Games that Left Our Collections | July-December 2023
Transcript
hey I'm Ryan this is my brother Daniel and this is rolls in the family today we are talking about all the games that left our collection in the last 6 months the back half of the Year this is one of the few videos we do on this channel that's a little bit more negative leaning with not always super negative we're we're pretty picky about games we keep so sometimes we're getting rid of games that we actually think are pretty good but um always interesting to hear kind why did they not stick around for us maybe that helps you determine if they're game you might want to check out if you decide you disagree with us and you're like actually I really want to check that game out we have all the links in the description below you can go uh check it out you know not any games for everybody it might be the perfect game it's true tell us why you're wrong why we're wrong yes uh you can feel free to leave in the comments uh any games you've gotten rid of recently and why uh it is honestly like like it's always nice to get a a recommendation on like why you should get a game but sometimes it's even more helpful to hear why somebody it didn't work for them yeah and kind of like oh okay that might be similar to me or oh that I don't think I would have that same problem yeah at least I've found that especially as we get later in this list because uh we have some popular games that uh made it onto the list so it'll be interesting to hear we're not we're not being contrarian just for the sake of uh clicks or anything yeah we would never do that no who would but uh we've got what 13 games to get through here um I think we had pretty I got rid
of seven you got rid of six um we're going to start at the lowest R we're going to be providing our ratings with all these so we'll start at the lowest rated and work our the trash can first work our way up and uh Daniel yeah Daniel is gonna get to start us off with that yeah I I I I apologize to every uh designer of of these games for uh me they just didn't stick around they just didn't make it for us they you know great great for someone else maybe great for you and that's why you should go check the link below um okay Ryan let's start this out with um the bottom of the barrel for games that I left my collection um and this one more was uh Less on the less on the game itself really but I I honestly can't even remember how I got it I I want to say it came I actually do remember you know okay well let me announce it first so my number my well it's not my number my uh first game is that how I'm saying this low TR my lowest trading game is going to be come going to be fry Thief coming in and I'm gonna give fry Thief a rating of a five out of 10 um and Ryan remind me how did I get through yeah we were at a there's one of the rare moments that we were at a local convention here we went to that uh was itom that was gameplaying stuff and they had some like contest things I can't remember if it was like a bingo card or something and you got to pick something from a
selection and this was the game you picked oh my gosh wow I would have never remembered so I mean that is it is an example of like Mo usually when we're talking about games on this list it's games that we bought because we were really thinking they might stick around and get this is a little different yeah this one's starting at a you know it's not not at an advantage coming to the collection um and so I I I'd be honest I think I only tried it maybe a couple times um but really kind of simple two-player game of you got these fries and ketchup and you're playing these cards kind of back and forth between your opponents trying to you know score points here um it's been so long since I've even played it it's been on it's been I haven't had never actually it was kind of forgot it was in my collection and so it it wasn't on the last cold list partially from a uh just uh forgetting uh found it Dro behind the I was like behind this game and I'm like wait a second fry still here um so you know cute little game my wife and I tried it but it just you know five out of 10 it just didn't there was there was nothing in it that was going to keep us uh coming back for more and and not I don't think it's trying to do a lot and and for you know someone that enjoys just a a nice little simple kind of back and forth carard game could be good but we got a lot a lot of other games that uh that my wife and I enjoy playing together um and so it's uh tough to make the cut sometimes and so you know no I don't I don't want to hate on a fry thief too much you know I'm sure it's a I'm sure it's a good one for for you fry lovers out there yes those fried
yeah nice so yeah there you go Ryan I think you got the next one too actually you're you're the yes back gosh I know I'm a I'm a tough cookie um so coming in now at my uh the next game I got rid of is going to go to Odin's Ravens uh and I'm I'm going to be giving Odin's Ravens a 5.5 out of 10 uh this is again another two-player game uh that uh actually had you know it has some interesting things of it's kind of a this racing game where you're you lay out all these cards that and you and your uh opponent are on kind of all the cards have two kind of sides to them and so there's like a track going down on one side and then you got so you got to go down and then you got to turn around and come back the other way and like both of you have to do that you're kind of racing uh but all of the game when you play an environment you have these environment cards in your hand that match the the symbols out there and whenever you play a card you get to move um as far of that environment that's in front of you and so really what you're trying to do is like align because you have ways to manipulate the cards for the track so you're kind of like manipulating the track to try to get similar environment cards that match so you can move faster um and whatnot and so there's some special cards thing they call them these lowkey cards cards and whatnot that do a lot of the kind of manipulation and stuff like that and you know my wife and I played it a few times I think she got to play with some other people and uh and you know had a had a decent time and
whatnot um I think thinking about it I it didn't give me any like exhilarating race feel which I think can sometimes be hard to do uh in a game you know it's one of the things that I think we've enjoyed about like a game like you know heat pedal to the metal was like we much get that like exhilarating racing feel which is sometimes hard to get um I was even thinking about you know I have a quest for El Dorado and you you get a little bit of that kind of uh you know can make a big move yeah like big move and and exciting moments I think that's kind of critical in a game that's racing and maybe just didn't see that a lot um in this one but it's got some clever kind of manipulation of the cards and whatnot but that's why it is going to be a 5.5 for me but enough of me hating on board games Ryan I need to give you some uh some room so I'm going to pass it over to you well and I think unlike your two examples so far which was like God as a prize at a convention and I think you got odens ravens as a gift yes this was a wedding gift I want to say interesting I don't think anybody gave me board games in my wedding yes no but it's it's hard to be the person that's gifting Us games will say I I kind of hope the people who gave it to us aren't watching because uh you know you always feel bad if someone you know gives you something and then you know it happens it does happen but mine is not like that mine is a game that I researched I bought thinking this is going to be a really nice uh addition to the collection something that really
uh draws us to games sometimes is like really wide player counts like o this could be good in a lot of situations yeah this is one that I was hearing a lot of stuff about being good really from like two to eight players um kind of in the Rolland right genre but has a much different kind of feel than a lot of other ones this is long shot the dice game and this one was definitely getting some buzz and I was pretty excited about it and I was like this just sounds great of a short game where it's a horse race and everybody's kind of doing the rolling right thing of you know filling out your sheet but then the roles are actually like doing the horse race um and admittedly my first couple plays of this I had a really good time but this was one that burned bright and burned out hard quickly and I think a few reasons why um I think one of the biggest things is the game Arc felt like it was going to be almost exactly the same every time like there's kind of this pattern of at the beginning of the game most players are going to try to acquire a horse because if you can get one of the horses you get the horse's ability and so you don't want to there to be like nothing left for you so it's kind of this initial like every get a horse the one time I played it that was gets the horses um and then like you know you're kind of doing this Mak rows and columns in the little concessions thing to get bonuses but the bonus options are all you know the same each time and you're placing these bets on horses to ultimately hope that those horses win another thing I really didn't like about it was um some of those
bonuses were like move a horse forward two or move a horse backwards to or move two forward one and what ends up happening is just like people are just like doing and undoing each other's work because like obviously I've bet on these horses you've bet on different horses and I didn't find that fun like as we literally are just like I move it forward to and then the next one is like I move it back to and it was like we're just like stalling doing nothing and it just kind of felt weird um and so yeah it kind of ended up just I I guess another thing I didn't love about it is you roll and then everybody's going to use this result so it's like great simultaneous play around the table with eight up to eight players that'd be great but it's not quite simultaneous play because the buy a horse action you need to go in order to know if someone has bought before you as well as as you start getting some of these abilities where you move horses you need to know if somebody does it before you so it's like oh everybody can start thinking but you really do have to go once around the table and so I would have groups where you know you'd hit somebody who really is kind of stuck thinking and it kind of like holds up the whole game so it feels like it like loses one of the big selling points of these types of games of like hey everybody can do it at once um and so I think that also caused the game to outstay it's welcome a little bit was a little longer some of the sessions I would have liked it to be um so yeah one that didn't really land for me the way that it seemed to land for a lot of the
reviewers that I was seeing um when I was researching the game um but yeah there you go it was you know all right six out of 10 I want to say so I just played it once I believe we were on a family vacation played it and I very much agree with your sentiment that well I didn't even really have the high first play like I I played it that one time and and after that I mean I think I was pretty honest with you I was like that I was not a huge fan of it um yeah and that was probably my worst play just the dynamic but I think you know it's for a lot of the reasons we're talking about of why totally yeah so there you go long shot the dice game did you uh I don't even know if you ever said what you rated it but uh what what are you going to I did but I'll say it again six out of time okay well then I just was listening so go there you go you know I usually tune out when you're talking to yeah yeah just I just I do the uh you know you know freeze to I freeze my screen so it looks like I'm paying attention and I just go and you know yeah you're just on like a little video Loop so I think you're still engaged you laugh every once while key okay Ryan uh the next game that uh I got rid of that um I'm going to be giving a six out of 10 is going to go to Colt Express uh I've had Colt Express now actually for quite some time and again I played it once with you and it was a while ago yeah I was going to say I think this is one that was like I just got a crazy deal off you know Facebook Marketplace and i' heard about it and heard about you know um seemed like kind
of a fun uh kind of group group game and whatnot and this one obvious I think from a it's got a really cool kind of visual uh presentation of you got this you literally have this you know 3D train in front of you with your you know characters and you're uh kind of moving you know there's levels and you're you know able to move you know up and down and whatnot um but and and thinking back on man gosh it's been a while since I've played Colt Express um because it's all about kind of playing I want to say play maybe we'll work together on you all like play cards simultaneously right and then it's like you all res you like resolve resolve you resolve yeah you all are playing the cards and you resolve the round you kind of see how it R so it's actually it's got a cool kind of like action that happens of like okay what how does it all resolve and whatnot um and you know you're kind of you can you know attack each other you can go and try to grab treasure and stuff um I think you know that part of it of kind of the resolving it all is like fun but also a little too just chaotic maybe for what I was where almost when you're making your decision you start to get this feeling of like I don't know almost doesn't matter what I do like gosh yeah I have like no idea really what's gonna happen so I I guess I'll just try this and hope for the best and so your decisions start to not feel
very important and so that I feel like you have to really get into just the fun of How It's unfolding I remember when I was playing it I think I had a similar feeling of like I can see why certain people would really like this it's just not really my favorite I think the right group would could really get like if you get super into this because it does have that like fun action like just craziness feel and like as kind of a take that you know kind of if you get your group kind of has that that Dynamic and whatnot um but I did I just didn't get selected a lot for you know it kind of um it didn't get picked a lot for kind you know the right situation which again when games that's always the big sign for us is when a game needs to leave is when it's like huh why am I never picking this one yeah even when I have the right like the per like if you ask me what's the perfect group for this and I'm still not picking it okay well then then maybe it's time to go so that was why after all these many years you know it's not a bad game by any means I could totally play game Colt Express again and and you know have a I think have a decent time but yeah it was it was time for it time for it to go you know what I'm saying Ryan I do that's that's like the definition of a six out of 10 that like I'd still play i' have an all right time but reading our definition number six no well speaking of six out of
10 my next one you sick fre my next one is the game best transition ever which I give a six I glance over at the ls and I'm just like oh my goyan you so the game is called 10 TM uh I'm giving this a six out of 10 uh this is a game that's kind of in the genre of filler card game kind of based around push your luck um I would kind of compare it to something like no thanks it's actually got some similarities to no thanks where you're uh bidding to try to get you know card game I actually currently have no you got it again I do yeah I mean it was called was called like 12 years ago and then I see we need a list now of games that Ryan's cold and has now reacquired yeah we we'll do and then games that Ryan's cold reacquired and then that's a good segue for later on this okay yeah we'll talk about that later uh but I was going to say it's like no no thanks has the thing where you're acquiring cards and like you want to get ones that are sequential because then only the lowest number counts and you're trying to avoid points 10 actually has like that almost exact same mechanism it's a little bit of um similar to the game push where on your turn you're going to be flipping cards and deciding how you want to go I do like push as well in fact push is staying in my collection while 10 is leaving and I think a big reason why is 10 takes those types of games and add makes it a little bit more complex it
has this whole thing that you're not just flipping the colored number cards but you flip these cards that sometimes just show the little Stones they're like just the black tokens and it's like okay if you flip those they actually subtract from the total so it actually helps you to not bust because if you go over 10 or something but it also means that you're going to be like giving your opponents more of those tokens um if more of those are there but then you can also bust if you get too many of those so it's like making your total go negative but if that goes over 10 then it bust so just that in and of itself is a little hard to explain and get you know the group to all kind of understand which is not really what you want for that type of game like you want it to be like this is pretty understandable and then it also means that as you're going it doesn't just mean like I need to add a total you're like going back and forth it's like okay six nine okay minus five we're back to four and like if you ever forget where you're at you have to like reink it through now I tend to do a lot of math like in my gaming and always enjoyed math so I maybe didn't like you know have too much of a problem with that but I could tell other people around the table were kind of like oh man what are we at like what's this it's just like a feels unnecessary and so for me the additional complexity and kind of friction that was added into this style of game it didn't feel like there was really any payoff
above these other games that I like in that genre I felt like I was getting almost the same payoff and I'm like well if I'm getting the same payoff I'm going to pick the game that's easier to explain quicker to play um so it's an interesting it's got some interesting ideas but for what I want in that style of filler game um I mean really any game if you're adding complexity and I'm not getting don't feel like I'm getting like a big gain from that complexity that's like you know always a bad thing yeah totally so yeah played it a few times but ultimately felt like I had some ones I liked better in that niche in my collection did I play this one you did we played it once with our family at our parents house yeah must not been that memorable good thing you're getting rid of it man CU I can't remember it at all yeah okay well good God that one it very quickly got to the point you know there's always the thing of like how many times do I try a game you know to see but it got to the point where you know you played a few times and it's like we don't get to game that much so do you really want to use a gaming session to play a game that you're pretty sure isn't going to stick around how many how many times do you chances do and so I was like okay I I think I know where this is headed yeah so yes 10 gets a six another game that gets a six for me and this is a game talk about games that maybe are got a lot of hype in the last year um this is Disney lurana which is Disney's Big trading card game now many board gamers you know
avoid trading card games like the plague because it's kind of the old uh model of buy Blind boosters and you know it can be a big money hey we were big Yu-Gi-Oh fans back in the day however yeah we do have a history with trading card games I have a soft spot in my heart I do enjoy those style of games and I've enjoyed like a lot of fantasy fights living card games we enjoy key Forge which isn't that but it's kind of the same genre of gameplay um and so I was intrigued by lur con because I've got young kids we like Disney they're watching Disney stuff if you look up some lurana stuff the art is all great like the they did a really good job with just like nice you know and so it's like okay there's like a world where this could be kind of cool like and with kids getting older to have a collection of these cards that we can you know build and play decks and maybe a little lighter style of game um I don't know if I said but I'm giving lurana a six out of 10 um played a few games of this mainly with the starter decks with a few extra cards that I had gotten with it um and it has some interesting ideas it's pretty vanilla like it doesn't hugely innovate on like the dueling Trading Card Game formula the big thing in lurana is every turn you can turn one of your cards into ink and that like increases your ink well and then you exhaust your ink to play cards so it's kind of got that ramping that something like uh I haven't played much Hearthstone but I think that has it I know marvel snap that I played for a little bit these are digital
games um have kind of the ramping thing that it's like the first round you're only gonna be able to play like a level one card but the second round you'll be able to play a level two card um if you're getting the ink and so it was kind of cool my probably my least favorite thing about it was like just the way the math Works in this game you only draw one card per turn but then you can ink one card per turn and then it you can play cards so if I ink a card and play a card but I've only drawn one card like I'm going to have have one less card than I used to have and so what I found when we were playing like is typically you want to be inking so that you can play better cards but you're kind of just losing your hand and almost getting to the point that like well whatever I draw I'm going to play and just the decision space really shrunk to where it was like man I just do not feel like I'm making very interesting decisions it just feels like the game's putting these chains on me of like I just don't get to play with a lot of the cards you don't like that feel um you know the game wasn't doing enough other things that were interesting to really like yeah drive that now I'm sure if you get into the game War and you build deck strategically you can probably build Decks that more intentionally get more card draw and do some of this but I was just like you know what the only way this was really going to stick around is if I really like liked it and was like oh this could be really fun to play some with kids and because I was lukewarm on it there's always a little bit of relief it's like
dodged a trading card game that like would have you know because if you get into it you're going to be releas new sets for it I think quarterly so four times a year there's going to be a completely new set of cards yeah that's I have a new mantra I feel like when it comes to board games I will not invest or I will not if a game isn't great for me in its starting form I'm not gonna like I don't want a game that says go buy everything and then it'll be great like I like I want a game that's really fun right now and then it's like okay yeah getting more stuff of course cuz this is already amazing but I am just so weary of games that say oh well just wait until you get everything and then it'll be you know so yeah and so I you know it's I'm glad I got to try it I'm kind of glad it didn't stick around so that I don't have to put more money into it um and honestly I mentioned keyforge that was part of what I was thinking when I was playing I was like man comparing this to something like key Forge where I feel like every turn cuz you always redraw up to six and key Forge and it's always an interesting decision of which house do I pick and I want to play as many cards as possible and I was coming off of recently playing a self-organized key Forge tournament thing that was on one of our previous top playlists really and so it's just like when would I ever I would never want to play this game over keyforge so like it would only be it would only be if I feel like I'm able to
get it to the table with somebody that maybe wouldn't play keyforge which is true with the Disney IP and it was an easier game but not enough there for me so leaves the collection with a a six out of 10 stamped on it big fat six out of 10 nice big fat six we're out of the sixes now we're out of the sixes and I would say Ryan I don't know about you but I feel like this we're we're taking a a jump here um to I would say at least for me now we're starting to get into games that really I think are good games and and ones that left not because I um don't think that not because I think they're bad games but rather just there were either some specific things or even just uh uh you know just fit within my collection or even sometimes a better game comes along uh so my uh next game is one that uh I believe I backed was it a Kickstarter I want to say I think I I think I backed on Kickstarter way back and it it did pretty well and uh and and have enjoyed it because my uh uh my wife especially but both of us enjoy polyomino games so I've always been kind of uh ex you know find trying to find different ones that that work well for us and so this was early on in the polyomino games that we really kind of win in on and this is this is going to go to Isle of cats um which I'm going to be getting giving Isle of cats a seven out of 10 um aisle of cats I almost feel
like when I talk about it I have to talk about two uh separate games because they actually have a family mode as well that I played I think equally as much as I played the standard mode um because it actually made it really accessible like I played with uh people in our family you know even people like Ryan and even me no um but uh but anyways aisle of cats you know it's uh so you got kind of your ship that you're draft it's got kind of your your um draft in the cats that you're placing you know their shapes and you're placing into your ship and whatnot you're got kind of car drafting going on and all that sort of stuff with you know uh you've got these fish that you're using to kind of kind of the tension of the game is do you you're using the same resources of fish to buy cards as well as buy cats to go into the the on your board and so figuring out like what do you spend on what um and then in those cards there's like OB and all that sort of stuff um and so it was it was honestly a a a really good game that that we played quite a few times and and had a good time with um I think there were a few just specific things that really um kind of I don't know rubbed me wrong or or just maybe didn't fill exactly what we were looking for um in this Niche and and the first thing is with what I realized that my wife and I love most about the polyomino
um element in a game is when it's really tight like we love when it's like we are just snugly fitting shapes together you work yourself into a corner exactly it's like how am I going to make this work all together and we love that and this is why my city I mean has been just a hit with us is because that is what that game is unfortunately that's just not I thought I kind of thought that's what eyo cats was but you really quickly realize it's not the ship is you're not feeling the whole ship yeah you're never and and so you're not like tight I mean you can focus on a on a corner and tightly fit stuff but if you want to do well I mean because there's all these rooms you got to try to fill you'll oftentimes just like bolt you know make us beine across the ship to then fill another section but there's not this like really tight constraint that I think I was looking for in a game um like that um and so there was that I also uh didn't love the objective cards in that game um because they were in the cards that you're drafting so just throughout the game as you're going objective cards are coming up and you can buy them but I find they just weren't that exciting for me and then as the game go gets later like a lot of the objectives cards are like yeah well that can't that I mean that does can't even do anything with that anymore that's not
going to do anything and um and then even like there's public objectives and so then why would I play a public objective it can score for either of me or my opponents like I don't know it just that felt weird to me and so there were just like it's like the game was really fun but there was just these few things that I found myself rarely being like yeah I want to play I of cats right now and and it's in that level where we've got a you know I mean this is this is where you could play a wingspan you could play a qu quinber those type of games and so you're starting to get into some of our our favorites up there and so actually replaced this one um and have played it a few times now with world wonders that's a a recent one that came out and that one having played it a couple times definitely hits that tighter polyomino um game more yeah t tune in in six months to see if get rid World W because I'm a I'm a I'm just constantly axing stuff so you know that I feel like at least with our philosophy of games the bigger the collection gets the harder it is for new games to like find your place and hold on True yeah but the question I remember playing I cats with you one time I remember liking it I remember feeling like it kind of just felt like a mishmash of kind of a bunch of modern mechanisms that kind of like it didn't feel like really cohesive to me it was kind of like okay there's some fun stuff going on here but I I don't remember feeling compelled y play it again so yep and so that's why it's
getting a seven out of 10 for me nice next game yeah we go Ryan my next game I'm calling for the second time uh I want see I I wonder if it'll ever get cold for a third time so there's times when uh this is true of life in general where your memory of something isn't necessarily represent representative of how the thing really work was and so this happens sometimes when we look back on some of the games we played when we first got into the Hobby and enjoyed and what ended up happening with us is we had some of these games in our initial collection that got just hammered with plays because they were the only games we had I mean one of the first orders we ever made was dominion and small world and we played those two games I mean so much cuz it was like you go to the closet to pick a game do you want to play Dominion do you want to play small you know Ryan life was so much easier now whenever we now it takes us like 10 minutes to pick what play game day yes so what ends up happening is we played them so much that when we expanded our collections a lot of those games ended getting sold off because we were kind of burnt out on a lot of them even though we still enjoyed some of them well now 10 years later you look back on some of them and you're like actually now that I haven't played it in 10 years that game was fun and like maybe it could fill a niche this is an example I mentioned it already as being one of our first games this is small world small world is a game that
in the last year I was thinking back on it and I was like you know what I don't really have like a light accessible area control game and that it's got the whole thing with the variability of the powers and the races that get lined up every game and I was like man that with the expansions like that that is just a good time and it could fill something that I don't really have um and so I picked it up again and I played once and I had a good time but I also just realized suddenly some of the reasons why maybe it left the question you know and where I maybe wasn't remembering that quite clearly um it's a good game and I actually think there's certain groups that would really really love small world there's a few things for me um that kept it from sticking around a second time uh one of it is in in that style of game it doesn't have a lot of exciting moments once you pick your race and you're expanding on the map most of that is deterministic it's like you need two more than what the tiles in the region to take over the region and so you kind of have to decide where you're going to go but it's all deterministic except for the final reinforcement role to try to go into a last region but it's it's a little extra thing yeah and so you know most of that gameplay isn't like exciting it's more kind of just like there's some interesting decisions about how you go about it then one of the fun things is getting a new race and picking like which one do I want to go for that only happens a few times a game and the other thing is when you have all these expansion content that's great
with the combinations but it also means almost every time you bring up a combination you're having to check the rulebook on like how does this work now yes that would be alleviated if I played it a bit and got to the point where I felt like I just knew them all and I can explain them to people but it isn't exactly like you know I was thinking this is going to be in a niche of bring out kind of as a just very welcoming game that about anybody can play and I was realizing it actually is kind of a lot of information to be like you have six races to pick from each have two abilities there's basically 12 things I've told you that you need to remember what they do because the iconography isn't like G to it's like a little reminder but you do really have to remember what I told you um so yeah I think it just was like okay this is fine but I think if I was to I think I can find another game that could maybe fit in that Niche that is a little bit more exciting maybe has more dice rolling in the combat or something like that um I'm glad I played it again it was fun to play like such a nostalg what's become a nostalgic game like I looked at my board game tracking and it was like 13 years between plays are you serious small world oh my gosh um and so it was fun to do but yeah thinking on it after the play I was like you know what I don't think I'm going to be wanting to get it to the table and that'll that'll do it so SE I I don't remember if I said this rating but I I'm rating small world of 7.5 sorry I got all nostalgic forgot
to 7.5 out of 10 no I uh I totally agree with you actually about the the when I think about what's the most fun part of small world for me it's getting a new race yeah like the the excitement of what's the pairing you're going to get you know but then you're totally right where like the actual I mean con in isn't that exciting it's cool to see like your race do well I guess but there's not a lot of exciting moments in it and yeah it's like an example of a game that's like got cool mechanics but lacks maybe some of that excitement that I think a game you can also get really screwed in that game like if somebody decides actually I'm going to just like mow through your area and something you're like I can either go into decline with like nobody or like yeah yeah oh okay well but 7.5 I I do like I said I do think the right group could really have a great time with small world I just wasn't going to yeah yeah let us know in the comments over under five years before Ryan Cole's small world for a third time you know Nostalgia gets youal get you run but this time I'll have video evidence I can go back and watch like why did I get rid of this hey do you remember when I was texting you the other day about almost picking up a killer bunny set again uh a little while that's very similar I'm telling you Nostalgia when I think about killer bunnies our first board game we really got into you know it Nostalgia can get you Ryan some found memories okay Ryan let's move us along uh next yeah this
next one is not an old game for not an old game no very recent uh one that I uh actually got from a Miniature Market I was in their store and it was on a steep discount because it was missing a critical piece but I found a way of repl are you getting rid of it cuz yeah I was like wait a second um no I was able to replace that and still get it for a pretty solid uh discount there but uh this is going to go to massive Darkness 2 which I'm going to be giving a 7.5 out of 10 and oh this one was sad because the like the type of just game that it is I was hoping for like a nine like I was thinking man this could really be up there for me of one of my favorites and uh and I got it to the table a few times and pretty quickly realized that this wasn't what I was uh uh going after and probably part of it's my fault Ryan does a lot better research on stuff than than I do I'm very impulse just yeah let's just get it and try it out um that's I thought you would like this game from the research I had done yeah yeah well and I know you know Dice Tower said uh Tom really liked it and whatnot so it looks really cool um after playing it you know I mean it's it's a it is it is a cool game it's got sweet Miniatures it's got this awesome just like the characters I also give them that the characters very different
I mean they play Just wildly different and so that's really fun of like this uh just what you're doing with your character is so different than what your partner's doing and how you work together and move through uh to do it like and that all was amazing I love that the problems I had um with it one was just it was just a lot lighter than I was wanting it to be like I wanted like I loved the characters and all that I just wanted a little bit heavier of it like a step up in like the heaviness of the experience and it a little bit fell into what if you watched our previous uh I think it was in my previous cold video um Arcadia Quest that left my collection as well very similar VI VI to that game of kind of just falling back into you know sometimes they call it like the beer and pretzels type game of just you're and that can be great for some groups like that's be exactly what you want um for me usually when I'm getting the a group together that is gonna play a game like this we want something just a little bit more thinky than than maybe it was um and so there was that element to it and then along with that and it just was also easier than I was hoping and I know with you know there was I did some research on like ways that you can you know try to tune the difficulty and PE
there was some like variance people had kind of come up with but in general the consensus was yeah this is just an easier Cooperative game and that's always hard for us I mean Ryan and I have a biy do like our like our Cooper games hard I mean Ryan uh the last game here on the we talking about today is an example of that um uh we we like him hard we like the challenge because man it makes our victories like so exciting and I I remember both games I played we won and we never even sweat it and it was and and that's like really a let down because the fun is this like tension of oh you know we you know how did we figure it out and push through and so we love when there's points in our Cooperative games where things really do feel kind of hopeless oh yes because like when you win after feeling hopeless like or even just get close to winning like it's just a great feeling I know yeah it's it's so true and so I just realized that um and I think with that this is a game that for you know we were talking about games that you can expand um I mean this is one that that just incentivizes you to go buy everything for it and so I similar to you when you were talking about uh uh which one was that when which one were you saying that about I was saying lurana like you're relieved you money on it yeah yeah how I I was able to save some money by uh cutting it off uh at the head and and not uh there you go not
going down deep but I like man it just was disappointing because yeah I was I was really uh really thinking this one could could be a hit but just kind of just kind of fell flat good game 7.5 but but not great for me yeah oh all right my next one is also a recent release one that when I saw the early reviews for it I initially was like o this is one my wife might like which my wife tends to like a little bit lighter games um one of the games she really likes is uh that's pretty clever or gone clever she'll be on the channel lot comboing on the uh you know that get something that gives you something this game has that element and I was like o she might like that piece of it um got it and played it a few times with actually different groups and kind of decided you know what I don't know actually if she would be as big on it this is Milla Fury by Riner Kia um it's a game where you're basically drafting cards and whatever card you play is going to let you play these little transparent diamonds in one of the areas on the board and it's kind of this point sality thing where each area kind of scores in its own way like one of them you play a diamond and score for every diamond in your contiguous group so you're trying to like make a big group of them but other ones you like have to um have had like the right number to play the next one or you like have to match a symbol or something um and it actually is a very fun little rhythm of you know picking it and then
everybody resolves in order and you get these and it fills throughout the game and it's you know we like card drafting so it's lots of Just Like O nice decision nice decision yep um I think and I did I did enjoy it I think I realized some something about myself that I've known about myself but this like further confirmed it psychology you is if a game doesn't have a piece of exciting variability in it it's really got to knock it out of the park with like how much I love the core system and re revisiting that core system and there's games that stay in my collection because I love that core system so much this was one that you know there really isn't much exciting variability like you draft cards so the card drafting will be different but it's the same feel every game and the kind of things you're doing um and I just don't think there was that was exciting me to like have it be a game I keep around that doesn't have that type of variability so that definitely was a big part of it um it also had a little bit of weirdness so like it has each section has a way that you can get like a bonus turn so you like if you surround a certain thing you get to take a bonus card from like this common row and sometimes you can like chain that like because you could get something that then gives you another bonus term the thing is most of these bonus turn things aren't going to happen until a few rounds into the game because you need to get some stuff out there to surround things or do things but when you're when there's the opportunity to get them like somebody could play in
this place to do it it is so valuable to be going first because you all draft cards in reveal but then you start with the start player so they're going to get first pick to get like this this spot and so I actually found I feel like the game has a little bit of a in how it handles turn order because there's only like five rounds in the whole game so say you're playing with like four players so if you were the first player in the first round I think you're at a huge disadvantage because you have first pick at the point where there aren't any of those opportunities to get these big turns but whoever is going third the round the third round going to be the start player they might have you know all kinds of opportunities um because they get to be the first card played that entire round um and so I thought that was a little weird like it just felt a little like wow it feels like you got a way better position just because you were seated a little bit differently at the table um so had a good time with it uh played it a few times yeah I play that one but it was gonna either it also isn't a game that I think would play well two players so it was like okay I'm probably never we're I'm not going to play it with my wife two player is it one that and then it fell a little bit into like even if my wife liked it I don't know that I like it enough to be excited about like and like and there's games that we definitely keep that you know she likes more than I do and I enjoy it because like you know it's one that we can play together uh but yeah it
just wasn't especially with it not being a two-player game or a good two-player game yeah it kind of gets to that point where uh you know like we've been saying with others where it's it's like a good game but you're also never going to choose it you know how what's the length of this one I'm I'm trying to it's pretty Snappy actually it's like 30 to 60 Minutes depending on the number of players and that was actually an advantage to the game that is an advantage so so you that actually is more I was for some reason thinking it might have been oh got you know if it's going over that hour Point that's a I wouldn't say said it well it's welcome I think there just wasn't a lot that excited me to go back to it yeah that's fair so wow okay you got a you got a popular one here next in fact we we got we got two two where all the UN smashing smash the unsubscribe button you know at least drop us a like before you smash that unsubscribe button you know little Charity little Charity like um yeah so my La uh I think last game for me that I got rid of is a very popular game um it's many people uh have this maybe as their number one board game of all time time uh probably the the I mean I would guess well it depends how you describe popularity but one of the most popular games of this designer uh and publisher and whatever they are there you go uh this is from Stone Meer games this is going to go to
Sye yes the Glorious Scythe left my collection I'm gonna be giving it an eight out of 10 um because Scythe is a very good game is it scye or scythe you pronounce the is it I guess you could do either way I usually would say sythe I think okay yeah yeah I like that better it kind of rolls off the tongue sidee rolls in the family rolles in the family smash subscribe button um sythe is a very fun game I like I I would love playing a game aye right now um it has a lot of really fun uh fun things to it uh I you know what's always the first thing that comes to mind that's fun about Scythe is the adventure cards going a draw those those are always so exciting and the artwork's amazing and it's always cool the the choices are so different and and get you cool stuff but the uh I mean it's a really interesting uh I there's probably some board game term for kind of the the blending of It kind of you know is this Euro hybrid it's like a hybrid game of uh you know obviously you're it's a very Euro game in terms of this board in front of you and you're you know moving these cubes and upgrading and but there's also area control and really interesting thing is the whole thing where you're like producing resources but they're govern like you have to like protect them you have to protect them which is interesting also can be kind of brutal if like you I I found the time I
put aside that I don't love that feeling whole time you're like terrified that someone's going to come take all your resources um and whatnot um but really interesting game I mean with the I love the boards in front of you of the whole uh whenever you you get a like move a CBE I don't know if it's there's some way to upgrade where you move a cube from kind of the bottom uh up to the top and it's like a you're like upgrading two things at once which is kind of cool um and and it's another example of a game where you have you know four actions and so I believe it's four and you just have to take and I I always love that in games just like simple like but how do you use those to kind of the best of your ability and whatnot um and so I yeah it all comes together and is a really a really just a lot of cool things happening a couple things from just the times I've played it one I always feel a little underwhelmed at the end of the game and I don't know why it's like I'm I think it's going to Del this bigger moment or feeling than it does I well it's probably probably the table presence like it it's like it's telling you that it's going to give you this certain kind of experience beautiful board with these mechs and these like it's just this big thing and and it's like I play the game and I'm like I'm having fun and then it
then it gets to the end and then it ends and I'm like yeah that was funh that was but it wasn't like wow that was awesome like I I never at the end of a game of Scythe was like talking about these like memorable moments and and this exhilarating feeling it was just like yeah that was that was a good game um a game I could play again an eight out of 10 you know it's like that that was good and and what's tough is like that's I mean this category I mean gosh you at least have to be a nine out of 10 I mean these are the these are the top kind of games uh that for us that we're playing and so it was it's always not a great feeling when a game just isn't quite delivering what you're um expecting it to deliver the other um thing that I had with it and again that may the totally I'm sure there's expert size players that are like this is how you block that or or this is there were just multiple times playing where I found it got into like a one player is just running and grabbing Advent like running all got some extra movement and is flying around and grabbing all the Adventure tokens and getting all those I don't know it just it it was just and it's like okay so we're not we're kind of not fighting but then we are and yeah I don't know it's it it was one
that I was always so excited to play like man I was excited to pull outside and I don't think I ever walked away from a game of side like fully satisfied with it like delivering what I was hoping it would and uh and that's a that's a hard realization so the hope now is the you know I always like to kind of replace games see if a game can maybe fill it better so the new one that we'll we'll see stay tuned but uh with dwellings of elderil you know some people say there's you you haven't played it yet haven't played it yet no that's a recent acquisition um some people say you know there's they're very different games but there's there's some similarities one thing I'm hoping for my wife was not a fan of Scythe really at all um and I think there might be a chance she maybe will like this one more we'll see so I feel like the the category of like hybrid games is really hard because they fall into this category where certain players might want there to be more of the combat side of it and then other players wish there wasn't as much like you're taking these two Realms that usually people really like one of the other and kind of blending them which is just difficult and there's some people that that's going to be their favorite type of game yeah it's like either yeah it's either your favorite game or you're just kind of left like H yeah nice there you go that's all I got uh yeah I've got I've got a one but very different reasons I feel like that I'm yeah this is another
controversial controversal but I will say this is a game that honestly probably is not the right game for most people but for the right groups it's like the greatest game ever I mean there's lots of people that this is I'm sad I didn't get to try top that honestly is probably the thing I'm most sad about getting it is can't believe before I got to try it but the thing is even if I you know we game together so infrequently are we really G to spend the time to play a game that I think I'm going to get rid ofe this is root I'm giving root an eight out of 10 root made my top 50 this last year and we did it and I think I specifically said yeah no I specifically said I was like this is really preliminary I could see this being a game that goes up for me I could see this being a game that drops out of my collection the the ladder turned out to be true um root is an it's a fascinating design it's a highly asymmetrical game that despite looking very cute is very much like a ward game jockeying for position race for points and it's very fascinating the way that diff these different factions interact in the board State can evolve um it does mean it's a very difficult game to teach you know because you have to teach four different games and not just like here you need to understand how yours works but if you're going to strategize and really enjoy the Strategic landscape of the game you really have to understand everybody else's faction like you can't know if the Woodland Alliance is doing well over there if you don't have like an understanding of like how that faction
works and what they're trying to do um and so that's hard because for you to get the experience you really want out of it you're going to have to play multiple times with the same group I had got into this I I've played it twice now and I got it with different groups so I got it to the table now with a new well they were like years apart to completely different situations but um introduced it to a group um you know and it was it was a fine first play but you could tell that you're like we're missing out on what this could be because none of us are comfortable enough with all the factions to really feel like we we understand what's happening but I found like man the work to get it to the table with the same group to work to get that experience and with like how often it would get to the table like it wouldn't be super close together most likely so I'd likely have to be remembering rules myself um so that was GNA just make it really really hard and I just realized I would have to love it for me to be like I'm going to keep it around because there are games that I would say I have that fall into a category of very hard to get to the table I need a specific group but because they're you know I really love it in a specific Niche I keep them um and I realized I'm like fine on rout and and part of that is probably it's it's very much a you know area control um confrontational game which tends to not be my favorite type of game I have a lot of games that I like in that category but it's usually a notch down um
and I just like didn't feel like I was wanting to like intentionally schedule the next session of it because it was like um there might just be other games I'd rather yeah play um so yeah it's one that I just realized you know what I think I just got to say goodbye to it there are some other games I'm eyeing um that maybe fall into that category of very asymmetric and require you know a tough rules teach one that comes to mind is hegemony the leader class to Victory Rec years that looks that I think intrigues me a little bit more than root I really want to play that one but who knows I maybe I end up getting it and getting rid of it for the exact same reason me for a steep discount yes uh but there you go root eight out of 10 um one I would be happy to play again it's like it' be fun to play with a group that uh knows it a little bit better might get whooped um probably would get whooped um it also is a game that's very much a uh you're there more for the journey than the ending I feel like because if everybody understands the game you can definitely pull back you know attack the leader and like it kind of self-balance and it's a race to 30 points so it's kind of just going to be like somebody pops out as the winner like not necessarily who played the best so you're much more there for just the interesting Journey along the way which again is fine but it doesn't tend to be my favorite kind of game yeah um those ones so nice
there you go route eight out of 10 trash I've got the last one too oh look at me look at you uh this is a very different reason for getting rid of this game uh this is a game that I really love we've had many good memories of this this States back a long ways this is Ghost Stories which I give a strong 8.5 out of 10 and it is only leaving the collection because it has been replaced by its sequel essentially which is last Bastion um and we've talked I know in some previous videos we've talked a little bit about how this happened it was basically had ghost stories with the played many many games of ghost stories ended up getting the white moon expansion liked it but then kind of realized man this is adding length and complexity that almost feels like it's pulling away a littleit a different little yeah different category and like kind of took away from some of what we just loved about the core formula so it was like okay let's just play base ghost stories again well once we were there I remembered that there's a new version of ghost stories that I hadn't considered before because it doesn't have the expansion so I kind of reinvestigated that really kind of liked some of the changes that they made and went ahead and pulled the trigger on it and we both uh are in agreement that it is a really nice just like 1.1 version like it really is pretty close to ghost St it's not it's not like it elevated it up even a rating I don't think like I probably rate both an 8.5 I have to play last Bastion more um but it's a you know if I had to pick
one to own I pick last Bastion with just some of those um changes so it's you know it was with a little bit of sadness that ghost stories one of the first Cooperative games in our collection a very loved copy so many exciting moments with those dice um yeah sent it out to hopefully another home that will love it like we did they don't know the yeah the pie the pieces show it a little bit when I was getting ready to sell I was like okay this thing's been loved this thing's been loved games you know we'll we'll live on with last Bastion creating some new memories in a similar space um definitely a game I recommend checking out personally I would recommend last Bastion if you want to check out one in that yeah that series um so occasionally we get some of those on this list that's less of a coing because you know we're tired of it or whatever and more of something just kind of naturally replaced it yeah yeah but hey I mean that's that's it's surprising because you know ghost stories obviously was uh is is one of our favorites but the fact they came along were able to make some good tweaks enough where you know obviously you say same rating but obviously it was enough for you to say I'm gonna go buy this instead so you know yeah I mean it's it's in my DNA that like if I have a version of game and I know there's a game that I like this much more that's like the same game was like well what I want to make sure I
own the one I like much more uh you know and I was able to because I had the ghosto expansion I was able to sell it for you know a reasonable there you go reasonable amount recoup try to keep this hobby going without breaking the bank yeah yeah but yeah and if you want to keep this hobby going for us go uh buy some of these games through those links below support the channel help us uh get try more games make more content well there you go Ryan uh those are our uh games that left our collection July through December 2023 stay tuned every six months we plan on doing this uh who knows maybe we hope you watch some videos in between them but you know if this is your jam you can come back for I only I only watch cold videos that's that's all I watch uh yeah so those are those are ones that left our collection July December 2023 hey if you enjoyed this video kind of hearing some thoughts on games that didn't stick around in our collections you can check out the video here of us doing this six months ago and talking about some of the games I think we actually talked about quite a few more games um in that video otherwise there's another video recommendation here and we will see you in the next one