Skip to main content
Loading video...

Top 10 Board Games I Want to Play But Not Own - Chairman of the Board

Transcript 14:11

hey everybody today i'm talking about my top 10 ball games that i want to play but not necessarily own and that could be for a number of reasons perhaps there's something in the rules or mechanically that raises concern for me because maybe through previous experience it hasn't gone down too well and additionally maybe i just know these games aren't going to be right for my collection because i'm never going to have the right opportunity or game group to get these ones off the shelf and get them played but despite those issues there's still something here that intrigues me and makes me want to try them out so let's get started with the list now of course i've never played any of these games so my knowledge of these games is going to be a lot less than it normally would but regardless of that let's get started at number 10. at number 10 i have lord of the rings journeys in middle earth so the main reason i want to play this one is because of the intellectual property itself i'm a massive lord of the rings fan and something i really want to get into the mindset of is try to divert so much about thinking about the the mechanical side of games i find it very hard to enjoy games that are purely story driven and focus more on the immersion and theme of the game more than the actual you know mathematical part of the game and i think maybe journeys in middle earth could be the game to sway me more from that mechanical side of things to that story side of things because i am so invested in the theme itself and i also quite like the idea that this game isn't kind of dice driven in terms of its combat you are flipping cards over to resolve combat and trying to match symbols and things that sounds interesting to me and one of the other kind of big red flags for me is that

this is so app driven i know this is you know a big portion of the game is going to be the digital side of things rather than the actual um like physical cardboard pieces and that for me is also good raising some concern but i think maybe i could overlook that i could enjoy a few sessions of this one and additionally i do tend to play most kind of one and done style games you know and i don't tend to play a lot of campaigns or legacy style games but i think this one could have enough to hook me again because of that ip so i know this has a lot of praise there's a lot of things you could do with the app here because you can constantly add new content new stories new characters and you know this one could be the game if i had the time to invest in that could really help me immerse get me immersed in the actual story and then the theme which normally would be something i wouldn't do so that is journeys in middle earth at number 10.

at number nine i have merchants and marauders so this one i just love the idea and concept of this being almost like a sandbox style pirate themed game as you can sail around you know fight pirates you can do trading you can pretty much do anything you want in this game and you're not given a direct path you're not led down a certain track and i like that idea and i must say i've not really played a sandboxy style game before and i'm interested to see how i would kind of respond and react to it so yeah that for me just it sounds interesting and i like pirate games in general i like the way this game looks i have again heard some concerns about some of the mechanical standpoints of the game and it's taking too long um some big elements of down play in this i'm down time in this game again which normally is again another red flag for me but i would like to just take an afternoon and just enjoy or explore what this game has to offer you'll see how i react to a sandbox style game and because this one is the pirate theme it could be the right game for me so that is merchants and marauders at number nine at number eight i have a diplomacy so diplomacy is kind of like an iconic air and majority negotiation style game i tend to like those things um but the big red flag for me in this one is how long it takes now this one is going to take four five six hours to play i just haven't got the gaming group to invest that amount of time um into playing a game particularly when it's going to be as dry as this but for me this one really is on that bucket list style of game for me i want to play this at least once in my life

and just again put that evening or afternoon decide just to fully get immersed and get my head in the game i understand this is completely cutthroat and people can get eliminated and things but i think if everybody gets into the right mindset and everyone's prepared about prepared for that going into the game then this could be something i really embrace and get into so we're really intrigued by this game i want to try it um but i really don't see that happening anytime soon at least that is diplomacy at number eight at number seven i have this war of mine this is another game that's really hooked me because of the story-driven style of things this is all about the doom and gloom and fallout of people on the kind of ground level of an ongoing war so i like that gritty nature of the game i tend to like dark stories i like depressing stories believe it or not but um yeah i'm interested to see how well the writing is implemented in this game you know i do read a lot and i've heard this game is really well written and quite well quite poignant i suppose in its approach um i've got some concerns about the actual gameplay itself i know is it purely based on that story side of things or is the gameplay strong or is it simply just kind of going through the motions and seeing how the story develops i'll be interested to find that one out this almost kind of rings bells of a game like dead of winter a game that i thought mechanically was very weak but i did like the way that the story is developed and the kind of lasting memories you took from the game and i think maybe this war of mine could fall into that category something i definitely want to try but i really don't see it being right for my

collection so that's why this war of mine is at number seven at number six i have western legends now the reason for this one being in the on the list is almost identical to merchants and marauders being on the list however i think this one looks a little bit more polished than merchants and marauders in terms of the gameplay itself so this one is another sandbox style game but in certainly kind of wild west as you can go around you can gamble you know with these poker cards you can kind of heard castle you can go and you know hunt down bandits and things uh you could be an outlaw yourself so lots of things you can do here and you're pretty much given free reign to do what you want and i've heard that even a lot of um kind of more mechanical minded gamers enjoy this game which actually does intrigue me a bit more so uh again it looks really good on the table you know the presentation and the production is fantastic and i'm quite interested about how this one plays out i think this one could be one of the ones in terms of the gameplay that i would enjoy the most on this list um that is western legends definitely would be willing to um you know set aside a few hours and give that one a play at number five i have cedarial confluence so this one is a pretty involved euro negotiation style game which you might think you know if you watch my content regularly it might take a lot of boxes for me and yes that is the case you know on paper this is everything i'd like but i just know that i haven't got the game group to enjoy this one so not only because i know this game goes on for hours and hours and hours but also it's quite involved and quite

complex whereas the negotiation games i tend to enjoy i play with more casual gamer friends and they like that kind of low barrier to entry and this one is going to really require a lot more of that initial rules intake and a lot more rules overhead in order to get the game playing in the first place but with the right group i could really see this game shining for me as you really are kind of converting resources into other resources trying to get as many points as you can and strike up those great deals that benefit you more than other people get out of all these games this is probably the game i'd probably take a chance on actually purchasing for myself but i just know i have that that kind of knowledge in the back of my head this isn't going to go down well with my gaming group it's going to be too much um and it's just not going to strike that right balance of the negotiation and just the rules overhead so unfortunately i don't see this one giving a right for my collection but i would certainly be very excited to try somebody else and be taught this game and to get it played so that is cederial confluence at number five at number four i have a bit of a silly one with fireball island so this one is a very simple i think it's a set collection style games you're moving a little kind of um tourist around this big island but this island is this big plastic almost like um injection molded plastic structure and every now and then these marbles roll down these different shoots and can potentially knock your player piece over basically and set you back a bit i just think this game would go down really well but i think my concern is that it would go down really well once and then it get very tiring and very boring very quickly so for that reason i'm not going to invest

in the high price price tag to get this onto my shelf just to get it played once or twice um and take up a hell of a lot of space but something i'd really like to experience i think it looks like a lot of fun and um you know for a light game it's got that novelty factor and that fun factor that tends to go down well but for very limited times so um you know for that reason um i'd like to play fireball ireland but i certainly don't think it's going to be right for my collection at number three i have blood on the clock tower so this is a really involved social deduction style game with a lot going on there are tons of different roles where you're trying to you know as the bad guy basically trying to um win the game through nefarious means and the good guys are trying to wean out those bad guys and to find out who they are and expose them i tend to enjoy social deduction games if they're well executed um maybe three years past i did enjoy them more than i do now but i still think the good ones do stand up well and i do like to play them you know periodically this one it looks like more involved than any other social deduction game i've played before for better or worse and i think it would be a really solid game but i think there's too many moving parts here and it requires too high of a play account to get the most from this game so first of all i'm pretty sure this game requires a moderator to actually you know make sure the game runs smoothly which is automatically going to take my play account count down by one generally my maximum player account is going to be six players i think this one shines starting at about eight players

which is never ever happens for me um so for those reasons alone i'm just never gonna get this one played if i did end up purchasing it and i just know it's going to be played so few and far in between that um that it's just not going to warrant a purchase but i'd love to be taught this one in the right experience for the big play account where everyone's invested and wants to get the most out of it i think it would go down a treat but that's just not going to happen very regularly at all i'm talking years apart so therefore i'm not going to buy blood on the cat clock tower but would love to try it at number two i have the king's dilemma so i think i mentioned at the beginning of the video that campaign games and legacy style games generally don't fit my style of play because i play so many different things i don't have the time or the really inclination to play the game again and again and again to make sure i have that thread of story made remaining fresh in a player's mind or all the players minds and the king's dilemma is very story driven as you are basically take up i suppose the possession of all these royal figures or basically the king's council i suppose and you're trying to advise him and all these different almost like political um events basically and they can be quite controversial things you're trying to sway the king or try to influence that decisions to your needs and your your basic your house's needs and desires and i love that idea you know this kind of historical drama basically where you're trying to steer things in your direction and to argue your case as to why that one is now i love that idea in a thematic sense and it isn't a in an immersive sense

but i do have massive concerns about how strong the gameplay in this game actually is how much of it is player driven in terms of creating that story and immersion yourself and how does that lincoln hook with the actual mechanisms of the game and the decision space in the game um so i'll be interested to see or hear your opinions if you've played the kingston and how those two things are balanced and how well of a design is it in terms of the gameplay and how well of it is dependent on the players creating the story and immersion themselves but i'll be really interested in trying this one with the same group again and again and again really getting invested in the story and seeing where it goes and basically fighting your corners and creating these compelling arguments as to why you should do certain things i'm really intrigued by the setting of this one but again those those red flags for me about how strong is the gameplay itself is something that i can't quite get over but would love to try it to see if that was the case or not that is the king's dilemma at number two and finally at number one i have root so root is more of a war style euro style game and i'm pretty confident i would enjoy this game this is a ultra asymmetrical game where each player takes a different faction and they all win and interact in completely different ways and for me that is the big appeal to this game but it's also probably the biggest um the biggest area for concern because i just have a massive idea in my head that when i if i did purchase this game or teach it to other players then that initial teach is going to be too much um and just to break it down and just explain a different game to each player

it's just going to be too much of an initial rules overhead and it's going to completely basically alienate people before the game even gets started so i don't think the people who i play this with would have enough investment or desire to learn the game and would be interested enough to play the game again and again to get the most out of it so you know for that reason i just know it's not gonna be right for me you know if i'm thinking logically that is the case but again if somebody was very knowledgeable about the game and could teach the game to me i would have other people who are wanting to play the game and to experience the game to the fullest then i just know this game would be a hit for me so no sadly it's not right for my collection but i'm pretty sure that i'd love it so that is root at number one so i hope you've enjoyed this video um if you again if you do have any knowledge about these games and maybe have some knowledge about the games i tend to enjoy then i'd like to hear your feedback on these do you think i would enjoy them or not and for everyone else i really appreciate you checking out this video if you have enjoyed it please hit like and subscribe to my channel and check out my other content too additionally if you want to go that extra step and support me on patreon then i'll leave the link below for that one and for everyone else i'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye now

Progress saved