Skip to main content
Loading video...

Guessing Games We Love from Negative Reviews

Transcript 38:07

hey I'm Ryan this is my brother Daniel and this is rolls in the family and today we are we're getting a little negative Daniel not from our perspective that's true but from the perspective of the people out there we going to bask in the world's negativity today the world's negativity cuz that's really what we need more of we do need more of that there's been complaints on our channel that we don't have enough of that so yeah yeah people are like man there's just too much positivity in the world like if only I could spend my recreational board game content we've actually pivoted our mission statement we want to be a beacon of negativity in this world beac yes it's good to have goals uh yeah so this is going to be us uh we actually got this idea um from Jamie and Jeff over at Foster the meele which I believe they got it from somebody else so who knows where this idea originated but of taking comments from Board Game Geek kind of review comments on games that are very negative maybe kind of funny in how Negative they are and we going to be presenting them to each other for the other person to try to guess what game are they talking about you can play along at home if you'd like you can pause the video see if you can think of what game they could be talking about um we've got five of these you know for each of us to pass back and forth so hopefully it'll just be kind of funny I guess that we we picked all games that we do like so we're talking about games that we enjoy but clearly yeah this isn't just any board game ever so yes the these people clearly do not um you

know if you do play along that's something you could leave in the comments below how many out of 10 did you get you know did you perform better than the combination of the two of us um you know you can brag or lie you know that's the joy com on intern if if a random person beats one of us that's going to be that's going to be pretty you know humiliating yeah catered to the ones so you have an opportunity here to to show off your board game uh knowledge yeah um I suppose we could throw links to all these games below I think as we announce them we'll probably flash up the information about the game in case you've never heard of it so you can check out these games if you'd like if you're more convinced by us liking them than the just you know very negative review that was presented y um but yeah dang let's uh let's jump into this this going to be interesting we're kind of winging this I feel like there's a you know qualification that uh you know everything that's you know mentioned in the comments obviously is coming from someone else and isn't our full endorsement so you know just take it there also is the outside chance that somebody watching this we read their comment IM off Board Game Geek so and you should feel special that we chose your comment yeah we we gave you a a platform we gave you a platform that's so right okay Ryan we're going to start out with u this uh comment uh we found so first game the comment reads bad Randomness disguising itself as

difficulty after the first round I just played to do whatever I could afford and wasn't trying to win or really concerned with scoring points I won that's how random it is and it may be the ugliest box all caps ever fire that graphic designer and put them in a job they are more qualified to do cleaning toilets at interstate rest stops seems good and it is and beneficial to society instead of whatever they did here rating two out of 10 wow okay so really random they just started doing whatever each turn and still won yeah they felt like it was extremely random um and and probably the biggest clue is around the uh the second half of that yeah I I have one that comes to mind I I guess I'll do my first guess but I'm not super confident I'm going to say terraforming Mars that is incorrect incorrect incorrect okay really ugly box cover let's here I'll give you a clue Ryan let's just say uh I was not impressed by this box cover either oh well my mind goes it maybe has grown on me a little bit my my mind has gone to either uh like Lorenzo magnif go there we goow Lorenzo which is really funny uh the whole Randomness disguising

itself as difficulty but I think you know it's around the uh yeah the like the cards coming out and then the die roll the die roll right though that's fair Randomness right it isn't like it is funny I my mind didn't go to it immediately because it is a very skill-based game but like uh so my I I know ter Mars one that people complain a lot about like the randomness of the card draws and stuff but there you goand dising one that's one of my favorite uh and and poor poor graphic designer for that game getting no no love from that comment I think it looks very stoic stoic I know I think that's what they were going for yes okay there we go okay well I uh what do I get a half point for that maybe maybe that's the rules here yeah yeah half Point Half Point if you needed a clue to get there okay uh Danel here here's the first one I've got for you wow I have no idea why this game's ratings are so high I played it for the first time and hopefully only time last weekend it's a slog two hours felt like 4 hours it's boring and very repetitive not much variation from turn to turn the Builder strategy seems nonviable not sure what people see in this game thankfully my friend who owns this game feels similarly so he will be selling trading it away soon three out of 10 oh no I'm a a little background about me I'm so bad at games of like guessing um so so so we'll see so we'll

see how this goes but the Builder strategy the biggest clue right there um what game and just for clarification this are these all games I own or are these uh games that are in your collection as well uh they are all games you own in this instance yes um the Builder strategy repeat that comment about the Builder strategy again the Builder strategy seems nonviable It's seems non and not much variation from turn to turn the Builder strategy why let me know when you're ready for your clue I'm ready for clue number one give me a clue so the the Builder strategy it's kind of one of three types of people in the game the Builder being one of them so there's there's three different types of people that you can get and if you got a lot of Builders you would be doing kind of the Builder strategy if you got a lot of this isn't Stone Age no that doesn't have no um there's three types of people and gosh I feel like you know what there's also three of there's three goodlook people big on the cover at least of our addition of this game goodl looking that's subjective Ryan what game of ours

do we have the first edition that has three this is such a fa how do I not know I I think you're getting a zero for this one we were down to 0.1 points you know from CL oh my gosh three people Ryan I don't have a sing you owned before I owned it there's three people on the cover I think so three big faces one of them is wearing a cowboy hat Great Western Trail there's three people on the cover I think so isn't that the first edition oh my gosh okay one sec here we dangle is gonna verify if I'm lying oh my gosh you're right I was like that's pretty iconic look at that there you go I I still don't think that cover looks as bad as everybody says it does but Daniel took off his headphones so he probably can't hear anything I'm saying right now I was just telling them how you took off your headphones and probably can't hear anything I'm saying right now well I don't listen to you anyway so it's all good um okay can you just can you just like quickly read the comment again now that I know what game there no idea why the ratings are so high played it for the first and hopefully only time last weekend it's a slog two hours felt like 4 hours it's boring and very repetitive not much Vari from turn to the Builder strategy seems nonviable not sure what people see in this game thank my friend who owns it feels similarly and we be selling and trading it you know it is interesting the Builder strategy in that

game I would say that's the one I've had the least or maybe I've just done the least like gone all in on it the other ones are a lot more obvious to just make happen but I have seen it done pretty powerfully because the fact that you upgrade the buildings like you can really get a lot of points just having the

I'm try let us know in the comments if the Builder strategy I just can't believe there's three faces on that cover I just thought it was I thought was be I was so mesmerized by the center guy that I just missed the other two there you go well H hit me with number two D I'm winning uh 0.5 to zero right now you know it's 0.5 to Zer but the Gap feels a lot larger than uh than than that um uh okay Ryan so this one's a little little bit of a shorter comment but uh so a puzzly Tetris placing zero interaction sandbox boore of a game experience welcome to soliter land with many of these games I might as well sit by myself the game felt like punishment

blah so do you know what the first game that came to mind was what was it this is not an official guess unless it's a right unless it happens to be right well you can't say it's not an official guess unless it's right Ryan that's called being we'll say you're allowed multiple guesses as long as you don't get the first clue you can still get full points but uh tasty humans was the first thing that came your own game I should have I mean read that com somebody who doesn't like this humans would say just for for The Listener tasty humans is a game Ry Ryan design game R design go check it out link down below yeah yeah if you can still find um okay yeah so it has a puzzly yeah a puzzly Tetris placing zero interaction sandbox B of A game experience I just love that you thought of your own game when I read that yeah you know what comes to mind first w r it's a bit a little self-deprecating okay um welcome to Solitaire land I might as well sit by myself the game felt like punishment BL I'm going to say Planet unknown that is incorrect incorrect the other one that came to mind was Feast for Odin and that is correct is correct A Feast for Odin okay I claim four points on that yeah I was going to be a little surprised if you pointed unknown cuz I literally like just got it played it but no but definitely I mean a the sandbox experience I mean that's very much a uh something that you know you experience in uh in Feast for Odin um but yeah it's

punishment the game felt like punishment I know that's a that's classic so I'm going to punish my children you have to play we're playing Feast for Odin tonight I know yeah well and you know it is interesting cuz the um you know it says welcome to Solitaire land you know I think that game doesn't have a ton of like you know whereas like it's the worker placement a little bit but it's pretty pretty open and forgiving it's one of those things that it's like that is a feature or a bug depending on the person like some people the more solitar it is they are like this is terrible some people are like this is my favorite type of game is when I get to work on my own thing and not have people mess with me so I might as well sit by myself well dang I've taken a strong 1.5 to zero lead I know you're blowing me out man got to perform you I've got a shorter one for you as well um I need like a list of all my games in front me I know this is this is the the exercise okay here we go see how well your brain works it's most overrated game ever okay I've got a guess now like this game is super boring you just collect cards and then trade them in eventually could go on a list with Monopoly and risk fighting for the worst overrated game ever created one out of 10 oh man okay collect cards and trade them in eventually um let me think here I got to taken PE see Ry I've

got yeah but you also have a good memory so that that helps um let's see here collecting cards I'll take a clue number one okay uh we definitely claim that this game is like a classic modern board game like it's oh I know what it is okay it's tiet to ride it's ride yeah there we go there we go okay yeah good job dang I mean uh so the comment you just you collect cards and turn them in and I mean kind of kind of this it's overlooking a lot of the tension and TI a dve between the different actions and feel like you could make I feel like you could make a comment that's very like dry about like any board game like the resources and I eventually trade them for the things that give me points this game is two out of 10 two out of 10 yep but you know okay well half a point that's a half Point yeah give me that strong Half Point come back man come back except it's not really a comeback when I just got one and you got half oh is true I'm falling the Gap has uh increased uh okay Ryan um okay we're going to go with this one um next comment uh is you know they I'm curious where someone is at mentally to start out a comment like this but

we're just going to go with it um I would rather choke on my own underwear than ever Glimpse this game again what a worthless waste of time and pile of garbage I guess if tug ofwar is your thing then go for it but you don't ever make any real progress in the game two-player games like this are very frustrating I take my turn to undo what you did then you take your turn to undo what I did repeat Until the End one out of 10 interesting most of most of the biggest clues in the underwear comment by the way that's that's where you really got where you really got yeah well as you started my mind was going to Challengers but then it got into like the two cuz like the tug of war with no real decisions but then it got into more two-player and like undoing what the other player did yeah I would say it's less around decisions cuz this game certainly does have decisions but it's the tug of war to back and forth the game I think of with tug of war is Twilight Struggle and that is correct is that really Twilight wow wow what a comment what a comment what a comment um you know right it is funny with the guessing on these cuz you you think of gaming you're like surely it's not that game uh what you don't ever make any real progress in the game that's not true

Ryan's blown me out many you haven't seen us play Ryan's made massive progress M oh gosh yeah but uh but I suppose if you don't like you know kind of the the tug of-war Style game I can't like imagine coming away from that game with the feeling of there's no like real decision they had some comment there about their not it so they said after the underwear comment what worthless waste of time pile of garbage I guess if tug OFW is your is your thing then go for it but you don't make any real progress in the game oh real progress so about decisions uh more just that feeling of like I do something and then you just maybe he played it once he or she played it once and TI well you know what I'm thinking maybe they just uh uh what's it called when you just place like you just normally place influ maybe they just weren't even playing any like cards for weren't doing any other actions and the only action they thought they could do was just placing influence is something I think about a lot is like how in modern board gaming games are often played wrong more than they're played right like yeah we we get rules wrong all the time with games that we like know oh um and you wonder how often people end up at a negative review like this and really it's cuz like something was completely play they only thought they could place influence and so they're just placing back and forth dumb you know could have happened one out of 10 well dang I'm running away

with this thing but I believe in you on this one I believe in you I don't I love card games but I hate this game the special cards are pictorially meaningless and therefore impossible to keep straight I never have any idea what they do the scoring is nonsensical I look at my hand and have no idea whether it's good or bad or what to do with it pure frustration well run I have a guess you have a guess my guess is T you it is tachu but I feel like a boy that has cheated on the test because that was one of the comments that I you got the exact same you started reading it and I'm like H I think I know this one is that that's amazing we did not we did not collaborate at all that's unlike any games any comments that one jumped out to me as well um I love the phrase the special cards are pictorially meaningless I mean that is like a I mean they have different pictures I guess the art styles you know similar yeah I think the comment is like they don't tell you at all what they do maybe cuz they said be a little hard to remember like the Dragon versus the Phoenix but like you know a little a little overblown on on

how although on the other side I did just play this with uh a new group recently and I was having to kind of keep reminding what the things do but you pick on up on it uh really quickly you know the scoring is nonsensical it's a funny comment because in some ways tens and King although kind of every game that yeah yeah it's it it is a little arbit if yeah it's very much doesn't feel like as conect that's always like the hardest thing to explain in this game is you almost have to just be like oh don't care so much about the when you're new to it yeah don't worry too much about that worry about trying to make sure you can go out or you were your partner goes out first it is interesting though like someone who loves card games it's like man you know there's a good chance that tachu is going to be a very enjoyable game for you if you love card games but mhm you know have bad experience with it not for everybody we'd love teach you though well I hope you it's a good thing you said you brought extras right so I stle one of yours I've got extras yep um good I didn't think of that scenario so I'm in trouble if I'm glad I read mine first cuz I didn't I don't have any extras okay um let's see here we are GNA let's go with um let's go with this one uh wow I just just don't get what all the fuss is about reading their views you would think you make the most of what you have was a revolutionary new game idea not the stuff of Dusty luck driven

children's games dry repetitive gameplay arbitrary theme frustrating mechanics and a whole lot more luck than the Fanboys like to admit definitely not an adventure game as I understand the term and not a very good deck builder either copious downtime extinguishes any Sparks of pleasure this tedious stinker might otherwise I love that that's so good a soulless a soulless and pointless game that would have been ignored from any other designer one out of 10 wow there's a loten there's a lot here yeah as you're thinking I'll give you just the highlights uh so make the most of what you have um there was deck builder deck builder an people refer to it as an adventure um copious downtime soulless soulless um yeah I would say probably the yeah the biggest guess you got a guess I'm gonna guess Mage Knight that is correct Ryan dang look at you what was the what was the biggest uh clue in that for you I mean deck building Adventure narrowed it quite a bit cuz I'm like what would be deck building and Adventure I was like I guess Mage Knight has that um and then I was like well Vlad Shad he is kind of a bigname designer especially back when Mage

Knight would have been yeah you know he was kind of a hot designer during that time um right soulless what's funny is that in that whole comment they didn't say anything about like the rule book or like I know that's something you we would probably concede is like a weakness I know it would been so funny if at the end the rule book was great but but everything else was I mean it's just a very complex rule set hard to learn I know I know yeah Mage definitely not for everybody but man that's soulless sess cop what was it copious stinker or something uh well it was uh copious downtime extinguishes any Sparks of pleasure this tedious stinker I'll give it to them they've got good command of the English language that is what a wizard Vivid Vivid Vivid okay Daniel okay you know you're just trying to you know make this look uh competitive at this point I don't know that uh it's going to be in the cards to catch me no abysmal mashup game imagine everyone gets a bag of random chess Checkers and descent pieces some people get Queens While others get pawns oh and you can only play Che Checkers or descent but not all three yet the pieces can interact with yet the pieces can interact with pieces of other

games bad Randomness no planning yes you have to think each turn just as teenagers on cell phones have to readjust to conversations they keep they keep having to rejoin after being distracted by the latest Instagram or SnapChat wow what a comment what a comment what a comment okay so to break things down a little bit you you said a Abal mashup game then they go into kind of this thing about imagine everybody gets random chess Checkers and descent pieces how like some people get Queens some people get didn't you say a bag like they're all in a bag or something um that's kind of our that's just part that's not that's not a big clue Le leaning into that everybody gets different pieces and some people get really powerful ones and some people don't and they're all interacting but you can only play with let's see how did they word it here you can only play chess Checkers or descent but not all three so there's you can only pick one of them to use oh my gosh the abysmal mashup game is another clue it's definitely kind of mhm I'm just so mesmerized by that by that comment abysmal

mashup can I get a uh can I phone a friend no I'll take um so the the when he's talking about everybody getting you know something and some people get better or some people get worse um it is a game where everybody is getting like their own unique thing to use that they can't change that they're bringing into the game to play with and we're getting very different things it's also a pretty big clue the like needing to choose one of the three to do okay in like any turn we'll say okay every any given

turn oh gosh oh gosh Ryan I'm just I'm floundering um oh one sec you said you can do any three things you have to to like only play one of the three underwater cities no okay I was so I was I was trying to think of like the you know you can you're there's the three colors and you're play uh playing the card um man yeah I'm trying to think of another clue that wouldn't just give it away right I mean it is it's a game where literally on your turn the first thing you do is you declare one of the three things and you can only use what you

declared wow I don't know dang that was a pretty big clue so I I think this is going to be a zero pointer here I'm so bad at it's a game when you buy it you're going to get like a unique thing that you can't change oh my gosh okay key Forge yesy okay I haven't played key Forge in a hot minute just love the whole imagine everyone gets random chess Checkers and desent some people get Queens some people get Pawn you can only use one of them at a time okay gosh that was a two out of 10 by the way they you know not quite a one they still liked it somewhat they still lik it and then you do have to think in your turn just as teenagers on cell phones have to readjust their conversations they keep having to rejoin after being distracted by the latest Instagram or SnapChat yeah oh gosh that's good uh what number are we on now Ryan is is this I think this is the final one this is the final one yeah okay uh let's see here um okay I think we're going to go with this one it's a little bit of a longer one but it makes it more fun yeah mine's long too so a dice allocation game where Rolling High numbers is strictly better than rolling low that is never a good thing especially in a game where you roll your dice only six times you can get Dice from your opponents or flip yours but these options cost valuable

resources besides it may be annoying when you are the player whose dice are taken the cards are wildly unbalanced and require dice of a determined color but you must choose your initial dice with no information on which cards will be available of course you may get more dice during the game but you also may lose them as the other players take theirs and there's nothing you can do to prevent that all in all I found the amount of Randomness just unacceptable for such an overly long and complex and convoluted convoluted game and the bad iconography surely does not help also the ugly art and generic theme fail to disguise the complete abstractness three out of 10 I'm pretty confident that the answer is tuah it is tuah I as I was reading that one I was like oh Ryan's going to get this one immediately yeah so Ryan I'm going to just I'm just going to Pivot now cuz I have a bonus one oh you got a bonus I I was debating between I don't have a bonus for you so you have no chance for I've got a Bonus one cuz that one was that was too easy for you uh so we're going to move to this final one incredibly boring the theme is like someone made an obvious joke but it was interpreted as serious by the game maker ugly design ludicrous cartoon style horrible Forced Gameplay with absurd illogical rules the game brings out the bad of the players in that aspect it's an evil game really okay you're going to have to read that one more time yeah there's not

there's not a lot in here to latch on one more time incredibly boring the theme is like someone made an obvious joke but it was interpreted as serious by the game maker ugly design ludicrous cartoon style horrible Forced Gameplay with absurd illogical rules the game brings out the bad of the players in that aspect it's an evil game really wow it's a difficult difficult comment because there's a lot that you would just objectively disagree with what they're saying so you have to like I'm trying to cartoon artwork more cartoony artwork and it brings out the worst in the players probably the most you can latch on to is the the cartoon style somewhat and and maybe brings out the bad of the players although it's even that's kind of an interesting comment but man I had to whip out a tough one for you at it's a tough one I'm like struggling to think of like cartoony yeah it's artwork like not I don't know if cartoony is but it's you know the artwork is uh yeah cartoon I might need a clue describe I

might need a clue um so thinking about the last comment brings out the bad of the players um it's a game that a lot of people might not like this game um because of how the the mechanics of how the game uh makes you feel when playing it and the

constraint makes you feel like my mind is strain to kind of like more party games oh you are very far off very far off okay good you might consider it a party I don't know I need to give that the uh like there's like Cosmic Encounter but that's not no you're very far off Ryan um I give you another clue so it's an evil game really which maybe connects with there is a slogan about this game that for people who don't like it is this a gria is a gria you're going to have to read this again so I can think of it through that lens okay right this is this is a comment of arria yes incredibly boring the theme is like someone made an obvious joke but it was interpreted as serious by the game maker ugly design ludicrous cartoon style horrible Forced Gameplay with absurd illogical rules it's so funny cuz oflike Euro games it's one of the Euro games that the rules are so clearly tied to the theme like how it works on the pH no they're illogical r this is a true this is a True Farmer who yes uh yeah that was very disappointed by this yeah this game this game brings out the bad of the players in that aspect it's an evil game evil man to to get to the point

where you call a game evil I mean that's that it's like as they're writing the comment they have this realization like it's evil really there's no other word I guess that's what it is oh gosh I had to had to that yeah that was that would have been sad to miss yeah okay I've got one more for you Daniel okay I almost just read the name of the game because that would have been a really sad ending video super overrated game very repetitive and stupid game play the game is actually only carried by the theme and its many fans it's actually like a good book or novel if you're into that genre in an objective comparison with deck building games like Dominion paleo or magic this game is clearly inferior in terms of gameplay fun and variety of decisions the fact that this game ranks higher than paleo Dominion or magic once again clearly shows that the ranking at bjg is still a geek ranking and not an objective ranking of the really best games uh if you want to play a really tough Cooperative Adventure game with a variety of decision-making options and a great storyline then play Robinson cruso so they want you they want you to go to Robinson cruso read that last comment one more the last part of it one more time if you want to play a really tough Cooperative Adventure game with a

variety of decision-making options in a great storyline than play Robinson crusa I mean there also pretty big clue with like the in a comparison with deck building games like Dominion paleo or magic it's clearly inferior yeah so a deck building Adventure um game cooperative that's Cooperative but I own it so it is not like slay the Spire or something like that um yeah lean and it's talking about storyline said it's actually like a good book or novel if you're into that genre the genre of reading what a great genre if you're into that kind of thing oh my gosh oh let's see here deck building well okay my guess well I'm gonna go with Arkham hor of the card game it's Arkham more the card game Go yeah there it is with the the deck building the story line uh I just yeah I love the genre comment yeah I love that I also love the it clearly shows once again that the rank it BGG is a geek rating and not an objective you know that's a fair complaint Ryan I I just anytime people start talking about objective reviews or

objective rankings of games it's like you do know it's just like people what they think about it and like the rankings are just a bunch of people what they think about well no Ryan here it rolls in the family we're yeah we're object who is the objective Authority on this this guy I guess it's true reach out to him if you want to know how game is that was a three out of 10 three out of 10 could could have been lower but oh man yeah man just uh some nice negativity to start off our morning here hey thanks for watching this was a fun one for us to do and if you found this fun and you want us to maybe do this once a year let us know down in the comments below uh it definitely uh brought a lot of laughs for us and if you're interested in checking out another video we got a couple right here and we will see you in the next one

Progress saved