Board Games I Got Rid Of (And Why) - Episode 18
Transcript
hey everyone and welcome to episode 18 of board games i got rid of and why so this is an ongoing series that i do where i talk about all the games i've left my collection and i give some rationale an explanation as to why i came to that decision because sometimes it's not as nefarious as it sounds so we've got another 10 games here some pretty big iconic titles as well so let's get started so the first game that i want to talk about is vasco da gama so this one is actually probably one of the best games i've ever culled from my collection um there's a lot of good things going on in this game it's a watch your game title a paolo moro design so a lot of credibility and to be honest the gameplay is rock solid i got nothing really bad to say about the um about the actual gameplay the design itself has some ultra interesting mechanisms particularly in terms of the initiative that and the almost programming aspect of this game where you would actually draft all these different tokens with these initiative values on them and allocate them to the different action spots as the game goes on and they'll resolve in the order in which they were drafted like from the lowest number to the highest number but the lower numbers which will of course be resolved first may end up costing you more than you originally anticipated um because it's got this kind of random generator that moves up or down and it can kind of relieve you of some cost or even cost you more so you've got to be a bit um you take a bit of a gamble at times and be prepared to get stung i absolutely love that mechanism now to be honest that was the kind of unique selling point of this game the rest of
it was a pretty generic euro you know collecting meeples collecting resources building ships and gaining points in different ways but at least this game did have something different in that programming mechanism that i've to be honest completely adored i thought that was a great mechanism um i did end up keeping this one in my collection for quite some time but i found that it was just sitting there on my shelf never getting played um and there was always like a cube building up in front of this one and i just knew that you know even if i hadn't got rid of this one it would still be sat here on my shelf but again this is one of the only games where i've kind of seen um secondhand copies pop up on the market i'm thinking shall i get that one back because it's pretty affordable and it is still way better than a lot of the games out there on the market so still highly recommend this one um but unfortunately i can't keep every single game and this is just an example of that so that is vasco da gama next up i have another game i actually have advocated quite a lot over the years this is kashgar merchant of the silk road so another kind of example a bit like vasco de gama i really don't have that much negative to say about this game at all i think it's a great game as you're building up these caravans of cards building up like an engine basically is you can only ever resolve the first card or the the nearest card in each of these caravans but when you use it they go to the back of that caravan so you've got to kind of time things where if you use this card you've got to be ready for this card to be used and so on to get the most efficient engine going very clever mechanism i've never ever seen used before so it's again another game that has something unique going for it um but why did it leave the collection i played this game a ton over
the years and pretty much exhausted everything it had to offer now if there was ever a game that needed an expansion on new material then kashgar might be top of that list for me so you know all it needed was an injection of new cards some new little mechanisms new different ways to score um i know this would still no doubt be in my collection but unfortunately that incentive just diminished and again i've seen everything that has to offer and played the hell out of it and sometimes you know i happily come to an end with the game and i'm ready to move on and move on to the next thing but still nothing negative to say about the game i think it's great that is kashgar merchants of the silk road the next game i want to talk about is res arcana which is probably quite a controversial pick because i know a lot of you out there love this game and to be honest i think the game is rock solid a very elegant and streamlined design and probably one of the strongest examples of a game doing so much with so little so this is kind of like a resource conversion engine tableau builder style game as you are playing up these cards which will convert kind of resources into other resources or with the aim of racing to get to a certain amount of points now i do like the way that you can completely just transform goods into other resources and amplify things get stronger and stronger as the game goes on um but to be honest the only reason this one left my collection and this one might be a completely isolated incident is that i had a game with this one that completely fell flat and the cars didn't quite gel as well as i would have hoped that wasn't just for me that was for the other players as well and everyone just kind of felt a bit
trapped and not being able to do much with the cards they had now i know that a lot of people would argue against that being the case with this game but that's just what i personally took away from it and i thought it was a bit frustrating and to be honest i kind of tailor my collection to being towards games where i have a lot of trust not at least 100 trust in where if i know i'm going to pull this off the table i know you're at least going to get something out of it it's going to be guaranteed fun basically at least at least for me whereas this one that little bit of a gamble that happened again really did leave a bit of a sour taste in my mouth and just made me think you know what let's get rid of this one i like the game but i didn't really love the game i thought it was solid um but that was just enough you know that incident was just enough to tip it over the edge for me and make me again make that decision to get out of the collection but again might be a completely um personal experience because i know this game is massively popular and a lot of um you know really really um experienced and the seasoned gamers whose opinion i trust a lot do um think a lot of this game and i you know i'm sure i am the anomaly here so that is res arcana the next game i want to talk about is taj mahal by reina kinicia now i'll be completely honest i'm a massive rider kenicia fanboy and i was very excited to play this one because i've heard a lot of good things about this one over the years and actually when you play games you're anticipating you you are excited to do so um this one has some pretty cool mechanisms in it and particularly the way that you play cards or manage your handoff cards where essentially turn off the turn you are bidding with these cards
trying to compete in the i think it's four or five different categories but if at any time you have the most of a certain type of category on display then you can withdraw from the round basically and take the reward corresponding to that now what that means is that you don't even necessarily have to bid the most by the end of the round just if that one snapshot in time you have the most then you will win which i do quite like a lot and it adds some pretty interesting decisions and makes you divert away from what the other players are doing and it also has this cool decision of wanting to get up around early because it means you get more cards into your hand for the next round so obviously i thought the hand management in this game is very good and you do have to pace yourself quite carefully the route building part of this game i thought was average at best just getting points here and there as you kind of connect your buildings together there were some mitigation tools as you can get around things by duplicating spots that other people have already been to um but ultimately i thought my expectations for this game were a lot higher than what the game actually reached so i did feel a little bit not not deflated but i'm not even underwhelmed but it just didn't quite reach the peaks that i would have liked it to and hoped it would have but a solid game we all enjoyed the game but ultimately i didn't really say you know i need this my collection to play again and again it was just just a good design that wasn't anything special in my opinion so that is taj mahal next up i have juicy fruits now this game actually featured recently on my top 10 games that should have been mega hits and i still completely stand by that statement despite me calling this one from my collection personally
the game is quite unique in the way it plays as you have this personal player build with all these different fruits on them and you're sliding these fruits around almost like a sliding puzzle and the more spaces you move means you get more of that resource and as you're doing it you're clearing things out on your board as well to create more kind of opportunity to get more resources with a single movement and then you're trading them in to get contracts and things just get victory points so a very fast snappy game that's got really low power barriers to entry and a lot of people could enjoy and have a lot of fun with um the game was a little bit light for my personal tastes now despite me appreciating the design there's a lot of games out there that i think you know that feel about bracket now i think the game's like wingspan i can completely see why they were mega hits i can completely understand why so many people enjoy them but it's not just not quite tailored to my personal place what i'd want in my own collection but i can still completely recommend this game to so many different players especially if you do play with you know lighter people who enjoy lighter games and maybe family weight style games then this one is right at the top of the pack for me and i can completely reiterate that this game should have been a bigger hit than it was lovely lovely production very fast and again just different so that is juicy fruits next up i have master word which is a party game that kind of flew under the radar from a couple of years ago this is a twist on the mastermind system however you are doing this with word association so basically you're cooperatively you
are working together to try and work out what the master word is so maybe a category would be listening like animal and then everybody is writing a word associated to animal and then the clue giver is going to show how many how many those clues are correct and how many are incorrect and you're trying to introduce as a team um what what clues are viable what ones are aren't viable trying to filter out the bad clues and to get to the keyword so a very familiar design but one that works really well um i just thought that this game didn't quite um do what i wanted it to do too much when i'm playing i'm really enjoying it but when it's sat on my shelf i don't really have the incentive to pull it out and i seem to lean towards other more familiar party games that are a bit less stinky and just a bit breezy out and you can sit back and relax whereas this one you need to concentrate a bit more because there's quite a lot of pressure to get things right and to actually do well in the game but i still think this is a a very well-rounded party game a lot of fun i'm pretty clever in the way it plays and um you know it's kind of a spin on those old classic games that have been tried and tested to be good designs but ultimately there's just so many other great party games out there this one didn't quite never really got pulled off the shelf so that is why master word left my collection the next game that left my collection is whistle mountain which is actually a very interesting design a worker placement game where you're actually building the board and the worker placement spots as you go as one of the actions is to construct this kind of um scaffolding and then another action is to actually put the work placement spots
on them so you know to get resources to convert resources into other resources however the way you collect these resources or the actual work replacement spots is so cool as you have these airships of different sizes and you can squeeze them into different spots on the grid and depending on where you're touching means the work goes placing spots you can you can activate ultra cool design and meanwhile listen again there's not much i don't like about this game the only issue that i had with it was that i thought the game was far too forgiving and far too generous in terms of getting resources so i always found myself never struggling to get anything i was just completely shouting resources just had the opportunity to buy whatever i wanted constant engine building benefits that i could just afford at any time and i would have liked it to see a bit to be a bit more restrictive to be a bit tighter and a bit harder to get what you wanted done achieved so normally when games are a bit too generous uh it kind of makes me lose interest quickly because i don't really feel like i can better on my previous games and sadly that's the um the lasting impression i had of whistle mountain despite it being a really cool game just a few tweaks would have taken this to the next bracket but i can still completely um i recommend you at least check this one out because it is worth worth your time and it is a solid design so that is whistle mountain the next game that left my collection is the bloody inn which is a pretty cool game actually one with some pretty interesting hand management mechanisms and a very cool theme as you are basically this um this hotel owner and
every night a bunch of guests are going to come into your hotel and the idea is you're trying to murder these occupants steal the money from their pockets and then bury the bodies um however every now and then these police officers officers will come and attend the hotel and if you've got any bodies lying around when the police officers attend then you're gonna get hit pretty hard um so a really cool concept one that's pretty grim but i find it a lot of fun and quite interesting and it has some pretty cool systems as you could recruit these different people into your hand which will give you strength at different areas you know maybe they'll make it easier for you to kill people maybe they'll make it easier for you to bury the bodies you can even just use these people as buildings in the first place to give you a location to bury the bodies and if you kind of have such a congested hand by keep collecting cards then every or at the end of every round you have to pay an amount of money which is your victory points in order to keep them under your employment so there's a lot of things to spin here so it's a very tight little hand management game where the small stuff mistake could hit you quite hard um the reason this one left the collection despite me enjoying how different it was was that i thought some of the mechanisms were quite obtuse and to be honest despite me liking the way the game worked i didn't get a tremendous amount of fun from it i kind of one of those games where i appreciate but don't enjoy as much as i would have hoped and on top of that um if i was ever to introduce this to other people it never seemed to land as well as i
would have hoped it seemed to confuse them quite a lot so it meant that i don't even play it with my brother who we both understood the game and um we tend to enjoy other two-player games more or would rather play a you know a game designed for two players rather than the bloody inn but another game that i know a lot of people like a lot of people like the solo mode of this one and you know if you want a different concept and a different theme with great artwork then give this one a look because it is a good game but one that wasn't quite right for me personally the second last game i want to talk about is a fake artist goes to new york so this is a party game by oink games as you are working together to draw a picture uh everybody is going to know what picture you're drawing apart from one person so they're going to have to kind of wing it and hope that they can cotton on to see what people are trying to trying to make and what picture they're trying to draw so on each player's turn you're just drawing a line or two and trying to kind of enforce confidence in your teammates that you are not the fake artists it's got some really cool moments in this game as some people expose themselves you know you're clearly drawing a you know a fish or something and all of a sudden it will get a fake artist and then they draw some legs on this animal and then i was like oh obviously they're the fake artist and it you know a lot of fun to be had some good laugh out loud moments um that being said i do think this is kind of a one-trick pony and once you've played it a few times and had those good laughs then i don't think it has that much staying power to play it many more times and to be honest you do not
actually need the game itself to enjoy this concept you can just get some pen and paper and um and play it that way so again it's a bit of a waste of money to buy the actual game itself because you're just getting a bunch of paper sheets and some pens so i would just encourage you to just uh learn the rules and play it yourself if you weren't interested in the design but it's a good party game just not one of the great ones and i'd always lean towards playing something like telestrations over a fake artist goes to new york and you know when something's been directly replaced with another game i don't really see the need to keep them both hence why a fake artist goes to new york is out of the collection and the final game i want to talk about on this episode is race for the galaxy so another game that i know is going to be somewhat polarizing because a lot of people love this one i'm considered one of the best little tableau builders from the best hand management and engine building style games it's actually another tom lehmann design who i've already spoken about who designed res arcana and staying true to his style of games this is another one that does so much with so little as you are trying to play all these cards in um which synergize with each other and give you points different ways um but this one uses that puerto rico action selection system as you're playing a role and um whoever whatever role you play you get the stronger version of it but everybody else gets a kind of a weaker version of it so sometimes you want to play things and that you differently than what your opponents are doing because you you have some trust that your opponent is going to play a certain card and you can piggyback off
that it's all about being as efficient as you can with utilizing and abusing that system but the one of the running themes on criticisms of this game is that it is quite difficult to teach it is quite fiddly and confusing in terms of its iconography and to be honest i do think that is true i do think it is quite um it is quite esoteric and hard to drill into your head at least i found it that way i'm sure the more you play it the more it becomes easier which obviously is the case and we played the game so sporadically a lot of the games in our collection we didn't play uh back to back we didn't play them through big um you know numerous times in a row we felt like every time we were going back to this game we were learning it learning it again from scratch whereas i think race for the galaxy is the kind of game that you want to be playing again and again and again because you do start to polish up your skills and it's one of those games that rewards repeated plays because there is a lot to explore here there's a lot of sophistication to the game design and too much that style game doesn't suit me personally because i like variety i like diving in and dipping in and out of all the different game types rather than kind of exploring the same game again and again so it wasn't quite a right game for my collection personally um but i don't discredit the game at all i think it's a wonderful design that's clearly stood the test of time a lot of people enjoy this one and two honestly i did enjoy it and i would happily play this one anytime but one that's not right for my collection as i said so that is race for the galaxy so there we go there's another 10 ball games that
have left my collection hopefully this video has given a little bit of an explanation and rationing as to why i came to the decision of getting rid of these games because i know a lot of these are very popular and very highly rated um and a lot of people are going to want my head on the spike for saying these things but hey you know everyone's got their own tastes everyone wants their own kind of collection and these just weren't quite right for me despite a lot of them being fantastic game designs if you have enjoyed the video please be sure to hit like and subscribe to the channel and check out my other videos too uh in particular if you want to see all the other games that have left my collection i've got another 17 videos before this one so that's 170 games that i've explained why i left my collection and be sure to check those out because you know something might be useful to you there might be a little bit little nugget of information that could help you decide if this game is right for you or not but for everyone else i'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye now