there's three of these little parts of the island. If you're playing two players, there's only two. If you're playing solo, there's just one. It's very, very simple in that way.

And again, the spirits are very, very asymmetric. They're all very, very differently. They pay play differently. And this is a game again, people play hundreds and hundreds of times because you can just play them over and over and over again. As Mikey said, there's the invaders are coming in, but that's all going to be like telegraphed to some degree. So, you like you know where they're going to be coming in. So, the game is all about like working together and really planning things out.

Yeah. being super adaptable to what's going on. Like what are the hot spots here? Like what areas are in the most need uh you know using this the the spirits and their different abilities. Some of they're a little more defensive or they might you know affect the areas. Some are more I'm just going to deal damage and fear. Some are fast, some are slow. So there's a lot of fun interplay between uh the spirits and how they work. The cards you're playing will produce these tags which allow you to use your kind of like natural abilities and things. So again, there's just a ton of content uh even in just the base game and then with the expansions would give you more spirits and stuff. The branching claw gives you

uh additional levels of difficulty and stuff to engage with. And I love that you're like a taking these things out, but you're also generating fear. You get these kind of big fear cards, which are these big kind of moments and you're trying to drive them all away. Just comes together all in a really cool way in a really tough cooperative puzzle for you all to just like munch on with your brain parts.

Next up is going to be Unmatched. Uh this is

Unmatched.

Yeah, honestly it's like there are so many sets at this point uh across so many uh themes uh some IP driven, some you know based on just myth and legends which are always our favorite personal ones. Uh but the the through line between all the Unmatched sets is that the art is going to be absolutely redonk fire.

Yeah, true. Uh, and it's a really simple, straightforward game, um, of trying to knock out each other and using your characters abilities and stuff uh, and kind of cracking that puzzle to use it to great effect. I think this is a game that like is there is no limit to the amount that they can and should make of Unmatched.

Yeah. Right.

Especially because this is a game system. All the characters uh almost entirely uh are completely cross-co compatible with any other set that you buy. Uh including, you know, Unmatched Adventures, which turns the game into a co-op game.

I think there's one character

Black Panther. I mean, it's like the only one that you can't do that.

Yeah, there's something that that breaks the co-op game. Yeah.

But like literally everything can be used in anything. So, you can use any two heroes on any on any map uh you know, in multiple modes of game play and stuff. and they have used different artists throughout this uh game, but they all like everything fits into the unmatched like universe still,

even though a lot of the art's very different.

Yeah. But it like somehow just like still works and stuff. The thing that's also really cool is like each character is different. They have their own unique set of uh deck of cards uh and abilities and they often uh do a really good job of feeling thematically appropriate. Uh one that's always I think really cool is uh Achilles. A lot of characters come with a sidekick. They come with Patrick uh Petroas and uh basically Achilles is like fine and solid but when Petroas dies Achilles gets real mad because that was

is it pronounced Petetrois?

Yeah. I mean,

but I distinctly remember Brad Pink going Petrickas like that.

Yeah. No, they they mispronounced a lot of stuff that

he's like Patrick.

Yeah. Uh,

talk about because he's like,

talk about a game where everyone's hot.

Oh,

Troy.

Oh, yeah.

Everyone is hot in that movie.

Everyone's getting it. Everyone did get it.

Fight him, son.

Fight him.

Sorry. Continue.

Uh, anyway,

I did not know that.

Yeah. So, Achilles gets super raged out and strong.

Yes.

Uh, after dies.

Yes. And, uh, that's really cool. That is what happens. He goes into an absolute rage and uh

does bad acts after that. Um for sure. So that's really cool. I'm like, yes, that is what that character does. Uh there's other characters who are tricksters and stuff and they're popping off the map. The invisible man can disappear and then reappear elsewhere on the map.

Raptors can do that, too. Yeah.

Yeah. They do such a good job of like making the characters do things where you're like, "Ah, that's awesome. That is what that character would do." It's so satisfying every time. And they've made so many sets and they're all freaking awesome.

Yeah. And like I said, it's it's an easy game. We've like run tournaments of this game like at cons and stuff and it's just like this game level.

It takes like five minutes to learn like the individual actions you can do. Again, the decks and the characters to learn can you have to want to play them a lot, but like in terms of how you can play the game is simple. It's also the game is like 20 30 minutes per match, so you can kind of like rattle them off. It's so much fun. Like you said, the art absolutely banger, but the components are good too. Like all the sidekicks are like acrylic pieces. They're nice.

The boards are nice. All the

health dials and things that have art on them as well.

All the um charact heroes are minis. The minis are nice. You know,

unique and stuff.

They're great for board game minis.

They have a wash on them. So, they even have a little more.

Yeah, they come with a freaking wash. Like, it's it's component-wise, it's great. And then replayability. Again, there's not only is there replay-ability, there's a a big tournament scene for this where like people run unmatched tournaments all the time. There's like rankings of characters and how strong they are and all this different kind of stuff. I mean, it is a big big deal this game.

We're ranked on there too, man, because we're characters in official

Anyone's ever played us in a tournament.

Oh, probably not because it probably wouldn't be a good idea, but but yeah, we out here.

No, Unmatch is awesome.

Number one is going to be a game that I'm actually not a big fan of, honestly. And but this, I think, is the [snorts]

absolute number one for this. And this is going to be Root. Yeah, man.

I like Root just fine. It's just never going to be my kind of game.

Sure.

Show for this list. Like, I can't deny that Root has mechanics. I mean, gosh, it's so many people's number one game. The art, Kyle Farah's art is, I mean, it's what made this game

100%.

Cuz the mechanics didn't make this game. The art is what got people to play this game.

Yeah, this game popped in the hotness uh before the Gen Con that came out, I want to say 2018, 2019. Uh, and it was because the art is, it's this war game, uh, you know, based on the coin games and everything like that, but it is set in this cartoony animal world. And I think that was the thing people were like, wait, you can do that? Like that's legal?

Uh, and that art like really sells because it's just very in-your-face, uh, very conflict heavy game, but it has this cute art to it that is just like makes it a beautifully appealing. Yeah. uh and and it just brings you right into it. And yeah, I think this is a game that there is so much content for now. There are so many factions. There's different maps. Uh and every faction is deeply asymmetric.

It's a whole different game that you're playing.

Yes, you have basically an entirely different way that you are going about generating your points. It is a race game where you are racing to get 30 points. the second someone gets 30 points, they immediately win. Uh, but the way you're going to go about that, the way you are going to be able to earn your points is vastly different. Uh, and that is what's so cool about that game. It does hamper its accessibility a little bit because it is a game that every faction is basically like playing a whole new game. So, you need to learn that and everything, but the depth that that provides is endless. Like literally the amount of

people we've talked to about Root and they love it. Not just for all those reasons we mentioned, but for like the whole meta, the table talk element of trying to talk to your opponents and be like, "Hey, you don't need to attack me. I'm not really that strong over here. We should go focus on them." Meanwhile, they're scheming to do something over here and and all of that. There's this whole other level of above table

uh game that's going on, the mind games of that.

Um [clears throat] the components are really fantastic in kind of like a simple way. in a simple way, but kind of like also feeds into like the kind of very odd art where again it's they're the components are really cute

like the little me.

They're kind of minimalist uh versions wooden meeples but they make it very clear which faction and adorable

different shapes.

I think it's infinitely better than if they were minis.

Oh, me too. Oh god, yes. You know what I mean? In this game, minis wouldn't really make that much sense because the the art is so different and cartoony and stuff. If you had minis of that, it would just be weird. There are definitely times where like there's uh what is it? Endless winter has is that where it has like Mihalo Dutriki art, but then there's minis of that art [snorts] and I'm like this is a weird style to have minis in. It just kind of doesn't work.

But you're like this is weird.

They're just different. And so I'm like yeah having meeples that are one very clear to see. It's easy to see where the woodland alliance is. It's easy to see where the bird birds are. It's easy to see the cats. You can very clearly see everything, but they're really nice. They're really nice components that are super cute, great to feel. They're just it makes the board presence look really, really great. It's just outstanding top to bottom. Like I said, the mechanics again, like this is so many people's favorite game of all time. It's a game that's played over and over and over, hundreds of times by people. The replayability is there because again you choose a new faction, you're basically playing a whole new game.

Yeah.

And then the art again it's I mean the art,

don't tell me art doesn't matter in games. This game if this game was about some dusty ass countries in Europe,

it wouldn't have sold. It would have sold fine, but it would have sold at the level that like Kubé does.

Yeah, sure.

This game has made millions and millions of dollars because of the art.

Agreed. Yeah, I think it is

because people try this game because of the art and the components and then they get addicted to the gameplay. Yeah. And that is why art and components matter.

I totally agree.

The theme is great. Root is the absolute best. Like this game has it all. Even though it's a game I'm not a big fan of, that doesn't change the fact that this game absolutely has it all.

Yeah. And that was the thesis for our list is like games that bring all of those things together

in in equal parts to create super games. Yeah.

Uh and yeah, so let us know what you think about our list because I'm sure you have your own examples of like games that for you you're like this crushes every metric so hard. Yeah.

Uh so give us uh those picks for you in the comments below. We want to see that. If you want to hear us yammer on more about games, uh, we can absolutely do that for you over on our Patreon. So, go check that out. Uh, that would be most fantastic. We want to give a big shout out to Wandering Games for sponsoring this top 10. Uh, the, uh, campaign for SOG is still live, so you can check out the description of this video for a link to that. Uh, do not miss that. Uh, and I think that's going to be it everybody, right? Yep. That's it. That's us, everybody. I'm Mike. I'm Nick. We will see y'all in the next one. Bye everybody.

Progress saved