Skip to main content
Loading video...

Board Games I Got Rid Of (And Why) - Episode 12

Transcript 18:01

hey everybody and welcome to another episode of games i've got rid of and why so this is a series of videos where i talk about games that have previously been in my collection but have subsequently left my collection for one reason or another and i'll try and explain the reasons for that decision so forgive me if i have if i get some of the um intricacies of these games wrong because i haven't played them in quite some time um at least some of these but um i'll do my best so let's get started with the first game so the first game i got rid of it is x-men mutant revolution so this was actually one of the first games i ever got when i got into the hobby purely based on the ip because i i loved x-men and this one is actually a re-implementation of another game called spartacus i'm based on this spartacus tv series so this is um a game where you are trying to acquire these different x-men obviously superheroes you're trying to get these students which have different values and you're putting them in this kind of arena combat kind of um simulation sometimes fighting each other sometimes they're fighting like a big baddie like apocalypse or something um you are auctioning to get you kind of heroes into your into your camp and competing with the different um players in different ways um you can play some take that cards on them and stuff um this one is to be honest it's not the kind of game i'd go for now anyway i was inexperienced when i got this one to the table for the first time um it's a kind of a dice chucker you're kind of reducing people's stats the more you fight them um i did like this kind of bidding mechanism as you could and the way you got new heroes and students into your camp you would

actually blind bid on them and obviously the stronger they were you could really ramp up the bids sometimes you can get bargains um but yeah ultimately i thought this game was a bit convoluted i think it went a bit long and to be honest one of the big things that i took away from this game was some of the use of the terminology this had some horrible cringy um use of language and use of words where you know coins weren't just called coins they were called hope coins and there was like revolution and oh just so many silly superfluous words that got a bit annoying to be honest um but not not my kind of game and just not a game that's going to hold up in my collection so no interest in playing this one ever again that is x-men muted revolution and next up i have xi'an so xi'an is actually a game i still recommend i think this is a lovely intro level simultaneous selection hand management and work replacement game and to honestly i would still have this game if it did have more content so i really do feel this one needs a um an expansion or just something to ramp up the complexity because it has so much that i like about this one so this is um based on the terracotta army so the idea is that you're trying to play these cards with um for different reasons so you want them for the initial value which gets you priority on giving you worker placement but also for the ability on those cards which gets you resources you paint because you're trying to erect these statues and then pick them your color to get area majority bonuses a really cool game i had some another set collection layer onto it as well as you're trying to collect weapons to

equip your terracotta soldiers i had yeah has so much i like i love that i love that dual layer card system as you know what you're going to play for your the ability and what you're going to use for the initiative i think that's a mechanism that can be explored so much further but yeah as i said it did have a glass sitting on how many times i can get this one played i didn't play it quite a lot i felt there was nothing else for me to explore and um again i think this is such an underrated jam and if you do generally or you know frequently play um work placement games and kind of gateway plus level games this one is certainly one to check out but yeah ultimately just just didn't have quite enough to keep me coming back next up i have yamatai so yamataia pretty popular i think some days of wonder a bruno cathala design this one um to be honest i hated that i really did not like this game at all and it had a lot of um variables within variables which just really did ramp up the analysis paralysis and if you are a kind of an analytical player like like i am i try to min max things as much as i can and this one it was just insufferable you could not do it after your this one you're trying to draft these different action tiles then you're building um boats onto the board either starting new routes or expanding on of existing routes trying to surround these islands and you're collecting these tokens to get unique powers um you're trying to put your buildings on these um on these islands by matching up the boats to them to get points and coins in different ways um and as i said there were so many variables in this game that did find i did find quite annoying but

also um i really suffered this one because it was so un unfriendly in terms of being um colorblind compatible um i couldn't decipher some of the components from one another and um of course my brother's color blind as well so we just absolutely could not could not play it was unplayable at times so um but i i think i've kind of discovered that i'm not the biggest fan of bruno cathala games anyway and this one just kind of solidified that that opinion next up i have half truth so half truth i really feel this is a bit of a shame to talk about this one so this is a party game that came out last year i believe in 2020 and this one is a kind of a party trivia style game as you are kind of bidding on yourself and your your knowledge of knowing quite quite a difficult question so there's going to be like um you know which um which of these people wanna want an oscar or something and then you are trying to gamble on yourself on how many of those people on this card of six different names won an oscar so three of them are going to be correct three of them are going to be incorrect and you can play it safe and just guess one or you can really gamble and guess if you can if you can get all three of them and of course if you guess more correctly you're going to get more points um so i love the idea of it i love trivia i love party games this is right up my alley and i loved everything about it the question the problem with this one was that um this was taken from a very much uh an american opinion and a perspective so a lot of these questions were not really applicable to you know british people like myself um a lot of them were about american sports which i

don't follow they're about american you know cultural kind of things which just some of it just was a bit of a disconnect and the more i played through these decks of cards that became more and more apparent and to be honest it did kind of taint the game for me quite a bit but i did enjoy this one i would escape if you do live in the states this is a great party game if you um if this is your cup of tea so that is half truth uh next up probably my most controversial game on this list this is great western trail so great western trail one of the most successful euro games of modern memory an alexander fister design set in the kind of the wild west as you're traveling around this almost a rondelle which is a point-to-point map collecting cards along the way which are represented by these different cattle are visiting different buildings and then trying to reach kansas city to trade these um hands of cattle in to get points you're traveling along this train track to go further along to get even more points you can invest in different strategies you've got a kind of cowboy strategy which can give you more mitigation of getting new cattle into your hand and increase your hand size um it had lots of roots to go down uh kind of upgradable player boards everything you'd expect in an alexander fister game and i will say upright this is a great game i do really enjoy it i think it's um certainly deserves a lot of the credit it gets um and again i don't dislike it at all i would happily play this um the reason i got rid of rid of it from my collection was because i have maracaibo so maracaibo is one of my favorite games of all time i think i i absolutely adore it and to be honest if i ever had the choice of

either bringing great western trail off the shelf or bringing out maracaibo i would 10 out of 10 times choose to play maracaibo and there's quite a lot of crossover with the game so i yeah i never would feel like i would i would choose to play great western trail if maracaibo was an option so for that reason i couldn't warrant keeping them both but still both fantastic games but maracaibo is an incredible game so uh yeah unfortunately i can't warrant i'm keeping that one uh next up i'll talk about another alexander vista game uh cloud age so cloud age i think another 2020 release this one is slightly lighter than his other designs or at least his most successful designs and this one has quite a unique theme with it where are you kind of living in this dystopian future where water is a very scarce resource and you have these kind of hot air balloons as you're traveling from city to city trying to fight off these different kind of bandits um you are building a bit of an engine to increase your weaponry or to increase your speed i'm getting points in different ways it has a bit of a narrative thread going through it as well if you want to play that way um and i did like this one um but a bit like a bit like xi'an and some other these games that i normally end up parting with it did have a bit of a cap on what you could do with this one it did feel like it it didn't quite have the breadth for the depth that a lot of the other alexander fister games do have so it did feel a little bit a little bit limless in terms of comparing it to the other games but i'm still a great designer had some good scope and again in terms of

building an engine and playing cards i've had a very cool mechanism in terms of how you get your resources in this game as you have these really cool card sleeves which i'm kind of slipping these resource cards into them and the idea is that these card sleeves obscure the view of these cards and by these clouds and you're trying to pick which resource is the most kind of um most uh most common on that card so i i really did like that system i thought it was quite a novelty that worked well in practice as well but a good game not a great game in my opinion um but i still i still did enjoy my time with cloudh and i'm actually my uh the next game i'm going to talk about is a third alexander fister game so nothing against alexander vista i do really like his games um and i do like these games but this is expedition to new dell so expedition noodle is almost a board game version of another alexander vista game called oh my goods so this is more of a resource management has an element of worker placement to it as you're trying to acquire these resources in order to achieve kind of end game objectives another game that has this story arc to it if you want to play that way as you progress into different balls introduce different cards from game to game tried to work towards different objectives this one had a really cool um a cool kind of push or luck mechanism put on top or layered on top of the worker placement where you could choose to put your workers on certain spots and almost gamble if you're going to achieve or exceed the amount of

workers or the the amount of resources you need to achieve that it's kind of a weird thing you have to see and practice i think but it was quite unique i had a good solo mode in this one that you could play pretty you know pretty quickly in terms of um how deep and how rich the game is um and ultimately i didn't find the hook with this one i did enjoy it i didn't love it um i only want to keep games in my collection that i love um and again would it get to the table again after i played my initial burst of um games of this one probably not so i enjoyed my time with it wasn't great was good but not a keeper that is expedition to new dow next up i have another game by a titan of board gaming uh design this is forum tragenum by stefan phelps so stefan feld one of my favorite designers ever i've got a ton of his games this one was probably one of my least favorite designs by him despite being nothing wrong with it so this is a perfectly fine game as you'd expect mechanically um sound nothing um nothing that doesn't work very well balanced um some cool mechanisms very dry but that's not no issue for me um but yeah this one it didn't have the magic and didn't have that that extra layer of satisfaction the extra hook to keep coming back to it so this one is kind of your traditional dry euro this one had some quite cool mechanisms though as you draw a couple of cards off of a deck which will show the tiles that you take off your individual player boards and those those tiles would show the actions you could take in your turn such as getting

certain type of meeples or something like that but as you're taking these tiles off your individual player board you're almost carving out space to place building tiles which can let you climb tracks or let you um kind of donate people or forefoot people onto this area control style mechanism in the center of the board which had a kind of a luna esque style feel to it um i did like it it was fine i still rate it you know six and a half seven out of ten but when i've got a library full of you know eight and a half nine ten out of ten stephenfeld games was this ever gonna get brought off the shelf no it wasn't um it's not the easiest game and not the quickest game to teach either so it did take a bit of an effort you needed the right group to play it because it's not the most appealing um but yeah it just it was it was fine nothing wrong with it at all um but not great again so um wasn't worth keeping but the next game is hanza so hanza i think is a really obscure and quite uh quite a fascinating little game where you i have this board of um supposed the hanseatic sea and you are moving around this communal boat from port to port and the idea is you're trying to collect these different resources and visit ports that you've invested in in order to sell these resources but for points but it had this really cool economy where if you would sell or pick up goods at certain ports if somebody was controlling that port by having more um these tokens on it you'd have to pay the money to them so it had this kind of really cool flow of currency going

around the board you'd have to you could only take one action at each port as you'd go around and you had to follow these very distinct pathways but for each kind of route your travel you'd have to pay an additional coin and you really did have to map your turns out quite carefully not to leave opportunities for your opponents because again you'd control this ship as one piece and if you moved it move it for all the other people as well so you didn't want to leave very valuable spots for people to visit and make a you know make a really great time for somebody else um i really did like the the choices here again are you going to pick up the good are you going to invest in that port so people have to pay you money and when you sell goods you're going to have to kind of dilute down your um your investment in those ports by reducing tokens on that spot um a really clever concise little game um i think the reason why this one did leave the collection was because i think despite the clever mechanisms in it the game did feel small in scope it felt a bit too contained and like you're kind of going through the motions doing the same thing and it didn't really have that that opportunity to spread spread your wings try different things try different strategies and i had a pretty distinct path to victory now that's not a negative on the game more a personal pace thing and i would say if you can pick up a copy of this again relatively unknown obscure game and you like your dry dusty traditional euros i would say give this one a look because i think it's um it's got some really interesting decisions there and it has a bit of a niche that i haven't really seen other games explore so that is that is hamza

and the final game i want to talk about on this episode is rajas of the ganges so this is another massively popular worker placement game a really bright vibrant game set in india as you are trying to place your workers um you know beating people to certain spots is great because if people jump on those spots after you they're gonna have to start paying money and i like the way in this game that everything or your resources in the game were nice so you'd use dice to do everything you'd be spending spending them to convert them into other dice you'd be buying tiles with them to build on your individual player board when you build certain buildings you get points um you could invest in certain areas to make these buildings worth more points and you build up these roads to try and connect them to the outer rims of your board to get additional bonuses a really nice gateway plus game that i think um why in fact i know a lot of people enjoy um and on top of all that i really loved the winning mechanism in this game where you would have to obtain a certain amount of prestige points and certain amount of coins which are on the same track but start from different ends and when they connected that would be the end game trigger so it was a race which is quite a different take on a worker placement game um the reason why i got rid of this one was because i really do tend to struggle with worker placement style games and i really like my work placement games to be a a level higher or at least to have that extra layer or two of strategy because i think there are so many and so many uh different types of workplace games that fit in that in that gateway plus to medium light level i'll say this is certainly

one of the best ones of that category and i i still give this all my shield of quality but if i'm gonna reach for a work replacement game i probably will reach for something like um maybe barrage or something like that something a bit more involved or sulk in the mind canada just something that's going to make the um the gears in your head spin a bit more than this one would and on top of all that i've recently acquired the roll and right version of rajas of the ganges called rajs of the ganges the dice charmers which pretty much does the whole experience just on a piece of paper so it takes a fraction of the spaces on my shelf and to be honest i think the potential for combos and things is a bit more satisfying with the roll and right version so um i would actually choose and actually recommend the roll and write version over the actual board game which again might be a controversial decision but um or or controversial statement but hey it's um it's my channel so uh that that concludes them this episode of 10 games some really good games here and again i wanted to re-emphasize that just because the game released my collection doesn't mean that i didn't like it doesn't mean it's a bad game um even though i didn't like some of them some of them i still really enjoy but um i just can't warn keeping them in um in such a limited um space or such a limited capacity for games i have in my house so i hope you enjoyed the video if you have please hit like and subscribe my channel and check out my other videos too and for everyone else i'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye

Progress saved