Skip to main content
Loading video...

We Replayed These 9 Board Games | Which Ones Are Worth Keeping?

Transcript 28:08

Hi, I'm Sarah.

And I'm Drew.

And we're back today with another collection curation update for Let's Table It. If you're not familiar with the channel, uh, collection curation is kind of our long-term project where we are playing through every game that is on our shelves and really digging in to decide if it deserves to be there. So, no more keeping games that are okay. No more keeping games cuz we feel bad that we bought them. No more keeping games because they're not just exactly what we want, but they're close. So, we are being super brutal and making sure that we have the best collection for us

that is possible.

Yeah. And I'm glad you said for us because there's going to be some that people probably can't believe we're getting rid of.

Yeah.

But it just didn't hit for us or we have something else that just just scratches that itch better for us. So,

so I want to dig in because we have a lot. This is a bigger shelf. So, we want to make sure that we can get through everything and honor everybody's time. So, we're going to get started.

Um, first up, we usually go through the games that we played as a family. And so, I think all four of these games that we have first are ones that all four members of our family played together, which isn't always the case for us. So, we have a lot of family games on this shelf. And first up, we've got

Star Wars: The Clone Wars.

So, this is a pandemic style game based on Star Wars. And basically some of the differences. Let's see. Um

you you've got a few different uh bosses that you're going against towards the end and different ways that they work. Um obviously the infection instead of that you're placing droids on planets cuz this is the Clone Wars.

You're not necessarily collecting card. It's not really a set collection like regular pandemic is. Your cards have different powers and abilities. So, you're going around playing these cards to attack or to move further or things like that.

And at the same time, there's a little card collection because you can only use one color to attack the droids on a planet. Uh you can use the purple or the red, but you can't combine them. So, in that case, there's a touch of that.

There is. And especially with the missions, cuz that's something else that's different. So, you have these extra missions that you have to accomplish before you can attack the boss. And so, um, some of those missions do require different kinds of cards, but I would say it's just not to the extent of the collection in

regular and and you basically you tap the cards as you use them and can reuse them the next, uh, your next turn and stuff like that. So,

so, um, we actually ended up playing this a couple times before we made our final decision.

We played once at four

and then we played, I think, at two or three. I can't I think it was three.

We've played at all at four, three, and two.

Yeah. The very first time we played was at two, but are we ready to announce our decision?

Okay. 1 2 3.

Yeah.

Um, we found at four players, it was very long and very difficult.

Yeah.

Um, so

and for a game that's going to be for the family like Pandemic is, it's just too too much. Too long.

And we were playing on like the suggested first game setup and we couldn't win it.

Um, when we played at three it was a little bit better. Yeah. Yeah. But still just edging on that too long.

Um and things like this. And I'm not sure that I like it as well at two because you're not covering as much of the board.

Yeah.

And I don't know. It it just didn't work for us as well as just good old Pandemic or a legacy.

Little bit of a spoiler alert there because that's coming up here later. But

but at the same time, it just didn't I mean

Yeah. Yeah. Anyway, we like co-op games. We like family weight and thing. And this just is on that edge of family to where if your kids are in that 8 to 12 range,

they might unless you guys are huge time start Star Wars fans, it just might not work.

Yeah. And that's the other thing is we enjoy Star Wars. We'll watch the movies, but it's not something that we're going to go out of our way to experience most of the time.

Exactly.

And so, we just don't have that big connection with the IP that I think would really probably help this game for us. So, In the end, it's one more off the shelf.

Yep.

Okay. Next family weight game and family game that we play at three and four all the time. It's trash dash. So, uh, shiny pigeon, you covered this game.

We really enjoyed it. Uh, when we covered it, our son asked for it quite a bit. It's basically just a racing game. Each player has a little different special powers. You're drawing cards. You're using those cards to move, to attack, to avoid attack, different things like this, you know. Overall, super cute meeples.

Uh really good art and cute art. Uh 100% gives you that cartoony, you know, vibe and and just fun.

Variable track setup. So each time you can do one of their suggested setups, you can do a setup of your own. you have some um control over the length of the game because you can do one, two, or three laps around the track, right? So, it it's just it's a good one.

Yeah, it has a I mean the we like Mario Kart quite a bit as a family and playing that. And this has a little bit touch of that with the little attacks and the the little things you can do. Never in a way you necessarily feel like you're ganging up because you're probably just going to attack who'sever first. So,

you know, it's and it has some really good ways to mitigate some of that luck, too, because of those attacks and things. So,

yeah.

Are we ready?

Definitely.

Three, two, one.

Keep.

Keep. Yeah. This is a family favorite. It's one that gets requested by the kids quite a bit, and it's easy to pull down and play.

And, you know, any game that gets requested by the kids and we don't mind or enjoy is just always going to stick around. So yeah, it's fun.

So this one's staying on the shelf for now.

Okay, the aforementioned spoiler alerts. The next one that we played as a family is Pandemic. And our kids have really grown to love Pandemic. Um they will almost always play this if we ask them to. And it's one that

I just get the craving to play every so often. I'm not going to talk a lot about the game itself because it's it's so wellnown. Most most people probably know it's a co-op game. You're curing diseases, collecting cards, getting around the map.

Well, and that's the thing when you have essentially a family of games that's grown out of and you call it the pandemic system.

It's ubiquitous anymore with so many co-op games and things like this, different roles. Um, just fun set collection, moving around, trying to basically beat the game because you're working together.

Yep.

So, it was a lot of fun.

Ready?

Yeah.

Three, two, one,

keep. Um, we have tried various different Pandemic games now. We saw the Star Wars. We played Iberia, which I know a lot of people really like. We had We did, too. We did. It's just a lot tougher.

Yes,

we've played the Hot Zone one, the little version. I know there's tons of other versions, but honestly,

every time we play one of those games, we just wish we had played Pandemic.

Yeah, we can back to it.

So, um, Pandemic is so far is going to win out over any of those versions of the Pandemic system. And so, it just sticks around. And I had somebody ask at one point. I did an interview and they were like, "Just basic pandemic. You just play basic pandemic."

We love it.

Yeah.

We I like that we can adjust the difficulty. So if just us two are playing it, we can add in a few more um epidemic cards. If it's just the kids, we can keep it a little lighter.

And then we just have our system down. And so we just enjoy the challenge of trying to beat the game. And I I think, you know, as far as that goes, there are definitely people out there who want the new, want the play, want to try something different all the time.

This just it's it's like our version of Comfort Food or that book that you're going to pick up every year or two and just keep rereading. This is that's what Pandemic is for us.

It was one of our first

It was

co-op games, too.

Yes.

It's maybe the second.

Yeah, cuz Forbidden Island was one that we got really early on. like maybe the first game that we bought, but this was our second foray into co-op and we just we enjoy co-op and this is one of the absolute classics and I I can't see this ever leaving our collection if I'm honest. So, it is staying on the shelf.

Yep. Okay, on to another that we play as a family and it gets requested a lot by the kids. Um, it's Mysterium. So, this is just a really interesting one. you've got to try to figure out with one person giving the clues to everybody else. Figure out your own mystery and what you're going for. Um, we don't play it necessarily as the rules imply where you're going against and you're trying to beat the other people and beating the clock and all this. We just try to figure out our own mystery and sometimes even try to help each other. We help the kids some. We look for those clues that maybe the ghost was giving them and

whatever it might be. The art is so cool. um definitely has that Dixit vibe and again libaloon is another one of those that so art is so awesome production's pretty decent um it's just a fun game.

Yeah and it is kind of fun. I think the kids have really grown to enjoy being the ghost as far as giving out the clues even though that's pretty tough job or it can be.

And um so the ghost um cannot talk and they're really not supposed to give any hints or anything with their facial expressions or anything. They have a hand of cards. They're going to divvy them out to the players and then the players have to figure out first who their person is, second where the scene is, and third what the the uh murder instrument was. It's a little dark, but our family our family can handle that.

You know, no more than clue.

No, no, it's not. So, um it is it is really a fun one and we do try to beat the clock. Yes. We try not to just play until everybody gets it.

But um are we ready? Yep. Okay. Three, two, one, keep.

Not only is this one staying on the shelf, but I just bought an expansion that we got to play with for the first time when we got this back out,

and I'm probably looking for I know there's at least one more expansion, if not two more expansions. But, we play this so much that we would enjoy that content as well. So, this one's not only staying on the shelf, but it's probably going to expand what we have for the SK.

And the great thing is the insert has a little bit of room for some of those, too. So, it's kind of nice.

So, it won't it won't take up any more shelf space,

but Mysterium is a keep for us.

Okay. Next, we are moving on to games that we played as a couple,

right?

So, here we go. First up, we've got Windmill Valley. Windmill Valley is probably one of the heavier games in our collection. Um, there's just a lot of moving parts and a lot of things that you can do on your turn. And one of the really cool mechanisms in windmill valley is your action selection. So you have this actual windmill thing with gears on it. And every time you will turn yours one, two, or three gears depending on the board situation. And then you will choose one of the two actions that you have on your windmill. And you can also upgrade those actions and add more actions in as the game goes on. So it's super customizable. And in the end, you are trying to probably gain the most probably it's probably money in the end

essentially gain the most. You're trying but you a big part of that is you're you're wanting to plan out your field in such a way with the tulips that they will score best. It's it's an optimization. Yeah.

So, um again, it's it's a little thinkier. It's a little longer than maybe some of the other games in our collection,

but will we keep it? Are you ready?

Yep. Three, two, one, keep.

So, we do enjoy this one. This was only our second play of it, but I think we're starting to get that rule set down a little bit.

One of my goals is to get this out again in the next couple weeks and play through it again.

Um, just to kind of internalize that rule set so that it's not like relearning the game every time we get it out of the box. And again, not only is this one staying, but I'm in the process of printing some upgrades for it. So, upgrading the little tulip parts and maybe even doing an organizer into this one so that it's even easier to hit the table.

Yeah, that'd be great. It's It's a good game. Um, honestly, once you get going into it, it doesn't necessarily feel heavy, as in rulesheavy. It's the decisions that really make it tougher. Um, so, and that's kind of that's perfect because I don't mind a tough decision. I don't want to go through a 40page rule book to figure out how to actually take a turn. So,

and I will say I think one of the things that really draws me to this one is just that customizable your customizable windmill. You get to draft different powers. You get to draft different endame scoring conditions. And so, you can really choose your strategy and make it work. And so, there's very many ways that you can win this game. Lots of ways to score points, lots of strategies to try out. And so, that's something that will always keep us coming back to games. So,

Winmill Valley is a keep.

Okay. Next, as a couple, we tabled lore. So, I got this a few years back um on Kickstarter. The art is absolutely gorgeous. Um the same artist has gone on to do stuff like Alte and some things like that. Absolutely gorgeous art. Uh we got it back out to the table. Uh we got going on it and man, this is it. It's rough. Um,

I don't know that I can tell you what I'm supposed to be doing in this game if I'm honest.

Um, you're moving your your pawn around to different areas. You're collecting some cards.

Um, you're trying to do these quests and fight these creatures,

but it was it's pretty convoluted with the current rule set.

Yeah. And so, um, I don't know. Should we say whether we're keeping it or not, and then we can go from there? Okay.

Three, two, one. me.

He um so I here's the caveat. Um I backed because they had uh they I backed the second edition. So basically what he's done is he's gone back through and retoled the rule book, made some tweaks, made some changes. Um and for those of us who were first-time backers who backed the the project the first time around, we're basically getting it at just over cost. I mean, he's barely making anything on those that are returning. Um, I think what he's really trying to do is make this a better game, even if he's not going to make money at it. Um, so I'm I'm hoping that we get that um within the next year or so hopefully. Um, it I want to give it one more shot with the retooling, with the changes and everything because I like I like the idea.

Um, I like the look of it. I like even not just the art, but the idea of moving your pawn, going to different locations, using what you can do at those locations to battle in different ways to go on these quests to do all of that is there. It just it was really just not clear and convoluted and a little rough. Very rough. Um, so yeah, fingers crossed.

So I remember the first time we played this, I I didn't hate the game.

No,

I thought it was fine. um the the art is what sells this game for us and then we just never got it back out. It was probably two or three years before we played it the second time for this. And in going through the rule book and in our taste evolving in games and us being a lot more particular about what we look for in games,

we did not finish our play of this. We that's why Drew said we tabled it. We didn't necessarily play it. But um I would say with its current rules set, it is not playable. like it is very very difficult to figure out what you're supposed to be doing. And so we are keeping this for now.

I think what I might do is kind of put it into another room like on another shelf just so it's not taking up valuable shelf space right now until we get that second rule set and then we'll give it another shot and see.

Yeah. And I'm I'm hoping um that it really tweaks things and just refineses and irons out and all those things that you you need. Um, I'm hoping that makes the difference. I'm

We'll see.

Hopefully. I'm I'm optimistic.

I think we both sat down. We're like, we want to like this game. It's so pretty. The production is amazing. This the gameplay's not there.

It just ticks every box except for the gameplay itself. And again, I just feel like a few uh few ironing out here and there. And again, clarifications and some stuff like that. I feel like with those things, I am very willing to give it another shot. I'm not going to say it's a keeper necessarily, but I want to give it one more shot with this new iteration.

Yep. So, it's staying for now. We'll see after that what happens with it, but Laura's sticking around for a little while.

Uh, next up, we played a game of shallow sea. So, this is probably our third or fourth play of this one since we got it probably last summer or maybe last spring. spring.

Um, in Shallow Sea, it's very Cascadia stylesque, where you are drafting a tile and a fish mele on your turn and placing them onto your board. And your tiles might be reef tiles, which will need different colors of fish um around its edge to complete, or it might be a goal tile. And those goals might be something like have two of the same color fish in this direction or have this surrounded by all of the different colors of coral or something like that. And so then you are flipping those tiles over when they are complete and scoring those points at the end of the game.

Yeah. And um you know you mentioned Cascadia. I think it's got a touch of that uh to me of calico to it. Uh but Cascadia definitely fits with the fish and the the tiles and stuff like that. Um, I just don't think it's quite as open as Cascadia.

Yeah, it's it does close up a little bit, but I will say it's not as closed as Calico because you you're going to have spaces open at the end of the game. You're going to play until you have four spaces open on your board. And so I I personally feel like there's never a time when I'm like, "Oh, I can't place anything that's going to help me out."

Right. Oh, yeah. Yeah. It's it's definitely not not to that degree. Um, this from Bad Comet, this is what their third or fourth game. um and have gradually gotten more refined and better. Uh production as always with Bad Comet is so good. So, those things are awesome.

I would say this is probably one of their lighter games if you're looking for an entry point.

Yeah, I think you're probably right cuz when you look at Lifeia, Wondrous Creatures, this is definitely lighter than those two.

Um

you know, and things like that. So, yeah,

I personally really enjoy the production. The fish meeples are really cute. The art is beautiful.

Yep. And there's a lot of variability because you have different um goals that you're kind of trying to achieve,

right?

And it does have a little system of um like challenges that you're trying like kind of like some of those other Cascadia type games that have the solo challenges, but these you can do,

anybody can do like you can do the whole game and then just see if everybody made that goal, right?

And then we also this time played with the nesting season expansion which adds a little bit, not a ton.

Yeah. Yeah, I agree. It's just a touch. You don't then there's

some more scoring.

Yeah, you could honestly do that at any point or never. It doesn't matter. There's a lot of replayability to this just like you said with the different goals and and things like that. So,

okay. Uh, ready?

Yep.

Three, two, one. Keep

keep

I think he's actually a me. He just doesn't want to say it.

Yeah. I mean, it it's on that verge, but you know, if you pull it out and you want to play, I'll play. I don't have a problem with that.

And I will probably pull it out and play it solo a few times here. Um, just because I do really enjoy it. But I think for our daughter has played it with us in the past and it was maybe a little bit much for her as far as the decisions that you have to make throughout.

I I think you don't like the possibility that there will be a goal that you won't be able to achieve. And so um I'm I'm okay with that. Um I like the challenge of trying to get my board to be as full as possible. So

and score as much as possible. So um we'll see if this is more of a Sarah solo game or if we get it out to the table as a family a little bit more too. Yep, Shallow Sea is sticking around and I actually ended up printing an insert for this one. So, um, we're adding to our Shallow Sea box as well.

Okay, next up as a couple we played Starship Captains. So, this is another one where you are basically going through and uh contract from fulfillment. Um,

that's a big part of it.

Oh, yeah. That I would say, you know, that's that's one of the primary ones. You're trying to fulfill the contracts. Um there's a little bit here and there of, you know, battling the pirates or doing this that you're upgrading um your uh meuples or characters as you go through.

There's a little bit of tracks with the different civilizations that you're trying to impress.

Yeah. And so it's got a few different areas, but overall gameplay is fairly straightforward. You know, I don't think this has, you know, anything convoluted about it.

It has some really cool mechanisms with your meeples, whereas when you're upgrading them, you get more things. And then also you have this sliding track. So you'll slide all of your meeples until a certain point and then that's the pool that you have to work with on your next turn. So it has some cool mechanisms.

Yeah. And so the way you put those back is going to determine what happens in a couple no, you know, in two more rounds and what comes out and when and how that all works. So um yeah, it's it's a fairly simple system overall.

Are you ready?

Yeah.

Okay. Three, two, one, keep.

Yeah. Um, when we first started playing this one, I was a little worried that it was too simple, that there just wasn't enough going on. But by the end of the game, I started to see some strategies because I think I thought the strategy I was taking was like the strategy to go cuz I was going for contracts, those uh missions that you can fulfill. I really went heavy on that.

Drew went a little heavier on the pirates

and filling up your cargo bay.

Yeah. And then also um I tried to and you caught up by the end uh with the civilizations with the other uh

that you're trying to impress. I was trying to hit those pretty hard um as well. But honestly, it was close at the end.

It was pretty close. Drew still ended up winning this one. And so I was just kind of like, like I said, that kind of changed my mind as far as well there's only one real way that you could win this. You have to go for that. So I I'm excited to dig into it a little bit more. It has a really cool epilogue system at the ends where you can take your final score and then it has just a little couple sentence blurb about like where your career went and so that's kind of fun. Yeah.

Um I'm not going to say that this is a forever game for us. I don't know if at some point we'll have seen everything it has to offer and you're done with it.

It's definitely a possibility. I'm not I wouldn't say that either, but keep it around for a couple more years and you know as we play through there might come a time when we're like

Yeah. And the kids are Star Treky fans too. So, they might be interested in trying it with us at some point as well. So, Starship Captains is sticking around down to it. Uh, next up, I'm going to try to say this correctly, but if I mess up, I apologize. Ada um which is a management game kind of.

Yo, yeah.

Where your um man, how do I even explain it? You have different tiles that you can place different types of um meeples on. So, you've got bats that can go into houses or different bat spaces. You've got different kinds of livestock. You've got fruit that you want to collect. And you are trying to pretty much um increase the population of your village, but you still have to be able to feed everybody

because it is a Rosenberg game. So, you have to feed the people.

So, um there is just a lot of decision space. There's some really interesting mechanisms with as you fill up your

um your player board with your trees and things like that. And then you're going to spend those, but you kind of want them to be up to certain points because then you're going to get bonuses.

And so there's just there's quite a bit going on with this one.

Yeah, it's it's definitely got a lot of decision space. Um, and again, it's that optimization of how to build this as quickly as you can yet in such a way that you can keep everything to the end and use it the best. You know, it it's definitely an interesting one. Yeah. So,

and the theme is really

the theme is very interesting and I probably learned a lot about how bats can really benefit these villages. And so,

it's it's very interesting. We first were able to play this at a local gaming convention and we just barely scratched the surface of what we could do. I feel like cuz I was trying to learn it really quickly and then I was able to get a used copy of it and we were able to play it again. And are we just ready to review? I think so. Okay. Three, two, one, keep.

There's just so much going on with this. I love the theme.

Um, it's definitely different than a lot of games in our collection, which really works for it as far as something that will scratch a different itch.

Yeah. And this is another one that you can approach in a few different ways and how you're But I mean, at the same time, the key is growing and, you know, trying to get things developed the way you want. Um, but like I said, the direction you go to get to that final product can take a few different ways. So, it's kind of cool.

So, Ada is saying for now.

Okay. So, that's another shelf down for sh for for collection curation.

Um, let's talk some numbers. So, this shelf wasn't the best as far as getting rid of games, but it did have some games that we really really love on it.

And I think that's just it. It had some games that we knew weren't going anywhere to start with. Um, and again, keeping in mind that getting rid of the one, it could be two. Yeah.

Um, you know, and

we'll just see where the shelf takes us. There are a few that I don't think are forever games, but there are several on there that I really do think will stay in our collection forever.

So, we got rid of one out of the nine games, and so that is about 11% for that shelf, which did end up taking down our overall percentage just a little bit. We have played 45 games from our collection and that's probably an eighth about an eighth of our collection.

And we are at right around 30% of the games have been cold and so I'm happy with that.

Yeah, I think that's it's decent. Um, obviously like we said this shelf was but you know I can look at a few shelves and be like well there's one two three you know it just is going to vary. It will and we'll I I would like us to be around that 30% mark I think for most of most of this project.

I think we will.

And so just clearing ways for new games to come in that we love as well as just loving absolutely everything that we see on the shelf every time we look up there. So

u we're making progress and we are ready and raring to get going on our next shelf which I think is going to be another one that probably won't have a lot. It's going to have some a lot of movement on um and looking at those games we've talked about. We're really excited to play these ones again. So,

we are going to get started on that and hopefully have an update for you soon.

So, thanks for watching. You can find us on Instagram at Sarah Always Loses. And please make sure you are subscribed to Let's Table It so you don't miss any other collection curation updates or um board game reviews that come up most weeks. So, we will see you at the table.

Progress saved