Skip to main content
Loading video...

The TOP 10 board games of all time | Ep 150

Transcript 1:07:41

hey everybody Welcome to the going analog podcast um the podcast in which three board gamers each pick a game and topic to discuss usually except today you guys are really lucky because it is our 150th episode they're so lucky Super Lucky in fact we are all going to go over our top 150 games just it's not going to happen so we wanted to celebrate with somebody very important to us and the podcast of course so we had our super editor Mike Zipkin join us today hi Mike hi guys what up Mike be here Mike is a h prolific board gamer a great editor for us edits lots of things videos and podcasts and everything and our ultimate beige gamer our favorite beige gamer so excited to talk to you as usual and instead of 150 games we're each going to talk about our all-time top 10 games which was very very difficult for me so we will discuss how we did it and as of this moment what that top 10 would be was part of the difficulty here that you waited till the last minute to really put it together no it's the ranking is hard I definitely had like a top 12 that was pretty easy to come up with for myself but then uh ranking it was was the tough part but yeah I've never done this specific exercise before and a lot of times when people ask like they'll see a game on our Shelf and they'll like oh this game and I'm like oh that's one of my favorites probably top 10 top 20 but I don't know how many times I said that I might have had like 40 of those

top 20 said that too yeah and so now it's uh kind of cool to actually solidify that list and make it official for us cuz we've never we don't normally do like top 10 lists or anything like that no we this is our 150th episode our very first episode was back in August 8th 2018 so uh we have the cred you know we've been playing games ever since that time and before so these we'll have pretty interesting lists I think a little bit of overlap we'll see we'll see mhm so how did you pick your top 10 mic I think I just looked at my collection and I was thinking uh like what would I rather play if we had a group big enough to play the game at whatever player count and I was just like okay what would I rather play other than anything else here and I just kind of like looked at some of my favorites and I didn't want to pick games that I picked or played only once uh so anything I played only once didn't make the list and it's and there's a lot I haven't even played in my collection so I just feel guilty looking at all the games I think could be in this list but I just haven't had a time to play yeah we just like making you feel bad so that's the goal yeah it worked but yeah everybody always asks like when they come in and see my collection they always ask like what's your favorite game and so I always give the same answer and so it's going to be the same answer here okay okay do you by the way should we explain to people why we call him a beige gamer because the color of my skin yeah if if you're not watching this on YouTube you might not quite understand this or if you are watching on YouTube you might be like what are they talking about no he looks incredibly

beige so we make fun of Mike but he he likes this name I think or totally love it I own it yeah um you know what what what qualifies as a beige game to you Mike that you love something old German uh kind of they call it like OG games on some of the uh forums and shows that I watch on YouTube so I'm an OG gamer I tend to like games that are um from Europe from like that are high in interaction uh low on rules overhead so elegance and yeah beige is fine I like beige and I would say usually the boxes are quite beige so yeah I think this where it originated from was like if you look at Mike's preference for games they're usually a little planer looking a little less colorful we'll see we'll see what the most colorful of your beige games will be at the end of this top 10 list too

okay Sho how did you pick your top 10 so for my top 10 I want to make sure there's a mix of different weights right so I'm like I need some light games in there some party games some heavy games you don't need to well I I wanted to make sure that I had a wide range because I think my list probably Skuse a little heavier uh but then I'm like I wanted to make sure that I'm like well same similar to Mike I'm like will I want to play this game will I want to break it out so then there's sometimes it's like well there's bigger groups sometimes so I'll pick a few party games in there and I also wanted to make sure I was like this is still a game I'd be happy to play today yeah because there are some games they're like this is an all-time great like a spoiler code names is not in my top 10 I think it's one of the greatest games but I'm like I don't know if I want to play it too much it feels a little bit long compared to when it first came out uh so games like that didn't make my top 10 I also excluded a lot of really new games because like if I didn't play them enough I felt like well it's either I I didn't play him enough or I don't necessarily have the perspective like so there's recent games like Forest Shuffle waterlands W the bail of Eternity search for plan of X Vindication Acropolis River of gold The Guild of merchant explorers that I think in maybe 3 four 5 years they might make a crack the top 10 but right now I'm like I don't know if I played them enough to really know for sure looking at the rest of your list some of them I feel like are just are that new also though but we'll see my real top 10 yeah we we'll talk we'll talk what about you

Christina how did you come to your top 10 I it was mostly a similar way of thinking it was like what would if I were to play this today would I like be excited to play it or would be like H you know it's fine maybe next time or something like so I want to be excited when I hear somebody say I want to play this game like yes okay I definitely want to play it I also figured in how often I play this game now so there are I think maybe one big surprise where I was like I just play this game a lot so I should really put that in um and then yeah yeah I think they're just sort of personal for me or there's something very interesting about it and I really like the gameplay and they scratch different itches of my my gaming uh preference I think they do tend to skew a little bit medium heavy um because that's what I tend to prefer but just as a spoiler my lightest one since I'm going to start on my number 10 anyway is telestrations so this was my one acknowledgement for like I just this my favorite party game and that's never going to change I think telestrations is not and it's some would argue maybe not even a game the way that we play it but uh but for a party game I don't care about winning often times and so it's about you know I always have fun with telestrations when I have a big enough group it's basically telephone Pictionary um I don't even think there's a designer credited for this game because people would just play it with pieces of paper for a long time um but what I like about telestrations is that there's a flip uh sort of flip notebook

for everybody and we use dry erase markers so you keep playing it and we do not play for points we don't even use the cards that come in the Box they could still be in shrink wrap I have no idea we just have everybody write their own phrase or word that they want the next person to draw you write that phrase down you pass it on the next person draws it Etc it's just hilarious lots of things show up and I always have a great time with it so that's my number 10 nice yeah I've had so much fun playing that with you guys like I bought it and I don't think I've played my copy but you guys sold me on it it was like we had so much fun playing it at your parties yeah it's a classic mhm yeah number 10 we going you calling on you call you're the host uh shoe number 10 all right my number 10 is this one if you're watching we're holding on if you're watching on YouTube we're holding up the boxes this is Rising Sun you should actually see I forgot that we had our copy signed uh impressive by the designer like for Lang so uh Rising Sun The quick version is uh you it's a Japanese mythology based game the five players can play on one map you're putting out units but it's not really a war game even though it's kind of the trappings of a war game it's not a traditional war game it's just like about align with people gaining different powers triggering these powers to move your characters around to buy more monsters to buy more Powers you could win peacefully lots of ways to win and it has a really really clever

bidding system when you do fight uh because you could just give up or you can Retreat or you could capture prisoners so there's a lot of cool stuff it runs a little long but it's one of my favorite games it's pretty epic and for me dudes on a map type game which is what I would generally classify beyond the sun it is my favorite dude on the map game is just not my normal game preference not beyond the sun rising sun but you were close you said R did I say that you said beyond the sun oh cuz that's hint something that's coming up later Rising Sun is my favorite dudes on a map game for sure nice awesome okay so my number 10 is one of the bigest games in my collection so that's a great place to start uh this is hob and gut this is H the The Have and the good I think uh in English they translated it and so this is a stock market game um it's very um I guess just like simple rules it's just like you have these cards that are on these card holders in between the players and so it's like between two cities if you've ever played that where both players to your left and right share a little bit of information with you and you have um insight into how the Market's going to change you have to um on your turn you just have to like buy or sell stock and then you have to manipulate the market with one card from each neighbor and so you can kind of work together there shared incentives with both neighbors and you can see like the stocks start to shift and you know

uh and working together to like make that go up or down so it's a lot of fun okay uh the the one rule that's that I think a lot of games um should have more often is the the person who like throughout the game you have to donate a piece of stock to your charity everybody has to and the person who donates the lease after the end of the game uh is completely is eliminated uh just no matter depend yeah doesn't matter how many how many points they have and well money is points obviously so um yeah it's a it's a great game I love that rule I love a bunch of games like that but yeah okay number nine uh I want to talk about because it is beyond the Sun and I said that wrong because I was talking about Rising Sun before for me number nine is beyond the sun it's G by tennis Dennis kchan um it's we just played it again recently and I was thinking oh I was excited to show this to somebody who hadn't played it before and I just love this Tech Tree it's basically Tech Tree the game and I'm here for it and I'm happy it about it because you're just discovering new technologies the game develops differently every single time um and there's like fun space themed stuff there but it's basically a tech tree I like the tech tree mhm next for you Shu well let's go to Mike so we can switch up the order a little bit okay uh all right now I have to check what my list says all right so number nine you threw me off number nine is hanza Tonica so this is a great classic beige Euro game

um where you're creating the htic league of um Merchants going around Europe and setting up little shops and upgrading your powers and everybody has these cubes that you're placing out and you can uh and you're from your little board and as you upgrade stuff you get to yeah open up more more of your abilities and just start to move you know mountains as you're getting through to the end of the game so it's just got a really cool Evolution as you get from the beginning to the end it's very competitive so I as I I think I taught it to somebody to people and I was like I like this game I see whether it's a good game but I don't like playing it cuz it's like brutal but I I like see that yeah there's a certain level where the game reaches enough aggression like there there's got to be an aggression meter hidden somewhere like in background but Christina senses as like this has crushed my threshold then she will not enjoy it as much yeah it's personal thing all right my number nine is cocol I'm not going to show it because it's big it's heavy and uh there you can cause accidents with it we have ours hanging on the wall and then her brother uh one time shout out to Brandon yeah dropped it while trying to hang it back up and then cracked our uh baseboard along before we have to get that repaired but kocol uh is this awesome game where it's like a huge uh wooden sort of platform it's usually circular or sometimes you could find them in octagons and such and then you're flicking little discs across this very smooth surface and you're kind of

bumping other discs in or you're trying to get yours closer to the middle or in the middle for scoring and so you go through several rounds so you kind of think of it's like shuffle board finger shuffle board finger shuffle board but on the table so yeah it's a very fun game and it's always like a weird one people like if you've never seen and people are like what is that and you're like oh let me show you and then guaranteed good time and number where are we on number eight number eight uh I'm going to take number eight my first number eight um it actually is genotype I really really like this game from genius games uh designed by several designers John Kio Paul Salamon and Ian Zang um it really really appeals to my bio background so that was my major in biological sciences and it takes the science of genetics and the history because uh Mendel some people may remember uh you know did a lot of genetic experiments with peas and it's all about we are these Franciscan monks and we are doing pea experiments CHR is nerding out so bad right now I love it so much I also thought about oh one of my qualifications was how much did I bling out my copy so I know that Mike blings out a lot of copies but I blinged out my genotype it's deluxe edition and my first player marker is a real mini little travel thing so it's so cute I love it it's a good game and it's good science so I love this game yes Sho all right my number eight is El Grande

so this box that we're showing on video right now is the newer version which is way prettier than the old one uh I've shown the old game to friends before it is immediate there's a there's a barrier you have to overcome it's so dry and ugly I don't not for me and it's like right up Mike's alley he's probably like whoa what is this thing what is this uh so but then uh the uh the newer version is a little bit more colorful a little bit more welcoming it's an area control game you have certain number of territories and then what you're doing is putting people out but then you're also grabbing cards like you have to make decisions do I play a card that's going to give me more people or do I play a card that's going to let me go earlier do I grab a power that's going to let me shift other players around or score immediately so it's constant manipulation of what's going on around the board and it's just super strategic but it's not a heavy uh dense game by any means I love El Grande so uh it's a game I'll play Forever nice soet I do love me some El Grande it's not it's not on my list uh but my number eight is Lords of Vegas and um even though I've never won a single game of this I still love it it doesn't matter oh wait all these years you've never ever won ever won uh you have to have a bit of mixture of luck and you know timing um so it's tends to be something where I just like I'm doing really great at the beginning and then suddenly I'm getting overtaken so uh but the basic premise is you're

buying You're Building casinos in the strip in in Las Vegas and you have like these uh chips or every card you get has a coordinate and you get to take control of that spot to build on later and you're trying to like build build up this these casinos in like these uh six or seven different colors uh and when a card comes off the deck it'll be one of those colors and so all of those casinos of that color will score uh and so if ever two players have the same color casino that touch each other that connect and like like an amoeba they become one casino and then whoever has the highest dice pip uh on in the casino is the boss and gets to take the victory points when that color scores um so it's super Cutthroat and mean and lucky sometime very lucky uh and yeah I blinked out my copy to it to the nth degree so yeah Sho we're going to go to you for seven number seven so let me grab this box here uh this is a game we played the heck out of during pandemic times uh we just played this so much and we probably I think we ended up recording 150 plays of this um but this is the Cooperative game the crew the search for Planet 9 the Quest for Planet 9 excuse me the question uh so this is a Cooperative trick taking game and so the game each Mission uh and the book will come with several missions

will lay out the parameters of like you need to accomplish this many objectives or you have to accomplish objectives but in a certain order you have to do this or that so you all have to work together and be clever About It by making sure like okay I need to get rid of maybe certain colors so that Mike could win his objective or I have to play this at the right time so that Christina could win her objective and he can't communicate what's in your hand of course that'd be cheating but uh the yeah so it's a lot of fun it's very it's like super there's a lot of strategy there but it's not terribly complicated and you feel so rewarded when you figure it out because like the whole team's like yes that's exactly what I wanted you to do this happened this happened it worked out perfectly sometimes you're going to lose really badly just from a look of the cards that come out but it's an incredible game that uh I just keep thinking about all the time and I wish we could kind of I want to start over and play it again with new people we played a ton before it came out when it came out we played it again the sequel is actually pretty good too I would actually recommend that one but I have a soft spot for this one because of the theme and how much we played it and how much we played yeah this one takes place in Space the other one's underwater themed uh it's there's a little bit more variety there I think it's probably technically the better game but this is the one I really like and I feel like that's that was about the age of a couple that you took out for saying they were too new I'm this is a 5-year old game yeah but I think some of the other games you have in there close anyway maybe but but that's how important it was I played those other

games 150 times right I know this one we beat we played multiple times we played like one full campaign and we played several times before that so this is comfortable for me to be able to put in my all right I'll allow it I'll allow it it's a Sentimental pick that that uh yeah during pandemic that changed you know that created a lot of time to play games for you guys yeah that's true what was your number seven Mike uh my number seven is one of your favorite games Christina it's the Estates oh that's sarcasm in case anybody missed that there going to be a few of those on this list um so the Estates is like one of the meanest games I've ever played uh it's incredibly mean uh so you're you're basically like trying to build these different skyscrapers in the middle of the board but every single piece of the skyscraper is an auction and so everything you do you're on your turn is you're auctioning something else off and so it could be your piece it could be something you need or it could be something that one of your opponents really wants and so timing everything just right so that um if you build it you have to pay for it um and whoever uh but if somebody else you know decides to they pay you so you have to decide like am I going for the money this time or am I trying to am I trying to get points this time so it's all about these different decisions um and it's so interactive it's awesome it's a really Bean game but it's I I like it a lot yeah that's a great one it's a really mean game period for

me no I see it I see it uh my number seven is lost ruins of arac so I really really enjoy this game and um uh was super excited to meet uh Min and Owen the designers uh during Gen Con once that was really cool and I blinged out my coffee a lot too so you are explorers on this island and explor trying to make your way through the jungle to get these resources to explore this Lost Temple um there's so many expansions of it now and I really enjoy some of them but even the base game I played it on board game arena played it the base pretty recently with some friends like it's still so satisfying I like putting those resources together to get as far up that track as possible and I switched out all of my little green compasses for little working compasses and it's adorable oh and my first player of marker is like a working um stopwatch like not a stopwatch pocket watch so yeah good times I approve yeah mhm it's very much mik in terms of like uh for my favorite blinging out individual games what about your number six Mike okay we're going back to the auction house MH to play Modern Art uh by Riner Kenia one of my favorite designers and this is probably my favorite game of his because it's all auctions and you're B basically you have a hand of cards and each card is a painting and so this version is the dice tree Games version it's so beautiful has real you know uh re you know Rembrandts and picassos and da Vinci works of art

and so you can sort of tell a story about your art as you're selling it and you're just trying to yeah sell your car sell your art to other people so that you can take their money and also you know try to have the best art that uh keeps you know ex uh going up the point ladder uh exponentially with each round so a lot of fun my favorite part about that game is that there's different types of auctions yeah to mix it up yeah so it's it's like sometimes it's like everyone bid at once the highest bit wins sometimes it's like you go around a circle and keep out bitting the other person and things like that so I think there's like maybe four different types of auctions that could come up so uh that's the best part of that game really cool uh when we had Riner Ken on you know call out name dropping uh rer kesia on our podcast he actually talked about how there was a whole exhibit on the different um additions that they've put out of Modern Art and someplace in Germany and that would have been so cool to see cuz we have the little oink version which I love cuz it's so small and it comes with a tiny little easel to present your your your art on so yeah this one comes with metal coins auctioneers gavel and the easel as well so and you didn't have to get that gabble it was already in there yeah I probably spent 60 bucks on it but you know it was came pre- blinged so that's great um your number six are we on six Yes mine is Concordia specifically the Venus version so uh this is a game about

trading in the Mediterranean which sounds about as boring and generic a Euro game as possible uh but Mike kind of thing uh but all the game play so you have this map and then you're extending you're moving your uh either your colonist or trade ships around the map to establish different trading posts around the map and you want to get there first because they get more expensive the more people that are laying down houses there but all the gameplay takes place with your hand of cards and everyone starts with the same hand of cards You'll Play it you'll activate some power and then you have to play there's one more card that you can play to pick up all those cards you can play and start over again you can buy more cards eventually people start to develop different powers uh or different kind of ways of playing just due to their their deck composure uh composition sorry uh not composure but anyways it's a really awesome game but I and I like the Venus Edition specifically because you could play in teams of two so you could do 2v2 or 2v2 V2 which is really awesome because uh it doesn't like a six player game of Concordia Venus doesn't take that long in for a six player Euro game because on your turn or it doesn't feel that long because whenever you play your partner gets to do an action as well so it always feels like it feels kind of like a three-player game because it's always you're constantly doing something uh it feels so it's a fantastic game and it's one of my all-time favorite Euro games so good that one's good too uh my number six is a feast for Odin I was oh

only number six I thought this would be higher for you I know I was deciding between this and another uve and I love Feast for Odin a lot every time I play it I love it but for me the only big thing is every time I want to play it again I have to think about um how do how do the rules work again things like that it's like worker placement like your it is worker placement like a lot ofmer gapes but there's an added polyomino element which I love but it's just like like a just a bigger obstacle to get to when I want to replay it I think than the other uve that I picked so it's my number six but I love it it's great yeah that was crazy because it's like it's also hard to teach because uh unlike a lot of work replacement this is like a whole Board of like what two dozen actions that get picked from right off the start so right away you're just like oh my overlo yeah your first time play you're just like I don't know what I want to do do you want to build boats do you want to go hunting do you want to go uh try to pillage or do you want to trade goods and it's just like a lot going on and so uh but once you kind of get over that hump it's pretty awesome the problem is I need to play it like three times within a week to like really make sure it sticks and that never is going to happen so yeah so we're on to number five um let's go with Mike again number five another one of your favorite games Christin this was one we played last time this is a street car but this is the San Francisco version so uh highly interactive uh sort

of tile placement game where there's a lot of you know like involved in the pull of the tile um but it evolves as you play it starts out you're you're trying to connect your two Depots um to and stop at a certain certain spots along the board and then end up at the the other end of your Depot um but if you let on too early as you're placing tiles uh like where you're going people can totally mess up your route for you and so it could be very mean and you just kind of have to know going in that uh you may not make your route uh so you just have to be okay with that um but as you're placing it starts like I was saying evolving uh from like trying to hide where you're going into then just trying to screw other people over as well and then just try to finish your route quickly because as soon as the first person who as soon as you finish your route you call it out and your train leaves the station and becomes a rolling move like race to get your train to hit every stop and get to the through the board uh so yeah it just I love that Arc and that sort of race element as you're just starting off trying to be secretive and get to the end uh so far it's very unique the tempo I was not good at it but I I see the appeal yeah they you know it's a mean game yeah and things might not go you're right Mike's a mean person I think I like mean games I'm not a mean person just kidding well what I was going to say is you know it's a mean game from Mike I things may not go your way during the game if Mike's apologizing to you

during the game CU Mike brought this game to us the last time he visited he brought this and then had us all play it and he could see like oh people aren't having fun because like things are going wrong for us it's the mean parts are coming to coming out our routes aren't getting finished and you're just like oh I did all this work to kind of build this route and then it wasn't happening and then Mike was just kind of like I'm sorry I'm sorry it's a little zany I think I think it's fast enough that I like I'm cool with it I'm cool with it I think you have one good game and you you kind of pick it up and you're like okay I I can see why this is fun mhm sure okay uh I'm going to go in another Direction and do a party game My Party game uh hive mind so this is the newer Edition uh from calop games and this is designed by Richard Garfield of Magic the Gathering Fame and the basic idea is super simple premise like however many players you have the game will ask you prompts or you can make up your own so for example name five Marvel movies or name name uh four brands of cars or name three things you find in a refrigerator whatever that is you write them down and then when everyone's ready you read this one by one so you one player will like okay my first Marvel movie is The Avengers and then you raise your hand and you see how many other people at the table raise their hand and all those people who just raise their hand will score that many points so if they're playing a 10 player game and six people pick the Avengers The Avengers answerers scor six points basically you're trying

to think like as the name indicates like the hive right so you're trying to get popular answers so it's the opposite of a classic game called scatories where you're trying to come up with unique answers you're just like what will people at the table uh think of like what what what is this table going to write and then you try to mash them as closely as possible and it just becomes a lot of fun because inevitably you're going to go off and think everyone's going to say this and then no one will say it you don't score very many points that way and then so it's just a lot of fun at least a lot of fun conversations and arguing fun arguing about people why you would why would you pick the Avengers over endgame or blah blah blah so things like that so it's uh it's one of my favorite party games mhm and my number five is actually shards of infinity so it is my ideal of a deck builder so that's why it's because I play it so much not the physical game actually but I play it on mobile pretty much every day um I have 10 games going on with one person but it's fine and uh I just don't get tired of it it's like just a simple deck builder but the added sort of edges to it to make it more competitive I really really enjoy so you're like a normal deck builder you start with a basic hand you may buy new cards to improve your hand but you have this added resource of combat so you're also taking trying to take down the other people's health and so your win conditions can be like yeah I can just kill you which is fine I win but there's

also this extra aspect of um Mastery so as you build up and play cars you can improve this Mastery sort of resource that never you never spend but as you reach different Milestones cards will get more powerful and then if you ever uh reach 30 then you auto win if you play a specific Shard card so that tension between like oh no I'm about to die but I'm also about to reach 30 Mastery you know what can I do first is really thrilling and they're quick games and I love them and I still play a lot of shards of infinity every day so yeah yeah I I love this game because it doesn't and like Dominion's a classic deck builder but it's just sort of like all right we're done count up the points all right and see who has the most points a lot of games are like that but this one like builds up to a climax because it's just like oh man like everyone's like a t at the table's freaking up cuz Christina is at 29 Master she gets 30 and then draws this card she gets infinite power it destroys everyone but other people have like hits of like 20 combat in one hand you know things like that so really scale up and you reach this big climax so I love that version and it doesn't overstay its welcome I uh only recently I decided I think I'm like this is my favorite deck building game because we got the physical version I've same as Christina I've only played it digitally and the digital version doesn't have the expansion so I'm like it's okay it's just you're just playing the base game but now that I got to experience some of the expansion content in this new uh The Saga collection version of this I'm like oh I think think this is my favorite

deck building game there's so many cool Combos and so many ways to play and it's very exciting they did rebalance a lot of the cards in the base game too uh favorably so I I like that part too it's great nice all right number four let's go back to Mike okay this uh game was too big to carry into this room so I brought the Box lid Railways of the world um uh I need to find the designer's name you guys are throwing out designer names uh but theway the railways I think that might be it might be Martin Wallace actually I think it is so Railways of the world is just uh a huge map uh sometimes or you know if you're playing with a smaller player account you can shrink it but you can play up to six and you can do the the entire West uh or like Midwest to the west coast of the United States and every city has different Goods that want to go to different places and so you're just constantly balancing your how much do I want to spend to build out my railroad tracks and you know where is where is my next Evolution going to hit like uh because you're as you're playing the years are progressing and your trains get faster and can travel farther and so you have to be able to like deliver more cubes later in the game so you have to plan early on um and I love that I I love games with Evolutions like it sounds like shards of infinity does uh and like Street carded uh where you're not doing the same thing you were at the beginning of the game by the end of the game so yeah I'm really happy Mike's doing this with this cuz our choice choices are so diverse and so

different like Christine and I will probably tend because we play games together so over we haven't overlapped but we're like kind of I like all the games you've brought up I like all the games you brought up so sweet so romantic cute mhm but yeah interesting cuz like a lot of them I've played of yours and I do like some of them and as you as you noted I don't like some of them also but it's fun yeah I should have just made my top 10 the top 10 games Christina hates that I've made but my number one I hate it oh that'll be another topic but uh sort of negative we'll see we'll see number four for ah shoe let's go in the same order okay uh this is my number four Great Western Trail from Alexander Fister um this cover you're looking at it's a second edition definitely get this one cuz this cover is like 5 million times better than the original cover that is constantly mocked uh I think they could finally get over that because there's a new cover now the the board's been redone is a little prettier of a game and they fixed one problematic element of the original game that kind of like now you can play it guilt-free uh but the basic idea is a little bit of deck building a little bit of work replacement you have uh these uh cattle handlers I guess is ranch chair R I don't know where're we're ranchers Cowboys we're Cowboys cow it's cowboy cowgirl cow person cow person excuse uh but you uh will go along this

Trail and then you end up you started one city you'll end up in Kansas City and then deliver cows onto the train which will score you points but the trains will start to progress and then they'll be like take you to farther and farther cities that are worth more points for those deliveries along the way on that trail you will customize those Trails the the the players build out the board So eventually you build buildings that will allow you to do other things like skip moves buy better cows uh get other resources move the trains and all this stuff it's like really really great uh a kind of different feeling a Euro game from a lot of others so uh it yeah it's it's just a great game and then like and then there's because of the different ways that the players will build out the boards and then there's different buildings because each building tile is double-sided you're only play with one of the sides so you can mix and match these to make for a different experience each time and then it's been so popular they've since come out like the original has an expansion and the cing the second edition also has the same expansion uh but then they've come out with two sequels and then we just there's a third one third sequel come out it's like a streamlined versioned version on board game arena also it's called El Paso yeah Great Western Trail El Pas El Paso uh but my other favorite one in the series is Great Western Trail New Zealand which is a great one as well but that one's a little bit more like if I had to pick one of them I was deciding like which one one would I pick if I could only choose one it would be the original still he my favorite I do think

like and then the fun part is like you know you deliver your cattle and you start back at the beginning so in the very beginning when our friend Tim Schaefer made this joke it's just Monopoly with cows and I'm like ye yes I see that actually I don't know about that you guys are dropping names left and right I know I know Riner kesia great episode um my number four is the search for lost species so this is my favorite deduction game period I think this is true yes um so this is from uh Ben rosset and Matthew omali they ALS they also did the search for Planet X which was the original search for game and this was its sequel I had a really hard time deciding which one I like better um but I think lost species because it again sort of adds on this extra theme that I like uh where I'm searching for a biological lost species so um in this case it might be rainforest where we haven't seen this species in decades or a 100 years does it still exist we don't know um but you're using these other uh animals that you're discovering along the way to deduce where that lost species is um I love this game everybody who plays it um always looks like they're suffering as you're deducing where this Mel species is but it's like such a good hurt you know um so I love it it compared to Planet X it adds in an extra like work work ER movement and I like that when you um go to these different Villages for help it's a

little bit more interesting than the uh sort of M similar mechanism in Planet X where you get to actually uh take some character Buffs or maybe more information different things at Villages so it adds a couple tweaks that I really like and I love the theme a lot so search for lost species for number four nice that's another another cool one I think I like Planet X a little bit more it's a little bit more straightforward and I like the theme of that one but the gameplay of lost species is definitely better uh but I I used to say those two are my favorite logic deduction games uh chronologic uh might be beating yeah I really really like that not as good as that you're wrong not as replayable I've heard though but yeah I need I need to play those games sure yeah those are the search for series are run by apps so there's like a a presumably infinite number of combinations that the app kind of come up with so so good all right now we're going to dedicate some extra time to our all our top threes give it a little bit more love right so number three let's start with shoe this time okay so M number three these were starting to get hard to kind of come up with I'm like this is pretty important but I'm going with zoken the Mayan calendar uh so this is an older game uh it's a classic in and I remember playing it uh a friend of our showed it to us at a a friend's birthday

party a while ago I'm like this game is just amazing so it's a worker placement game and you're putting them out on these big wheels there's these giant inlock wheels like they look like giant gears that are sitting on a map and there's several of them and so what you would do is place them and then the more you place out the more expensive it gets so you have to kind of balance it so you're either placing workers or you're retrieving them but as the day advances you turn the central wheel which turns all the side Wheels the day advances and then where you're worker now is that it's not where it's at on the wheel but the the kind of uh board the graphic on the board surrounding that wheel so now your car all your workers that are on the table have advanced one day and now they have access to something better than where you originally plac that character so you're making these decisions of like do uh later when I want to pull workers off the table do I want pull it now or let them sit there a little bit longer to get to for the days to advance and the wheels to turn to access even more powerful actions like which might give you more resources or more points or let you build cooler buildings or Advance on different Tech tracks so it's just this constant like oh you have to not just Place workers and do whatever action that is like a lot of other worker placement games but you have to do the timing of when do you place when do you take it off and try to balance all of that and then you have to feed them of course yeah you have to feed the workers of course which is uh difficult so like if you're kind of newer to Euro games I would never recommend this one because

it does have that complexity of like when do you take the mob and you could find yourself if you don't play it well of like oh no I have to take my workers off now because you have to do one of those two actions now I have to take all my workers out cuz I have none no more to place and this was not the ideal time to take him off they cuz it hasn't they haven't reached the spots I wanted them to reach so there's a little bit of that experience but it's not terribly difficult it's not a complex game it's just very very clever and it it looks cool on the table as well cuz we got our Wheels Gears of course painted yeah so they're a little bit more colorful uh but yeah it's a it's just a super cool game uh with this interesting mechanic of like this time and just waiting and making sure your workers are coming going out and coming back at the right time uh really really neat game I I really need to play that one you've ever played it no yeah oh I know I I don't play enough of the games that I really need to play mhm yeah uh yeah that's one if we were living near each other if I heard that I'd be like immediately walking over right after this Friday we're playing it nice I I want to see your painted board though I've seen the like I have like the game in my collection and I haven't played it but just seeing the gears working together it's so pretty to like watch the whole thing move yeah yeah MH so cool and your number three Mike okay uh my number three is AC chire so the Sid Saxon classic and um yeah so acquire is a game

that that was made I think designed back in the 50s and I wish uh my parents had brought me up with it because I would have gotten to know a lot better and be actually decent at it instead of how terrible I am at it um but so basically the game is you are trying to um you're you're playing a tile in your turn and you have like a rack of tiles kind of scrabby and your tile goes out on the board at the at the coordinates like one uh you know 1 through 7even or whatever and a through F uh and so it goes out onto where it belongs and then if it's touching another tile that becomes a hotel um you know Corporation and so you're starting these corporations and you're taking stock on your turn you're trying to trying to invest in other people's corporations and trying to make sure that you're in like the primary you know like stockholder position so that when that company uh when those tiles uh let's say two companies touch you know tiles where one joins them you the bigger one always swallows the smaller one and uh so you want to be in the primary shareholder position of the smaller one so that then you can sell your shares and make off with a ton of money um and it's just such a simple design all you're doing is just placing a tile and buying stock and then it comes back to you and it turns move pretty quick um but yeah I I I wish um the buildings weren't uh super futuristic like they are in this version but like to get the one I want it's like

copies of this game from like the 80s go for like $300 wow um but they just uh that newer Edition Renegade I have the new Renegade Edition and it looks great uh it's not my favorite version but but it comes with you know poker chips which I love uh it's pre- blink I mean you'll deal with itess I'll deal with it yeah I mean I got rid of my old Hasbro copy which was you know terrible uh so yeah it's a it's a classic for a reason it's great are do all these versions play identically and it's just a matter of like the materials and the presentation somewhat uh I have a 3M version from the original print run from like the ' 50s and the board is more rectangular I think there's more coordinates um more higher like numbers I think it goes from like one to nine or higher and then the newer versions made it more of a square um so yeah the older version like some versions are have more tiles and so it changes the game um for super Pros talk about it GG yeah okay okay yeah shout out to our other episode Phil Walker Harding naming drop naming more dropping of names um also picked that as the game he wanted to talk about he loves AC choir yeah our last episode I feel like now I don't think I've played it before have you played it I don't think I have either yeah I feel like we're gonna played silen and acire the next time we hang out at the same time okay so my number three I see on shoe

side so if I could grab our first overlap it took this long for us to overlap so I was just cuz like I love Cava I Love A Feast for Odin um I love a good uve Rosenberg game with his little face looking all cute in the rule book and stuff um between the two because of the sort of obstacle of like relearning the rules that I have with Feast for Odin I just always really really enjoy caverna it's it's a little bit more sandboxy for me in this it's a work worker placement game and we are cave dwarves dwarves yes cave dwarves um either building out our caves inside mining them getting some rubies putting donkeys inside our caves more building out the farming part um outside of the cave so it's Some people prefer Agricola which I feel like caverna sort of like a spiritual successor to it right caverna is going to be a little bit more forgiving where Agricola is like a little bit more brutal you have to be more careful with your resources and things like that but I I like the the fun of Cerna I like the extra theme I want to see how many sheep I can fit into this cuddle room cave you know things like that and uh we got this one expansion where you can have um asymmetrical faction Powers essentially and so that adds to it and I really love the flavor of CA I always enjoy it I want to play that again it's been a while so I love CA we there's a classic moment where Christina was pulling this

game off the shelf and she dropped it and it I just heard her scream out because she was it she didn't hurt herself no there just so many pieces in this there's like so many resources there's like es and donkeys and sheep and dogs and it plays up to eight or something so there seven I believe seven yeah didn't we play a seven player ones yeah it took a little while but it was still fun and then there's like wheat and pumpkins and up like there's a million pieces and it and it like I look on and I had to laugh and I took a picture of her cuz she's just on the floor almost like ready to cry because we have an organizer where all these things go into their certain squares and it was just like a big massive mess of tokens and it took her a while to kind of put it back together no yeah but it's got the Classic uve Parts you're farming your animals breed and you have to feed your family but all in like a fun I don't know I just love this game it's classic classic mhm play that too I haven't played it what I know God damn it Mike triple game day triple game day okay number two what's our number two Mike you're number two so just I mean I was almost going to put these two a tie but I have to say I like this one a little bit more than a choir it's very similar this is shark shark shark is another older stock game I love me some stocks economics and some stocks um but this one's a little lighter uh it it plays quicker uh and

it's still mean um because you have uh these different like you have five different spots on the board where when you roll the dice you're either going to put one in the coordinate that it tells you so it's a dice roller or a chucker and so you're rolling Dice and building out these corporations and then again if they touch like one can cut off another one and completely destroy it um not like swallow it but it like cuts it off there's a theme running through a lot of your games Mike yeah yeah I never noticed this before maybe you're noticing it for the first time um yeah I like mean games I like interactive games I don't necessarily want them to be mean I just I like I love games that are interactive like I don't want to be heads down uh focused on what I'm doing kind of looking at your board I want us to be like face to face on the board yeah but not even mean like a lot of your games are like like the territory and then the control and then the the things are touching and absorbing and growing into bigger territories trying to Psycho analyze Mike yeah like like the Estates Lords of Vegas this game Acquire all are all kind of similarly themed there but he knows what he likes yeah there's there's a reason Reon I like the all these games they're very similar um yeah I think I think I know what Mike's number one is I haven't heard it yet so I think I know what it is I think I know what Christina is of course of course of course if you've W if you've listened to the show at all you probably know what my number one is um number two I will

say is my Mikester um and so it's a card game though I really really like this old CH game called Innovation I thought that was going to be your number one no I my number two my number two um I play this a lot on board game arena um I would not say this is the best way to play Innovation but it gets it gets that itch scratched okay it's a highly competitive multi-use card game and it's ridiculous and chaotic but there is a lot of strategy that you can employ when you're paying attention which I not to do when I play it on board game arena um essentially as you're playing out cards into your Tableau there's five different suits essentially you play them out and each of them have icons and so these icons are building up your Mastery in these different areas of building out of civilization so you're constantly competing like who has the most light bulbs who has the most leaves things like that because if I have more leaves than you I can dictate that you give me one of your cards or take out a scoring card and it can be actually very very mean which is a weird game for me to like uh but I think yes so I there's just something about this game where like the first time I played it I hated it because um a lovely friend of mine forgot to tell me one of the endgame triggers and ways that you could win and I was uh very

upset but then we had this other like uh gaming getaway and I played this game four players which usually is not recommended but I played it like four four players five times in a row and it was so different every single time and we had so much fun um it's like completely different every time I play it um sometimes you can like just smash the opponent and it's like brutal and you feel great and other times it's like really really close and I come back from behind or they come back and surprise me and it's just always exciting um you can play 2v2 teams and that's ridiculous too and the way the cards interact are so crazy this one time I played this whole game team wise and we're we're like doing great then we started doing really really poorly you have your score score was going down really really low our civilization is not doing well basically but then the other team they start triggering some really high power cards and accidentally created Skynet essentially and so that endgame trigger turned out to be now because you created Skynet the people the team with the lowest score will win and we won as barbarians so I was very excited by this outcome um so I love how crazy this game is and I will always play Innovation so that's my number two that game is awesome I love Innovation Sho what is your number two my number two is let me reach for this it was very close this was almost my number one but I'm going with the castles of burgundy that was almost in

my list for sure what Su yeah almost made my list too yeah yeah I'm surprised that this is like a lot of people's like top 10 kind of game uh this is the special edition that you're looking at um so this is a stepen Feld game and the idea is every round you're going to roll two dice and your two dice you have to figure out what you want to do with them it could mean hey I could take one of these tiles from these number Depot around the main board so if I rolled a one I could take a tile from the number one uh spot and put it onto my own player board uh then your player board is this grid of hex's that all have different colors and numbers on them then the number one at the same time could mean I could now take a tile that's on my supply board and place it into a number one spot on the board there's other restrictions and rules about where what you can place and where uh it has to match colors for the type of building but uh so first of all there's different there's scoring there's like ways of like oh you want to play aggressively and fill in certain colors to complete uh uh region to score but all of these buildings there's a ton of them you needed a player aid for sure and most games most of these games have them but they explain the building so for example putting down a ship might let you take more Goods that you could sell for money or you could take a building that will let you take another building or you could build animal pens and then the animals will score differently on their own or you could get build a castle that will let you do anything you want like like as if you

had a wild diey so it's really there's a lot of game there for not a lot of time like it's not a Time investment Mike at some point called it a super filler which is the most ridiculous oh I remember this yeah we had this big argument it's like it's not a filler game it's not a super filler it's still like if if you're playing two players maybe it's a 45 minute game if everyone knows what they're doing you can play it pretty quickly but it's uh it's a very meaty game that feels so streamlined and so easy to play and it's so rewarding and I I've never met a person who did not like this game um converted one who said he didn't like it WR we've been showing our friend ma' uh Stephen fil's a city collection of gains from Queen games like uh Hamburg Amsterdam mares and he's just like man I think I'm a big stepen felt fan except he played castles of burgundy a long time ago and he said I didn't like that one and we're like something went wrong there because there's no way because that's his best game by far it's like the highest rated on boring geek everyone will rated by me so everyone will tell you this is uh stepen Phil's finest game uh and so we made him play it again I'm like we're going to show it to you and then he's like oh my God he does he learned it at a convention someone taught it to him something went wrong there then he fell in love and bought the special edition as well um yeah if you get this game uh if you're willing to invest right up FR get the special edition because it's

beautiful it's gorgeous art uh they fixed a lot of things with the artwork being kind of really small and hard to see they have you can upgrade more and get these really nice acrylic tiles uh that are kind of chunky and kind of clacky clack and they have these nice bags to put them in to draw the tiles out of uh the Arts amazing on this new edition like I just love this game and I I just I I'm just so amazed that you can play it so quickly too like a four player game I've taught a four player game three new people and it was like under two hours like with the first time teach too it just goes so fast a super filler yeah it's what is known in Mike's head as a super yeah but uh absolutely fantastic game the castles of burgundy check out the app too the app is a great uh version of it so and it plays quick it's great a great super filler app got it can play it in in line for the bus MH yeah I play it on a board game arena pretty regularly so yeah that one's good too okay so we're finally at number one I think we will go with Mike's should we guess who what everybody's number one is I or I know what yours is do mine first because mine's going to be the least fun to talk about okay sho's number one what do you think it is Christina knows but Mike you got to guess what's that game called uh I have it's not Vinci anymore but it's uh the other game that you have the Super Deluxe special edition small have

a lot of is it small world no no no he spent all that money on the super deluxe version is not even top 10 it's a great game it's maybe my top maybe it's number 11 we don't know we didn't do top 11 um I think Christina is Arc NOA okay yes it is but anyway we'll talk about that soon we're gonna talk about shoes number one it is cerno so uh we already covered it Christina headed as start number three actually I'm surprised because you used to say your favorite uve Rosenberg game was Feast for Odin but at this point in my life I I think I I enjoy CA you've grown up and uh you've become wiser just want the Streamline jumping in that's what I feel like so we already talked about it but I I will say one of the other things that uh I love about this game is like it comes with a million different rooms that you could build right and they all have different powers they either help you score things or convert things I do like this a lot better than a gria obviously AG gria wasn't in my top it's like once this came out I'm like I don't think I want to play a gria again and we literally never touched a gria again after that I think I played a couple times on board game arena but it's uh it's just such a great worker placement game there's a bunch of choices and the board grows as the rounds go so it's not like eventually by the end of the game the board's much bigger than it started out with but that's kind of great in that way of like it doesn't overwhelm you I think like Feast for othing can it's like okay the game will grow more options will come out it is tough you have to think about feeding your uh your

people your family all the time but it's not as punishing I think as in in Agricola it's easier to find ways to bake food it's easier to build your pastures and all that stuff it's just like uh it's just a great game that has like a lot of different aspects to it and like you said the Forgotten folk expansion where we can now play as like trolls or elves or things like that like different different fantasy rockers creatures other than doors and then now it that's a lot of fun too because now you could like I want to just focus on The Cave Part or these people don't like the cave they only want to be outdoor and then say get more points there so it's just uh it's my alltime favorite game I I similar to you I used to say my favorite U Rosenberg game was laav but I'm like I'd rather play caberno yeah I think for that factor mhm I and since Mike spoiled my number one um surprise surprise it is Ark noova uh I love arnova I have so many plays of arnova because I also really like the board gamer Marina implementation um they've done a really great job uh the base game is on it and also the expansion Marine uh the Marine world's expansion and it's just such a great game where you are building out a modern zoo and you are balancing both the appeal of the zoo which brings more uh visitors in so you want to play these cool animals so then these people want to come see the animals but at the same time a good modern zoo is going to

contribute to conservation efforts and so um I might be having these cool animals but maybe I release them back to the wild or um I contribute to a breeding program or things like that so it has this interesting sort of two-point track mechanism where the appeal is a basic point and then you're also gaining conservation points that are worth more at the end of the game so when it first came out these tracks sort of meet in the middle and so if anybody uh they're sort of like overlapping and they go in opposite directions so if your two point tokens every reach each other you trigger the end of the game um then typically you would take the difference between those scores and that would be your score so if your markers passed it would be a positive score and if it didn't pass you had a negative score but people were really sad about that I think and so now the official scoring mechanism is you add a 100 to that difference so everybody gets a positive score uh which is fine and that's how board game arena is scored but I I've clocked I don't know probably close to 100 games of it already 100 games yeah between board game arena and in real life um I've blinged out as much of my copy as possible thanks to a great insert to shoe and then I changed out a couple of the tokens here and there and it's just so satisfying I love playing these cards in my zoo I think in some ways this is not a mic game because it is multiplayer solitire in a lot of ways but uh cuz you're building out your own map so there is a little bit of a polyon polyomino aspect to it but getting my

Zoo to fit my map and going for that as bonus Point sometimes or maybe other times I just want a lot of really big animals because I'm going to get bonus points for that and synergizing the like base goals with my personal goals is just like it's it hits everything that I like in a game and I love building the system out so um I have maybe five six games going on in BO game arena right now I don't understand how you keep track of those games like the strategy because it's very tactical and I think I like tactical games so it's sort of like at the moment I can sort of see this is my map these are my goals these are the cards in hand this is what I'm going for and I can figure that out so I really love it what's your ideal player count CU I know it's better at two or three yeah I would say two or three um I have a lot of two-player games online right now and that's that's really I can actually look at their zoo and Care um and it actually can get pretty Cutthroat when it's two-player especially cuz you're like racing for certain objectives um so I I or like you snag this card that you know the other person wants so um I still love arcn NOA and if anybody wants to play I will play with you oh yeah you can teach me sometime I need to play that one and then okay guess mics uh you got it yes yes okay so I actually don't even have my copy here so it's like the only game I don't have here which is weird cuz it's my favorite game but uh that's because it's in storage

and I'm waiting for my new Super Deluxe Edition to come out to show up um so kimala is the bigest game ever and um you're basically just like the theme is You're Building textiles and you're shipping them to different parts of Europe either by carts or by boat and so you're kind of like trying to build that infrastructure um based on these actions that um you have uh 3x3 grid of actions that change they're completely Dynamic you can remove them you know and shuffle them up and then like place them out randomly every single game and so it's totally different every time you play um not just because the actions but also because of what's scoring so every city scores at a different time and you're building these buildings and each one of those buildings scores at a different time and so every single game is different the strategy changes um and so what you're you're trying to do what your actions is is you're placing a dis on between one of those 3x3 uh spots on the board the action board and you're going to trigger both actions for yourself but also anybody else whose discs are below you gets to go gets to have those two actions again and so if you're if you're smart and you strategize enough you can plan you know where are people going to go and like uh and like figure out like where can I get more actions for for going there um so it's um interactive it's economic it's got everything I like in a game it's beige it's beige so beige uh and the new the

new version they didn't even try to color it up they were just like no people love the beige of this game so we're just going to f going to keep that going so it's it's very very beige too I remember playing it at your place and thinking this is a really good game I just haven't played it enough I think and we don't have a copy but I remember really liking it when you showed it to us so it was cool it has a minimum player count of three and I think that's a good count uh but five is ALS four and five are also good I think it plays up to five um yeah I I just love it it's great hly Mala yes yeah and it's not the it's not Indiana Jones and the Temple of Doom people are always like oh so gets a lot of those jokes all right so that was generally 30 games I mean our top 10 for sure we we'll get to 120 other ones some other time to get 150 but thanks for joining us everybody and thanks for listening to our 150th episode hopefully you liked listening to our favorite games you have your opinions about our picks and then you can let us know thanks to Mike who will be editing this later and uh everybody I hope you enjoyed it stop listening and now go play a game bye

Progress saved