Skip to main content
Loading video...

Top 10 Board Game Inserts - Casual Friday ft. Jennifer Graham-Macht of Keymaster Games

Transcript 57:02

are we talking about that on this this button yeah exactly well that that's one of the reasons why i think a lot of people would be like this insert sucks hey everyone this is jack from the cardboard herald and two quick things before we get into our top 10 greatest inserts of all time five each from myself and guest co-host jennifer graham mack now first off jennifer is of key master games which you may be familiar with from being the publisher of parks which has just about as amazing of an insert as can possibly be which makes jennifer an ideal subject matter expert to have for this conversation but we decided in all fairness to disqualify parks from consideration on the top of our list but if you want a real good insert you should probably check that out second thing is that this is a long one i mean you get it you're looking at the time count below going like jack i see that it's long what's up with this well the thing is is that jennifer brings that great expertise and publisher perspective that allowed us to talk about so many interesting things in relation to inserts that are both from the gamer end user perspective and the publisher perspective like accounting for sleeves accounting for future content the cost of production on these things and i think that this is well worth keeping the the

full spectrum of discussion included in the video that said we did have a pretty lengthy intro discussion about one the inspiration for this list which was actually kind of a funny story and two some of the challenges that went into us putting our respective lists together if you want that full shebang all of it is going to be available in the podcast version of this that's going up on the podcast channel as soon as this goes up on the video channel and we'll have links below but for now we're just going to get straight into going back and forth on our top tens greatest inserts of all time with myself and guest co-host jennifer graham mack of key master games enjoy the show jennifer why don't you take us away with your number five on your list my number five on my list is dice throne season two uh i like it yeah yeah uh these aren't i won't say that these are like in um like definitive order um but i would put yeah yeah this is not like a hard and fast like the number one is like solidly my number one because that would be like really really really hard it's not going to be written on your grave right i'm not not that's not a hill i'm dying on uh dice thrown season two uh what they did and they ended up going back and they liked it so much they went back and repackaged season one to do the same thing because they basically were like

yeah this is a way better experience than than what original season one is um and it was the right decision i think it's the right decision i actually didn't get the repackaged season one and i was like i kind of wish i got the repackage season one so each character um dice throne if you don't know is um a dueling game a dice dueling game a yahtzee style with asymmetric characters that um have really interesting abilities and uh abilities that you can upgrade along the way and it's just a it's just a dueling game you're just trying to knock out your opponent you can play it at more than two players but it is an excellent two-player experience so it definitely has uh high marks in my household what what i like like the high this high level this is that usability thing is that your personal stuff comes in a package so you have smaller boxes right um which they which they did so that they could sort of uh improve the the the um you know like reduce the barrier um to the accessibility of the game instead of having to buy into a group of six characters you could just be like hey if you just want two here's the smaller package that you can grab and just do it one versus one a head-to-head battle um so you open up that box and then there's two trays um and i guess we should just get game trays out of the way now just have that quick conversation exactly right exactly whether whether you like it know it or not game trace has become um a leader in developing inserts uh

so it makes it onto the list several times in several different places um and i you know like it's it's interesting to me that there's no real competitor for them at this point um uh but so they develop these trays and and it's just a personal like your personal things everything you need to play dice thrown comes in a little package that you just take out of the box hand to the person and even from there like it's snapped so nothing's ever gonna get disheveled it's got a snap lid so you can't get you know tossed around or anything like that and then you unpackage it and it's like even from like the top down the way you unpack and get into your personal box matches how you would want to set up your gameplay prepares you right away to play you don't have to deal with excess components like that that's a big part of it to me is that by sectoring it out into the the individual boxes or tubs that you don't have to deal with like all of the setup involved in a full player count game or all the components that are irrelevant to your character which is a huge boon you know like one of the complaints about board games for a lot of people is the time that it takes in order to play and if you get set up and take down to be easier and more efficient and less overwhelming then not only are you more mentally prepared for playing but you're taking up less time

in order to do it yeah and maybe dice throne is um uh already well set up for this because there's no central board there are no uh central components that you're having to uh to manage you're not like giving somebody like universal control of that thing um and and so that aids to it and and that's sort of like out of the perfect what we're talking about but it's it's definitely relevant to say hey this was already uniquely positioned to be a great experience but it's important that uh roxly recognized that and leaned into it and like recognized the opportunity to make um that setup experience so simple because they want their game like it's a yahtzee style game there's zero reason for uh that is a dice run is a great gateway gateway step above gateway experience for uh gaming um and it's an awesome game to throw out on the table it's really accessible for kids so just like increasing the potential for a game to get on the table because of ease of use in that way um made it uh made it a huge plus for me well my number five and this is a completely different perspective than yours is five tribes and the reason why five tribes is in this is actually uh related to another game when i first started getting into modern tabletop games i i played the katans and i i played a few other games that were available but i was blown away by small world and

small world was like the first time where i saw everything having a relatively meticulous uh place within the box or comparatively to other games and so days of wonder made a really big impression on me just from opening up that box and seeing the treasure show of within you had the removable little tubs that had all the different cardboard tokens for all the different characters as i played it more i realized that there were little annoying bits that things didn't just quite fit in or i wish they'd done something differently but there was like a recapitulate of this experience that i had when i got five tribes and it combines two of the aspects that i really like in an insert one it has all the different spots for the different like citadel player pieces and all the different cards the gins go in a specific area and everything doesn't float around and go crazy but there is a basin like an open area to the side as well that is just much more flexible for what have you that can go in there now some people are going to complain about a game that doesn't uh forward think to account for expansions and yes if you are going to get uh the the artisans of nicala or the expansion that looks like paul mccartney is on the front of the box then you're going to have additional

towers that don't fit alongside the original set of towers that are in there but the the freedom and flexibility of that central basin allows you to get everything successfully into the box and the lid closes you know that that's something where i have been able to get it all in there keep it organized and still have that that beautiful presentation of when you open it feeling like it was specifically designed for this game in a really smart way so this one is partly sentimental but it's also that sentimentality that i kind of judge future board game expansions based on so i had to have it on the list yep i uh i so i went back and uh before this and i i looked up dates i wanted to know the dates of all of our um our polls so five tribes is actually the oldest game uh old yes at a whopping six years old um it's now in first grade uh is the oldest game on our list uh which i thought was uh really interesting because i was just curious i was like i wonder you know like i i felt like i was trying to pull back when i thought like i really thought and then i looked at my list and i was like i really haven't gone very far back at all have i like well you know is it is it just that that's how much we've really sat down and and as a as an industry as publishers as manufacturers really thought about saying hey this need this is a priority and an opportunity um for us to improve experiences in this

hobby and part of part of in that vein make gaming more accessible approachable for other people yeah totally i mean like when i think about board games from my childhood and not just the the classic monopoly and risk and all that kind of stuff but even games like hero quests and dragon strike and everything when my brother and i got done playing those we just jammed everything back into the box and it was a nightmare every time that we took it out in order to get everything set up in the way that it should be and that was a huge part of the time commitment and also something that would sometimes discourage us from playing you sometimes open a box and just look at the mess of components within it right you know what on second thought let's just play some parks yeah yeah that's making me think about that i i'm remembering i had an anniversary edition of risk um and it was the metal the first metal edition metal components edition of the game and in that edition that was the very first game that i had that had uh bags in it cinch bags for your your army and it was that that velvety uh finish bags you know it's still big big picture they're still relatively cheap right we're just right right but it made me care about the things that were in the box i coveted that game i coveted those pieces uh every time i took them out like i cared about like organizing them and making my army rows

and columns you know very neat and making it look very sophisticated because it felt like a sophisticated experience like that plays a part into that care right right if it feels like a prestigious thing and relative to whatever price it is that's going to make you treat it as a prestigious thing as something that's worth investing your time in and thinking more about like well what else could i do like that's actually a big springboard for a lot of creativity on the gamer side of the hobby is people saying well this was a good start but how can i develop something with my 3d printer or foam core or all these other options that people do as like crafts at home that are incredible and i think a lot of that is inspired by the starts that even early games like a really nice addition of risk would have kind of given them the push out the door on that yeah and and i want to you you brought up something really interesting that i i before we move on uh with five tribes that i wanted to call out which was the this idea or this notion that a game box should be forward thinking uh for expansions uh and how how much that that idea comes from really a minority of the population that is it you know like as a publisher the drop-off rate between who buys games and who buys expansions no matter how popular the expansion and

i'll say i'm very excited about nightfall and nightfall has been doing really wonderfully for us like it's been really awesome to see people getting nightfall and loving nightfall but the drop-off rate is still substantial um so making a box with an insert that is like you open up and then like you've organized all the things you've got card components and then there's just emptiness in the box and you're like i wonder what that's supposed to be for that's not a good experience for for a person to feel this this emptiness there um as much as like the desire we have this desire to want things to fit inside of a you know a box and be compact absolutely i have that desire but i'm not sure that's this this specific experience that we want the majority of people to have right and it's a double-edged sword right you know if you open a game and there's room for an expansion in there then your your first thought might be like well why wasn't the expansion included you know if we already know what the expansion is and you're already accounting for it as part of the overall experience and playing this game then should that have been part of the base game or if you're the type of person who likes the base game and never wants an expansion it's going to feel like a bunch of wasted space and potentially you know that that's wasted shelf space that you have it's uh a waste of materials in extending the box extending the the the actual insert itself you know uh that that's additional carbon footprint that's being

put into something that you never are going to see the utility for if you don't buy the expansion so i i totally uh understand why some people are like why doesn't this account for all the future stuff but i i'm with you on this one so wha what's going to be your number four here jen so my number four is gonna be number nine i know it's a play on words there uh number nine is the one of the older this is where i thought that it was i was reaching back far it turns out i wasn't really reaching back that far this is a 2017 game um and number nine is probably the least uh assuming game uh on my list right but i was this was one of those like surprisingly made it onto my list like totally didn't expect it to um but when i looked at it again i was like you know number nine is an incredibly simple game um and the insert sits in the box like so so number nine is just a bunch of numbers and it's just a spatial game that you're trying to play and it accounts for pieces for four total people um to play inside of a box but it's basically infinitely expandable um but because of the nature of the game the game is just this rule book and these these stacks of numbers and the insert is just the the um uh what a cold press

uh what is that press called uh fitting uh you know of the pieces of each of the numbers into their spots and they're it's thick enough for uh the all the components for each player for each number to fit nicely and smoothly so they're evenly on top and they have finger holes around them no it's not the nicest plastic um it's a relatively cheap plastic but this insert is not an insert that i ever want to take out of the box i think i guess there's a deck of cards i think you flip over cards to get to what number you're pulling sure sure um so there's one other thing that and that should come out but that's just a deck of cards you take it out you put it on the table and you can put it right next to this box so i realized that this insert doesn't need to come out the pieces don't need to come out it's really easy to grab the grab your your number as it's flipped over um and it becomes this super functional like when when you were talking about doing imperium i was like this might be my dune imperium yeah well uh where it's like just like the most basic thing but i realized i super appreciate that it can just like you literally take the lid off the box put the box in the middle of the table shuffle cards put it right next to it and go um and it didn't need anything else and they just did that in a great way well that actually dovetails into my next one which is a dark horse contender that just changed i hate to tell you this

but the the potential spoiler that we had earlier was for raccoon tycoon and raccoon tycoon is an honorable mention in here because it's an example of where that expansion comes where the expansion has the box in order to account for the base game so now if you're getting the expansion hey you have one nice box where everything goes into it and the fat cat expansion just it is a fat cat expansion is bananas how much is in there but it also has room to integrate everything from the base game into it so you have that one nice consolidated thing but i've moved it over to honorable mention because i cannot get away with this list without bringing up habbas dragon's breath this is yes this is a kid's game but i well first off i think it's a great game for kids and adults alike it's a great game that teaches speculation and you're dealing with all these wonderful gems and likely shower curtain rings which are great but it's the integration of the the insert as functional component in the game that is so wonderful there's a central board and that board rests on top of this subdivided almost like hashtag looking insert you uh lift up the board and then inside you can organize your components so everything's nice and neat but then you put the board back down

after you've taken things out and it has these reservoirs i guess in the in the inside uh where you are going to shift these uh tokens to either the tokens that you've collected as part of playing or the tokens that fell as part of the dexterity component of the game and it's so concise and well thought out and the the fact that what keeps your things organized on the shelf are also the things that are going to keep you organized in a completely different way as you play is such a cool idea and such a like a synergy of function and elegance and just everything i love about tabletop games and so i'm sorry raccoon tycoon but dragon's breath came in uh and just you know took your number four spot from me um that's such a that's such a great call out because i that that totally reminds and and it's very unassuming you're totally right that the um uh you know you open up that box and it's just there and it's ready to go and they haven't used um the the most lavish of components or anything like that because habba is not trying to you know up that that market price right like they do a great job of staying in this in this like price bracket and they they just have that on lockdown and they did a great job of making a super dynamic game experience that

uh as adults love yeah just as much as kids yeah a game is awesome well i guess we'll shift over to what's on number three what you got going on uh so my number three is pandemic legacy season one oh this was almost on my list and i i disqualified it because i was like well i i got rid of pandemic you know or legacy season one i didn't hold on to it afterwards and then it you know it's complicated to think about pandemic legacy post playing it as like this shelf hog and then you're like it's this wasted space and everything but it nearly was on my list so i was actually really excited that was on your list i i you know this was a um uh i i think the the breadth i i'm i think what i love about the the list is um maybe the most is the breadth of gaming style gaming types that exist on the list um and uh as i was thinking about it i was like you know what legacy games literally cannot function without a really like really fine finely detailed um well thought out box box insert box presentation um and i think that i i i would generally say that every um i'm using pandemic legacy season one because i think uh both i i guess before risk legacy

um which i haven't experienced like i haven't played that one i've seen pictures of it but i haven't played that one um so i didn't necessarily want it so i'm adding it on the list as like my first experience that i thought was a well-done game again we're not talking about like um excessively expensive um component quality material quality um but it's still fun right it's fun to look in that box and see the yellow tape which risk legacy also does they do that that tape taping sort of thing as well and i think they even have taped envelopes in on their lid or something like that or right um so like it's it's fun and engaging to look at and then there's plenty of warning signs but like how you organize boxes and how you you label them um and make it interesting to look at but also functionally allow for game setup without uh overdoing it i'll say that i'll call out i'll call out sleeping guys and i i like i don't want to be on this podcast and be like they say uh sleeping gods because i just i want to preface this and say i'm we are absolutely having a great time with sleeping god so like asterix super great time with sleeping guides set up for and it's not exactly a legacy game but it's kind of along those lines right um the setup and the organization that needs to happen when you open sleeping gods is a big miss for me um i i was uh i was a little now that we're in it

it's great but that moment was uh was a little bit of a hurdle and that is not something that you experience with now the first time you play a legacy game it doesn't matter it's going to be a challenge to understand what's going on right um but i think they just did an excellent job with managing how things are labeled and how you can go to access things and find things uh through the rules and like making those the rulebook and uh the box compatible and building that system and improving that system along the way yeah exactly that that's the most interesting thing about it to me i mean absolutely yes uh the the ability to keep clandestine items you know secret until they're revealed is imperative in the design of the the insert and the packaging within the game but as i recall my two times going through season one and my one time going through season two and uh well i haven't actually opened legacy season zero it's on the shelf right now but i'm waiting for all of all of my pandemic group to be vaccinated in order for us to to hit that one to the table but as you play you develop the organization for the new components that come in and you can repurpose a lot of the tubs and trays and things in order to develop your own system but i never once felt like now that this new element has been introduced it's out of control like we don't have a way of accounting for this

and even if the tub itself isn't holding the contents that were secret within it when we started it still was part of the process and part of the fun of the game was feeling like okay we've opened this now how are we going to integrate this into all the tools that we have here how are we going to preserve all of our torn apart cards and trashed items and that kind of stuff like i i'm totally with you on here uh is integral to that experience so they knocked it out of the park yeah yeah what about you what's your number three well my number three uh is a game that i think this is where we could say that some people are going to take umbrage with us and that's bloomhaven jaws of the lion so the reason why i think this may be uh a problematic pick for some reasons is that when i i originally reviewed the game shortly before it came out and then uh the discussion that i saw happening on like reddit the day that it came out was a lot of people saying like how the hell do we get this all back in the box and the the insert looks beautiful it's one of those ones where it's like this looks great and you know like everything should have a place and then suddenly it it doesn't work in an intuitive way so i just sat down i was like okay i'll just make a quick video how to organize gloomhaven jaws in the lion because my group had some experience with it at this point we played through

over half of the campaign by the time that the game came out and we had developed our system which worked with all the components there we didn't have any added elements we just had more time to figure out what is the intent of this insert there's some mystery involved and and how do we make this work uh that video uh i think is at the moment my second watched video on the cardboard herald and it took me about 20 minutes to do and was some of the laziest editing that i've ever done so clearly a lot of people do not feel that this is an intuitive insert by any means um but to me it's the initial presentation uh when you open up the box and just everything uh as it's originally presented has its wonderful place and it's mysterious and the different characters and the different uh minis and the things that you're not allowed to look at until later on it just presents in such a great way and it's functional once you know how to harness the powers of that insert there is a degree of sacrifice i think a lot of people aren't big fans of i think if you sleeve your cards it's not going to work are we talking about that on this and this button yeah exactly well that that's one of the reasons why i think a lot of people would be like this insert sucks is because if it doesn't account for sleeves then they don't want to hear about it but you know what you're the

minority here's here's a fun fact i will i'll say this uh here i'll share this this detail here on our nightfall memory is side note no sorry uh um uh during our nightfall campaign uh because we hear about people one people love perks they love the the artwork on it and they they want to protect it and i totally understand that and i'm like when i say that we are using high quality components it's with that in mind because we love it too always questions about uh sleeving uh and about uh it fitting in the the game which it doesn't um right cards do not fit in the insert to parks or nightfall they don't fit um and so we took a survey of the people that responded and it was a good sample size less than 10 percent of people who responded said that they sleeved or cared about sleeving their cards or would consider sleeving their cards less than 10 is not the right reason to make an insert like that that was our audience and yes that could totally be different for a different game uh i i absolutely can can concede that 100 audience makeups might be different for specific types of games but in our case it was not you know it was a good reminder to us that sleeving is a hobbyist mentality is very much a hobbyist mentality it's not even like the whole hobby it's a segment of the hobby right right

fact but you know the the squeaky wheels they're they're the ones out there sometimes talking the loudest but let me put it this way um lords of waterdeep is a game that i have that i've played a bajillion times it's uh one of my wife and i's favorite games uh and so from the time we originally got it to the time that we have it now we have played it a ton and to we've never sleeved it and i know this is just me uh i do like protecting games but i like being careful but actually the weathering on it over the past what eight years since it released maybe nine years since it released is a big part of the character from the meeples on them to the cards themselves starting to show a little bit of wear we're careful with them but inevitably over time over 50 60 70 plays then it's going to have some of that my personal opinion is that if you have gotten a hundred plays out of something and you're like oh my god the if i had only sleeved this i would have been able to get 500 plays out of it you kind of gotten your money's worth i mean you might at that time maybe get a new new edition of it sometimes sleeves are really expensive on their own right well that's that's a good segue back to gloomhaven because our this is jaws of the lion but i i'm so curious like deep if you feel like this the insert in draws the line is like a direct um like feedback loop with original

gloomhaven where i bought gloomhaven and i bought a fishtack box and fish tag but it's exactly i i think it is a direct response to criticisms of gloomhaven and i think that of the entire game as a whole like jaws of the lion is not just gloomhaven for babies that's not what it is what it is is looking at what are the real problematic elements of gloomhaven and how do we address that in this new edition uh and it's not meant as a replacement but it is meant as kind of like a pathway this is the starter path for you wrapping your brain around gloomhaven in the first place whether it's the tutorialization of it it's the far more limited scope it's the map that is done on the spiral bound notebooks that could be put together instead of having this bananas amount of uh tiles there tiles for days and like how do you get them to stack like stacking tiles in gloomhaven og to get them just the right because right it we're on really pre there's a very finite amount of space that they can fit in and they have to fit there and i know i can get them to fit there but i always have to remember how i'm supposed to stack them and make it fit so so to me uh jaws of the lion from the design approach to the usability of the maps versus the map tiles to the insert itself is a direct

response to how to make the experience of plain gloomhaven better and i'm really hoping that from the insert to the maps to everything else that they take the the success and recognition that jaws of the lion got and utilize that in the the future gloomhaven releases so you know what if you got beef with me come at me world jaws of the lion is my number three nice climbing up the list where are you at jennifer all right my number two uh as uh sneaks sneaks into the list as you said as you set it up in the conversation um it might be cheating um but i don't care it is wingspan nice wingspan does technically have an insert in it for the cards which i will actually say is my least favorite part of wingspan as much as i love the trade just the fact that it can it can display the the bird cards i think that part is excellent but that that tray is actually um to me a concession toward slivers um and towards sleeving that creates so much pocket space and air um that the cards moving around in there have a lot of potential to get damaged for thus that don't want to with expansions leave i don't even know i don't have 500 cards it's ridiculous and there's more coming every day and there's more coming i'm not leaving my wingspan i when i'm not sleeping my wingspan um and i do sleeve cards just i will say that i do sleeve some of my games i

specifically leave the games that don't use good card stock in them and i kind of like do it begrudgingly i'm like you're lucky this game is so good that i spent all this extra money on these sleeves yeah yeah because i'm a snob of course and i'm buying expensive sleeves yeah um sleeve fluff the the extra you know little slough on the side when it doesn't fit perfectly isn't that maddening to you it's in yes okay i really i don't want to pull out sleeves and they're bent so i totally get it you don't want to like try to stuff it in there and then that's why people trash inserts i i get it um so wingspan makes it onto my list because of box mapping um box mapping in parks was actually inspired by a little partially partially inspired by that it was something that we had in mind and i was like this is a this is a good idea uh and you know like and and then they uh uh maddox when he was making the the the wraparound did it box mapping on that's on the side of the box i think is so excellent because it basically wingspan removes all inserts there is this you know if we're going to call that an insert i guess we can i don't really consider the card uh carrier an insert it kind of is but i don't really consider it that i just consider it a uh component for the game like a thing that you do um it's an empty box and that he he's just organized the components and and teaching you uh stonewire's teaching you how to uh

organize the components in a way to make the box super functional without any added extra fluff materials in it um and i think that is excellent and even with inserts i think more like that's a i think that's a valuable addition to boxes um for for this reason like you you're talking about jaws of the line imagine a map on the side of jaws of the lion that is just a simple put away put away map i don't know because i i this is i don't know how like functionally relevant that is there jennifer this is my second highest watch video you were talking about here so are you trying to take away my livelihood is that what's happening here i'm i'm what i'm commenting on is how fortunate for you that they didn't put a box map on the side of it so that we could be here to talk about it today um i think you just need to hashtag jaws of the lion insert again in the in the title of this video and then yeah exactly get some clicks that's that's what it's all about but as far as wingspan if we think about what is the intent of an insert it's to protect your components keep things organized and make it easier for you to play then having no insert is yet everything fit together perfectly in the way that an insert is supposed to serve in other games is perfect that that's the best insert for that game right where it's it becomes intuitive and and

yes like there's like but so there's little uh pouches right uh i forget what what uh stonemeyer calls them they're containers they're their specialty container yeah that you pop open it becomes two little dispensers for uh for materials so these are things that just pop out and open up very easily onto the table and become places good compartments for um tokens they get used all the time uh we love them so yes maybe like those aren't again they could be considered inserts i don't necessarily consider those inserts but i but because of those integrated and useful functional again we're circling back on turns out that function is like a high priority here um that functionality mixed with just good box organization and spatial organization is perfectly eloquent now has that box do i use that anymore because i have the expansions now no i've i've developed a new box mapping system um while i wait for uh like everybody else very patiently for the big box uh and uh i'm very excited for that and i will for sure use it um so yes that's changed uh since since that box map but as a like base game core game setup i think it's i think it's excellent hashtag big box we need to have patrick leader come on here and once again be held to the coals exactly over the lack of root big box announcements

yes making expansions patrick instead make a big box exactly we want a big box i want to hold everything i want it to be a locker size box i want my play mats to be able to fit in there so for my number two uh speaking of leader games at least is uh tangentially related in that this is a whirly gig games release this is pax premiere second edition which i think is kind of the refinement of everything that i liked originally about inserts this isn't an overly meticulous one but it's similar to that experience with small world and with five tribes that i was talking about earlier where you open the box and just it it looks like a feast as soon as you open it it's so well thought out and yet at the same time it's very minimalistic there's open areas for you to put the player tokens in little bags and then there's a little tub in order to fit some of the other tokens which are going to be put on the boards uh what i love is there's a nice specifically allocated amount of space for the cloth map that you roll up and it just looks so beautiful in there and then it has those whatever they are clay tokens i don't know what the player pieces are made out of but those are in uh their own specific space that can be removed and put next to you on the table and used as you play which works

beautifully now this i think is in part in relationship to the tokens themselves because the the insert is serving in some ways as a showcase of the tokens and so it feels very old school in a way like it almost looks like a beautiful chess set that you know your grandparent might have had something you open and you're like wow this looks like a one-of-a-kind thing of course it's a mass-market game but opening it up feels so wonderful you have enough freedom that you don't feel overly confined especially if it's a game that you want to add more components to i know a lot of people feel like the games that already look really lovely they want to you know interject some love into it by further upgrading and yet it stays organized it stays clean and it just feels like it's a through line with the act of playing the game that's so elegant and the the packaging and presentation itself so pax mirror's second edition when i think of good inserts was one that first jumped to mine yeah that was that is on on your list the game that was almost on my list it's the that's that's the the mine uh of your pandemic uh is pax premier um i love that comparison to uh chess sets that idea that like you open like sometimes you just open the box and look into it and you've got this display case for those tokens i think they're like an mc or something like a type of resin i

should know this because we've been sampling them um for something no comment uh and uh and i don't remember what the designation is for what type of material that is right now but um they are so nice to look at and and it totally shows off in a very simple way just by having a clear uh overlay on top of it um those pieces while keeping them functionally safe and they're very square you know like they're not strange shapes so that like they could roll around or there's like a ton of form fitting that needs to happen they're essentially just uh rectangles that that um you know can can uniformly stack together um or sit together very neatly so i totally appreciate that and that plastic because there's just a clear plastic overlay that goes on it right that slips right on top of it uh specifically of that section yeah yeah um and and that reminds me of uh of honorable mention i'll just call it out like broadly is the the beatle lucerta eagle griffin big box games they do that a lot and that's their like non uh uh game trace right like their non game trace take on on that but those are like those super functional just like they're not clipping in or clap you know clicking in in any way um but they just slip on top of something and become displays for games with beautiful components in them nothing about this list is concise uh we're spending an hour talking about 10 inserts here so i don't feel bad about asking this quick tangent we're not haters

we're not going to you know call out games uh more than you already have i mean sleeping gods is in the corner crying but i'm really sorry did you have an easier time coming up with really bad inserts even inserts that look or seem like they should be really good inserts but were actually bad or were just examples of garbage thought put into just throwing games into the box you know you know what i think the big takeaway for me was this as i was looking at my shelf and and and thinking is i was going through games that i love uh and and i was sort of being like i would go and i'd be like no yep no no and and like it wasn't so much there that there was any like true vitriol against them more so a sense of um uh disappointment or or at the potential uh for for games to do to have done to do just a little bit better right and being like wow i you know like yes maybe in the big scheme of things the the insert uh that box experience um isn't playing this huge role in terms of my impact and enjoyment because i do try to just keep games on my shelf that we really want to play and care about um but more so that it was sort of this like i was able to go through my shelf and know how i felt about those inserts like i i i had a definitive like i knew which

ones i have good experiences with when i open and which ones i don't um so like whether it's subconscious or not it does matter totally totally yeah it makes a big impact and like you said that disappointment like you're one of my favorite games why couldn't you have done better here right yeah all right well then let's take it to your number one what do you got um well in in that spirit of like of knowing my number one is based on me having an instantly positive reaction to an insert and that is wasteland express delivery service good pick i believe that it was my first game with a game trays insert in it um because i also believe that it's an early if not the first that i don't know that definitively but i do think it's an early game trays work uh uh commission um but no matter what i i feel like everything to me has sort of built around and built off of uh of wasteland express like um i was thinking about and considering the new tricarion um edition and and i was like i i could do that but i really feel like that's just based on wasteland express yeah yeah yeah that what they iterate they're just iterating on it and maybe tricarion is a better insert i don't know but um if we go back to my number five uh which was dice thrown and it was all it was about

that personal experience wasteland on at a very early yet 2017 way way way long time ago um was one making a ton of game fit into a really compact space it's yes it's still a fairly big box um but two making a game with universal components very easy to set up and very user friendly um there's the mod shop in it that is easy super easy to pass around um you have those personal components for your personal player there's there's uh spaces for cards so the game setup is like trade out on the table and then there's some box mapping where you just put the trays back in really easily and they nest really nicely together so that you can truly flip box over on purpose or on accident and everything is totally fine um and that includes a ton of tiles like going back here we go gloom haven lots of tiles you know what wasteland has a lot of tiles in it and i don't feel as bad about game setup as i do with glue maven right and you know with gloomhaven it's not just the game setup there's the knowledge that you're going to have to spend the time putting it away and even that can be a deterrent and so yeah the the things that you're talking about that that feeling of just less stress involved as you're playing it and uh you mentioned to the ability to flip it upside down

you know how many inserts or just games in general uh do you have on your shelf where you could flip them upside down and it was supposed to stay together but suddenly it is all awry in there you know it was marketed to me that way yep yep well that's mine what is yours my number one uh is eclipse second dawn and the there's or second dawn for the galaxy there's a lot of reasons for this but the thing that i think i most wanted to highlight is how much of a functionality improvement it is over the original eclipse experience which eclipse to me was an incredibly innovative game at the time that it came out but it was also it kind of felt bare bones from an artistic perspective uh from the component quality perspective it felt like it was kind of we have this really good idea and it involves a lot but we really can't commit a lot to it because of you know various reasons uh and now nearly a decade after the original came out this beautiful new addition is here incredibly like meticulous and and absolutely stunning yeah yeah it it's another one of those things where it looks like a feast when you open it and the the functionality that i'm talking about here is that just like you were highlighting with wasteland express and with uh dice thrown you remove a

tub this which would be an insert for a whole other game on its own but it's a personal insert in the case of eclipse you have this tub which is color coded to the player pieces and on top it has uh inlaid spaces for you to keep track of all the various resources so if it gets bumped it's not going to go sliding everywhere in the way the original would have where you were keeping track of it on a cardboard map uh but in this one you open up that tub and within it is organized components for everything that you personally are going to use to play the game and then underneath all six of the different faction tubs that you remove is a beautifully sculpted insert to contain all of the shared components for the game that's all the tiles that populate the center map it has all of the npc tiles and further on you have like upgrade tiles that are a big part of this game a huge aspect of what makes eclipse cool is that you are organically upgrading all of your different technological capabilities that influence your uh your ship's ability to do combat their movement but also your personal ability to like have economic growth and you know exploration is modified through all these different upgrades and these tiles

are you know they're a mess in the original but in this it's so well thought out and organized and presented and it could just be put on the table easily accessed and relatively for the size of game easily put back into them it has just completely transformed what is the absolute worst aspect of this game and made it this beautiful premium extremely well thought out experience and my instinct when i originally saw that was like well that's got to be like the super nice upgrade version and no it's the stock version every copy of eclipse from now on will have this in it and yes you could argue that has probably increased the price the retail price of the game is pretty high but at the same time if that's the game that you want to play they give you so many good tools in order to play it i i was blown away and to me that that is the pinnacle of that game trays experience of how do we have this elegance and functionality absolutely i when yeah when i saw that at the top of your list i was like yeah that makes total sense it's like a it was like angelic almost to look at it on on kickstarter uh i don't know if we can call game inserts like that but if if we could that's totally it um it's yeah it maybe it does make things more expensive but uh that that criticism comes up a lot and at the end of the day

this is about having a great time and it's about presenting the best experience so for you know like this is a push and pull a tug and and there's no you know hard and fast uh uh right or wrong answer here but pushing in favor of more expensive for something that's gonna result in a game getting on the table more easily more quickly more frequently um is always going to be a plus in in my book um if i can make that especially a game like eclipse that is so fun like i i don't have a bad experience memory playing eclipse i just don't um but you're right the only thing is like okay somebody needs to get here for the original one to set this game up an hour before whenever that's gonna happen um because like you just don't want people to have to deal with that part of the experience so someone just like sacrifices themselves to the setup and is like i'll do it i'll be i'll be the bigger person here and do this setup and if you didn't have those organizational tools every person who i know who owns eclipse has gone out and got organizational tools for themselves and so the fact that it is custom-made for this game and integrated into it in such a nice way that it all feels intuitive like you don't have that real complicated feeling of like do i have to tetris this back together where do where do things go like i i have

some collectors editions of games like i was saying that partially inspired this list where i'm like it is a lot of work to put this game back together compared to the base edition which maybe had no insert whatsoever but you know you had a little bit more freedom and flexibility but eclipse is to me the the pinnacle of how you can do that like extremely in some ways overwrought extremely produced insert that is beautiful but totally do it in service of function and i'm all about it so i think that is our list this has been so much fun jen do you want to make any plugs for keymaster games i mean you have parks is out and is a hit you have nightfall which people can get and it has its own beautiful insert anything else going on uh more more is on the way from from key master in uh 2021 that i'm really excited about uh not right now but we i guess we will have just wrapped up uh the caper europe um kickstarter when this when this goes up and and i'm super excited for for uh caper in in 2021 uh which will have more uh delicious uh delectable inserts in q master fashion um and and other stuff that we haven't even announced yet so i'm i'm excited uh for 2021 i'm excited for summer and

spring and uh thanks for having me yep thanks for coming on the show and let us know audience what are all the inserts that we miss and what are all the problems with the inserts that we listed we do want to hear it and if you have any ideas for other top tens top fives movies whatever you want to hear about gaming related or otherwise uh that you'd like to see on this channel that you'd like to see jennifer come back onto the show to talk about uh they're ready let us know thanks again jennifer thank you if you enjoyed this video we have all kinds of other reviews interviews and recommendations via writing podcasts and video here on our channel and website cardboardherald.com our content is audience supported so if you want to show your support please visit our patreon thank you so much for watching this has been the cardboard herald

Progress saved