Making board games is harder than making video games (guest: Tim Schafer, Double Fine) | Ep 176
Transcript
Welcome to the Going Analog Show, the podcast in which an industry guest brings a game and topic to discuss. We have a very special guest today. We have the founder of Double Fine Productions, Tim Schafer.
Hello.
And Shoe is sort of the expert on Tim. They've known each other a long time. So, I'm going to throw the intro to you.
Well, you sort of just introduced him. Maybe that's enough.
Oh, yeah. That's it.
Yeah, the rest will just go to my head.
I make video games. I know Shoe from the old days of video games journalism.
Yeah. So, Tim, if you know video games, and there's a reason why he's here on a board game show, but if you know video games, Tim's responsible or partially responsible for games like Grim Fandango and Full Throttle and The Secret of Monkey Island, all these classics that I'm way too young to remember. This is way, way, way before my time.
And then And then with Double Fine, like hits like Broken Age and Psychonauts and then most most recently Kill.
Kill. Kill's a good game. A legend.
Yeah. So, in Brutal Legend, you made fun of me. You gave me crap about this because the first time you visited my place, you're scanning my video game collection and noticed Brutal Legend wasn't in the uh Hopefully it's there now. Yeah. I Yeah, sure. Um but yeah, welcome and we're There's again, there's a good reason why you're here on the show today, but what do you What is your topic for us today?
Oh, we're doing topics?
Yeah. Well, you just introduce Just introduce your topic for now.
Uh I will later we'll talk about I had some thoughts about how board games are harder to make than video games.
Ooh. And that's very interesting.
Not that I've ever made a board game, but I've tried.
So, you tried?
Yeah, yeah.
Yeah, yeah.
And this is not our normal studio.
No, that's why it will never look this amazing again. If you happen to be watching on Facebook or YouTube, we're at Double Fine Studios right now and it's this beautiful setup. We have our logo behind us. Uh yeah, I feel like I should anchor the news right now. I don't know.
Yeah, we're in soundproof room.
Uh-huh. I'm in a soundproof room.
Soundproof room, no one can hear you scream.
Yes.
This is where Double Fine streams normally, so thanks for letting us borrow your room. Like Tim organized a board game day for us because we were in town in San Francisco. So, they were like, "Let's get him on the show while we're at it." So.
And turns out, you may not remember. Do you remember you've been on our podcast from the very beginning?
and it was uh during COVID, I believe. Cuz my topic was kind of like, "Do you guys uh still like games now that there's no one to play games with?" And you're like, "We're playing tons of games."
So, you were like our episode six and maybe we had him one more time in during COVID. It's like
too young of that age.
Yeah, yeah, she doesn't remember anything.
she was in a bassinet.
So, we have some amazing game picks to talk about first. So, the first game pick we wanted to discuss was our going analog pick, which is Postcard.
Postcard from Sen-nen-sa Games.
It's a beautiful, beautiful game. Uh you are traveling through France and sort of collecting and punching out postcards as you're going through the different regions, setting up camp in different cities that have different um specialties and those stuff like that. But, the big draw for me on this game was just the entire packaging. It's uh it's just like this beautiful, sleek art that and they are postcards that I would have picked out in a postcard store, basically. So, one of the major like like mechanics in this game, you're traveling on this map, you're bicycling around, it's very cute and quaint, uh and then you're collecting these postcards with different cities and uh special locations on them. And when you collect it, you flip it to the other side and as you cycle through, you are going to be collecting stamps to either stamp the postcard or activate some bonuses as you're going around. And so, it's like a sort of combo-y, very light game, but very beautiful beautiful game.
We recently of course featured did a feature for Let's Go to France, so very different game, but both are France-ish. Very France. Very French. Very French. What did you think about this game, Shirley?
Yeah, by the way, I thought it was funny because the first time Christina played this game, she's like, "It's not realistic. People biking around France and camping." I'm like, "I'm sure people do that." She just doesn't think of France as a
Why would you camp in France?
It's very popular. Yeah. I mean, I wouldn't do it, though.
I like a posh hotel, but
Yeah, I know. Glamp it. Glamp it.
Uh yeah, it's a very charming game, especially in the aesthetics. In in the beginning, like you always get three moves a turn, so you're always trying to figure out how do I optimize that turn to camp at the spot I want to camp, so I could cover the right spots to trigger more actions, or to get the right stamps and get into the right region to deliver the proper postcards because you can't send postcards from anywhere. You have to send them from the region.
Right. Yeah.
So, a super charming game. I of my one minor complaint about it, I think is later in the game when you've kind of filled out all your different combos, now you're just like, "Oh, shoot. I'm running out of time." I thought the end game, the very end game felt a lot of I just need to get the stamps now. It's kind of like all this stuff you've been doing all game doesn't matter at the very end. It's just like filling those stamps so you could fill out those postcards and get rid of your postcards because that's the most score you can get in the game. So, I felt like the end game was a little but I also lost, so maybe I didn't play it well.
didn't do it the same way you did. So, I can see it, you know, playing out in different ways, but it is very nice light game, great introductory game for people, especially if you're playing with somebody who cares about the aesthetics. The aesthetics are beautiful on this game.
Yeah, I feel like it's a great gateway game for someone who loves the theme, right? If they're like, "Oh, traveling around France and camping." It's like in the art is just gorgeous and it's a very attractive-looking game, but it is light. It is definitely more of a gateway game for sure.
And Synapses Games did send us a copy, so thanks.
Awesome.
We have an interesting game
Basically a sequel to Postcards. Very similar, very similar aesthetic. This is Cave Evil.
Yes.
Cave Evil is not a new game. It's from like I think originally was 2011, but when I first got into board games, I was like, "Oh, I want to play you know, I played like Sushi Go." And I was like, "What's another game I can play? What do I like? I like heavy metal." So I searched heavy metal board game and this came up. And it is like the most heavy metal board game of all of you can play like Brutal Legend the board game. It's a lot like this. It All the art in it looks like it was drawn by like your stoner friend in high school on your math on your geometry book. It's just like It's really unapologetically black metal and it's just great.
Yeah.
Every hundreds of cards in here and every single card has a unique piece of grotesque evil art of something.
I can see it.
evil wizards. You can see here these are evil wizards that are summoning evil forces out of the mud of this cave that you're digging. And eventually either an evil goat will pop up or some horrible lich king or something will come to end the game. You're just trying to kill all the other necromancers and jump into the pit of a eternal pit of them. It's just very evil. It's a very evil game, but it's really fun and it's it opened my eyes up to this whole like subculture of board games which are like war games war game cuz it's kind of like a war game with hexes a hex map with little cardboard cutouts where you move them around and you also have cards with all the stats on them. But a lot of these games by this designer Nathan Hayden come in magazines. They come in like portfolios, little slim magazines and you you open them up and you lay out paper map and then you um punch out a million pieces of cardboard like you would do like people who are into war games buy buy these magazines.
They play a really specific battle in like Africa during this one war. Like then they know a lot about the history and it's a whole different world like the rest of board games and I didn't get into war game side of it, but he makes these kind of horror um uh portfolio games like one called Freakface set in a like a circus and one called Don't Let the Walls Eat Our Baby. Like it's a lot of um See Evil, which is about being on a you know evil ocean. And so they're kind of like um just these horrific but really fun over-the-top uh grotesque adventures that I recommend you check out.
Yeah. So, for people who need to do play them on the same night, Cave Evil and Postcards.
Yes. Sounds gross. Yeah, Postcards and Cave Evil.
We do need to give our listeners some variety.
on video. Couple's night date night.
So, you know, we we have added in a new feature. You were probably the second person to get it. For our guests, we just want to remind people we're also a trivia board game trivia show.
not warned about this.
No, of course not.
You invited me to be on your quiz show once and I was like, "No way."
But this is only one question.
This is why they didn't want to tell you.
one question.
But then I watched it and I was like, "I can do better than these guys."
Exactly. Exactly. But you know, we like to personalize this question to you. And one of the favor fav- famous stories on uh your biography in Wikipedia and on Double Fine was that when you interviewed for LucasArts for that job there, you famously said, "I love all of your games. I really love Ball Blazer." And that was unfortunately the pirated name of that game. It was in fact Ball Blazer. So, you know, I wanted to kick you while you're down. You're not great at remembering proper game names, right? So, this is a callback. We had this question quite a while ago.
On the Board Game Quiz Show.
Board Game Quiz Show, which you can find on YouTube. And so we asked uh at the time uh who was it? Uh Nikki and Donald, right? Who were guests on our show. We wanted to know what's the official title of this game about exploring a haunted house together until somebody turns against the group, right? Is it A, betrayal {colon} House on the Hill. B, betrayal at House on the Hill. C, betrayal at the House on the Hill. Or D, betrayal on the Hill at the House. And I've written it down. You may look at it.
the last one. Well, come on. Well, that's the trick. See, I know you are very tricksy people. Very I don't think it's betrayal House on the Hill. Could it be? Oh, this is a terrible question.
I always in my mind I always say betrayal at the House on the Hill. But it feels like it's too easy and I want to say it's betrayal at House on the Hill cuz that sounds wrong. But It's a good It's a good question. This is a great question cuz no one gets this right.
Well, he's about to He's about to get this question right.
Now, you're just leading me into this thing that I probably is wrong. So, I'll say the one that sounds the most wrong it is knowing how tricksy you two are that it's B, betrayal at House on the Hill.
Yay! You got it right.
This wasn't how much I know about board games. This is how much I know about the evil that lurks here.
He knows us too well. He knows us too well.
that does sound wrong. Betrayal at House on the Hill. I guess it's like a like an English type name for a manor, House on the Hill.
Yes.
Betrayal at House on the Hill.
We wanted to add a new one because since that original question on the quiz show, there's the Netflix show uh Hill House.
Yeah, and I'm like we could have that in there to really mess things up.
They just switched that name. They just stole that name and it's
They did.
Oh my god, I got it right. Okay, let's do the whole show. Quiz, quiz, quiz. I know everything about board games.
He knows everything about board games. Expert here. What We wanted to bring up though was to talk about your topic. And so, what was your topic again, Tim?
I had lots of suggestions, but the one I think Dan liked the most was me saying that board games are harder to make than video games. And that's totally just subjective based on me cuz I've been making board video games for like 25 years, 35 years.
So, so easy for you.
45 years, since 1989. I did like your other suggestion is like uh there are too many trick-taking games because we have an upcoming episode planned that's about all trick-taking games because there are so many. And today for your board game party, like you didn't know this, but the ones we were bringing to your party
Yeah.
I think we have four trick-taking games in there, I think.
I mean, yeah, I love trick-taking games. It's just that I like in college I used to play Hearts all the time in this apartment we all lived in. We played like one game after another Hearts. So, way back in college I used to play
the the the
Classic OG OG.
Hearts and Spades are like the classic trick-taking games. And I like I like a lot of them. I love Cat in the Box Deluxe.
Is that really the title of it?
It's the super giant one.
Uh and I I love a lot of them, but it seems like every time you see like a new Kickstarter it's like it's a trick-taking game but it's got this one twist. The cards are purple or something like one thing. I feel like I want like a lot of changes of flavor from like something really new. Like I can't think of the last time I saw like a really new feeling trick-taking game. But there's even like even like Arcs is kind of like a trick-taking game.
Yeah.
But that's kind of like it's much more to it than that. So, I think it's I think it is an interesting question, but um I mean, maybe these these things take care of themselves. They hit like a saturation or whatever and then what's that?
Eventually. Yeah.
But it's so easy to pick up and teach. And once you've taught someone in your group trick-taking, you can just always drop in a new trick-taking game. It's true.
We should have brought This is not a game about a pipe.
Mhm.
If I got that title right. I think Tim would have appreciated that, but All right. But anyway,
That's not our topic.
What is our topic?
No more talking about that. Please, if you're making a trick-taking game right now, don't fall into despair cuz I've been there for years.
We'll still play it. We'll still play it.
Yeah. We'll still play it. Um so, I've made videos for a long time. So, I have this way they're not easy. They're definitely hard. They take a lot of money and time and people, but I kind of have this process of thinking about a world I want to bring to life and putting a hero in there that has some ability, some power. Like if it's a platforming game, they can jump really high. Or if it's Psychonauts, they have psychic powers. And think about what they want to do and who's an antagonist and what are their powers. And those that's kind of how I think back and forth about uh making that world. And but as soon as you like kind of imagine the world and create the environment, you can drop a player in there and you can just start playing it yourself and just having fun and figure out what do I want to do in this world? But uh try to so getting into board games, playing a lot of board games, you naturally start to think like I want to make a board game. Surely you guys have had thoughts where you're like I want to make a board game.
And I was going to make like something that seemed easy to me like what if you do like a Sasquatch hunting game that these decks of piles of cards and you're trying to figure out where a Sasquatch is these piles and you're like you're trying to scan for it. And then I was like wait, how do you scan a bunch of cards in a pile? Like in a video game it'd be so easy to like is there a Sasquatch in there? And then make a certain, you know, uh and but in cards it's like uh I just and so this is more like they're harder to make for me cuz all things that I take for granted with like something you could program a computer is so easy to do but in cards it's like if it doesn't work in the cards, it just doesn't work and you can't like wow them with special effects.
You can't you can't just have a really elaborate cutscene and make everyone you know, you have to like you have you really have to figure out how these So I have a ton of respect for board game designers cuz um it the I have a I have like many ideas for them that to get to a certain point like I don't know how to do that with cards.
Hmm.
I don't know how you achieve that. But um someday, maybe when I retire.
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Well, you have the time to think about it.
other thing is hard about it is that with video games you could just implement it and try test it yourself and just play it and play it. But board games you have to find someone to play your horrible horrible prototype of your game.
horrible.
Yeah. And then how do you do you just make your family play it with you?
In the beginning.
Yeah. I guess so. Or you find other board game designers but then I did I did um I did a prototype for one game idea that I had played [clears throat] it with um Nick Sutner. You know Nick Sutner?
Mhm.
He's a tough audience.
Especially Nick.
Find your nicest friend. Don't start with Nick. He's nice but he's he's pretty uh
He's he's
open with his opinions.
Yes, he's very opinionated.
Let's just say I haven't worked on that game since.
We miss Nick because
Oh, do you like it? He's like huh? Yeah.
Nick did help us start this podcast back in the day, too. So, shout out to Nick.
ask him what he thought of it? Don't Don't ask him what he thought of it.
That's true. That's why we're still around. We haven't asked him. Mhm. So, but in terms of like I've seen this sort of trend of like, you know, board game things going into video games. Have you seen that sort of helping out over there or you like trying to like I don't know. Maybe Maybe for like getting that mechanic to work out in a physical game, we need you need you need to find like a good co-designer in the beginning.
Yeah. I mean, I have uh it's secret. But, I've been like I have been playing a lot of board games and those kind of mechanics have been sneaking into video game designs. And they do just help like kind of mechanically solidify the underlying um It was funny cuz uh it's really um not considered it's kind of gauche in board games to call them a mechanics.
Yeah.
Like mechanics you shouldn't cuz that's like a guy with a wrench. You have to call them mechanisms. In video games, no one says mechanisms. It's like mechanics mechanics of the game. [clears throat and laughter]
Uh or maybe I'm just wrong and no one tells me. Um
I've heard of both ways.
But, I feel like it definitely can make um that just I think it shows some a bias um on mine which is like a narrative base. Like a lot of my games are very start with narrative. And um and if people who maybe who start with more uh mechanisms uh in their game maybe would find it easier to make a board game than I would.
So, are there some board games you've played that you're like, "Man, I wish I designed that."
Oh man, that's a great question. I don't know. Cave Evil is definitely like has a lot of Brutal Legend in it and uh that would be a fun way to explore that world. But, have you had that thought of board games that you wish I've had video games where I wish like I remember when Little Big Planet came out I was like, "I wish I could Men in Black everybody and just tell them I made this game. I'm just so great."
Cuz it still like fits into what you love, right? Things like that. I guess I guess a good I mean, the any game where the rules are so elegant and simple that are like, "Oh, anybody could have thought of that." Obviously, nobody did until this one person did.
a lot of Reiner Knizia games and I cuz I like games with simple rules and uh but people will often think a simple game might be simple too. Like a simple piece of art that has like a line line art, but when I when you watch an artist draw like a simple line art drawing, it looks so easy like I could draw. But then you try doing it and you're like, "Nope." And it's like they have their years and years and years of training like learning what not to draw and like you know, it just goes into it like a writer, you know, the more time you put into it, you can get it tighter and tighter. So sometimes a really short piece of writing is much harder to make.
Yeah, yeah.
Yeah.
The uh I've always thought Codenames would be my one oh, I wish I came up with this idea because a lot of people I've seen other people do that when they play it for the first time back in the day uh few years ago, they were like, "Oh, this is so clever, but it's so simple." And then literally I hear all the time people like, "I wish I thought of that." But I just like the way it's set up. Like no one not a lot of people at least in our circles play it nowadays cuz it's a few years old now, but it's like it's infinitely replayable just with the way it's set up like the cards and the grid and everything like that and a just simple clever game. I wish I thought of that.
[snorts]
I I one thing I'm wondering since you mentioned like Cave Evil is like Brutal Legend as a board game. What if you had to pick some of your favorite video games that like what would be an equivalent in a board game for you?
[snorts]
Uh I've thought about that a lot like with Psychonauts. There's a lot of things with Dixit and then games that are about they're about subjective interpretation of art and it's like exploring a mind and minds have a lot of dream logic to them and like dream imagery which is kind of what Dixit is all about in a lot of ways. So like how would you use that to explore someone's mind? But like you know, I stopped cuz I realized how hard board games are to design.
Do you think part of it is because you're used to working with teams uh for video
do all the work for me. Absolutely true.
You're the ideas guy.
I have to just mumble. I have an idea about this game and then someone else takes it and runs with it. Yeah, yeah. I don't know you can you know brainstorm with other people. There's so many disciplines required for video games like art and design and programming and acting and stuff like the musicians and stuff that it's like you naturally are always going to talk to a a bunch of different people about your idea and they all add something to it.
[clears throat]
That's that's probably it. Where it says like a board game, it's not teams of like what like how big is Double Fine? 30 something? What 70 people? 70 people. Yeah, so you don't have that kind of team building a board game together. So maybe that's the problem.
I mean some people make video games all by themselves. For sure. And some people make but a lot of people more people make board games in like teams of one or two and then and then the art and stuff like that. I don't know. I don't make them. You know I know. I shouldn't be talking about that. Yeah. Do you find the the medium of just having physical media something like a kind of a obstacle or roadblock for you of like having to think that way even though you're a board gamer or is that generally not the issue? And the physical media is so accessible. You can find all sorts of stuff down on the internet of like cards, blank hex tiles. You can amass a fun little tokens to get together be like this could be a game and that's part of the inspiration. I think is like like do you have a box of old bits at your house? Like I have a box of like cuz when you deluxe a game you don't want to throw away that I used to even keep old cardboard coins. I should forget all those but like wooden meeples that became like 3D printed pieces. You can't throw away a wooden meeple and it goes in this box and like someday I'll make my own board game using all these amazing meeples that are in this box. I've never looked in that box but I think the physical like table presence to me is like one of the most appealing things about a game. Anything that catches my eye is like what is that game? It looks so cool on the table. And so I think working with the physical part is actually part of the appeal as opposed to um video games and that's what when you guys first started it was like going analog. I always thought that was interesting because there was this you know explosion of of board games but also within the video game community. I think a lot of people who play video games got ear like started to amass those giant board game collections in their offices. And I was like, why is that? Like people just after like a digital lifetime, do they just crave touching like a little
meeples and you know, do they just and being around a table with people and stuff? Yeah. So,
I think so.
I think it's part of it This is not all of it, but part of it's like I used to love like couch co-op games, right? Or couch you know, competitive games. So, like old days like GoldenEye 007 or Mario Kart and everyone getting together and having that camaraderie and that everyone laughing together. And the more games that shifted online, you get a little bit less of that. Even though it becomes more accessible and anyone could play online games now, but you don't get that same personal feeling. But board games help you kind of recapture that. That's why I think I think that's part of it for me why I've been drawn to board games.
People just love touching stuff and messing around with fiddling with things, right? We played a really simple simple game that we gave my nieces this little Pusheen Pusheen is like cartoon cat. So cute. Everybody loves Pusheen. Yeah, yeah. For people who don't have it. And it's literally just this tiny little stacking game, but they just loved it so much because it's adorable. You stack this little sloth sideways or face up and then just had a great time with it. And then they could just add into their Legos afterwards. So,
sort of the job.
What's the furthest you've gotten on a board game design?
Can't tell you. It's a secret. But I've I've I ordered the cards. I've drawn on the cards like the the thing and I probably showed it to Nick Sandner. So, that's the furthest probably. And then he killed my dreams. So, it's over.
Thanks, Nick.
Yeah. But do you see is it really that where you're just like you're discouraged and now you give up on it? Or is it do you think there's some things that like they're still sitting in your mind and then you want to revisit?
It's sitting I mean this is a big topic of like creativity and they probably ADHD and probably all sorts of things like everyone's side project, you know? It's like you getting to the I watch a um Stonemaier Games uh guy talk about recently how he got started and how he used to think I need to retire in order to write this novel or something. Like I need to I need this big chunk of time. And then he's like I learned to just take 2 hours a night to work on his novel and then he got the novel done and then he turned that energy toward games. It's like that's the next step I think uh has to take that discipline to like work on something a little bit every night I think is So it's really more about about uh focusing
Consistency.
and consistency more than like board games itself. It's just any anything like that like you cuz you're going to hit a stumbling block when you hit a board game and or you're going to write a screenplay or anything. Like you hit this thing like you don't know what what the next step is and you either go and take someone to lunch and talk to them about it or you do write it in your journal or something like that. There's There's ways to get past it but it's really easy to just put it on the shelf forever and just go back to work on your your day job.
Yeah. So like in terms of that stuff I just feel like we've had a lot of designers on our uh podcast before and they just find a really good sort of playtesting group where where like other designers where they playtest each others and can give some feedback. So might be a thing to think about. I'd want to play a Tim Fesler
You're in San Francisco cuz uh we're now in LA and then there's a lot of that where there's specific events that are all playtesting and when we have some of our big game day parties where we'll have like five, six, seven tables running at the same time and we have some game designer friends come over. They're always bringing prototypes to cuz this is like there's a house full of new people to run this by and get new opinions and new looks at. Uh so every designer just like inevitably they'll bring their prototype design over to play. But you being in San Francisco I'm sure you get access to that. So I'm sure the playtesting part where getting people to playtest is not difficult. Plus you're the boss here.
They don't have to say they have to like them.
Yeah. Or they have to play it at the very least play it.
You just balance it. Every one Nick Sattner opinion you get like five yes people to say they like it then
you just work in between the two, you know?
Yeah. And the thing is I feel like my ideas get stuck before they're testable. Like just making it functional, making a game loop like functional with the cards and just it's it's I I have a lot of respect for people who can do it.
Mhm.
[clears throat]
Yep. Just make a stacking game. We'll be good. Okay, right.
I did I did try to make stacking with chess but was that I forget it.
I'm giving away your all your secrets. It's coming. It's coming, right? So thanks so much for joining us today. We had a lot of
fun talking.
Those are good times. Um one I'm excited to one day play a prototype from you.
Okay. Someday.
Yeah. And then now, you know, we have Kiln coming out like that.
actually Tim gave us a code I but I've been so busy last 3 weeks I haven't had a chance to play it. I told Tim I'm like I'm going to have time in the next 2 weeks. Finally I can get online and play that.
And then you make Kiln. So you make pottery and then they fight.
This is where we do our live stream. Sell pottery on the floor over there.
Oh. We just fight with that pottery. Great. Where do people follow you, Double Fine?
Uh I'm on Blue Sky, Tim of Legend. I'm Tim of Legend in most places. doublefine.com you can and Double Fine is also on Blue Sky Instagram. Uh that's where we are.
All right.
Tim of Legend, by the way, a little pretentious uh or is there a story behind that? Do you think it's not accurate? I don't understand.
I never even occurred to me people would think that cuz it was that I Twitter was really like came into being when I was promoting Brutal Legend. So it was just Tim of Legend. Promoting Brutal Legend and that's all it was. I didn't realize that. That's what makes so much sense. Yeah, I'm like it's I'm like yeah, I'm like that's not very like Tim to be like Tim of Legend, that's me. But I think it's very accurate. It's fine. Uh you got to promote yourself. Yeah. Okay. There's no place for humble people in this world. It's just cutthroat. That's his problem. Right. Too humble. You can give yourself a pat on the shoe. Right?
At least like a high heel shoe or something.
Oh, damn the high heels?
Yes. Mhm.
If you could see under this table, you would know I were wearing
Thanks so much for listening. Thanks to our amazing editor who actually helped us set up today. So, thanks Mike Zipkin. And you can stop listening and go play a game.
All right.
Bye.
Bye.