Top 10 Board Games of All Time | Top 50 Board Games | The Finale
Transcript
nice okay jeffrey have i missed anything no notifications very popular last one we did it people were at the finale hello everyone and welcome back to foster the meeple why are you laughing i'm sorry jeff the sooner we do this the sooner we can eat pizza okay okay no no hello everyone and welcome are you getting funny in the head why are you so into pizza right now i'm starving we only had one box of crab dinner instead of two today okay okay okay
hello everyone and welcome back to foster the meatball a channel all about board games or gaming things yes we are here today guys we made it we did it hey look ma i made it this is the last video of our top 50 board games of all the time all of the time all of time every of the time that we've played these are the top 50. since 1987 and 1986. wrong eight okay you got your your year wrong also i'm 87. you thought i was older than you i don't know why i said 86 and 98. 88. so this is the last installment of our top 50. this is number 10 to one that's the easiest one that's the games those are the games we are gonna jump into it we are very excited i have no idea what is on jeff's list because he's already thrown me for a loop pretty much his entire time and it is your turn to get us started let's do it jeffrey don't look i can't see it i saw you looking are you chicken my number 10 favorite game of all time which i think is going to make jamie very very very very happy is mansions of badness i wasn't expecting it to be on your list at all i i love mansions of madness every time we talk about this game you make me feel like you think i don't like it that's because sometimes when you roll the dice sorry oh it's when you roll the dice it's so frustrating i get very angry at manchester band this doesn't make it a bad game top 10 though
yeah it's only improved it's only improved for me i think was it in my top 10 last year it's only improved because i think collectively when we play together yes you love it so much and you're having so much fun and that rubs off on me there are incredibly difficult scenarios in this that are yeah very frustrating but there's a little bit of everything in this you know i like to inherently go and fight monsters you like to go and be a little bit more detective work i love that we can both do that i'm sleuthy and it gets us closer do you want to mean like you can do your thing and i can do my thing i really love mentions of madness i would like to play it more it's been a while since we've played it yeah that's my number ten mansions of madness second edition third edition second edition i don't know it's over there guess we'll never know it's second edition just the second edition very good jeffrey and there isn't even a third edition i don't know why i went to look more of the expansion yes i know my number 10 is from ravensburger gilness castles of burgundy i love this game even though there's no theme even though i should prove to you that some of these other games that you write off you should probably try oh for sure even though it's the ugliest game even though it's not the ugly it's one of them it's definitely up there it has so many elements that i love like the dice placement and the tile placement and then there's like actions that happen and i don't know there's a lot going on in this game i love it so much we need to buy our own copy yeah i totally forgot that zach took it back first of all how dare he take his own
game back i have played it a few times now on bga i was gonna ask do you like it on beat you i don't love it on bg no but i will play it because we don't have it and if somebody wants to play it then yes i will definitely play with you on bga just so you know when we say we are playing games on bga we do that often with our friends in the discord you should join our discord yeah we haven't pitched it in a while but there it is that's my number 10. i love this game so much it was up higher on jeff's list or lower i don't really understand how the lower higher in ranking lower in number right my number nine favorite game of all time is another fantasy flight games another campaign game that is star wars imperial assault knew it i have such a good time playing this game very thematic you're upgrading your character you're uncovering new planets and new storylines it's so so so you're pewing the bad guys i don't love star wars nearly as much as i love lord of the rings but there's a key mechanic difference in this game that i prefer much much more than journeys in middle earth and that is the dice rolling mechanic versus the card you guys didn't see that but he did do this off screen did i yes amazing game love it so so much can't wait to keep playing it now i'd like to get some expansions to that as well yeah we had a lot of fun playing it but i think what happened there was we were in the middle of jaws the lion yeah we had two campaigns going on at once yeah that's too many campaigns my number nine i am assuming is not on your list at all which is sad but that is the
isle of cats i love cats i love cats the very first video that i ever did on this channel was an unboxing of isle of cats before we actually officially started it right it was like my trial round i forgot it video i don't really count it i love this game it is a polyamino tile placement game where you are rescuing cats from this island because there's an evil man trying to like kill cats which is just crazy is that the theme yeah it's like lord something anyways and you're just please you're trying to get as many cats in your boat as you can scoring points and i love it i love this game so much i love it it's great it's right behind me it's always up there i don't you can't see it but believe me it's there my number 18 favorite 18. my number eight favorite game of all time from affair games is gloomhaven jaws of the line jottle that was jeff's number one game last year that's fair yeah because we had just finished it we just finished it i don't know what else there is to say about gloomhaven i think jaws of the lion is the superior version in my opinion because we don't have a massive gaming table or gaming group or gaming superior we've we've played gloomhaven multiple times with multiple different gaming groups that constantly bailed on us yeah the jaws of line is superior because you grab the book you put it out it's got your maps got everything set up is easier quicker and the story in my opinion just as good the one thing it does miss i think the mark on is
upgrading your character and getting new new character mechanics and new miniatures with new abilities and stuff fallen from grace a little bit and probably will continue to my number eight was my number two last year a game that i love very very much and it is about birds and that is called wingspan i still love wingspan and i think like my love for it has not well it has diminished a little bit but like i still will play this game anytime if anybody wants to play it i bought the app to play i love this game we have not played with the ocean expansion only with the european expansion i think we played with the ocean expansion it would increase my love for it even more but there's just something about this game it's just it's such a tight game i just love it it just works so well it's beautiful i love the edge there's a reason why they sold a million copies this game i would never in my life ever get rid of this game everybody loves this game was it on your list at all it totally fell off your list oh it wasn't even on your top ten last year my number seven favorite game of all time is dipped a little bit i believe brass birmingham it was not on your list at all last year really oh so it's in it's not just dipped jumped brass birmingham is a economic game where you are brewing beer and getting resources in order to basically up your production of other things jamie hates it because it is economic very industrial looking theme
with industrial looking art i the boards love it and it's probably increased exactly for the reason because i always want to play it and no one ever wants to play with me we did we were going to play it at a board game weekend i did relearn the whole thing and then we didn't end up playing it and i was like that took me like all day to relearn yeah it's a very it's a heavy game it is a good game i don't see brass birmingham popping off my top 10 for a while that is my number six great western trail what what oh i flipped taft i was like one that is my that is my number seven heaven's the best season i need to take a break that is my number seven brass birmingham yeah and is number six great western trail which is not even his number six my number seven there's a game i'm waiting to hear and i don't know where it's going i know my number seven is fantasy realms that's high i was shocked that yours was so low again it's a product of the type of game it is yes i don't know but this is the type of game that i just love to play we discovered this this year it is what red rising is based off of so you know fred rising is on my list that fantasy realms is going to be on the list and it's a game that now we play all the time i can see us playing it too much that we're going to start to get a little bit bored with it without getting the expansions i don't know what the expansion's at me either i think just more cards maybe but i love this game it's just super fun it's easy we can pick it up throw it in your bag you could play it anywhere we have
taught it to many people and we've played it with many people and we just love it my number six favorite game of all time is dune imperium i totally forgot about this game i knew you forgot there's a couple on here i think you're i'm surprised i can't believe that's why you're top ten because it's dune i thought maybe like wherever i had our neck you would just have dune why i don't know that's just how my brain works dune imperium is a deck builder with worker placement elements to it and there's also a side track and a battle element which arnac does not have i love dune theme i love the book i haven't read any of the other books only the the first one doing imperium super tight and every game of this we've played has come down to one or two moves at the very end in terms of determining the winner it did not end up on my top 50. i can't believe that because i i don't know because you're an ernac fanboy and you can't get rid of your bias first of all i'm a fan girl now keep in mind the first head in the sand the first time we played dune imperium we played it for 17 hours because we played it wrong it wasn't 17.
the best experience and then the second time i wasn't even close to winning it wasn't 17 hours okay obviously it wasn't 79. the second time i wasn't even close to winning and you know how that makes me feel so we need to play more my number six is another one by sir john d claire he's not knighted but i like to pretend that he is and that is qubitos ugh i love this game this game is everything okay it has everything it's bright it's colorful it has racing it has push your luck it is little cube animals it's funny it makes me laugh i always win it's great i love it so much this is just a racing game you're in this like cube land and you're just racing and there's so much variability this game i recommend a lot of people have asked us what do we prefer between quacks and cubitos and i always say like uh i don't that's pretty easy for me i don't really compare them that much no they can live harmoniously but obviously according to my list i would prefer qubitos if i had to make the choice between them i love this game so so much i i'm not shocked by that at all my number five is a game we also have not played in a hot minute but uh i think next board game weekend i would like to pull this one out that is gaia project okay so that was on your list last year at number seven so it has gone up guy project is a re-themed reskinned version of terra mystica you are building out a bit of a tech tree in order to fulfill aspects of a gaia project essentially which includes i
don't want to say terraforming but like because that's like terrifying but it is kind of like terraforming planets building out satellite different building types factories to score uh victory points really love the theme i'm a big space guy as you're aware a guy project is just again a product of not having the play group there's an element here of me picking games that i don't get to play because we're two player primary yep that i absolutely love and probably would always want to play if i had a group of four yeah i mean my number five favorite game of all time is fort from leader games okay this is a deck builder where you're a bunch of kids you're building up forts you're getting toys of pizza make friends stealing your friends from other people you're just trying to build your fort the fastest this is the game that every time jeff's like well what do you want to play if i don't know there's two games i go for i won't mention the other one yet but this is always one that i will pull out i can attest to that always i and i rarely ever win this game no she does rarely but i love it it's very good it's so good i love it i love the art it's kyle fahren art it's leader game so you know it's good it is a deck builder game but you can you know take cards from the playground or you can steal from your opponent's backyard and so the deck building aspect becomes a very interesting part of this game when we play because we're only stealing each other's friends so our decks are very small we're so competitive but i'm just like i don't want you to have him i don't want you to have her so anyways yeah i just i love this game i always
have fun so we're moving into top four this was the hardest part of my ranking any one of these four could have been anywhere in this one to four in my opinion all four of these are one i know what three of them are it's just they all live there my number four favorite game of all time is vast crystal caverns my number four favorite game of all time is the first one this is going to be our only crossover vast crystal caverns is a purely asymmetrical game wherein you have one sole objective it is basically to defeat one other person on the board yeah unless i believe you're playing as the thief and you're just trying to steal stuff you're trying to just steal stuff or the cave which the cave is trying to build out itself and then collapse itself onto everyone that's it there's no board the cave is your board you're playing as the board and you're building out the board as you play it is incredible and i don't understand why more people don't play this game or why it doesn't get more love no i have no idea i looked this up on bgg it's in the 600s yeah people are very intimidated by this game but one thing i will say is i was too at first this game is so much easier to learn than root if you're like if you can learn root you can very easily learn fast i very easily i've struggled a little bit with people that have said that you know crystal caverns is difficult to learn because in my opinion you just need to learn your one fact your your one player ability yeah you would want it to have one person who
kind of knows how everything works but other than that everybody else just needs to know their facts it's so good we love vast so much it competes with the initiative in terms of my favorite gaming moment of last it was my favorite gaming it is so good i cannot wait to play it more we have not played mysterious manor yet we do own it my number four and jamie's number four from leader games vast crystal caverns so good so good love it so so so much you're very curious about my top no no i know what at least two of them are my number three favorite game yes of all time is res arcana okay i knew that would be there as jaime has already alluded to res arcana is a fantasy themed engine builder the thing i love most about res arcana is there is a draft variant that you can play wherein you draft your hand and makes it a little bit easier to build synergy but where i love res arcana the best is that you are dealt a hand of cards and it is up to you to figure out how to make those cards work deal with what you're dealt you are essentially laying out cards and building up resources in order to buy places of power which allow you to build out your engine even further and score victory points first person to 10 wins and it has one of the coolest first player abilities i've ever seen in a game wherein if you are first player you get a victory point first person to pass their turn in a round gets to be first player that's the victory the victory res arcana is one of my most played
games of last year and every time i play it i love it more and more and more my number three game of all time was on my list last year as my number three it is still my number three and that is mansions of madness i love this game i love this game there i don't think there's a cthulhu game that could ever touch mansions of madness for me i love the fact that it has an app that makes it very atmospheric i love that it is so challenging like you're gonna lose this game and i think in these types of games that's something that you want to happen it's very challenging but not so bad that you can't win except for a couple soon a couple of them took us a long time but we did end up beating them eventually i have never gotten bored of this game i think like we will go into big spurts of this game and then we'll put it away for a while and then we'll pull it out again and as soon as we pull it out again i want to play it again and again and again and i need to give you some breaks from it i think so i'm very excited to pull this out again this year and hopefully maybe get some more of the expansions because we only have sanctum of twilight so we only have one yeah this game will just never get old for me i i just i love it i really love it there's certain games that we'll play one time and jamie like you wanna go again again and that's one of them there's only a few that she's like that with and mansions and madnesses yeah definitely one and when we were playing cthulhu death may die i think some people thought maybe it would challenge manchester madison but it would never
yeah i was like yeah it's too fighty for you yeah not enough i like the pa like this game is puzzly like you have to solve different things and there's a challenge to it there's a challenge in cthulhu death may die as well very much more railed though like in terms of like there's not a ton of like exploration it's just rolling dice defeating monsters exactly yeah my number two favorite game of all i know exactly what you're talking from stone meyer games is sides this was your number four last year i could do a whole video talking about my love for scythe we actually have a video on the channel all about science if you'd like to go watch it we all love scythe jamie loves scythe jason loves scythe i don't know where zach lands on it but um jason absolutely adores scythe so it's always a pleasure to play that with him i'm looking at my computer my background is from scythe it's the first game you ever found it's first game i ever painted i love the theme the dystopian kind of like alternate reality industrial world i love mex it's beautiful this game is beautiful we have everything almost everything for it i don't have the big modular board but that's because we tend to put it yeah we don't have a place rise and finish is one of the my favorite gaming moments ever such a great campaign-esque addition to this game i i can't say enough i don't think it'll ever move out of my top five i knew that was gonna be there and i know what your number one is man my number
two favorite game of all time is overboss from brother wise games i love this game i love this game i love this game i love this game i felt betrayed when it was at number 40 something on jeff's lift jess j i think i just had a mini stroke you need to break two on jeff's list we've played this a lot together but i this is my most played solo game ever is my favorite game to play solo you have a different affinity for it i do there's just something about it that i just love like i love the puzzle of it i love like optimizing where i put people i like the variety i am really hoping that more content will be put out for this game more terrains and monsters and expansions whatever there's so much that they could do here and i just love it it's beautiful nobody talks about how pretty this game is have you seen the cover i love the other insane it's beautiful i love it and i will forever talk the good graces of overboss oh we loved it so much we had zach's coffee he moved back from egypt he tried to take it back from us because he owned it and so i just bought him a new copy and just kept this one because i'm like no i can't not have this game in my collection yep so that's over boss my number two not surprised you know what my number one is then right yes okay i've known about yours since the very beginning yeah my number one favorite game of all time is from leader games that is root i told you i loved root the first time i played it at two wasn't great but i still had a very good time with it i loved it at our three player player
count with uh jamie and jason who did you play i was the woodlawn alliance right and you guys were the birds and the cats i believe i absolutely just love root to jamie's point i think she mentioned it in her take on it we primarily play on the app now which has been great i mean it's a great way for people to get into root and i'm so happy that jamie has gotten into it because when the marauders expansion comes out that will mean probably we get to play it more yeah i do wish we were able to play this more in person with people because i have everything for it i love everything to do with roots super cute i love root too so good adorable so many so many things i could say that is my number one favorite game of all time i predicted it root later games i mean you knew i knew i was like there's no way this is not number one i was like kind of going back and forth i thought scythe might be your number one but again i think any of those four would be able to have an argument for number one yeah now i assume that this is going to come to no shock to anyone at all but my number one game of all time is agricola just kidding i gotcha that's not even close my number one game of all time is villainous this was my number one game last year as well i don't it's going to take a lot it's going to take they stop doing expansions yeah i love disney like there is nothing in the world besides you know we're not talking about friends family and the animals that i love more than disney i
love that i love that you had the caveat yeah well i mean obviously villainous is was one of our intro games we have everything it is displayed very prominently in our basement in our board game shelves i hope that they never stop making expansions for this it is my favorite game to play and then we had our villainous tournament i'm sure many of you thought that my love would dwindle but guess what it did not that was just a weird day usually i win way more than that that was one of the best days ever i can't get enough of this game it's perfect two-player game i love all of the characters some more than others i'm very excited for the new expansion that's coming out because it has madame nim in it and i love madame mim and you actually saw i wouldn't say predicted it but you she was on my most anticipated like if i could pick we might have a video coming up about that in the future so okay we won't talk too much about that but she was on the list so i have to take her off of the list that's my number one it's gonna take a lot for that to ever change ever like ever and that is our top 10 board games of all time it has been a journey we've gone through 50 games i believe we will probably try and do this every year yeah just to see how things change so many people have been doing their top 10 so now that you're finished watching ours you should definitely if you haven't already before you play just did theirs all you can board just did theirs board game barrage just did theirs and
so so many more people i've seen tons of them come out so i always i think it's so much fun to see what kind of games people love and it always gives you great ideas for what to add to your list yeah i really love these lists and i think it's cool to do them every year depending on how long we're in this hobby which we think is going to be a very long time for red you know we can look back and see how we've evolved as gamers um every year and i think that's a really neat exercise and something very exciting also our next video is going to be kyle's top 10 games of all time if you missed the announcement kyle is joining our channel for a video a month and he's kicking it off with the top 10 because he also wants you to get to know him and his gaming preferences a little bit better which are going to be very very somewhat similar to some will be similar to mine kyle likes some big boys yeah kyle kyle is a completely different dynamic than ours in terms of game likes very different for mine betcha grickle is on that list oh probably those are our top 50 games of all time let us know down below what some of your favorites are let us know if we surprised you were you surprised about villainous you shouldn't have been if you are interested in buying board games like any of the 50 that we have talked about so far you should first start by checking your friendly local gaming store and for us here in halifax that is the boardroom game cafe heck yeah it is thank you guys so much for watching if you like what you see please subscribe we hope to see you again soon and now we say goodbye if you can hear that noise our heat pump just kicked in
anyways it's all good in the hood hello everyone and welcome back to foster the meeple a channel all about you started that i was like four years guys we had to start again you said okay and then you immediately started to rub my face touching your face okay okay okay yeah i'm not a donkey donkey is there something like sticking out of that eye i can't say anything okay jeff then it doesn't exist you're accurate on all of those things i am accurate if nothing else yeah and this is a game like that we've only really played one time no we've played it twice we did yeah yeah anyways we've only played it however many times just so everybody knows if the camera angle has changed slightly it is because our battery died so right at the end right at the end all right
you