Board Games I Got Rid Of (And Why) - Episode 13
Transcript
hey everybody and welcome to episode 13 of board games i've got rid of and why so this is a series of videos where i talk about board games that i've previously owned but for one reason or another i no longer own it and of course i will get into those reasons for the decision of kicking them out of my collection and because sometimes it's not as bad as it sounds and before i get into the games i just want to give a shout out to kianda code at uk which is my go-to website or board game website in the uk um where you can get great games great prices um and you can even use my discount code kianda five to get a discount of five pound off at the checkout on deliveries 40 pounds plus but let's get into the game so um the first game i'm going to talk about on this episode is a game called venice so venice was a game i was actually really looking forward to this is a david tertzy and i believe it was andre novak co-design um this one um is a kind of a pick up and deliver engine engine building um kind of a root building style game as you are basically traveling down these canals and trying to pick up different resources and drop them off somewhere else um you can invest in these buildings where if you drive past them or sail past them then you're gonna get a certain bonus um and there was you know everybody'd have a lot of ingredients of a game that i usually tend to enjoy so that's probably why i was so i'm excited to try it and i will say this game was not a bad game but it was just missing um it was just missing something and i think i can put my finger on what what it was missing so first off um production standpoint so you know their basics this game did have some pretty
bad production issues and the board was nowhere near as big as it needed to be as if if certain people or more than one player were at a certain point on the board then it became extremely congested and just it wasn't fit for purpose additionally you'd have to place meeples on certain spots which would cover up vital iconography um and it just had gameplay-wise also had some issues in terms of it had this mechanism where if you accumulated or acquired this um this i think it was like an intrigue or some kind of corruption throughout the game which you normally get you know if you have a certain amount of corruption at the end of the game if you have the most then you are disqualified from winning this game had that mechanism but it just didn't quite resonate resonate as well as i would like it to and all these different problems as well as some fiddliness and some confusion when you ended up mapping out your turn it just became a bit of a problem and it also took a little bit too long so sad to say this was a bit of a near-miss um and i would like to see maybe an improved second edition for this one um but yeah unfortunately i couldn't keep it for those reasons and the second game i'm going to talk about is genoa so genoa is actually an earlier really good dawn game so if you are a regular viewer of my content reddit gadoran is generally a designer who i sing from the rooftops about i love pretty much 90 95 of his games um genoa a bit like venice was another near miss from me so this one actually used the famous istanbul mechanism where you had a stack of merchants and you travel from kind of
square to square dropping a disk off along the way however this one threw that concept on its head where it would become a competitive negotiation style game where on a player's turn you would actually drop these discs off trying to visit these different resource areas or these conversion spots to convert research into points and the way you do that would be um you you kind of have a free reign for the other players to interact with you and say you know if you come this way and visit this merchant i'll give you x amount of money and so on so i really like that idea i love that core concept but this is one of those games where while the concept and idea of it sounds great in practice it didn't quite work the way i would like it to it dragged on a quite a bit longer than i would have liked you know this is quite uh quite a lengthy game um and i just thought this one just just held back a bit too much i would have liked seen a bit you know more spots to go to have a bit more open board where maybe you can even convince the player to visit several spots on your behalf because i think you you were kept only being able to um use a certain spot once on another player's time which felt a bit it felt a bit it had its limits and yeah it was just it was so close i wanted this one to be brilliant but it just it wasn't unfortunately and this one i think has maybe been a bit of a victim to the uh the tests of time so it hasn't aged as well as i would have liked it to but a bit like venice as well i really would like to see a re-implemented version of this a new fresh clean version ready for this era of board gaming but near miss that is genoa
the next game i have whale riders which is a relatively recent rhinocannicia design this one pretty simple in its design as you are just traveling from point a to point b and along the way you're collecting resources and then trying to convert them in for points uh it's very simple contract for filament game with a point-to-point movement system where you do you want to jump further ahead and beat people to it or do you want to go slower and potentially collect more along the way but you're affecting stuff as as you're going so very simple family friendly design absolutely stellar production and artwork i think this was illustrated by vintage detroit and probably one of the most gorgeous games i've played in in quite a while actually but the gameplay itself it was more catered to a family audience um it has it didn't have its own identity there was a lot of games out there that are very similar to this one but which was a bit of a shame because i would love to see that artwork used in a in a better game design but no issues with it at all it just wasn't very inspiring that is whale riders next game i'm going to talk about is a brutal kingdom so this is a game i actually did dislike quite a bit so this is a michael renick design who's generally a designer i don't mind i generally like his games this one was a big miss for me though so this is a kind of a role selection drafting game if you're collecting these different characters with unique abilities on them um and then you would use them to collect points and do different things to interact the game state and i did like the scoring system in this game where you would have a communal pool of points as well as the points you collect and then multiply
with one another so if you have to say like five tokens personally and maybe there's three in the center you'd get five times three fifteen points but the more you collect you would start to water that down so it was a kind of a balancing act on the way you scored which i thought was really cool um but the i thought all the roles in this game were just way too circumstantial some were clearly better than others most of the time didn't trigger at all and it was just a bit of a boring um just not very well designed game in my opinion just can't really see where the fun would be extracted from this one so um a bit like pearl riders as well this one had lovely artwork some of the best kind of anthropomorphic animal artwork that i've seen but gameplay was certainly lackluster and i would not recommend brutal kingdom uh next up i have two dice now ironically this is probably a game that i like most or more than a lot of people who have played this game so it's not a very well received game maybe because it lives in the shadow of its bigger grandfather game tour this is the the role and white version of the game as you would have this um where you roll a bunch of dice and then you would use those dies to obviously take things off on your player sheet but i did like this element that the game would fight against you where every now and then or every round a certain box would be destroyed means that you could no longer kind of go for those points anymore but you could actually go to another spot and protect them from that happening so i actually thought this was pretty well-rounded um i'm pretty well-rounded and a quality role and right game i'm i'm in the minority there most people didn't like this game but
i was a bit disappointed that there wasn't much variability here you're pretty much playing the same game every single time you can pretty much follow the same paths um but despite that i thought it was a solid one and if you do like one right games this is one of the better ones i think anyway but again i'm in the minority there next up a big game this one i'm a bit sad to talk about this is actually raw so ra um a kind of a classic rhino kenitzia auction style game as you are using towels or these bidding tiles in order to acquire these other tiles which will score in lots of different ways i've just set collection bonuses or not having the least of something um i had a really cool element of push your luck where you could just wait and wait and wait and hope for this road to fill up but as soon as a raw token would be drawn or um then you would actually wipe the whole board off and basically waste your turn or it would actually start the auction which would mean that you could lose out um but i did i did like the way this game works i think it's a really fun i think it's a pretty classic game i'd happily play this any time but unfortunately the most people i played this with didn't like it half as much as i did so obviously i'm not going to play games or force people to play games that they're not so keen on just because i like them so and you know i'm not too worried because i have so many other auction games in my collection it's one of my favorite genres um but so i yeah i'll always have something to go to and i just couldn't warrant having wrought in my collection it's taking up space when i just know in the back of my mind that the other people aren't enjoying it as much as i do so that is ra unfortunately had to go next up i have number nine so number
nine is actually a pretty interesting target placement game very puzzly game as you're laying the foundation of this um of these tiles down and you're made up of all these different numbers so and they'll fit in together in weird wonderful ways then you're basically building new tiles on top of those it's a 3d puzzle and you're trying to kind of abide by certain restrictions but the higher the number or the number is multiplied by the level you put it on so you want to get these high numbers on as high level as possible but normally the higher numbers have a bigger base value so that you can't actually place them as easily as the lower numbers really clever design i think this is a nice filler you can get it played in under half an hour um certainly very accessible family-friendly style game and i would like it and you know i probably would have this in my collection still if it wasn't for another game just downright replacing it for me and that was miyabi uh by michael kiesling i thought this game that game just does everything better than number nine does another kind of 3d element game when you're placing tiles upon tiles and scoring bigger multipliers so that one has so much more to offer so unfortunately it was a direct replacement for me but that's not a slight on number nine i still think it's a good game next up i have heaven and ale so heaven and ale you're talking of michael keisling uh this is a a rondelle style game and a target placement game as you're collecting towels and you can place these towels on either side of your board you've got like the shade area and the sun area one is going to give you money and one is going to give you victory points and the scoring system in this game was a bit obtuse a bit weird um but i like this time track
system where you can travel as far as you want but you can never go back on yourself it's generally a mechanism that's done well and this is one of the best examples of that mechanism being used well um and i mean this is a bit strange because i can't really rationalize so well why this one did go from the collection i think this was just it just slipped further and further down on the pecking order of what i wanted to play at any time so it was sat on my shelf for quite a long time just not getting played probably not getting played anytime soon as i was getting more games i enjoyed more and when i do have that rare occasion to go back and play older games then then i'll probably lean towards something else so it was just a matter of not getting played but if you put this out in front of me and say you know we're playing heaven now today i will happily do that so unfortunately a strong game that still holds my shield of quality but not one that i'm going to have in my personal collection any longer next up i have red seven this is a pretty weird um card driven game by carl chadwick this one you are basically trying to on your turn you have to be in a position where you're not losing and to do that you're either going to play cards in front of you or you're going to play them in the center of the table and that's going to change the rules so one might say you know have the have the most cards of a certain color or have the highest number or something like that so you can either play a card in front of you just to be the leader or change the rule that you're the leader or even do both and it really is a game of attrition trying to manage your hand as carefully as you can um in order to stay in as long as you can you can string these moves together to try and get more mileage out of your cards it works pretty well i think it's
good one this one was really on the brink of being great it was it's good it's not great it just it just has its limits ready and i think this was another victim of being you know in a pool of so many great games in the same kind of space and time frame this one takes so you can get this one played in 20 minutes or so but again you get a lot of other amazing games like this filler games done in that time frame as well so step further and further down the pecking order wasn't getting played um you know capacity in my room my games room is limited so unfortunately it had to go and the final game i'm going to talk about is legendary a marvel deck building game so this was actually probably the game that got me i'm hooked on the board gaming hobby in general this is a deck building game obviously based on the marvel comics universe and this one is you know despite me not being the biggest fan on i'm not the biggest sucker of duck building games generally is something i tend to shy away from um but a big part of that was because legendary was always my go-to deck builder um i love the way this game works as you're building um basically a team of superheroes into this big randomized deck you're fighting uh a mastermind with a unique scheme that he's trying to fulfill they're all wildly different you know there's massively a massive scope and spectrum of different objectives you can go to and try and stop i'm a different henchmen and different bad guys supporting that mastermind so the variability in this game is downright outstanding and you're never going to play the same game twice of this one
because there is so much variability purely based on the amount of expansions uh released for this one um and that was kind of a double-edged sword for this one because this game did quickly become very bloated uh the setup time wasn't the easiest as it was because there was so much variability so much shuffling cards and stuff and with more and more material coming out for it it just became a massive obstacle to get those onto the table it became a point where i had just an absolute you know a calyx cube full of legendary stuff and i just didn't want to look at it because i couldn't even um stomach getting out onto the table because it was just just that much of a pain um but the games itself is still really good you get some great combos and stuff and i just think as time's gone by uh maybe my my enjoyment of the marvel comics is dwindled somewhat as well um and i always grew up loving marvel comics but as it's becoming more and more corporate a bit more pc it gets a bit it just rubs me the wrong way a bit but uh it's it's a good game you know if you like deck builders then i would recommend it but um unfortunately it's not gonna be a game i'm gonna reach out and play anymore and i'd rather play a more self-contained succinct game i'm like one of these um to my right here so um yeah that's um that's the reason i got rid of legendary um so that concludes uh this installment of games i've got rid of and why i hope you've enjoyed it and hopefully that you've got some kind of use and um you know you found it useful and could maybe steer you towards or away these away from these games that you might have been interested in but if you have enjoyed this video please hit like and subscribe to my channel and check out my other videos too
additionally you can support me on patreon by visiting patreon.com chairman of the board to keep the channel going and of course visit canada.com if you're in the uk and you like board games before without everyone else i'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye