Skip to main content
Loading video...

7 new/new-to-us board games (and what we liked/didn't like about them) | Ep 133

Transcript 1:02:39

hello welcome to the going anog podcast where we usually have an industry guest uh talking about board games and a topic to discuss but today you get your favorite two people me and Shu only hi Shu your favorite and her backup sure whatever um in any case we just have a lot of games to get through right so we've played a ton of games there have been a lot that have been sent by Publishers a lot of games we really really like and we just wanted to take the time to run through seven games in we promis less than 7even hours today we have a lot of games and we're going to talk about something we like and dislike about them so stay tuned we are going to be talking about veil of Eternity far away Monumental Elder Scrolls betrayal of the second era Heroes of Might and Magic 3 the board game converge and Evergreen so we've got a lot to get into Shu yeah they're all new is games either they came out this year in 2024 or uh I think the oldest one was about a year ago or so so they're all really new games that were really excited to talk about yes and tell us what you think about them also so the first thing we're just going to Dive Right In is veil of Eternity so veil of Eternity is a game um published Stateside by Renegade and was originally uh published in Korea under Mandu games designed by Eric Hong so this sort of like quick drafting card game is uh essentially about being creature Tamers in this magical world that's not Pokemon

but other mythological creatures and on your turn uh you are going we're like the players are going to snake draft two different creatures every round and then you have some really interesting choices to make with these creatures so on your turn you are going to decide well am I going to sell this creature for its value based off of its suit or like type of creature so different creatures will be worth more or fewer Magic Stone resources um or you can tame them and put them into your hand hoping to summon them later by spending some of those magic Stones um a couple really interesting twists to this seemingly simple game just really make it shine so uh one aspect is when you have these magic stones that have denominations of 1 three and six only uh you can only hold four stones at a time every time you go over you're going to have to discard down and there's no change when you go and use these Stones you're going to have to just spend it all and try to be efficient that way um so really interesting choices to make as you're building out these cards they will combo in super awesome ways if you find some good Combos and there's just a lot of uh variation there I've played this game a lot and every single time we've had very different combos different people winning it feels different uh just we've been really into this game right you yeah that stone thing is so cool it's so weird is because it looks like a limitation and it almost feels initially like oh they didn't really think this through but then totally thought yeah

it's like because everything is based around okay you have to spend either this specific stone or you might have to make a choice like would I buy a one cost core uh card for a six Stone and that's all I have no value but there's a lot of cards that combo off of like hey if you have this colored stone or if you use this stone or you could change these stones to these stones and and so there's this whole Economy based just around these set stones that you can have again you can't make change there's no such thing as exchanging six for a three and a three or anything like that unless a card gives you that effect uh so it's really neat it's really limiting in that fact but it it creates all this cool all these cool kind of combinations the other big limitation is each round in front of you summon cards you can only have as many as the current round number so round one one card round two two cards so there's this whole play about okay do I play cards that will let me uh take back cards that I previously summoned or there cards that will kind of re uh go back into your hand by themselves to free room for others or you can pay to remove some of your cards uh and then that in itself creates new combination possibilities of like now I could to re-trigger this onetime effect over and over again if I could create the economy to do so so uh sort of sneak peek uh sneak preview this is a contender for a early Contender for my 2024 for a game of the year in the sort of light light medium category already it's only May it's early May too I know I I really like this game so much yeah

it's it's just so cool and when we've shown it to most people uh We've shown it to uh really like it like we've had I think I've sold like two or three copies so far to what a kickback on that nothing no Kickbacks unfortunately but uh yeah they immediately like like I'm buying this my group's going to love this game and such so uh so if you what's your one thing that you like most about this game I really like the way that it ramps up so you can play to 10 Rounds or if somebody reaches 60 points that's the game and Trigger Final Round right uh and so in the beginning because you have just a few creatures here and there um you know you're making tiny moves and you're like ooh I can get this car that gives you like one point or two points I'm like great but by the later part of the game like that's just like crap that's just like baby points right and so you can like make huge swings depending on like how clever you are with your Combos and what you can put together so one of the games I played um our friend Jonathan ended up making like like like 50 points in one turn so it was like insane because he made this like beautiful beautiful combo and it was just exciting to see even though I didn't get to play it so you know um really fascinating uh lots of weird stuff you can do there I really like that part yeah is it 10 Rounds or eight rounds something like that anyways 10 if I had to pick one thing I'd liked about the game it's the definitely the combos

because uh this will be sort of uh anyone who's played any kind of card games you you've done stuff like this before but they've done it in a very approachable Manner and with these limitations like we mentioned that are really cool so I I really like the combo system it very rewarding uh you can be somewhat of a newer gamer and then start to trigger a lot of cool things and and you'll be like oh man if I could do this I could do this or let me go dig through that D discard pile to find this one card that will let me do this and this and this and then they all start to chain together it just feels super rewarding for uh little overhead right it's not a collectible card game but you get a lot of that feel uh it's not ter terribly complicated but you get that same feel as more complicated games it's just really elegantly designed the Art's great sort of this like slightly quirky but like cool bright mythological creature illustration you get Chunky like wooden pieces to to enhance the game just great yeah yeah and then if you have to pick one thing you didn't like about the game what would that be uh I think you know when you when somebody else is running away with a combo and it's not you that's a little bit of a feel bad but you know he's like oh I still got an a combo that's pretty neat and because it's card based there's of course some RNG there too right so even if somebody else draws into like a really great combo um they still have to take advantage of it or if you AR there are ways to get around stuff I think that can amarate some bad draws sometimes yeah uh if I had to pick

something negative to say or sort of a criticism I think uh it's very minor because I absolutely love this game but if I had to pick something uh I think I've already played it a bunch of times too and I feel like oh I'm starting to see like I I'm starting to be familiar with the deck of cards right there's a lot of cards in the first few plays You' be like there's all these different combinations 70 unique creatures yeah and then so I think now after having played it a while it's a weird like kind of criticism but it's like I'm familiar with the deck I want more content so I'm really hoping that this game does well enough that they're going to make expansions and introduce more creatures and more monsters maybe another suit or another type of Monster uh so I'm looking forward I hope they do more I I don't think they've announced anything yet but uh um I'm hoping there's more content on the way yeah I think did It win the Mena award recently too cannot remember but they might have W them so that might help also I I enjoy just the creatures that are cuz I've played it a lot and I feel like they interact in very different ways each time and depending on when they come out in the draft versus um you know like what they can combine with so I haven't found that issue yet maybe it'd be something cool like where you take out one type of creature completely and substitute in another one so that it doesn't just add a lot more it just kind of changes said Dynamic but any case it's yeah it's starting to feel a little familiar just but that's because I played it so much so it's like sort of like oh well I played it a lot CU I like the games so it's a weird criticism

but uh so veil of attorney really like that and our next game is far away so where's our cover for far away for people who happen to be watching this on YouTube when we upload this uh far away is by johannas goopy and quarantine lebre from and published by pandasaurus so another very small small game Tiny Box game just card-based right fascinating game we got it fairly recently so thanks to pentaurus for sending us a copy um it is through the whole game you will only play eight cards for the whole Tableau so the it's something about like you're in this lost continent alula and these cards are region cards as you're exploring the regions you're meeting different citizens in this land and as you play them out from left to right you are trying to build a good scoring system so some of these citizens have Quests for you and so if they are difficult quests to accomplish like you need all of these symbols you get a lot of points and the value of this card is higher but the value of the card is also initiative so there's a constant balance between like do I need to play this High number early so I can set up for my quest or do I want to play a low number so I can do a better like pick of drafting the cards for the next round you know so this concept cool because the real twist here is after you've played out all eight cards from left to right you will only trigger and activate the scoring from

right to left so if you had a high-scoring card that you needed to like certain symbols for you had to play those after you played that one card so there's a lot of like push your luck there a little bit um so it's really sort of trippy and different from a lot of the games that we've played and we we really really like that I think yeah it's such a weird game uh it's uh like scoring backwards it's not intuitive but once you play it once it's like oh okay I get it uh it's uh it's a short game so you could just play that second game immediately super short game you can play it in about a half hour so yeah every once's like you have to make all these decisions when you're making the first run through which is playing the cars from left to right right you have to like do I do I put in uh scoring cards now not knowing what symbols I'm going to play later that will trigger off of those cards uh am i setting this up correctly not knowing what cards I'm going to drive or do I play a low number because a load number card will let you draft the next card earlier into your hand maybe beating your opponents with some good cards or do you play uh the next a higher number than the previous card you played because that also triggers an additional effect which is to get uh Sanctuary cards which are additional smaller cards that will either give you symbols that you need or give you additional scoring ways that are kind of permanent they don't care about the left to right right to left thing uh but then you you lay this out it kind of I I love the Cadence of this game too because there's a kind of buildup build up right you're like okay I hope this is going to be good the next

card fight I hope this is going to work I hope this work you're just like building up and up and up it's like all right now everyone scores we flip all the cards over and reveal them backwards and then you're just like you're you're going to see a lot of groaning of like I did that wrong I did not play this I was hoping for this symbol it never came up or or you're like this triggers this triggers and everyone's like oh good job there good job there you you managed to make all these cool combos uh cuz you got a little bit of luck but also like you set it up properly but what a neat game this is another early Contender for my game of the year um two of them already I wish it it was in a similar category of bale of Eternity kind of lightish uh like I wouldn't call them medium weight games they're like on the light to medium side uh so they're in the same category and they're competing in my mind with each other but it's another such a wonderful game because it's so unique and different like you I don't think anyone's played like it's likely you've never played anything like this so it's worth it just to check it out just for something new and refreshing in the card game genre for a nice little filler and stuff too um yeah you're ready to announce your game of the year already blowing your wad all at once don't say blowing your wad yeah I don't know gross yeah kids go find out what that okay uh okay thing that you most like about this game uh that that sort of s like the the tempo of the game is so different and the decisions that you make are really unique uh I also really really like the art uh I think the art is is this sort of

trippy hippie dippy sort of design I don't know I've never seen art like exactly like that I'm really bad to describe art evid yeah uh but it's got like real quirky little citizens in the different land and it's very colorful um it's just a really catching game too simple art simple art yeah cuz the cards are all small and square uh because you need to have enough room to be able to lay out four of these in a row um yeah for me the thing I would like most is that obviously the mechanic about uh your playing cards left to right but you only trigger them right to left which again creates a different dynamic because when you're again going right to left it's kind of weird but it's like cards you haven't encountered when you're going right to left do not help you trigger any of these cards before it so you're playing one way in your mind but you're activating them a totally different way uh it's it's just really neat mhm if you had to pick something you didn't like I don't know I I really really like this game is there anything I don't like about this game uh the lack of pineapples the lack of pineapples so it's one of the it's one of the symbols that score in this game and is the rarest symbol so they do lay out of these three possible symbols that show up on the these cards um that is the rarest one and it's just been a running joke in all of the games that I play where people were like oh no I need more pineapples and they're not even pineapples they're like golden thistles or something but they the stylized look of it make them look like pineapples we're like no no no I want that

pineapple well I have enough Pineapples by the end of the game and uh so for me the big thing that I've been like smacking my head over and my I've played it twice I think two three times uh I tend to Mi miscount one icon and then I Miss like scoring 10 12 points just on this one thing so every single time I'm like oh my gosh oh my gosh I forgot this one thing anyway yeah I think for me it's probably uh again this is why I like the game is this weird mechanic uh for a newer player uh maybe a less experienced gamer they might have we we've seen this they have a little bit of a hard time kind of wrapping their head around it cuz I ran this at our game party a couple weeks ago a week and a half ago or so and then uh I could see kind of this confused look of like how does this work and I kind of had there's part of me that's like well don't worry because a lot of people's first games will be just kind of like like oh the light bulb will kind of go off after you play it once but you try to explain it to them and then even as they're doing it they're just like wait that didn't quite work like uh it's like again until they actually see it in action then they're like oh okay it works but again that's the reason why the game is so cool cuz it has this really weird different thing to it so yeah so uh it's it's a minor criticism mhm so if you need a quirky little unique filler we are loving far away yep the next game bigger is Monumental

by and you keep talking cuz I realized this laptop is not plugged in so don't stop I'm going to go my sh so the game is Monumental uh designed by Matthew dunon and published by funforge so monumental is a sort of deck building Tableau Builder SL area control game about building out your civilization and Matthew Dunston has also designed a bunch of other games that we like especially the Guild of merchant explorers we one of our favorites so very excited for Monumental um so really unique game as you play different civilizations like I played China and there was ancient Egypt and all sorts of other civilizations you have a few unique cards and then you're taking these cards and on your turn you are laying them mount in a 3X3 grid so your cards will give you certain resources or different abilities and things like that but you don't activate a single card at a time what you're going to do is choose in your grid a row and a column and activate all the cards within that row and column so really different way to think about a deck builder because as you acquire new cards that go into your deck that will uh deal out into this Tableau and you're trying to find the best combination to do your goals as you try to take over the different territories or buy better cards or um increase technology all of these different aspects to this game yeah it's a civilization Builder so like all the

classic civilization things you would imagine like I'm going to build Wonders that will give me ongoing powers or going to research science because science cards don't clog up your that 3x3 Tableau you can trigger them in addition to a normal card uh or expand your military which lets you move around the board and take over other territories and the way they do combat is super streamlined so if you're like if you like Civilization or Forex style games but you're just like sometimes a combat's a little bit too involved or uh what I don't like in a lot of these games like if you have combat between two players like if you're playing a game of eclipse for example Forex space game Eclipse uh everyone kind of has to stop if two players are going to fight right so it's kind of uh this has very little downtime with regards to that because if I'm going to take over yeah for combat take over Christina's territory it's very simple calculation if I have more uh Power more strength then I'm going to win and then you don't have no dice rolling no having to calculate no her playing defense or anything like that uh so uh streamline military combat which I like because I think military combat and those conflicts are the least my least favorite part of Forex game I like the expanding the researching Technologies and things like that so that's really cool and then monumentals also uh I think one of its appeals is like all the factions have slightly different cards and powers and different things that they can research and they sell expansions we didn't play any of the expansions but uh the expansions have

more races that you can include in the more Nations you can include in a set to for more variety so yeah it's a pretty streamlined Forex game um like if I say yeah with a caveat so we'll get to that in a second um so if I had to pick one thing I really like about it is that 3x3 grid like that alone even I think before I played it I was like that's a really cool idea of like having to pick which row and which column to trigger and you only are triggering those cards and so like building it out right that's like really rewarding to be able to be like not just play all the cards in your hand but like whatever you do randomly but to set it up strategically but also planning for future turns because like the cards that you remove and then replace back in there will matter as well so it's like do I play this card now do I play this card later those kind of decisions so I really like that part of monumental a lot uh as a deck builder it worked really nicely there's definitely ways to call your deck um but the randomness comes in how you deal it out into that 3x3 grid so uh that part was super exciting I did love the combos lots and lots of combos going on between uh your military resource being able to do this and get a reward and then building off of that by activating something else and it's just like ooh combos everywhere so that was that the one some of my favorite parts of any sort of tech building game yeah and then if I think we're going to say kind of the same thing uh if we had to complain about something one thing we didn't like about the game uh the length of the game

was uh kind of bad for me so this at four players like the last time we played it took over 2 and 1 half 3 hours to play uh but it's not a super heavy game it's not a heavy game it's not a complex game uh but so there's games like deck building games typically you you will play a hand of cards and you do everything the cards say right so you're going like all the actions possible like I'm going to buy stuff I'm going to attack stuff I'm going to create these combos all of that happens within a player's turn but most deck building games because you're just playing with cards it's pretty quick to do um and there's other more uh more Grand games Grand scale games where to make it kind of efficient everyone takes one action at a time Monumental kind of sits between those two worlds where it's a deck building game you have to take all your actions but that makes the game take a long time because there's so many different things you can do and different choices to make it's not as streamlined as a normal card-based deck building game so you have a lot of decisions so there's a lot of times where there's three people kind of waiting for one person just like I'm going to do this I'm going to combo this person having a great time with their combos but then when they're done and somebody else has turned to combo then you're like sitting there do I pull out my phone like you know do I play another game uh so I think for yeah the my thing that I did not like was at four player specifically that's just too much downtime because you can't even like plan your turn that much you can you're like o I'm probably going to trigger this row and column but then you're still waiting for the other people and

then if they take over our territory or if they buy the card you wanted then you're like oh do I reconfigure which row and column I want to activate uh so I think you know we have haven't tried two player yet but I feel like that would be pretty ideal where you don't have to wait too long and you're still getting those crunchy combos yeah it's it's it's designed for up to four players but we we all decided like I don't think we want to play this four player anymore uh neat idea but just like because you had to wait if you have to wait three people to do everything we just described late later in the game right in the beginning of the game not that big a deal but as the game goes on and you have more to do and you get more complex cards uh and the map situation is really tight cuz everyone's all right on top of each other uh then you there a lot of decisions to be made and a lot of downtime for that my other thing I didn't like was this game is called Monumental and we build all these monuments and wonders and somebody forgot to tell us that we could put them on the board uh which would have very much changed the uh at least the territory control part of the game yeah when we were putting it away monal yeah the first time we played when we put away we start putting everything away uh wonder I forgot who said what are those cards over there and I'm like oh crap when you build a monument in your Tableau you also put it on the map which which provides one defense for that territory thought it was like three was it just one defense I think it's one defense but uh we forgot so so yeah that that would have been interesting cuz it was based it was called Monumental so maybe they should

figure more more more broadly in the game uh but a fascinating game really nice puzzle to that game just wouldn't play it at four again mhm and then we had a big boy after this um Elder SCS Beyond betrayal of the second era Sorry by published by chip Theory games designed by Josh J Carlson and Michael gns uh this is a really really big game that was on Kickstarter I think last year I want to say I don't remember exactly when and we got a cool demo of it during B gon a while back so di West dice toar West so sorry dice tar West thanks to Andrew from Chip the game and we love Elder Scrolls so this is based off of Elder Scrolls online and we most we played a little bit of that but we're mostly like I was mostly into very very into Skyrim played a ton of Skyrim together um sh's played a whole bunch of other Elder Scroll games we've spent so this is our fandom just so to give a bit of context with how much we know Elder Scrolls uh we played Elder Scrolls Online a little bit we put 188 hours into Skyrim the first time through a ton of hours into a second time through uh I've played Oblivion I've played Marl wi and I've played even Daggerfall so all but one in the series uh big fan of the series is a fantasy medieval setting and then in this uh if you've played or familiar with too many bones by chip Theory games uh it's has similar system it has kind of the soulle of too many bones uh which is basically we're uh

adventurers we're on a CO Cooperative team and we go on these we have an Overworld map where we're deciding where we want to go uh and this is though it's an open world unlike too many bones it's like we do we want to go to this small campsite or do we want to go to this small town what do we want to do once we get to that town do we want to go to this dungeon uh we're given a mission and we need to travel but there travel takes time and we need to budget that in like can we get to do all these side things in time before we get to our main quest so you have to make all these decisions together as a group we all have different classes and different races that all give us unique powers and then we all have our own dice sets that not not so much for Rolling but for setting different dice faces to trigger different actions or attacks and so on there's a cool down system for like when you use certain dice you can go out of play for a little bit so you have to manage that properly uh and then yeah and then when you're in the dungeon or when you're on a battlefield you have these sort of poker likee chips that have like our units and then the enemy's units with their attacks and their stats and their ranges and all that kind of stuff on it uh like chip 3 games tends to do and then uh and then you have those uh those encounters and you might pick up some treasure you might pick up some loot You Can level up your characters get more XP and do all kinds of things so very very much a Cooperative RPG mhm uh the build out of the character in the beginning very much like like Elder schools too where you have a combination of the character class with the sort of

uh racer background of it and then together they combine to give you some unique sort of buildout skills one really interesting thing about it on your player mat when you have these different skills based off of your character um there's like two skills on either side and you have to decide a balance between you know uh when you increase one of them that that sort of limits how far you can increase the the opposite one so really interesting balance there so you don't get like super crazy on any one sort of um you can't just max out all your skills and some are directly opposed to each other and we getting more XP you can unlock more Dice and more skills based off of those Dice from your character uh that part was super super fun and exciting probably spent a long time on that too the initial so yeah we don't have the game here with us because it's not out yet uh we only play this demo it was a prototype it was a prototype and it was uh we played for almost four hours four of us like you me uh Phil and his friend and then uh and then our our Andrew from Chip theory was kind of watching and facilitating it so it's helpful to have someone there who can like tell you this this is how this works right like just teaching you and running the game for you but um it took us a long time and we didn't complete half one scario we did take a long time to to get everything set up to decide what we want to do and we're kind of uh just relaxing and kind of chilling through this whole thing so it is a long game so this is the kind of thing I'm not sure what the final MSRP is going to be but you're getting a lot of game because like if we're playing

let's say even at 4 hours we went too long and that should have been closer to 2 and 1/2 hours or so for half of one scenario and there's multiple scenarios and there's different choices you can make in the Overworld you could link scenarios together for a larger campaign uh there's so much to play here that's going to be really exciting and uh and yeah you can make different characters there's a whole bunch of characters that we didn't even touch upon uh so it was just like I wanted there was a lot to explore with just my character and like I wasn't even close to leveling up even halfway to the Max and there was like oh man there's all these cool skills that I would unlock if I play this enough but I'm like but there's also a dozen more characters that I want to play and check out and see what they all do so very much like to many bones where all the characters play very differently from each other but not as crazy as too many bones I think this is probably more Str yeah which is what I liked about it so definitely we've only played too many bones once uh yep and despite sh owning the whole thing for years and years and years we played it once finally and had a good time but I think that the Elder Scrolls implementation of of similar sort of combat system seems a lot more smooth out to me so I found it pretty uh straightforward there's like lockpicking and stuff like that that that's thrown in which is sort of fun too when you're getting treasures and things like that uh but everything seems to make sense and it seems pretty streamlined the one thing I didn't like as Shu mentioned was it did take us a really long time but I feel like that was probably our fault

when we were talking to Andrew who's run lots of these demos he mentioned uh yeah yeah we're an outlier it normally doesn't take that long to run through um that much of the scenario so I think we were just very excited by all the ways we could build out the character and probably taking too much time to decide uh on some of those build outs when it was just a demo so yeah I think same two things for me like I I my favorite thing is like all the different characters and how differently they play uh the thing that was uh more like for me like and this is a plus for other people it's just like there's a lot of game here like like for our kind of Lifestyle gaming lifestyle of where we play a lot of different games uh it might be too much game in one package right even though we love Sky if I were to invest a lot of time into one campaign I think I would want it to be this one though because I I like I like the IP so much and the system just clicks for me I think so it'd be really exciting if we were able to like really build out that character and make them super powerful too so it' be very rewarding so I think if you're comparing the two uh too many bones would probably be better if you're more like I want to just play Standalone games more you know like in 2 three hours I'm done and then you next time you play you play a totally different game with very very different characters uh that are mechanically much more different from each other than they are in Skyrim or uh Elder Scrolls and then uh but Elder Scrolls if you want a deeper richer campaign in this kind of almost like a living world where because again you

have this Overworld map these locations you could go back to and Revis visit and and you kind of get to learn this world and get familiar with this world uh and yeah and it's you're going to get way more hours I think out of other Scrolls and you bow too many bones yeah I wonder cuz one of my favorite things that got us super into Skyrim for a really long time was just all those like super ex weird random side quests that can happen to you U like we once got uh overly drunk in a Tavern and woke up on the opposite side of the map and had to figure out what happened you know I wonder if those are things that could build out if you're playing that campaign where there's like a lot more personality to the narrative but we only had like a short demo so um interested to find out the next game is a big chunky boy also so we also played Heroes of Might and Magic 3 the board game and of course it has to be three because this is based off of the PC game Heroes of Might and Magic which is a series but everyone agrees that Heroes of Might magic 3 is the best one and so it is huge uh I don't even know how much it weighs at this point but uh if you are watching on YouTube you can sort of see that it dwarfs both of us uh it's a huge box so much game to it and it it it is so nostalgic because hero of Might magic 3 is the PC game came out in the '90s at some point yeah it's been a while it's been a long time we love playing that game we would play at Hot Seat just the

two of us and play at Co-op or like against each others occasionally but there's so much you can do so in the PC game typically you start at your castle and you are exploring the nearby area to get resources and build out and then you meet all of these creatures that you might have to conquer things like that and then you might run into other heroes or other villains that you're trying to conquer and different scenarios have different objectives um there's mainly the main map buildout as you're exploring and then if you are doing combat then it becomes sort of this hex based battle that's a separate phase so we were super curious how that would translate to the board game yeah this is uh Heroes a might magic 3 specifically is one of the top five video games PC games for me of all time uh played it for years long after it's like long and done and they they're on like herold's five six seven go back I still go back to three I try those and I'm like three is still the best one and then the game makers the board game makers clearly knew that because this is the one they chose to make a board game out of uh but yeah so uh they you will explore a map you put out the tiles and then I'll say there's several ways to play it you can play solo The Campaign solo you can play a two to three player co-op or you can play two to play three player Skirmish uh no more than that and there's probably a good reason for that which we'll get into in a second um when you put out the tiles within one hexagon there are seven smaller regions in there that might contain uh different artifacts or different uh special

buildings to go visit uh you might encounter other castles or you might encounter neutral creatures so if I went and fought even though if I'm playing so we've only played this once it's a huge game uh Christina and me and our friend Dan who's also a big fan of the PC game uh we all play because we all have this Nostalgia and we really excited to play the board game uh and this box by the way that Christina mentioned and we just showed on camera is uh the Allin box like the normal base game box is not this big but I didn't care how the game played I'm like I love this franchise so much I'm just going to get it all and deal with it later uh so this is published by archon games forgot to mention that and uh designed by Camille Bowski and ycob uh oxic yeah probably close something uh yeah so you you go on and explore these areas there's a kind of fog Awards some tiles aren't flipped over until you actually reach them you have to you have only so much movement uh and action points you can spend a day and and then at its core it's a deck building game as well so your your deck uh will offer you like okay if I uh learn spells or I've upgraded my guy or I have certain skills they're all comboed and work together through the cards uh so that it might be like okay I encountered this group of imps now I go to a separate map and then this game offers the hex map like the piece of game but they also like the normal game is just like more of a grid simplified where you put the cards of the unit so like okay my vampires are

represented by a card on this board and they have Miniatures as well if you if you've upgraded to that that package um so and they all behave just like they do in the PC game like like almost literally right like haries have a way to avoid retaliation or they can fly back from where they came from they fly in attack and come back medusas will uh can kind of freeze people temporarily uh and things like that the only thing this doesn't do that the PC game does is like where you could build armies of like hundreds of a certain cheap unit type uh you know it's it's not you can't really do it's unwieldy for a board game to do those so hundreds of minis well the way they do it is like uh you if you have one side of a card of a unit card it's a few and if you flip it over it's a pack it's a more powerful version and there's uh theoretically more of them and they have more health and things like that but they really simplified the combat that way it made it make sense for a board game so from a pure Heroes that might IM magic fandom point of view I think the game did a really really good job got the same Heroes like solir the like Genie thing and then uh while we were playing the game I made sure to like look up a Spotify playlist for the heroes of my magic 3 soundtrack uh it was great put the battle music on when the battle was going it was like so nerdy and so great for us fans yeah and then um one thing I did make a mistake of was uh I cuz I mixed in all the different map tiles and played and then some of them weren't in the r book and I was like wait where's this it was like

cuz it was part of an expansion and I had to look elsewhere to see what this one thing does like what's a magic well I I forgot what it was but anyways there's like different buildings that you could visit or different structures you can visit to do things that had to look through it uh which leads me to well let's talk about what did you like about the Game Heroes of mind magic 3 it it felt like I was playing the game but smoothed out for a board game so definitely gave me all the right feels for for hero and uh it was very fun to revisit that in like a tangible physical way because the original PC game has a lot in common with board games too like the the way that it moves and stuff so yeah yeah uh I agree that's my favorite thing about it too like I actually after we're done playing I'm like I'm not sure I would take the time to teach this game and we'll cover more of this and our what we don't like part um to a nonh Heroes of magic 3 player it's great it's big but it's it's sort of like you appreciate it so much more if you're a fan and we know enough fans I'm like I'm just going to I would just show them and I would just play it with the people I've already played it with um but even down to like one of the appeals I don't think you mentioned this but the uh one of the appeal appealing parts of the PC game to me is you build out your own home Castle right you you're like okay when I get enough money you go out and collect resources or you collect uh resource generating structures and then when you built enough you could like okay now you have to make decisions do I build a mage Tower to provide more

spells do I build this structure that will produce these specific units right like uh stable will Pro will now start to produce Pegasus on a weekly basis pegasi uh or this structure uh will give me uh walls and archery towers for defense of my castle this thing will provide more gold right you have to make those decisions and then uh every like there's set with the all-in Box the base game I think comes with three or four uh factions you could buy I think four because you could buy three additional ones we got the all-in box that had all of them but each town is different like so my town that unique to that faction yeah so if I play I think you played the dungeon faction I played the necromancers uh Dan played the tower faction we all our buildings were very different and you would take a little tile put it on your little player board to represent that that building is now built it's super cool uh it's like what what decisions how do I want to upgrade my town and then my heroes out dancing around the map and fighting different things uh super cool ambitious game that's very very faithful to The Bard like as much as I think I could ask for you know like in uh of course this deck building the original PC game wasn't a deck building game the deck building was clever I how they Institute that I really like that because both your spells and sort of like cards that affect battle but also your like uh skills are they skill cards yeah so like you have everyone has basic four uh attributes uh your attack uh your

defense your pow which is like your spell power your knowledge uh those translate differently into the board game similar field though yeah but it could you you would play like an attack card would help you enhance other cards and things like that for attack and such so uh again it's like not one to one but like pretty close so which leads us to what we didn't like and I'm going to go first cuz I had to deal with this uh this is the worst rule book I've ever ever read I hated it I was like constantly frustrated and confused and I didn't I was like what why didn't they would intro they would mention or reference a concept that they haven't yet introduced or Tau to you yet until later things aren't quite in areas where they uh that they aren't intuitive in terms of how the things are laid out or organized uh I just hated this rule book it was so bad I I went on Board Game Geek um to look at to research more into this I saw that uh the community specific there's one person and then he worked with the community to redo this role book and then I saw he had a huge Manifesto about why he did it uh he's just like here's all these problems I'm like yes yes yes yes yes so they redid it uh they had a giant GitHub repository of notes from the community they fixed a bunch of things uh made it make sense and then as as I was reading through through that version of the RO book I'm like yes that's what that's the thing I was missing that's the thing I couldn't

find and that makes so much more sense um but our printers broke in so I'm like reading this through the iPad so bottom line is our first game took uh three of us almost eight hours to play uh a lot of some of that is because I put in the expansion tiles which like like this made the game bigger than just the base game we did pick the most basic scenario that they recommended that you start with so we did we I didn't go like let's pick a really crazy scenario it was a small map there's a lot of like okay I know where this is in a normal rule book I can I find it there can I scroll through my iPad to get to page 35 need to be faster at scrolling know it was I if I if you read the forums on borang gek you'll know that I'm not alone in this uh it was just absolutely awful so it took way too long to and it got to the point where when we're done no one had a bad time it just took way too long uh 8 hours like we someone on I think uh on social media when I posted about this uh someone I think on threads one of our followers said they only got through 3 4 hours and they were like not even halfway done and they were like they quit it just they didn't know it was going to take that long they couldn't do it for another 3 4 hours so it's definitely out there it's definitely a problem it's to the point where I don't think I would ever play this game even with other Heroes of my magic 3 fans like I had a lot of friends when I posted about yeah they were like oh I love the PC game like can I play this with you can I play this with you I'm like I don't want to teach it to you I I'm just going to

play with Dan or Christin again and maybe not even Dan uh maybe just Christina one-on-one because yes I beat Dan it's a shorter it'll be a shorter more manageable game we both know the rules it'll be because here's the other thing every time you get into combat it's always between two parties so it's either between you and a neutral creature on the map or you and another player there's always another player who's not participating and then they have to wait out this potentially 10 15 minute battle maybe not 15 minutes but like 10 minute battle where you're playing what cards and deciding what to do and attacking if you're playing a neutral against a neutral character uh the the opponent takes care of that that's still somebody sitting up yeah so it's like I don't think I'd want to play this even three players no so if you want to play it with Shu you will have to learn the game yourself is the takeaway from that uh but yeah it was very very long uh I would say also like I had uh you know I posted a picture about it and then somebody asked like oo a dungeon call is this fun so I had to ask them have you played Heroes of mind magic 3 the PC game and they hadn't so I was like I just I can't recommend it I I think that I think the gamepl is fun because there's just some really great attraction to this to the hero system in general it's just so satisfying to build out your castle and your units and go battle and stuff so it is fun but I don't think that the the burden of learning it is worth it if you don't have the Nostalgia for it so if you have the Nostalgia for it yeah you know go ahead and learn it and see can convince

sh to play with you but I I I don't think it's worth it if you've never played Heroes before yeah I think that's well said so but we loved it so got to try it at least one more time so next we have a way smaller game going from a gigantic Heroes 3 to this small set of card games from button shy Des signed by our friend Peter C Hayward called converge so there are three different sets currently available for converge we have catalysts of change Sparks of Hope and engines of progress each of these wallet games is a self-contained game so you can play it it's two-player 1V one game where there are three factions per wallet essentially and so these three factions uh come out in this deck where you are trying to play cards um each turn of this route of a game is very very quick your choice when you get that card is you're either going to play it into your Tableau as one of your in in your faction essentially uh or you could play it for the other team if you wanted for various reasons um you can also play it in the middle as a goal but you have to watch out because every sing after every turn which is one card played from each player we evaluate the goals to see if anybody has outscored the other right yeah they're common goals for both play it it still works for the other player M and then the third choice is you can play this card for its ability right you would discard it you play it for its ability that can twist the game in lots

of ways it could swap cards like the goal cards and a card from your hand it could take a card from the discard back you know there's all these different ways for it to interact but what's really smart about it is for each of these three factions um the call skill set we're the factions we're the factions there's three skill set skill set so they could be Alchemist or they could be healers or different things like that they're all numbered 1 through six in their own skill set and then uh the the numbers are the same and for each faction the ability is the same so you don't have to parse through like every card is super unique but they interact in really really fascinating ways so once you've learned a skill set then you know okay from now on this could do this ability and there's all these different ways to like in this constant quick struggle to outsmart your opponent basically yeah it's a really smart game for how what it is just the 16 or 18 cards or so uh it's like literally really quick I play card you play card and then we see if anyone has won that round and then if it if you have the artifact and I win I take the artifact if I win again so if you win back basically back to back then you win the whole round and it's best two out of three rounds so it's really fast in that way but a little bit of analysis process cuz when you're sitting there and it's like okay Christina just played this move that if I don't react to it she's going to win then you you there are those moments where you're like okay

what do I do what do I figure out and it gives you so many things to think about because yeah three cards they all have different discard powers or can I change the goal and make it so Christina doesn't win or that we at least tie and move on to another uh set of turns and things like that so it's just so so simple with really deep decisions to make uh it's just I think it's uh out of the games I played from Peter uh it's my favorite design by far it's it's just well I'll probably play French toast a lot more than I'll play this game because it's one of my favorite party games um but this is just such a smart smart design uh and I'm just really impressed with like man you just every like so many cool decisions to make it for just to play one card it's like one card can do mean everything so much in 18 cards and yeah although there's like all of this little bit of analysis where you have to figure out like oh wait what's the best move for me here it is also a limited Choice set which really helps because again you only have three cards to choose from and so there's uh there's like limited ways to uh to take advantage of that but when you do it's really really rewarding uh we I normally don't really we don't normally play two-player games that often but we really really like this in one day we played through all three sets because we were having such a good time and wanted to see all the different skill sets um when you play them all too you can recombine them in different ways and have three fa three different factions

and play a sort of more unique game than the you take skill sets from different sets and combine them yeah so there's a lot of potential there and even within a one set there I can see it playing out super differently every single time CU obviously we played you know usually two three um three round three games per round to see who would win or three rounds best two out of three first to two so if you like one thing about the game what is it I really liked how quick it was to learn but also the the the like agonizing decisions so it really strikes that really good balance the push pull of how you want to play those I love my agon agonizing decisions in board games yeah yeah I I like that too I like that you feel really smart if you could make the right move but there's so many things that feels like it just feels like we're just taking big swings at each other right it's like Christina will play something that feels like she's want it she's basically has want it with that card and then I have to play a card to like can I counter that or change the conditions to where now it's not no longer she not winning but maybe I'm winning you know it's just like really swinging in great directions like that but in a very satisfying way that doesn't feel cheap because we both have access to it feels very balanced because it's not like I'm playing one skill set they're all available in the deck So eventually we all have access to these powers and it's like how do you twist it to your

advantage yeah so I like the one card feels so significant and you could do so much but it doesn't feel cheap ever because the other person is just going to do the same thing back to you right it's like you're like I got it you know like nope she's going to play something really big and completely changes everything and I'm on a completely different path to Victory uh from just 5 seconds ago so I I really like that about the game mhm and the different factions their ability is very different each time skill sets skill sets very different each time so uh really loved exploring those and seeing how they might combine in different ways when I combine them in a different way mhm if you had to pick something you didn't like about the game what would that be I don't know I I think it's I only well I've only played it I guess each set once uh and I see myself carrying it around a lot for travel cuz they're so tiny like most butt button shy games are uh I don't really have an issue with this game yeah I I think it's it is that where it's almost like that Checkmate scenario or check or Checkmate scenario where it's like oh I think she's got this and I don't think there's a counter but then I could still take a long time to get to that conclusion and there was one time where I'm like I evaluate every card I'm like does this discard help me does this goal help me does this do this this do this and there's some cards that might say activate the power of this other card somewhere and so you have to look at these other cards and say well any of those help me and I run through that exercise and like I think you want so kind of like I think that very very

last step before you give up or you know that you can't counter it and you have to let the other person win can take a while if you're stubborn and you're like I don't want to give up I don't want to give this to her and let me eval every possible F it's fine there was literally one time where I'm like I don't have it I don't I give up and I would just like let her look because then it becomes kind of a fun puzzle of like okay do you have anything can and she's like do you officially give up you're you you've given up you uh uh lost this round I'm like yes and so she'll look at my cards and try to help me she's like yeah you lost but it it's kind of fun there was once where you just hadn't noticed this one card it could have stayed alive don't know if you there's one time I made a mistake and and gave up two early there's like one specific move but anyways there's a there's a lot to think about but uh really cool game and such a small package yes really like this game great job Peter he did not pay us to say any of that so he did give us a free he gave us these games so which going to use and our final game is I guess older compared to the other ones we're looking at um this is Evergreen and this is published by horrible games designed by helmar hawk so the designer of this game also designed photo synthesis which has been an ongoing bone of contention game between me and Shu every time we tried to purge he always pulls out that that one game of photosynthesis and I'm like nope push it back in cuz I don't want to sell it because it's beautiful it's about photosynthesis sort of um the so the original photosynthesis game was

more of like an economy game with all of these trees with like four different sizes and acorns and they would grow in different ways and block the light from all these different directions and uh I acknowledged it was not the best game but I liked having it in our collection for a very long time it's a really pretty box beautiful box like this this one tree standing in this Grove with a beam of sunlight shining on it and it looks pretty on the table because you make all these 3D cardboard trees of different varying Heights and colors so it looks really neat but it's actually an abstract economy game so uh but I was finally ready to sell it because of Evergreen so from the same designer uh I think this just takes some of the main ideas from photosynthesis where you are scoring off of how much light these different trees can absorb um and then also how big your Forest is so those are some of the two main aspects of scoring in Evergreen the newer game and it just Smooths it out so much so instead of like four different tree sizes whatever it was now you only really have two sizes um so you have like a Seedling and then a small tree and a big tree and you build that out onto a double layer board where you're just sort of laying the mount to this Forest essentially um way smoother game play I would say there are cards now that sort of designate on your turn you're going to draft a card that will give you uh a biome that you can grow some stuff into like maybe some new seedlings or grow a small tree into a

big tree whatever you need to do and then it comes with like a secondary effect and the cool part about drafting that card is you can use its do its regular growth in that biome but the secondary ability when you take that also Powers up that secondary ability so as you you know maybe build out a bush like the first time you build a bush you get one Bush and later you might be able to plant two bushes as your additional action so it rewards sort of building a small little system also and bushes will help you build a bigger Forest without collecting light so there's all there's like a really interesting way to build out this this tree system that you have going where you need to watch out for as the sun sort of goes from different angles like can we maximize the amount of light that you're collecting cuz that's points and then I also want to grow a big Forest which is another major source of points per round and there's isn't one of the bonuses just points too I think what anyways there's a lot of ways to oh yeah one of the secondary yeah one of the secondary actions yeah so um in photosynthesis too if you're familiar with that game there's uh the sun is represented everyone's building on a common board and then you're moving the sun around and it's going to different things will block your trees May block other people and there's like six different positions for the sun uh I really I didn't that's one of the things I didn't like about photosynthesis because I'm like it's kind of hard to plan and strategize because different things will be kind control but uh photo or in Evergreen you

have your own board that you're working on so you don't have to worry about what other people are kind of doing you're just competing to outscore them I think that's a great change and then the now having a sun in only four positions uh around the board Al is a great change because it's like it's much easier to kind of figure out what's going to block what in an or kind of in the cardinal directions versus like six different positions of like rows and uh diagonals and all this kind of stuff so it's streamline but the scoring is better it's just I think it's a better game overall and it looks very different too but very cute in its own way cuz they're just like little tree kind of wooden pieces wooden meeples little little uh uh what are they called the seedlings and the bushes and stuff so it looks really abstract but kind of in a cute friendly manner with a really light kind of minimalist art so I really like how this game looks and it plays so much better uh so I would definitely recommend this over photosynthesis if you're looking for this kind of forest growing uh economy kind of Base game yeah what another really cool aspect about it is when you draft the card for your main action there will always be one final card left over and that tree that that card is going to go into a fertility Zone where it's a point multiplier also at the end for any large trees in those biomes they will count for however many fertility symbols are in that biome so that adds a really interesting aspect too when you're

drafting like do I want to leave this biome hoping that it'll Ender in the fertility zone or do I take it away because I want it you know so there's a there's all these tiny little twists that are not you know making it much much heavier but add some fun strategy to it and plays really smoothly yeah yeah so one thing that you liked about the game um I really like the trees I don't know I just the the whole gate like the way that the scoring system works makes a lot more sense I think um and then there the planning for it is a lot more intuitive so I just think it's a much more elegant smooth game now and I and I finally gave out photo this y mm yep I agree the same thing I think it's a better game as I said and uh it's very smooth I think even if you know nothing about photosynthesis right it's an older game sure um ignore it don't worry about it you don't need to play honestly on its own it's it's it's a it's a good solid game it's like it plays really well and it's just very satisfactory to play out and lay everything out so love everything thing that you didn't like about the game um what do I not like about this um I played it on BGA first for quite a few game marinaa with Eric of Eric play what's Eric playing what's Eric playing and uh it was it like you know the big thing there was I didn't bother reading the rules for a while so um so I sort of learned the game by playing and making mistakes and stuff um but that I I don't

really have um a negative to that because at the more I played the better I did get but it wasn't too Sy each time so I did play it a ton on on board game arena and in person now um and it's been sort of unique depending on how the cards come out so I I still enjoy it even though I didn't know the rules when I firstes okay so that's interesting because my criticism initial criticism I think would be with the map feel to saman as after a while because uh your map the different biomes that Christina mentioned they all uh it's not symmetrical they all kind of fit together in different ways and I I wondered immediately as soon as I saw this game like would this map start to feel kind of syy after a while because you can only do your main growing action in the biome that you draft a card from so the way the cards come out H changes your build every single time I think uh so and you can also have a different variation where instead of starting with the sun in the same position for everybody they can start in different directions and that can add some even more variety to how you build it out cool mhm so Evergreen uh from last year I think but worth it if you are into tree growing and uh a nice elegant game design cool so we managed to get through seven games uh pretty well I think in about an hour in about an hour so not seven hours great job us um thanks so much for listening if you have questions you know reach out to us we're on all

the things we're on X Twitter threads Instagram Facebook so however you want to Blue Sky also yeah um ask us about these games tell us what you like and thanks for listening thanks to our favorite editor Mike Zipkin and uh now you can stop listening and go play a game bye

Progress saved