Skip to main content
Loading video...

Episode 88: Justin Bell, Contributor with Meeple Mountain - Kitting out your Board Game Experienc...

Transcript 1:28:14

Time itself is testing you. In Take Time, the newest cooperative game from Liolude, you and your team must think together, but act in silence. Each clock is a new challenge. Play your cards wisely and master 40 evolving tests with unique rules and twists. Discover 10 mysterious rules brought to life through stunning poetic illustrations. Discuss, decide, then trust each other as silence takes over. Take time. Embark on a tactical and poetic journey. Hello and welcome to episode 88 of the Board Game Geek Podcast, where we geek out about board games, the mechanisms behind them, and the people who create them. I'm your host, Amanda Panda, and today I have with me Justin Bell. Most likely you know him from Meeple Mountain. How are you doing, Justin?

I'm doing great. So, uh, I'm a contributor for a website called Meeple Mountain. We are, I think, the best written content on the web for the tabletop space. Uh, and we're led by Andy Matthews and a fantastic team of about 15 or so regular contributors. I I write about 150 to 180 pieces a year, give or take. And I've been with Maple Mountain now for about 5 years. I'm based in Chicago, but to your point, I've probably met a lot of people listening to this show if they've been at other conventions from gosh going to Can for the Festival International Deja to uh Gen Con Indianapolis every year, Shiel in Essen, Germany, kind of all over uh even small conventions like tracks, the 18X convention that happens uh outside of Denver, Colorado. So, yeah, excited to be here. I feel like you and I met at a show, I'm sure, many years ago, and it's been great to to always see you whenever we go to the same convention. So, it's great to be here today.

Yeah. And then we started working together on the Five by podcast.

That's right. Yeah.

Which is pretty. And I love the mission of the Five by too. And it's it's been really

It's been fun to be a part of that group in part because I I feel like I have a a radio face, if you will. And so having the chance to do

to do uh podcasts and things like that are a fun a fun gig. So so yeah, I love that team too.

I'll have to have you on my Twitch live stream so that everyone can see how there's cameras there. I don't know. We'll see about that one. Yeah.

Now I'm surprised can film festival like is there four games? What brought you to can?

Yeah, exactly. So that show is essentially the Gen Con of France

and I do a lot of work with some of uh the other French publishers particularly that are part of the Achette publishing line and they were like you should come out at some point to go and and check out the show and I did and it was great. Um it was just a great chance to go somewhere else. Certainly I'm not only not a movie star but I have no future in the movies. So it was fun to be a part of going to a board game convention but in a famous place. The food was a lot better also in can than it was in Indianapolis. So that it's got that going for it. The fun thing about that show, I had the chance to meet Fabio Liano at that show. He was demoing a game that was kind of an unknown at the time called Shackleton Base, A Journey to the Moon.

And so I met him. I talked to him for a few minutes. We got pictures and they sent a copy after the show. And and from there I was like, "This is going to be one of my favorite games of the year." And it was. So it's just a great chance to go and see a new place, meet some new people. Um, and the French were reasonably nice to me, which I didn't expect.

So, it's not during the film festival. This is just in the same place as the film festival.

Yeah. Okay. I think it's in late February of each year.

I never knew about that. There's so many cons going on throughout the year, throughout the world. That That's really cool. Now, you started at Meeple Mountain February 2021. Did you do other stuff in the industry before that?

Not in the industry. You know, I think I'm lucky in Chicago, we have a couple of gaming groups. Uh, and a big shout out to the Wednesday gaming crew that I I play with uh here in town because a lot of those players are also either established or burgeoning game designers, play testers, what have you. And so I think in terms of industry contact, that's probably where it started for me. That was probably about 15 years ago. I'm a lifetime a lifelong gamer, so I've been playing games forever. But in terms of industry, no, I really didn't start in the industry until postco.

A lot of us started

Oh, yeah.

in the industry during co. So, yeah.

Right. I didn't have that much going on, right? I'm lucky. I have a pretty good social circle. I I feel like my club days are mostly behind me, but CO reset things quite a bit. And so, now I'm a part of now four different gaming groups here in Chicago. So, it's been great to, you know, have some chances to play a lot of different kinds of things. And now that I'm a reviewer, new games seem to show up regularly. So, it's easy to engage with those groups here in town.

I like that. Now, if you didn't know, he's been on the BG podcast before with Candace on episode, I think 30, and I'll put a link to that in the in the description. So, I don't want to really go over some of the same things, but I always ask the question, what is your favorite game mechanic? M you know I think that that um especially now like if you're catching me today and I'm thinking about that. I think right now it's hand management games.

Okay.

So um I really love the brass system of games. U so a mix of Age of Industry, Lancasher, Birmingham. I know Pittsburgh is coming. Hey Roxley, please call me please.

Um, and so those games I love in part because I really love those tense decisions that come from, okay, I got a few cards here. What do I do? Um, and that mostly scales into heavier game design. So,

Hijgemony, Lead Your Class to Victory was a favorite of mine. Was my number one game actually from 2023, maybe whatever year that came out. Voidfall is another one that I really love and that that it's incredible how tense those decisions on Voidfall are as well. There's there's a massive system tied to it, but then you're like, I have nine cards. What do I do? Right. So, I think games like that are are quite interesting. I think if I had to pick a second one, it's some mix of shared incentive systems, which is also a game like Brass, but lately the Nucleium system is another game system that I'm really enjoying. Um, and I know there's a new map coming here in the next few weeks, but I I really love the nucleium system as well. So, um, those are probably some of my favorites right now. Although, if you looked at my collection of not many, maybe I'm I'm a small collection guy when it comes to my other peers in this space, I have about 200 games in my collection. Um, it runs the gamut from from quick guard games to uh, 18xx titles to really heavier stuff um, like like Voidfall and other things like it. So

yeah, I just made a very shocked face because as a content creator reviewer, you don't hear that they have only 200 games in their collection.

I I push very hard. It's funny you say that because you're so right. Most people I know in this space have many hundreds of games. Mhm.

I am not a hoarder.

And so whenever I finish reviews of games, I typically give most of those games to the people in my review crew because I just don't I don't have the space and I think it's just it's a great honestly payment for those people. I drag them through the coals for some games that are great and some some that are not great, right? So I like being able to give those games away. We had a giveaway from that um from that pile of the Essen and and Gen Con games last week with my team and I gave over a hundred of those games away to the group. It was just like, "Guys, take them. They got to go. Just take them all. Just get them out of my house.

There's more games coming."

Yeah. So, if you live in Chicago, maybe join one of his groups. I'm kidding.

Come on out. Yeah. You love playing. We got room.

Yeah. Wow. That's That's really good. I I I I applaud that because that rarely happens. I'm such a hoarder. Uh I definitely need a call. But yeah, I've I've met some people that are really good at keeping their collection of games in a more strategic, you know, more of a I will play these games. These are not games or props for later content.

Right. Yeah. That's what you see. I mean, for those who are listening, Amanda and I can see each other and and Amanda knows there's essentially nothing behind me, right? I don't have this big closet of games that you can see behind me whenever I'm on I'm on camera with for these things cuz I just don't have a big collection.

I bet your family likes that the games are not taking over their home, too.

Not only do they love that I mean, they love that part.

Yeah.

But they also love that my habit of just buying a bunch of games is mostly over now that I create content. So, this family saves a lot of money through review copies that come in because I used to be that guy, right? Before I was in the industry, I buy a lot of titles, play less. Right now, I'm really fortunate to be able to to cover games in this way because I'm a reviewer. I'm not maybe a traditional content creator in that way because I play a game three to five times before I write a review. Um, and so I get the chance to play the games a lot more than maybe others do right now before I I push the games out of my collection. And I think that that as I look forward to 26, it's been it's been great to think about the year because I'm trying to do a little bit more of the write a lot of reviews. I think last year I I published about 175 pieces, right? So almost every other day I'm putting something up, but really get having the chance to explore relationships. I wrote a piece last year on a visit I did to Mine Clash Games and their studio because I wanted to get a sense of like what is it like to like work at a board game company? Mhm.

So I'm trying to do more things like that, more interviews, just more things beyond just reviews and I have good relationships right now with people in the industry. So it's been fun to to explore those.

Yes. I think that the relationships that we have with each other and with the publishers and the marketing people and the designers and all the people in the industry are basically the driving force at least for me and board games is such a analog connecting way for you to connect with people that relationships are very very important in this in this industry and if you don't have a good reputation that's also a big hit on you but Yeah, if you want to get into the board game industry, relationships are definitely a very important part for you to

massive massive. No, I agree with you. And I think I think that that's where outside of of tabletop, I do learning and development work for a consulting company. And um [snorts] I I joke with with colleagues that I seem to do better whenever we do things in person at events where we have the chance just to spend a lot of hours beyond just the workday

learning about each other and catching up and and just getting a feel for who people are beyond the work. I think tabletop is the same to me. I I've really had a blast. I mean, people who know me closely know that my favorite time of the year is going to to Essen for Shiel because there are parties on the on the exhibit hall floor every evening for industry folks. And so I just I love it cuz I those four or five hours after the show each night are where I build the most connection and and um it's always fun to see a lot of now longer time friends through those those connections. So it's good.

Yeah, that was what surprised me at Essen and I loved it. Um it was just very interesting and there was quite a few of them that I was like wow this can go for a while and most conventions are so busy like you have 10 15 minutes but with someone at most maybe unless you go out to dinner with them. Having that time afterwards to hang out is just wonderful. And I do love when you have the the content creator reviewer press events where you can go and hang out with other people that you know who do similar work and just play games and eat and chat and it's just a lovely time. But there's always too many that you're like staying an hour here and then moving on. You know, you're doing the the reviewer crawl, I guess.

Well, it's a lot, right? Mhm.

I think even now when I go to these things and a couple people who who they'll they'll know who I think they'll know who I'm referencing when I I say this, but like now when I go to shows I I make sure to see the same 10 to 15 people at every show, right? Because we've gotten friendly and I really want to make sure I carve out the time to spend with those individuals because yeah, just I I love them, right? It's it's it's gotten to that point. And I I think that um I don't go to as many shows. I feel like you and some others go to many more events than I do or you got the California Connection or the New York thing or some other some other bits. I only go to two or three shows a year cuz I have limited amounts of vacation to spend to go to tabletop activities and I have a family. Um so I really want to make those three or four weekends really count. So I'm I'm pickier than others on on making sure I carve out the time. And and you're probably doing this now, too. When I go to shows, this is probably advice for those that are thinking about entering this space in content creation or just the media in general. I really don't spend much time talking about the upcoming catalog when I go see publishers. I spend less time doing that. I mostly set up half an hour, hourlong meetings with contacts, with publishers, with designers simply to catch up on life. It's mostly a social activity. And so the guys from Horrible Guild know this because I love that publisher quite a bit. It's an Italian publisher, King's Dilemma. They have a lot of I think really top-notch titles.

But when when I go to Germany or even when we did a meeting with them at Gen Con last year, it was just drinks. Like that's all we really did. It was just drinks. How's the family? There was some smack talk and then we went about our merry way. That's all I look for in this. and board game people are the best. So if you have the get to know people in this industry, it's it's it's hard to beat.

So if you do that, do you just email them afterwards if you want a review copy for a game?

I I think I think usually how that ends is, hey, I know we didn't talk about any games, but we we'd love to to have you cover X or Y or Z. And so that usually is the end of the meeting or maybe the beginning. Um, I'm getting a little bit better now. Or maybe my reputation is is rising a tad because now, um, I have a lot of peers that get most of their games mailed to them months in advance. That's usually not me. Usually I have to go and and do a roundup at the show. So after these meetings are over, usually some games are dumped on me and I take those out and that way I can get to work on them quickly. No, I think that for me the games games are the games. They're going to come either way. Okay. And I think what I love about my reputation right now, I think in this space is people know they're going to hand me a game. I'm going to cover it relatively quickly and I'm going to be honest with the audience from Ele Mountain. That's that's really critical for us because we don't love every game is how I like to frame it and and that comes out in the reviews.

Yeah. Not every game is for everybody and that's okay because if it's not for you, it might be for someone else.

Although I'd still say not every game is for any person either. So So It kind of runs the gamut. It kind of depends. I will say though, the baseline for games has changed so much in the last 20 years. And that's the one thing that's great about games today in the tabletop space.

It's harder and harder to find a real dog, a game that hasn't gone through a rigorous test, a series of plates, tests, uh some real development cycles before it gets into our hands.

The baseline is higher than it was uh that again 20 years ago, 10 years ago. I mean, I I definitely agree on that for publishers, but there's a lot of indie publishers or people first time they're just playing with their own family of friends and they put it on Kickstarter. So, there is, you know, that, but for the most part, if it's by a publisher that's already published games, they definitely know that the quality has to be high. You have to have play tested or you're going to get slammed. And people know that you know already how to do this. You've been through this. I joke in my uh my end of year, it's called Justin's Highs and Lows for 2025. It's my kind of end of year review. I joked in that piece uh that I think publishers have gotten wise to me knowing that um if I don't like a game, I'm going to write about how much I didn't like the game.

And I think I get less chances at

question marks, if you will. But I agree with you. Sometimes the newer um designers, firsttime publishers, their their process may not be as rigorous, but for every one of those, I meet a couple more that have had a game I feel like in the development cycle for 8 n years. It's just now hitting Kickstarter. A lot of people had the chance to try it and it's been it's in a great place. So, I love having the chance to meet people that have a game that they want to show the world for the first time. Uh because it's just fun to be a part of those initial success stories.

Absolutely. And it's great to see how they grow and I love supporting them because we want a variety of different people making games because then we get a variety of different games and you never know what comes out or what new concept or mechanic or um theme that's going to pop out and you'll be like, "Oh my gosh, that's amazing." So

yeah,

absolutely.

I agree.

Now for our main topic today, we are talking about kitting out our board games. It's a topic I love in part because now that I've been in the space for a while, like the upgradeable goodies are one thing, like buying deluxe editions, fine, but I still think you have to have a lot of other extras if you host a lot of game nights. And so that's

Oh, yes.

We will talk about that for sure.

Yeah. So, you're talking about even if you have the deluxe copy, you still have extra things on top of that.

Oh, yeah. Yeah. I mean, I think that that right now, um, I know I mentioned Voidfall earlier, like anything that that hits the table from Mind Clash games. I just recently did some review plays of the series, uh, Perseverance, Castaway Chronicles. You open the box and it could not be more deluxe. Like, all the bits inside are great. But then for every one of those games, there are 10 to a thousand other games that don't do Deluxe the way I prefer Deluxe to be. So we I I have a few other things that I keep handy just to round out the experience for the other players. I think it's really important. So yeah,

I remember the first time I ever blinged out my board game, made it extra was Lords of Water Deep and Mele Sports just started kickstarting stuff and I was like, "Oh, I'm getting those meuples instead of cubes and for Lords of Water Deep and all the other screen printed meuples for all the different factions and stuff." And so that was my very first game that I really made completely different by buying other stuff. Then I got into, oh, there's so many good metal coins and I'm like, I need a whole

So you're a metal coin person.

Well, I am, but I'm I'm good. I've I've held back. I've gotten two sets that I can usually get through and use in multiple games. I have poker chips. It's not too bad, right, that I've done it. But if a Kickstarter happened to have a deluxe edition with metal coins, I'll probably get it. I was

going to say, so that's your trigger. Like that you're thinking, I need to get the deluxe edition. Sure. But if there's a metal coin add-on, you're in. You're like, you're all over that.

Yeah. But then those metal coins just stay in that game. I have sets that are hanging out that I can put into any game.

Yeah.

Yeah.

Okay. So, you got some generics. That's good. Yeah,

I um I am big on poker chips and I complain about cardboard money pretty regularly in reviews that I write um because most get that wrong. Now, I am a I'm going to say I'm a part-time train gamer. I don't want to pretend that I'm doing 18xx games every week,

but I play enough train games where I need to count up revenues in the thousands somewhat regularly or or games like City of the Big Shoulders, now Chicago 1875. Um, where I I appreciate that they included money. That was that was cute. But I'll never use like paper money, money cards, cardboard chits as money. No thank you. I want those ships. And I think that that's where for me I'm I'm actually going hard on I have iron clays. I have a set of the iron clays 400

that is now pretty much sitting on my game topper whenever I play games because even if there's not a lot of transactions in a game, right? Like like it's a kind of game where you have like one or two coins, you never have a lot of money anyway. The money's usually gone. I still think people like to play with something the tactile experience of having it in their hands while they wait to take their turns.

Enter the clays. Now, some of my friends and especially the ones in my Wednesday gaming group are pretty aggressive poker chip snobs. It It's actually It's actually funny to watch. A lot of them look at my iron clays and they're like, "These aren't heavy enough. The these aren't Vegas enough."

Or they go the other way. Hey, I really love these really solid chips, but they're smaller because you can carry them in a smaller case. So, people go to a bar or they go out somewhere to do a game night. They need to have those chips times and a couple times a year this happens. Someone starts a thread that is, hey guys, I'm ordering more chips. Who needs them? And like like we already we definitely have 20 sets of poker chips between the team. Why do we need more chips, man? What's going on here? So, that's that's a big one, but I get it now. And I would say I'm open to paper money

if if it is quality paper money. Did you ever play rock hard in 77?

Mhm.

Okay.

I I mean I I I'm constantly telling the folks at Devier this like

it's the greatest paper money ever created for a board game, right? If all if all publishers took the time to do that for me, paper money, you know, I'm in, right? But usually it's I'm punching cardboard five 10 unit money tokens. Garbage.

I mean, I know, I get it. I'm a snob. We acknowledge it. But I need I need those chips, man.

But you don't take iron clays out, right? They just stay in your home and you have people come to

usually. Usually.

But if I'm going somewhere

and we're doing something that's going to require it, I definitely put the iron clays in the bag.

Yeah.

Oh my gosh. They're so good.

Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Got to do it. I just look I'm trying to think of games I've played. Okay. This one of my favorite ones I call out is Ark Nova. Ark Nova comes with pretty pretty generic. In fact, I think it's just I want to say the currency isn't even named. It's just like 19 money. Hand me my starting starting income of of 20 money. But it's an insult to a player who plays a lot of games to give them their money in cardboard chits as a sign of respect. Here are these poker chips. I make a lot of friends this way. It works out every time.

I feel [clears throat] like it's like Japanese samurai or uh you know kung fu. As a sign of respect, you need to hand me poker chips and not cardboard money.

Uh I I I won't name her here, but but one of the team members at BGG, her husband and I are always joking about this because he knows when I sit down at the table, he looks at the money in the box, the cardboard, and he's like, "Justin, do we need Yep. Yep. Yep. Yep. Get the chips. I need to eat the chips. Then he goes over to grab a set of his very handsome poker chips

instead. I'm always gonna want those chips.

One of my friends going out along, Shu and Christina, they have a lovely home and they have on a long sideboard uh on top of a bookshelf is just rows and rows and rows of different bits. So they have like four or five different sets of coins. They have different bits, wooden bits, bits that could go into multiple games. And so when you pull out a game that you want to play and you want and you see some bits that go with it, you can just grab, you know, the little containers, play with it, and then put it back. And I was like, that is the ultimate thing to have in your board game room is these upgraded bits that you take and you put back. So, do you like to upgrade your cardboard bits to wooden clay bits? M great question. I I have something similar at home where and I mean you're probably the same way. We we get so many board games and sometimes they have

too many bits or when I donate games sometimes because if I don't give them to my review crew, I usually give games to the gaming hoopla. It's a convention that is hosted outside of Chicago and they have a charity um kind of element to it.

I keep some of the bits for games that we're going to throw away anyway. And uh the game Charter Stone from Stonemire

um had a lot of these like just spare bits that came from it's a legacy game, but there were a lot of very random like pumpkin tokens and meeples of all colors and and things like that. So that was the start of my creation of like essentially a grab bag of wooden components. I sometimes use those when the things included in a game just don't work for me. Mhm.

So, I do that. But, but now you have me thinking I I don't do a lot of upgrading to wooden components

from cardboard. I do, however, I if there's an option for metal components, I'll typically go for that. I don't do coins as much cuz I don't need those for the money. But, if I can get like like Thunder Road Vendetta, I feel like the minis have this wash on them, right? I love things that look that cool like that. But I'll I'll pay for that kind of an upgrade, but not a separate I don't really have a lot of separate things that weren't offered as upgrades in campaigns. The things I'm looking at now that I have scattered around my desk that that I use for games that I upgrade, dice for sure, and and dice are a big one. Another Stonem production. Stmar does great work with their productions, but the dice that were included in the Rolling Realms games, those two large like purple bluish dice, those have become the substitute for a lot of things that I use. Also, Fan Roll does great work with dice and so they send some promotional items that I end up keeping to use as dice substitutes because sometimes the dice that come with games are not great. I have a lot of those kinds of things, too. And then little bits like, you know, the the little finger pointers that you see at demo tables whenever I need to teach a game cuz that's like two three times a week I have to teach new games. So now because I'm always like pointing at various things, I got a couple of these like little little little pointers that I always have around uh the tables so that people can point out things there.

Train games especially those little like suction cup pickup tools for tiles. Okay,

I need those when I need to go and like move tiles around or rotate tiles. Those are a big one, too. I when I tell you when I went to tracks that HXX convention, I was shocked at how many upgraded components I saw there. Like, we're talking about nerds within nerds within nerds. HXX gamers, I salute you. It really like is another level of of bits upgrades. Train gamers are no joke. So, these are the suction tools. I think I've seen some of them where they were originally made for electricians or electronics. Um, and then they're using that to pick up tiles, but have you seen the ones that now are everywhere about picking up the cards?

Yeah, I have seen those. And look, each time I see that one, this is probably this is actually this is actually a good call out. I want to say it's called pickup.

It's just like a like a $30 suction cup tool. Mhm.

Each time I see the ad for it, I'm like, I don't need that.

But as we're talking right now, I'm like, I might need that

because I do. I again, I I play a lot of games and I teach many more.

So, that little tool, it'll come in handy. Sometimes cards are always getting like it's hard to get them off a table without having to try to pick them up and you don't want to scratch the edges because I don't sleeve cards. It's one of the few upgrades I don't believe in.

I never sleeve cards. I hate No, never.

Um, that's a that's a handy tool.

Yeah. No, I was like, "Oh, the luckily some of my friends has the pickup tool for the cards and like they work sometimes and they work they don't work other times." So, I would rather just have a good match on the table that makes cards easy to pick up.

I think you're right. I think it's not a need.

This is probably more in the want category, but it that want also has to deliver, right? Like I want it, I don't need it, but it's got to work.

Yeah. But I do think there's a moment again when someone pulls out that tool where then you get that like factor. That's a real thing. I want to be able to impress others that come over from time to time.

Those that think they have seen everything and this is a good chance for them to see something they've not seen before.

Mhm.

I think when we wrap up today, I'm I'm going to go pick up a copy of uh of Pickup. So, I've got one in the house just just in case. No reason.

Just a little to show off. So, do you think a board gaming mat or games like Earth that has the player mats, is that a upgrade as well? Is is that a mustave or do you

That's a good question. Um, the the team at uh Capstone, Clay and Christopher and others, when I I picked up a copy of Pirates of Marrabo, uh, which is a fantastic game. I never ask for extras. I never want bling when I go to get review copies. I I want the version of the game that that most people will buy, right? Cuz I want the experience to be on a pier with what people do. But as I was picking up the game, Clay was like, "Hey, I think you need to take this, too." And he handed me a copy of the mat that is used for for Pirates Americ's not a board. You're laying out cards on a table and the cards are the board. But I got the game home and I whipped out the playmat and I immediately was like, I needed this. I don't think I even thought that I would need it, but I absolutely did need it. Tag team last year, I'm still kind of angry I didn't grab playmats because it's another one where any of those like battler style of games, having cards laid out that way is just easier. Um the the big one for me uh and Yan Jan at uh at at Ion will will agree with this. High Frontier for All was a game I reviewed last year and I didn't think I would need a mat. So I get the game home and we bust out the board. And for those of you that have seen the High Frontier for All board, I'm a man of a certain age and uh my eyes are what they used to be. I'll just put it that way, right? The board I thought be big enough. It was not. I I

after one play went on to the ion website and I bought a high frontier for all. Basically, it's the board but blown up like X or 5X and so it's a playmat that is the board absolutely required. And when I played the game with my play group, my son and I did a game, we just use this large mat. It just made it made the entire experience so much more immersive. This is basically a mat that is a map of the entire solar system, right? and you're moving pieces along it and placing chits along it, but but it just that's just easier to do with a large playmat. And it adds so much to the experience. I don't always believe that, but I think in limited cases, I think a mat is the right.

Always like playing on a mat or at least a tablecloth. It just I feel like it makes things smoother and easier um for most games for me. But I always will have a mat in my back trunk in my trunk somewhere to take.

Oh, you keep one in the car. I love it.

Yeah. Yeah, I T Woo, who is the designer of Sunrise Tornado, he makes bats with really cute cats and he made this really big one and I backed it and now I have it in my trunk because usually if you go somewhere it's like a folding table or regular eery and they have like grooves so I just put the mat down. It's just a lot easier to play on.

That's funny. I'm thinking of him because you said it this way. I'm going to give a shout out to my my man John Casley. He's a friend of mine here in Chicago who's part of one of our gaming groups. He's big on, okay, let's put a mat on this table because it'll make the play surface experience better. But he's also a big proponent of one other upgrade that I have not adopted enough yet, but more and more I need to do, which is he's a big fan of creating player aids for games that don't have them. And he is known in our circle as the master, right, of of getting this kind of thing done. And so every time a publisher does a game now and I wrote this article called every game needs a player aid because every game really does need a player aid and publishers I think are missing out in that way. John is always the guy who has player aids.

Sometimes they're sourced from other people who have created them and left them in the files area on BGG. So they're out there because others have made done the work and on on some occasions he just makes them. But I love that he provides that service for all of us as players. He also takes he takes one extra step. He sometimes laminates them. It's a deluxe operation when John is is involved. So, I'm learning from him. That's that's becoming a big part of our game nights, too.

I love that.

But I think that um he's someone that just gets the deluxified nature of bits, components, like for game night, let's make this experience great for everyone. And it starts with things like that. Um big shout out to John for for for doing that for for a lot of our game nights. completely agree that player aids are a must. Unless the game's really easy, I think player aids will just always help um help get the game to the table, get the game played easier or faster uh and have less questions um once you get going.

Playerides, for any publisher listening, I'm telling you, if you're like, "We don't need player aids." I'm telling you right now, you are a thousand% wrong. This is not even like a a heavy euro question. This is games of any weight. Players are so distracted now when they're listening to rules. They're going to forget half the stuff that we as teachers are are are laying out for them. Play rates.

Now, one thing I also have is a little bell. I won't ring it, but I have a bell that I keep handy for all game nights because as the one that teaches most of the games, I ring that bell if we do a four or more player game, if each other player has asked about the same rule each time we do plays. So, by the time the third or fourth person asks the same question, usually, hey, yeah, so that thing you talking about, so tell me again, how do I do so and so? And if other players ask the exact same question, by the time it comes to player four, I just start ringing this bell. I want people to focus on all the work that we've put in to learn these games and people just they just go on autopilot. They don't think I wonder if someone else has asked that same question already. Nope. So the bell is kind of like, hey, I'm a teacher and so I want to ring the bell to just remind people, focus people, listen, put the phone down. If other people ask the same question, I want you to not miss it.

Yeah,

it's annoying, but I love it.

Whatever you need to do to get everyone on the same page. And

I feel better. That's right. I feel a lot better after I ring the bell every time. It's it's it's important.

Now, do you think inserts are a must or not must? Like 3D printed or like folded space phone core inserts?

I'll say this. Each time I stop by a booth at a convention, and I won't name the companies here, but there are a couple of big companies that I think do great work in the inserts space. I am a fan often of the Eric Martin approach. Dump all the stuff back in the box.

No,

but I am also a fan if I've dropped the money. If game trays is involved, love a good sorting tool, right? Galactic Crew Cruise does great work with with the game trays. Andromeda's Edge, love that storage solution. Everything from Mine Clash, great. But for the most part, I can get away with dumping everything in the box. And especially when the inevitable expansion comes out for a game and I got to fit it in there somehow. I don't have room for foam core. I just got to jam it on that box. I think I like it if you like it, but I don't need it when it comes to a good insert. But doesn't it take you a lot longer to set it back up after you've like just jammed everything in the

No,

that's right. Nope. Nope. I

don't even use baggies.

I No, I do have I do keep things in baggies, but then otherwise I just jam it all in the box.

Okay.

Sometimes though, I do have some games I just jam it all in the box. I do.

I don't mind

because then when I put the game out, I just I just pour all the stuff on the table and I have a a topper, a game topper. So, it's got like a vault style kind of edge around around the the outside. So, it's not like I spill things over the edge of the table

and it's very easy to sort the things, right? And if I have the chance to set up a game with other people, usually not a problem.

Yeah.

But if if it comes with it, love it.

But more often than not, I feel like publishers don't

provide any kind of a good storage solution. And I'm I guess I'm just getting used to that. Maybe it saves you one money.

Okay.

Yeah, it's usually the deluxe edition will have a storage system or game trays, but the retail does not. It they just have the insert so that things don't get messed up during shipping. Right.

Right.

And nowadays, and I I admit that this uh probably is a firstworld/bougie problem for me. I don't buy a lot of games anymore. So, I only buy three to five games a year now. And so when I buy games, I usually do go all out. I buy deluxe versions. So I'm like, "Okay, I want that, right?"

Um, but when I talk to publishers, I actually want the retail version. If your game is good, I don't need deluxe components. It'll come out when I play it. And in those cases, there's never a good storage solution. I'm like, "All right, it's fine. I'll make it work."

It was funny. I just played Vineyard from Pencil First and I think I got the retail version because it's a review copy, but man, the trays, the storage system was perfect. You know how you had acrylic standes? They had little space

so that you never have to take the standies apart

and then it fits underneath the bit like tray with the lid so you can just take that out and put it onto the table. It is fancy.

Yeah,

that's real fancy. I was surprised and it was a good shock to have that everything had placed, everything was labeled where everything went and it was really nice that everything fit nicely and made it easy to get onto the table and put back away.

Yeah.

Yeah. Another thing I usually carry along with me if I'm going anywhere for game days or game nights um besides a mat in my trunk is I have a set of Gigup bowls. you know, the kind that are flat and that put together and giga card and bit holders because they're different colors. So, we can base it on the player color and they have a ledge that you can hold your cards in there and also the bits. And these are silicone. You can find it in the BG promo store. But I find those so nice. I at least have a set for myself in blue so that people know I play blue. But otherwise,

I love that that you put that out there, too. I I'm a huge proponent of those Geek Up silicone bowls. In fact, they're here off screen. Just pull them up. But what I love about those, I have them in two different sizes, too. So, I have them in like there's like a smallest. You should probably call this out for listeners, but the smaller ones are great and and they tuck nicely into the bags that I take whenever I go out different places and they always get used. even if it's not my game, I I'll pull those things out and other players will use those to store bits on the table. I do game nights at bars in the city from time to time, and that's where they become really important. Another thing that I'll call out that um not even because they're sold in the store, but because they're the best of the kinds that I found at conventions are the draw bags. The draw bags that BGG sells through the store are fantastic. I actually each time I go to I don't even need anymore, but I keep buying more of them. I have probably a dozen drawbacks that I use for games because anytime a rule book asks me to shuffle 30 tiles face down, I'm like, you're crazy.

That's just not happening. I'm not not doing it. So, I pull out the draw bags

and I just keep all the tiles in those bags and I can shuffle in the bag and then just draw from those bags. So, then I keep the bags off to the side of the table. So, I have that as a way to also like minimize things on space. There was a game last year that Deve released called Covenant. And Covenant had a lot of that that problem. I'll call it a problem. Hey, shuffle these 20, 30, 40 tiles face down and then stack them in a large pile on this part of the board. I'm like, I'm never going to put that many tiles on the board. So, I'm just going to keep the straw bag nearby and it's going to have everything that I need. There's two sizes on the BG stores site. Mhm.

One of them is a little too small and one of them is the perfect size because the other thing is I have big hands. I'm a taller guy and so I need the bigger draw bags because I got a big hand problem.

So you

Yeah, the microfiber draw string bags. Is that what it was?

Yep. And the bigger ones of those I'm going to I'm going to butcher how big they are, but some of them are just too small for my hands. So, I bought a bunch of the bigger ones

and I bought them different colors because and even in in games where players have like a wallet, but they don't have a way to keep money secret or tiles secret. I give them drawbacks. So, those draw bags end up being fantastic. Again, I don't work for BG. I could buy bags anywhere, but the ones on the site are the perfect draw bags for I I probably use these draw bags essentially every game night to either set up the game or during play. I think the one you're talking about, the larger one is the 13 by 16 cm because the smaller one's 9 by 10. So there

I don't know centimeters very well. I won't lie to you. But uh but but he just put a note on the website size of Justin's hands. I think that'll be better for the listeners. I think that'll that'll be all they need.

But but I get it. I I love things like that because those are the upgrades for me. This is perfect.

I I agree. I love upgrades that make it easier for me to play the game. So, absolutely. I do have to shout out Modern Mele, which is really rising. I think people are now hearing more about them. They have the Lazy Susan bit holders that you can, you know, turn around and they have ones with, you know, a single compartment, double, tripled with card holders. They have whole sets just for your own personal board and pieces. And now they have bags that they're coming out with. So, they're really like getting into the space of upgrading your experience and upgrading how easy it is for you to get your games to the table. So, that being the transition because I saw their bags through other people's lenses through other content creators, but of course we have, you know, Borg has their bag, but Allplay is almost the standard.

Oh, yeah.

For board game bags that people like now they have ones on wheels. So you don't have to carry this giant bag on your back. And for us shorties like I am, be very careful around those. They will smack you around and you'll go down hard because they're right on that level of my face and I'm like, "Oh god."

I mean, I've seen people get knocked astray right when when they get hit with those bags, man. That can be rough. So I get it. And All Play does great work. I was telling somebody the other day, it's weird to me that All Play to Me was board game tables and they were

to me purely a like accessory tables like like that kind of company, but now I think they are if not the premier one of the premier publishers of games um out there. I just I love the stuff they're putting together, but to know that they they give you everything is it's just a great they're doing great work right now.

They're almost the onestop shop, right? because you can get your table. Yeah, all play is doing great and they're connecting with other publishers so that they can help distribute their games which is really nice especially for smaller publishers.

So, it's almost a one-stop shop for a lot of different kinds of games and very inexpensive shipping as well in the US.

Huge fan. All Play is doing to me everything right right now. It's it's um it's just been a fun story to follow. Now, uh, we're running out of time. So, I'm going to say one thing that I don't like for upgrades for games is, uh, stickers.

Stickers for your wooden beds.

Not a fan of stickers. I I agree with you. I don't think of stickers as upgrades. So, I'm with you. I support you on not in love with stickers. I

It's just so hard to put on. I mean, tweezers help a lot, but a lot of times I'm just like, "Oh my gosh, they're like a little bit off and I can't peel them back on."

And I'm just like, "No." Anyways,

totally with you.

Yes.

Uh stickers, no thank you.

No, no thank you. Um and you know, y'all know there's t-shirts to be found. There's board game tables to be found for multiple companies. So, um there's a lot to help bling out your board game experience that has nothing to do with the games themselves. Um

right. So, our game list top five is games of 2025. Uh, a lot of them are published or put out in 2025. Some of them, for me especially, I played in 2025 but did not hear about it or did not play it until 25. So, they're going to be on my list. Also, this is not my ultimate list. Okay? I hate doing the ultimate. These are definitely my top five games. No, these are the first five games that I thought of when I'm thinking about my gaming experience of 2025. So, there is that.

Love it.

Justin, do you want to start?

I'll start. That's great. So, the these are my top five games of 2025. And like you, most of these were released in 2025. A couple were not, but we'll start there. So, my number five for 2025 is a game called IR, Children of the Sun. Um, it was published by Osprey Games and by Mandela Fernandez Grandon and Fabio Lupiano. I I I think the Maple Mountain team knows that I'm I'm becoming a bit of a fanboy with with Fabio's work cuz he's just I think he's been banging it out the last few years. Shackleton base was was great. I thought Autobomb was pretty good. There's just things that he's touching right now and it's mostly working. IRA is the third game in a series of games from Osprey that started with MV and then the middle game I think was called Sor the pride of Mansamusa. I actually didn't really like Sor that much and so when they sent a copy of IR I was like all right well let's see again name is on this but let's just see how it plays just unbelievable and I think what made it great um was that it's an easier game to teach than Sor.

It's definitely a mediumweight Euro that plays in about 90 minutes. It's a 1 to four player game. There are essentially four mini games that are the center of what happens during each player's actions. They're moving these these tokens along various tracks. On paper, it sounds like almost every other Euro that came out last year. But when we got to the table, I was surprised at how much tension is tied to the system that is the main mechanic on each player's turn. You're taking they're called Tambos, these little houses off of your playerboard and putting them u on one of the four tracks that is uh in the game. And and that also drives a little bit of a race because as these meeples are moving along these tracks, the one that finishes each round in last place essentially retires. I don't want to say dies. Let's go with retires. And they go away forever. the way that triggers some of the other scoring mechanics, the way players have to invest in what other things are going on in the game. At four players, it creates attention unlike any other game I played at four players as a Euro last year. It was really shocking.

And I think that that the main asterisk for this game is that it's a fantastic game at four players and it's not great at two. At solo or two players, I wouldn't even recommend trying it. At three players, it's somewhat interesting. at four players, it is magic. And its big hook with the scoring is you have to manage two different scoring tracks. There's like a sun scoring track and a moon scoring track. And like other euros of this type, the lower of those two is your end game score. So you have to find a way to keep both of those things moving up throughout play. Just a big surprise. I thought I was great. I think Osprey does great work. Um I still think Crescent Moon is one of the best games that they've ever uh published. This this to me was just very strong and a big surprise. So IR Children of the Sun was my number five from 2025.

Very nice. I have not played that or the games in that series. So very interesting.

Along those lines, I am starting to be a fan girl of Tomas Holik. Uh he did he he came out of the gate in 2024 with STI Galileo Galile Tarded and everybody's like who is this guy? So my pick was STI the search for extraterrestrial intelligence for one to four players by Tamas multiple artists and the publisher is CGE and oh my goodness this was such a great game. Me and my friends really love it. Last year they came out with an expansion that kind of does what Prelude does, which helps you like get really into the engine of it. Multi-use cards, which I sometimes hate and sometimes like, but really enjoying this one. And it is beautiful. Tablehog with various aliens that can come out and change the whole game mid game. Uh some people hate that.

I did not really I mean it didn't really hurt me. I did I liked it. Um, but it was really lovely. The solar system, you know, revolving around in the middle of the table was beautiful. People are lighting up the sun with little puck lights now. But yeah, this is a really good, heavier euro with a lot of different things to do and very tight resources that really drive what you can and cannot do. There's that technology engine building that allows you to do a lot more. I really enjoyed it. I try to get it to the table as much as I can, but it is one of those heavier, longer games, so it's kind of hard. I played it solo and enjoyed it. So, I have to say that it plays good at all player counts.

Have you played this one?

I love SEI. I think that's um uh when I first reviewed it, I thought SEI was good, but the some of the gaps were tied to what you just described, which is I think it needed a prelude style expansion in order to round out those edges. It always felt to me like the first round was a little too slow. So, Space Agencies uh did change some of those things which I love. There's like quick start cards. If you played Terraform Mars Prelude and then you immediately played STI with Space Agencies, you'd be like this feels like like they took a lot of the good ideas here, but STIed it, which I love, right? And I think that when I I did an interview with with Tomas last year and I think there was some acknowledgement that that um it could use some rounding, but I have a lot of friends here that think that that that's their favorite game of all time. I know that it entered the top 20 on BGG this year. It's it's a very popular game now. I think SE is great.

Me too. So that's from Tomas Hol from CGE Games. What's your next one?

All right. My number four is a game called Jungo designed by Toshiki. I'm going to say it's Ara. That might be me mispronouncing their name. Published by Happy Camper. I think Jungo is the updated version of a game called Hashi Train, which came out a few years ago. I liked what Happy Camper did with the game Trio, which was also a game based on a Japanese title called Nana, which I had played when Nana first came out cuz we have a friend here in Chicago that's the big like importer of Japanese card games. So, Jungo is a shedding game. And I look at all games the same way. If I show it to my family, how much do they want to play it? Jungo was my most played game in the house in 2025. My son could not stop asking to play Jungo. And that tells me Jungo is great. It is a a very straightforward uh shedding game where players have a hand of cards and as they are able to play cards to the table when an entire pass goes around, right, you play cards at the table, no one else can beat your played hand. when we clear cards from the table, player that um that that triggered that can choose to add those cards back to their hand or not. And that's the only real mechanic to it.

Sometimes games of Jungo take three minutes. Sometimes they take 10. You could play Jungo once or 10 times and that's the number of hands you could play to call it a game. The artwork is beautiful. It's very, very easy to teach. My big complaint is the box is too big. It's a deck of cards. I have no idea why Haboc Camper keeps making these games with with the box being like double the size it needs to be. Save for that. A fantastic experience. Jungle is my number four and it it's not challenging the place of Scout in my or other people's households that have tried it. I think Scout is still the king of shedding games in in my circles. But I thought Jungo was a very handsome alternative for that style of game.

Yeah, Happy Campber has been bringing a lot of games. I think their whole thing is to bring these more Japanese or Asian games and make it a little bit more friendly for the broader market and make it look different enough that you know they can invite or entice other people to play it. I definitely really enjoyed Nana and play trio but still like my Nana version because it's animals. I have not played Jungle yet. They did do Nana Dori. I think they did a remake of that as well. So yeah,

is doing great work. I think it's a publisher I like following because they're clearly I think they're looking at the market and saying, "Okay, you could import these same games for for a lot more money or we could just give you this version and as long as you keep the game play the same, I'm I'm in."

Yeah, absolutely. Maybe the big box size is for retail. I have no idea if they

Maybe. Maybe.

Good point. All right. What's What's your number four? Yeah, my number four, not in any specific order, but a game that I want to play over and over again, is Citizens of the Spark for one to five players. Designer is Philip Dubberry, artist is Diego Sa. Um, publisher is Thunderwork Games. I played this last year uh with multiple friends. And we're like, okay, now we got we got the rules down. we're going to not do the starting lineup and we're just going to do either it's chaos and we just randomly pick different sets of cards or we're like, "Oh, we really want to try, you know, engine building." But man, it's so fun. Even if it's the most chaotic set of cards or if it's really really mean set of cards, we're just like still having fun. I guess it's a little bit of engine builder, but not. You're just going to take a row of cards, try to get as many sparks, try to get a little bit of a combo going so that you can get more sparks because you can follow other people when they choose a card that you have in your tableau. And then you get to do that action as well. Uh, and you have to really see what other people have around the table, especially the ones right next to you because some of the cars depend on your neighbors neighbors on your left and your right.

Uh, and it just has a such a large variety of cards that you can mix and match in. Every game can feel different based on what kind of cards you have. You can have a little bit more of a mean game where you're attacking each other and so you need to have something to protect yourself or you could have more of those where, okay, I'm going to kind of work together a little bit more collaborative. And they have different sets of cards that they suggest in the rule book. This is definitely a nice one. I don't know if you like the sparks because some of the sparks are cardboard and some of the sparks are like bits. It's a little weird in that end. Well, they're not cardboard. They're cubes and then there's like, you know, bits and stuff. So, it's just a little bit different, but yeah, I really enjoyed this game.

I still haven't played Citizens of the Spark, but I I've been told great things and this is another endorsement for it. I need to try it. I I've heard this might be up my alley, so I think um I need to get this to the table.

Yes. And I know they've sold out multiple times and they're, you know, restocking it. So definitely check it out. It's Citizens of the Sparts Games. So, hey, you're number three, sir.

My number three. So, um, I'll preface this by saying that, um, this is a series of games

that the team at Cosmos sent me last year. So, so I think my hope is they'll continue to send me the upcoming games that I've not seen yet. But my number three from last year was the game Masters of Crime Rapture.

And it was originally released, according to BGD, in 2021, but I didn't get a copy of it until last year. These are essentially Cosmos is shot at a um escape room oneshot style mystery deduction games, but for adults. They have Exit the Game that series that's more familyfriendly in most cases. This is meant to be I think it's like 14 and over or 16 and over um in part because of adult content. But even though I picked Rapture as my number three, the reality is almost every game of that series is an A+. If you are looking for the kinds of games that are, hey, it's date night. I want a 2 to four hour experience where um you're dropped into a world and you've got to solve this crime. This is that series. And I play a lot of these oneshot style games and this is definitely the best of them. In Rapture, in all of the games, I won't I won't spoil anything, but in all these games, you're actually playing some version of the bad guy. So, you're either playing a crime boss or or maybe a low-level mobster within the mafia, you're already a bad person when the game begins, and you're having to solve some form of a mystery within what all else these bad people are already doing.

So, it's already got a great hook going for it. Some of these games seem to find ways to like create the solutions out of thin air. Masters of Crime is does a much better job of becoming a logic puzzle. What makes sense? What's what's sensible based on the characters involved? And then by the end, you have to figure out which suspect, we'll use the term suspect, and that's not quite right. Which person is possibly guilty of something. Masters of Crime is fantastic, and all of them use the same format. is a 70 card deck of suspects and locations and items, conversations, uh, but just the way it weaves together its story and uses websites. There's some puzzles, there's technology involved with all of it. It's it's it's just very well done. The designers for the game, Lucas Setky, Martin Student, and Verina Witchens or Vichins. And I assume each one of these games has a different set of designers, but but Cosmos has just nailed it with the series. There's two more games or three more games here that I have not tried, but I've tried Vendetta, I've tried Incognito, I've tried Shadows, and I've tried Rapture.

Almost all of them are great. So, my number three, Masters of Crime, Rapture, originally from 2021.

I love that. I'm guessing once you get the feel on how to play for one game, it makes it easier for you to learn and get into the next few games in the series. But if you played if you played any of those kinds of like cold case unsolved mystery types of of games,

you'll be right at home. And if you've watched any of those standardized TV shows that have murder mysteries going on over the last 50 years, you'll be right at home. But I think that the twist is that you're the bad guy. And so that that always becomes a very interesting take on how to go through those games.

I'll definitely have to check out because I'm a big police procedural fan.

Oh. Oh, pick up right now. If you That's right. If you're a police procedural person, yes,

right this second, Masters of Crime, it's it's a no-brainer.

Awesome. For me, my next one is a a game that also came out in 2024, but I didn't play it a lot until 2025 and it blew up. This is one of the few campaign style games with right multiple missions that I actually got to play multiple times because everybody was very excited excited for it. Uh that is Endeavor Deep Sea for one to four players. Designer is Carl Dave Vizier and Gerat Gray published by Bert Island Games and the Grand Gamers Guild. Uh I got a review copy from Burnt Island and immediately loved it. Uh me and my friends played multiple times. Every time that I get to play it with someone that's already played it, we're like, "Oh, we're going to try some random mission." We did not go in order. We jumped around. Every mission kind of feels different. and you start with a different setup and it's lovely. One thing I'll have to say and I did make this mistake and usually if a game has a co-op version, you can get people into the game a little bit easier if you play co-op and they learn and then they'll want to play it competitive. Not this game. Do not start it at co-op. Co-op is very hard. You don't get to feel how the, you know, the combinations work. you don't get to feel how, you know, cool the movement and how you're upgrading your workers work. It don't start at co-op. I accidentally did

that and people were like, "I don't understand this game." And I'm like, "I'm so sorry. Just play it competitive and then you'll love the game." But yes, uh, this was really fun because every round you get a new person. So, you get a new action to take. you have very limited resources on actions. So, you have to decide which ones you're going which of these discs you're going to use to put out onto the board and which you're going to hold back to actually activate the people that you have. And then you have to upgrade all of these different tracks in multiple different ways so that you can have, you know, more disc to do more things or get a better person on the next round and so forth. And it just really all connects well to each other. And there is slightly multiple ways to victory, but I really enjoy just figuring out the different uh I guess the different ways that each of the mission changes the game. I have never won a co-op game, even with experienced gamers. We're just like, this is way too hard. And Justin's laughing at me.

I look I I'm laughing because you're so right. I played Endeavor Deep Sea maybe six or seven times, but for the co-op plays, I lost the ball. There's a new one.

Yeah.

Mhm.

I don't know why, but yeah, the the but it's a really good game. I have to say it is a really good game. So,

is there an expansion?

Yeah,

I think it's an expansion maybe coming this year. I don't know why I think I heard that maybe on BG, but

yes, Uncharted Waters is coming.

Yeah, I I'm curious to see what that what that will add or or change. I thought Endeavor Deepc was good. I have a lot of other people in my network that loved it much more than I did. And so I kept my copy because I I was like, I bet there's an expansion that's going to be coming sooner or later. So looking forward to see how that

I thought there was already. Is it in the Kickstarter or maybe not because I remember there is a fifth player expansion because the base game only plays one to four. I think I have played it played the Uncharted Waters expansion because it gives you a green, blue, teal player color that's for the fifth player. There's a little board that you add on to have a little extra worker placement spots or you know the different spots that you put out your disc to research or get cards and stuff that you add to it if you're going to play at the full five player player count. Um, so I it's not that big and it has four new scenarios as well that you can add to it. So it definitely is not like changing the game. It just adds to it which is good. And I have played it at five players. I don't think it adds too much to the time which is a good thing. But it does allow for up to five players if you have the expansion which is really nice I think.

Okay.

But yeah, that's Endeavor Deep Sea from Bert Island Games and the Grand Gamer Guild. your penultimate ones.

My number two for 2025. So my number two is Speak Easy designed by Vital Lera and published by Eagle Griffin Games. I mentioned this in the article that

it's a tricky one for me because I know you talked earlier about this. Speak Easy was a game I had the chance to cover before the campaign. So I played it seven times for the review in 2024. Eagle Griffin sent a production copy a few months ago and so I had the chance to play it a couple more times late in 2025. I I am someone who's a fan generally of Lera's other games. It's kind of factored that and I feel like some people are big fans of Lera's games and some people use him as the crush to say this is what's wrong with gaming. This is crazy. There's so many rules. Fine. There are a lot of rules. There's a lot going on. But I think this is some of the designer's best work. And I think as this this is coming from someone who was critical of weather machine and who admittedly loved inventions evolution of ideas, but I know that it's also a very very heavy strategically positioned game. Speak Easy is one of those that just work for me in part because I'm a big fan of the theme and that one's easy, right? like like New York, gangsters, prohibition, booze, all all those things are are just whenever there's a movie that comes out that has those themes, I'll always watch it. But I just think that this is some of his best work because of the way interaction works with players around the area control portions of how scoring works in the game. I also have a weird fast fact.

Across my nine games, the person who has spent the most money from behind their safe screen has always won the game. And so it creates this dynamic where players start the game with like let's call it 15 bucks in cash that they can spend freely and 30 bucks behind a screen. But if they spend that money behind the screen they actually the way it's it's it's spent it costs double to use that money. So there's a lot of negatives to using that in part because at the end of the game your score is the amount of money you have left over. So, even though I tell players this and I'm saying this now in this podcast, it never changes the behavior of people are like, "Oh, I don't want to spend my money in my safe." It just it's too valuable. I don't want to spend it. I'm telling you, you got to spend it. So, that part is funny. I think this the restaurant space is the best space, not only in this game, but in terms of a mechanic. I think it's my favorite laser design of any single piece of one of his games, too. And I think the player boards designed by I'm sure a mix of Ian Oul, Lera, others. I think the player boards are maybe the best work that Otul's ever been a part of. And that's saying a lot because he's been a part of so many great things

as a production. It came out in the same year as Galactic Cruise, which I think a lot of people rightly think of as a fantastic production, but I I just thought Speak Easy was a home run. And I think for players that were beginning to drift away from what Lera was doing because of those heavier games like Weather Machine, this felt a little bit more like some of the classic Lera designs to me like the Gallerist and Vinos and Conbon EV. So there's no getting around it. The price tag is somewhat shocking. Fine. But as a game, the two plays I did last December after I got my production company really brought it home. Like I just think it's an incredible design. So my number two was Speak Easy from Eagle Griffin Games.

Nice. Now I was able to play it last year because my friend backed it. Um and I was like, "Oh, this is such an easy game to get into for Lerta." And you're right, it does feel that gallerist kind of weight in how you can get into the game and learn the game and it does really connect like with Conbon. It's very logical if you're in card manufacturing. And I felt that it was really easy to learn really getting into. It was beautiful like the area control. Um I'm not necessarily a big fan of area control, but it was not bad. It was not bad. We weren't playing too aggressively, I guess, with each other. But, oh man, I don't know if the person who won used the most money from behind their screen. So, I'm just like, "Okay, now I have to think about it."

And maybe if I get to play it again, I'll I'll see if that works for me. I'll be the one person. I'll be like, "Justin, it not work."

I only can say it's worth a look to do that. And it's fun because that tension is there right from the first turn. Players are sure they do not want to spend that money from the safe,

but I think to win you have to do that. So just creating that mechanic is another reason why I really enjoy what speak easy has to offer.

Absolutely. So my number two is Sanctuary. It is a sequel, not an expansion to Ark Nova. It's for one to five players. designers Matias wig and it is published by Capstone Games and I enjoyed it. I play Arknova but every time I play I almost need another teach just because I forget how things work and how things connect and the iconography and stuff. And Sanctuary was so much easier for me to get into, so much easier for me to learn and to teach and get other people into. If you like tile drafting tableau builders, this is up the alley and it has animals and I'm always trying to find the panda. But I did a whole 5 by review of it if you want to check that out. But that was very fun. I really enjoyed it. So I'm very grateful to Capstone that allowed me to take a copy and then basically show it to everybody that I knew. This was really fun. I did I don't know if you did it the same um the same set of demo plays at Gen Con. I joined Capstone and the folks from from maybe Foyand to to do a demo of Sanctuary back in uh

back in August of last year. So I did one play of it. I haven't done plays since then, but I liked what was there.

Yeah, it was very nice because they had different time slots. They had multiple copies of the game set up. They did one teach and then they had people walk around and I just happened to be at a table with all women. So, it was it was very interesting. It was nice. We all really enjoyed it. We didn't have time to finish it, but they were very kind to let me take a copy and play fully and teach other content creators in my area. And I it definitely is one that I will pull out and teach other people. Not as heavy as Arknova, but it has the Ark Nova, I guess, DNA. Some of the terms are very similar to Arknova, but I feel like even if you've never played Ark Nova, you definitely can get into Sanctuary. So,

definitely a family weight version of Ark Nova's system. I totally agree with you on the DNA comment.

Yeah, absolutely. But it's not light. It's definitely a midway game. Yeah. So, that's uh Sanctuary from Capstone Games. And your top one of 2025, Justin. Number one, my number one game of 2025 was Vantage, uh, from Stonemer Games and designer Jamie Stegmire. Vantage, I think, is one of those that is probably out there. For those that have that that listen to this podcast regularly or that are gamers, I'm sure you've heard of Vantage. But I think that what I tell people is if you are looking for a really kind of unique narrative experience, it was a pretty easy win for for Vantage for me. I also get that some people have had not as good experiences with the game if you don't see the things that maybe I saw, right? And that that's a big part of this. I'll share just one story because between 900 locations, I feel like a thousand item cards, everyone's got their own voyage. Uh when it comes to the Vantage experience, the way Vantage is set up, players take on the role of like I don't want to say an astronaut, but certainly someone that was like on a voyage on a spaceship, that spaceship crashed and those on the ship took escape pods to land somewhere on this kind of magical mystical planet. And so play is simply discovering this this world. And you discover it through cards. And there's more to it than that, but I'll let players discover it if they've not. One mechanic in the game if you play with other players is everyone

lands in different places. But if you ever somehow end up in the same card location as another player, you can go around with that other player or players and continue the adventure with them. So, across 900 location cards in one of my I think it was my fourth or fifth play um with one of the other guys that that writes with me on Evil Mountain, a guy named Kev. I was on whatever card I was on and Kev took his turn and he announced that he was moving to card picking one card 120. That's where I was. And we both were like, "Wait, you're moving into my location." And there was this like like high fives. We stood up and hugged. like it was just this magical like yes we are in the same location randomly across this massive world and for the next 45 minutes I wrote that I called it interplanetary date night. He and I just basically went around the world for like seven or eight turns doing stuff together raiding a little a little looting of a location here and a raid there. We met some cool characters. We picked up some items. We we got the chance to like split the loot at the location. It was amazing. And we also had some kind of cool surprises that I won't spoil here that added to that experience. I did seven plays of Vantage last year and I would say five of them had just kind of cool things like that happen on the adventure. I was a huge fan of choose your own adventure books growing up when I was a kid and Vantage got me relatively close to how

that felt. So, as a game, nothing kind of came close to what Vantage did in terms of being a unique experience for me. I highly recommend trying it, especially if you can do it with like one other person. I I think it doesn't work as well with four or five. It plays up to six. I I don't even recommend it at more than three, but as a solo or two-player experience, Vantage was a very easy pick for my number one game of 2025.

Nice. Now, have you played Seven Continent or the Choose Your Own Adventure games?

So, I have um I have one of the choose your own adventure games, I think, somewhere in my like pile of older games I need to try and I've never played the Seventh Continent. I think at least the latter that would be a lot heavier cuz that the nice thing about Vantage is it's extremely easy to teach and play. Like there's almost no teach at all. Like the game is like roll these dice and start playing. Great. That's why I think Vantage also works. like I played in my family with no teach. You can't you can't beat that.

And I agree with you. Like every story that I heard of people loving Vantage is because they really went on this adventure together and really got into the theme and the story of the game kind of like a RPG TDRPG instead of like a board game where you're trying to find and do stuff. You you're really playing on the story line and that created a lot of good memories. And so they loved it. But then if they played with people that were very quiet and not really getting into it, then it kind of fell a little flat.

Yeah. Yep. I was lucky to have the former when it comes to experiences, but again, I I get why opinions seem to range quite a bit, but I I had a great time with Vantage.

Nice. Uh for my last game that I want to talk about from 2025, I got a demo of it at in 2024. Um and it was gorgeous. As soon as I saw I was like, "This is very pretty. How do I get a copy of this?" And it took a while. It took over a year and I finally got my little pause on a copy of Pergola for one to four players from designer Michael. I do apologize. Even the co-designer Preset, um, I apologize. I'll have the link. You can go check it out. But they did such a great job of it. The artist is Carolina Kidak. I say this because the artwork in this is just so beautiful. I was really looking for a lighter, cozy game and Rebel Studio definitely put out one that fit the bill. I got a review copy from I think Asthma day, but it is one of those very light, easy to learn, easy to play, multiple ways to get points, but you're just building your own little garden with your pergola. You get you get to hop your own little frog around the lily pods to get insects and dragonflies. And it is a very easy. You're going to choose a tool and they're actual little tools and you get your own little pot to put the tools in so you know how far in the game

it is. Well, it's definitely well done. The production quality is high. Like the little lily pad actually sits in the tray that holds all the bits and it's really nice. Very well done on the production quality. But it's easy. You're just pick picking a tool, getting your resources, then you're going to do the action that is underneath the tool. Some things like lanterns allow you to change that action. You can go have your frog jump and get insects. You can go down a waterfall to get insects. You can go pick leaves and get other insects. And it's all different things to do to get your garden built out. At the end, everyone has a different garden. It's so beautiful. and you're going to rearrange things to your liking and people are always going to take pictures and it's it's really nice. They even have like a board underneath a player aid that tells you how everything scores which is

just give me one player that I'm a simple man.

So easy, very easy for me to teach, very easy for me to play. I've been playing it a lot on board game arena because it's on there now. But it's a light cozy game for anybody to that wants a pretty game that's very relaxing to play. Definitely not heavy at all. But it was definitely one I was looking forward to. I'm so glad it lived up to the beauty hype that it showed to me because there's some games that I'm just like, "Okay, this is not what I was thinking." But this is definitely the game I was thinking of. So very, very happy for Perga from Revel. not tried this, but it's great to hear that it's on board game arena. I will definitely give it a look there cuz I've not

not heard of this. This is great to know.

Well, we can do it async game. It's very easy async, too. So,

there you go.

Well, let's do it. So, those are five of our favorite games from 2025. Uh, next is the moment of positivity where we just celebrate something happy that we want that's big or small that brings us joy. Justin, why don't you start? Um, [snorts] I just came back from a work trip in Florida and um, right now it's like it was a couple a couple days ago it was 111 degrees here in Chicago. And so we're we're right in the thick of cold season, but I have a chance just to sit outside of a hotel for about 20 minutes in between like meetings that I had at this at this hotel in Fort Lauderdale. Nothing beats great weather and I get it. And so in January, February, nothing beats sunshine. Hey board game players, leave the house, go outside, soak in the sun. Not all of us live in LA like you, okay? Some of us got to suffer.

Don't forget to leave the house and soak in some rays, man. It's it's it's so important right now.

Yes, absolutely. For me, I did something indoors. I baked a blueberry and apple coffee cake just yesterday. It was delicious. Of course, I ate a little bit warm. I had to taste it before I handed it off. My mom brings all my baked goods to her workplace and shares it so that we're not constantly eating it. But I had some blueberries that were going bad fast and I was like, "Oh, we're not eating this fast enough." So, I just add supplemented it with some apples and it was delicious. I really enjoyed it and I hope there's some leftovers when she brings it back. But I like baking and especially when I know other people will enjoy it. It's really nice. Although I don't like baking when I'm under the time crunch and I didn't like prep. Like I'm going to game night. I need something now and I'm like, "Oh no, I'm not going to bake." Even cookies take longer than you think because there's like a cooling time. So, but I always have some cookie dough frozen in the freezer. Uh it not only helps the flavor develop, but it makes it easier and quicker for you to bake up the day of.

But good homebaked goods always makes me smile, you I look forward to you bringing some of these things to the next convention we go to. Now we want now I want to try some of these goodies, man. So you got to bring them out.

Man, when I first started, I brought like 100 200 cookies to Pax Unplugged the first two year. Yeah. And just came in the mail.

Oh yeah, you missed out.

Thanks for rubbing me in. I appreciate that. Yep. But yeah, sometimes I do it like it it just depends on if I had enough thought to do it because it takes me a whole day to bake the cookies, to let it cool, to wrap them and stuff like that. And then um it's funny because I I don't mind it for packs unplugged because I always bring empty suitcases for copies or games I buy because it's just that's where you get the spiel and the Gen Con releases, right? But I will have just my carry-on is just cookies. It's that's all it is. It's like one set of clothes and cookies because I don't trust them on you mushing my cookies around if they put it underneath the plane. So it I never actually got any type of looks from TSA to have a bag of cookies,

which is surprising. But yeah, I'll have to remember to bring you some baked goods on the N.

Yeah, come on, man. I know. I'm sorry. I know. So, speaking of which, when can people meet you? What's the next cons for you?

You know, I think that this year a little bit lighter. I'm sure I'll be at at Shiel. I'm never going to miss that show ever again. Then, Gen Con for sure cuz it's a short drive from Chicago. Great question. I'm looking at the schedule. I really want to hit UK Games Expo at some point. And so, that's the next new international show I want to try and hit. And I need to look harder at what other shows in the US I've not been to before. Geekway to the West is the one that that uh I'm told I need to go and check out. So, that's the most likely of the domestic shows.

Okay, nice. And where can people find you on the interwebs?

Yeah. Uh www.melemount.com is our site and uh you can find me all over the place there. I'm light on socials. Justin Bell says, "Just s i n b- ls a ys on Instagram and and Twitter, but or x, but the reality is uh you can usually find me responding to comments on the Maple Mountain site because I write so much there. So that's the best place to start."

Nice. And all the links will be in the description of this podcast, including links to any of the shows he might have suggested or said something about and the episode with Candace for you to check out. And if you want to check out his reviews, you can also find him on the Five Pod podcast, but he's stepping away from that for a little while. Hopefully, he'll be back.

But yeah, I I do love hearing your voice and and your reviews. Like even though you're doing a lot of writing on Mele Mountain, I like to hear your voice, too, because uh even though you think you have a face for radio, you definitely have a voice for radio.

That's very kind of you. And I I will tell my family that at least somebody cares to hear my voice more often. So, uh we'll see if that works out.

You've been listening to the Boardgame podcast produced and edited by Amanda Wong. Be sure to visit us on the web at boardamegeek.com. You can also find us on YouTube at Blue Sky, Instagram, Facebook, and Tik Tok under Boardamegeeek and Twitch under Boardamegeeek TV. You can reach us by email via podcast at boardgamegeeek.com. Thanks for listening and happy gaming. Game night isn't just about the rules, it's about how it feels to play, the weight of the pieces, the clarity on the table, the little upgrades that make everything click. The Board Game Geek Store is built for players who want more from their games. Offering premium upgrades like Geekup bits, smart accessories, and exclusive designs that enhance play, reduce friction, and make every session more satisfying.

If you care about how your games look, feel, and play, visit boardgamegeeekstore.com and level up your table.

Progress saved