Episode 306: Do nature themes suck?
Transcript
I'd like to start out this episode by saying the opinions of the host do not necessarily reflect the owners of rolling Dice and taking names wa all right I am responsible for the title of this episode which is do nature th no no do do board games with nature themes suck I thought it was just going to be board games with with the attempt to do a theme suck no that's not necessarily true no it is board games with the nature theme suck well I am targeting and here's the thing yeah look this is my opinion this is my opinion I am getting really really tired of nature themed games Tony and just like in the past there's always a theme that seems to come out that extremely popular and everybody wants to capitalize on that them theme prime example right after zombie side came out we just got zombie zombie game after zombie game right and every game was like okay it's another way to kill zombies how is this one any different to me when wingspan came out many years ago huge hit everybody went oh there's a market right there and so we're going to start making games on flowers and trees and animals and everything and it's to me it's like okay so it's a game where I'm trying to grow something make something match something collect
something in order to get victory points and it's like literally the the Box covering anything with flowers and trees and stuff I'm I just kind of zone out even if it potentially could be a good game all right well you know and I hate that you feel that way because there as you said you could very easily miss a good game that is based on something around nature now being the C the stronger chromogen of the um rolling Dyson taking names family mhm I feel that all themes for all board games aren't don't matter plain and simple you don't a theme of a board game gets lost as you play it now oh but that's not right Tony what about the theme of War games or this theme or this thing I could paste any freaking theme I want on a game and it will work it doesn't have to be War Games nature people uh civilizations uh you know ancient times Medieval Times the future space it's the same and I think that's where it is there are a ton of games out there that have some great mechanics in them and it doesn't matter what the theme is so you hate your nature themes I don't think theme really matters in a board game it's about game playay I will counter with please I agree gameplay is under 100% more
important than theme I think theme draws people in going back to the nature I think why wingspan was one of the reasons it was so popular cuz a lot of people who have may have never played board games understand oh birds birds lay eggs trying to collect some eggs make more birds hey I have this bird in my backyard I've seen that bird before it's very relatable so I think nature games are more relatable than the old stale Euro games from 20 years ago of Renaissance figures out there trading Goods on the Mediterranean trying to collect victory points I understand that was a very common theme too it got old and tiresome and like you said the theme really didn't matter and there's probably more appeal for me trying to collect a bunch of cute little furry animals than there is for me to try to collect wood and Stone and wool and trade them and try to get something out of it so I I agree probably most games I'm not going to sit here and say all games because I just I'll come back to that in a second most games probably can be reemed with almost the exact same mechanics probably rename a few of the items or stuff like that and it will work the same way so I I will concede that that's true and gameplay is more important so you're right I may be missing some interesting games that are nature themed I'm I'm I'm just ready for something for me a little bit
more relatable that's all that's fine so you have to find out what are your interests that are going to draw you in so root came out in 2018 and wingspan came out in 2019 root was a battle game you know asymmetric game cats and I forget raccoons and everything else that were involved in root and you know the hit of that was how asymmet it was and how each of the type of things were played so if you go back and you look at well okay what other style of games you know did root spawn where are there other I think vast okay vast yeah oath right and I mean that was horror based that was Monsters and all but so yeah so yes it is a thing of okay I don't I'm interested in Birds I want a board game about birds okay I go pick up oh by chance I picked up wingspan which is a really good game and therefore it is a hot game now I could go find another board game about birds and it could possibly suck right right right so you brought up root which is going to be actually something else that I brought up there also seems to be a more and more games are using I had to go look this up anthropomorphic is that right your faor yeah so when you take something that's a non-human give human characteristics turn a squirrel into like a looking like
a human Etc that seems to be extremely popular um uh for recent uh they recently uh redid libertalia there was a lot of people that's like I don't really care for the new libertalia because instead of actual real humans as pirates you've made animals as pirates and I I would prefer humans too and I throw this out to you because I don't really know but I wonder do some Publishers do that with stuff like root and stuff like that because it's safer people won't get as upset and they feel like okay this is a safer space where I haven't got to worry about who I'm drawing and how I'm drawing I I just make animals that look like humans and and and kind of like people won't give me any grief about it probably and probably maybe it's more cute it'll appeal to more people it's like oh you know you know the common thing is like hey I want myself represent in the game totally understand that so with animals it's one thing you it's one level you have you can remove it really doesn't matter at that point right yeah I'm not offending any one particular uh group any person right because now yeah let's say I I really like cats and suddenly the dogs are beating up the cats you know we always hear you know there's always somebody right there's somebody I mean but yes it's it's easier to do that but also I think from nature a lot of us can understand the balance of you know how nature works you know like raccoons
don't like cats so I can get into that with root I know how that works you know cats are going to eat birds okay let's you know let's add a enemy to a wingspan or something not that they will do that or anything and I guess that's I think one of the things between you and I is I don't pay I go back to where I sit I don't pay a lot to to themes you know you don't pay a lot of attention to things I don't I don't but yeah the the themes I mean like behind me I have power grid I mean like that game doesn't even come close to operating in power grid but it but that's what I do I'm in the power industry we just recently played power line what power line power line but you picked that up and we're interested in it because of the theme because well exactly because how is it going to resemble that but that game you're absolutely right you are buying a book by its cover right I am judging a book by its cover but but you're absolutely right I don't and I think a lot of it has to do with the fact that I pick it up just to see how close they get to something that I am very familiar with now if I was a bird watcher but theme does matter then you said theme didn't matter at all but it it did help you buy a game it it made me look to buy the game but it did not make me want to um what is it did it make it a does it carry through for the game to be good no not necessarily yeah you're right you caught me in my own lie fine I'll go with no no it it wasn't a lie but I just think once you start thinking about stuff I I think theme makes you more inclined to pick a box up off a
shelf I'm I'm just not going to pick a box up off the shelf with trees and flowers okay that's that's what I'm saying and if the theme would have been something else and maybe it was I I don't know I can't even think something that would appeal to me is it I'm sorry what is it theme is it really theme because I'm sitting here thinking you know we we talk about the war games and you know various parts of um some of the war games we've tried you know I prefer this area of history is that theme or is that a particular time you know but the theme of the game is from that particular time so I'm more drawn to Medieval ancient war games than I would be to World War II yeah I'm looking up the word the Define theme a subject of talk a piece of writing a person's thought or an exhibition a topic it's a topic yeah the topic of the game is yeah topic of the game is Birds yeah the Roman Empire how the topic is have you have you thought about the Roman Empire Today have I thought about the Roman Empire no I have not I have been thinking about gnomes and um what else congratulations you're now thinking about the Roman Empire because you know guys as guys we got to you know we think about the Roman
Empire a lot don't you remember don't you remember a couple weeks ago when that was a meme going around it's like how often do you think about the Roman Empire you know I don't pay attention to I don't know why it was the funniest thing it was trending where uh women would ask men how think about the Roman Empire like I'm thinking about it right now and it was just I don't know why it related to so many people but it did for some stupid reason I don't know it was just sorry that was just a tangent there but well and how do you see these memes uh on Facebook X Twitter whatever it is T yeah uh the things I don't do that fair and you're better for it so okay I'm sorry am am I I'm grumpy you are no you well you are grumpy but you I am always crumpy yeah May laugh you may see a cute little animal uh little video or something that may make you less scrumpy that's yeah well I mean that's what I use YouTube for maybe if I watch the meme Channel on YouTube I might see it is there there's a of course there's a meme Channel there's always for everything speaking of theme squirrel okay back to theme all right so you're tired of the nature theme you're hoping what what theme do you want to suddenly grab a hold of the industry now it's it's not that I want a certain theme to grab hold of the industry I'm just tired of the current Trend and I'm ready for it to jump onto something here's the thing when wingspan first came out I
thought cool very approachable I'll get my mom to play Vanessa got her mom to play it was one of those that I could get people oh I I know what a flower is I don't know what a Renaissance Trader does over in Italy but I understand how a tree grows I get it and it is an easier way to bring a a person in personally it's it was just very dry for me now I this maybe this is kind of a tangent but I mentioned to you this the other night as do you feel that Euro games are becoming more multiplayer solitire games where we sit down and play but because there's a lot less player interaction we're kind of doing over our own thing and whoever has the most victory points after 45 minutes to an hour wins you see that as a trend recently it seems like the the games that we've played we lots of times say well there wasn't a lot of play interaction while I kind of doing my own little thing and I did my little thing better than what you did but I couldn't stop you from doing your little thing we we've had a we've had a run of that now true we don't get to play all the Euros so maybe there's you know but of the ones we've gotten the opportunity to try out that we have been able to uh obtain that we've that seems to be the trend now it would you know a solitary theme game around oh I don't know trees growing you know there there you go well I mean that that's a Euro type game that
could happen it's probably already out there like evergreen or something but yes I think you are right recently it seems like every Euro Style game we play I'm doing my thing you're doing your thing and we're never in each other's business other than maybe we're not pick pick something or do something that you really wanted to do but I'm not I'm not hurting you that much right now in our game group I think we probably like something has a little more player interaction because it's just more fun with us but you said you had a prime example you said with Donna she's like she was all she's all into the multiplayer Solitaire experience yeah leave me alone Guild of merchant explorers she she absolutely that game is top notot she's doing that and the most interaction she enjoys is prime example carcassone any type of tyene game where it is not yes I can mess you up but that's the level of how much she's willing to take of going at you where Vanessa oh who's where can I put this I know this is basic Katon robber oh you nobody's gonna be hurt over here on this 12 okay I'll put it there oh 100% Vanessa is definitely like I don't want to mess or hurt anybody so I'm going to put this over here where it affects no one so she would definitely be more into the non not violence the wrong word uh non take that non-confrontational style game and and maybe that's just the trend because uh maybe people were more
inclined to sit down and play if it's not confrontational especially newer players it's like I sat down and play a game and I just got attacked all night and it wasn't any fun I understand that cuz when early on that was my issue with small world I never played anything like that I remember I sat down and played and got the crap beat out of me and it was not a good experience for me so I I get that part but I think I've gotten now to the part where I don't know with our little game group of you know sticking it to Mark is fun and him sticking it to me is fun and we laugh about it and it's You Know Nothing Hurt that's just part of the game it's part of the strategy too right well I kind of see what he's they're doing over there you know classic worker placement I'm going to put this worker here just to keep this part from getting their worker there from taking that thing yeah that's a very classic thing that I tend to see less and less of of locking people out keeping you from getting that there are some games that we've talked about in there's hate drafting that still kind of exists we talked about that with pyramido it wasn't necessarily hate drafting but you want to make sure not to give the other person the good tile to choose on their turn yeah and I'm thinking back to some of the um other examp to take that as we continue to play some of these games there's always the Lesser option to for everybody to do there's the good one I mean well was the age of innovation recently you know everybody went to this one but I I never felt as you locked everybody out at once there were there were things that you could do or things but that was that's kind of age of innovation that was
pretty solitary too was it fny you should say that uh yeah in hindsight it it kind of is it's not it wasn't a lot of take I guess you like you said you could take an action that somebody else really wanted you could take a tile that maybe somebody else really wanted but it wasn't necessarily out of Spike cuz usually it was probably it was better for you um if you did it that way so but I but here's the thing is one of the my favorite games of the past couple years was class of cultures I really enjoyed the player interaction of that you're attack you because you can attack people you can go and do stuff and mess other people up but when everybody's doing it together and nobody's and everybody's a good gamer nobody's really dogpiling somebody else it's just it's just fun it's it makes a memorable experience where I like age of innovation Terra mystica for the experience as I'm playing it once I come out of the game I don't remember a lot of it but it's the player interaction stuff in games that makes it something I'll think about later oh remember that thing I did did to Tony and Tony had that reaction ah that was funny that's very memorable you know that stuff happens when there's a lot of player interaction you know one of the things that I've noticed is we also tend to where we really screw up the rules that's more memorable you know I guess probably I mean you know it's it's one of those but uh from a theme memorable you know what are more games doing I think you're right I think it is time to move on from uh those
games that are just you know go do your own thing go be this animal pirate thing um that doesn't cause problems for anybody you know just well I think there's a place for them and I'm not saying do away with them I'm just kind of ready for for the trend to move on and I kind of set myself up because before this uh recording I went and looked at the BGG top 20 and I think there was maybe one nature game in the in the hot BGG top 20 so right now maybe that's not it's not a big thing um it's just to me the nature is very generic it's like a lot of it is I'm going to get plants and grow plants and collect and and stuff like that now I I will say this um the problem me doing this live I can't edit so I need to check the what is the name of the game that Northstar games is coming out with that is about animals and stuff that I'm actually looking really forward to it is H I forgot you know what it's called it's called animals that Marty doesn't want to play It's called nature CU you remember J con said are you really going to call it nature went yeah we are cuz I was like oh my gosh the one thing he's callic in nature so this is based off of their uh series of games like and it's it's leaving me what's their series of games
um Evolution Evolution Evolution thank you sir thank you you they have all their different Evolution style games so they're coming out with like a big box retaking of the rules it's called nature it's nature actually BR like I said I said could you come up with something a little more catchy and it's like well it kind of is what it is all right but there you go you it brings you right in you know exactly what you're getting you know ex it is it is not something you have to go look up and figure out the reason why it's very interesting to me is because they said but the thing about this game is you're going to set up the type of game that you want do you want a game where you're just kind of doing your own thing you don't want to mess with anybody well then here's these sets of cards and setup we recommend you use do you want to really be messing around and screwing up everybody and hurting them then you want to use these sets of cards I think that's really cool of coming out with a game and not every game has to do it but I'm glad they're doing this in this way it's like do you want a little more take that or do you want a little more something that's a little more less uh interaction and confrontational we have both for you in this if more games start doing that I that is really cool because then that satisfies both needs we're gonna definitely make it confrontational for those that want it you know yes yeah yes so and then because when we talked to them they were talking about how you know I talked about Evolution where you had the various people who would turtle and
basically you know build their their species so that nothing could bother them or the maneaters or the carnivores but people would often in that game and I've seen that happen with evolution was the people who know the game suddenly really dominate their species dominate no they WR dominant species that's a game yes so so yeah nature I'm I'm looking forward to that one even though it's called nature it's it draws you in because you understand how nature works you understand you know add the climate expansion you have to deal with the Ice Age things like that so it's going to pull you in versus oh I don't know here's a game where it's a bunch of animal going around trying to do something they're casting magic right right no yeah no I think it's going to be a big hit for them I really do and I think one of the huge selling points is you play the type of game that you want to play use these carnivores if you want to really go after each other or use these nice little deer and these little furry animals if you just want to leave each other Al you know sort of deal so I I think you know a lot of people clamor now every game must have solo so it' be interesting if people if designers come out it's like well here's a way you can play it where it's less confrontational one there's a little bit more um and I'm not saying every again it's not a requirement and if it doesn't have it no big deal but I think that would be more Mass Appeal to the game if it has that option for both yeah and I was thinking
that from the games with the theme Dungeons and Dragons been around forever right since yeah I thought with the release of the movie we would see a hard influx of more games around D and D you know more of the Wizards more of that type of stuff is people went out and saw all the movies but you don't but we didn't so yeah what's what's going to Dethrone the nature games right now and yeah I know over there on btg but the some most of the games on there are very old games yeah yep so yeah so yeah I am again I know there's a lot of people people out there is going Marty I I love nature games and that's great I have no again that's it's an opinion and you know one person's opinion is just as valuable as my opinion they're they're both valuable in your own personal ways but and this is coming from two guys who whose um logo has a squirrel who rolls dice crap right wow okay I didn't say I didn't set that one up right it's like you idiots it's like right in your logo you got in that little fur fory animal yeah we were ahead of the curve that's all we we were out before you know the whole you know if we would have done it if we' have come up the logo with a theme at the time it would have been a zombie not a squirrel yeah I guess it
would have been it been right right around the time time of the zombies yeah so but I mean it was but it we tried why did we just well I think uh uniforms with people with little furry squirrels is you know those are cute people are going to look at them but no not really not talking about people walking around in fur uniforms all right here we go uh for comments uh why don't you let us know what kind of themes uh are you into are you getting did you get like I can't edit all that out so I'm be there hold on I gotta cough yes he does he's coughing he's had mute that I have a cough button see when it's live I can't I can't edit any of that stuff out no me my nose started itching really bad I'm like oh my gosh what am I going to do because that's right y this episode is on our YouTube channel so if you want to go to our YouTube channel you can see our pretty faces that over here as we do this and you can comment over there on what are some of your favorite themes do you still like nature themes how do you feel about player uh multiplayer soliter games do you like them you like some a little more confrontation of course you can always come over to our Discord Channel and uh chat with uh us there too so Tony you asked me is there a theme I'm looking forward to is there a theme that you would draw you into as the next run of themes that you're into I mean would be into or just you said you didn't care if the game play is good you don't care what the theme is yeah and be interesting to see I think it would be interesting to see the next game series that's coming out more of a
um not confrontational but we need more interaction we need a little bit because I I always go back to cards and how interactive those games are and playing well see even that I think about even some of the simple card games there's not that much interaction hard space you know you're just playing cards try yeah I guess we recently played inheritors and I felt like that has some really interesting player interaction of oh yeah I did you know because you you were looking around the table it's like I want to get this before they get that sort of do and I don't want to play this before they do that and we played uh Inside Job inside job well that's yeah but I'm talking about uh the the card game that we just played the other night um oh paper uh uh salt and paper sea salt and paper SE Sal oh is that it yes sea salt and paper from pandasaurus yes yes uh we I thought that was really interesting too because there was a lot of uh I want to keep you from drafting this card so my discard is going to be on top of this pile so that you can't take that one sort of deal so it is interesting that some of these kind of simple card game Scout uh is another one too that has a little bit of player interaction and stuff like that too see yeah uh maybe theme isn't doesn't matter but give me something that has a little bit more confrontation to it and maybe that's why you and I are getting more into some of the historical games cuz maybe we do like that head-to-head type confrontational type thing that uh we don't get a lot of now absolutely all right so there you go uh do nature themes suck I'm kind of getting tired of
it Tony really is they don't suck we're just tired that's it I'm just tired let's move on zombies nature what's next there's not much