The 2024 Games of the Year episode (guest: Beneeta Kaur) | Ep 147
Transcript
hey everybody Welcome to the going analog podcast I your host Christina and it is uh I'm surprised we're going to get this in by the end we're going to record it by the end of 20124 because as a podcast we have to talk about our top games of the year right it's just necessary or they take away our license or something we don't have a license um content creation o content creator obligation and so to help us with this of course we have invited our very good friend Bonita Carr to tell us about her favorite games of this year as Shu and I also came up with our favorite top party games light games Medium games and heavy games of 2024 so of course big disclaimer we can't play all the games that came out in 2024 but we tried our best we tried really effing hard so um yeah you know we played a ton of games and we we haven't played them all we are limiting them to hopefully games that came out in 2024 or became available as far as we know in 2024 so you can look them up and hopefully our listeners can discover some new games through this too yeah basically we're using if it says 2024 on Board Game Geek that's kind of where we started but then some of them like there's one of my games actually BGG says 2023 but it released in North America 2024 so it's it's a little soft there the other thing too is when we do these with our guests we have a different guest every year to join us to share this um we don't really have heavy rules about like what qualifies us heavy what
qualifies immediate we're all going to learn about our picks in this show in real time so so later we might be like wait you consider that a heavy game I consider that a mediumweight game that might happen that's super light for me I'm just saying but but that's okay that's okay that's fine uh so I'm excited to hear everybody's games we actually played a lot of games this year with Bonita who is a fantastic twitch streamer so I wanted to introduce you and you uh you stream every Wednesday and Friday am I right so close I stream every Monday and Wednesday occasional Fridays at 1000 p.m. Eastern 700 p.m. Pacific and yes I'm very excited to be here and we were actually talking about it I feel like we played more games together in 2024 than like ever before cuz we were actually at like conventions and like playing games together instead of like actually when you hear my list you're going to be like oh we played this one together you know spoiler rer it's always the company that makes the game better so yeah of course
obviously okay so we're going to Dive Right In we're going to go first into party games so we're going to start off you know a little bit lighter and get heavier so favorite party game of the year I'm going to start with Bonita what was yours okay so this was kind of hard because I feel like there was a lot of good party games and you know I'm going to say you don't have a category called card games which I wish you all did because card games kind of can feel like party games um so I have a few honorable mentions that I want to talk about before I get into my best party game um I got caution signs which is a party game with from Danielle Reynolds and wise wizard games Duck and Cover from uh like Captain games and then cabanga which is like a card game but I love playing cabanga to like five to six players so it feels like a party game But ultimately my favorite party game was flip seven by Eric Olson and the op and this is like a blackjack card game where you people are constantly busting you are trying to you have like you have a dealer and the dealer gets to play you are dealing out cards and the like the number of cards is like from 1 to 12 and it goes like 1 one 22s 33s occas up to 122s and you're just dealing cards out in front of you and if you ever get two cards of the same number you bust and you don't get to score so it is a lot of gambling and a lot of push your luck and it's just so much fun and this is the game that we played together at Gen Con this year and we play a lot of this game
play so much so much of this game and you know I consider it a party game because I have played it with like such massive crowds of people and it's so fun and everyone I introduce it to there's always so many laughs like I think I have a video of us where like someone's like cursing like one each other out because like I remember like Shu kept giving like busting when he was like dealing to me so you know M I was busting myself or I was busting you you were busting me I kept like getting zeros when you were dealing yeah that that game I love egging people on to draw more cards when they really maybe shouldn't and they could have and I'm just like someone's like uh I I cuz you can Bank your points right and then they're like okay no I want to freeze and then I'm the one who like you're only four cards away from the bonus yeah cuz if you get to seven cards you get a 15o bonus I'm just like you're so close just think about this there's a couple more just get the 15 points and then uh when you can cause them to bust like that every the whole table's just laughing and they just know that person made a big mistak and got talked into my favorite is also sometimes you never need to to egg some people on like James our friend U James Hudson he's going to hit no matter what so you don't have to egg him on at all yeah and like you know there's like cards in there that like second chance that basically gives you like a new life there's cards that like freeze meaning like someone else can't play anymore um and there's like you know little modifiers that add a little like extra fun to the game and then there's the teeny bit of strategy is that you are
not shuffling cards every single between every single round you play out the whole deck so you can remember like oh you know in previous rounds almost all the TW were dealt out so like it's a pretty good chance you're not going to bust on the 12 now if your memory is not good that's not helpful strategy but it it it exists it's something about is a card counter she that's how she I am not a card counter that's why I almost always bust in flip seven but yeah my favorite special card though is the flip three because then you can just force it on other people and just make them Bust or or they some or i' I often done the flip three on myself especially if it's like in the beginning of the round cuz it's a good way to get the seven cards before anyone else mhm mhm yeah pretty sure this is on the top of all of our lists we're very close what's your winner well I think my winner was actually caution signs which you mentioned as your runner up yeah so I've been playing a lot of caution signs which is a very quick party drawing game and um it's a really simple game so as we didn't mentioned it was designed by Danielle Reynolds and Scott Brady and wise wood published by wise wizard games and it's just a ridiculous game all of the dry erase boards look like yellow caution signs and so we have a picture here if you are or if you flip it over it's the UK version of uh caution sign oh so International I didn't know that's what that was yeah so so depending on where you are where you want to feel like actually also the designer Danielle
is like hanging out with me right now she's like over there she's in the room with you right now she's in the general vicinity of the room with me yes oh funny do you want me to call her over have her have her way but she won't know what we're talking about give her give her some random thing on your desk as an award yeah here here's my upward uh yeah so really simple game barely any rules you just give everybody a combination of a uh a top card and a bottom card which will be an adjective and a noun and it could be something like um a light fire fighter that you have to draw or a confused Manatee whatever it might be but the trick is you only have 20 seconds and everybody's like you're crazy how am I going to draw something in 20 seconds uh but you're then you have to get very creative to get the meaning across without relying on being actually good at Art so it's a great drawing game for people who suck at Art and it's even if you really really suck at Art it's hilarious for everybody else it's so fun yeah uh I never say no to playing caution sign so I've really really enjoyed it yeah did you explain the guesser has to oh yeah sorry and the points there are technically points but really you're just at people's drawings um there's one guesser who's not participating in that round and they have to figure out well which of these modifiers and nouns goes with which pictures but there's two extra dummy cards for the top and the bottom card so it adds a little bit of confusion and a lot of times people are standing there like what the heck is
this like yeah and we discovered our friend Phil doesn't know a Road Runner is a bird you know things so good times good times yeah that game is so much fun because uh the best design decision in that game I think is not only the dummy cards that get mixed in but the 20 second time limit because even a lot of people like they're like oh okay I can manage but then but when the timer actually starts and they like times up everyone's like oh my God I didn't realized that was going to go so fast and then you just have these mess of drawings or incomplete drawings and I love drawing games where the drawings are bad right like uh we're just puted into that situation it's really fun oh so Pro tip because 20 seconds is a very short amount of time um if you keep if you uncap your marker and then flip it over you save yourself like 2 seconds yes that's that is what everybody picks up too when we started literally the other night we were playing and then uh someone your friend Chris or friend Chris uh was trying to draw and he forgot he's like oh I had to uncap I to like get my boarded position and he's like I feel like I lost four seconds which you did he probably did this for a second was a slow uncapper so that's his fault so you know yeah there you go and Sho your your part oh did you want to do any runners up oh my Runners up was it was flip seven it was my B yeah so like basically our things were like reversed mhm mhm so funny enough my well okay let me do my runnner up first but I I kind of spoiled which is I going to say uh so my runnner up I also have uh
caution science was my Runner out that was my close second I was actually like like you two like right up there like one or two it could have easily beat my number one it's the kind of new party game besides my winner that we almost break out with everyone because it's such a crowd pleaser uh I also really like this year Contra banter uh which I don't know if this is everyone's game but it's just basically a game where you have different teams and you're trying to you get these cards with words and you're trying to sneak these words into conversation with your teammates and then the other people are trying to catch like that was a kind of a weird use of that word and then that must be the secret word and trying to catch what words you're trying to use uh that you're using that are your cards but my winner is also flip seven oh yay that's awesome thought I was trying to sh Cha's like pointing to the box to show it to the camera you and I was like oh she's shaking my hand for this so uh flip 7even uh yeah we already talked about it but it's again so good uh we played it with like Christina's mom we played it with kids like everyone really understands this game and then there's just all this excitement energy even when it's not your turn you're just watching cuz you're like are they going to bust or not or are they going to make me draw cards and stuff and it's so simple like it takes like a minute to teach so yeah fantastic game that we have the same best party game of the year and also like all our like like ones we're really close uh so I have a cool little fact about flip 7 so if you go buy it in the store right now it's
like an annoyingly like big box for a card game but I hear next year that they're making the Box small like small which is so much better okay currently that's only like a promo version we got Gen Con U but it's so convenient when it's the small convenient yeah yeah ours is getting a little rat and I'm thinking about like should I sleeve the car cuz we play it so much that the cards aren't fresh anymore so I'm like should I sleeve them and put it into a deck box I'm like that's a lot of work for this really simple game I just buy another copy sometimes I know it's like it's it's a pretty inexpensive game so I would I would just buy another copy but waiting for it to come into a smaller box I don't think it's going to be in a tuck box I think it's just going to be in a smaller box because like right now yall the box is like this big and it's unnecessary yeah and it doesn't the cards don't store in it very nicely versus the tuck box we uh quick little story about that so at Gen Con the op just for full disclosure they gave us this copy of flip 7 uh they're like we hadn't played it before like all right and then we started playing we played it with you and some other friends at the show and they were like oh man this game is fantastic uh and they're like the but the retail version will come in this bigger box for shelf presents but then when we got home from genon we saw in the mail we also got the op separately mailed us a copy of the retail version so I'm like well I'm going to take and then we spilled water on our promotional Edition copy at Genai yeah so I'm like I'm switching out the cards I'm going to
take the new cards from The Big Box put them into the tuck box and I'm going to give the old water down cards water log cards and the big box to another friend so I just upgraded our personal copy I mean you know what at least someone's going to enjoy the game that's that's what matters
yeah moving on we have our Light Game of the Year light game of 2024 we'll start with you today what was your light game I think I know you do because you told people yesterday at our game day oh yeah uh okay so I have a few Runners up uh what for is fishing uh so this one is a great trick ticking game that also has deck building elements in it so a lot of the strategy in this like do you want to win cards and get points but you're also going to take all the crap that everyone's going to throw at you and stuff like that or vice versa so it's like a really fun trick ticking game where your hand your uh set of cards get better and better well yeah cuz I feel like it's like this crazy ramp up because you get seemingly game-breaking cards every new round if you had sucked enough in the previous hand but anyway it's a definitely interesting cuz depending on number of players you play an x amount of rounds and you're like okay I want to lose these rounds so I can get cards but then you have to time it really well it is a you still need points you still need points it's a very interesting like trick taking game like I trick- taking is not my favorite mechanic but I actually really enjoyed fishing it's a good one yeah shout out to uh Eric Martin for of board game geek for introducing that to us he Tau me that game too did did he destroy you cuz he just like dominated and like in the last round of the game he won every single trick and just blew it out of the water and I'm like Eric you just taught everyone this game and you were so
mean I don't know for sure and I don't have the records to prove it but I think I won you said you won the first time but the second time he played I got destroyed yeah yeah he was just holding back that first time so it's just Eric just destroys everyone he loves showing it people but I I see why cuz it's such a neat game uh my other runner up uh is Lord of the Rings dual for Middle Earth it's a two-player version if you ever played Seven Wonders duel it's the same designer same format uh but a little streamlined so basically one player is playing The Hobbit trying to get the ring to Mordor the other players saurin uh Team trying to stop the hobbits and there's three different ways to for victory and it's just really tight really exciting and then uh I think I think it's better than seven wonders du going to get rid of Seven Wonders duel so so Seven Wonders duel is like probably like my top 10 game of all time I haven't played Lord of the Rings yet I just got it at pack so I haven't had time to play it I'm pretty positive this would be like my number one game of the year so I'm very excited to try it but unfortunately haven't played it yet it might have won your uh light game of the year if you it might honestly would have yeah also this is really interesting cuz like would I consider Seven Wonders duel like game I feel like it would be like a medium game but like I think right like it's interesting topic yeah I do think Lord of the Rings version does lighten it I mean there's still a lot of decisions but not in a bad way yeah not a lot of times when they kind of
simplify things for a new addition like it's like baby and boring but I don't I don't I don't get that for I think this they make good decisions here but yeah uh next uh runner up is Open Season which is a game about collecting different trophy and setting this on your wall and where you place them will score differently I really like this game a lot uh this drafting game the gang which is how many Runners up do you have sh this is the one the most this category I had the most well I also have a ton for medium me too there was so many medium we that's my big yeah uh the gang which is a Cooperative Texas holdom game and then Sears catalog which is a sort of a trick- ticking set how do you describe games like that like Scout shedding shedding C shedding game so you're trying to make pairs or three of the kinds and so on and get rid of them but there's all these different powers that come into play uh but my winner is far away from pandasaurus games oh I know why what do you mean you know why I got confused which category you put this other game into but ah yeah so far away uh it's a really cool it's such a unique different game it has this really lovely art I don't even know how to describe this art like with heavy lines it's really colorful it looks almost like uh like this otherworldly culture cartoony but surreal I know uh but yeah and it's simple you're just drafting cards you're playing cards from left to right you're going to play eight cards is a very short game uh and then how you play them in order will
determine whether you get access to other artifacts if you play higher a number higher than the previous card and then also if you play a low number you get to draft the next card early but then the end the second part of the game comes in where now you have to travel this uh path you just made this adventure and the storyline you just made you have to travel it backwards and score the cards backwards so now you you're scoring things from right to left and things on the left side haven't happened yet so those symbols and those colors are not available for your combos so you have to kind of plan ahead of like I hope I play this card on the left side that's going to benefit from cards I play in the future that I haven't seen yet or I haven't played yet so it's a bit of the set you're setting things up things aren't going to always work out right a lot of people's first plays yeah especially your first maybe one or two times playing where you're just like it's such a strange concept you're like ooh that did not work out anything like I thought but once you get it it's just such a neat idea of like it just it's you've never played anything like this and you have to it's such a unique scoring system and then you also have those like sanctuaries there's these like little map icons where you can get like extra cards that are just going to be on top that will either give you points or symbols and I definitely like to play The Sanctuary game because that helps me with the symbols cuz there's so many times where my first card will be like you need four blue symbols and you'll get 24 points and the rest of the game I'm trying to get those four blue symbols and like the amount of times where I get three and not four
because I keep getting like other Sanctuary cards I'm like come on I want these 24 points and I don't get them h s far away is so good yeah it's balanced so well so the designer I think it was uh H is goopy um he's he had another game that came out through pandasaurus through too another oh and corentine lebrat I guess there's two yeah yeah so like uh what I really like about his design choices is whenever you're drafting cards and making card decisions there's always like a couple like uh conflicting goals that you're trying to balance at any moment so even though it's such a quick little game you're only playing eight really eight cards like oh do I make sure I pick something in order to get a sanctuary card or do I just make sure that I can score this you know and there's constantly this this decision you're making um in a in a manageable way and then the first game you play is so weird that everybody's like we need to do that again I like to didn't get it and like sort of breaks your brain a little bit and then your brain comes back better at in the second place so it's great yeah but it's not complicated at all you you can totally teach like a less experienced gamer and then they're like it's weird but then they'll get it eventually yeah and also one thing is like when you're like placing a card to put in your row it's also how you are drafting cards like and if you place a lower number you're going to get the first pick so that's like a really interesting balance too because sometimes you want to play a lower number card because you really want one
of the cards to like to select but then that doesn't work for the sanctuaries in the sense like you it's not a higher number so I feel like that decision choice that struggle between like getting another Sanctuary card versus like I really need these card cuz that's thought the symbols I want is a such an interesting choice for this game mhm and the art on it like we talked about the art it's really interesting and fascinating like um I've seen that artist do several games now for pantosaurus and I've like just really into this like quirky Vibe they've got they also did like codus naturales so Maxim Mor really like really like their art too so yeah thing to keep in mind and what about your light game Bonita it's it's far away that's why I have so much to say as soon as you said it I'm like okay so like are Shu and I like gaming soulmates this year or like cuz we have the same games yeah everything we just said about farway I think the way you put cards down and score is so clever um I've never really seen it before in other games and I just liked it so much so I don't want to like keep talking about it cuz we just did for like 10 minutes I will say my um Runners up were harmonies M which is a abstract game where and it's it's beautiful we just talked about art like this harmonies has such beautiful art in the animal cards you are building structures you're trying to get points by building like farms and lakes and different animals and it it's just it's it's
really good um also castle combo which is a pandasaurus game where you are building a 3X3 G grid the cards are multi-use I just it's very interesting like clever system and then finally River Valley Glass Works which is you're picking up Stones you're trying to like set collect and there's like really interesting like sliding mechanism of how you pick up the glass from the river so I really like that one as well so all like all four of those games I have played so many times but like far away is like my number one for sure yes so a lot of overlap for mine my Runners up were far away for sure and uh the Lord of the Rings duel for middlee um like I only recently played it and I just like couldn't get enough of it I was like we need to buy our copy like immediately I played somebody else's like why do we not have this already yeah she's been scolding me for she's like why don't we have this I'm like you have access to the same retailers and online stores that I do I don't know why I'm responsible because you played at first and didn't immediately buy it so that's why that sounds that sounds like it's on you show yeah okay my game of the my light game of the year though was harmonies so but you mentioned so I'll pick that like just to show off the um the the cover for people who are watching on YouTube the art is so beautiful like Bonita was saying and I think it was our friend Bond who showed it to me first uh at a game day and it's
pretty abstract in a lot of ways it's just sort of like a pattern matching pattern making game but it plays so smoothly and the production of all the pieces and components is so nice they're really chunky wooden pieces there's no plastic involved in storing the components and uh it's like you know it's really just colors that you're putting and building and to represent things like trees and rivers and things like that um but there's all these different ways to score and it's just it perfectly hits this like itch in my head about like patterns and like like spatial puzzle I like really really like it the first time I played I was like yeah yeah I'm into this I'm not normally into abstract games but I was like I I do want a copy of this and I've been teaching it really like really often and enjoying it every yeah we played it together uh at BG con too yeah so um good yay harmonies that was by uh Johan Ben venudo and published by libud I think if I pronounce their name correctly lie
yes okay so for medium game of the year I have several Runners up and um why do you get several R you had like 10 for the last one um okay but I'll go first for this one so my Riv renders up were uh veil of Eternity I really like that game um that was originally from a Korean publisher designed by Eric Hong and published also by Renegade um and it's like really fun comboing as you collect creatures and this reminds me of like um collecting Pokemon to make them score but then they're like these weird like mythological creatures and I have a feeling somebody will talk about this more later so I'm going to leave that at that and then U my other Runners up I really liked creature Caravan designed by Ryan Lockett from Red Raven games this year love his art all the time so fun um traveling and collecting and building up a a caravan of creatures to help you avoid these zombies but there's this really great um system of like being first to score something means that you start a timer on that particular scoring thing and then now other players only have one more round to be able to score it so it adds this really interesting tension that I haven't seen in a game before um I also really really like let's go to Japan from uh Josh Wood and Ag and I we've been playing it for a while because we got an early copy we went to Japan and like took pictures with the cars at various tourist destinations that matched um and I've just recently replated a bunch on BGA
board game arena and I was like I still really like this game it's just a card drafting game you're trying to plan out a really great trip in Japan between Tokyo and Osaka so you're trying to like make it efficient to not travel between Kyoto sorry Kyoto and Tokyo good catch thank you we went to Osaka on top of those uh those various cities and so uh the art is so adorable there's artists from like Japanese artists created all of this and you're trying to like then I make everybody tell a little story about their trip after you score it so um lots of card comboing and you can see that blog about our travels in Japan on going atlock show. um I was once talking to Josh and apparently like some of the artist because they hire Japanese artists they would like go to a ramen restaurant take pictures and that they would use that as like a reference and that's why like a lot of they look so good pictures they look so good me hungry all the time right and my other runner up final runnerup was worms fan by Connie vogelman and stone Meer games um I love dragons cuz I'm a big nerd and so it's like of course of course right I was like I remember it was announced first like a couple years ago and I was like that's a joke that's an April Fool's joke right we're wingspan but with Dragons but it works really well and it's its own unique game I think definitely inspired by wingspan um but I really like the extra sort of action point um economy of getting coins that's different from wingspan um but
you get all these cute dragons and the Art's so great and it's like very like uh watercolored themed uh dragons so I really like that I like the Explorer action like in worms span I that's like something unique to worm span versus wingspan and like also Elizabeth was the developer on worm span you can see like like Connie made it her own but you can see that like it has the bases in wingspan but I I I I don't know if I'm allowed to say this but I think I might like worm span more the wingspan it's very good I I think I do too I do too so yes um we love having them on our our podcast so now they won't come on thanks Bonita I'm sorry um and then we actually had both of them on to talk about worms span last year so it was a it was a really great episode so go back and listen but my winner for this year I know what it is yes so we have a pile of boxes if you're watching this son uh video of like our Runners up and uh winners cuz Christine and I don't know each other's winners but I'm like I'm already pulling this upate for her I'm like I River of gold which I started playing at what 11:30 p.m. with you the last night of hey we finished it we finished it we just got interrupted just a few times a few like a few dozen times yeah our we the three of us were supposed to play and then after it was approaching midnight and I'm like Christina our flight's at 6:00 a.m. like I we haven't
packed we have a room full of games that we have to figure out how to put but I had promised the need I would teach it to yeah and then and then our hotel was off site too not near the convention center so I'm like I'm going to go home and I'm going to get uh ready sh took one for the team and went to go pack for him and Christina while Christina and I finished the game yeah Christina got to play games while I was like I'm in the hotel room packing everything that's why it's a great her crap up so it's designed by Keith pigot and um and published by office dog and obviously very very shiny and gold as in the title and like the theme I think is not as exciting as the other games that I've mentioned as my Runners up but it's just plays so smoothly and we played so much of it it's you are um in control of a clan and there's this uh I think it takes place in rugan rokugan it's rokugan the river of rokugan yeah it's this this game Universe called rokugan vaguely Asian inspired I think so there's this River you're traveling down so you have some ships traveling down this River you are control of a clan and you're trying to influence the different regions as uh you trade things and travel down this River um it plays so smoothly and it it gives me that perfect middleweight game where it's yoy you're still making strategy decisions aiming for certain point objectives um and it's just uh I don't know it's I've played it so much
even on board game arena and in person and every every time I still really enjoy it and it plays so quickly it gives me exactly what I want from a middleweight Euro game um within like an hour hour and a half depending on the number of players you have so yeah yeah it's it's great I remember like you know like and you have like you have like objectives you want to fulfill there's like definitely like an area control type of element on one side of the board as well and then it's cool because you can build buildings and then you like own them and so when people come visit the buildings that you've built you get cool benefits as well they're called owner rewards and I love that mechanism I love that like when people come visit you also get some stuff yeah and every time the river builds out so differently and you have different objectives that are shuffled into different regions uh yeah it's been a little while since I've played it but I just thought back to the year I was like this is my perfect middle weight game for the year so yeah mhm what do you think sh uh I love River of gold that was a close that was almost my medium weight he got beat up by something else so that was one of my Runners up uh I also had uh let's go to Japan was a runner up uh creature Caravan uh which I think is my favorite Red Raven game as I mentioned I think I really need to play it okay it's cool I'm like I think this is my favorite Red Raven game uh and then I also have chronologic Paris 1920 chronologic spelled with a K so this uh actually at our game party
yesterday or was that two days ago uh I played this twice and I kept wanting to play it because I I was like so excited to show all these you people have you play Crown life can you play Crown life so showing like content creators who are like this has been on their list to play I've been showing friends uh I showed a game designer it's like everyone really liked it so it's a deduction game logic deduction game so the idea is it takes place in Paris 1920 in a opera house there's one opera house with different rooms like the Grand Ballroom the stage the dance room the uh foyer and stuff uh so there's these rooms that are connected and so you need to know what rooms are adjacent to what rooms and then everyone has these pieces of paper that show these rooms over 6 hours over the course of the night then the game comes with three different scenarios each scenario with three or with five different variations of that scenario so scenario one is you need to find out who killed the detective uh scenario two is the Phantom of the Opera and you need to find out which character was alone every hour of the night in a different room somewhere doing weird alone things but anyway weird inappropriate alone things then you know that's a Phantom of the Opera who's like causing problems and causing Misfortune and accidents during the night the third scenario is about this jewelry heist and you have to trying to track where these Jew stolen Jewels anytime two people are in a room together you know person a transferred to person B now you have to follow person B until they're in a room together alone with another person then
they've trans for to person see and so on and you just have to kind of track this so you're trying to solve these crimes as detectives and then what you do is you pick a location like uh the the state the ballroom and then you pick a either a character there's one of six there's six characters so some kind of vibe like clue uh it's like a way better clue it's always the love clue I need to try this oh this is fantastic so there like there's the chauffeur there's the baroness there's the there's a journalist and it's like I want to know how many times the journalist was in the ballroom throughout the whole night the 6 hours and then you take these this card and then this sort of uh cut template with a with cutouts and then the card has all these different codes and symbols and you place it in what shows through the two windows are the pieces of information you get so you get one piece of information to share with the wi well I'm talking this is just a runner up I'm talking I know you're describing this a lot your as as I start and I'm like oh I'm kind of talk sorry this so the short version is it's you get a piece of information and then you start tracking people's movements throughout the night and then you start mapping it out and you're like oh this person couldn't be here this person had to be here and then you start to logic deduct everything and so I would say the designers are the same designers of turing machine also so you get the same sort of mechanic of this card giving you answers so that you don't uh have like individual players messing things up by giving people the wrong information by accident um so but
I think there's like a way better theme I would probably have called this a light game but it is a really good game yeah it's it's fantastic I need to try it so like I avoid a lot of logic deduction games because I have PTSD from stf for the elsat and that was like the one category this will heal me but this theme sounds so interesting and clue is one of my favorite games going up so like I this sounds like a lot more fun yeah this game is I this was also a close Contender for one of my winners as you could tell yeah I know like but not your winner so what is your winner I got so excited and got caught by that one more Runner out title blades to rise of the unfolder uh I could I haven't played enough of it to really know how the campaign plays out but so far from what I played I'm like it's gorgeous campaign Cooperative campaign based game uh that takes place in a title blades Universe with this really cool card I really like the action sele the ACT yeah you lay out cards and when you lay out row through you could trigger everything in the road uh but my winner is so I can finally move on and get to this is the veil of Eternity from Renegade games so uh as Christina mentioned this was originally a game that came out in Korea and it's a very simple card game like you lay out a number of cards equal to two per player so if there's four players playing you're going to lay out eight cards you're going to snake draft them and then they all have different costs so you're like I'm going to take it into my hand to buy later or I could sell it immediately and the different suits have different cost cost that you would gain
this money or you can from your hand you could pay those costs to lay it down in front of you each round round one you can only have one card round three you can only have three cards and Etc and they all do crazy combos with each other like this might say for every pink card in your hand uh get a point or for steal a point every round or if there's people ahead of you take a point there's all these cards they just designed this really awesome system where all the cards interact with each other so beautifully and immediately like even you don't have a lot of experience with these kind of card combo games you can just read the cards you're like oh if I get that card like for example the last time I played I had these card this card that said all of my one value Stone which is the currency in this game are worth plus one and then I got a carard that every at the end of every turn gained four of those stones automatically and so that what would be also four worth of currency for normal players would now is worth eight for me and it became really powerful I didn't win it's just really really cool to like discover these different combos yeah that sounds cool yeah it's an amazing game and the the best thing it's a weird limitation that makes the game so awesome is you can only have four stones on you any denomination and there's no change yeah so there's stones of value one of value three and value six and so you also have to manage this resource because like you can't just hoard money and buy whatever you want you're like I Can Only Hold four Stones whether they're four sixes for ones or a mix of
anything in between so a lot of it's like your some cards will give you points based on what Stones you're carrying some cards will make certain Stones worth more but you have to be very careful because you can only hold four so you're constantly managing this the limitation really makes it shiny yeah it's a weird it doesn't sound like it should be fun but it's like oh this is this makes you think so hard you can get great cards but you really only have enough room to play a certain number of them too so you have to be very careful which ones you're going to invest in and playing um because otherwise you have to actually spend more money to get rid of old cars that are clogging up your Tableau so this this really interesting balance that sounds really fun yeah yeah you haven't played it yet but you know no I but it sounds really good I love like combo we card games so it like seems like right on my alley oh yeah so we can teach you yeah we should do a game night yeah I would love to I love that there's so many games on PGA but your medium games what how many Runners up what do we have some overlap a fair amount of Runners up because I feel like this is such like this is my sweet spot like Medium games like they get played a lot more often um I'm going to tell you which what is my medium game then talk about my Runner because Christina you already talked about it it's for ver go that is my medium game of the year it is fantastic like everything Christina said and like what you and I said um to add on it's so clean and elegant there are like four or five actions that you can do on a t you choose one of them and then you do it
and then it's the next person turn and I love it um I love that there's like different parts of the board you're doing different things like you're trying to get objectives you're trying to do area control in like these like six different categories that relate to the die because the you're rolling Dice and you can either use that number to do this area control thing I talked about or like basically like a roll the move on the river the game is so pretty there's like gold embellishment everywhere the organizer is pretty like it's just it's such a elegant clean game it plays so fast um though I did teach this game to my family and I was like oh I'll teach this game in 10 minutes cuz it's like a light game I'm using quotes it took like 30 minutes and until the end my mom was asking me wait what's an owner reward again so you know that just reminded me like oh yeah I live in a bubble of Gamers and you know like for some people like this is like the heaviest game they've ever played or will ever play and I need to be a little bit more mindful of that I'm like oh yeah I'll teach you all this in 5 minutes cuz like I think I could teach this game in five minutes because there's not that many rules but um yeah I I love River of gold it's great um but my other game well one thing I was going to say that you were mentioning it plays really fast one clever thing I think this game does is that D roll determines where you could take it what action you take or where you could take the you roll that at the end of your turn so
then it gives you I don't know why games don't do this yeah you could think about what you want to do next by a time it's very smart yeah yeah so so it speeds it up you're not rolling for the first time and then sitting there thinking so everyone's like oh you're always ready to plan your next turn so it moves so fast for that one reason alone it's so clever as as long as people remember to do that but yes yeah that is true that's true M so my Runners up let's let me devote some uh time to my Runners up not as much as you did I got too excited so again mediumweight is like my jam probably like my favorite like category of games cuz they get played more often so I really liked inaria which is a Michael keyling game from Pegasus Spiel and so this game is like the theme is you're making parquette floors uh you're renovating a restaurant but it demoed it I remember now yeah yeah yeah you have beautiful like wood in pieces it is an abstract game through and through at the end you are going to be scoring points for how developed your floor is like like um you start with like um a base then you have a medium piece and you have a core piece and then you add a table to it and at the end these are all different points like if you built up the whole like section with the table that's 12 points well if you just have one piece that's just one point um and how you doing it is but you are um like if you want to build a purple piece you will give one purple card if you want to build the middle of the purple piece two cards the core of the purple piece three purple cards and the table of the purple piece
four four purple cards but as you are giving cards depending on the number of cards you're getting cards back in different colors so you can plan ahead so for example if I'm building the core for purple I'm going to give three purple cards and there are wilds and there's like a two for one exchange rate but then I get two cards back in other colors so I can start planning for some of the other colors there's also this like tool table where if you are the first to accomplish um like two purple pieces with like a core in them you can get tools and the tools are like a little set collection um points and you get points on them and then more points for how many of the same tools you have and there's six different types of tools it's great like I I really love it um I it's easy to teach like I played it for the first time like right after Gen Con and then I recently played it and like I skim through the rule book but I'm like oh yeah like it came back to me like I love games where you can like easily teach it again and you don't really have to like read all the rules um I really like windmill Valley from Bor and dice um I think that's like a medium game I don't think that's heavy it's like one of Bard and dice's like slightly like um Medium games that was good I like rebirth from mighty boards it's a Riner kitzia and it's so clever and it have you either you played rebirth I keep hearing about it but we haven't played it so I don't know if it would our wish shopping wish list okay yeah so it it's really good um I also like Spectacular
from chili fox games which is like a dice game it's a really clever Dice and tile Lan game it's very clever you're building a zoo um we did video I Like video game champion from Arcane wonders which I know sh you you like you like that one right we play that together I really like that one that one was a quite a surprise for me because I it looks kind of garish you really did like the graphic design of that yeah you're you're like I remember when we played Bonita you thought the little baby it looked like a cherub almost like she's like it's so cute I'm like what this thing looks ridiculous um and then but it's a really fun game with a really cool theme too and it has like cool components like these like little crystals and you know the theme is so cool it's like you're going to the video store and renting or buying video games and you're playing them and you're beating video games so they're very like '90s nostalgic theme to it and then finally skyrise from roxley games and that is a very interesting um auction bidding game and you're adding it and you're like building up your main board you have the pieces the pieces are how you auction too cuz there's numbers on on the back of the pieces so like depending on that you can put your piece down and you can get points along the way and there's also like a on your board there's like a little bit of a set collection thing going on based on colors um yeah so a lot of different Runner UPS because this
was a very hard category for me but definitely reverve gold number one which leaves us of course our heavy game of 2024 so I think I'm going to have Bonita go I know you just talked but I I think we're going to ask for your Runners up and game of heavy game of 2024 first so let's do runners up so Runners up I have two Runners up I got Endeavor deepy from kids from burnt Island games kids table board gaming um I really liked the original Endeavor yeah from years ago didn't like the theme so I was very excited when they said they were going to remake it and they changed it up and it has a very interesting like um system where you are exploring the ocean and you are getting you know people to like help navigate the ocean for you there is more theme to that I just not remembering it um and then you know you can play cooperative competitively I have not played The Cooperative version I think the competitive version is great but you know there's different ways to score it there's a lot of modularity in it it's fantastic also MOS is also really good from bord and dice super heavy I love the the different dice placement of it I would recommend not playing it at 4 unless you want like a 5 hour game of mos yeah which we did together well also play that together we did play that one together and but but all both of those
games are great and if anyone wanted to play with me I would play it in a heartbeat but my number one game is SEI which sh taught me how to play a BGC when it was an excellent rules teach I got to say oh thank you thank you so Saidi is search for extraterrestrial intelligence from cge um and the designer is Thomas holck so SEI is you are trying to like you're searching for alien life but you're launching probes you're playing cards you're trying to communicate with aliens and I think what s does is really interesting you have all these rules but then halfway through the game you're going to start like uncovering aliens and these aliens unlock new rules and they unlock new cards and the order and how you unlock could really like change up um I just think it's fascinating it's also a very like tight game the resources are very tight um when I played I can't apparently can't do math and I miscalculated by One Resource One Credit and this game is where um there's not equal amount of turns you keep playing until you pass and because I like I I I had no I had needed one more credit and I couldn't do the thing and I tried to push my luck by like going to the cards because the cards all to use you can either discard cards for a resource or you can play the cards by paying the cost I was trying to like get a carard
that I could discard for a resource didn't work out so I had to pass before everyone else I was just sitting there and watching people that was really fun for me but I know but I think that proved how much I liked it but even though I had like not the best first play of it like I was like I can't wait to play this again also you know it is a pretty heavy rules teach like it took like almost 30 minutes to learn the game but I think the rules tied in so well for the theme which not a lot of heavy games do I like the the theme was not is not just window dressing in this it it is actually incorporated into the rules and I think it makes sense and I really like SE and like it as soon as you learn it you're like oh this makes sense like we didn't really need any rules clarifications as we were playing I just because I think it just like clicks once you learn how to play and so yeah s your teacher was so good obviously obviously has such a good teacher I remember from the game with you was that you just like really hated the U how the whole um basically the solar system would keep rotating yes I did hate that I did hate that because it just wrecks your plans and I was like you can you know how it's going to spin but you don't know exactly when and when that's going to trigger so I just remember Bonita complaining about that a lot so I was surprised that that's your game of the year but but I love that game I love that game and I was looking at other
heavy games when when I when you asked me to do this and you know there was a lot of heavy games and out of all of this one I want to play seti the most I also played unconscious minds and I just like I I think it was really great but I feel like the theme and how you're playing didn't tie in as well as seti and I'm like okay got to go got to go for mhm that a solar system rotation thing is uh it is a little Annoying I think especially at first- time playing because you're like I'm sending a satellite to Jupiter and it's like now Jupiter's not where it was when I started off on this plan but I also like it's going back take advantage of it too the rotation you can take advantage of it and so it's it's again going back to what you said about the theme it's like it's really cool because in real life you wouldn't send something in a straight line to where that thing is in space where it is at the moment you plan for where it will be by the time your craft gets to that sometimes it helps you like at one time on the wheel I got closer cuz like your probe can move along I mean there's like a lot of asteroids which makes it harder to move through but hey if someone moves it the asteroid field is gone it got covered up so it can help mostly it hinders but it can help yeah but I I I like that part I I didn't like it at first and then I grew to really like it CU I'm like thematically this is really cool and once you could start to play for the rotation you're like I'm going to plan for the rotation so that I get there faster than I maybe would or otherwise
so it's it will feel a little random I think for firsttime players and then once you kind of get to realize all the different ways you kind control it won't ever 100% be in your control cuz other people can rotate the Rings as well but you know where it's going to be eventually it's mhm um spoiler alert that's my game of the year also for the heavy game for sure um so my big thing about seti is I've played it three times now which is uh almost unheard of for the same heavy game for me and and uh cuz we got it so you only got it in November yeah so we only November too yeah mhm and so what I love about is the game is so different every single time because of the aliens that come out and so there I think there's five or six five five total aliens and so in my three plays I have seen them all now and they're so different from each of them because they're randomized uh the the two that you play with each game get randomized um and the different combinations between the two really changes things um and then you have like sometimes pickup and deliver missions versus oh this this particular thing might be like similar to a corruption issue where you have to deal with um powerful actions but maybe you have to pay the price later you know so they all play completely differently from each other and like you said the big thing for me is just how the theme is w WS everything up so nicely like I was so surprised uh the last time I played it it had been at least a month between plays and uh I was like oh yeah this is
all coming back to me like well our friend was teach reteaching it to some new players but I was like oh yeah I can I know what what everything does I know how to read the iconography and like it was super fresh again like really quickly so yeah shout out to our friend Brian for teaching us the game in the first place before I got to teach it mhm and then my Runner that I want to talk about is uh actually Black Forest uh an U Rosenberg just got that it's good really really like it I've only played it once um so I you know if IID played it more who knows if that might have become my my game of the year but it's a basically a redo of GL of glass Road um a classic U Rosenberg game where you are making glass okay um but now I think from what I hear he had wanted to do this sort of bigger game that involved the region of the black forest in Germany um which was known for making glass but at the time that he made glass Road the publisher was like let's pair it down let's like really focus on the glass part and not so much the region um but in Black Forest I think he fulfilled his vision a little bit more maybe informed by having designed a lot of games in between and so you still have this like crazy rondelle resource wheel that sort of shows as I gather these resources if I have enough of these components they will automatically form glass together like you'll need sand you'll need um coal or whatever the different resources are that will make glass so you have to manage your resources because if you're not ready to
lose the basic resources you can't you have to time it um so there's that whole resource aspect but I what I really enjoy that laid on top of it is how you get your resources and your actions you're traveling through different Villages where you land um you take two actions that are adjacent to you um if somebody else is there and you're joining that Village you have to give them a resource so there is some player interaction where that's pretty rare for an uve game I think normally it is pretty R right and then uh but as you're traveling you do have to feed your people but in a different way than a normal game you have to provide this better sort of provision so you're balancing making glass with making Provisions so you can move around um and so and then there's also this aspect of like moving a traveling Merchant that will change up the board as they're playing too so there these little tweaks that I really really enjoy about this game and I can't wait to play it again so I really want our copy to come in I'm not as enamored with black forest as other people seem to be yeah um but I I also I remember like I kind of wish our friend Brian taught it to me oh we have a friend who teaches a lot of heavy games and he's like excellent teacher and provides all the context and I'm like I feel like I didn't know what I was doing for several rounds I'm just like it's so Random how this st's going and I I think I needed someone with more experience to kind of like I'll teach it to you I'll teach it to you so yeah I I really like that game so I can't wait to play that again and your heavy game sh uh so C was my winner as
well yeah that's the first uh first one that we all matched on yeah uh C's just amazing it's a big game there's a lot going on but it's just thematically so cool like you said my favorite part is the thing you mentioned Christina the aliens like it's so cool that there's five different aliens so which two you pick at random will determine different ways that the game will score but I love that they don't introduce this until maybe halfway through or two-thirds of the way in because uh everyone kind of it's not a Cooperative game but they work cooperatively to unlock the aliens yeah and then once they do it's like oh you're reading special instructions and they have new cards and then New pieces that might change how the game works right and then but it's really smart that they do this a little bit later so everyone's kind of you get used to playing game first and and then it throws a Twist in about halfway through so and then two twists so I'm really excited I hope that they will release expansions sounds I have to right like just like Al expansion just more alien like an alien pack of some sort to add more of that variety I don't want more rules like I just want more aliens I don't want any more rules exactly yeah yeah uh then uh the next thing is my Runners up I also had mino's dawn of the Bronze Age uh cuz I love dice plac games that's one of my favorite genres and then my last runner up is an age contrived so this is a beautifully produced it's it's the deluxe
collector's edition's over produced for sure uh it's but it's in a like like look at this there's so much stuff in here and it's just a little area control uh a little engine building and you have this sort of like conveyor belt mechanism that will uh determinate will determine what powers you have accessible to you at any time so uh it's just a neat really big Hefty Euro game it's definitely chunky it's chunky it's it's just uh and it's really beautiful looking and it has a lot of systems that aren't necessarily familiar you know it's like it's hard to kind of qu kind of qualify what it is exactly uh because it does so many different things a little differently so I really like that game are that something on me no oh I thought Christina was like so yeah so much crossover in this list yes yeah I think more than our previous guests so I think we're kind of the same person I know just merged together I think I think sh the only one we didn't cross over was like our medium game I think everything else was the same your your medium list your your wider Runners up list was the most diverse for the mediums yeah got to play more Medium games with her there a lot yeah and then she always makes fun of me because in the past I've somehow made Arc NOA my game of the year twice when it wasn't the coming out that year so just a shout out to Arc NOA cuz I played it 77 times on board game arena this year so 77 times wow wow so she always finds a way
to work Arc Nova into every year for years after it's come my win on this year 77 times yeah yeah don't play I will not play here you need to go into the um World Ser like the world series of board gaming you need to like enter the arnova I keep telling her to do this thing because she plays her average is really good her win rate I mean it's okay I am not doing like arena games on BGA yet so that'll be the next we'll see we should do it okay everyone here knows her win rate is every every two people here other two people here and she keeps downplaying it because she doesn't want a big Target on her back foot so thank you so much for joining us Bonita we had so much fun talking about games we have some more game so we'll play with each other on BTA probably really soon um except AR NOA you don't have to play with me and um and thanks for Shu of course for providing his games and insight and thanks to Mike Zipkin our fantastic editor for editing this podcast we hope our listeners found some fun new games they want to go and explore and tell us what your game of the year was we'd love to hear and so thanks now you can stop listening and go play a game bye bye I