Skip to main content
Loading video...

Board Games I Got Rid Of (And Why) - Episode 6

Transcript 16:16

hi everyone and welcome to another episode of games i've got rid of and why now this is a series of videos where i take a look at games that have previously been in my collection but now for some reason are no longer in my collection and i'll explain the reasoning behind why i decided to cull them so let's talk about my first game here is illusion now illusion is a game i suppose it's not been amazingly popular despite being from a very popular designer wolfgang wars who was famous for making games like the mind taverns of tiefenthal a wavelength this one is quite a an interesting and unique card game where you are playing cards out on the table and these cards are made up of all these different patterns with different colors and the idea is that you're trying to place cards in order based on the percentages of a certain color on its coverage of that card a bit of a weird concept and it's a real um a real kind of brain tricker as you're trying to carefully um you know align them to put them in the right order and then when it goes on to the next player they can either play a new card or they can kind of call your bluff and call you out and thinking that your answer was wrong and um if if the person who calls you out is wrong then you get the point but if the person who called it out is correct by um you know by saying that you were incorrect by your placement then they get the point a really interesting concept you can play with pretty much anybody um i found that this one was a bit of a had a bit of a short shelf life what because of its almost novelty aspect of the game um i

thought it was really cool really creative um but i found myself wanting to play it less and less as time went by and it also gives you what personally it gave me a bit of a bit of nausea actually looking at these different images because it does really does mess with your brain and um but some really good interesting moments as well where you would um you know be certain that a certain color had more coverage than another card and it would actually end up being incorrect so a fun game and i would recommend someone check this now if it does appeal to you ultra light and you can play this as anybody that one is illusion next up i have emo tap now emo tep is a game i've talked about quite a bit on the show um particularly it was on my list of games that i soured on so i initially really did like this family weight gain where you are i'm collecting these stones and putting them on ships and sending them ships off to different locations and where you would offload them to get different points different ways such as building pyramids building obelisks um and things like that a nice family game again very easy and low threshold to teach somebody you know looks nice you know nice production the reason why this one ended up kind of falling from grace for me is because i found that the decisions you made and the autonomy really did fall into other players laps a bit more than i thought that i personally like you know when you when you load a boat that's pretty much the end of your turn which means that the next person will take their action and could easily sell you off to a location that you had no intention of going or going to um and i understand that's completely the the usp of the game it's what the game's

about it's um some people are going to absolutely love that and initially i did like that but the more and more i played it i thought you were so subject to what other people were going to do with you that i kind of started to um you know started to not appreciate it as much as i did initially but still i can i completely understand why people like this family weight game it's a solid one i'm from a really good designer um but ultimately i just didn't enjoy it as much as i did next up i have a stefan feld game believe it or not this one is la isla now that isa is a game i enjoy i think it's a very clever little engine building game as you are playing cards into different slots which will determine um what those cards do they can give you like a permanent power or at least a temporary power they can decide which resources you gain or can decide which animal kind of raises up its prestige which is going to score your points if you collect more of that particular type of animal and then you're going to be deploying your adventures onto the board trying to surround these animals and capture them i love the card system in this game where as i said you were getting three cards you're allocating them to different slots to see what you're going to use them for i thought that was really cool and when you started getting more cards you had to cover up existing powers really unique concept i thought this game was really good i i did completely like it and um it barely messed out with my um or my shield of quality um the only reason why this one didn't stand in the action was because i played it a few times and i thought you know that's i've kind of experienced what the game has to offer but for a relatively light game it was certainly on the lighter end of the stepper field games probably less than 2.5 in weight

i found that it was quite long it kind of usually between that 45 minutes and an hour and i would have liked to have seen it fall more believe or kind of below 30 minutes if it had done that i probably would have kept hold of this one but i just couldn't see myself ever finding the time to drag this one out or pull it off the shelf um for an hour game so i'm not not a fault on the gameplay i thought it was a really solid game and it was a lot of fun um but just a little bit too long for me uh next up i have a popular two-player game with jaipur now jaipur another game i can appreciate this one is a kind of a market game where you are collecting different sets of things and selling them off in bonuses or in sets trying to get bigger bonuses a really fast and um flowing game a fast flowing game you know very little downtime quick decisions um i liked all that stuff the thing that i i found the more i played this one was that i thought the decisions were quite obvious in what to do um and not only that uh i found that you're a bit of a subject to the card draw a bit a bit too much so you could often like take cars from the center row of the table like a kind of a market and when you did it would we refresh and bring new cards out and because of the different values of the resources this one you've got like really cheap leather or you've got a really expensive and a lucrative diamonds um you could kind of take all the leather and then replenish with all the diamonds and your opponents would take all the diamonds so it was it could very much fall just kind

of fall unfavorably um on the odd occasion and i found those odd occasions became um more and more frequent the more i played it but i like the game i think it's really really well designed perfectly smooth fun fast but i thought the the card kind of the luck of the card draw was a bit too strong um by the time i was finished with it so that's why jaipur didn't stay in the collection next up i have the king is dead now this is a highly revered game by pier sylvester an area control star game that has some really interesting concepts particularly in the fact that at the beginning of the game you've only got eight cards in your hand and these are going to determine the actions you can take throughout but from start to finish you are never going to replenish your hands so those eight actions are all you're gonna have for the duration of the whole game and deciding when to use those cards is an agonizing decision um had a cool concept where you have the three different nations you know england scotland and wales i believe and you you don't actually have a particular nation you're controlling you're trying to either collect the most of a certain type of um of nation um while they're controlling the most regions as well so you've got to have this clever balance of taking cubes off to get your investment in those nations but also making sure they're winning the battles and balancing that can be very difficult um so many good things about this game and it is almost a a brilliant design really to be honest

from a from an objective kind of point of view but i found the fun factor in this game was lacking for me and i i don't know what it is because like again i can completely appreciate how clever this was i you know how how well things or the system was ironed out it's completely streamlined to the core and for that reason i couldn't give it anything but my shield of quality i think it's a really rock solid game but would i pull this game off the shelf and introduce it to new players am i going to think that these people are going to enjoy this um i think it's going to be quite a niche to people who you know a niche of people who are going to enjoy this game and i didn't really see my gaming group being a group that who would appreciate what this game has to offer but still objectively a fantastic game but not one that was going to stay in my collection because it simply wouldn't get played next up i have kingsberg now kingsberg is one of the i suppose one of the first dice driven euro games and this one's a work placement game where you're placing um your your dice down in pairs or even bigger than that and the bigger kind of denominations of dice you put down you'd get more strong rewards you're trying to upgrade your little city try to fight off threats another nice game um has a lot of things that i tend to like about euros but i found i had a few of these games that went on a bit too long because it's not the most complex of games it's pretty simple and what the game has to offer um additionally i started to discover games that were driven by dice um

a lot i used to like a lot other games more than this one like games like marco polo games like lorenzo coimbra and as more on these games as i was discovering more and more of these games uh kingsburg slipped further and further down that list where it simply wouldn't get played um i actually ended up selling this one to a good friend of mine so um i can still play someone if i want to i like the game i can certainly see why people do like this game um i still wrote it about you know a six or six and a half out of ten but certainly one that i'd never choose to play anymore because there are so many of that category that i think are better than kingsburg next up i have lancaster now lancaster is actually one of my favorite worker placement games ever i think it's a brilliant game still holds my shield of quality i think it's fantastic i'm some really great player interaction here from one of my favorite designers in matthias kramer um the reason why this did the collection was for a couple of things the first thing being that i hardly got to play this one it doesn't play at two players or at least you have to make some quite strong changes to the gameplay in order to play with two players so you know you need at least three players to do it um secondly i i found that the housekeeping of the game become quite a burden um particularly because i partic i personally like to play with all the modules all the expansions um in the game uh you can strip all that out if you want to to have a more simple game which personally i wouldn't find satisfying um so yeah i i liked because i like to have so much stuff into it it did kind of get a little bit bloated

all the phases and housekeeping and just upkeep became a little bit too much of a burden and a bit too um a bit too cumbersome for me now that didn't take away from the gameplay itself has some great decisions here some great interaction as you're voting on these different laws and things you're trying to jockey for a position to control the worker placement spots by allocating the strongest knights i've had some great area control as you're fighting off these different threats a fantastic game a really really brilliant um but in addition to these few little faults i i mentioned i felt like i played this game i know i had i played it quite a few times now i had a bit like um a bit like some of these other games i've talked about i've explored everything the game has to offer and i'm ready to move on to something else because there are so many games out there so i enjoyed my time at lancaster i would still strongly recommend it to worker placement fans but it wouldn't get off the shelf for me anymore so that's why lancaster is no longer in my collection uh next up i have lifeboat now lifeboat is the kind of game that i very rarely play this one is an absolute ferocious take that game where you are trying to basically dominate this lifeboat so the idea is you've got these different characters um on this vessel out to sea and you are allocated a couple of cards at the beginning of the game so you you've got a personal character which fluctuates different strength you've got like very weak ones but you'll get more points if you survive or very strong ones where you'll get a fewer points if you survive but you're also allocated kind of a person who you love and a person who you hate so the idea is you're trying to kill the

person you hate but make the person you love survive until the end and you're going to end up playing cards from each other trying to kick each other off the ship you're fighting with other players using weapons to like basically kill each other it's brutal there is some really strong player interaction so which kind of leads into the reason why i personally didn't enjoy it in the end um was because people could people could get eliminated very early in the game and have to wait you know 30 45 minutes until the game ended just sitting out with no participation whatsoever and i think most games nowadays tend to lean away from that there's not much player interaction and play elimination in games nowadays at least not to this um you know blunt effect but still like if you like vicious in your face take that games then check lifeboat out very simple card driven game but not my cup of tea and not my taste next up i have little circuses now this is a game that's quite interesting i thought um it had a lot of potential it's a not only because of the theme you know you building a little circus up but this is a tower placement game where you actually have a meeple on your tiles and you can kind of go from location location trying to fill up your bleachers of different kind of visitors get money and stuff and build new tiles expand your land and such um pretty good i felt that the game itself was a little bit underdeveloped so not only because well to be honest the gameplay was mostly strong it was the uh the rule book and all the

symbology and things there was no consistency there was some massive oversights in the rulebooks and that really did drag the game down um it was pretty generic although there was nothing really wrong with the gameplay i thought it was pretty generic um but it did have potential being a good family weight game but um i i thought that it had its limitations and it didn't really have the legs to hold up to a lot of the games that come out nowadays so um it was okay but certainly nothing to write home about and probably you never heard of this one and it will never come across this game so i'm not gonna go too much into this one just wasn't quite strong enough to hold its own um and the final game i'm going to talk about is london now london is a game by prolific designer martin wallace this one is a card driven game as you are kind of building up an engine of different um or different cards but when you run your engine you are actually exhausting that whole pile of cards which is quite interesting interesting so you're actually kind of building temporary engines and you've also got to weigh up the fact that you are um have to weigh up the poverty you're going to get by running these engines because they're going to count as quite significant end game points um which can really falter and um kind of restrict your chance of um you know winning the game um beautifully produced especially this version by osprey games which is the version i played um you know i like the game you know i'm i'm a brits i i live in england so um i i like games that are set in england but i thought the game was solid it was a lot of fun um but i found that the game had uh

too many as kind of a slight rain on it so it didn't quite have enough to keep me satisfied it was just i wanted like 30 more complexity and a bit more variation what the buildings did because they're all quite similar um so i i found that a little bit frustrating because there was such a clean engine or clean um game system that actually ran the game but the cars themselves just weren't dynamic enough they weren't interesting enough and everything was too similar so it's a shame because it was very close to being a good game and a game that i enjoyed but um but it just didn't quite um didn't quite hook me and sink its claws into my you know to keep me satisfied and to keep me going back to this one so i can see why i like people like this one again pretty light but still has some good decisions but just wasn't quite enough for me personally so that concludes this set of 10 games i've got rid of uh if you have enjoyed the review or this video please hit like and subscribe to my channel and check out my other videos too for everyone else i'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye

Progress saved