My Fourth Year Reviewing Board Games - Going Over My 2023 Reviews
Transcript
And we're back with 2023's review breakdown. This is part of an ongoing series I've been doing where I cover my reviews for basically an entire chunk of well, a year. Uh, I forgot the intro. Hi, I'm Alex Radical from Board Gameco and this is 2023's review breakdown. It's a series that I've been doing, a series of six videos covering 2020, 2021, 2022, 2023, 2024, and then eventually a recap that I haven't yet decided whether it will be live or just recorded. But either way, this is covering 2023's kind of year in review as far as my reviews that I gave out in 2023. To that end, a short recap. As far as average rating goes, my current average rating for 20, well, current, you can't change it anymore. My average rating for games I covered in 2023 was a 3.55. This is down from specifically, it was a 3.69 in 2020, a 3.61 in 2021, a 3.69 69 again in 2022 and then a 3.55 in 2023. I covered 70. Well, in in 2023, I did 329 reviews. This is the highest number I've ever done in a year. It does not ever get higher. At least Well, I mean, ever is a loose term. 2024 was lower again, but I did 72 reviews in 2020 in 2020. I did uh 209 reviews in 2021, 262 reviews in 2022, and 329 reviews in 2023. The breakdown of these scores are as follows. I had two 1.5s I gave in 2023. I have three twos I
gave, and this is three, sorry, to be specific. Sorry, two 1.5 out of fives, three two out of fives. I did 19 2.5 out of fives, 70 three out of fives, 121 3.5 out of fives, 77 four out of fives, 27 4.5 out of fives, and 10 five out of fives. If you've been following the series so far, you can definitely see there's a bit more of a drift towards being a drop more critical. Nothing crazy. Again, dropping from a 3.69 to a 3.55 is not huge, but across the number of reviews, that does have a decent chunk in the actual average. Uh but yeah, definitely been a bit more restrictive as time went on to being a bit more critical on average. Very minorly. No major shifts. My opinions didn't go from a game as good to a game as bad. But whenever I have that half point sliding because it deserve a 3.5, it doesn't deserve a three. I've been shifting a drop more towards a little more restrictive whenever I'm given the opportunity. You can see this even in last last year's uh breakdown of 2022.
Well, not last year's breakdown, the breakdown of 2022 reviews. there was like I think there were like 14 4.5s and 17 fives versus this year there's 27 4.5s and 10 fives meaning like there's definitely a larger shift towards 4.5s just airing on the side of does it really deserve a five out of five although there's some interesting uh background to that as well that we'll get into in this video. My most a my most common rating is a 3.5 out of five as you can see with a 121 3.5 to fives and then a very narrow split between 70 threes right before it and 77 fours right after it. So I'm a bit more inclined to give a four than a three. Although that does make sense. I do generally find that games are more satisfying than not. A three is usually a game that is just kind of forgettable.
It was fun, but like I don't care at all. Like I just don't care. I had fun playing it. Move on next. Whereas a 3.5 is already a good game and I do find most games are good games, but I only get to the recommendation point at fours because there's too many 3.5s to recommend a game just because it's good. So that's kind of the overall breakdown over there. As far as the games that got a 1.5, those were too block and guess. It was a party game that I got from Gen Con that I really thought failed horribly at what I was trying to do. And then Epic 7 Arise I thought was a mess. A good premise. I wanted to like it, but I thought it was a mess in terms of components, in terms of rules, and in terms of the general gameplay. My two out of fives are less notable or interesting. But I had Come on, Bite Me, Oh My Brain, and Roll for Great Old Ones. The first two weren't really on my radar. They just weren't really great games. Roll for Great Old Ones was actually a campaign I backed that I was excited for, and I was very disappointed that I just did not like the game. I thought it was I thought it was kind of a miss overall. As far as my 4.5s, we have a whole lot over here. So, I'm going to rattle through these pretty quickly, but I will have some notes on the the things that I think are interesting. We had 20 Strong, Seven Wonders Duel, Ancient, sorry, 20 Strong, 7 Wonders Duel, Ancient Realms, Apiary, Assassin's Creed, Apocalypse, Beast, Shattered Isles, Carson City, Endeavor Deep Sea, Evidol, Farhore, For Northwood, Four, Shuffle, Framework, General Orders World War II, Innovation, Junk Drawer, Marrakesh, Marvel United, Marvel United Multiverse, specifically uh we had, oh, sorry, the Marvel United Spideron specifically Massive Darkness Hellscape, Match of the Century, My City, Natureopoulos, Run, Spiritfire,
Trail Blazers, Wafers of Sigus, and Wizards of the Grimmooire, as well as the Wizards of the Grimmooire Shifting Sands expansion. Those are the 27 4.5s or fives. Honestly, I think most of those are still here, if not all of them. I think most all of them might be still here. They might all still be here. Like there's Yeah, I think they're all still in my collection. Then there we have my five out of fives. And I'll get to the interesting notes soon. We have my five out of fives which were a feast for Odin, cichlides, dei which is divide at imper from louisis magna studios, expeditions, marvel united multiverse, mythic mischief, mythic mischief 2 specifically. I'd already covered mythic mischief. Mythic mischief 2 revive sori teneris adventures and ticket to ride legends of the west were my five out of fives. I will say this year has the highest amount of five out of fives that stayed five out of fives.
The only one that shifted was Tenerous Adventures dropped to a 4.5. The others are still five out of five games for me that I think are absolutely amazing and definitely recommend that you check out in any way, shape, or form. If you if they seem remotely interesting, check them out. They are great games. On the other hand, my 4.5s, a bunch of them shifted upwards. Again, this goes back to me being a drop more conservative my ratings where sometimes if I wasn't sure, I gave it a 4.5 and then if time goes on and I think it sticks the landing, it did get the five out of five later. Not in the video, unfortunately, but in later recaps or in top 100s or things like that. To that end, the games that I've moved to a five out of five are Seven Wonders Duel, Ancient Realms, Evidel, Farhore, for Northwood, Marvel United, Better Expire Get On, My City, and Trailblazers. So, seven of those 27 4.5s actually became fives later, which means if I had done the breakdown properly, instead of being 27 and 10, it would have been 20 and 17. And I'm still fine with this. I'd rather air on the side of caution. Like I'd rather have a kind of look back where my fives didn't shift downwards and my 4.5 shifted upwards. I'd much rather that aspect. I I think I take more of a mental responsibility to if I'm really excited about a game and I love it and it's a five and a five and then later it's a four, I feel bad about that versus if I'm really excited about a game and I give it a 4.5 and then later it becomes a five, that's fine with me. That's that's, you know, that's a game sticking the landing. That's a game lasting and not just having the initial appeal, but continuing to hold up across multiple plays, whatever it is that ends up continuously changing it. But any case, by the way, some some of those games are incredible for Northwood and Trailblazers. Some of my absolute
favorite games to play both as well, as I say, both multiplayer and solo, but that's true for Trailblazers. For Northwood is just solo. That is basically my breakdown. Overall, most of those are still fives. Like I said already, Acropolis dropped. No, Acropolis is from last last video. I meant to say um Triness Adventures is the one that dropped. But overall, that is my breakdown of 2023. No major changes, nothing crazy going on here, but the amount of reviews shifted up, although it will shift down a bit in 2024. The average rating was 3.55, which is my lowest so far. Although, we will see what 2024 brings. And overall, I seem to be shifting a drop more to the middle, a little bit away from the end of the positive side, and shifting just a drip just to being a bit a bit more a bit more mindful. In any case, and until next time, I'm Alex Radical from Board Game Code. This has been your 2023 review breakdown, and we'll be back with 2024 at at some point. at some point and and and and I hope you have a good