Board Game Rating Changes - Episode 3
Transcript
hi everyone and welcome to another installment of board game rating changes so this is a pretty sporadic series i do where i take a look at games where my impression of has changed since the last time i rated it so they've either gotten better or they've gotten slightly worse so i have 10 games here um six of which have slightly decreased and four of which have increased and some of these games have changed more than others but even if they've changed by say half a point at least it gives you guys an idea or an impression of the trend these games are heading before we get started on the list i want to give a shout out to the show sponsor kianda dot co dot uk who are my go-to online retailer in the uk they have some brilliant loyalty schemes and if you use my discount code in the show notes you can get five percent off your first order but let's get on with the video the first game i'm talking about is deep sea adventure which was originally rated at a 6.5 out of 10 and now i've decreased it to a 5.5 so if you're not aware what um deepsea adventure is it's a very small box pushy luck game by oink games where you are basically um in a submarine you are you have a shared oxygen tank with all the other players and then on your turn you either dive deeper into the ocean with the aim of getting these higher points tokens or you can kind of cut and run with the treasure you have and try and make it back to the submarine and secure those points now the reason this has decreased for me is because each time i play this one it seems to follow a certain pattern and i don't feel like there's enough wiggle room to really exploit that pushing up like mechanism because as soon as
somebody cuts and runs uh the oxygen in the tank starts to deplete and what that generally means is that everybody has to follow suit and it doesn't really give you that incentive to keep pushing otherwise you're just not going to make it back in time so it kind of just became an exercise of rolling the dice and hoping you roll higher to make it back up to the submarine but i love the concept of this one but i think in practice it just started to show some cracks the next game i'm talking about is the chronicles of crime so this one i did rate a seven it might have even started off higher than that when i originally played it um and it's since dropped to a six out of ten and i think the reason for that is because i'm at a point now where i feel like i've played enough scenarios um not only from the base um the base game where you're playing as a police officer but also from the expansions um particularly the uh the film noir private detective expansion which i thought was actually an improvement on the base game but even with that um improved setting and more enjoyable setting i thought that the stories were often quite predictable and cliche you know there's nothing like ultra creative about this where you thought like oh this is this is good this was leading me down a path i wasn't expecting so i thought again the more scenarios you played and started to unravel you think that well they're all pretty much just you know cliche um murder mysteries or cliche uh yeah like silver crime stories so yeah for that reason um it has decreased me i did enjoy my plays of it but it's not really something i'm looking to get back to play playing anymore i mean maybe if there's a particular story that i'm interested in i might have to give that
one a go but i'm quite content where i'm at with chronicles of crime the next game is nova luna which is actually an increase for me so i originally played this one it was a seven out of ten i've increased it to a 7.5 out of 10 and i might even be being a little bit harsh with that because i think it probably should be an eight out of ten um so yeah i might even give it some grace there but this is a really interesting puzzling style game by juve rosenberg it uses the almost the same kind of time track system as patchwork where you can take certain tiles but all these tiles have time allocated to them which will move you along this track and as long as you're in front you will not get another go but i love the puzzle aspect of this one as you're trying to line up all these different colored tiles to basically trigger each other because all these tiles want to be touching a different kind of orientation of other tiles and you can trace path through ones um and you can have these immensely satisfying turns where you can trigger a bunch of these tiles all off at once by placing a single tile so actually i thought the the game design this one is pretty much genius and you know what i might even say let's give it an 8 out of 10. just uh just from talking about it now really enjoy this one it plays in a succinct amount of time and each time i play it i enjoy it more than the last time so that is that nova luna very impressed the next game is re-nature which is a slight fall for me i'm going from a 7.5 to a seven so this is a a a majority style game designed by kramer and keisling but the twist on
this game is that everything is done by placing dominoes and you're going to be placing these dominoes trying to match up symbol december which are these different animals and then placing these different fields and bushes and things in these adjacent regions to try and control the majorities it's a pretty light game but although it does have some pretty nasty elements to it as if you have a match like a a coverage or influence in a region with another player then you cancel each other out and you can really use that to your advantage by placing neutral pieces to basically try and eradicate other people's placements so it actually does have some depth here but you are somewhat pigeonholed in what you can do and because you are limited to the dominoes you can place but that's not a criticism of the game i do think it actually works with the simplicity of it but the reason this has fooled slightly for me is pretty much just by by default and not actually a fault of the game because since i've had renatu i ended up acquiring a game called rumble nation and for me rumble nation is a quicker experience but it still offers that lightweight introductory error majority niche that i need in my collection so i tend to be leaning more towards that one than this one so it's kind of default pushed it down the um the pecking order but i think it'll ever really fall below a seven but i just think i have preferences over ring each at this time which is again by default pushed it down slightly the next game i'm talking about is rising sun so believe it or not this game was actually my number one game um from from the year it was released i was very much enamored with this game but since then my tastes have changed
quite a lot and i kind of steering away from these massively huge sprawling table hogs with miniatures and different game modes and cards for this and cards for that so that was kind of one of the um you know the tipping points here i should say that this has fallen from a 7.5 to a 6 out of 10 for me now i still appreciate a lot of things this game offers particularly the combat system where you are basically blind bidding on these different factors which will determine the orientation or the the way that these um battles are going to get resolved very clever combat system one of my favorites actually but the rest of it um i just don't feel like i'm willing to fully engage with it anymore i'm not really interested to see how all the different monsters and factions interact with each other i'd rather play something a bit simpler as i mentioned earlier um either something very simple like rebel nation or if i'm going to play a more involved majority game i will lead towards something a bit more urified like el grande or maybe something like waldenstein the next game i'm talking about is miller fiore which has actually increased for me from a 7.5 to an 8 out of 10.
very much enjoying what this game has to offer and this is the most uh recent game on this list so this is uh very much a point salad style game but mixed with drafting as you um you're taking one of these cards and then obviously passing them on to the next player and then you're taking an associated action with that card on this board which is basically made up of a bunch of mini games and all these games will score in different ways but they all basically just shower you in points and it already is a game of kind of deciding you are you're going to help yourself by getting a massive bunch of points or are you going to spend this time to try and cut off somebody else to prevent them getting a bunch of points and just weighing up who's going to get the net gain there is kind of a big part of the game the drafting is fun it's ultra quick and again it just really does feel satisfying especially when you pull off these huge combos where you do certain things on the mini games which will give you an extra follow-up turn and you can even change several of those turns together so i think um canezia is on an absolute role at the moment loving what he's doing and miller fury um is just going from strength to strength for me the next game is another drop for me this is corrosion i'm originally rated at a 7.5 and i've dropped it to a 6.5 so this is actually a very interesting um engine building style game but the twist on this one is that your engines are pretty much temporary so they're not going to stay there forever as the um as more intense and terms go by your gears and things will start to corrode and come off the board meaning you have to buy new ones
um lots of things i enjoyed with this game and i won't go too much into detail in terms of the mechanisms but i want to talk about why this has dropped for me so originally when i played this for the first few times you know this is a really strong game however i do have some concerns that it's running a bit long um because it does really have the potential to to go to about two hour mark which is a bit overkill considering this is the the heaviest of games or the most complex of games um but i gave it the benefit of the doubt because i know the designer and a lot of people came up with house rules saying if you play this way it doesn't affect the balance at all but it does shave a lot of time off the um you know the ultimate game length i gave some of those um variants a go and the game still ended up feeling too long for what it was and i thought you know there's only so much grace i can give to a game so many households i can um implement put into place before i have to say you know what this game is just too long for me i'm not going to get it played and i'm never going to pull it off the shelf for that reason so the sprite is showing some really good promise here and you know originally really enjoying it um it has fallen to below that recommendation mark simply because it goes on a bit too long the next game is merlin by stefan feld now if you watch my channel you might know i'm pretty much a step and files fanboy it's very rare a failed game will fall for me and this is actually a game i've advocated a lot over the years i still do you know i still rate it a seven out of ten but i did rate it and eight out of ten and the reason i um i have decreased the rating of this game is because you get the optimal experience from this game
you really do need to use a lot of different modules and expansions in a quite a personalized way where you need this bit from here this bit from here and before you have the optimal game you've kind of got stuff everywhere and then it becomes quite um quite cumbersome to sort everything out to get things set up and packed away to remember how all the different things work together the order in which to resolve things so like i just wanted a more streamlined version of this my desire to put in that extra work to get the optimal experience from it has um you know has dampened and it's kind of taken away from the overall impression i have of the game and because if you want to play it with a straight up bass i will call the cool version of the game it's just a little bit lacking for me but i've always felt that way but as i said if you want to really get the most from the game it takes a bit more work than i'm willing to put in at this time so um yeah unfortunately for me um cumbersome games games that require a lot of effort and remembering things um just naturally have fallen for me over this last year and i've started to appreciate more self-contained simpler more streamlined games and unfortunately merlin has been a victim of that change of mindset for me but the final two games are ending on a positive note and a pretty significant increases so the first one is going to be babylonia which is the second dab kenichi game on this list and this is raised from an 8 to an 8.5 for me you i think you know 8.5 not that big of an
increase from an 8 but an 8.5 for me is when it starts to venture into my elite um commendation which means that it's pretty much amongst my favorite games out there i'm loving this kind of root building game lots of different ways to score points um good turn angst in this game as you want to try and connect regions together and build a chain of things but try and cut people off as well and i've raced to get to the best spots and surround these regions for area majorities collect tokens and get unique powers but all in an ultra condensed game that takes about 45 minutes to play the rules ratio to the depth is off the charts for this game and i am still loving it and in fact you know it's getting better for me and i can really see this one doing well in um this year's the top 100 so that is babylonia strong recommendation um from me and the final game is chinatown and which has gone from an 8.5 so already loved it up to a 9. so chinatown one of the most interactive fun economic games you can possibly imagine as you are claiming spots on this big map which is basically several different grids you're placing your token on them then you can allocate shops to those spots with the idea of trying to have a bunch of the same shop next to each other to get more income at the end of each round however everything in this game is up for trade one of the most dynamic and creative games out there you can really strike some amazing deals um the commodity speculation this game is great as you might be sat on a
spot there that's not collecting you any money but maybe that sport is going to be worth a fortune to somebody else later in the game um if you like negotiation you like you know player interaction you like that economic thread through a game then it does not get much better than chinatown and much like babylonia i can see this one climbing quite significantly in this year's rankings so yeah very much loving chinatown at the moment so there we have it that concludes this video hopefully it's been somewhat useful and interesting for you uh if you have enjoyed it please be sure to hit like and subscribe to the channel and also check out my other content but for everybody else i'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye-bye