Skip to main content
Loading video...

The 10 Worst Deals at GenCon 2024 . . . don't fall for hype.

Transcript 25:51

everything about Gen Con is designed to make you want to buy games right from the hype lists coming out the new releases that are only available there on the convention floor the packed Auditorium in the hallway that gets shoved up against the door the time zone where they open drop balloons and everyone scatters rushing towards the booth they want to stand by whether or not it's luron cards Kingdom Death Miniatures or pins listen if you're sitting here watching this video getting ready to rush towards your well most hyped game let's bring that level down a little bit I've got 10 games that have appeared on multiple reviewers content creators and just General Media lists is the most hyped games of Gen Con 2024 some of which are games that were on my list and that my wife and I would actually like to own but I have a compelling reason for each one of them as to why you shouldn't purchase them at Gen Con specifically with whether it's the best price you should know what you're getting into because it's probably just going to sit on your shelf or the publisher really doesn't have a good track record of putting out reliable products so the hype is where they make their money and the window of time afterwards is well where everyone forgets about the game they published let's walk through this let's break down these 10 games quickly and fast cuz I know everyone around you right now is screaming bye bye bye run run run get in line wait and bring out your credit card all

right the first one on my list that I do not think you should buy at Gen Con this year is the brand new potentially hottest Game of the Year arcs by leader games and before the BGG and Reddit Community start leaving comments down below saying that I'm a clickbait blackmailing you know horrible husband and going to be a terrible father I actually like arcs quite a lot it's a compelling interesting game and I'm nearing 10 game plays of it now I'd like to hit that 2030 possibly even 40 game plays before doing a final official verdict but I don't hate this game I think it's really really welld designed I think it's extremely compelling and I think there's one core reason why you should not purchase it while you're on that convention floor arcs is such a strategic nuanced complicated game with arguably unfair rules for any players that have slightly more experience than the rest of the table that if you purchase this you need to be committed to getting 10 game plays to your gaming table within a limited W window of time 3 to 6 months with the same or close to the same Core group of people I never want to teach arcs to another fresh table of Gamers and I will if I have to but this game requires multiple plays for you to even fully understand understand the Nuance micro rules let alone the in-depth strategy and then all

the weird mechanics it starts introducing As you move into the campaign and some level of asymmetry it's a beautiful game and I truly believe shut up and sit down when they say at 40 games and potentially even 20 games they loved it but that was 20 games or 40 games playing with experienced players playing with people who knew and were willing to teach learn educate and Co commit to repeat plays of this one title I mean it was on the cover of tabletop gaming it's one of the best games of the year according to this content creator This reviewer and many many others and it might still hold a spot in the top 10 of the Year for me but that doesn't mean you need to get a copy of it now they're reprinting it it's going to come back into circulation play a friends demo the game absolutely but unless you can commit to at least a minimum of 10 game plays in the next three to maybe 6 months but really 3 months this is just going to sit on your shelf cuz the first couple game plays are educational and arguably disappointing possibly potentially compelling then you get into a little bit more of the strategy but you'll make mistakes that cause you to lose in Dynamic High fashioned ways it's not until game S 8 9 10 that you really feel like you can sit down and be highly competitive now it does play great at two-player so keep that in mind 10 game plays with one other person might not be

too much of a commitment but there's going to be a lot of people that buy arcs like a lot of these other games on my list and they'll play them once maybe but for the most part they're just going to sit and crowd that wish list of games that I shouldn't have bought now cuz I can get them for a better deal later and why not play a friends cuz everyone's going to own this the people that aren't watching this video are going to be running to pick this game up anyway moving on to game number two card by d games this is like the top for everyone this year and I understand why de games is an amazing publisher with really smart intricate design high levels of production quality and usually very satisfying gameplay however I have two big arguments against picking up rock hard there on the convention floor first off there's not a single music centered game music themed game that has broken the top 1000 on tour the role and right would be the closest from my BGG research I could be wrong about this but this theme has historically not settled well in the realm of board gaming and the board gaming hobby there's not enough people that have that crossover and relate to it and I know some of you are saying you're very excited about it but people have said that about other games that are music themed Ragnarok stars and vinyl games that I think were a lot of fun I think this is going to fall off quickly and I'm concerned about that because many people are going to spend that $50 $60 picking it up there on the convention floor cuz they're excited and because they're hyped I mean

this was on my wife's list she certainly would have picked up a copy but I think it's going to be on sale within a couple months not from the publisher but specifically from people like sellers on BGG we bought the three- ring circus last year they on the convention floor and within 2 months we could have bought it at Half Price like new so if you're excited about this and you want to get a cop this isn't going to be the best deal the theme is not going to settle well and on top of that based on some of the other games that de has just recently released a game called sand specifically they've struggled a bit in translating and bringing over Rule books for mid to high level complexity games and I know this isn't supposed to be so heavy but I would wait to see what the general consensus is not only about the quality of gameplay but also about the teach if you purchase this on the convention floor you're probably going to try to get it opened and played and I heard reviewers on BGG talking about spending 30 minutes 60 minutes just trying to teach some of the other div games that have come out because the rule book was so rough so keep that in mind I just don't think this is a good spend there on this day maybe in the future and I certainly hope to play it as well we stood in line last year all night for lurana we had a great time we hung out with the crowd we rushed in we bought everything they had available from playmats to card sleeves to terrible binders that we ended up replacing because they were made out of the cheapest Chinese quality stuff

possible and and then we we played we played a lot we opened our packs we did a series of videos here on the channel and by the end of that series we thought two things one we had a really good time as a newly married couple exploring a brand new card game that had just launched with themes and artwork and story that attached to us because we grew up as Disney kids and lurana at that point wasn't a very good game it felt unbalanced and swingy it felt wildly irresponsible some of its decisions around how you get cards back into your deck and colors or the way that you combined colors was extremely unfair I know it's been balanced a little bit more and this expansion is going to be introducing a new wave of mechanic systems and characters that you love but don't buy the hype yet don't spend money there on the convention floor unless you're looking to resell immediately so then you can make a profit but lorana right now is just not the investment you think it is from a gaming standpoint if you're a Disney fan or a collector I understand you're going to be standing in line but we stood there as Gamers we opened unboxed punched packed and tried to play everything that we purchased and we should have honestly just stuck it up on eBay and made a couple hundred dollars off our sale so as an investment or a collection yeah sure if you're bought into lurana stand in line but if you're just interested in playing it and starting to explore that mechanic system it's not a very good game yet it needs time to age grow and develop a little

bit of maturity and other living card games have that same element Pokemon Magic the Gathering Yu-Gi-Oh all of those took a few generations and Seasons to lift up to the status that they hold now I think Lor Conor will get there but it's not the time to invest moving on down Kingdom Death monster I know my favorite game of all time but hear me out on this you you shouldn't you shouldn't stand in line you shouldn't rush to the front you shouldn't go through the Kingdom Death line until at least a day or two has passed by you might miss out on a few limited run models there's some collector things like resin busts and stuff they release but here's the problem with the Kingdom Death Booth it is beautiful it is an art display it is full of all of these things that you just want to put your face into well maybe not the goblin but but the problem the problem is that Kingdom Death monster one is Giant and unwieldy and two is one of the most effective games selling you more stuff than you need if you go in with a $100 budget and you walk through the Kingdom Death monster line and you're a fan and going to purchase anything you'll spend more than your budget if you walk in with a $1,000 budget for the convention floor you might blow it all in a single Lin standing scenario at Kingdom death I mean last year we did not have the money to spend at Kingdom Death and we walked through and between my wife and I went from we're only going to buy gameplay

related stuff to we've just purchased something like $1,200 worth of product and we're still shopping on the convention floor it's not a responsible Booth to go through unless you you just you just have the money to throw around it's you should go there you should look at it it's beautiful the models are gorgeous but but do it after the rush do it after the hype don't don't don't get caught up in the wave of everyone grabbing everything everyone spending everything it's going to destroy your budget or put you in debt I mean we've probably paid what credit card levels of interest for an entire year on those purchases that wasn't worth it that removes any incentive from buying it in the first place moving on down foundation's Metropolis now foundations is a great game in fact we just had a game night this week playing Foundation of Rome this is our board this is the beautiful Miniatures that built out I lost horrifically but we love this game and I understand the argument it is unwielding expensive kind of hard to get to the table it doesn't travel around very nicely so there's an argument on behalf of buying foundations Metropolis but if you already own foundations of Rome Arcane wonders has a really good way of reselling you things that you've already played and my biggest argument about buying foundations Metropolis right now if you already an owner of foundations of of Rome is that you're not going to get one or the other to the table that much more often and foundation's Metropolis is missing some of the more advanced strategical elements that

foundations of Rome included in the Box the little miniature expansions things like monuments for instance A system that I play with every time because one it makes your board beautiful and two it gives you more asymmetry for how you're scoring and how you're moving through the game I think many people are going to buy foundations Metropolis as the affordable accessible easy way to get into the foundation's game and system and I think that's actually reasonable responsible and totally justified I also think Arcane wonders is smart for reprinting and rebranding in a more accessible fashion but if you already own the big box or you want the big box with Miniatures don't seek out Metropolis it's just not there yet I think what we're going to see happen is those expansions that everyone loved in that original bigbox game will be released down the road as little mini expansions that'll have another resell to everyone so that price point will creep a little bit closer to well not the $300 Mark but maybe the1 $120 range when it's all said and done so hold on be calm they're going to keep printing it they don't have things that really go out of print as a publisher it's going to be available everywhere and wait for the demand to Skyrocket for some of those better more advanced mechanics to show up my next one Star Wars the Mandalorian Adventures a lot of Buzz around this a lot of hype around this which is is kind of confusing to me cuz I don't often see IP games coming into the board game Marketplace and capturing everyone's attention I mean this is a little storybook game card driven you

can play it solo you can play it cooperatively and I've heard good things I me Dice Tower gave this I think like a high seven mid eight final score and I'm compelled I like the show I like the Star Wars Universe sh and I are currently watching through all of the movies as we await the little baby and uh I also don't think you should purchase this on the convention floor it's just not going to be fancy limited or rare enough they're not saying right now that they're going to be putting it in a big box store but let's be honest this is going to be a successful game a hyped game it is clearly produced I mean you can just tell by the way that they have uh you know made the cardboard standies and printed everything in the spiral ring binder to keep the box size like exactly where it needs to be to go on retail shelves this is going to be available this is going to be printed in Mass many people are going to have access to this game and I think very quickly after people have started purchasing and playing through the entire campaign because it is a campaign game you're going to see them popping up for sale really soon post convention maybe a month maybe a little bit longer so you'll be able to pick it up at well a severely discounted price quickly and then on top of that just not even the resale Market this is going to end up being printed and distributed in a lot of big box stores or if not your Targets in your Walmarts at least across mom and pop stores all around the country and online retailers to boot and there's going to be steep discounts there as

well I have no expectation of this becoming rare or limited which means you don't need to rush to the front of line to get your hands on it now because playing it now versus playing it I don't know a month from now really isn't that big of a difference moving on next we have undergrow another game designed by Elizabeth Hargrave and I have to be honest I'm a fan of Elizabeth Hargrave I like many of her designs and I'm always interested in what she's putting out next but the hit that wingspan was has really been hard to compete with ever since it came out this has been a game that Elizabeth has been dreaming of Designing for a long time but right now the reviews that are coming in are saying that it misses some of those elements that you'd want when you're exploring this beautiful Rich you know um mitochondrial I don't know what the actual official term is but you're exploring the world of mushrooms it seems lovely it seems compelling but here's the problem this is the second game I believe that's been published by AEG with Elizabeth Hargraves name attached to it uh Mary Posas uh the the Flight of the uh butterflies was the first I think and it's standing at like a 6.2 or so over on BGG this is already standing I actually have it written down right here Year Mar poses is standing at a 6.8 undergrow is standing at a 6.2 Mary poses has 5K reviews with a lot of hype since it was I think the second game the game that had immediately released after wingspan and then undergrove is already scoring lower than

that with probably the most dedicated invested people getting it to the table initially I don't think this one is going to hit it out of the park I don't see that score ticking upwards as it starts to arrive into more and more backers hands and uh people purchase it in more and more retail locations and based on what they did with Mary Posas I just don't trust that there's going to be good quality production and a final compelling game if you really like the mushroom stuff there's also Melia this has been the year of mushrooms Mycelia is standing at a seven uh like a high seven over on BGG I think it's like a 7.4 or 7.3 and it's got your beautiful mushroom landscape and architecture and nice little high quality wooden pieces that spread across the table so if you want the theme you don't have to go with the new one by Elizabeth and if you do want the new one by Elizabeth Hargrave it's probably worth waiting to see where it pans out or trying to just play it and demo it from someone there on the convention floor you might love it it's very true but I'm not sure and evidence is seeming to indicate that about half of you won't so keep that in mind moving on down the search for uaps unidentified anonym Anonymous phenomenas there is something

out there one man I hate that name why not like the search for UFOs or something like that something that I can remember and say again uaps is not a phrase that I think I've ever heard it's certainly not normal you know parlament a normal point of conversation and so this game is going to be one hard for me to remember I'm already turned off cuz I don't like the name and it's just a rehash or a reprint of two other games the search for Planet X and the search for lost species now there are differences between all of them and thematically they do shift and change but basically the Dice Tower review for this the search for lost species was it was the search for Planet X with a worse theme and slightly better mechanics and it played better at two-player than the search for Planet X did these are great games I want to play all of them I want to explore all of them but if you're hyped up for the search for uaps and you haven't played either one or at least one of the other two go buy them it's going to be the same brand new experience for you let people get the hype out of the way for uaps I can't even remember it sitting here in front of a game board box I think it's a terrible name and then pick this up because it's going to be available down the road again it's just one of those things where unless you are a big fan of the original two and you need something new the game's already been done twice and arguably already been done better I mean they stand at like an 7.9 and an

8.0 on BGG with thousands of ratings so this is going to have to do really well like exceedingly well and do something completely different and unique to beat that score I just don't think it's going to be there all right moving on down search for Planet X search for lost species rolling Realms Redux brand new rolling Realms box from ston Meer games I really want this I will end up owning this but here's the problem with rolling Realms if you're a fanboy like me great you already know you're going to get this you don't need be watching this video you've tuned out you're like looking down the aisle for what you're going to you know how you're going to run to the stone Meers booth for all of you that are thinking about getting this cuz you've seen people continually talk about it here's the biggest problem with rolling Realms it's really really Niche it's a brilliant roll andri game and if you know a lot of board games you're a board game hobbyist Enthusiast collector I think it does a really interesting system of mixing matching and giving you a flavor of all of these various different types of games but this one's getting way more nuan than the original and so like half of these games in this board I've never even played so yeah maybe it'll pique my interest but I really just want to play in systems that I'm slightly familiar with and so this is getting steps away more and more into the hobby Centric side of rolling Realms it's like a little board game shelf of rolling right card game puzzles and that's beautiful and that's amazing but I can't really get rolling Realms to the table with anyone but me and other Gamers who are as enthusiastic as me and

so I don't find that it gets off the shelf often because many people just don't know the game so they can't appreciate how unique the design is and so if they can't appreciate how unique the design is you don't want to sit there and have to explain it to them I just think it's I just think it's too closed of a system an amazing game a beautiful system but I don't think you need to run out and grab it now it's stonem it's going to be available it's going to be in print and yeah I mean how often are you actually going to get it down to the table moving on Aquatica coral reefs and this might be the last one on my list I wasn't counting as I was doing this there are 10 know that for a fact I shouldn't say confident things like that but uh we historically have been very big fans of Aquatica as a game however this is on our list because we just recently got Aquatica back to the table two times we played two sessions of it with with a a friend who was being introduced to it and both Shir and I have really cooled on Aquatica it was compelling and interesting when it was one of those early games that we were exploring three or four years ago one of the first games she came across that was not only bright blue but also mechanically deep in a way that she found very satisfying but nowadays because we've played and deepened our love of games that have any type of hand management or Tableau building or drafting Aquatica really sits on a very thin line and so if you know that you

already love Aquatica I could see an argument on behalf of picking up coral reefs I probably would as well I'm interested to see what they continue doing with the system and it's a game that I have loved but I've cooled on it went from like a 7.5 to probably a 5.5 in my book which is a pretty steep drop over the course of the past few years but I'm not convinced Coral waths is really going to do anything that causes me to consider the game saved it might raise it just a little bit back up to like a six or a 6.5 but it's still down from where it used to be for me when I first discovered it but my big warning to all you people who are seeing people talk about Aquatica seeing people talk about the brand new expansion seeing how beautiful the artwork in the box is our Instinct would be to buy base game expansion expansion everything right away and I don't think that's the right approach here I I think if you're going to get into Aquatica get that base game to the table first see if you enjoy it see if you like it see if the depth and the strategy is where you are in your gaming experience but if you're considering any of these other games that were on the list Aquatica might just not be right for you anymore if you loved Aquatica back two or three years ago get it to the table again before buying the expansion that's coming out it's been a long time since new stuff has come out for Aquatica and I don't know it just hasn't held up in the realm of other games arriving so there you

have it there's the 10 games that I really don't think are worth buying at Gen Con there's a lot of games that'll be better deals you really have to overcommit to like Kingdom Death Or arcs if you want to pick them up and on top of that there's just a lot of stuff that uh sells primarily during this season of hype they hold it they bring limited quantities they artificially inflate how big their lines are and how much demand there needs to be and then a month or two later it's still in shrink on your shelf or potentially punched in sleeve but never played sitting on your shelf and everyone stopped talking about it if you want to see the games that I think people will hopefully still be talking about we did do a top 10 games that we would absolutely be standing in line and running for if we were there at the convention today but not these well still probably some of these what can I say I I'm a duck I have better advice than I follow and that's a good thing you should always have something above your current standard that you're aiming at so you know I'd probably still be in line for at least at least two of the games on my list here but not all 10 at least I can say that thank you for watching thank you for being here have an amazing time at Gen Con and let me know which games you're absolutely still going to be purchasing despite my well well wisened advice we'll see you later bye

Progress saved