Top 100 Board Games of All Time! (2022 Edition) - 100-91
Transcript
hi everybody i'm luke hector from the broken people if you like what you see please remember to thumb up the video consider subscribing to the channel or patreon or better still leave a comment in the video about any of the games i talk about today so we're here for another top 100 yes yes i always enjoy doing these even though they are a bit of an effort to get through particularly as today we're in another heat wave seriously global warming this is getting ridiculous but that being said i gotta talk about a hundred awesome games now first of all before i start a quick little shout out to pub meeple pub people is a website that allows you to do those like top nine collages that you see on social media all the time but also they allow you to do rankings for anything it doesn't even have to be board games it can be just ranking anything but essentially what it allows me to do is to import my collection and rated games from board game geek and essentially just stick them in a giant list and rank them two games at a time side by side which one do i prefer it does this about 500 to 1000 times yes it does get a little bit repetitive but then at the end it spits out a draft list for me to start tweaking for any anomalies and such trust me the first time i did the top 100 for this show it was on post-it notes surely you can't be serious i am serious and don't call me shirley i kid you not i just wrote out about 150 games on post-it notes and i was there constantly shuffling through paper to try and get the list done it hurt a lot but this pubmed ranking system allows me to get it done much faster even though it's still another short process but
yeah without it this top 100 probably wouldn't be done each year because it would just be far too much effort on top of everything else so thank you pubmed give them a look and use their engine for your ranking system in the future so bear in mind disclaimer these are my top 100 games in my humble opinion okay these are my top 100 games not necessarily the top 100 games although i do argue that some of them probably should be in that category everybody got that i've played tons of games a lot more since i started getting into gaming and now it's getting harder and harder to narrow it down to a hundred when i first started i was putting games that were like six seven out of ten ratings on my top 100 because i hadn't played that many games at the time but this was like years and years ago but nowadays a lot more has happened a lot more games have released tastes of change and all sorts so now when you get to the bottom end of this list do not assume that the bottom end of this game is garbage because the lower end of my top 100 is still games i rank an 8-9 out of ten if there are no sevens on this list you cannot be just good and get on this list in fact even if you're just considered great you have to be content with the fact that you might not make it on the top 100. now most of this list is considered games that i would give a seal of excellence to see the distinction sorry that's my rating so nines and tens for a good 80 to 90 of this list of what i would rate these games so yeah everything on here is the creme de la creme as far as i'm concerned now no game is ever flawless so there are going
to be reasons why some of them have dropped some of them have risen etc and even when you get to the top 10 there's going to be flaws with those games you know no game is ever perfect but for those of you like stats i've got my phone over there with all the details on it because i don't have a fancy clipboard and i don't want to be holding my phone all the time but essentially i have got 18 games that have fallen off the list since last time 18 nearly a fifth of my list isn't on the top 100 anymore not to say that they're garbage and out of my collection and out of my life forever they just didn't quite beat the cut but then that means we have 14 games that have now like come new on the list so there's a lot of new content to throw in there and four games that have returned to the top 100 why would the game fall off and come back well you're gonna hear a lot of those explanations in this ten because three of them are on this batch of ted so we'll get on to that but well yeah let's just go let's go that's what you're here for get on with it yes get over it my number 100 is a asurder eagle griffin game yes you know that i have had four games on my shelf with regards to veto assertor i don't like co2 i don't like escape plan and on mars was just far too complicated for the pers for any normal person to get into but this one is lisboa this bower was the retailer sort of game set in well this bar in old days where it had gone undergone a catastrophe like earthquakes and fires and all sorts of destroy the city and you're essentially rebuilding it up
while influencing various noble characters it's not so much the city building aspect that i like because that's mainly just a grid with rows and columns and stuff and little bonuses what i like about this bower is the card system you play these cards into your portfolio and you've got a up section and a down section and depending which card you play and where you play them have different effects like they'll influence different nobles you'll be able to do different court actions you'll be able to get money a treasury's influence in such a way and it's really that card system that sells liz bower for me i mean it looks cool on the table it's a little bit tricky to see where everything is on the board but other than that it still looks pretty and i do like the column stuff that goes on with the city it's just not necessarily the reason i like the game a lot it's really the card system because it's you you've got a hand of cards they've got sort of multiple users and you're kind of like hmm you know i need the influence but then i also want to do this action but then if i don't do this action i can't do this uh he's got all those courtiers there which means it's going to cost me more influence but i could do with some money as well and then even when you're drawing another card in your turn you're like hmm that looks good that looks good oh that'd be a nice card yeah i could use that for later that sort of thing just really intrigues me it's a 100 liz bower will all three of my other lasallia games feature on this top 100 you have to wait and see so 99 is the first of the returned games to the list and that is i think actually the only game i like that has alex alexander fister in the title for designers yeah don't kill me but this is broom service broom service
usually fluctuates up and down into my top 100 and that it usually depends on how many times i get it played but this is a cool fairly oldish game actually as far as i'm aware from a layer and it allows you you take control of a witch and you are going around this landscape delivering potions of different colors to various places for points okay that sounds pretty generic what makes this game though is that role selection the idea that you have those different witch cards that you can play the little gnomes and the various other witches and trolls and stuff and druids but you have certain you have a selection of them at the start around you choose which ones you want to play but then it's a case of right i'm the brave weather witch or whatever i'm gonna do this and it's like well hang on a minute did anybody else around the group also pick that card because if they do they're gonna usurp me and get the action and i'm gonna get nothing so maybe i should be a cowardly version but then i don't get as much but did you honestly pick that card or did you not this can really destroy friendships if you're not careful because you are in a good way actually how could that be a good way i don't know i digress but this one does have you shouting a lot because you're really mindful of the fact that you want to play this particular card but you can't rule out the fact that other players may have played that card and it scares you to heaven and back playing this with five players is definitely the way the player because then you have none of this like little fiddly rules about you know certain roles being bewitched each round no five players you get all the rolls and all the tension it really is a good fun tense game and it just keeps fluctuating this area of the top 100 mainly just because of getting it played
and the fact that well you have to get used to the fact that it is quite in your face sometimes another returning game to the list yeah and this one's taken a while to actually return to the list actually because uh to be fair it doesn't get played very often it's not a game i tend to solo that much it's not a 10 game i tend to get into groups that much except for a select few but when i do get it played i do really enjoy it and the reason i can't get it played in many groups is because of the nature of x-com the board game this really takes the x-com theme and does well with it it's got all the sound effects and all the look from the video games but i've got some mates i can play this with with four of us we know what we're doing and each of us can take a station and still do well but this is a timed game for the most part you know half of it is timed with an app and half of it isn't and some people don't like that whole timed aspect and certainly if you're teaching new players this it's like what am i supposed to do it's a little bit scary for them but ah find a group who knows what they're doing this is such a cool co-op game the app integration this is one of the first examples of using an app in a board game and it does it so well teaches you all the rules gets you all the sound effects takes you through the timed phase nice and easy with one person sort of barking out orders but regardless of which station i'm doing whether i've got to order the budget for the whole like saving the world or i've got to kill you know ufos or i've got to take units on missions or i've got my favorite as the scientist i get to you know juggle around all these sciences and try and
make cool tech for everybody it's a cool game very thematic yeah there's a lot of dice rolling and a fair bit of luck but it's still really good fun to play and it's tense it's down to the wire because you feel like you're on the back foot but eventually you get to that final mission it's like come on we gotta do it this turn because everybody's panicking and we're all gonna die it it does a great job alright 98 xcom emma 97 is another returning game yeah all three returning games that are on this list were all next to each other that was not planned it's just the way it is which means there's only one more game to talk about and you'll get that on we'll get on to that i think uh next next session actually i believe but anyway this 97 is a red raven game ryan lockett it is his magnum opus in terms of open world design it's kind of ridiculous how open world this is and that is sleeping guards sleeping guards i have played through the whole game and i feel like i've barely scratched the surface of this thing and you know you've got to find so many totems in order to get out of this world that you're in and when you get to the end it's like i think i did pretty well i found this many totems and i got out oh by the way there's about another 50 more that you didn't find excuse me i i literally can you know at some point i'm gonna once i'm done with tainted grail on the other table i'm gonna get this out i'm gonna lay it out and i'm gonna go through and i'm gonna just go in a completely different direction and go yeah well i go this way now and i'll find a completely different world different encounters different play style different characters to explore different landscapes in fact uh
is a great system now not the best one to save in between games the save system is very clunky but if you can just get out on the table leaving out whether it's a group of you or preferably solo and two player really it does make for a great fun open world sandbox experience i get to choose what i want to do nothing forces me to do this other than obviously an encounter not going my way but just the sheer amount of con content in this even before you start throwing in things like the dungeons expansions and that is ridiculous this one's always been kind of in the low hundreds like 105 108 and the shira just seems to have squeaked on at 97. i mean you know i'm excited to get it back out and i do remember having a great time playing it the first time around it's just a case of long campaign game need to find the time and the table space to have it out and keep it out it's taking me long enough just to get tainted grail back right i'm just gonna use my phone now because this is getting ridiculous trying to stare at it over there because i can't read the stats so lisboard dropped 15 places from 85 to 100. uh the other three obviously have just returned to the list this one has dropped 52 places what hui yeah that's a quite a considerable amount of a drop i think you know but it's not the fact that the game is bad it's just it's very bloated it has a long setup time it has a lot of table space required and so it really isn't hitting the table anywhere near as much as it used to but honestly this game
just hasn't quite set the you know met my desires to get played and that is dinosaur island still love the retro look still love the dinosaur theme and i still love the idea of building up this nature park and just going you know crazy with it but it's just the fact that it's a lot of setup and a lot of table space required not to mention it or be a fairly long game with four players particularly if they're new that it's kind of getting eclipsed by a lot of other games so i have a feeling that this one could drop off the top 100 at some point but at the moment it's now sort of moved from top to the bottom of the list just to kind of go you know what i still want to play this but maybe not quite every single week like i did before there is such a thing as too much for a game but dinosaur island is still fun building up your theme park getting the dinosaur exhibits deciding whether you want fries or a roller coaster or whatever and using your little workers in such a way to get the dna to make more dinos do you want herbivores and not much excitement do you want all the carnivores and all the excitement but then all the security required before they start eating the tourists if there's anything that really does hurt me a little bit with this game it's that whole going into the bag and deciding right here's all my guests and if you get unlucky and just pull out a bunch of those purple hooligans there's not a lot you can do to mitigate that really and so there is a bit of a luck of the draw aspect for what is essentially a heavy euro but it's still a cool game just not one that's kind of as like a 10 out of 10 rating i gave it before i think now that rating has dropped to about an eight but i still think it's a quality game
number 95 we have the first new game to hit the top 100 the first new one and this one only came out last year actually in fact it featured on my top 10 games of last year at least the retrospective version now yeah spoiler alert the other big brother will be further up the list of course it will but this one was still a really cool spin-off by antoine bowser for seven wonders and that is 7 wonders architects someone does architects is just a good symbol fun game i mean it's got barely any rules in it that you have to learn the setup time is literally about 20 seconds just get the pieces out of the box and set them up and that's it and then you take about what like less than three to five minutes to explain the game and in your way and then within the half hour mark you finished it's a nice quick easy filler but it's still engaging i mean yeah you've only got to choose between three decks you've got to choose from the side or the one in the middle and then depending on what color card it is it will do whatever it is but there's still those science progress tokens to get for special abilities and scoring opportunities there's still the whole like can i get that cat statue and look at the top card of the deck do i want to trigger the war do i grab the shield strength thinking that i'm gonna fight my two neighbors or should i hold back and go for something else it's still just light simple fun yeah okay it's not a three hour meter euro but i'll take a 30 minute light filler any day and you know the production quality is great it's in a bit of a big box i gotta admit but it does well when i take it to events to demonstrate the people because i can just lay out all seven of those boxes seven people sit down and i
can teach it in no time at all there's something to be said about simple games simple like gateway games and seven months architects has wowed me quite a bit 94 dropping from 76 18 places is a giant euro which for most people would be in their top 10. sorry not a top 10 game for me but it's still one that i enjoy preferably solo because when you play it with multiple players it does drag on a little bit too long and it did need a certain expansion in order to um get good because it was literally a case of yeah i think the original game is slightly unbalanced this is putting me off but then i was able to get the norwegians expansion for this and it really did a good job of boosting up a feast for odin feast for odin the polyamino game of epic proportions because i don't think there's any game that's even more epic than this when it comes to polyamino lane i don't know correct me if i'm wrong but this one has the 50 to 60 action spaces that you gotta teach this game is a nightmare to teach this is why i like to play it solo all those action spaces are like oh i don't want to go there there there there there there there there although i've gone cross-eyed it's impossible to sort of get this game done teach easily but for a solo experience you've got a very cool little ai system that blocks up the spaces in a neat little way but then you can just have fun with the sheer sandbox nature of it do i want to go exploring another island so i just build up my
little storage house shall i go hunting whale shall i go hunting deer or shall i go get all the occupation so i just get all the goods and fight you know artifacts and stick them in my personal board do i harvest a ton of resources do i get animals you know what a pig donkey you know whatever maybe make some donkey juice i could that's oh that's a z garcia i think but yeah it's a cool game just not going to want to play multiplayer very often and that's why this one tends to drop a little bit further down the list not to mention you got a lot of setup to do but i say feast rodent is still a really cool game it's an eight out of ten for me i still like to play every now and again but usually when i've got the time and the table space to warrant all that stuff i mean there's a lot of stuff in the box it's big it's got you know cardboard pieces all over the shop but it is a good fun experience my 93 has actually only dropped 13 places but it's still a really cool a layer game well another layer game on the list actually and this is one i tell people to play whatever they say oh but i really like ace of the galaxy and i really like puerto rico well this one's kind of an amalgamation of the two in a sense for me but it's lighter it's quicker it's more elegant i don't like to use that word that much when i describe games but elegance the one i'm gonna use here and that is san juan the second edition it is on the shelf right down there and i still really enjoyed this you know race for the galaxy is over complicated with the symbology and it really only works at two player puerto rico is fine but again this one
just gives me a much easier experience essentially uses the role selection mechanic where you have these different roles and you pick a role and you get the ability but so does everybody else around the table but yours is slightly better so you gotta think of the timing like do i take this ability now knowing that everybody else is just gonna do the same thing or should i wait do i really need that bonus nah really i'll just wait for you to build and then i can build later so i'm going to take trading because i've got stuff to trade and you haven't cool little system but i love the fact that everything in this game is just one big deck of cards that's it your currency your buildings your resources everything is just that deck of cards and you essentially just keep drawing cards and then you use the cards as currency to pay for a building cost to play a different card for it so it's sort of multi-use but not really it's just the fact that rather than give you unnecessary components it just uses the cards in the game to do it it's a cool clever concept and the second edition gives you the expanded buildings for a bit more variety but yeah this one is quick easy done and dusted in 45 odd minutes get to 12 buildings and you're done i would sooner rather pay san juan than puerto rico or race for the galaxy any day spoiler they're not on my list but then again they've never been on my list so you should notice by now so yeah san juan is still going strong just obviously it's not something that i would stick maybe in my top 50 for example okay two more to talk about here my 92 has dropped 44 places and this is gonna annoy some of the heavy euro fans here because they might have it slightly higher but i
still really enjoy this game but i've played it a little bit recently and it's kind of irking me a little bit more because of the punishing nature of it this is a game that you cannot like get wrong at any point during the game if something goes wrong for you you're not going to recover very well and so it does have that little bit of a runaway leader and pseudo knockout problem but i still really like playing to carry on legends of illusion or whatever the tagline is for mind clash games it's still great fun the collector's edition is a beautiful sight to behold and that doll guards academy really does expand the options you have in the game but it is very punishing it's worker placement you're putting on this magic act every so every other rounds you're starting off with basic tricks but then you've got to get the high level tricks which yield more rewards for coins and points the problem is everybody else is going for the same thing and spaces are tight because it's not just a case of oh i can go to that spot no i need to go to that spot and have enough power rating in the guy i used in the space i went on to do what it is i want to do so there's two things that people are contesting for the location and the power space and so it gets ridiculously tight particularly at four players and so if something does not go your way either because of bad timing or someone just jumping in front of you when you least expect it it can get very problematic and yeah you end up in a situation where by halfway through the game you're kind of like well i don't think i've got a chance of winning you've got a big enough lead no one's getting in their way so you get nothing you lose
good day sir the tricks are a slight problem child though because you have to kind of go to the end of the game and plan your way back saying i want this high level trick which means i need this medium trick and it means i need these low level tricks if one of the other players takes one of those tricks before you get a chance to you're kind of screwed it's very difficult to pull yourself back and that is why this game has dropped because as much as i enjoy it it's not one that i kind of want to play over and over again because i'm afraid that when i do play it it's just going to be one of those occasions where am i even in with a shot of winning or am i literally just going through the motions because i'm sitting at the table and i haven't really played it solo because well it's a massive mind clash game the solo modes are outright complicated as all get out but i still enjoy the game i still think it will remain on my top 100 but it's definitely gonna probably stay in the bottom part of the top 100 rather than be closer to the top it's you know those realizations have come to pass recently and that's why it has dropped a bit and then finally for this segment my number 91 has dropped oh i've got a stair really closely at this 38 places from 53 and that is a madiga game which is another sandbox experience and i do like these sandbox games these sandbox games are really good fun but they certainly do take a bit of effort to teach especially now as i think one of the things that's affecting my enjoyment of a lot of these games actually is the bloat factor do i go a little bit mad at buying the expansions to it not realizing that
maybe the game doesn't hit the table enough for me to warrant all that expansion content not to mention teach it to new players this is western legends western legends is still great fun perfectly represents the western theme i love the fact that i can be law abiding or you know or like a criminal i can go and with the expansion i can now decide right i want to go prospecting i want to wrestle cattle i want to go kill people i want to go shoot that player i want to go rob a train i want to go do high stakes poker i want to do this poker game i do love playing poker in this game but i really love that card mechanic where all the cards are the suits you know from a typical deck of playing cards and you know they've got different abilities that can help you on your turn but then they're also used in order to do various skill checks and like comeback checks and the actual poker game in question it's just a really cool system and really thematic and really engaging but it does take a while and there is quite a lot of rules in it particularly with the expansion i mean i've got the play mat i've got the extra map i've got the other rules in it maybe i went a little bit too far i don't know and that is hurting it because it's not one i can get to the table very often i have to treat this kind of as an event game one that i'm gonna say look in advance okay we're gonna play western legends with all the bells and whistles okay do not play or have a rough idea right well i better make certain i know all the rules off my heart oh this is going to take a while and that's a little bit off-putting which is why this game has dropped a bit but i know that when i do get this game out it's glorious and great fun i mean i think i played it a few months ago actually and again it was just great fun i mean i i'm not even a big western fan
but this one is the i mean even more so than something like carson city this one just does it for me in getting that theme across and i do love a good sandbox game this is something you will notice with games i like give me the freedom to do what i want to do in order to in like start my thematic experience don't pop me on a linear path because that another's keynote but yeah it's still a great game western legends at my 91 so there we go that is my 100 to 91 i'm going to try and speed through these a little bit quicker in the future segments because now you don't have to hear all that disclaimer stuff but also i want to get through the bottom half of the list a little bit quicker so i can start focusing on top half the list even though i love all these games you really want to hear really what i'm rating tens you know that top half of the list is where you're more interested i'm sure but yeah it's going to be fun to do this but i'd better get on with doing the 90 through 81 and then all the segments beyond still a lot of effort but i still enjoy doing these so that's it for me i'll see you on the next broken people video if you like what you see remember to thumb up the video consider subscribing to the channel the patreon but more importantly let me know your thoughts about all 10 of these games whether good or bad i want to know your opinions until next time you can check out more content on the channel including the top 100 that i did last year check out these two videos to see the beginning of that saga so until next time take care and remember as always it's only a game bye for now god it's hot