Board Games I Got Rid Of (And Why) - Episode 8
Transcript
Hey everybody, today I'm going to talk about another 10 games that have left my collection and I'm going to explain the reasons for that. So, the first game I'm going to talk about is Munchkin Marvel. So, Munchkin is generally a game that a lot of players get into when they first start to get their toe into the hobby. It's a race to get to level 10 game as you are equipping your character with different items, trying to fight monsters. Um, I must admit it's the kind of game that I would not really consider playing anymore. It's very random. It's got a lot of take that into it and it has a horrible kind of bash the leader style mechanism where whoever's running away with it just gets absolutely pounded by the other players until somebody else wins. And I I don't really like these kind of random take that in your face just very um brazen style games and I just don't enjoy that style of gameplay anymore. Um, this one was a lot better than your normal Munchkin style game because not only did it look a lot nicer with the Marvel artwork.
This one had some quite interesting elements added in such as locations and um you know quite interesting character abilities as well. But, at the day it was still Munchkin, still a random mess and um I just don't enjoy the game at all. So, hence why it's not staying in the collection and um I'll never be looking to play that one again. Uh next up I have Ninja Camp. Now, Ninja Camp is a pretty simple filler style game as you have this big map of these cards and you're playing cards as well to move your player, put tokens around, jumping from card to card, moving in different ways and collecting them to get victory points and also collecting them to kind of determine which future moves you can take. There are a lot of these style games out there almost abstract in this feel as you're mapping out your moves, trying to grab cards before other players do. Um, I must admit it's the kind of game that I would not really consider playing anymore. It's very random. It's got a lot of take that into it and it has a horrible kind of bash the leader style mechanism where whoever's running away with it just Uh the next game I'm going to talk about is Notre Dame. Now, Notre Dame is from one of my favorite board game designer Stefan Feld. Um, and very very rare that I'll get rid of a Stefan Feld game. Only a couple I've done in the past. This one is on the lighter end of the scale of his type kind of game. It's a card drafting game and actually scales pretty well. So, I find that a lot of card drafting games don't work at lower play counts. It was it was good. This game is a game I played a lot in a short time frame. And there are a few different strategies and things you can go down.
You're trying to you're trying to collect points, you're trying to control the cathedral, you're trying to fight off these rats that are um kind of disease or spreading disease in your city. Has a lot of the Stefan Feld tropes that you'd tend to like and I really did enjoy the way that you could compound your actions in this game where if you go to the same spot again and again and again, you'd get enhanced versions of that action. But, ultimately there was quite a limited things that you could try in this game. As I mentioned before, it certainly is a an intro level Eurogame and those style of games I find a bit of a struggle to get to the table now because naturally um very casual players aren't interested in playing a game that looks this bland and um has this dull of a theme and the kind of more heavier, more involved Eurogamers want to play something a bit more complex. So, for that reason it found a bit of a bit of difficulty to find a niche on my shelf.
I enjoyed my time with it. It's still something I'd recommend as an entry level um kind of Euro style game and a solid card drafting game as well that I really enjoy, but not quite strong enough to stay in my collection. Uh the next game I'm going to talk about is Onitama. Now, Onitama is widely regarded as one of the best and one of the purest abstract or this modern abstract games. Almost chess-like in its feel and approach as you have this grid and you have a bunch of player pieces, one being your sensei I suppose or your master, the other ones being this kind of um
This is Palaces of Carrara by Kramer and Kiesling. Now, Palaces of Carrara is a weird game, quite a unique game because a bit like uh Notre Dame, this one is relatively uh simple to explain, but it's has some depth there as well and the scoring and feel of this one is a bit different to your standard Euro as the players really do dictate the pace of this game. So, in this game you're basically collecting marble on this wheel system where the longer you wait, things get cheaper and cheaper, but you've got to bear in mind that that also get cheaper for your opponents so they can get some good bargains before you get a chance to buy them. And then you're building buildings based on the quality of those bricks and putting them in different cities. Um, but the weird thing about on top of all that, the weird thing about this game is that when you Well, as an action you can choose to score a certain city which means that that city can no longer be scored by anybody else. So, it has this chicken style effect to it where you want to get the biggest amount of points to it and you don't want to score too soon, but if you wait too long, then your opponent could score it before you do leaving you high and dry with nothing to do.
So, that was quite weird and sometimes a game could last really quickly because um people would score all their tokens um you know very rapidly and sometimes people would just wait and wait and wait and will go for a different approach. And on top of all that, there was so many different objective and scoring cards to add a ton of replayability to this game which really do make the feel the game feel so much differently than other games you might play. And you know mechanically and the fun, everything in this game is something I can't really criticize. I think it's such a strong design. It's a unique design and um something that I should I feel that should be a lot more universally played and um praised. And a bit like Notre Dame, this game struggled to find its place on my shelf because if I wanted to play something introductory, then this is has a bit too much going on to it. It's a bit more bit weird, a bit more nebulous than your average game. Whereas if I have the time to explain it and to fully you know play it with somebody else, then I'd probably rather play something a bit heavier. So, for that reason I didn't really have the group to play it with and to fully get the you know to get the maximum amount of potential with this one.
And you know because it's so rare as well, I I thought you know it might be worth just cashing in and getting a bit of funds to buy other games. So, it was with a heavy heart that this game left my collection and it still holds my shield of quality, still is on my top 50 games of all time and you know just it just just didn't have its place on my personal shelf anymore. That is the Palaces of Carrara. The next game I'm going to talk about is massive. This one is Pandemic the base game. So, Pandemic one of the most successful and popular board games of the modern era. A cooperative game as you are trying to traverse the globe, trying to basically stop a global pandemic, trying to eradicate these diseases and use your player abilities by taking actions to clear up the diseases, to travel around, to try and collect the antidote.
And it's it's a it's a modern classic, you know, if you're watching this video, probably almost definitely played Pandemic. And I still think it is a strong cornerstone and a great example of what cooperative games can do. A lot of games share the DNA of Pandemic. Um, I kind of ran my course with Pandemic. I played it quite a few times again. I I it it it it sort of became a go-to game for me and when that happens, I find very fatigued with games. I get bored of things very quickly if I'm to play them in quick succession. I like variety and I I just it just ran its course with me. I don't really have the incentive or desire to play Pandemic again or even play a kind of a variation of Pandemic. I like something a bit more involved and a bit different because I I find that a lot of games are just too busy stealing from Pandemic and have too much of a similar feel. The next game I'm going to talk about is another Kramer and Kiesling game. This is Paris. Now, Paris is a game that I still rate highly. It still holds my shield of quality. It did very well on my last year's top 50.
It's a beautiful looking game as you're trying to fight for control or jockeying for position by having the majorities in these different sectors in Paris by placing these keys and jumping from building to building, trying to get these higher values and score the most points. And it also has this pretty interesting score track as you are balancing not only controlling things, but also how far you're going to move your token. Um and collect these bonuses, but as you as you travel further down this track, you can't go back on yourself, and you can have some really cool um synergies and different combos and things that you can mix both the area control and that time track with. And I thought these two things independently meshed together wonderfully, almost seamlessly um you know, designed this game. It's so smooth, so elegant in the way it works.
Um but I I find that this well, I I did really enjoy the my plays of this one, and it just sat on my shelf after my initial plays, and it really did struggle to fight for its place and struggle to jump out on me to want to play it again. Because if I want to play a time track game, I'll play something like Glen More. Uh if I want to play an area control game, then there's a ton of them out there, including El Grande by the same designers. So, another great example of a an introductory level Euro game. Uh again, wonderfully produced, looks great, and still a testament of how great of a designer or designers Kramer and Kiesling are by keep coming out with wonderful games. You know, this one only came out last year, and um and a new new expansion has come out as well. But for me, it just had a bit of a glass ceiling and didn't quite have the depth and the claws to kind of satisfy me. So, um hence why Paris sadly left my collection.
Uh the next game I'm going to talk about is Pirate Flux. So, a bit like Munchkin Flux, uh an immensely popular small card game. Uh this one is just wildly random, as you're trying to achieve a certain objective by having a number of cards. The game's rules are constantly changing by um you're changing how many cards you're drawing, how many cards you're playing. And I just found this game a chaotic mess. No strategy in this game whatsoever, just pure um you know, pure wild randomness. And I found that this game would massively outstay its welcome. You know, sometimes you'd draw the cards you needed in 5 minutes, sometimes it would take 40 minutes, and it was just tedious. I I hated it. I really really hate Flux, and um you know, for that reason, it's not in the collection. I just don't like it at all, and I rate it very lowly. That is Flux.
The next game I'm going to talk about is Polynesia. Polynesia is a game I had quite high hopes for. It's uh another game from 2020 uh by Peer Sylvester, who famously designed The King Is Dead. Um and I remember playing this one not long after I I played The King Is Dead, so my expectations were relatively high. Uh this one is an abstract game as you are placing these different, I suppose, tribal people on these different islands, trying to um collect tokens and score majorities or this kind of thing. Um and it had a a relatively interesting mechanism in the in this game, which I quite liked, where you'd take three actions, then you'd take two actions, then you'd take one action. But the order in which you did these things is quite important, and it could really add a lot of um decision space into the game. But ultimately, I found the game quite boring. I found it bland. Um it didn't have anything to excite me. And um yeah, this was another kind of thing that backed up my idea of not really enjoying abstract games too much. And I just found this game a bit pedestrian. It didn't do anything that a lot of I know it didn't just kind of have its place on the market for me. You know, there's so many abstract games out there, and some really good ones, and this one was just not quite up to standard, and um which is a bit of a shame. And but yeah, just not for me really. I I suppose if I'd done a bit more research before playing Polynesia, I probably would have known that, because it's just it's just not my not my cup of tea.
The final game I'm going to talk about on this episode is Pyramids. Uh Pyramids is a small box card game, where you are trying to build a pyramid to score points by collecting all the different colors of bricks. You're trying to build an obelisk, and you're also trying to build a crypt by collecting certain types of cards. Um but the thing I really liked about this game was the action selection mechanism, where you would have these tiles out, and you would draft which tile you wanted, which would not only determine the initiative in which you're going to draft the cards you wanted to build your pyramids, etc., but it also determined how many actions you can take per turn. So, you could either take a bunch of actions, but go last in initiative and get last dibs on the cards available, or you could really get you definitely get the cards you want, but only get to take one of the actions.
And that added a really compelling mechanism to the game for me. I I really did enjoy. Uh this was a big uh kind of surprise hit for me, a pleasant surprise, as I didn't know anything about this game before playing it. I picked it up on a complete punt, and I really enjoyed it. It's one of the best filler games I've played in terms of not knowing much about it, and it just did it just resonated well. It had a nice positive aspect to it, and as you were trying to match up all these bricks and trying to collect these big chains as the pyramid is funneling down into its pinnacle. And it just it just worked for me. I will say it was a bit of a a one-trick pony. It didn't have the mileage and the legs that a lot of great filler games do, but this was still a good one, way better than average. And um I would I I do think that there's a big market out there who would enjoy Pyramids if they knew about it, because it is relatively unknown, and it has kind of flown under the radar a bit more than I would have expected. But really solid filler game, that is Pyramids.
That concludes this episode of 10 games that have left my collection. Uh hopefully, you've got a bit of insight here about why these games haven't stuck around. Um if you have enjoyed the video, please hit like and subscribe to my channel, and check out my other videos, too. For everyone else, I'll see you next time on Chairman of the Board. Bye.