Can Theme Redeem Two Similar Games? | TABLEscraps #54
Transcript
today's topic oh honey I totally don't already have this game welcome to table scraps short discussions about word card and people top gaming submitted by the viewing audience and discussed with the viewing audience hey there are one welcome back to another episode of table scraps the show where I a live stream with the studio audience here on YouTube to discuss a topic about board and card and tabletop games and the topics themselves are submitted by the viewing audience as well and today is no exception because today's topic comes to us from viewer Pierre Allard who asks hey everybody I think I have a topic idea that concerns a lot of gamers and I hope you're right Pierre because we're gonna use it on today's show he continues would you keep - mechanically very similar games just because you like both themes you know maybe you think that you already have too many dudes on the map games but this private game seems really awesome if you hesitate between Ziya and merchants and Marauders and you think that Ziya might be a superior game but you prefer pirates or you can't get enough deck builder so you just buy them all what do you guys think hmm well I'm glad you asked for that Pierre because we're about to let you know what we think would I keep two games that are basically mechanically very similar if I liked the different
themes well I think the best answer to that is to give you a practical example because I brought a couple games here with me today I went out and I got a copy of this game divinity derby which is all mechanically a lot like camel up to me and I went out and I got this game after I gave away my copy of camel up to a friend who was using it as a gateway game to introduce their in-laws to board gaming but it left me without a young camel based racing game so then I came across divinity Derby which has kind of different mechanisms but the similar idea you have things racing around and you're trying to place bets on which ones and you're trying to slip up your opponents and everything then eventually camel up came back into but now by this time I had a racing game already I had a crafty loopy strange racing game so when camel up came back into print I of course went and I bought a new copy of it wouldn't actually I've got my new copy just like four days ago I haven't got out of the shrink yeah it's not new but um I made a decision that even though I now had a replacement wacky racing game I still went out and got good old camel up because it's a great racing game a great introduction and so even though the two games mechanically are very similar even though divinity a derby is printed sideways apparently even though the two games are mechanically very similar I felt that there was definitely space in my collection for both of them what there's
not space for is a space on my desk next to my mouse so I'm gonna have to move on these two games so they're right there there's my answer very practical straightforward yeah I think that if definitely there is rooms and collections for two games that are mechanically similar with different themes and some slight different mechanics even if it's the same general idea now would I go out and do this with every type of mechanism and every type of game you know probably not I think it varies from person to person and that's okay I myself don't play a ton of really heavy euros so if I got one or two of those in my collection that's probably gonna be enough to satiate me personally I'm not gonna want to get every single worker placement game in the world and if I did get a third one I would probably consider perhaps getting rid of one of the others if if the themes and the feel of them were different so it probably also varies genre by genre of game as well so again that's just one gentleman's opinion fortunately we have a live studio audience here with us to share their opinions as well so let's go and see what the other people in the live chat have to say about this topic as well oh let's start off today's antics with a comment by christian.kell borg who's gonna say that i have all three realms game's hero realms star realms and Cthulhu realms but they feel very different even though it's this mechanics oh you know what the realms line excellent excellent example on that and
what's neat about that is these games they are not just carbon copies of the same game each one does kind of introduce different mechanisms and kind of go in a little different direction which is really cool to see and I think really makes them stand as independent games it's not like love-letter re skins where you have all these different reckonings of love-letter that may introduce one little new concept or something but i feel are still just a reskin of the same bloody game let's continue on to Toyota Wolff who says I have several games that are similar mechanically but are different themes for example the legendary encounter series I love them all though and also I gonna reread that I love them although also I have many deck builders I would postulate that the legendary line may actually be a little bit closer to the love-letter REE skinning side of things than these star realms each game can operate kind of independently line of things the the encounters version of legendary definitely does really spice things up the the alien ones and the predator ones where they are known as the encounters where they change a lot of mechanisms the way the enemies are introduced and the way that you have missions in the way that you you know battle the enemies and things surprises happen that definitely does change from the base legendary Marvel game and the other ones that are just basic but I think among those two subgroups I think there's a lot more similarities in those
all a love-letter than the than the star realms but what do you guys think but let's continue on to meeple Critic next who says I am much more cautious of having duplicate themes than I am mechanisms I feel that repeat mechanisms are ok if the theme sets it apart for me theme is the most distinguishing aspect of games ooh you know I think you're right it pains me to say it but I may not have been as 100% accurate as I thought I originally was before I read the words that you you know it's like music isn't it you you can have all these different genres of music switch or Ollie on themes of music if you were to apply a board game analogy to it but you're still playing that same finite set of notes you're just playing them in different ways and different methods with different instruments so the notes could kind of be seen as the mechanisms and the rhythm the tempo the instruments everything else could be seen as the theme what you do with those notes we could kind of draw an analogy you know in that way between board games and music in that you can start with a few simple core sets of rules in games in gaming case literally and build off of those with all these different themes and yeah I think there's more room for repeat mechanisms than there are for repeat themes because the themes make them so so distinguished let's continue on now with a comment from kabuki kid who is going to join us to say I
definitely have friends to have multiple versions of love love love love love letter at least they all seem to have some differences in how they play even if even if it is just very minor I've already touched on love letter so you you know my opinion you perhaps don't need all of the versions of it in your collection because the overlap just might be like playing the same game correct me if I am wrong a chat in the meantime kabuki continues I can see how some people would avoid one version over another because they don't like the theme Toyota wolf continues our conversation by saying I also just realized I have several versions of pandemic ie you rain of Cthulhu and rising tides and pandemic hoo-boy with all of its expansions and stuff I I thought at first that pandemic would go towards the love-letter version of the scale but man the stuff that they've been doing with pandemic recently the pandemic iberia I believe it was and the Cthulhu one of course pandemic legacy who they are so similar in mechanisms and theme so I'm wondering do you guys feel that they have put enough twists on the pandemic line or is the pandemic line starting to just get stale I personally wonder how long the pandemic line can continue before it starts to to its luster begins to fade but every time I think it's time has come
I realize that monopoly is still out there pooping out new versions of Monopoly you know now we have gold tokens now we have electronic banking now we have cheaters monopoly because we're completely bankrupt of ideas so what do you think do you think that pandemic has a lot of life left in it or do you think since it is one of the more newer modern hobby board games that it's actually not going to have the same type of limb javadi that old-school games like monopoly may let me know what you think's about that mmm our next comment comes from Eric who says I have both pandemic and defenders of the realm I play them with different people oh that's a really good example too because defenders of the realm with a completely different theme and but it does share a lot of those same mechanisms so right there is an example that reinforces our idea that themes may be the more important factor in board game overlap in one's collections than than mechanisms and if anyone disagrees I'll fight ya kabuki kid also mentions that Ziya and merchants and Marauders both played differently enough to allow room for them in a collection even though they're both sandbox exploration games in ships they're also sometimes when a game is strictly better than another similar game for me Axis and Allies totally replace risk for me and I've yet to play risk since and that was
in the 80s mmm I've been looking at this topic in one way but there may be another way to look at this topic you know I was thinking about really adding games into a collection you know basically doing the test of when you're evaluating a new game you know do I already have something similar enough that it is worth adding this new game and perhaps that new game would push out the old ones but how many of each distinct mechanism or do theme how many of each of those do we need in our collection what is the determining distilled core value of a game that really makes it distinct and how many of that you know do you need let me know what you think about that in the comments below our next comment comes from Mike Jones no really who says so what talisman relic and Horus heresy count I own all of these but there are differences in the mechanisms so let's not get into the number of 40k inspired games at Ione googly-eyes yeah I know that um the 40k universe has been applied to many many different games so there's one theme that covers a wide range of different mechanisms I think the answer to that question is within your post itself if I may get introspective here because the fact that you feel that there's enough variants and room for all three of those in in your collection I think right there demonstrates that the answer is yeah there is room for these I think like
with so many topics that we discuss you know the fun is just mentally chewing on the topics itself and discussing it I don't think there's a definitive answer here to this topic so I really think it's going to depend on the gamer by gamer basis so Pierre I apologize I don't have a definitive answer for you I think the fun in it is each individual gamers exploration and experience finding new games and figuring out what works for them and what they want to collect dragon fire beer drawers in to say I find mechanics make the game more enjoyable but I do enjoy a good theme so I'm kind of torn on this hmm dragon fire beard also continue to say that I enjoy my dungeon crawlers and they are similar in that aspect but having the different heroes and monsters or campaigns makes it enjoyable to me still excellent example there yeah done dungeon crawlers Wow I mean you can't you can't fall off of a chair without there being another dungeon crawler there to break your fall so definitely it's amazing to me sometimes how much every time I think that at certain genre or category or sudden set of mechanisms is satiated in the marketplace someone comes up with something that introduces a new one that people still get excited for and that's really neat to see demo weasel says Robinson Crusoe and first Martians both have the same core game mechanisms but they are different enough in flavor and flow that I'm happy to keep both in my collection I think that first Martians and Robinson Crusoe are an excellent example
Robinson Crusoe seems to be a little bit more of a refined game at this point because it's been around a little bit longer and it's been kind of revised a little bit first Martians is newer and still I think a little more rough around the edges but me personally I am drawn to first Martians more than Robinson Crusoe but yeah I would still play Robinson Crusoe and I don't know though if I would add it to my collection unless I found like a really good deal on it because to me personally first Martian scratches that itch but I can totally see between Robinson Crusoe and first Martians I can definitely see their theme and their flow and their approach to it being different enough that having having room for both so I think that those two games are prime example of this topic so thank you for bringing those up let's continue on with Trevon who joins us to say I don't know that I agree dat true Rhys kins like love letter or legendary belong in this discussion there's a difference between similar games and the same game with a different theme really no I can totally see where you're coming from Trevon and I yeah that's I do not disagree with you but what but just for the sake of this discussion just to get people to type things in the comments and share their own points of view let me ask you a question how close can different games be before they are essentially the same game there was I
cannot remember the name of it I apologize but there was a card game that was published a while ago that I believe Wizards of the coast actually brought a lawsuit against because it was basically a total and complete ripoff alleged ripoff to Magic the Gathering the the card layout style the mechanisms totally just so similar it was just like I read skinning of magic but it was a different game by a different publisher so where does that fall into this would that be a similar game or would that actually just be the same game with a different theme applied to it even though it was created by a different publisher so my point is that you say there's a difference between similar games and the same game with a different theme but I'm wondering if that implies that those same games with a different theme have to be created by the same publisher whereas I think there may be more of a gray area and and perhaps it's not as black-and-white of a statement as as it seems again I'm just saying that for the sake of discussion I actually don't disagree with you but gotta do something on YouTube so there it is just to dos water on my own argument Trevon did then immediately follow up by saying Ries kins are different than the difference between camel up and divinity Derby so perhaps Trevon before I even made my rebuttal perhaps who already addressed
my concern with that very post so yeah as seems to be the norm for table scraps episode we may have deviated and morphed the discussion a little way straying from the original question itself but I think that it's like I said it's one of these questions one of these topics that I don't think there's a black-and-white answer to it the fun in it is in the discussion and that's why I encourage you watching to continue this discussion in the comments below because I would love to know what you think about this you know mechanisms versus theme what makes a game distinctive as an actual game and how many games like that do you need in your collection before you have enough of them let me know and we'll continue the discussion from there in the meantime episodes like this are made possible by viewers just like you who've been supporting pair of dice paradises pod pledge fundraiser campaign thank you to everyone who's been supporting the channel because every little bit helps and is appreciated until next time we get a chance to get together again I've been Chaz Marlar from pair of dice paradise and I have been having a discussion with the YouTube live chat who is from all over the place literally just everywhere perhaps even out of town so until next time we get a chance to get everyone together in this location thanks I'll talk to you again soon go ahead and
start typing your comments there and I'm gonna take a minute or so to tell you what I think about this what was the question and that's why I do something on YouTube when I talk to you each game can operate kind of independently line of things and now I have a tickle on my face it's no good to do a live chat if it feels like I have a bug on my face my apologies for being gross and free think what I say next