/pic3894197.jpg)
High Society Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About High Society
Across the channels that cover it, High Society lands as a tight, tense auction filler that wrings a surprising amount of drama out of a small deck of cards. BoardGameCo, The Dice Tower, No Pun Included, 3 Minute Board Games, Banter and Boards, Board Stupid, and Adam in Wales all treat it as a design that has held up since 1995, with more than one channel ranking it among the best pure auction games available. BoardGameCo's review covers the newest AllPlay edition of the game, and the video discloses upfront that it is sponsored by AllPlay, the publisher of that edition.
Where the channels split is on how much they enjoy the design's sharper edges. BoardGameCo names an unintentional kingmaking problem as the one real flaw holding the game back, describing games where a losing player's overbidding ends up deciding who wins instead of the player who actually played best. The Dice Tower treats the same swinginess as part of the charm and still scores the game highly, though they flag that it can end abruptly and confusingly if the fourth purple card appears too early in the deck. 3 Minute Board Games goes furthest in acknowledging the game's bite, warning that the tension can feel unnerving and frustrating even while calling the design a favorite, and No Pun Included frames the entire experience as merciless toward anyone who misjudges their budget.
Core Mechanics That Define High Society
The Fixed-Denomination Auction
Each player takes a matching deck of money cards in fixed denominations. The Dice Tower lists the values as running from 1 up through 25, and 3 Minute Board Games points out that these cards must be spent in their entirety since the game never gives change back. On a turn, players bid by laying money cards face up in front of themselves, and each new bid has to beat the last one on the table. Cards already committed to a bid cannot be reclaimed unless a player drops out of that auction entirely, at which point the whole stack returns to their hand. Once every other player has passed, the remaining bidder discards the money they bid and claims the card. Layered on top of that simple structure is the game's signature twist, repeated across nearly every channel that covers it: whoever holds the least money once the game ends is disqualified from winning no matter how many points they have collected.
Bidding to Avoid: Scandals and Reverse Auctions
Not every card up for auction is something players want. Scandal cards, the negative-point cards, and the card that forces a discard all flip the normal auction on its head, according to BoardGameCo, The Dice Tower, 3 Minute Board Games, and Board Stupid. Instead of bidding to win the card, players bid money to avoid taking it, and whoever passes first is the one who ends up with the unwanted card, keeping their bid money while everyone else who bid loses theirs. Alongside those negative cards sit a trio of doubler cards that double a player's final score, a halving card, and a card that makes a player discard a point card they already earned or will earn. BoardGameCo notes that combining an eight-point card with a doubler can be enough to win the game outright, which is part of what keeps players weighing every bid against the cards still left in the deck.
The High Society Experience
Reading the Room, Not Just the Cards
Banter and Boards places High Society at the top of a list specifically because it plays the players as much as it plays the cards, describing it as a social push your luck game built around reading the room and figuring out what an opponent is willing to spend. Board Stupid backs that up from the mechanical side, pointing out that because money cards are fixed values that get spent all at once, a sharp player can track which high-value cards an opponent has already used and push them into an auction they can no longer afford to win.
Racing an Unknown Clock
Four purple or teal cards sit shuffled into the deck, and the instant the fourth one is revealed the game stops immediately, with no chance to resolve whatever auction was in progress. BoardGameCo describes the resulting tension as coming from two directions at once: not knowing when the game will end, and not knowing how much money opponents still have in hand. 3 Minute Board Games and The Dice Tower both describe the pacing that results as one of the game's strongest features, though The Dice Tower adds that the fourth card occasionally shows up early enough to end a game that had barely started, which they count as the design's one real weak spot.
What Makes High Society Stand Out
A Pure, Undiluted Auction
No Pun Included singles out how little the game asks of players beyond the auction itself, noting that unlike other Reiner Knizia auction games such as Raw and Modern Art, there is nothing in High Society that isn't an auction, with no other mechanism stringing the experience together. They call it the lightest game the channel has ever covered and praise how a design from 1995 still captures the psychology of overspending more accurately than many modern games, framing every purchase as a decision that blows the budget before the satisfaction of owning something ever arrives.
New Cards That Refresh a Classic
The AllPlay edition reviewed by BoardGameCo and The Dice Tower adds three new cards to the original deck: a twelve-point card that forces every other player to take back one of their spent money cards, a blind-bid card where everyone bids a single hidden card at once, and a card that doubles a player's remaining money at the end of the game. Both channels single out the twelve-point card as a favorite for how it reshapes decisions earlier in the game, since players start holding back their highest bills in case that card appears. The Dice Tower also praises the production itself, calling the card art fantastic and the art style vibrant, and Adam in Wales separately highlights the most recent Osprey Games edition as gorgeous production for a surprisingly affordable price.
Potential Drawbacks
Unintentional Kingmaking
BoardGameCo is the most direct about this flaw, estimating that roughly a third of their games of High Society produce a moment where a player who was already losing overbids in a way that decides the winner rather than winning themselves. In their account, a player who is clearly primed to lose can end up spending down to almost nothing purely to deny another player a card, which then hands the win to a third player who had been positioned to lose. They call it the one thing that consistently holds an otherwise excellent bidding game back.
A Merciless, Confusing Edge
No Pun Included describes the game's balance of greed and caution as merciless, since overspending on one auction can wipe out half a hand of cards in a single decision with no way to recover it. The Dice Tower adds that the rules around switching money cards during a bid can be a little confusing for new players, and separately flags the foil-heavy packaging of the AllPlay box as a shelf-presence problem, joking that the title nearly disappears against the cover art. 3 Minute Board Games rounds out the criticism by noting there is no solo mode and that the tension many players enjoy can just as easily come across as unnerving or frustrating to others at the table.
If You Enjoy High Society
Reviewers who like High Society point toward a short list of other games built around the same kind of money-driven tension. BoardGameCo and No Pun Included both recommend Raw as one of the best pure auction games available, and BoardGameCo separately suggests QE for players who want a chaotic bidding game with a similar rule about not spending the most money. BoardGameCo, No Pun Included, and 3 Minute Board Games all point toward Modern Art, another Reiner Knizia auction design, for players who want to stay in similar territory. Adam in Wales pairs High Society closely with For Sale, describing the two as sitting right next to each other near the top of their favorite games list despite coming from different designers.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"This uncertainty of when the game ends adds tension. The uncertainty of how much money players have left in their hands adds tension."
— BoardGameCo
"It's about finding a balance between greed and impulse control. It's about riding that razor blade edge of frivolity. It's about looking your opponents in the eyes and asking them if they press the self-destruct button, will you press an even bigger one."
— No Pun Included
"This game is not playing the game, but rather playing the player. Someone said at best when they said, High Society is a social push your luck game. It's about reading the room and who you're playing against."
— Banter and Boards