Skip to main content
Loading video...

20 games we never played before (Keep or Cull)

Transcript 35:30

thank you hello everyone this is Johannes and this is Cinema and you are watching board gaming ramblings welcome back to keep or color where we play our whole collection of 600 plus plus board games and decide whether to keep or call them and this is another episode of self of Shame project which is the kind of spin-off series like I love it when we have our own spin-up series or our own show big like oh we're gonna make a speed of series which is like the exact same show just with different games different games that and all the shows of Keeper Girl already have different games so it's kind of the same thing but this this we haven't played before but we have owned them for a lot of them a long time and some of them for a shorter time yeah but these are games that we hadn't played before that we owned before January 1st 2023 yes that's kind of the rules for this one which is a special episode of keeper call that you get every month in addition to the other Keeper Girl episodes we want to finish this year yeah just having that said and the statistics tells us then that we have to play eight to nine games every month to make that happen we did that the first three months yes then the third month we played five which was bad bad people playing few board games no fun how many did we play this time 20. you probably

already know because it's probably in the thumbnail so it's not like exciting wow did that happen we didn't know we did because that's kind of the advertisement for this episode to make you watch it so now we're going to talk about 20 games some of them are small some of them are bigger none of them are like super big should we just get going yes let's talk about games first game Sherlock death on the 4th of July starting off with a pleasant theme murderer this is kind of like a detective style board game which you could know by the name let's do the thing yes one two three boom I thought when I read the rules for this game that oh that sounds fun because your playing cards from your hand and you have to like keep or kill them and yeah keep them or discard them and you want to keep the relevant information to your case and discard the non-relevant and you have to guess I have a question for you yes was it fun no it wasn't it was very hard very hard and not fun yeah it was like we don't know what cards we're just doing something um but it made sense like it was not an illogical thing it was just that it was not fun no I didn't care much for it we have another game starting with the smaller ones because those are on the top on the pile if I put this under other games the power will fall over yes this is mint delivery this is in a series of games in a kind of enlarged mint box this about is about delivering things are you ready for the thing yes one two three boom this was a boring game this was just like going through

the motion doing things which was picking up and delivering but there was really no strategy it was just doing the thing that made obvious sense the good thing it took 15 minutes oh yeah positive thing but it was not a good game so it's going on the co-pilot do you have anything to add no I fully agree with you crime soon zooming in on the cry yes this is also like in a mystery solving that is detective game and this is called bird of ill Omen yes because we've already played another one called something else yes which is it's not the same thing it's not the same yes so you want to do the paddle yes one two three boom I don't know if I should like it's it's a cult because we're not gonna play it again yeah this is one time thing but I like this one a lot I really enjoyed this I think that um the system that I've created with like a cars displaying like a room and you have to like oh I want to invest it that closer you flip that around and it was a good lead or a bad lead you're actually getting like some fingerprints some evidence that was cool and trying to figure out what happened I really like this series yes I think I could recommend them if you enjoy this kind of shorter detective style games this one's good so yeah but obviously not gonna keep it because it's the one I've already played it next up another detective Style game pocket detective I think we bought it such a Spiel in like 2018 or something maybe 19 and now we plan it and this is the one

let's talk about it let's do the battle okay one two three boom yes uh same kind of thing I like this one I think this one was fun in the same it was I think I like the crime soon better but this was of the other ones we played I think this is last one so the three we played this was in the middle yeah green it was it was fine yes I I there is like a bigger box now from looking at games like this is season one case one and there's like three cases but somebody said this is the best but I think now you can get it like in a box because this is like self-published from a small publisher next up we have another game this is monster and what is this game about oh it's uh um a weird weird game what is it about monsters it's like the theme is like being in a movie but it's an abstract game trying to place your cards like the the color you have gotten randomly hidden in your hand you want most of those cards to show at the end of the round because that's going to give you points I don't want to try to hide what color you have with the other players we play the two players probably better with more yeah since two to six yeah so two is usually not Advanced let's do the paddle one two three boom I like the concept of this game you always need like trying to okay I want blue to show the most but maybe I should like not make it so obvious so that you only target blue when you're like covering a monsters up so you're trying to like maybe yeah the juice what the other player have but also then and not make

it obvious what you have I think that would be fun to play with more lighting very chaotic game though but it's not a key for me I don't love it but I liked it like this is one it was a surprisingly fun game so if you if you do like this kind of like it's a quick playing game it has some deduction in it like 15 minutes on the box so yeah that's a good one next up we have another exit game uh these are games that we used to really love the exit games and they're kind of not getting better uh so let's do this one yeah this is an upside down now it wasn't the gate Between Worlds one two three boom this is also a one-time thing it is an escape room game if you haven't heard of the X6 series before I think like yeah because it's you're cutting things with scissors you're like bending things so you're destroying the game it's you can't play it more it's not possible especially when you chew it in a garbage you cannot play it again but I think like the first exit boxes were good like up and down um but in the last one we played I I need to stop buying exit games I feel like because there's so many good games and except it's just not good enough for for me no but we still like them yeah like and so but now we just want them to be as good yes please make better games next game is Astra yes on to the bigger

boxes Australia is a game about doing Star viewing you look at the stars and then you mark them with a pen like in real life and then if you mark the lost or in a pen you get to take the card and other people get to get points and do things that is my overview of the game and now let's do the paddle yes one two three boom this felt fresh I like this game uh I think it's cool with the um you're trying to have like the majority of stores marked on the card because then you get a good bonus but it's the last star that gets marked that gets to keep the card and you're trying to get points basically that's what the game is about it was a boring game I thought it was fun but it's not fun enough for me to keep because I will not play it but this was actually I like this one we played five players yes which was a bit chaotic oh yeah because it was very tactical in it but like when you got if it was my turn I could take a card I would probably take a card yeah and if I couldn't take a card I would probably do something else yeah but but if you had we spent a lot of resources marking a lot of stores on my car already you maybe will not take it because you will get the best bonus and that is to like choose but it was it was fine it was we spent an hour and 20 minutes playing it that's the time it took it was a game that we played and I'm not gonna remember that it exists next up on the list is a small box again Aztec this is one that we got from madigo with other games for a long time

ago and have not had a possibility to play it I read the rules and it sounded horrible and and I'm kind of like didn't play it and then I read rules again I was like yeah it still sounds horrible and we didn't get to play it and then your brother came out we're only found some games to play and we plugged played it yeah because he needs to play horrible games apparently apparently he's like oh let's find something that people hate so we play this and now we're gonna do the paddle yes one two three boom boom oh this was fun yeah it was really it was kind of like the The Twist did you see the twist coming on you this was gonna be no you didn't know I was gonna no but I didn't know that you because now you're kind of like saying to people that we know no no we don't but I know that I needed I didn't know that you would keep it I was a little short myself because it's like we have so many other games you know but I really like this one yes um it had like a cool um you draw a card and then it says how many like gems you get and then you can decide to follow the card or just take some other random gems and then yeah and then you look at the other players and be like hmm did you really get those gems and you have to like decide if they are bluffing or telling the truth and then you get things based on if you correct wrong or correct so I don't want to keep it it was fun yeah I liked it I was like when we started I was like oh yeah there is something here and it was just like silly fun yeah but it was a lot of fun silly fun so it's one that I think with more players gonna be even

more fun yes it's a as as the same with monster against we played at the the minimum player count and when a game goes from three to six it's probably going to be better with four or five than it is yeah and also who doesn't love a good theme about kids robbing like ancient temples that's a weird thing perfect next up we have Century Eastern wonders this is the second game in the Century Trilogy we never played the third one I play this once uh but games on this like silver frame is games that you haven't played as well like yeah either yes but this one I had played I don't think we own a game that you have played I haven't played no uh but this one you didn't because this came out when you were studying somewhere else when I played it once and now I played it again you know the drill next to the paddle one two three boom I think that it was all right uh it had like a cool Twist on the original game that you're instead of getting cars that lets you convert resources you're traveling around and converting on these different Islands that's true but I like the original better um we call that so I'm calling this as well yeah good ending to that sentence good we have other games to talk about this one for example is a game and it's called solar sphere face solars solar it's called sphere solar spare I don't know swear spare spare swear it is a game uh about being in space and trying

to build things on the sun I don't know why you wouldn't die you're burning yes no it's a very weird thing I I think it's like in space because in science fiction so maybe now we know how we will live on the sun and you're trying to do other things as well but they don't matter um oh yeah that's true one two three boom it seems that this game is broken yeah I I hope someone's gonna be like you played it completely wrong because we read the rules four times when we're playing like this makes no sense and we also checked on btg and no like two people that don't ask the questions and nobody announced it because like there's really no reason to do anything else than just build on the place because there's so many ways like there's actions to get resources but you can just use something called morale to get those resources that you need to build on the sun and then when somebody builds a Json to you on the sun then you're gonna get morality on your next turn than used to get those resources that you need to build on the Sun so you're just gonna build understand the game is six rounds yeah it ended after three yes because we have built along the whole thing and that's still the trigger of the game yeah in fact like in um you play five players yeah in in three rounds we had like done nine actions each yes and seven of those actions for one of our players was building on the sun yeah and there's quite a lot of actions like a lot of things you could do but don't because you can just build on a sun and win

oh this sounds really cool and I hope we did something wrong next up is Sesame it's a game about coffee in Berlin a deck building kind of game with different elements and some of the best components I have ever seen in a book they are amazing kind of like with flamecraft I just want to keep the game just because of the components they're so beautiful this is again and here you have this kind of resin uh you have coffee beans that you can take with the little things and so now I can cheat and try to do it many times until she gets as many as you want to you can like add an exterior element and you also have this very cute sugar cubes yeah just like they look like sugar they look you want to eat it the whole game the production is amazing but it's a game good or is it bad let's find out next time on Kino against all right okay one two three boom I thought the game was fine yeah for me nothing more and I wanted to love it so bad because of the components it was so beautiful I was like please be amazing and it was fine yes but I think like um it will sit on the Shelf if we we keep it we will not play no we will just like look at the game and be like oh those beautiful resources yeah and we can put them on the Shelf somebody else can get to play this game instead that is true that's how it works next up we have a big game called Mosaic a story of civilization this is again we did a preview of it so we kind of played a prototype but we have decided to add all the games that we know our own retail

coffee so I like the actual copies of two to seven because games can change and stuff like that Mosaic is like a very card driven uh civilization game kind of it has kind of like terraforming Mars Vibes about you have these tags which is a huge part of the game trying to get them uh yeah let's do the paddle yeah one two three boom I thought this was fun yeah I like it it just took a little long time for me personally you have these decks of cards that uh will like you have to reach some points of those decks for the game to end or everything's like you get points for like these Milestones basically it has to be taken it myself so everything you did in the game I liked I like the area majority I like to collecting the tags I like trying to reach the different goals and also building up your little cities and towns and get these trade goods I liked it I just thought like at the end of the game oh it's nothing more to do I like when the game is like Cuts me off and I step around but no this is the game now I have to do more stuff and it didn't feel like that no and I know a lot of people love this and it is for a lot of people and I think that is like the main reason for me to call it yes is that somebody else also will enjoy it more than I did and we'll have more funny fun more funny stuff more fun with this copy like and

as you know like these games that we like playing for the first time are easier to call because they haven't kind of been in their collection yet so I I we are calling this and other games like sister bean I could have kept yes uh because it's so nice and I liked it kind of enough I know somebody else will enjoy it more so as we talked about last time like why am I keeping this a hostage on the shelf and just like getting dust when somebody can enjoy the game yes that is kind of my mind so many games I'm trying to think that way more and more these days is it me yeah yeah you're looking for see it in your eyes connecting flights the game that Wendy and Chris on the dance Tower loved so much no I think they gave it like a four and a two or something good uh but did we like it that is actually we don't care about when they are well we care about you but you know okay are you ready yes one two three boom calling day yeah we're calling a lot today uh but is it serious you said to call the new games um as well yeah yeah I agree I didn't care too much for this game I liked some aspects of it like you have to have a a good enough playing for the passengers and you have to deliver them to uh uh what you call airport yes that is not the right word and you have to uh like match like a pattern and you

want to if you could like travel multiple times in the same like I don't know the problem with this game for me sorry were you know this game is one it's very random yeah like oh I want a level two customer let's hope one shows up that wants to go to where I want it to go which is random and then it also has this super fun thing which you got to enjoy a lot sabotage yeah which we don't usually like and you're like oh no you can't do this and you can't do that I think you still won but yeah it was it wasn't fun it was just a a fine game I don't and this is the deluxe edition I think what does that mean is there anything in this that sounded Deluxe this is the deluxe edition I don't know why this is the Luxe it's the game I don't recommend it but it is here but it is again soon not now it's my turn this is another game oh oh it's called Space Alert Space Alert from Brother survival we really like a lot of skins most of the time there's so many different games and Space Alert is a real-time Cooperative game about you being very bad at running a space station we played with five players and we play three games of it so that we because this one game that you cannot really play once and then understand it we played three times didn't understand it and now we're gonna do the paddle yes are you ready yeah one two three boom

um oh I was thinking you were gonna do key for this really yeah I I this was so hard yes and it's hard isn't bad no but hard is bad when we you have a hobby that is playing a lot of different games and not the same game over again because I always talked about right after we played it if you have like a game group and you get really good at like communicating and like delegating in tasks I think you could like have a lot of fun with this game but we were just like I'm going up in the elevator like the first round we did nothing I'm trying to fire off this cannon but oh there's no energy because no one has refilled that and so it's very hard but I thought it was a fun game yeah and this is like a I I don't think like this is a I think it's all the print but uh and this is a brand new copy basically yeah because we punched it yesterday I don't know when why we got it already because it was lunch bottle yeah we had kept this it's on your side now on the other side of the color pile if you can't find the game it's so many games on my side you have one over there ah next up we have Dune house Secrets yes the detective game from Portal Games if you go to bdg you can see why we haven't played this search for now because I think like it's like a five on bits working geek and to be a five on Morgan geek people do not like this game and we played just the tutorial match because time and yes yes liked it a lot let's do

one two three one two tree boom we love detective we really do of course one of the best experiences it's amazing like what it lacks in great actors and like Cliffhanger trailers for The Next Episode in a real like show on TV yeah it makes up for in like you're making the seasons yourself yes and you feel really involved they have taken all that away in these later games and it takes just away so much of what I love from detective so I don't really consider this a detective game um I don't care too much for this one might have like a cool story but this is not what I want from a game many people have said it's not a game because you have no decisions no you have like there are decisions decisions and they now add it like so if they the bottle games is good at listening to their customers that is something that Portal Games does an amazing job at and they have added now a kind of question part at the end it's still not good but it it's it's better than like the other version which was just like and we checked both of the endings on the first scenario and of course it could have balloon us away playing the rest of it but we don't have time so if somebody want to play this we still have like in a detective expansion that doesn't get played so I would rather play that next up we have an older game this is like 20 2001 I think so it's 22

years old traders of Genoa it's now known just as Genoa this is one of the older uh Elia games number six in the Alia Big Box series we played it now we're gonna do something about it one two three boom we're gonna kill it because this is a fine game that just goes on for too long we play the five player game and I enjoyed the things that we did in the game yes and if the game had been like an hour to 90 minutes it would have been a fun game but it was three hours and not because we were super slow at doing things but just because the game is very long with five players the game is 7 rounds long but if you roll dice at the beginning of the round and you end up in the middle of the board it's going to be one last round but that never happened so what people like decide to do it and that happened at the end the one player says like oh let's stop playing this game and they did that and it was a fine game I it was it was nothing this is a negotiation game like or or training it is kind of an auction but but kind of not and it really isn't a good match with our group we're bad at these things and I think that is a very like individual thing so if you're into negotiation games then drag on for a little too long I think you should check this one out okay next up is on my side I think oh it's it's a very big pile so it's hard to get over it oh and it's a big game as a little time of time of Empires this is one that came out last year and it came out of nowhere

basically it is from Pearl games isn't it and I think that means it's the last game from Pro game which is kind of sad uh because there now they were a part of asthma day and they decided to not do that anymore so uh and they made some great games over the years for example which is the best one and now Empires I basically saw Rado do a video of this and it looked interesting yeah because everything Rado talks about looks amazing that is true but this one would piqued my interest a bit more than other games and uh we bought it or I bought it and we I read the rules yeah I opened up the rule book read all of these to me I thought that's uh oh yes no I slept uh while yes and then it was real time and was it fun we will see on the curl pile okay one two three boom I thought it was fun oh we have our first disagreement which is nice when we have like 60 games oh yes and what did you think I thought it was a lot of fun and it was one of the few games that we played uh this week where I was like okay this is unique enough this is kind of like if pendulum was good oh yeah I get what you mean I I think like the use of the time mechanism in this game was working very nicely you did get to do a lot of things so it felt sometimes very stressful what I didn't like

um wrap my head around was all the movement on the map because you yeah you had short time if you wanted to utilize your your sand timers in a great way but but it was fun yeah a little chaotic I think I want to keep this for now and it is one that I would love to play with more players because there's only two because I think it worked really well with two it's like if you like real-time games and if you like Civilization games and if you have a problem playing Civilization games because you're only two players this worked really well as a two-player civilization game I had a lot of fun and it's a short game you can play it in under an hour like you have three of these timed things that is nine I'm nine minutes like each yeah and so an hour is like a perfect time and I I really enjoyed it and I would like to play it a dance next time next up we have World of Warcraft broth of the Lich King which is a pandemic system game which means it is a co-op game and it's a pandemic Style game which is two things that should make me hate it yeah so this is an instant call from you I presume oh let's do the people I don't think yes one two three boom huh but it's almost the keep it was it was so it was really enjoyable like this for me is thumbs up way better than pandemic oh yeah and if you don't have to care about the warcraft we we have played World of Warcraft for like two days so it's not like something that you

need to know but it is it is like it it takes some of the elements from World of Warcraft and makes them less random and then they add a dice to make like it a bit more random so that you don't like it's not a pretty pretty it's not deterministic but it is one that like if I liked co-op games more than I do yeah this would be one that I would like to play more oh yeah this was a very enjoyable what I liked about it is that you're trying to to go to the game is to complete quests and you do that by going to the quest place and rolling some dice and you can also add like symbols from your hand because you have like the hand of cards that you do in pandemic but what you usually use your cards for are like healing traveling and battling to keep like all the what do you call the ghouls okay so that is instead of curing like the sickness you're using your cards to or and dice to fight off ghoul so so you don't lose so you're trying to just like control the board and focus on the quests so what I really like that is instead of like oh you have a blue card over there I need to collect it the cards felt like they've had another meaning this was just like overall super enjoyable yes yeah it is like almost yes it's the closest to keep that I

majority game a team-based game if you're playing with more than three or four players with the expansion about the American election trying to win the election by being the coolest candidate okay are you ready yes one two three boom I like this one um I didn't get like a hmm um true sense of if I wanted to keep or call it in the future no what uh what I know is that I need to just play it again okay so I want to keep it for now because I really felt I don't know a lot of the about the American like almost nothing but yeah very little but what I know is from what I know this felt very thematic so you're trying to travel around or do other things to get votes in the different states and if the majority of the votes are from my party I get to like all of the the points from that state and I want to have like the most points at the end of the game like them the most delegates I think I don't know yeah but it is possible to play this with teams and that is what we did I think for me this is like if you're playing teams I would think it's nice to have like the same amount of people on yeah yes it's people versions on the teams but I like this one I I thought that like if we go to play it again and we probably are because we're keeping it uh we I would like to play without teams

like playing into it with one for me the problem was it was like it's a huge board and if you don't know geography in the United States of America it's going to be a hassle to play the game because you always have to look where is everything even though there are good plays on the map on the cards that you have you can see where they are but it was very hard for me to get my minerals everything and also then one side of the map one side of your country is all these states and one is like a few States so it's very it's not your fault but it was not very practical in this board game and this is one again one game where the deluxe components makes the game harder to play because the normal game you get small pieces that you put on them and you have voters uh in this one you get this huge wooden pieces and when the the state is this big and you place 60 tiles on it you don't know where they are it just looks like a a like a flush of these tiles everywhere so it's hard to understand where things are which I don't like and then it made it and also it was late when we played it so I will give it another chance we will put it on the key or you decide so but I'm I I agree with you that we can give it another chance is what I was trying to say next up and last for today on this short episode is first draft this is another game actually I played and you didn't play because I bought this in Thailand when I was there in December and I played it once with my mother and father and that was like in 26 degrees or 30 degrees and now we played it in like 14 degrees

these are celsius if you think Fahrenheit it's gonna be way worse so yeah we play this now three players you will like it we will see one two three boom I like this I I think the race feeling is absolutely in and a part of this game but what I really liked about it is trying to place your rats tactically or strategically or like good in this or like in this like one-way Street it is a one-way street so that you can move more rats at once and Trigger more of these um spaces and you want to get Chase you wanted to get like resources to build a rocket because you're going to the chase Moon you're trying to and you're trying also to get like some bonus other things on the way I'm team but I really like this one I was actually surprised about was fun and fast and cute yeah this is a great game this is one game that is super nice because it is a gateway Style game so you can teach it to almost all people but I think most Gamers even like like this is a great light game with nice decisions short playing time plays up to five players and it's just like fun yes it is one that I was hugely Supply priced by the first time I played in and liked it even better the second time I played it so it is a one that we actually recommend a lot if you are looking for games in that category we

are going to do like the best and reverse but if you enjoyed this video where we talked about 20 games and we played this in like almost in in 10 days I think we play these games so yeah I don't know if we can even fit all the games on screen no I don't think so many more games if you enjoy what we are doing then you can help us out in a big Way by giving us a victory point and you might be asking how do we do that Cinema is ready with a tutorial we get victory points when you click the subscribe let's talk about the best game and if you already are a subscriber you can get a coin yes like this is not like video game reference you can help us get a coin so we can buy stuff by go leaving a comment liking the video because that is nice and we like it when people like us so best and worst experience go ahead best was first rats yes I just had so much fun with that I'm gonna choose then time of Empires or something else it's kind of between those two the worst experience I think was actually Solo's Fair because it just like it felt so broken oh mentally yeah where you do nothing but main thing Library it's a boring I'm looking forward to publisher I think that's faster official that is the end of this video we hope

you enjoyed it and we are gonna probably not play this many games on a simple Fame next time but hopefully you enjoy all the videos that are coming and um and you've been watching board gaming ramblings and bye bye

Progress saved