Top 10 Tactical Planning Board Games - JonGetsGames
Transcript
welcome to John kids games this is the second out of four top ten lists that are coming out throughout the month of February to help support the John COEs Pro pledge drive that is currently happening you may may not know that I have recently taken the plunge into making these videos professionally and the idea of this pledge drive is to direct some extra attention and support to the patreon campaign so that I can continue doing this well into the future so if you are interested in directly supporting the channel you can take a look at all the various options at patreon.com slash John gets games and I think let's now go ahead and move into this top ten list so the title of this one is my top ten tactical planning games and on a very high level the idea of tactics versus strategy is that tactics are all about the kind of short term things that you're working on right now it's kind of like very looking at your toes sort of planning versus a strategic type of thing is when you're looking really far ahead lots of turns ahead and that kind of thing so this list is really focusing on tactical planning where from turn-to-turn lots of things are gonna happen with the various game States whether that be a new hand of cards it's some dice rolled or just a lot of things are happening in the middle of the table that you can't necessarily predict and when it comes to this list this is not necessarily the games in order of my preference for the game itself as a whole it's more in order of my preference for the specific tactical planning nature of that game so without further ado let's go ahead and jump in corkle is a game that came out back in 2006 and the general idea of this one is you take the game of Scrabble and you get rid of all of the
letters from the tiles and you replace them with colored symbols and when it's your turn you are going to be looking at your private hand of these tiles and you'll be playing some of them out into the middle of the board and this area is going to grow as more more people have these tiles in and you're going to get victory points based off of how you combo these tiles together and specifically how long of the lines are when you actually put these tiles down and the rules are really simple when you are putting them in a line they need to either all be the same color but different symbols or all the same symbol but different colors and what ends up happening here is every single turn you have this thing that you need to plan through like you need to analyze the tiles you have in front of you you need to be constantly analyzing the board in the middle of table which is changing with every single player's turn and need to try and find those really great moments when you can sneak in tiles here or there to get a really good combo scoring situation but also you want to play defensively because it's very easy to put a couple tiles out and then accidentally leave a really good spot available to one of your opponents if they happen to have that one perfect tile and so you need to pay attention like how many of the best tile to go on there have come out maybe how many maybe still be in the bag and like you have to constantly be hedging your bets but from a tactical perspective I just really enjoy the act of reading the board read the tiles I have and I'm trying to figure out what order I'm gonna play these because you're gonna lose some of them in a refill but you might have a situation where you could spend a five tiles now or four and that fifth tile maybe you leave it in your area because it matches up well with that six tile that you have on your in front of you and you want to leave yourself more
flexible for the future so there's a lot of stuff to think about and certainly there is some long term things you can consider but by and large this is a very tactics heavy game and I've really enjoyed playing this one especially at the two-player count but yeah this one is a solid game up next we have bunny kingdom and this one came out 2 in 2017 and the general idea of this game is you have hand drafting which means you deal out a bunch of cards to every player and then on their turn they're gonna take cards out of that hand and then pass it on to their opponents for them to pick more cards out of that hand and right from the get-go bunny kingdom does something that seems pretty different to me when it comes to you this hand drafting because normally you'd take one card and pass it on but in bunny Kingdom you actually take two cards every single turn and at the beginning of the round you have a ton of cards in your hand it's gonna vary depending on the player count but right from a right there from a tactical perspective you have to analyze all the cards that you have in your hand and pick two of them which it seems like not that big of a deal one card versus two cards but when you grab two cards that means you could try to get a combo between those two cards as opposed to pulling one and hoping that something good is gonna come down the pike so you are thinking about what the options are with these cards and then you have this board in the middle of the table which is a large square grid and it has a little letters along the top and numbers down the side and you are many of the cards are just allowing you to put bunnies down on two different spots on the board and based off of the adjacencies of your bunnies on the board and the different resources and stuff that the bunnies are on top of you were gonna score a bunch
of points also inside this big hand of cards our other cards which are endgame nutri points which you will take that card to put it facedown in front of you and then evaluate it at the end of the game which means you are constantly cultivating your own custom victory conditions as you are playing the game but from a tactical perspective all of this comes down to just reading this hand of cards and trying to figure out what the best things are for you right now based off of the things you have already done in the past and also what you see in this hand and then you pass it on and you get it up the hand back to you and this one has two less cards obviously because your opponent just pulled two out but you still have a bunch of options and then you pull from those as well and again depending on player count in this game I do believe that some of the cards can come all the way around the table back to you and so that's something you can consider as well but just in general this is a game where you are constantly being given new information and you're constantly forced to plan around the options that you have been given and sure you might try to set yourself up so that you will be able to take advantage of some good luck going forward but at the end of the day the resources that I've been giving you are the ones you have to choose from so from a tactical perspective I really enjoy the planning decisions of picking out all of these different cards there's just so many to choose from and they have such a wide variety of effects that I found that to be very enjoyable and in general I've really enjoyed this game but specifically the tactics have shown through next up we have Glu Haven which came out in 2017 and this is a massive game with an epic campaign and a whole bunch of stuff going on but for the purpose of this list I want to talk about to the actual combat that you are doing because realistically you're doing
a scenario after scenario and within that gimen scenario you are running around with a figure who is trying to kill a bunch of enemies and the way you actually evaluate your terms is you have a hand of action cards that you have cultivated yourself and you're going to be choosing two of those and then using those to evaluate your turn so right from the get-go this is a little bit different than other ones on the list because you don't randomly pull these cards into your hand like you always have access to the ones that you picked and then once you use all of them you will lose one of them randomly and then you'll get the rest of them back into your hand to continue going so the tactics are really come into play when it comes to the the artificial intelligence of the enemies that are filling in this scenario up because every single turn you are going to be evaluating your turns and at the same time as all of these bad guys and they are pretty erratic like every single one of the different type of enemies has a personality like the hounds move very fast and some of those big abomination type things move very slow but that doesn't necessarily mean that they always move fast or always move slow and you don't know what any of the bad guys are gonna do until everybody has decided what they're doing for the turn then you flip it over and then you flip over all the things for the enemies and they might do things that you really didn't expect and what that means is from turn-to-turn you do have a tactical puzzle where you're trying to figure out what the enemies are likely to do what you can choose and with from the cards in your hand which will allow you to be as flexible as possible to deal with what they might be doing and it also means that you cannot really plan that far into the future
realistically you are planning from turn-to-turn because the entire game state out on the battlefield could be completely different next turn based off of maybe one of your companions did a really good comment on that turn and killed some things you didn't expect to have happen or maybe some new things got spawned and you didn't see that coming either and so I think the process of and tactically trying to figure out what your plans are within this given turn and then communicating that somewhat vaguely with your companions because you're not allowed to be too specific presents the players with some really good decisions and again it just keeps them kind of like in the heat of the moment doing this combat and not having the ability to worry too much into the future as they are playing within the game in turn up next we have Bruges which came out back in 2013 and on the face of it this is a card game with a little board in the middle of the table because what happens is you are going to go through a series of rounds and in every round you are going to draw up until you have five cards in your hand and then you are going to play four of those cards in turn order around the table until you go down to just one card and then you move into the next round where you draw four more cards into your hand and from a tactical perspective there are some really wonderful things going on here the first is that when you are drawing the cards they come from two different facedown decks but in the back of every card that tells you what the front of every cards color is going to be and there's a bunch of different colors in the game and the color isn't necessarily going to dictate what the other side of the card is going to do but every single card in this game can be used in a multitude of ways you could discard a card to get
some money you could discard a card to get some to place canals out on to this central board in the middle of a table you can discard cards to build buildings there are so many different things that you can do and the color of the card is going to be important because that color will dictate how much money you get for discarding the card or witch canal can be built or what resources you need to spend to build that card into a house and so right from the bat I love the drawing phase of this game as you're trying to get maybe a variety or maybe things that work really well for what you're trying what you've already been building in front of you because as you were playing the game you're building up a tableau of these cards in front of you which are essentially people who do specific abilities for you every single card can be a person as well as all of those other things that I talked about and so once you've drawn the cards into your hand you look at the five cards you can say well I'm gonna play four of these and if I want to play down some of these really nice powerful people I'm gonna have to spend money and I'm have to build buildings and all of these things cost resources so you need to figure out which card are you gonna get rid of to get money so that you can't afford to place this other card down but you're gonna also get rid of this card here to get a couple of the colored resources that you can then use to do this activation to do that and there's just all these kombu things that you need to do and at the beginning of every round you just get to analyze your hand and so every single round is going to be essentially a different puzzle as you are tactically trying to figure out how best to work towards your long-term goals with the short-term options that have been given to you within that given around and I think in general I love the decisions that come into play here and also the game is largely multiplayer solitaire so you can come up with a plan
and most likely evaluate it although occasionally there are cards that can be played that can definitely mess with people's plans which has just a little bit of tension to keep you on your toes so yeah Bruges is a really good example of lots of tactical planning within each given turn and I've really enjoyed playing this one moving on we now have at the Masters trials wrath of magma Roth and this game came out in 2017 and the general idea of this is that you are going to be a rolling dice every single turn and then you are to get to customize the dice phases by modifying this board you have it in front of you because on this board you have a row for every single one of the different colored dice you are rolling and then you have a column for these six different sides so that means if I roll the blue die and it ends up being a three then you find the blue row and the three column and you land that die right there and when it's your turn you can evaluate that die and do whatever is underneath that spot right there so right from the get-go it sounds like okay well you roll the dice and you evaluate the things you got what's the big deal but there aren't a lot of the other things going on here which add into the tactical planning of what you're doing within that give and turn the verse is that this game is fully cooperative you are all working together to try and beat some non player characters in the middle of the table from turn-to-turn as you try to grow stronger until you get to the very end of the game where you trying to beat Mac broth at the very end so what you were doing from turn-to-turn though is you are generating resources and you are going to be playing and cards down on to this board that you have in front of you effectively modifying individual die phases so as you go deeper into the game
your dice are effectively being customized because you put that card down and now when you roll that specific number on the die you go on to that spot and you can now evaluate that really powerful ability that you just activated but even on top of that you don't have to activate the thing directly under that die you can remove dice in order to move other dice around on your board because maybe the way you roll the dice didn't really work out too well for you also you can remove a die from your board in order to move around your companions dice from their board so as you're playing this game you are constantly talking back and forth about what everybody is trying to do what their plans are and what they need like maybe you just desperately need a die move and so you ask your opponent it's a non opponent sorry your companions if anybody has a dime of ability that can give be given to you to do this really good thing and so you are puzzling through every single turn trying to figure out how you could best use the dice as they were rolled randomly of course for you on that give and turn and then also trying to figure out how best you can spend the different resources you have to modify and upgrade those dice as you go deeper and deeper into the game and I just think the process of figuring out how to use the dice and how to interact with your companions around the table and how to upgrade is a wonderful experience and it definitely keeps you on your toes and Kenai presents you with a new problem to solve every single turn of the game moving on we now have la Isla which came out in 2014 and in this game you are playing explorers going out to an island trying to capture a bunch of animals and I don't know do sciency things with them I'm not exactly sure but mechanically what you were doing
here is you are gonna be drawing it three cards every single turn and this game does something somewhat interesting here because unlike your average card game where you draw cards then you play them in give an order or are you trying to figure out which one you're gonna play in which ones you aren't in la Isla every single turn everybody simultaneously chooses a role for all three of those cards and every card has three different things that it could be it could either be an ongoing ability that is going to affect you from turn to turn or it could give you a different color resource or it might bump up the score track for one of the given species that are out there on the island and you need to pick one of those three things for each one of those three cards and you can't overlap which means one of those cards will give you a resource one card will give you an ongoing ability and one card will bump up one of these scoring tracks and you might be in the situation where you really like this ability you really like this resource but you don't want to bump up that animal on a track because it's actually gonna help one of your opponents out because you haven't captured that many of that given animals so you're like okay well maybe I'll do a different plan and I'll do this animal scoring instead which will help me out but now it doesn't give me the resource that I need so what am I gonna do instead and all this stuff just gives you some wonderful tactical planning because from turn-to-turn you just have a completely fresh set of options and you need to figure out the best way to orient all of these cards so that you will move towards your goals because you are slowly kind of putting explorers out onto this island and so from turn-to-turn you do have some ideas of like okay I'm gonna try and surround that thing over there and do that but as you've drawn these cards maybe you have a turn or two where you just don't you aren't given
any good options to continue that plan over there and so the game forces you to be quick on your feet and change things up and trying to come up with a better alternative with the resources that it has given you and I just think the idea of this mechanic of just you get three cards and oh them have to be one of these three different things is a really brilliant idea and honestly I'd love to see this one pulled right up leisa and plunk down into some other game to try and explore the design space of that idea more but to the best of my knowledge nobody has quite done that yet but either way that is Lila next up we have pandemic Legacy season one and you might be wondering why I'm saying pandemic legacy and not just pandemic but I have a couple reasons for this so what I'm talking about pandemic in general the idea here is that you are cooperatively trying to save the world from these diseases and as you are going from turn-to-turn you are going to be randomly drawing some cards on the top of an epidemic deck that are going to spread disease all over the world and that is bad so that means from turn-to-turn you are kind of dealing with the random outcome of the disease coming out from the previous turn and you definitely have some long term goals of trying to eradicate diseases and try to get yourself into different positions that you can trade cards around and cure these diseases but from turn-to-turn you also have to make sure that the disease's don't go unchecked out there on the board so it does give you these new snapshots and these new puzzles on each individual persons turn because the dynamic situation out in the middle of the world obviously can change so much
it's very dynamic but now when I'm talking about the legacy aspect I'm not gonna spoil anything but you could almost say that from a given a game to another given game you have another tactical layer so like there's the tactics of the given turn but within a legacy infrastructure you have no idea what's coming in the next game because the pandemic legacy will introduce new rules it'll kind of do some surprising things that you wouldn't necessarily expect and a lot of the things that you're doing as you're playing the game will permanently affect the games that you'll put stickers down and rip some stuff up so what that means is if you were to take an entire game as almost like a turn then you are gonna be making some real decisions about the world and the permanent things are happening without knowing what's coming into the future and you kind of have to hope that what you're doing is gonna work well for that and you're gonna definitely trying to plan for that within the realm of the things that you understand but at the same time I just think it's kind of an interesting little snapshot to have a game change so rapidly from play to play and I think that it kind of flies when it comes to the tactical decisions that you're making they're up next we now have Isle of Skye which came out in 2015 and this is a tile laying game but what it does is every single round of the game is it has every single player draw three new tiles and you're gonna put it in front of you right in front of a little player screen and each person is gonna do that around the table and then everybody is gonna simultaneously apply a cost to those given tiles behind that a little screen and then one of the three they're actually going to be removing but you're not gonna know which one of those which one's gonna be until
everybody removes their screens but from a tactical perspective what that means is every single round there is a large number of new tiles that become available to you and as you were trying to price out the the tiles that you have right there you are also trying to figure out which one of the tiles out around the table you're going to want for yourself because these prices that you're putting down or gonna be the cost your opponents will have to pay to purchase that tile from you and then you will get money which you can then use to maybe purchase the towel so you really need it from other people but if nobody actually bias that tile in front of you then the price that you put down is gonna be the price for the town that you effectively paid and you gain that tile and lose the money that went right there so there are a lot of different things you need to consider as you are pricing these tiles and then as you are trying to purchase the ones around the table because these tiles need to perfectly fit in with everything else you have in front of you and there are a variety of different scoring conditions that are gonna be different from each individual game to game and I just think the process of trying to figure out not only what is good for me but what's good for my opponents what are they likely to do and how can I likely get around that he's a wonderful tactical decision and a big part of that is knowing how much money you think they maybe have and trying to evaluate just how worthwhile it is for people to be purchasing these tiles in front of you and maybe how much it is worth it to yourself to maybe put a whole bunch of money down so that nobody actually buys it and you get that one instead so there's just a whole bunch of tactical things going on from each given turn and then all those tiles are gone within that gimen round the next round happens a ton of new tiles come out and they are going to definitely alter the scoring
opportunities that you are once again gotta have within that given round so I think the tactical possibilities abound as you are playing this game and the decisions you're making are just super satisfying we now have by far and away the oldest game on this list which is teaching supposedly came out in 1991 and this is a latter style card game where you just have this deck of cards and it's a standard deck of cards going up to 52 plus it has these four special cards the dragon at the Phoenix the one and the dog and I'm not gonna talk about what they all do but they all have their own individual abilities and you are going to shuffle up this deck and deal out to everyone around the table and you always play at four players technically that you could play at other ones but nobody does this you only play it for and as a team game so that you and the person across the table from you or on the same team and then your opponents are gonna be to your right and to your left and so every single round you're gonna be given this big hand of cards and what you then need to do is figure out what opportunities the game have has given you because on your turn you are going to be playing down these cards in a variety of ways you might just play a single card down you could play a double or a full house which is a three of a kind and a two of a kind you might play at seven cards straight if that's something that works out with the cards that you picked up in your hand and the goal of this game is to lose all of your cards out of your hand as quickly as possible like the in a best-case scenario you and your partner both lose all of your cards before either of your opponents do and the reason this gets tricky is because only the first person within a given round is going to have
the ability to dictate what kind of card sets get to go down like if my opponent puts down a pair now I have to follow with a pair or I could pass and if I have a really good three of a kind in my hand I now have a decision to make do I break up that three of a kind of putting the pair down and leaving a stranded single card in my hand like maybe it's a seven or something like that which isn't too powerful and I need to figure out how important that is based on the rest of the cards I have in my hand and the different plans that I have because in addition to all of this kind of general purpose card playing type stuff you have the ability to call teach you each individual round and you can say this right up until you play your first card and this is essentially a hundred point bet that you alone will lose all of your cards before anybody else does including your partner who's sitting across from the table so in order to accurately decide if you want to make this bet you need to be able to properly analyze your hand of cards and decide like how strong it's gonna be like you have to decide like I have the strongest hand I think I can make this work because if you don't if you are the second person to go out and so the first then your team loses that hundred points and if the game goes until one team has a thousand points so 100 points is a pretty significant amount to lose and I have played this game well over a hundred times like I have 95 log plays and I played this one a ton before I even started logging my place on BoardGameGeek it is just a wonderful experience of puzzling through all the different options and trying to make reads on your opponents based off of how many cards they have in their hand how
they are passing instead of playing cards like you can read information from so many different avenues and aspects but after every single one of these hands you shuffle the entire deck up and then deal and another set of cards to everybody so from a tactical perspective you are not shooting for that thousand points like within a given round you're just doing all of these little battles these little unique discrete chunks of gameplay and you're trying to get the most points that you can out of each one of those and I unfortunately haven't really played this one and all that much recently even though I still think the game is absolutely brilliant and I would look forward to playing this one more in the future because it's just such a solid experience also it's fun playing a nice thinkI game with a partner across the table from you who can share in the highs and also commiserate in the lows when things maybe don't necessarily go your way so yeah teach you is just a really impressive game especially from a tactical planning perspective well here it is we finally reached my favorite tactical planning board game and that is going to be Oracle of Delphi which came out in 2016 so in this game you are racing you have a little boat in the middle of the Mediterranean and it's the Greek god type theming and the idea is that Zeus has a set of different tasks that you need to do and you just need to race and do all those before your opponents do and make it all the way back to Zeus in the middle of the table and you have this big hex grid of a map and it's gonna be very different every single time you play the game but realistically what you're doing in return is you're going to be rolling these dice that are in front of you and there are oracle dice and you put them
down on to the different spots that are d sixes and when it's your turn you're going to be evaluating these dice and there are so many opportunities and different things that you can do with these dice that I just love trying to figure out what the best thing is because you are obviously racing a trying to in some cases like kill some creatures in other cases you're trying to pick up some Goods and then travel to other places on the map and deliver them but those Goods are discrete like they don't appear again and each spot that takes those Goods can only take one of the goods so you are racing in so many different ways to try and kill the closeby creatures as well let's make the easy transportations you're also trying to plant some statues down there's just so many different things that you're doing and you roll these dice but then you have this currency of energy or I think favor one of those two maybe not you right you spend this stuff in order to modify things as in how far your boat can move but also you can spend these to modify the die faces on the dice that you have rolled and realistically you know when you roll a bunch of dice on your turn and then we use them that is a very tactical situation because you have no ability to control how they're gonna roll all you can do is maybe affect things after that roll has happened and I have always enjoyed this game like every time I've sat down to play this game I just at some point in the middle just like man this is cool like I just really love the planning that goes into figuring out how I can make all this work and yes there is some long term stuff because you're looking out at the map and the map isn't gonna change so you're like okay well I'm hoping to go over here pick this up and then move over there
and drop that off and then kill that monster and then plant this thing over here and then you like kind of have this whole thing going on but you roll the dice and maybe they can work for that plan maybe they won't and now you need to kind of modify that planning kind of said of going over there you kind of go over here instead or maybe you have this great plan and then suddenly one of your opponents zooms in and grabs the thing that you're planning on doing and you just didn't see that coming at all and now you have to again change your plan and so just every single turn you are given these different options but they are so varied that it is highly enjoyable trying to pick out all of different options and try to figure out which one of them makes the most sense and every single time I played this game I have gone away from it feeling like the person who won was probably the person who should have won like sure there is some randomness with the dice rolling there's also randomness with trying to kill the monsters but then we couldn't go into that one right now but it does seem like planning well will really help you out in the long term and the decisions that you are making on each give and turn are super important and also just at the other day I just really loved playing this game and so much of that and from the tactical planning like realistically that is the core that's the beating heart of this game and I think that it works so well and yeah it's kind of why it's my number one with that we have reached the end of the list and I hope you have enjoyed it I'll give you a little bit of a spoiler and next week I'll be doing my top ten strategic planning games so I trying to kind of split these into these two different sections and it was very interesting trying to figure out which side of things some of my favorite games were landing and specifically trying to parse out why so that will be coming out into
the next week and I hope you'll enjoy that one as well and of course if you would like to look into more details of the John goes pro pledge drive that's currently happening please check out patreon calm down gays games and I would really appreciate that support as I am venturing into the big scary world of trying to do this professionally and speaking of which I'd like to thank all of these producer level pledges who have been actively supporting the channel well if you'd like to see more vlog style content like this one as well as full game playthroughs and in-depth board game reviews please subscribe to the channel thanks for watching