19 Board Games Ranked - Episode 7
Transcript
hey everybody and welcome to another installment of month in review so this is a series of videos where i take a look back at all the new to me games i played during the previous month at this installment being november 2021 and i rank those games from my least favorite to my most favorite giving brief descriptions of those games along the way so i've got a big variation of games this month with 19 new titles plus one expansion ranging from pretty unknown fellow games to some big blockbuster titles so excited to talk about these and i will say um as a general this month has been really strong so um generally i probably only have a small portion that gets my kind of shield of quality my elite shield this one's been a bit more generous or maybe i've been in a bit more of a generous mood this month so and before i get started on these games i just want to give a shout out to kianda dot co uk who are my online retailer to go to in the uk and if you check out the show notes i'll leave a little discount code there for you um so you can pick up a good discount and some good games but let's get started on the uh on the list so the only expansion i've played this month or the only new to me expansion is the valhalla expansion to champions of midgard so if you've ever followed what i've said about midgar our champions midgard in the past it's a work replacement game that uses dice it's kind of like a hybrid ameritrash um euro game um that i'm lukewarm on to say um you know to be generous it's it's very generic for me i don't really get much enjoyment from it this one does however soften that blow of the random dice rolls where if you actually do fluff a roll in this one you actually get some kind of incentive builder where you can get more powerful dice and stuff so i do like that it's kind of mitigated if you do just have a
a terrible turn um but i would say ultimately it's not changed my mind on the game i still think it's very generic but if i am asked to play again i will certainly always say let's play with the valhalla expansion because it does as i said just take that edge off the randomness and let's get started on the actual game so at number 19 i'm not quite saying this one actually because this is a game called uh this game is poo pooh so this was actually sent to me by an independent publisher i think it's only a two-man company um or a male and female who absolutely lovely people but unfortunately the game is absolutely dreadful so this is a kind of a a exploding kitten style thing where you're drawing cards off the top of a deck um you know you do take that on other players snatching cards from the hand and the idea of this one is you'll try to play pairs of cards together um in order to score victory points but you can end up taking points and stuff and ends up just being a game of top decking and hoping to get the good cards so a complete random mess unfortunately does nothing new whatsoever and i suppose the only novelty about the game is the actual theme or the artwork where it's quite crude and um some quite funny cards and puns and stuff but maybe for a stocking filler just for a quick cheap laugh it's maybe something to go to but the gameplay itself is um certainly not to scratch so that is this game is poo at number 18 i have design town this goes back to 2016 and is a push your luck style game as you're trying to collect currency by kind of fanning through your deck of cards then using that currency to either upgrade buildings or to buy new buildings to add to your um at your deck basically and then you're trying to
basically get a number of these points out at once in order to score well there are some kind of alternative strategies as well um generally push a lot games are pretty much unanimously a hit with me because i do tend to like that mechanism i do tend to like these games because i think it's just cheap easy fun and it's always kind of guaranteed a good time but somehow and design town men managed to make pushy luck not fun so that's um that's probably uh the biggest criticism i can give of this game it's not good at all it takes a very long time to get going considering this next to no strategy it's a pretty horrible game that i wouldn't recommend at all so that is design town at number 18. at number 17 i have a relatively unknown filler game with treelings uh trading's azure came out last year and it's a kind of a card drafting um style game as you are i'm taking cards it's really beautiful illustrated cards from this common supply or common pool and you are either taking all the cards of one color or as many cards as you want as long as there's only one available and then you're adding them to your tableau and trying to build these towers because the higher towers you get the more points you get however if you have a tower that's overshadowed by a neighboring tower then they don't score anything at all and that actually applies to your neighbors as well so your neighbour players so like the my play to my left furthest right card if it's taller than my furthest left card then my furthest left card will be worth nothing if that makes sense so it works pretty well nothing revolutionary at all but pretty quick i said very pretty to look at and but ultimately there's a sea of brilliant filler games out there and this one's just okay at best
at number 16 i have fiesta mexicana which actually came out in 2020 against very little fanfare i didn't know about this game um this one is a bidding auction style game as you were trying to claim these different dishes and put them on your kind of a banquet table i'm scoring points in different ways you've got endgame objectives but also the tiles just have pure points on them and you're getting like kind of rows and columns and stuff um this game did certainly try to be different in terms of the way the um the bidding mechanism worked where all your different spots where you put these dishes on your board have numbers or bits assigned to them and whenever you i think it's lose a bid or another player ends up winning you actually rotate your board clockwise or anti-clockwise which will reveal a whole new bunch of bids that you can choose from so the more you play with the more of these options or your your choices get windowed down and then you don't have so many um you know so many options to choose from so you've got to be careful when you use those higher numbers um it sounds really cool as a concept but i think in practice it certainly did take quite a bit away from the from the kind of dynamic nature of auction games you're very much limited to what you could do at times if somebody goes straight with a high bid you can't just say let's have a bidding war and keep going higher and higher and higher you can't do that so it kind of lost a bit of the magic that you'd expect but still full props are trying to be different but um ultimately still way too many better auction games out there to make this one kind of stand out so yeah unfortunately i can't recommend fiesta mexicana at number 15 i have fearsome flaws if
you like the alliteration or you recognize the alliteration you probably know this is a freedom and freeze game dating back to 2003 so 18 years i'm old now this one is a pretty simple um kind of a token moving game is you have your basically your little team and you're traveling around this dungeon trying to get to the escape before the other players do and however there is this monster that's traveling around and potentially like gobbling up other players or sending them back to the start or even removing them from the game altogether and there's somewhat kind of a random element to it where you don't know how far this monster's moving um but you can kind of plan because you you know how that monster moves and who is likely going to chase after so you got to use that to your advantage you got to use this line of sight to advantage by you kind of hiding behind these towers and stuff um it's okay i think probably the best thing about this one is that it does scale so well i mean i think it scales from two to about seven i mean not many games do that so if you do want something a bit different that's not a pure party game to cater for those higher play accounts then maybe give this one a look but again the rest of the gameplay is pretty vanilla and nothing special so that is fearsome flaws at number 15.
at number 14 i have taj mahal which is actually again going back to the year 2000 so something 21 years old now uh this one is a rhinocannicia classic i suppose you can call it and as you're trying to manage this hand of cards with all these different symbols on them and then these symbols are going to or basically the idea is you're trying to have as many of these symbols exposed as you can and then choose to kind of fold when you have the most symbols in order to get a bonus and you're basically trying to put these markers to show that you're controlling these different cities and build a big network and connect them together to get more points um i would have i would say about this game it does feel a bit dated which is not normally something i say about rhinocero games i thought that the network building was a pretty uninspiring and it didn't really you know considering the work sometimes you had to put in to get these um to get these particular cities it didn't feel like the payoff was that satisfying um the scoring was again a bit lackluster it didn't really um it didn't really pop and it just felt a bit flat for me i'm glad i played it because i know this is considered a bit of a classic but unfortunately the fun factor wasn't there for me and it just felt a bit restrained and a bit a bit too small for me if that makes sense it it just didn't it didn't strike that normal kinesia spark that he normally does with me um so yeah unfortunately again i can't recognize um recommend taj mahal despite you know despite being a popular game that stood there or certainly remained in print for a long long time so yeah that's taj mahal at number 14.
at number 13 i have pungi uh pongi again another game i hadn't heard of this one dates back to 2017 and is a very small card game you know filler game that takes about 20 minutes to play and this one kind of strikes the feeling or kind of rings bells of a game like for sale or you're trying to collect these cards and the order in which these cards are displayed um it matters quite a lot because you know if it's the furthest to the left you might want to pay the strongest card if there's a third to the right you want to play the weakest card to make sure you claim that card and those cards are going to be points or they can even be negative points and they can also be these things to convert negative points into positive points but i like this game that almost has a trick taking feel to it where the first person is going to play a card and you're going to know the suit of that card but you don't know the number of that card or the strength or value of that card so you know they could have played a very low value they could have played a high value and then you've got to either try and you can play the same type and maybe try and get higher or lower just taking a you know an educated guess or you can try and change the suit and maybe jump them further behind the lines and use that to your advantage so again it kind of merges that for sale thing where you're getting things in order and trick taking and i think this one works surprisingly well probably better than it should do i just had quite a lot of fun with this one i don't think it's anywhere near as good as a game like for sale but for a certain change of pace and something a bit different this one is certainly something i'd play again and i'll happily do that because it's quite snappy it's concise um next to no rules on it and it's it's pretty good fun so that is pongi at number 13.
at number 12 i have gloomhaven jaws of the lion so this is the kind of introductory version of the goliath hit um gloomhaven which is a kind of a story driven um like a combat style game that has a lot of europe mechanisms but again kind of a hybrid between a a dungeon crawler and an euro game um i can't really cover too much of this game because it is so big but you're basically playing these characters working together trying to overcome these bad guys i'm going through a series of stories um using your powers your advantage i think the card system in this game is pretty damn clever as you're playing two cards at a time one of them is going to be the initiative i.e the speed you do your action and the other one's going to be the action and then you kind of can take a upper action and lower action and you're going to use that to travel around you can use it to fight bad guys to heal yourself to use um unique abilities as well all using or going through this kind of illustrated storybook so i think the ambition of this game is absolutely mind-blowing i mean the degree of detail and this game is pretty much like a gamer's version of dungeons and dragons if you want a gamified version where you're not just rolling dice and hoping to get good luck then this is a real good option and the story is pretty generic you know nothing special there but again it does have all these stuff you'd expect from a dungeon quality got your kind of area effect powers you can again boost people and you know buff people and travel around and interact with people it's so so big in scope um but
it was one of those games i never really got to play or we'll see this on the new to me games list um but i'm really at least i can say you know this is a game that i've played now i know what it offers um it's not a game for me because i'm not willing to pour the time and effort that game like this requires um it felt a little bit too grindy for me where you're just constantly slogging through bad guys just hacking them to bits i felt a bit samey but despite that i can't help but applaud um how well the design the design is put together and um i can certainly see why it's such a monster hit so yeah unfortunately not a game for me but one that i can completely um commend that is uh gleam haven jaws of the lion and number 11 i have again going back to 2015 by alexander fister this is a broom service so probably with an alexander vista game you're expecting something you know the big um huge euro star games you're upgrading things and the multi-use cards this one is certainly a change of direction of that it's a very simple pick up and deliver game using a pretty interesting hand management system where everyone's got a the exact identical set of cards and these cards gonna you kind of travel around the board they're gonna let you pick up potions and deposit them and move clouds around to get points um but this has a really cool unique system where you can either choose to take a brave action on those cards or a cowardly action and when you take a brave action you get kind of an amped up version of it where you can get things done quicker or get more points for doing those actions but you run the risk of being trumped by another player who comes after you in turn order because if they also have selected that card and they can take the stronger version as
well and leave you kind of out of pocket and not being able to do anything or you can choose to take the cowardly action where you're guaranteed to do it but it's not as strong so i did like that system i think the only reason why this one um isn't going to be a big hit for me is because i have other other kind of pick up and deliver style games that i enjoy quite a bit more but i'll say if i didn't have those games i would certainly um pretty consider keeping broome service around because it does work pretty well very smooth and it has that unique card system but a good game a very near miss for me um but yeah not one that's going to be sticking around that is broom service at number 11. at number 10 i have probably the lightest game on this list this is skull dating back to 2011. and this is a pushy luck bluffing style game as you are basically putting these coasters down face down in front of you and then eventually you're choosing to bid to see how many of these coasters you can flip over without revealing a skull that's pretty much the extent of the rules but as you kind of um as you reveal these skulls you lose a life and limit your options and what you can do um and i would say i wasn't sure what i'd expect from this game because i've always had loads of people loving it so it's a great um a great game that caters to you know six players uh really low rules overhead a lot of fun laughter loud moments but i was struggling to see where that was going to play out in the rule set um because again it's one of those games you have to play for yourself to understand the nuances and the player interaction the kind of the the fun it creates but really like this one i think this is going to be a bit of a go-to when i do
have that six player account and it's a certain it feels a certain niche that a lot of party games don't because you're not you know you're not drawing or playing word games this one is a like bluffing and pushy like style thing work which normally um pushy like games don't cater to six players so really enjoyed this one and it's going to be sticking around in my collection okay so let's get into the top nine and um i will say this these are where my shield of qualities are gonna start so at number nine i have a big surprise hit with a game called darkness uh doc mistakes back to 2016. and it really does ring bells to those kind of root building rhinocannicia games as you're placing your markers down on the board i'm trying to build networks trying to get next to things i'm in order to score victory points not when you're trying to get up across next to all these kind of monuments on a particular tile but you're always trying to get on all the tiles and because you can get points in different ways but i love how dynamic this game is because at the start of each round you are going to be drafting from these god powers and these god power is going to let you manipulate the bald state by sliding things around or rotating them so the board is always constantly in flux and you can kind of link things around and build networks and expand off it's a really interesting game again it really does come alive um really pure and in his elegance and um again it does really strike the um record of games like babylonia through the desert that kind of thing um but done really well so i'm really enjoying this one again a big surprise for me um if you like those style games give dogmas a look because again it's a really well put together
game that is docmuss at number nine at number eight i have a feast for odin uh dating back to 2016 and this is considered um uva rosenberg's biggest game it's um the biggest in scope is you're trying to um do the traditional polyamino style thing as you'd expect from a nouveau game but this one is certainly bigger in scope it's a work replacement game where you have a ton of workers and a massive worker placement board to do pretty much anything you can think of collecting goods converting goods into other goods you ought to feed your vikings on this banquet table you can go whaling you can go hunting and you can build boats there's so much you can do in this game you know you you name it and this game does it um i will say this game is certainly a an initial impressions review i think some does have a potential to get better or go higher for me i still think it's pretty well done um surprisingly easy to play i'm considering how again how big it is in scope i thought it was going to be quite a bit more fiddly and a bit more convoluted but it's actually pretty simple and pretty smooth um and i will say i did absolutely terrible in this game i think this is a game that's going to reward repeated plays to see what works and what doesn't you've got a bit of engine building um you've got some card play as well um that really is everything going on you could think of in this game um but for some reason i was left a little bit maybe a slightly bit underwhelmed because of the hype of this game and i think because it really is so sandboxy the first time you play it you really don't know where to go you don't know where to start um but this is certainly one of those games when i finished i thought yeah that was good i
enjoyed it but as the kind of time went by i was thinking you know that was really clever next time i would have done this i would have done this so i do need to play this more before i get my final thoughts out there but at least this moment of time is going to sit with a shield of quality and a comfortable recommendation for me but is it going to be something that's going to stick around and i'm going to keep playing consistently so um that still is yet to be determined but at the moment it's looking good so that is a feast for odin at number eight uh at number seven i have this search for planet x so this is a sci-fi themed deduction game as you're trying to find planet x you're trying to find out where all these different um spacings are you know your comets and your asteroids and things and meteors and they all have different rules to do with how they how they kind of react on the board or the um you know how they interact with one another um you're using an app to give you unique rules and expose things to you so you can use that to your advantage introduce things but the thing i really liked about this game more than anything was this time system where you could be quite vague in your um in your questions or what you're asking for you know you might say is there a comment between space one and space five and it will give you quite vague information for doing so um but you cost you less time however if you go for something very specific and you want to know something very you know in particular then it's going to cost you more time but going to give you more concrete evidence so i thought that was a really cool thing to do and of course the people behind keep taking turns until they catch up with the people who've used more time so it's a real cool spin on on the deduction genre where i normally
find that deduction game people normally finish in the same kind of ballpark um you know unless you're terrible at these games but yeah this game did certainly um kind of expand that and mean that if particularly good players can be quite a bit better than someone who doesn't really know what they're doing but at the moment really in turn this one can see why it's been a big hit last year and certainly one of the best deduction games i've ever played that is uh the search for planet x at number six i have a brand new game from 2021 this is savannah park by wolfgang kramer and michael kiesling a very family friendly level game a puzzle-style game if you're trying to move these animals from spot to spot try to create these groups of the same animals and get watering holes in them because they're going to give you a score multiplied on how many animals are there so if you had say two watering holes um in a group of um five elephants you'll get ten points because two times five is ten um however you've got to be very careful about where you put these tiles because if you put them next to these bush fires then you are gonna potentially lose those tiles if you put them in the wrong space um and it's just a real cool satisfying puzzle it plays quite a bit differently depending on the player count i'm a bit more chaotic with more players but that doesn't actually go against the game which is normally something i would say it does um but i need to react to the bald state create gaps so that you know someone chooses a particular tile you have somewhere to move it to really enjoy this one if this one's gonna um age well i think it's um so pure what it does and has a wide variety of people who can enjoy this one from ranging from children up to more against
salty gamers and um yeah i think this is a lot of fun and you wouldn't really expect much less from a design duo like creamer and keisling so that is savannah park at number six at number five i have another freedom and freeze game with a free ride so this is his brand new game and it's a train game so as you expect with a train game this is a route building star games you're trying to connect city to city by building this rail track however when you complete one of these tracks you're going to claim it as your own and then it means it's going to be free for you to use but for other people to use it's going to cost them a coin and coin also money in this game is so valuable it's a significant amount of points so you can't really be too flippant on when you're going to spend these coins and use other people's tracks and additionally as soon as you use it it becomes public domain for everybody so just add even more weight to that decision and other than that you are just kind of collecting these cards which show different locations you're trying to deposit from one or starting one location deposit to another location and get points for doing so so very simple um very little rules overhead um but this game just does what it does very well it's almost like a eurofied ticket to ride and i'm really enjoying it at the moment i think it scales pretty well from three to five um maybe four being the sweet spot where you just cut that tightness um where you know track becomes gobbled up a bit quicker but it still ticks along very nicely um again you can get to get this on the table get it going pretty quickly because again you've only got a few actions which you can take um so yeah the game is going to be very easy to explain and get going and again these games do stick do tend to do well for me where you know if i go
back to this one in a year's time it's certainly not going to be a uh a lot of work to go back and learn the rules so yeah really enjoying this one i don't have a game like this in my collection and i've actually reviewed this one already so go check out that video if you're interested in a free ride at number four another brand new game or semi-brand new game this is furnace so furnace is a pretty simple engine building and bidding style game as you are trying to claim these different industries um by using these bidding tokens and ranging from one to four four being your strongest and the highest bid on each of these cards is going to win the card and add it to their engine but the people who've bid lower than that are actually going to get a resource in a separate area of that card and that is a really fascinating mechanism for me you know sometimes you want to go high because you get the resources multiplied by the token that you placed but you don't go too high because you might not even want to win the card in the first place and once that's done you're going to run your engine you can either do it kind of freely or you can do a strict locked in engine where you go from left to right converting resources into other resources and trying to get as many points as you can very quick very snappy and it takes about half an hour to 40 minutes to play um really excited to see the potential of this game because although i think this game is excellent i think this game could be truly phenomenal with some real meaty um expansion content so yeah really enjoying this one at the moment i'm excited to play this one pretty sharply again uh that is furnace at number four at number three i have a game that i've been after for a long long time just been fulfilled on kickstarter as a
reprint by queen uh this is wallenstein so wardenstein goes back to 2012 at least the uh the second edition does this is a kind of a hybrid war and euro game as you're trying to control as many regions so you can because you get points based on how many regions you control you're building these buildings to get even more points but the way you do these things are so interesting as every reason you control is going to correlate to a certain card then you're going to use this card to place on your own player board on these different action slots which means that this particular action is going to happen in this location so that could be bolstering your troops it could be attacking an adjacent region it could be taxing that region or getting grain from that region because you need to feed your people and if you um if you go too hard on taxing and again harvesting food from the same regions again and again then you're really upping the chance of the of that particular region revolting against you and potentially losing it because it's um yeah it's a real delicate balancing act um on top of all that you've got this awesome combat system where when you go into a new region you're going to take a bunch of cubes that you used to attack with on the ones you've attacked and you're going to chuck them in this cube tower and then they're going to kind of pair off and eliminate each other and who's left standing is going to be the winner yes it's still semi-random and it is pretty chaotic but because if you do particularly badly in a fight your cube's going to remain in that cube tower and can potentially come and bolster you later and which happened quite a few times in our game you know some big surprising outcomes to those battles what an interesting dynamic game is nothing else really like that like it on the market and um i really enjoyed it so that is
wallenstein at number three at number two i have witchstone which is another brand new game from 2021 and this one is however a co-design with ryan kenicia and another gentleman who i forgot his name um this one is a real point standard style game that uses that ryan kenicia ingenious system where you're putting these tiles on your player board and the more you kind of compound these actions together and connect them you get stronger and stronger versions of them and they're using that to go around this pentagram and get victory points or going up this magic wand and getting points in different ways and getting kind of area control on this um kind of a magical ball in the center of the crystal ball um so much going on here i love how balanced all the different all the different areas of the board are gorgeous production um another game with extremely low rules overhead but still has a great amount of depth here particularly in relation to the potential to combo your actions you know where you can do this action which will combo this actually which will come with this and by the end of it you know tracking your action you're getting so much done on a single turn which just kind of offers a really satisfying experience i've had high hopes for this one you know my expectations were sky high and this one certainly lived up to those expectations and i expect this one to sit quite highly on my top 10 games of the year because i enjoyed it that much got straight into the collection and um yeah loving it that is which stone at number two and finally my favorite game of the month is capital lux 2 generations so this is actually a game from last year
and a game i really didn't know much about until my good friend mackenzie franklin from side game llc i recommended this one to me he said i'd like it um i picked it up and boy oh boy was he right this is one of the best car games i've ever played it has so much depth so much going on amazing variability as you have a hand of cards um of different suits and different values um and you are basically either choosing to play these in front of you for scoring or playing them in the city in order to get bonuses or special powers which sometimes you might not even want um but you've got to be careful to balance the two because if you have say um six points in front of you but you only have five in the city then you're going to go bust and not score anything so you've got to keep them make sure they're balanced and make sure that you're not going higher than what the city offers but of course all these different powers by going to the cities can really manipulate that um it has a clever little draft before it gets started and the progression of this game is phenomenal so it's broken down into three phases and keeping your cards alive from start to finish is so so tense because in a drop of a hat you can lose everything um if you don't play carefully and i love the way that the market's constantly changing and sometimes if you win these cards and by having the closest to that amount then you actually get to take one from the from the city and add it to your final scoring which will of course throw everything off and you have to start bolstering it again to make sure that you're not losing your cards in front of you i will be reviewing this one very shortly and um again if you've not heard of this one and you like clever card games um ones with simple elegant rules but just
tremendous amount of depth um nuances um layers this one is pretty much as good as it gets and you know what i've only played the initial setup um and i still love it this much a absolutely outstanding game um a no-brainer for my elite shield and this one is going to come pretty highly on my top 50 next year i can see it now okay so that concludes this installment of a month in review i hope you've enjoyed it i hope there's something on here that's popped up that you maybe didn't know about before something that's piqued your interest okay nice variation here and you know to have nine games that um that have received a shield is quite unlikely you know it doesn't really happen i normally only get say five you know four or five so it has been a really strong month so um yeah i've enjoyed talking about these games and hopefully as i said something here has um caught your interest so i hope you've enjoyed this video that if you have please hit like and subscribe my channel and check out my other videos too additionally if you want to support the channel by going an extra mile i do have a patreon page where you can back for as little as two pound a month and of course as always if you live in the uk and you love board games go check out kianda dot co dot uk for a great selection and for everyone else i'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye