Skip to main content
Loading video...

Top 10 Board Games of 2024 - One Of The Worst?

Transcript 55:19

hi everyone I'm luctor and this is the broken me a show where I devote my time to ranting and raving about board games but usually more the ranting part we'll get on with the show in just a second but first my sponsor would like a quick word as Gamers we find it hard to deal with empty shelves some worse than others you therefore want the supplier that has what you need at affordable prices and delivers on time for me that supplier is Kender they offer a discount on bulk purchases as well as a point scheme for future Acquisitions down the line if there's a hot title you're after chances are Kendra's got it Wings man mine Arc no mine Eclipse actually hate that game it's terrible but you might like it if you use the referral Link in the description below and sign up for a new account you'll get 5% discount on your first order over £60 so let's make gaps in your collection a ft of the past get down to Kender and start saving today thank you for listening and enjoy the rest of the video get on with it so yeah a little bit later than other people I went on a cruise holiday literally on the 7th of December took two weeks off came back went straight home for Christmas and then obviously I've been trying to chill as much as possible until today which is New Year's Day as I record this right before I got go back to work tomorrow Joy am I looking forward to that but hey ho 2024 was not my favorite year ever not just in board gaming but kind of just in life in general I mean apart from a couple of highlights like like my 40th and the cruise holiday uh 2024 was a bit of a let down and most of it was caused by work but you know 2025 I've got some re resolutions in place you know I'm going to take back some control at work I'm going to start a Mediterranean diet to lose a bit of the Christmas fat that I've pulled up on and just generally get

stuff you know back on track so hopefully 2025 will be a much more solid year but in terms of board gaming yes like I said uh maybe a broken record at this point I don't tend to find that recent years have done great with board gaming I think 2023 wasn't too bad I think 2023 overall the more I think about it was on okay there was some decent stuff like on a bread scale that came out but 2024 nah I thought we were lacking this time round I mean putting together a top 10 was pretty difficult I've got some honorable mentions for sure but when I'm trying to think oh yeah these 10 games I am going to absolutely Rave about you know a little bit trickier than most but that being said there is a top 10 list and these are 10 games really do like as well as the honorable mentions but my list is going to differ from a few others out there I can certainly say that much um a few games have been reviewed really highly by others which have not necessarily got quite as high by me and in terms of the games covered well obviously I can't play every single game in 2024 but then neither have you so you know it's just going to be the way it is like for example I've still got to review oh here we go come on little one here you know canopy Evergreen by weird City Games I haven't had a chance to review this one yet I have played it though so you know will it factor in the top 10 we'll have to see but you know this one I haven't had a chance to review yet there's just been a lot of stuff to do but then I've also just recently done a review for andromeda's Edge so that one's finally in the works and you know people have gone mad for

Shackleton Bas but that one's now reviewed so that one's in the bag so I have managed to catch up with a lot of the big releases from 2024 but obviously I can't play 100,000 games or whatever came out it's kind of ridiculous you know maybe I'll go back and look at the 2023 list and do an updated list for that but we'll have to see because obviously soon I want to get on with a you know top 100 or maybe top 50 I might reduce it this year you know stuff like that and of course I've got still more reviews to catch up with from prior to the year so without further Ado as the uh storms outside ravage Portsmouth at the moment I mean yeah even the elements are starting to get a bad idea about this list let's get on with it yes get on with it my number 10's a really unique one and I don't think this publisher gets enough uh credit really you know this publisher has released mainly the same sort of series of games in the past you know they've stuck to this particular IP this particular art style and they've gone with it but they created one of my favorite deck builders of all time and here they've created a really good solid Co-op as well which is snowdown designs peacemakers horrors of War this one is a Co-op that can be played solo just fine and you go through these different scenarios via a flip book and basically you've got two factions going up against each other the deck builder was Dale of merchants where you had all these different animal races that you know gave you really cool abilities and you had to build decks and do little market trading it was really it's a really cool deck builder but those same factions are

basically in this game so you got like the parrots versus the Bears or you've got the uh you know the little frog little stink frogs or whatever versus the you know the Beavers I don't know you got all these different factions going up and each one's got its own little separate card deck and the idea is is that you play effectively these kind of like vagabon individuals these peacemakers as you will who sort of T between the two factions on the map as they're fighting against each other and you're kind of Shoring up defenses for one side maybe boosting the attack of the other healing people getting each other's way maybe helping one faction over another and the idea is is that you're trying to balance things out so that the two sides give up you know if one side dominates the combat then they'll win the ward the other side gets wiped out and it's like ah okay problems and death but you're trying to get it so that two sides basically go I am sick of this fighting this is too much let's just quit now stop this war it's a really nice message I mean for a board game considering most games are like about you know annihilate the other side it's nice that there's actually a game that says no how about we stop War for a change especially when you're talking about cutesy animals there's cards in this game that have you doing things like you know getting tunnel vision and PTSD and stuff when you let other faction characters die it's like wow it does go with dark for what is essentially cutesy animal artwork but it's a cool little system it takes a bit longer than it needs to I do think the length in a lot of players is a bit much but it's cool that you're trying to manipulate these decks and yes the first

time you play it it's going to be different from the subsequent times because you'll get to know what these decks are but even with that knowledge you the the way that you're trying to manipulate the game to and utilize the cards that you have with other players if you play solo you basically just have a pool of cards but if you play with players you got to keep swapping them between each other so there is a logistical exercise to do not a ton for each individual player to do you have you are basically working as a team collectively it's not like one person gets to do a million actions and the other person only gets to do one you're pulling like a couple of actions around together but I find this it just looks gorgeous on the table beautiful artwork very simple rules pretty clean and is a reimplementation of an older version of the game which I never got to play so it's really cool to actually jump into this one now for the first time and it's still on my shelf downstairs and just represents a nice cool little game that can be expanded easily by just giving me another scenario book with a bunch more you know bunch more settings and a bunch more factions that's all you need to do don't need more rules I mean if you want to add more cards for a variety fantastic but you don't need to complicate the game just give me more scenarios and I'm happy how hard can it be he my number nine is probably one of the biggest surprises I have had in the last year now a lot of people sort of like the dice tower particularly they do like their surprises almost a bit like their 20 through 11 that doesn't really work with me you know a surprise could be my number one it could have surprised me so

much and blown my mind and it becomes my number one game this one definitely was a surprise because I think the I think the designers came out of the blue and just asked me if I wanted to review never heard of them I'd never heard of the game I just thought okay fine you know it's another game it looks cool it looks very pretty I think it was on Kickstarter as well so I had some knowledge of it but I didn't really know what was going on with it so I tried it and found this to be one of the nicest coziest most beautiful looking games I have come across in recent years a bit long for what it is yes certainly but honestly this wild Gardens has surprised me enough to be my number nine of the year now you there'll B pictures on the side don't worry but this by Rose Gauntlet I never expected to like this as much as I did you know it's a bit long that is a flaw of the game but it's got a solo mode that goes above and beyond the call of duty by giving you actual sort of semi story scenarios to use but even if you were to say maybe C this at two to three players this is just such a simple game you're foraging for different sort of like vegetables and vegetables well vegetables and fruit and stuff and you know I've got a sort of Premium set here with these really nice you know ingredients oh here we go so all of these lovely wooden pieces nice and beautiful nice and chunky all that lot you know beautiful bags some of the best artwork I've seen and essentially what you're doing is that you're foraging for ingredients and making recipes and you can serve these recipes to guests who give you special abilities or endgame scoring opportunities and with these little mini

packs I've got more of these guests I don't like the idea that some of these mini packs are based on people in real life like I really could not give a crap if you know you I I sort of like look I just want fictional characters I don't want to suddenly draw a card and suddenly it's watch it played it's like what no but you know it's variety at the end of the day and it's a gimmick but the recipe cards in here that you can cook my God I want to eat every single thing on this well maybe not the ones that have fennel in it I hate fenel but

Hy but you some of these recipes are so nice that you just want to like eat them off the card it's such a gorgeous game but it's very simple you know you basically just use action tokens with like movement values on them use one of those move around collect ingredients make the recipes serve the thing serve the guests but you also get to customize your board with skill tokens that mean that when you do a particular action you get to augment what happens with that action so there's an element of customization there's an element of variety and for a game that really does have a very simple premise like a simple rule set and a simple smooth gameplay now it's not the smoothest you know the whole thing with the day cycle can be a little bit on the fiddly side and certainly I says hey I think this game goes on a bit too long especially with four players I mean this is something that probably should only be a 60-minute game that can happen with two players in Solo but with three and four you are going to take longer and I think it should have been capped maybe they can fix that in the future we'll see but honestly this just really surprised me it's cozy and nice you know like you you know you want to stick M from studio gibl and shove it into a board game it's just like that it's got that kind of artwork it's got that kind of style and you're just in it sort of going ah that is nice that is nice that is pretty you don't feel stressed it's one of those style of games but I really enjoy it it's a good fun game and probably the biggest surprise of this year because I went into this with no idea no expectations and I was like wow okay a

like person on Kickstarter i' never heard of has put out a game that was pretty salad especially with the lack of faith I've G in Kickstarter projects these days this one really did surprise me okay let's Venture away from the whole light and cozy fluffy you know stuff like that to oh my God my head is about to explode brainy Euro game yeah this is probably I would say the most complicated Euro on my my list Def One could contend but no I think this one's more complicated certainly more fiddly you know overall with all the mechanics but it is huge in scope it is heavy it is brain burning it looks gorgeous still and it is Fantasia's effectively magnumopus game at this point unconscious mind this one is just it's a big epic scope game you've got a lot on the table treating these different patients with their psychological issues worker placement with the different action spaces of which you can determine how many times you're going to do said action a map with location actions which granted is the weak element of the game but it's still more to consider and not a huge amount of time in the game in terms of number of actions to be able to get everything you want done you've got to be efficient with treating the clients meeting certain endgame scoring conditions or you know boosting your reputation whatever it is you're trying to do in the game but it looks great

with this dual artwork St which I think more games should try where like the real world is done by Vincent D trait and the dream sequence like dream sequence cards all done by Andrew Bosley it's a good contrast of two very different styles and I would like to see this more often in games because I think other genres and settings could really benefit from this you could have something like where like the real world like reality stuff is portrayed by one artist but then you could have the the the the supernatural monsters that you got to fight or the evil stuff is done by another artist and have them combined I mean that would just I think you could create some really good stuff but I digress no he got the upside I got the downside see there's two sides to every schwar this game is great fun to play very long with four I do like to cap it it three um it's got a cool solo mode in it even though there is quite a lot to Pilot but I really enjoyed that brain burning nature of this you know the work of placement with moving your ink pot around your board customizing your board with the notebook tiles in order to create like a little mini engine that you're going for there's a lot of variety and a lot of different ways that you can play your game out now I reviewed the expansions as well and I will stress that honestly you should just stick with the retail copy of the game and not bother with the expansions cuz I think the deluxe copy is not worth the extra money for it as much as I do love those ink pots and you know the Miniatures are a waste of time and all that just stick with the wooden pieces but also don't bother really I think with the nightmares expansion all the other stuff that came in it those little modules cuz yeah there are some Diamonds

in the Rough there but for the most part it's not worth it and it's just too bloated at this point I mean hell the retail game is already quite bloated in terms of how much is in it it doesn't need more stuff added it just simply needed more variety of cards and more Publishers need to realize this you know just because you're going to expand the game does not mean you've got to make it more complicated you can just give us more stuff to see and that would be good enough but it sounds like I'm ragging on it a little bit but I'm not it's it's still a really solid game but it's not going to get any higher in my charts because because of its bloated nature but looks the part really gets the Marine cells going a really cool theme it's abstracted to a point yes but it's still like a very unique setting and something that we've not really seen and you know this has been in development for years by Fantasia games I've even seen it through its development at times by play testing it and some of the fixes that I suggested have been implemented so you know it's less fiddly than it was before believe me but I really do enjoy this one you know how long it's going to stick around we'll have to see I think a lot of it is going to depend on how often I can get it to the table but gets requested at conventions it does get played and you know give it time I'll be able to get more into the solo mode so we shall see but for now it's still my solid eight of the Year unconscious mind my name is Mr Charles you remember me don't you speaking of a weird gribbly Horrors and Nightmare monsters for you to fight we're now going to step away from euros

and go straight into story narrative driven games where this one you could argue this one might be a little bit of a cheat although to be fair we also need to do that slightly ahead of the the list as well I mean this year just wasn't a fantastic one for games what can I say but this one is different enough from his predecessor and I've sort of got to that point where it's like look why am I excluding these really great games on technicalities when I could bring them in and actually talk about them this is the sequel to probably my favorite story driven setting that we have had for any of the games in release that is Tainted Grail Kings of ruin this is the sequel that came out now you might think well hang on it's just tainted Grail yes and no same setting yes but different story lines different you know different scenarios different monsters and all that lot but it is effectively tainted Grail 2.0 and it really is a 2.0 cuz yes there are similarities but they really have tidied up a few of the problems in the original version that made it too great grindy in the second version it is much less grindy I mean occasionally you might have to grind for one or two things but not that often and not to a great extent with the second one you get stuck into the action a bit more it's going to take you a while to get through it it's still a very long campaign but you can also approach it from two very distinct ways because without going into spoilers you basically have you know certain things going on in the world and depending on the order in which you tackle them determines what happen

later on and earlier so you could effectively play this a second time through and get a fundamentally different game just from the main plot Arc let alone any side quests that you might have ended up doing because of your character or choices or your abilities that you have look let me go back in there and face the Peril no it's too perilous I do the night sample as much Peril as I can now we got to find the Holy Grail come on I enjoy this tainted gril Universe I mean this Arian grittiness it's got some of the best artwork I've seen for you know depicting a dark and depressing setting the narrative is so good this is novelization level writing really really good and if you get the app with the voice narratives you know the voice uh narration it's even more immersive it's just a perfect setting for me you know and and awaken Realms have tried stuff with things like ISS Vanguard and other stuff in the past and granted ISS Vanguard I like but I found it too much too long too complicated and the dice mechanic was a bit mhm H for me but the ship that you built in that game the immersion the sound effects the space exploration was absolute Gold Dust you know just a shame it didn't quite measure up to the levels of Tainted Grail but this is what awaken Realms does best they are very good at creating immersive worlds for really cool story driven games and I mean I did the preview for LS of evershade recently I'm looking forward to see how that turns out a kind of pseudo RPG uh game with a new setting and you know check out my video If that one but yeah this one gave

me a lot of enjoyment I played it all the way through to the end to completion and I no longer have any tainted Gr stuff in my collection anymore so Luke why the hell would did you sell it off if you love it that much well I can only store so many games people and you know it's a big campaign game that takes a long time for me to get through I could hang on to it for another year or two and then go back to it and go through the campaign again but I have a lot of games to play I have a life I have things to do I can't always keep campaign game from time to time you know I have played all the tainted Grail content at F and I've enjoyed all the time I've had with it I've now passed it on to somebody else who can basically enjoy it as much as I can it did its job it entertained me and I still love this setting still love this game Kings are ruin don't let me have just a little bit of peril no don't help it bet you're gay no I'm

not my number six is now going to lightweight Euros this is a pretty dry Euro even though it does look cool the IP is completely wasted and for some people they really like it and some people thought it was too boring with this one I find that this is basically a killer for games like Lords of water deep and I don't mean because of its setting in genre I mean because of its lightweight Euro nature like I can teach this to very you know I can teach this to a ton of new Gamers it's very smooth one of the smoothest games I've played recently looks the part on the board and allows for a little bit of variation and customization and this was another surprise for the year called River of gold this one that is just silky smooth silky smooth like the river itself it just you know doesn't get clunky at all doesn't outstay its welcome very simple mechanics you've got a die you roll it the number will dictate what area of the board you're allowed to sort of interact with or how far you can move your ship and you basically move your ship collect stuff uh build on a particular section or deliver to a customer on that particular section there's your free actions you can augment the die value with a little bit of mitigation but other than that the game play just plays very smooth without people aping too much and the idea that you can build different buildings on the river to create these cool sort of combo sections like you know somebody builds a building here I build one here I build one there and suddenly this particular area of the river is like oh if I land there I get loads of stuff but I'm also giving victory points to the opponent do I want

to do that but that's a lot of stuff it's pretty tempting and so you create these cool little scenarios some people have actually compared this to Monopoly what the hell are you talking about but it's like you're not entirely wrong on some of that aspect I mean you don't do any trading per se but you do move across this River and you do land on the spot and you get stuff but also have to you know give stuff to opponents I mean there's an element of it maybe I still think it's a little bit farfetched but you know I can see where people are coming from but this one is still in the collection I don't know where it is at the moment it's certainly somewhere but it's just silky smooth silky smooth and that is something that I think is missing from a lot of Euro games lately if you remember the reviews that I did for you know games like uh you know andromeda's edge and a couple of other like big Euros of this year you know smoothness is something that is lacking from games I mean even unconscious mind you know I love the game but it's not silky smooth in any way shape or form it's nice to be able to just play a game where the rules just flow where it's intuitive and you don't feel like you got to check the rule book every 5 seconds I mean hell i' never have to check the rule book ever again with this game it's simple enough and smooth enough that it manages to do that so why is it kill stuff like Lords of Water Deep Well Lords of Water Deep was typically one of those games that you played as a very simple introductory Euro but it has issues mandatory quests and things like that and the expansion making it a little bit too overwrought this one just keeps it nice and simple nice and smooth and all they got to do is just give us more customer with some

other abilities you could maybe throw in another mechanic in there without making it too complex but yeah I mean this one was another surprise it looked beautiful on table so I had some you know okay I reckon this could be pretty sweet but I wasn't expecting it to be a top 10 wordy game and look at it it's pretty much halfway up there give this one a try River of gold I love

gold my number five is not in my collection because this is kind of that semi cheat that I said before the reason it's not in my collection is because its predecessor is in my collection and that's the one I prefer but I can't dismiss that this game is still a fantastic game to play I do think it was pointless that it got made I do think that it's you know basically just taking the original game and tweaking a couple of things and now we've got a new version but it's the version that people are liking some people are really Lively you know they're preferring it to the original some people don't you know the IP I think draws people in and I said there wasn't a huge amount of games this year that I was raving about I got to gift props where it's due to Lord of the Rings duel for Middle Earth now certainly you know lord of the 7even Wonders duel its predecessor is the one that I would have personally this is like the 10 out of 10 probably my favorite two player only game that exists certainly with Pantheon it's even better but I can't dismiss duel for Middle Earth has been like a terrible release for 2024 because it simply isn't you know the Lord of the Rings version is still a fantastic game I gave it a nine out of 10 I don't agree with its its Inception but when I play the game I still have great fun it's still an excellent game excellent game for two players you know you've got that open drafting system with the cards you've got the automatic Victory conditions which I always like in games the idea

that you can go to points but also try and end it sooner that always seemings to me in games love it love it love it but you know this one is weaker than SE wond door for a couple of reasons you know the track movement with the ring is not really a tug-of warar it's more just a Chase so who get more of them in a specific time the green tokens they're better in this one I would probably say because there is more of a variety of them I quite like that but the the whole area control thing I kind of would have preferred the victory points than the original one because the area control one you can kind of nor up to a point depending on what the opponent's doing and for the most part it tends to end by one of the auto Victory conditions anyway but also you can kind of call who's going to win on the area control bit it's not as much of a surprise as the victory points in the original but I digress you know check out my review for more details as to how I compare the two people are going to argue for you know until the end of time as to whether they prefer the Seven Wonders version or the Lord of the Rings version and I'm not going to get on anybody's case about it because I personally prefer the Seven Wonders one if you personally prefer the Lord of the Rings one but you acknowledge that the original was there and was still fantastic then perfect do that I can't understand how you can like one and hate the other that doesn't make any sense whatsoever and I will certainly dispute that but if you think that both of them are fantastic games and you just have one preference then what the hell at least you're playing one of these games because they are that good stupid Fu h

my number four is a filler yeah a filler what a filler is on my top 10 well yes I did mention it before it's not like a big surprise except this one was a big surprise for me I never expected to like this game as much as I did I mean the name didn't really like sound like anything more than oh yeah there a little gimmick title whatever you know the cover was nice but not the most inspiring one ever but it's like okay I'm hearing good stuff let's play it and see what it does I'm really surprised so much that I think this is my biggest surprise of the Year castle combo really did a number on me I mean this one gets played so often this year as a filler because it's that perfect length of about 30 minutes you know 30 minutes to do nine turns which are not difficult you access two rows of characters you decide whether you want to shift from one row to the next or scrap it with keys but then after that you just choose one of three characters on that row pay the money take the character shove it in your grid of 3x3 nine characters wow the storm's really going out out there and you know you basically just create this little engine of ways to score like with comboing your characters it's called castle combo but each character has an instant ability that keys off based on what the rest of your grid looks like and an endgame scoring condition also based on what the rest of your grid looks like sometimes what opponents have but not often there's not a huge amount of interaction in this game at all but I love the fact that you know this one creates a lot of variety with characters cuz they're all unique and they all want different stuff you know some people want you to save money at the end of the

game some want specific color Shields and the color Shields are distributed unevenly across these different characters some want to be on the left side you agree the right side some want to be next door to certain other characters it's yeah does really cool stuff with like this game but it's got just enough depth to make you think about the characters you want and which ones are good and you're got to make some sacrifices you got to be think I really would like that character there but if I do that that means I'm going to not much money for the next round am I going to have to take a face down card just to get money I'd rather not it doesn't score any points but that character is pretty good it gives you enough little turn anxy decisions like that to you know to elevate this above most fillers and a lot of fillers either don't keep to the time length or don't give you enough you know enjoyment factor for it but nobody has played this game and gone oh this was rubbish I mean I have back I probably should get royalties for this game because I swear I've sold copies of this game to people where you know I've played it and I've shown them it and they're like oh sweet where can I get a copy of this and it's not always the easiest to get a copy of I'm not even sure if the UK has any stock of it at the moment but you know certainly if you can grab a copy of castle combo and you want a cheap portable filler that's like easy to teach to anybody but the most brand new of Gamers this is definitely one to check out surely you can't be serious I am serious and don't call me

surely okay the top three of the year the top three and this one is well A continuing trend for this publisher and this group of designers yes they keep putting out games that I really really like and even though they tend to put out free games at a time and there tends to be a little bit of a black sheep in each of those trilogies yeah I think you've kind of guessed which one this is now this Trilogy though has been solid all the way through and it culminates with a very thinky very complex probably borderline to complex for you know what their game should be but still a fantastic ending to a Trilogy that has put out three solid games we had wayf farers which I loved a bit we had Scholars which is probably the weakest of the free but still really really good and now inventors of the South Tigers my third best of this year I don't want the games to get more complex than this one though this one was like wh it's borderline there's a lot of stuff in here borderline 2 complex for some I think you maybe need to dial it back a little bit for the fourth Trilogy you do but you know for this one really really enjoy it the the variety in this particular game is off the chain I love the cool combos you can pull off with your little workshop engine building your dice manipulation your dice leveling but also the inventions that are effectively a group managed system I really like Euros where you have something in the book in the game that

is kind of maintained by the group and what the group does will affect your decisions you know you've got the different invention tiles and they will get invented they will get built they will get tested and then they'll get published I designed and tested them myself they smell like burning Reese's monkey really I guess when you're around it all day you stop noticing but depending on who does what will influence opportunities that you might not have seen before it's like oh somebody's built this particular invention it's like well hm invention's got a pretty good uh endgame condition I could benefit off that but that means I need to hurry up and publish it how do I do that then and it's jumping on those like little opportunities but there's limited scope for everybody to do it so you need to be quick about it and make sure other people don't beat you to it you've got worker spaces you've got the tent actions you've got the ship actions you've got all sorts of things that you can do in this like I said it borderline may be a little bit too complicated for many but you know it's got a pretty good solo mode I really like the solo mode in this I thought it did a decent job of simulating a multiplayer experience not fully there is some Cheatin that it does but I thought overall still pretty decent especially compared to the two that came before it but even playing as multiplayer for a player it's going to take you an eternity yeah maybe you be a little bit worry about four players but two or three this thing is great fun to play it's just such a Comber rific if that's a word I'm ever going to I'm going to keep using now you know Comber rific experience where you have lots of

different ways to approach it I have done games where my workshop has been practically full I've done games where I barely built a tile I've done games where I focused on one particular color of dice all free dice I've had games where I've done nothing but invent you know just invent stuff maybe the occasional building but you know not published a single thing you know it's there's a lot of different ways to play it and score points and that always works for me in these games but you know it's not my favorite of the Tigers Trilogy I think that still goes to way way farers way Faris just did exactly what I wanted it to do for me but inventors is easily my second favorite of this Trilogy and the fact that this Trilogy for Tigress has not put out a single bad game you know I mean maybe bad's the wrong word I mean to be fair the North Sea explorers any original ship rights no you know but the updated ship rights is pretty good honorable mention uh the the was it the West Kingdom Trilogy love Architects love Vic counts paladins not so much but not bad game per se this one though just a solid hit of three games and you know I I know they're going to put out expansions for these and I'm a little bit worried about that cuz these games are already pretty complex I don't think they need more mechanics thrown in and let's face it Garfield games if we're been perfectly honest with you lot you haven't had the best track record for expansions in your games have you okay a simple wrong would have done just fine but you I'm going to wait these Tig expansions with baited

breath but we'll see how they go but even if I ignore the expansions in the future and just concentrate on the base games these are still fantastic and inventors no exception it's their most complex it's their most brain burning one do not approach this if you are not used to heavy games or used to Garfield games I am warning you now but check out my review for more details this is still a great game good news

everyone my number two well we're getting on to games that have earned 10 out of 10 ratings for me this year yeah only a couple of games have but you know it's good that at least something did this year but this one is kind of like just starting a trend for this particular publisher who tend to take their time with games and I like the fact that they do this some Publishers like to churn out game after game after game after game and you know they just get lost in the mix and I don't feel that they spend enough time developing certain games you know there is that problem you have I mean with movie directors and stuff like that but or even video game Publishers have this problem you know turning out a game every year but this one turns out usually one game a year maybe two but very different games they focus on one particular big game and say this is our game for this year and for this year check game editions oh yeah you made it you gave me what I wanted in this one for sure oh come on squeeze out there setti seti really ticked with me and I know hasn't ticked for everybody and I can see why it wouldn't but this one worked for me I played a demo at the games Expo with I forget the guy's name but he was new to demoing and he did such a good job with it I know some people got a bit unlucky with some demo there it is hit and miss who you get that is the nature of demoing but you know this one like appeal to me from the get-go okay I've got multi-use cards love that opportunistic tactical moves that you can pull for points and that great love this space theme isn't about

you know flying around in you know massive space cruisers and shooting down enemy foes or something actually exploring space from you know a NASA sort of point of view it's like that's pretty cool but it's got a lot of other stuff besides and yet despite this as much as I will agree it's probably a round too long I think for a five round game there should only be a four round game and certainly with four players this can go on a bit long but it's got a very decent solo mode it's got very easy rules I mean this rule book may look large but most of it is large text and pictorial examples it really doesn't take long to learn this game it's got a very good reference a to make it that little bit easier but I love how this creates like a good little bit of variety with the different aliens that can pop up you've got five aliens you pick two of them and depending which ones turn up influence the game in a small way kind of comparable to something like Shackled and Basse where it doesn't fundamentally change the game but it certainly does throw a little bit of the new mix and it means that this game is right for expansions because all you need to do is just give me more cards to pan that deck out and more alen factions I am T doll an ambassador of the greatan Empire that's all you need to do more adens that's it don't give me more mechanics don't over complicate this game just find a way to trim a round out of the game that would be great find a way to trim this to four rounds that would be appreciated and give me more alien races if you can do that you have an expansion that I will buy and sign prises off everybody got

that it works for me it like ticks the boxes on some of my favorite mechanics that I enjoy with a great theme good gorgeous look I love this cover in particular this all bright blue background but yeah unique multi-use cards you know the the the setting you know the the Simplicity of the actions that you're doing technologies that you can upgrade I love this game this one is like you know such a solid one is it as good as LS of AR hard to say I think I came up with a decision in the actual review where I think I would say arnac is the better game and I think to I think I still probably stand that lost ruins of arac is slightly better but we're talking 10 out of 10 Benchmark games here I mean they you know they took the time to bring me L ruins of arnak a 10 out of 10 game they took the time to bring me setti another 10 out of 10 game you know and I even reviewed the other two games by this designer Tomas hak and tarden above average at best and the other one Galileo or whatever it was you know barely average you know I mean that those two did not sing for me as much as this one did you know and to do three games at s and was already pretty impressive so love this one I'm hoping this is going to stick around for a long time I want to see what further agan factions they put in it but failing that whether it's Solo or preferably up to three players I just enjoy playing this and I know friends of mine enjoy it as well so it's going to hit the table more often than not so yeah love it well done cge you done it again well that went

okay but that can be only one and yes this one was a bit of a tussle between this one and seti actually because I was really debating which one I liked more but this one has an advantage over setti seti is still quite a long game there's still a decent amount of mechanics in it and you know it's smoothish but it does have one or two clunky little bits in it this one though is Silky Smooth yet it's still very thinky doesn't have a lot of rules to teach but will get the brain cells turning it has one of the best resource management systems I have seen in any game period I love this resource management system and it's an evolution of a previous title which I didn't like as much at first but then grew to like it more but still would desperately say that they're different enough but this one kind of kills the original for a lot of people and even for me I'm still debating as to whether I hang on to the original or not but black forest Boni Rosenberg and you know as a tto maren's um forget the name sorry I'll put it up on the screen but you know this game is brilliant this is kind of like the ultimate balance like you need a balance of you know complexity versus depth versus you know like you know setup time and all that lot and a lot of people get it wrong they make it too complex or like remember my andromeda's Edge review when I said look you've got a decent amount of stuff going on here and things and you know stuff to do but man the setup is a chore and all this other

stuff that just makes it a bit too much this one is perfect balance Perfect Balance level of thinkness depth but with rules and setup doesn't take a long time to set up this game it really doesn't you know most of it is just tiles and it retains the same cool mechanics from glass Road it Tes out takes out the cards which for a lot of people was the weak link of glass road but it retains those two dials I love these resource dials they're easy to track resources but they keep giving you that fun little turn Ang stuff well I could get sand but if I do that I'm now going to create glass which means I got less wood but I need the wood for this and it's like ah and the amount of people who trip up thinking that oh yes I've done this and this and this ah but I've lost my wood no you know it always happens every game somebody gets caught out by it and it just shows the amount of like planning and thinkness that you got to do but the rules dead simple I mean you basically just move your guy around a map pay the provisions as needed or resources to other players so there is a little bit of interaction there and then you resolve the abilities of two trades people next door to you there you are that's your turn nice and simple and the the actions are not complicated I mean I have to explain two actions on those tiles how to build and what leveling up your little like glass blo housing or whatever it is the workshop does those are the two things I need to explain everything else on the trades people is basically self- inuitive oh gain this gain this oh based on how many lakes I have I gain this or something you barely have to explain them oh yeah and a traveling Merchant yeah so free three little things I got

to explain on all those tiles and the rest of them people can figure out for themselves it's just nice smooth yet still really quite thinky and in depth I mean this is I'd say it's a midweight game but it's on the upper level of midweight in terms of how much you got to think about but in terms of rule set it is just a midweight game it doesn't take long long to set up and teach not even that long to play I mean it does have the one floor the one floor I can mention about this game which is the fact that the AP generation the analysis paralysis generation here is kind of off the scale at times I mean if you play this with slow people you are going to be in a case of H yeah that's good yeah yeah yeah you know you are going to S of end it at that point you're those ones there the ones next to you now make you move all right all right don't hustle me bear that in mind but you get the right group of people you get fast players or even just cap it at three players you know you don't desperately need four I think three is a good sweet spot but for is still pretty good um even playing it solo just having the the one little AI thing run around and get in your way but you've got lots of different ways that you can play the game heavy on animals heavy on grains heavy on Lakes Heavy on buildings heavy on you know what type of building I mean it's like conver you get so many buildings out all with A and B size is like what like 36 buildings builds in the game with a bside as well so you can have 72 building choices here it's insane on top of the different trades people that are going to be in different locations at different times

oh such a good system I love the resource management I love building my own little map and expanding it and putting stuff in I mean maybe I wish there was a little bit more necessity for spatial awareness but there is still a condense of space and only so much you can do so there is that aspect but you know other than minor blemishes like that this one just works people get into this one they enjoy it they want to play it again I have played this twice in a row at times you know it's quick enough to do that all you got to do is just scrape the tiles off the board flip a few of the other buildings over and there you go you can go again for game two and I've done that at conventions and outside of conventions it's good enough and smooth enough and quick enough to do that and that's why it tops seti for me as much as seti might mechanically have one or two things that I kind of prefer in it I mean I do love multiuse cards but then I do love Resource Management as well particularly with these two wheels they are fantastic but as much as maybe that has some elevation over black forest the fact that this one has all those other tick marks for smoothness and depth versus complexity it's it's got to be my number one of the Year this one surprised me as well I wasn't expecting it to improve on the original formula that much it came out of nowhere I didn't know there was going to be like a remake of you know the glass Road system but it came I got a demo of it at the games Expo where you know somebody from furland Spiel came down and showed you

know me and a few other people this was not a public demo this was like a private little thing but I loved it at that point I couldn't wait to get it an Essen I grabbed it unboxed it took a while there's a lot of tiles played it and loved it this one is on the shelf and much like a few m Rosenberg titles it ain't going anywhere anytime soon people will still Lord about stuff like Feast of Odin which I'm still yet to have played in ages I must admit but field ofal still sits there kerer still sits there I mean when urri Rosenberg does it right he does it right and whichever is your favorite from this guy I mean this is definitely going to be one of my favorites from him I mean I don't think it's going to top something like fields ofal for me Fields ofal is just like the ultimate sandbox for me but I could say I prefer this to cerer because there's some elements of converter that are done here and yet this one is smoother so this could Eclipse it but for this year 2024 yeah it's got to be my number one black forest you're not sleeping with it are you

right and there you go that is my top 10 of the year I suspect this list is going to be very different to a few of yours so let's explain why it doesn't why it has differed firstly a few Honorable Men that didn't quite make the list windmill Valley from bord and dice you know I wasn't the biggest fan of Minos I think Minos was way too long way too drawn out way too fiddly to Merit the rest of the good stuff it had windol valley though another silky smooth game and that's the thing I like games to be heavy yes I do like heavy games people but the smoother the game is the less clunky it is the better I mean something like gallerist and kban you'd be surprised how smooth those games Flow despite the heavy mechanics in them compared to something like inventions or weather machine particularly from the same designer but windmill Valley again very smooth looks beautiful looks like very colorful maybe a little garish but still very colorful simple rules yet enough depth to get what you want done in a 90minut time frame and with a decent solo mode as well this one was a surprise for me to be as good as it was this would probably be something like my 11 or 12 it was that close uh the ship rights and Nai Redux it was a little I mean this one is different enough than original that you have to treat it as its own game the problem this one has is that it doesn't really cater for multiplayer there's pretty much no reason to play this multiplayer but when played solo this Redux is a pretty solid game which is why I'm still hanging on to it but not quite top 10 material uh Arctic this

little filler here now some people didn't like it as much as I did which is fair enough no chairman of the board really didn't like it but you know this one I like its quirkiness it's got a unique little card play system to it and I like quirky little card games could some of the player Powers be a little bit more balanced yeah for sure but it's nice and quick doesn't take very long and was again another surprise filler that I didn't think would W me as much as it did not top 10 material but still really enjoyable and I would say that castle combo is still better and then finally also harmonies harmonies yes people are going to wonder why is this not in my top 10 I played it a few times I haven't actually had the game in my possession I've had to play somebody else's copy for it but Harmony just still really good game I don't think it's quite like 119 on Board Game Geek levels as it seems to be at the moment this is the highest ranked Game of the Year in terms of BGG rankings as if we care about those but the as much as I talk about them but the you know this game is still pretty solid it looks cool nice and simple I think my slight beef with this is that I find that the cards sort of vary in terms of how lucrative they are and whether they're worth going for I seem to find that when I play Harmony k ing more to the positioning and the standard scoring mechanics in it seem to Warrant better for me than trying to level up all those cards which are quite tricky to do but it looks cool it's a nice premise very simple very quick and you know a solid game it would definitely probably be a top 15 game but just that top 10 material you know I do

really like it though it is pretty good and I think that's kind of it from an honorable mention side I mean there are other games I have liked this year we have you know the explorers and the Bor was a solid game game you know canopy Evergreen has been pretty solid you know there's other you know other titles that I've reviewed with sevens you know maybe eight out of 10 have been decent but there was also quite a few sixes fives a three remember Asian tigers who yeah no but you know there were some games that have done pretty well and you're probably thinking well where's cvoluion well Civ olution I couldn't really say on that one I haven't played it enough times but it's got sandbox feel which I do like for a fail the fact that I even like elements of it is pretty surprising anyway but I'm sorry this game has like an hour teaching time it has like a 3 to four hour Play Time particularly with multiplayer even playing it solo is going to take you a good couple of hours or something and maybe it's a game I need to play more solo like if I could if I could get a copy of this game and play it solo and maybe treat it entirely as a solo game I could see it being one that I enjoy but multi player it's too much too much I mean we played a demo of it at Essen and the demo was 2 hours and the teach took more than half of that demo it's ridiculous there's just maybe a point where there's too much in a game and I think civui has that problem especially when you consider that for a game that can take 4 hours to play your

actions are dictated by a random dice mechanic you know yes there's mitigation but if I have to the same thing I say about all these games where people use mitigation as the Ultimate Defense get out of jail free card if I have to spend time in an action limited game to mitigate the luck and you don't you are inherently doing better than me by default this is something that I would have accepted If evolution was a 60 to 2our minute game 2our minute 60 Minute to 120 minute game tops 3 to 4 hours though no that doesn't work for me you know I would happily like to try this more but I haven't had my own copy the copies at Essen had massive issues with production quality and missing parts and stuff you know so there were issues here but I would like to give this one more chances as a solo player but I can't see myself liking Civ civil as multiplayer I just think no too much uh Shackleton base you know gave it a six out of 10 it's fine I like it I will play it but it's not one that I got a huge amount of enjoyment for you know Game of the Year material no no I mean it's nothing particularly new in it it's just the fact you've got these little Corps That Vary the game of which is cool but they don't change the game that dramatically I mean for crying out loud all right I'll use this C what do you do uh you spend these little tokens and take these tiles and to get your points okay cool what do I do with this one oh you get this token and you put it on this board and it getes you a little bonus I mean that's not exactly that drastically different people okay but

the game is fine andromeda's Edge a good game that I would like to play but never own it's too much the setup is an absolute chore it's an expensive game particularly if you're forced to pay extra just to play it solo which is probably one of the better ways to play the game but I've got to pay another 25 pound on top of 60 quid to play it solo which I'm not a fan of and low behold if you want to spend £80 on the completely unnecessary and even somewhat bad elements of the deluxe expansion no but it's still a decent game I gave it a seven it's still good but I want to play it when people put it on the table and know what they're doing I don't want to teach it I don't want to like set it up ever you know it's a little bit too epic and scope but not quite as epic in feel as I would like and despite some people I know like um you know Mark from Ninja GE games thinks this is number one game of all time that's a bit of a stretch but still you know some people love it to bits I just didn't love it as much as others uh anything else I can think of um I mentioned Galileo that was you know not particularly good one not not at all uh any other ones I can think of uh not off the top of my head I say there's been some decent games this year there's also been some pretty bad ones but by all means let me know in the comments what you think of these games do you love them do you hate them what games did I not mention that would be on your top 10 say why by all means we can talk civilly about this things everybody's going to have a different top 10 for this year and so I'd be interested to

hear your thoughts on that front so that's it for me on this episode of the broken me we're in to 2025 now we got the top 5050 top 100 whatever I decide to do with it to do as well I'll probably do a top 10 list looking back at the 2023 list and redoing that because those ones are quite popular so I'll try and fit that one in at some point and of course I've got more reviews to do I shouldn't have any more Big Box reviews to do anytime soon I've already done that with andromeda's Edge and Shackleton bass but I've still got some speed reviews to do like the you know game of tarot from yellow got the canopy ever green I've got you know I forget is it kimoto memories or something like that for M S4 there's games like um the expansion to ancient knowledge there's Station to Station from alycat games Reef project from Bor and dice I wanted to take a look at so there's a few stuff on the horizon but mostly in the terms of speed reviews you know but uh you know with future top 10s and you know top 100s in play there's going to be more big content for you as well so without further Ado let's get on with 2025 and hope that it's a bit year for gaming than 2024 was so until next time regardless of whether you thought the games of 2024 were the best thing ever they're still only games so let's see whether the 2025 can still improve on greatness take care and bye for now

Progress saved