The Designer Is the Artist: My Top 10 Games
Transcript
Hey, I'm Jamie from Stonemaier Games, and today I'm going to talk about my top 10 favorite games where the designer is also the artist of the game. As a game designer myself, I am in awe that someone would have incredible game design skills paired with these incredible illustrative and artistic skills they've honed over many, many years. Just as I am also in awe of people who are game designers and also graphic designers. I'm not including them on this list, but they are also pretty incredible. Um but yeah, today I'm going to talk about these amazing game designers who are also the artist of these games. I'll focus on my top 10 in addition to a few other sub-list games that I haven't played and ambassador picks. And on my top 10 notably, this is the ranking of the games as as I enjoy the games themselves, not as I enjoy the art. I could probably do a different list in a different order of how much I enjoy the art, but the art is all beautiful if they're on this list.
So, uh let's start with the ambassador picks. They mentioned Ryan Laukat from Red Raven Games specifically Above and Below and Sleeping Gods. They mentioned Judson Cowan for who designed Deep Regrets. They mentioned uh Manny Tremblay for Dice Throne, and they mentioned The Old King's Crown. Among the games that I haven't played are Keep the Heroes Out by Louis Brea, Bullets and Teeth by Gavin Valentine, uh Almighty which I have backed but just haven't played yet by Malachi Ray Rempen, and I should have mentioned here that some of these designers are co-designers. They may not be the only designer of the game. Urban Sketchers by uh Jorge Tábara Redondo Redondo, and Tenby by Benji Talbott. I've actually visited Tenby, but I haven't played the game yet.
Some honorable mentions also before I jump into my top 10. These are games that I played that I you know, there's a top 10 list. I don't quite have room on the top 10 list are Irish Gauge by Amabel Holland. Although I have played the version of Irish Gauge Engage illustrated by Ian O'Toole, Cosmic Frog by Jenna Felley, Moon and Villagers by Hakan Gardner, and First Ascent by Kate Ot. All right, let's jump into the top 10 here. And here we go. All right. So, first up is Burning Banners. This is by Christopher Moeller. And I would say the the the primary reason I played this game, I played it fairly recently, was because of the art. I think the art the map art in particular on this game is so stunning and immersive that it makes me want to know about this world. And very cleverly, the idea behind this game is that it is a fantasy historical reenactment game or a simulation game where you are replaying some key moments in history uh of this fantasy world.
What I think is so clever that it's you are you are getting to discover this new world because it isn't the real world. It is a fictional world that has some similarities to the real world um to our world. But I I loved looking at the little details on this map and seeing the names of things and and and how they paired with the art. The whole production of this game is is truly stunning. Um and I enjoyed the game, too. The game was a little long for a game that I would return to over and over again. It might have just been the scenario that we played or the fact that we were playing with four players. All those might have made it quite a long game. But um the the core idea of the game it is mainly uh combat focused where you were taking a pretty long turn using every one of your units potentially in that turn, and a lot of it involves fighting other players. And that's why it isn't a game that um is at the top of my list to make me return to to play very often. I I don't often gravitate towards games that are focused on fighting or combat, but I would return it return to it for the art and the world building and maybe a shorter scenario with fewer players um because it really is Oh, and even even better than uh having one map, it has multiple maps that like piece together to form a giant board for some of the scenarios. Really incredible.
This is Burning Banners at number 10. At number nine, we have Planecrafters by one of my favorite people to work with, Andrew Bosley. Andrew's the artist of several Stonemaier games, and he designed this game, Planecrafters. So, uh it's been a while since I played this game, but I refreshed myself a little bit. It It is a an engine building game where you go through a few different phases each turn to um to hire people to help you build planes, and then you sell those planes or turn them into like points, maybe money as well, to uh someone named Mr. Pennington who's who's wanting these planes that you're making. So, I do like how the art pairs with the theme, both the art for the people themselves and the art for the planes because uh you're you're kind of piecing together these planes and creating them. I I do like the idea of creating a ship or a plane on the table using art that comes together really, really well. So, um Andrew Bosley. Uh I think this is the only game that Andrew has designed, but he has illustrated many, many games including Tapestry, uh Viticulture World, um uh Everdell is probably the most well-known for, not a Stonemaier game but a an another game that he's worked on.
But yeah, he's illustrated many, many games. He's working on a series of games or we're working with him on a series of games as well. So, that is Planecrafters at number nine. At number eight, we have The Old King's Crown by Pablo Clark. As I record this, this game is actually on Gamefound or the expansion for this game is on Gamefound. That'll be well over by the time this video goes live. I played this game. Again, this is a game that has a lot of interaction where you are uh fighting over territory control with the other players. Um not the typical type of game that I gravitate towards, but the art and the world building again, I'm echoing kind of what I said with Burning Banners, the art and the world building was so immersive and so incredible that I was swept up in this game and this world as I played it. You can see here this is just one of the the the factions in the game.
Every faction has its own look and feel. The people have their own look and feel, the their uh their their their ships, their their buildings, what that the kingdom looks like. Um it is I I the I don't know. I don't know what to say about this art. It is just so stunning. And I would say um I am in awe of designers who are also illustrators, but I'm also it's also like I have a slight disappointment whenever I find a game where I like the art this much because I want to work with Pablo as an artist, but I know that Pablo, if he's this good of a designer and he's a good publisher as well, that I won't ever get to work with him, which is unfortunate. But I Pablo's art is is just so stunning. Um I think it would be fun to work with him as a designer, too, but yeah, this this art uh is just incredible. It's stunning uh especially paired with the the world building. Um but yeah, so this is The Old King's Crown at number eight. And I'm focusing a lot more on the art than on the game play today, but this is why they're on this list.
At least partially. So, this is Apocrypha. I've I've talked about this game a lot. This is a a little undiscovered gem of a game that reminds me a lot of Obsession, but in a shorter game. And also more recently Off With Their Heads because it does something really, really cool where during the game you are deck building with a deck of fairly standard playing cards that some of them of which are slightly altered or have special abilities. And then at the end of the game you use seven of of those cards to play a hand of whist, a very bare-bones trick-taking game. Um that does have an impact on your score. It isn't the only thing that impacts your score, but it does have an impact on it. Uh so, other than that it is a society climbing game in Victorian England. And I I like the worker placement uses the playing cards themselves. Like if I want to go on this space, I need to play a club from my hand to move up to this space. So, the playing cards are really well integrated into the game in multiple ways. And Heather did all of the art for the game as well, Heather the designer. And it's really detailed, immersive, uh kind of period-centric art that I think works perfectly for this game. Apocrypha at number six. And as I say that, I realize that I have skipped over a game. Um but I'll just I'll just keep the order the way it is. So, we'll say that we switched up Deep Regrets and Apocrypha.
Deep Regrets is my next pick. You can see it here. Deep Regrets is designed by Judson Cowan, and it is also a beautiful game. This was a very close pick between this and Apocrypha Apocrypha. So, it's completely fine here at number six. Um the I think the thing that I love the most about this game So, this is a uh a game that's um I'm forgetting the video game now. I played it recently. Um there's a video game that's very, very similar to this game where you were going out and going fishing, and you might catch regular fish or you might catch some or some fictional uh fish uh like this bubo or the Dunkleosteus or the whispering skull. You might catch things like that while you're catching fish. And the illustrations, similar to it's kind of a similar style to The Old King's Crown. I love the illustrations in this game. They're evocative. They're perfect for this theme that's a little creepy, but it also a little real. Um and you can see up here that there's a kelpie uh um just a massive eyes that you can find underwater.
And the character art also is intense and beautiful. I Yeah. So, I I think this is a really, really clever fishing game. I also like how the art um reflected the theme in that when you were looking at the different uh backs of the cards to decide where you want to fish, you can see shadows of the fish under the water, which signals to you if it is a small fish or large fish or medium fish that you were actually fishing for. So, yeah, this is Deep Regrets by Judson Cowan. At number five, we have Lands of Galzyr by Sami Laakso. And Sami is the artist of uh a couple different games including Dale of Merchants which I haven't played, but I have played Lands of Galzyr and I really enjoyed it. And I think Sami particularly excels at these um anthropomorphic creature illustrations. I believe in the game that I I'm sure Megan played the I I saw the kingfisher here. Who did I play? I think I played this newt, but I can't exactly remember which one I played. But these are the the characters in this game. There's also a really beautiful map. Yeah, here's here's uh kind of an out of focus illustration of what the map looks like. But I think Sami, in addition to making great illustrations for the creatures themselves, I think he did an amazing job with this really detailed map. I love an immersive map in a game and Sami did a fantastic job with this. And even cooler, I think this ties to Sami being the designer and the illustrator, there are ways decisions that you can make and things that you can do in this game that change the map itself, but not with a sticker but with a card that you place over the top of the map. You can kind of see an outline
of this card here where a decision that someone has made in this forest has changed that forest from then on. And because it's a card and not a sticker, the game is completely replayable. It isn't a legacy game, but it is very easy to set up and put the card in the right place uh when you play a successive games. And also kind of crucially, it isn't a campaign game which I thought was cool. It just every time you play this game, it evolves a little bit for the next people who play the game and they don't need to learn any new rules. They just need to know which cards to put out on the map from the previous game. So yeah, Sami, incredible artist and designer with a very unique style for Lands of Galzyr. At number four, I have Beacon Patrol by Torben Rat Ratzlaff. This is a uh cooperative game where you are exploring um these northern isles that uh that and I again that's really unique art style by Torben that I really appreciate. Um basically in this game, you are choosing a tile to place adjacent to where your ship currently is in the hopes of surrounding a tile. So tile is completely explored when it is surrounded by four other tiles. That's what you're going for in this game and you're trying to accumulate points based on some um some scoring objectives and completing islands, completing tiles themselves.
Uh it's a very chill game. I would say it's in this cozy game category both due to the art and the design and the cooperative nature of it. I've only played it once, but I had a great time playing it and I would gladly play it again thanks to the combination of the design and the art itself. So that is Beacon Patrol by Torben Ratzlaff. At number three, artist Michael Menzel designed this game, The Adventures of Robin Hood. Michael has also designed um a game that I very easily forget the name of uh um Legends of Andor. He designed Legends of Andor, that that series of games. And I first saw Michael's art in Stone Age and I loved the um the iso uh isotropic art, this this uh kind of semi 3D art. I think Michael makes that really really well, that style of art. Again, focusing on kind of a map, but zoomed in here on on like a village or in Stone Age it's a it's a smaller town. But he wasn't the the designer of Stone Age, but Michael Menzel was the designer of Robin Hood and he does something really cool with the art again.
Uh I think art artists as designers have a little bit of flexibility as to what they can accomplish and Michael does something really cool here where the entire map is uh a composed of multiple layers where you can actually flip up tiles like right here. You can flip up this tile to reveal something on the other side and it might flip over to be new revised art on the other side. Like you might flip over two 209 here to find that the pier has been destroyed or that um or that someone is there at the pier. There's a boat waiting at the pier for you to escape over here. In fact, I think that might actually happen in the game at some point. Uh so there there are lots of dual sided tiles built into the board um that you can that you can reveal and change the state of the board or be surprised by what's on on the other side. But because he's the artist, he he's able to seamlessly blend it with the art for the game and with the design of the game, too. This is like a maybe a seven or eight game campaign with this great little storybook that I think Michael also wrote which is incredible.
A writer and artist and a and a designer. But the whole production, we had a great time playing through this little mini campaign. Um and it's completely resettable, too, because you just put the the cardboard tiles back in on the correct side. So that is at number three, The Adventures of Robin Hood by Michael Menzel. At number two, an incredibly talented designer and artist Manny Tremblay is one of the designers of Dice Throne. Um Dice Throne is I believe the only game of Manny's that I've played uh for with him as the designer, but I played a couple of his games as the illustrator and every game that that I've played of his, I I'm just stunned by the look of the art. It has this um a slight anime animation feel to it, but elevated in a way that is uniquely Manny Tremblay's.
And uh uh Dice Throne I believe was my first introduction to it. Dice Throne is a push your luck dice game. It's a primarily a dueling game where you're rolling these custom dice. You're using cards to upgrade your mat and you're matching those dice with the different um uh types of abilities that you have in your map. You'll you'll match the dice with one ability and you'll use that on your turn to try to reduce the opponent's life to zero. I love push your luck games. I love dice rolling games. I love games where there's a sense of progression. I think this does all those with really evocative beautiful art. Um yeah, I mean even just look at the art on each of these cards because he's created the art specific to each character. It really builds the story of the character as you are looking at the map and as you are overlaying cards onto the map. Yeah, really stunning art. Really close between my number one and number two picks here. But yeah, Dice Throne, Manny Tremblay, my number two pick.
And finally, at number one, I have a game from Ryan Laukat, Creature Caravan. I could have put a number of Ryan's games on this list. I really like Ryan's games including uh I would say Creature Caravan and um uh Near and Far are probably my two favorites. Actually no, it's Sleeping Gods, too, is right up there. Those are probably my top three from Ryan. But I picked Creature Caravan because I think this is the one that I will continue to come back to over and over again because it plays so well over over about an hour, hour and a half with up to six players if you have the expansion or the Kickstarter version of the game. Plays four players I believe in the retail version. And um every time I play it, it just plays so smoothly and so simultaneously, and yet I have this really strong sense of adventure and progression as I'm playing. And one thing I realized as I was looking up the art for the game, I mainly what you're doing in this game is collecting a a crew of of people and creatures that are going on this creature caravan with you across a vast map. Also, Ryan does amazing map illustrations. And I didn't realize until I looked at some of the photos on BoardGameGeek that some of these creatures compile together to form panorama style uh uh illustrations here.
So this is a single illustration of this group of friends, this caravan, and it it doesn't really matter in the game um because these will probably just be individual cards that you randomly have in your tableau uh in your caravan. But I really like that Ryan created these illustrations that go together. Here's another one. Yeah, a couple different ones here. Uh so really that's a really clever artistic touch that I didn't even realize was in this game, Creature Caravan. Um but the gameplay itself, fully simultaneous, you're building a tableau, you're rolling some dice and using different cards to uh to kind of activate or place those dice on your turn. Um it has a ton of replayability. In fact, we have played it many many times and haven't even played with the expansion yet that came with the game. So Creature Caravan from um from Ryan Laukat is my number one favorite game that was designed by the illustrator, in this case Ryan Laukat.
I'm sure I missed some games on this list. I used some geek lists. I used uh advice from ambassadors and viewers for this list, but I'm sure I forgot a game that um that you are welcome to mention in the comments. I hope you do. And in addition to that, uh among the games that I mentioned or among the the designer/illustrators that I mentioned, I'd love to hear your pick of your favorite game where the designer is the same person as the illustrator. Thanks.