Skip to main content
Loading video...

Our Top Picks from YOUR Game Shelves - Lost In The Shuffle

Transcript 13:53

You want to talk about board games?

Yes.

Well, you have come to the right place, my friend.

Yes, please.

We are going to look at another board game shelfie

Awesome. I want to do it right now.

and find lots of games to talk about.

Yeah, okay. I'm in.

And apparently at least one of us is not going to get lost in the shuffle.

Never. Show me the photos.

Well, I reckon that you are rearing to go already.

Yeah. These We've done episodes like this before where we look at your shelf of games and talk about our favorite games on your shelf or our underrated hidden gems or maybe a game that we haven't gotten to the table, but we really want to get to the table. And these are some of my favorite episodes cuz we just get to talk about board games. I want to do a 3-hour episode talking about your board games because I just love talking about board games.

You know what? I totally believe you could.

Yeah. I Oh, I definitely could. I definitely could.

Well, we're going to at least have a primer of that by digging into a shelfie that was sent in to the Game Night Picks Blue Sky account from viewer Matt Cohen.

Hey, thanks for sending in a shelfie of your collection and you got a great collection, so

Indeed. Yeah, in fact, let us put our visuals where our mouth is by diving right in to Matt's shelfie here.

I will tell you, Matt, you and I have very similar game taste. Like I was looking at this one and I was like, there's You have some of my favorite games of all time on your shelf here. How do I pick? There are so many here that I like like Cartographers, what a great game. Jaipur, Splendor Duel, some of the two best two-player games of all time. Middle Ages is one of the games I've played at my house the most. My roommates love that game and so we started playing that, but if I had to talk about a game that I want to play right now that is on your shelf, I'm going with Super Mega Lucky Box because I always want to play that game. I just love that game so much. It's dumb fun. You know, it's like if I had to talk about a game where I'm like, I don't know if this is the best design, I don't know if this is the most interesting strategy, but if my metric is am I having fun, Super Mega Lucky Box is at the top of me having fun all of the time. It's like bingo on steroids. You flip a card and then everybody has to cross off that number somewhere in their little score boxes, their little sort of you have cards with little boxes in them and it's just all about combos. And constantly you're like, I cross off this and that's going to give me this and that's going to help me do over here and I feel so invincible right now and I just love that about it.

You know what's funny? As I know you have talked about Super Mega Lucky Box in a previous episode, but the amount of vigor and enthusiasm you still have

want to talk like that's what I mean when I'm like you have so many games that I want to play like right now and yet Super Mega Lucky Box kind of always rises to the top for me. I don't know why I love that game so much. It's just dumb fun.

Uh well, the game that is rising to the top of my list of what I want to play right now is actually a game down at the bottom of the shelf.

Okay.

And that is the Mad Magazine game.

Oh.

Which I believe is from like the late 70s.

Okay.

And I was almost going to say that this is the game I haven't played but I want to, but I realized I have played this game.

Oh, nice. Wow.

I saw it and I knew I recognized it, but then I realized there was a birthday party, an overnight slumber party birthday party I went to in like sixth grade and at 2:00 in the morning those of us who were still awake, we brought this out and we were reading the rules to it off the back of the box.

And I do I remember

Yes, and I remember specifically that there's something in the rules about how something is determined by majority vote.

Okay.

And if the group playing can't determine what constitutes a majority vote, just take a majority vote to figure it out.

That's funny.

And that's all I remember about the game.

totally. Were you somebody that read Mad Magazine at some point? Does that Does that sort of brand Does that IP carry weight for you?

I never went out of my way to get a Mad Magazine, but Mad Magazine every now and then I would just like find one somewhere laying around the house.

Oh, interesting.

So, they would either, you know, someone was either bringing them home every now and then or it was, you know, a spontaneous generation. I'm not exactly sure, but I would stumble onto one every now and then. And it was always like, "Oh, these are kind of contraband, you know, they sometimes got adult humor in it. Oh, boy." You know, so I secretly read it thinking I was getting away with something.

All right.

Okay, so yeah, Mad Magazine the board game that That was the one I I would play that right now.

Nice. Man, there's so many I'm just I just continue to look at your shelf and I'm like, "I want to play Acropolis. I love Acropolis. I want to play that right now. I want to play I want to play so many of these." And if we're talking about like underrated gems, I feel like you have a bunch of underrated gems

Okay.

on the shelf as well. Ten Penny Parks from Thunderworks game I think is an underrated game. And one of the things about Ten Penny Parks is it is a tile laying game where you want none of the tiles to touch. It kind of flips it on its head where you're building an amusement park and you need to have But you're getting these different shapes and trying to not have them too close to each other.

Twist.

Fort is a really great little deck building game that I think is underrated because it comes from a company that does mostly big games and then they released this little game and I think a lot of people were like, "Oh, I don't know what to

Don't know what to do with this.

This I want Root from them. I want Oath from them. But Fort is an awesome little underrated game. Avant Card, have you ever heard of that game? It is a awesome little underrated game. It's like Uno on steroids. Super Mega Lucky Box is like Bingo on steroids, I've already said. Avant Card is like deck building Uno where you're matching numbers and colors, but you're you're literally buying new cards to add to your deck so you can create longer combos. But the one that I'm actually going to pick as my underrated pick here. And partly it's because I am a huge lover of history. I was a history major in college. Trekking through history is a really fun game and I feel like doesn't get as much attention as the other games in the Trekking series. You know, they had Trekking the National Parks and Trekking the World and then they came out and I feel like those get talked about way more than Trekking through history.

Trekking the World definitely, yeah.

Yeah, for sure. And Trekking through history is not that dissimilar of a concept where you're getting cards and you're kind of putting them down, but you have to get them in chronological order and stuff like that. This is one I played with my dad who is also a history uh person and I have played other historical games with my dad that he didn't care for because he's such like a history lover that he's like, "This isn't all correct, you know?" And that's what like he I played the game Core of Discovery with him. My dad was a professor about Lewis and Clark and I tried to play Core of Discovery

Oh, boy. And he was like, "This isn't Lewis and Clark."

And I was like,

Well, yeah, it's like fantasy version.

And he was like, "This isn't teaching anybody about Lewis and Clark." And he was like legitimately mad about the game that it wasn't teaching people about Lewis and Clark history. But Trekking through history was one that he really [clears throat] liked too as a history person. He was like, "Oh, I love the history in this game."

litmus test.

It did. So, it's a If you are a just a amateur history buff or anything like that, Trekking through history is a really fun game.

All right. Well, Trekking through history was almost my was my my other dog pick here, but I went one shelf up to Summer Camp.

Oh, I've never played it. It's always been one I wanted to try as well.

Okay, I have not played it either.

Okay.

But I have seen it on the shelves at Target

Sure.

remember picking it up and looking at going, "Oh, you know what? This actually sounds pretty good."

Yeah, yeah.

But I you know, just later I I was just talking to someone else about board games and they mentioned, "Oh, have you seen Summer Camp which is a really good introductory to its genre?" And I was like, "Well, there you go."

It's also from the same designer as Super Mega Lucky Box.

Oh,

score bonus.

Yeah, Phil Walker Harding who's one of my favorite designers because I think he does a great job at strategy that's also approachable. You know, I think he's one of the best designers for that specific space and

Yes, yeah, yeah.

I also went to summer camp every summer and they were some of the best, you know, summers that I had and stuff. So, I like the theme.

Summer Camp is one of those where I've seen it and I'm sure other people have seen it and I just haven't seen it talked about much though.

Sure, sure. Yeah. Man, there's so many I want to like talk about more here. So, the last one we're going to talk about is a game we haven't played that we want to play. And I've played a lot of the games that are on Matt's shelf cuz again, we share a real the same sort of taste in board games. Um, there are two here that I haven't played that I have legitimately wanted to play. And one of them is the game Jock Mock because I'm a huge Christmas person if you know this about me. And Jock Mock isn't about Christmas, but it's about winter markets that happen throughout Europe and I think more specifically even like Scandinavia and stuff like that. So, but it kind of has that like, "Ooh, this is still a Christmasy vibe, right?" Like I think you know, I love going to Christmas markets. There's a lot of cities in America that have them. Obviously, a lot of cities in Europe have them and so, this is one that I've always wanted to play just sort of simply because of the connection to like the holiday time and stuff like that.

neat that that is the aspect of it that helps to inspire you to play.

Yeah, yeah. And the other one that I've always really wanted to play and I've never played it is the Fox Experiment. Oh, really?

Yeah, because I you know, it's one I've heard that like people really like. You are rolling some dice and drafting some dice and then you're playing over multiple rounds and it mirrors an actual study that was done like studying sort of fox genetics over multiple generations and I think that's cool. You know, it's a certainly a unique theme and I've heard good things about it. I've talked to people that have played it and makes me want to play it. I've just never had the chance to. Have you ever played that one?

I haven't.

Okay.

But I would welcome the opportunity to.

Yeah. Yeah.

I would also welcome the opportunity to play the game that is my pick for this.

Yeah.

But before I reveal what it is, I want to first give you a little insight into the person who is me.

Okay.

You know, I love a good legacy game.

Oh.

I love the idea of taking a game and the rules alter and morph and evolve. Things get permanently taken out of the mix and just

Sure.

Yeah, I first played Risk Legacy when it came out and just fell in love with the concept.

Sure.

But not every legacy game is up to the same standard and I have found that at least for my personal preference, I believe the best legacy games are the ones that start with an established idea that's a simple approachable game like Risk or Pandemic, something like that and then builds on that foundation making it wackier and wackier. And that's why at the very bottom corner there, we have the Ticket to Ride Legacy Legends of the West. That is a game I haven't played yet, but I have it right on the shelf ready to go. I'm just waiting for the opportunity to get a game group together that can consistently go through like you know, 10 to 12 sessions of that.

Are you a Ticket to Ride guy? Like have you liked Ticket to Ride over the years?

No.

Oh, interesting. Okay.

I would not consider a Ticket to Ride one of my go-to games that I love.

Sure.

But I believe that Ticket to Ride is that strong, approachable, gateway foundation that makes a wonderful legacy game.

Sure. I mean, you know, I think Ticket to Ride is probably one of the top 10 games that have gotten people into board games.

Right. Yeah.

Right?

Yep. So, being able to take something that is that well-known and accessible and then put that twist on it makes this a potentially fantastic legacy game that I cannot wait

cool.

for you to really dig into.

Can you believe I have never finished a legacy game or a campaign game? In my board gaming history, I've never finished one of those.

You?

Yes.

Yes, I can believe that. Yes.

It's just so hard to like get the same group together all the time.

We played Pandemic Legacy season 1 and that we finished the whole thing, but it took like a year and a half.

Yep. So, I'm a big goal setter. I do a a bunch of work sort of in that week between uh Christmas and New Year every year to like think about what I did the past year, the the year gone by, and what I want my goals to be for the next year. And I did put on my list this year for 2026, finish a campaign game is on my goals for the year. And I got a crew together and we are five chapters in to Title Blades 2.

Oh, nice. Oh.

It is an 18-chapter campaign and uh you know, I'm filming this here uh at Chez's place at the end of January and I'm already five chapters in. So, I've got to I'm We're we're doing it. We're meeting every once a week right now

Bravo.

it. So, I want to finish my first campaign game this year.

I I think it is also delightful that your year-long goals involve the progress you're going to make in board games.

Yep.

Yeah. It is I have I have different I have board game goals and personal goals and professional goals and all that stuff.

Oh, boy. Oh. Well, whether or not you have been able to come to the end of a campaign game. You have come to the end of this episode. And hey, we want to thank you for joining us. We want to thank Matt Cohen for submitting this shelfie. If you want to find the Game Night Picks Blue Sky account, and there's a post that you'll find pinned down in the comments that you can go send some shelfies. And uh maybe we'll talk about your games in the upcoming episode. And until next time, thanks for joining us and we'll talk to you again soon.

Progress saved