Board Games I Got Rid Of (And Why) - Episode 23
Transcript
hey everybody and welcome to another installment of board games I got rid of and why so this is a series where I talk about a bunch of board games that I previously owned but for one reason or another no longer do and I tried to give some rationale as to why I came to the decision to part with them before I get started on these 10 games I want to give a shout out to the show's sponsor keyienda dot Co dot UK who are my go to online retailer here in the UK and if you use my link in the show notes or the QR code then you can get five percent off your first order but let's get on with the games so the first game I'm talking about is Emerald which is one of the earliest designs by prolific designer rudiger Dawn who just so happens to be one of my favorite designers and has made some of my favorite games including Istanbul and Las Vegas Royale but Emerald was a borderline kids game not much decisions to be had here and essentially it has a very simple movement mechanism as you have multiple Pawns and depending on the amount of people on the spot that one of your pointers on you're going to move that many spaces so if there's four people here you could take four steps and of course the next person could only take three steps because there's only three people on that space now and you're going to use that mechanism in order to charge into this cave trying to pick up treasure but try to avoid this Dragon piece that's moving up and down this row and if it lands on you it's going to cost you your treasure and potentially send you back to the start so a very entry-level game in fact I wouldn't even call it entry there but I'd call it you know basically a children's game so the decisions weren't quite there um you know it was quite a Charming
production it looked like an old throwback yeah but ultimately the decisions were lacking and it was you know a kids game so ultimately it wasn't going to stay in my collection so that is Emerald the second game I'm talking about is Metropolis which is an old school Euro published by estari now a star used to be a great publisher who brought out some amazing games some of my favorites actually and Metropolis was one that I'm kind of on the fence with you know I did like it a lot but not quite enough to keep and I think a big factor of that is because one of the key mechanisms in the game is kind of bidding I suppose I I have a lot of bidding games so in order to stay around in my collection now and to be a bidding game you have to be very special now I did like the way that this game handled bidding did it in a completely different way because basically you'd have this big map of these islands and all these islands will be divided up into different sections and what you do is you basically put one of your skyscrapers down on one of these spots to say this is what I'm willing to bid for this particular spot and all these skyscrapers are going to come in a unique number I think it's ranging from say one or zero all the way up to 13.
but once you've spent it you spent it but if somebody say bids a a seven and somebody wants to outbed it to an eight or above then you don't actually replace the spot that you're on you actually go to an adjacent spot so you're always kind of spreading um and you know the place you're bidding for is moving as the ram progresses which I thought was a very cool touch and I've never seen that before now I love that unique mechanism and again this is what I was very much on the fence with but the issue I had with this game was the fact that one of the main ways you'd get points is by these hidden objectives and from my perception these hidden objectives didn't seem terribly balanced some of them seemed a lot easier than others to achieve and some of them you know you've had to work a lot harder than the other ones so that didn't quite sit well with me now I am aware that this game has been re-implemented as a game called skyrise so I'd be very interested to see what changes have been made and because I wanted to keep the Simplicity and elegance of this game because it was very clever but yeah that balancing was a little bit off for me so hopefully that's been fixed without too much convolution so yeah I'll keep my eyes peeled for skyrise to see if this was going to reappear on my kind of radar and if I want to get it played again so that is Metropolis I'm definitely a near miss the next game I'm talking about is Glasgow which is a small box two player game and it's a little tile placement game as you're building up this city of Glasgow by placing tiles um but you're doing that community so you and the
other player are both placing in the same grid essentially and when you place things you're going to score points based on what these tiles do something might want to be next to certain building some of them will score if they're on the corners you know that kind of thing you've seen a lot of games that do this but I like the fact that you are sharing a grid in this one but the way the actors play out is that you're moving around this rondelle essentially and it's like a Time Track you know someone will keep taking turns until they catch up with the other player that's generally a mechanism I like so yeah on paper this one did have a lot of things I liked it was quite a Charming little game nice and fast some relatively interesting decisions But ultimately I felt like there are other games that do it better I felt like it was somewhat forgettable and it was like you know what you've played this a couple of times you don't really need to play it anymore because you've seen what all the towels do you're probably going to do the same thing each time and I found a lot of the decisions relatively obvious on what you should be going for so yeah unfortunately again I like the way how smooth this game was and you know how streamlined it was but yeah the decisions need to be there for it to stick around and I thought this one just almost played itself at times the next game I'm talking about is Crystal Palace which undoubtedly is the heaviest game on this list and advanced strategy game for sure and this is a dice driven Euro as you are placing dice on the board in a worker placement manner however you as the player get to choose the pick values of the dice higher bows are going to be great because they're going to give you access to better actions and allow you to break ties with other players however the bigger the um the value on the dice
it means the more money you have you have to spend add money in this game is so tight this might be one of the tightest money Magical games I've ever played very hard to manage your funds you're basically doing a bunch of different things you know climbing tracks I'm getting Powers you can you know get these um inventions getting points and you can assign characters to them to get more points tons to be done here lots of Euro goodness but it all tied back to that dice mechanism which I think was fantastic I love the way that worked and I love the way you actually do it simultaneously you know behind a screen and reveal them meaning that you know what I went for all high numbers and you went for all low numbers which means that I've probably wasted some money there because I could have gone lower and still beat you to the punch so yeah that was really interesting and in fact I love that mechanism and I'm surprised I've not seen it again since however it did result in some very analytical decisions and if you are AP Pro then you're going to find this game a big struggle because you had a very meticulously plan things out what are you willing to go for what you're willing to spend um how much have you got how much can you get is income and yeah very brain burnery and I did like the game a lot I did give this one my shield of quality at the time and I still do operate about seven seven and a half out of ten the issue is that because this game is so heavy and you're looking at around two hours to play maybe more than that I'm probably not going to get it from the Shelf often if ever because ultimately I have dice driven games that are quicker that are more mid-weight and
I prefer to Crystal Palace so therefore it's kind of struggled to find its place in my collection so yeah if you do enjoy very advanced games and you like that brain burning nature check this one out um but I do think there are better games out there such as some of the ones over my shoulder here and if I'm looking for a very heavy game or if I'm going to pull out a you know a two three hour game off the shelf then there's other ones I'm going to lean towards before this one so therefore it had to go the next game I'm talking about is at lat dice so not only does this game have one of the worst names I've ever heard um this was an awful game and I can barely remember how it functioned but I remember hating it um it's a dice driven Airy majority game it kind of felt like a very um awful version of something like Las Vegas Royale I'm very swingy very random next to no agency and just an absolute mess so just avoid at all costs that is Atlant dice the next game I'm talking about is Valletta by Stefan Dora another great designer who's made some fantastic games such as for sale and Pokemon and this is a medium lightweight Euro with a deck building element to it and some Resource Management as you are playing through cars getting resources and money using those resources to build buildings and they're already established on the board or on the on the table and when you're building these buildings you are getting the card on them and adding them into your deck now you get points for building these Builders and you'd also get discounts for building adjacent buildings to the ones you've
already established and for me that was one of the issues I had with the game because it almost lead you down a path where you you have such a strong incentive to build next to your existing buildings where you're always going to do that at least that's what I found and the way the game played it was quite a smooth game um you could manage your deck quite quite cleverly and I like the way that at the end of the game you could play through every single card you've collected to give you that extra satisfaction and you know pay out of your Investments but yeah ultimately this is another one where once you've played it a couple of times you've seen everything it's certainly on the smaller scale of a deck builder you're not going to have you know tons of cars to manage and have tons of different ones they're kind of like basic versions and then slightly improved versions so again this one certainly has a glass ceiling for what you're going to get out of it but a nice intro game um but you're probably going to move on from it pretty quickly and I played this one quite a bit after I played you know much more satisfying involved games so maybe it just wasn't in the right kind of priority in which I played this one but check out my review if you're interested it's a nice game and again nice nice introduction to some Euro mechanisms But ultimately there's better ones out there that um just have a bit more going on the next game I'm talking about is Hadrian's Wall which is a grandiose flip and right Style game certainly the heaviest one I've ever played we're gonna have two sheets full of tracks and boxes to tick off and this game has the whole combo rific nature of flipping right style games that you love to see you know you do one thing that triggers another thing that triggers another thing you can string off some amazing
big powerful terms that feels great and satisfying this game um had that in Spades but I do feel there was this weird jarring sensation where being a a flip and rock star game you know they normally skew on the simpler side of things you like them to be just like the quicker amount on the table getting played you know rip off the street throw it in the bin and you're done this one took around an hour to play which is certainly A step above all the other ones I've played and additionally this game had like physical resources you had you know your your resources you had meeples you had cards and all that seemed to detract away from this you know simplistic nature that a flip and right Style game should be so it felt like a full board game experience or at least in the production and the scale and set up and tear down time but you were just taking off boxes so it felt a little bit weird and I felt like you could play two simpler more streamlined rolling right style games or flip and write style games in the time you could play this one and feel equally as satisfying because although this was huge in scale it was more wide than it was deep if that made sense so you do one thing that wouldn't really affect another thing where in reality you could play you know three other simple world like style games that are equally as fun and equally as comorific so I did like the game quite a lot um I just felt like I really struggled to pull this one off the shelf before I do the other ones and you know if I want something where I'm going to just kick some boxes off I'm gonna place it something that takes 10-15 minutes rather than something that takes an hour
so therefore um again Hadrian soil wasn't going to find its place on my shelf go did like it and I certainly would play it again but um I didn't want to own it because I just knew it wouldn't get played so that is Hadrian's Wall the next game I'm talking about is Yoko Hammer um which is a game I searched high and low for for a very long time because I heard a lot of good praise and I got all the good things about this game and it has a lot of shared DNA with one of my favorite games called Istanbul which I've already mentioned on this sub on this episode where you are it has a the chord mechanism is the same where you have a bunch of your pieces and then you can drop them off on these different tiles as you go and the space you end on is the action you take now I love Istanbul I think it's got a great balance of being involved in decisions and yet being simple you've got a hammer wasn't terribly complex but it was a step above something like Istanbul where you are more invested in these spots getting more payout the more you go there get a little bit more going on a kind of Step Above as I said and I don't think those extra things added to the experience I actually do prefer Istanbul to this one and because this one is more involved it's going to take more of a teach it's going to be a little bit longer um I just knew it again it wasn't going to get played so if I had a game that can be directly compared to another one I'm going to choose one over the other because I get the full experience with the faster game and simpler more streamlined version so I'm probably in the minority though I know a lot of people who have played yoga prefer yoga
Hammer but personally I don't but um again I don't want to stand back make that sound negative because I think yoga Hammer is a solid design I did enjoy it a lot again it still has my my recommendation but uh yeah another game that's been replaced by something else therefore it's kind of position has been void essentially so that is Yokohama the next game I'm talking about is peep mats which is a small box card game designed by Ben pinchback and Matt riddle who are two of my favorite card game designers made some fantastic games like sebastro and Stella so I was very excited to try Pete mats actually because not only did it didn't have the designer pedigree but um it has some gorgeous artwork in a very Charming visual look of this game and I have some pretty quirky mechanisms as you'd have this kind of stack of these seed cards and what you'll be doing is you'll be playing these birds on either side of this perch and depending on the values you played you would determine these seeds you take and the seeds are going to be one way of gaining points but you're also trying to collect these pairs of birds of of the Sexes so you've got the male and female birds and for each pair you get you get a certain amount of points and you'd have to kind of be careful of the opportunities you leave to other players so it did to have this kind of nice flow to it it had this weird make sure it didn't feel different um but this game had a mechanism that I really did not like and that was the idea that you could obtain these I think it was squirrel and Blackbird cards which would have this horrible not take that nature but almost take that nature
but the game would hit you and essentially randomly take cards from your hand and you'd have to lose cards from your collections and it felt like very swingy at times because these seeds come in different values and if you keep on taking these um these Blackbird cards and they kept on taking your three-point values then that's going to hit you so much harder than if they only take your one point values so I didn't quite sit right with me where you could you know ridiculously plan things out then all of a sudden you could do nothing about losing three points so yeah I did not like the way that worked that was probably the only thing I didn't like about it actually um but I do think there's some better card games out there some of the ones I've already mentioned and that extra and that extra negative mechanism just pushed over the edge for me so despite being a tiny box game um it just wasn't quite for me and the final game I'm talking about this episode is curious cargo which is another two player only game and this game certainly is a brain burner as you're trying to build this network of pipes on your personal player board um and they can come in two or three different colors depending on the difficulty you want to play I mean I'd recommend two that's complex enough and then you're trying to build this network of Pipes making them touch the parameters or the edges of your board to load up these tracks essentially and then when you load up these trucks you're going to send them off to your Players Board of the sort of your opponent's board because your board and your opponent's bought actually touch back to back and then they can try and almost bring in your resources to get points that way so you kind of have to be careful about where you're pushing these lawyers along
and to make sure you're not leaving your resources to be sucked in by your opponent and you're doing the same vice versa but you're constantly just laying these tiles out you can overlap them and you're constantly changing your network because you can't stay static and everything's always in flux and it's certainly one of those games where you do one thing it's going to change another thing it's going to change another thing and it becomes a quite a frustrating exercise but again takes the whole puzzle nature of these games to a to a new level and I think for the right person they're going to get a lot from this for a two-player game it does take around an hour to play maybe even a little bit longer which is kind of above my Comfort level or by you know what I generally do if I'm going to play a two-player only game I'm probably looking at around half an hour because if I am going to play a longer two player again active players I'm probably gonna play a multiplayer game but out two players if that makes sense um but yeah this one was a weird Niche because it did feel like it was certainly crunchy um you had you're probably a game or two to get things out your system to try and play optimally you're going to make a lot of mistakes and this turn structure was a little bit weird but okay I liked it I liked the um again I quite like the brain burning each of it but at times it did feel like work and more than fun if that makes sense so yeah a strange one for me one that again was certainly on that border of was it going to keep it what was I not going to keep it but since passing on with this one so it's moving this one on I've certainly not regretted it or missed it if that makes
sense so um that is curious cargo so there we have it those are another 10 board games that I've left my collection hopefully you've enjoyed the video if you have please be sure to hit like And subscribe to my channel and check out my other content too for everybody else I'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye