Skip to main content
Loading video...

Going Analog Podcast 05: Scary games, games we hate but everyone loves (special guest Jon Gilmour)

Transcript 57:17

hello everybody welcome to the going analog podcast where forbore gamers come together each with his or her own topic for the group to discuss we have new topics every two weeks and this week we actually have a special guest so rest in peace Nick sutnar he's not with us this week but he stepped aside momentarily so we could have a special guest on a famous game designer I'm not gonna get your head blown up too big there but we have a famous game designer on board this week so my name is shoe I am your host and this week's topic for me I want to talk about games that everyone seems to love but you write like what are the games that all of your friends seem to love but you don't like quite like them yourself so that's my topic that I'm gonna bring to the table but I want to introduce first before we get to our regular guys here our special guest this week is Jonathan Gilmour Jon say hi hello so we have become friends we actually I first got to know you John because I backed dinosaur island which is one of your more recent hits and I backed on a Kickstarter and I just put it out on Facebook and I said I'm a backer of dinosaur island and then you said thank you for backing my game and I'm like wait a minute and it's like I had it like took me a second to process this I'm like wait on Facebook friends with the sky who's also designed like I think you're probably your most famous game is dead of winter which is a popular zombie game and so I

was like oh holy crap I didn't realize we're even Facebook friends and then you notice that posted and we just got to start talking and now we've seen each other at a couple of conventions and we play games together in we're friends now yeah yeah it's been great yeah so and then we recently on a recent episode of going out analogs podcast we talked about kids on bikes which is RPG released by renegade game studios that you designed and then so you ran us through one of those sessions a session of kids on bikes at Gen Con which is a big game convention a couple of months ago and we talked about that so we won't get into too much of that now but that game just came out recently so look for that if you're interested in the kind of stranger things Unni ask role-playing game really interesting take on the genre so you're the designer that too and I also mentioned it a winter which I think we're gonna talk about in this show a little bit later so we won't talk too much about that John so why don't you tell us a little bit more about yourself some of the other games you've designed and then tell us what your topic is so I've been a board game designer for probably about eight years now and I've been doing it full-time maybe the last three years I think is when I went full-time I got I think twelve releases on now so a couple of the other things I have our path of light and shadow and wasteland its press delivery service and my topic this week is going to be about how board games can evoke experiences because I think that's one of the really exciting things about

board games cool so alright thanks for coming on I know it's a past midnight for you right now so we appreciate you staying up late for us Kristina say hello and reduce yourself in and tell us what your topic is hi I'm Kristina so this week I wanted to talk about mainly since we we used to host a lot of board game nights and try to introduce board games to friends or just have you know already hardcore board game friends come over and play games just want to talk about how we as pretty experienced board game hosts sort of curate that experience I met a new friend it was a weird sort of friend blind date once and I was trying to explain sort of how I see my role as a board game person and I said like especially for new players but also for like friends who do like games I sort of explain what I'm like a board game sommelier right so like I'm gonna think about what what tastes you like types of interesting things you do and how I might pick board games that would appeal to your tastes so I wanted to pick everybody's brains and talk about that oh thanks and then Mike introduce yourself and tell us about your topic sure hey guys this is my exhibtion and so this week I wanted to bring up the topic of favorite games that I like to bring out during Halloween because I feel like there's so many great horror themed board games and Halloween is like a great time that I love to get everybody together because we're all as we all get older out of my friends and I we don't have time to go

out dancing and partying anymore and my idea of a good time is kind of just staying home and having a few drinks and playing a scary game and I sin spending time with friends alright Mike that sounds awesome that's actually I think our preferred social life too is not going out dancing and staying home and playing board games as well so why don't you start us off get into your topic in and let's discuss your scary games there's a lot there's so many scary board games out there to choose from and I really want to like hear your guys's thoughts as well as we get into this and I know John has a lot of interesting things to talk about it during his topic that's kind of tangentially related to what makes a good scary board game scary and you know how you actually invoke horror in a game and make it feel like the matically you know powerful so but yeah so like III do I do tend to like to try to get people together to play these scary games and I even had like a shelf dedicated to horror games and so yeah so one of the first games that I definitely thought of when I was researching this topic and that I always like to play every Halloween is a fury of Dracula which I know that shoe you have a copy of and we've played it at your house once yeah that's a that's a good interesting choice I didn't think about that one but that's a pretty good one yeah I mean fear of Dracula is perfect because I as far as this is more of like a gamer II game so you're definitely gonna be committing to a bit of an evening to one game you might be able to like start something maybe start the night off with something shorter or the end the night you know with something lighter but this is definitely a meteor

game for for gamer gamers and so this is one where one player is playing as Dracula and the other players are playing as you know van Helsing and a few other sort of Transylvania he's only one I could remember too he's the only one I can think and he'll Sanders and Van Helsing Enco and so you're also the three or four humans it's a two to five player game so you have one player is playing Dracula and that person is they're their characters not on the board until they're found it's a it's what's called a hidden movement game and so Dracula is trying to hide and trying to basically you know I know what would you say the goal of the camera the exact goal of the game is just to kill the other players yeah the Hunter has sus or the vampire has survived but the hunters have to hunt track and hunt down and kill Dracula which actually makes for me it's actually like that's a good choice and then I thought about him like well it's actually not that scary I think it's actually scarier for the Dracula player than the other players even though Dracula has like other vampires and and minions that is beck-and-call he could turn into like a Wolfman and and prowl and stuff like that but he's the one getting hunted I think he's the one that should be scared because it's like all these people like slowly like across them absolutely kind of cornering him in and getting into a corner and then they beat up on him like every game I play to that Dracula has lost badly well I think

you might be playing it wrong then or you just aren't the one that should be playing as Dracula because I think Dracula can be Dracula should be you know is a very powerful character and as the game progresses he just gets even more and more powerful and so it's all about the day-night phase and so there's like certain actions players can take during the day and they can move during the day but they can't move at night and Dracula gets more and more powerful so I find that one is a great one because it just kind of builds the tension builds and coalesces as the game progresses and it's just creates a really cool like partnerships between the carrot between the players who are human and then you know everybody and Dracula can sort of listen in on everybody and depending on the cards you know it can really be a force to be reckoned with John have you played a theory of Dracula or in do you what would be your scary game of choice um yeah I play for you to direct it I love it and I I agree that it can feel tense as Dracula as well so there's another game not to go off on a tangent but called nuns on the run where all the players are hidden except for one and it kind of flips though if you're a director on the head and that kind of gets that same feeling but as far as another stereo game my choice to talk about would be mansions a madness second edition hmm that's a good choice two very atmospheric very moody well you tell us a little bit about it yeah so mansions madness second edition is a cooperative game where you play investigators and you choose a mystery

and you're trying to solve it it's heavily app driven so there's a app that runs I'm on a tablet or a phone that basically directs the game it takes the role of like the dungeon master in that sort of game and tells you when things happen and when tiles come out and describes everything but it's really well integrated in that it doesn't take over the tabletop experience you don't feel like you're playing a video game there's enough things happening on the table in mansions of men is we actually covered on one of the last video series when we used to do video show so all the reviewers loved that game very good choice there how about you Christina do you have a scary game sort of a long low say mains like I I really you know that whole Lovecraft area you know you've got Arkham Horror eldritch horror mansions of madness I think my personal favorite at this point is Eldridge horror just sort of like on a bigger scale than mansions of madness and without a fancy app of course but we used to have like sort of really long epic place of Arkham in which you also play investigators running around Arkham trying to figure out what's causing these nefarious things happening and cultists sprouting up and old ones trying to rise and things like that but once eldritch horror came out I think it sort of you know for me just totally

took over where Arkham Horror used to used to live in my heart unfortunately um Elle Decor I felt was a lot smoother it's no longer just in Arkham anymore it's actually we could travel along a much bigger map but you sort of hit the same feelings of exploring these weird nefarious happenings with this horrible mythos deck and you draw these mythos deck events and bad things are constantly happening but you're working cooperatively with your other investigators to figure out you know how can we you know manage some of these monsters so they don't make us lose how do we prevent this old one from rising and you know can we actually win so it's a difficult game but a lot smoother than Arkham Horror although there is a new edition of Arkham Park coming out which we found out about it gen con' - so I'm excited for that tentatively but I still think eldritch horrors is sort of my favorite Lovecraft themed game lots of weird freaky things happening in it yeah all three of those games you just mentioned so Arkham Horror eldritch horror and pages of madness are all done by a company called Fantasy Flight Games and I actually had Arkham Horror on my list as well - as my scary game because they I think they do a good job with the art and the atmosphere around all the graphics in the game from the box to the board and to the character sheets and also they have a flavor text for everything and normally I'm not a flavor text kind of guy but they integrated

into the thing where you have to read to somebody that cares what's happening here's what you're encountering so I did I think they do a good job of drawing you into the world making it a little bit more creepy and the only other game I would just add myself is another game weary car we covered actually on the very first episode of our going analog video show called levels someone will make a protocol so this is sort of like if you're familiar with the video game series XCOM it's sort of like that where there's these eight you're a troupe of Murray like these Marines and or special ops soldiers and you're going around try to take out aliens but it's creepy in the same way the video game series is where you're going down tunnels in and there's another player who's controlling like aliens bursting out of the vents or like a cave-in or the doors circuiting and forcing you to go another way and then you never know where these like kind of creepy crawlers are coming from and you have limited firepower to take care of these guys but the aliens are obras overwhelming in force so I think that's a that's not a horror game per se but it does a good job of kind of just being creepy and making you feel that this sort of creepy aliens like XCOM like atmosphere alright so that was super cool it's kind of an early start for Halloween and Christina let's let's take a break from all of that mood and heavy mood and let's go with your topic so why don't you remind us what your topic is again and then kick us off yeah so my topic was talking about how everybody you know how what your philosophy is on how to host a board

game night as I sort of mentioned I went on this since we moved on to a new area one of my friends surely put me up with this sort of like a blind friend date so I went to coffee with a with a friend I'd never met and we were just chatting about her interests and I was explaining about how I see myself as sort of a board game sommelier for people you know I've got some people who are interested in the hobby and getting into the Hobby I've met people who are like I don't really like games so I'm like really maybe you just haven't had the right person introduce you to games but at the same time we also have you know a lot of friends who have experience with games so when they come over you know I want to keep that in mind also and think about you know this friend is very into theme and you know even if the gameplay is great if the themes not strong you know I want to make sure that I don't recommend a game that doesn't have that on the other hand we have a lot of friends who are really into crunchy crunchy games you know Mike Zipkin for instance especially beige covers yeah we we you know I know that's sort of his niche so the beige yeah so you know those are sort of things that I think about when we have a bunch of friends over I think the biggest aspect is also the number of players shoe has a magic superpower where he remembers the number of players for each game we own so that's always

really helpful for me because I can just ask him for like hey a shoe how much does you know bunny kingdom play how many people and stuff like that so two to four oh great so we have a lot of really great resources there and you know our old board game organizing system was helpful too since we organized by how long that game would take so that's in general sort of what I was talking about and I think that since all of us in this podcast right now are pretty big board game hosts and stuff we I just wanted to talk about how what you guys consider when you think about what games to bring into a board gambling so John you're like I'm really curious how you do this because I because Mike and Christine and I we obviously hang out so we're familiar with how we organize games in how we pickings but you're a board game designer right and but you also play games that you don't design obviously like are you like hey come play my latest game or help me prototype my next game or how do you go about picking games for your groups well so my wife and I have been running at monthly game day where we live for probably about seven years now Wow and we've got like we're in a very small town but we have a Facebook group of about two hundred people and usually between like twenty and fifty people show up every month for game day this is a your house yeah um yeah we usually have it at our house or at my in-laws they have like a big outbuilding during the summer yeah don't forget you the real estate prices there are like you

know ten bucks will get you an acre so yeah I've been doing I've been doing the exact thing you're talking about for a while I started to play prototypes at game days but I generally try to avoid doing it at our monthly game day because a prototypes are usually bad and they're definitely not as fun as a finished game so we started having design meetup so I try to keep those two worlds separate and game days usually like my weekend off every month mm-hmm so I don't want to play fun games and not work but the definitely the things that I keep in mind are you know I tried it when it's somebody new to the Hobby and I try to pick a game that's a theme that they'll light so you know I usually start by talking about what their interests are and you know what kind of things they enjoy and I try to usually start with shorter games because not everybody knows exactly where their preferences for light so if they don't like a short game it's over quickly but if they want something longer that's easier to jump into later yeah and that could also help you sort of like recommend the next game it's like you play a short game and then you say okay if you like that then let's move in this direction or if you didn't like that let's try something completely different and then do you I is it hard with that many people to try to entertain are you like all right let me grab the three of you or is it like your whole groups pretty well-versed in games

so anyone could run anything at first it was mostly me trying to organize everything and keep people going but there's enough people now that you know trying to take the lead that everybody is just running a different table and gathering people up and other people have kind of fall into like well these people play you know Battlestar Galactica so that's the group I want to hang out with this that's very cool how about you Mike oh yeah I think it just it obviously I agree it depends on the people so with newer players I think it's like we talked about in the Gateway Games episode I'll I'll bust out something like formula D because it's like a very accessible theme of you know Formula One racing that anybody can understand and you're just jumping into a racecar and we're throwing dice and and trying to go as fast as you can without blowing up but yeah I think it when it comes to crunchy ER gamers I try to find something that either I haven't played before but that I I know the rules really well it kind of comes down to like how well I know the game and how comfortable I am like either teaching the game or how well I think the audience that's gonna play this with me is is or how patient they are to learn the rules with me and you know and make sure that I have everything right so in the case of having you know like I should like you should like shoe over I would definitely try to pick something that I think that you haven't played before and that I could definitely teach and that I think you would enjoy so you know it definitely depends on the the taste of

the players and their patient level patient so yeah I really think it's you know one thing that I considered too is or I guess we do to prepare for game nights is like Xuan Xu and I will sort of read the rules for games we're planning to play ahead of time I mean it makes you fall asleep but and I'm sort of just really reluctant to do it but when I do it it's fine and then III just do think it's really important to be prepared when I'm gonna teach a game to new players I don't want there to be too much lag time or me trying to figure too much stuff out because it can be really off-putting for somebody who's not used to sort of working through those rules and that like every five seconds I have to go look up a rule for that you know I know when it's people that I know that play a lot of games I always enjoy trying to find games that they haven't heard of to introduce them to mm-hm you know pulling out something rare or really hard to find is a lot of fun for me yeah I definitely get a lot of enjoyment out of like like like introducing something new to the group and I think that's why we buy so many games is because I'm always chasing after the next new thing yeah well I used to have this system a long time ago where I put all my friends into one of four quadrants where the x-axis would be your attention span so you either a high attention span game area or you don't have much of an attention span and then the x-axis would be how much you care

about theme like some people care about FEMA lots some people don't and I felt like you say they were both the x-axis I say 2 X axis is 1 X 1 y you get the idea so they and so if you split people into those four quadrants you could kind of find a pretty good game like so like it's like low attention span they don't care about theme maybe Carcassonne might be something good right or Ticket to Ride and things like that so but over the years what I've started doing is good when Christine and I picked up a second and third gaming table we're just like sometimes we'll just throw it invite out invite as many people over in butts and then we'll usually either start with big group games and then break up into smaller groups into different tables or we'll do the opposite like we'll end the night when everyone's kind of maybe they've been drinking all my which are kind of tired of playing long games then we'll end with party games where everyone's a little bit more relaxed and just having fun and taking taking everything less seriously let's sometimes in a mood for like I want to play a heavy duty strategy game that's gonna take 3-4 hours then I'll just send out a small email to like alright I'm not inviting everybody I know this isn't for some of my short attention span friends and just like I need 2 or 3 people to play Terra Mystica with me or Arkham Horror or whatever does some heavy game and then and I'll just target accordingly and just like pick the game ahead of time and just say this is what we're gonna play who's in yeah one one thing I've been trying to get better at is deciding when to bring

my own game or like who's gonna get to pick the game that night because I have a standing you know weekly game night with these guys that I play with some of whom have been on the show before but I try not to bring a game over to somebody else's house if if I have already played one of mine and I kind of get a little annoyed when somebody suggests slike or if they bring a big bag of stuff over my house when I they know I already have like 350 you know board games it's like you know I'm the one hosting if if I didn't get to choose last time I think it should make sense that I get to choose but you know I try to be respectful of other people's choices too and like not not force my choices on them if I already got to play one of mine yeah I guess another aspect that she didn't mention is he also thinks about what's on our pile of shame that's true yeah it's like we prioritize the new gains that we bought that we haven't played yet so that's that's definitely a factor okay I'm gonna save John's topic for last because that's a really interesting one that we could go really deep on that one so let's go to my topic next it's another light one which is games everyone seems to love but you and I'm like I like this topic and I didn't realize my answers aren't necessarily very original if you're like maybe board games snobby like we all might be a little bit so like my one would be like for me is Dominion which is like a super popular game it sort of kind of made a deck

like the idea not magic the gathering style deck-building where you're buying packs and adding to your deck but the deck building genre where within one box you can add more and more cards within a game within one session and create a better and better deck as you play and then you end the game but you don't have to buy additional booster packs or anything like that Dominion was really the one that made that genre super popular I I thought it was okay and I didn't but even at the time when it was brand new and it weren't a lot of other choices I didn't think he was that great and one of the things I didn't like was in this game you can also you buy cards that are worth points and then those points cards go into your deck and they clutter up your hand so what you're supposed to be building this deck that's more and more powerful and doing all these cool combinations and then you have to balance that with just throwing in points that don't do anything for you so I don't really like that design and I like good games like ascension that does that same style of game but better in my opinion so that's one for me and then the other kind of obvious answers I think that you probably heard from a lot of quote-unquote snobby gamers is a our munchkin which is like this dungeon exploring game where you're fighting monsters you're grabbing loot but then you could really screw over other players and if someone's getting ahead and they're getting close to winning it's really easy to knock them down and then try to get ahead and it's just like it seems to devolve into non-stop just like preventing one person from winning and then someone just kind of stumbles across a picket line by accident by the end of the night I used to really like

that game when I didn't know any better I think and then I just grew really sick of it in every munchkin that's come on scene is gonna follow the same formula so I'm definitely over that series and then cards against humanity' is another one that when I first started playing it I loved it for about two weeks and then I hated it when I realized like there's all the humors just in the cards and there's no creativity being done on part of the player so then not buying expansions man I know like you just had to keep buying more and more cars and chasing after this so you know I again I'm not saying anything you have to think a lot of people complain about those games but those are mine how about you Mike I mean I feel like you know I'm gonna where I'm gonna go with this I do know a couple of years I think I'm I have a problem with two particular designers Eric Lang and Ryan Lockett their games tend to fall flat for me so like whenever I have a friend and I actually I think she would probably fall into that group where you know they tend to want to play there those games a lot and then they know that whenever they are gonna be playing those games they are not going to invite me so I don't get invited to these get-togethers because they're gonna play these games and I just find those two designers to be either very lifer and learn in Ryan lockets case like his games just sort of feel very similar to me and like they always kind of don't really ramp up very very quickly and they're the arc doesn't really I don't really find that they have a good feeling like in the arc and

I like games that feel like they progress and they've they build to something and then and they end in a big you know crescendo and then like it feels like a good payoff but I feel like the luckiest games kind of end with a go huh okay and so with and with laying it's kind of like a a lot of take that where you're just kind of pushing each other around so I don't tend to like those kind of games but it's funny because your friend Steve I've you introduced me to him he likes both those designers as do we Christina and our big Ryan locket fans we try to collect all his games and we have all we have I think it's impossible to own all Eric Lang games because he makes so many but we have a lot of his games as well so we will plan we used to plan gaming sessions with your friend behind your back because we're like I'm like well let's just hang out without my I know and that's not fair but I do hang out with your friends and it's your fault so I say I'll just take one last dig it Ryan lock it I just say I feel like he's kind of like the JJ Abrams of board games like he borrows a lot of other people's ideas and they're just not very good when they when he's you know done with them I I do love you know that he's I I admire his ability to manage all the different facets of the production from the art to the design to the promotion I have no fault with the amount of work that he does and it's phenomenal that can make it all do - all himself but for he's just not his games are just not for me okay

they're not for you but you're wrong about them not being good I'm trying about borders you are a joke whenever we play new Ryan laughs a game is its collecting and what ya set collecting and for some reason like carrot and toad people all right how about you Cristina I think I mean I I sort of agree with the general things that you mentioned it's not like I ever am fiending to play the things he doesn't want to play there but I think my it's like a whole sort of genre for me and it's just sort of like a taste I think you know there's a lot of sort of head-to-head conflict sort of tactical games that if anything is to chest like it just turns me off and I know they're excellent games and I've played some games where I like you know I'll play some of these like sort of attack type games with shoe and I'm like yeah objectively I can see that this is a good game it's just sort of not to my taste I'd rather not have to think you know eight moves in advance I like sort of maximising moves right now and in the near future and sort of guess a bit at what my opponents gonna do but I don't want to have to plan everything out ahead of time to do well at a game so I don't there's been a whole bunch of them show that I've played here there but I only put them once like I tried to get you to play summoner Wars which on a map and these cards represent different units so it's sort of like you're moving

them a few steps at time and attacking or battle the war which is like a hex pace where fantasy creatures and you have like all these units attacking each other yeah you're just not into any of them and it drives me crazy yeah and then I still beat you at them so you know when Jim yeah it's just sort of not my cup of tea I think I think the only one of those that I have sort of liked it maybe it's because it limits the choices you have at the moment I really like Tony Tama so I'd still play that one but in general that's sort of not my thing it's what Oh people with only Thomas oh I'm sorry yeah Oh needs is a really beautiful two-player game and it's it is pretty reminiscent of chess or checkers except it limits your movements you're trying to move your main main is it I don't know what that grandmaster yeah grandmaster yeah you've been trying to move him all the way across the board it's your opponent's side but the interesting aspect of your move choices are that there are preset move choices that are selected from cards and there's only a certain number of cards per game so when you make your move that takes it out of the available pool for your opponent but it's going to come back in the future so you can still plan in advance for future moves from your opponent but it's not like I have I know every single possible move and I have to think about 20 of them right now so I really really enjoy that game really elegant beautiful game that's a yeah so

when I invited John and I said is this an okay topic for you to talk about like games that you'd actually don't like because you work in the industry right you're unlike us where we're just commentators and you know who are we just a bunch of Punk's doing a podcast but you actually you design games you work and collaborate with a lot of these people some of them are under the same publisher I'm like are you gonna have a hard time criticizing other's work but you were like Melton not a problem so let's hear it well I usually have a pretty strict rule about saying anything negative about any board game publicly like privately I'll talk to people about things that I find her on with games but I don't like to post about it very often or if I do it'll be very vague and not mentioned natural game but when you brought up this topic I could think of one immediately that's extremely popular so I'm not too worried about it because they're they're doing fine and for me it's too many bones hmm oh if that's right we talked about this yeah like we're arguing about this in front of us at GenCon a couple years ago because everyone around you loved it and you're just like it's I don't like this game so tell us what tell us what the game is and tell us why you don't like it so too many bones is a game from chips theory games and it it's about playing these weird gnome type people that are going on an adventure and it has some some kind of RPG type elements but essentially you're like leveling up your character gaining

new skills which unlock new dice would you get to roll into abilities and like everything in the game is represented by either poker chips or dice for the most part and it's a beautiful presentation when I doubt my kid starter copy you know opening it up was a very very pleasant experience and it was there's really nice to look at but every time I played it it felt like a chore I think I probably played it three or four times before I traded it off and people seem to love it but I don't understand I just received a huge shipment from the too many bones their expansion or their standalone expansion Kickstarter so I just received like 26 pounds of too many bones content so yes I picked them up and we got that giant package together so I do remember you saying that in that almost kind of dissuaded me from but I'm like it's so many people love this game I need to try it out so I'll report back to you after I learned that game which might take me a few months yeah I'm excited to hear your thoughts because I don't know what it is about it that gets me yeah I think one of it then you say it takes a long time to play - right yeah I had to play the play time is very very long for what I feel that it does I think that's one of the main things into the action right right let's go to your topic then John why don't you remind us what that is and then start us off I

want to talk a little bit about how board games can evoke experiences a lot of designers will try to classify themselves as mechanics first like they'll start a game by coming up with a cool mechanic and then build the rest of them about that around it or they'll start with a theme so there's theme first designers will be like well I'm going to make a zombie game and then build the game around that what I kind of consider myself is experience first designer because I always think of not just the theme but what I want the players to feel and then try to pick mechanics and thematic elements that influence the players I want them when they take an action to feel like they're doing the thing that they would do as if they were in the game you know I don't want them to do things just because they're mechanically needed or that don't that kind of because sometimes you'll play a game where actions almost some actions will drop you out of the front of the game and I think that that's an important thing to avoid can you give us an example from one of your more popular games so you can kind of paint a picture for what you're talking about exactly from your point of view yeah so I mean I think with dead of winter the thing I've noticed over the years teaching it is that it's it's very very easy to teach I can I don't have a group plane in about ten minutes because you don't really have to explain a lot

of the mechanics about the actions to them you just explain you know these are the actions that you have to spend it a die for these are the actions that you don't spend a die for and essentially for the first round just tell me what you want to do and we'll pick one of these actions that does it so when you want to move you know you just explain to them how that happens and you they're all the things that you would want to do if you were a survivor and I was on be apocalypse you want to move you want to scavenge you want to clean the trash up in the colony because that you can't let it get disgusting so everything feels like if I was there what would I focus on and I think that helps gives give the players like a really unique experience when they can just really slip themselves into the game so I this I didn't talk about dead of winter earlier when time I was scary games because I wanted to talk about it for in this topic specifically now I've said this about dead of winter before I met you so I feel safe saying this without sounding feeling like I'm kissing your ass because you're on the show but I think it's a brilliant game and I really like the first time I played it was at a convention I'm like oh my god this is this is great it's so different and it's evoking these different experiences because I tell people all the time I'm like that winner is fantastic because it's a zombie game yes but it's not really about the zombies the game isn't about the zombies at all in my opinion right is my view you know I shouldn't be

telling the designer what the game is or is it about like the way I feel I'm like it's not about the zombies like the part about the parts of the game where you have to go out and like I have to take care of kill these zombies before they get out of hand or make sure I barricade these areas before the zombies break in yes that's part of the game but what you get out of it is the the dynamic between the players and I seen very few games that does it as well as dead a winner and again for everyone listening out there I said this I Christina could vouch for this I said this long before I met John yeah this is not just because he's here because you've created the system where you have to act selfishly but also act in the best interest of the greater of the group because it's a cooperative game but your each of you each of the players are in charge of a small band of survivors and you have to make really tough choices like I have a can of fuel do I give this to the group because a group needs it and it helps the group's goal or do I keep it because I needed to fulfill my own my own personal objectives right and so what you create is all this tension and where people are like why wouldn't you share this food or sure the fuel are you holding out on us and you're pissed off at each other but it's it's it's a fantastic dynamic because you start to feel like this is how it would work if there was a real-life sabe apocalypse right like if the four of us were in a room in a in this outpost full of other people we didn't know we sure we might think looking we're gonna do what's best for the greater good but there might be times where we were like you know what my wife

hasn't eaten in days I'm gonna selfishly keep this kind of food to feed her so I could take her make sure I ensure her survival and you know screw the rest of the group because I love my wife and I had to take care of her first so we've had a lot of interesting fights with our friends in this and arguments and all this weird tension and it just very much feels like you start you draw that out of people like how would you act if the world was really ending in your face with the zombie apocalypse and it's like almost like those zombies are secondary in this game and it's just such a cool cool feeling to be put in that situation and have that dynamic between the players yeah when when people say I don't like zombie games I usually tell them it's not a zombie game it's a survival game that has zombies and you know like the best zombie movies or zombie books there it's not about the zombies there background noise and they're an ever-present threat but it's more about the humanity and the stories of that and that's really what I want to focus on was you know how would it feel as a survivor to be in this you know what kind of things do I want and one of the times during playtesting when I knew we were doing it right is we were playing a game and the car the trolleys just starving and there used to be a mechanic where you could do a specific action to look at another player's hand

and somebody did the hatch and I looked at one player saying and they were hoarding food and then we looked at somebody else's hand and they were hoarding food too and there's only one secret objective in the game to hoard food the other person was doing it just because he felt like it was the right thing to do and in what I saw that people are starting to make decisions based on either their morality or what they would do rather than the mechanics of the game that's when I knew that we were in the right direction because I want you to make decisions that are fun and exciting and not necessarily the mathematically best decision every moment yeah that's right this last thing I'll say about this just so it's not a dead of winter podcast but I once I invited a friend over his first time I actually had him over to play games and then my other friend our friend Anna she ended up kind of being kingmaker for a specific reason that didn't make sense to me made perfect sense to her and we argued about it for about 45 minutes after the game and it in a friendly way we you know we weren't mad at each other but we just had this long discussion I've never had been in the game before we're discussing like why did you make the choices he made in whether it was right or wrong whether it's the designers intent or not so it's an Afghan yeah whatever we won't do here because it's gonna take too long to explain but it was just a really

fascinating thing because you're just tapping into all this like the psychology and the this behavior stuff that you'd normally don't really discuss or get out of a typical board game so great job on that I just love that game I think Adam I think you maile probably depends a lot up like with whom you're playing but I did play this with strangers at the con and they still thought it was great so definitely a cool game yeah my my wife doesn't like thematic games very much and the one time the one time I got her to play dead a winner I saw something happen which is she she doesn't like role-playing games at all she doesn't like anything like what she describes us anything that she has to use her imagination to play and I saw her starting to like kind of tell a story in the game and that was really excited to me but it was also she and it's a really proud moment for me but it's kind of a sad moment shaded up crying during the game because one of the cross Serb charts and came up I was like oh it's really cool as a designer to see somebody like real emotions over your game that's like oh man my wife's crying I should probably feel bad not good vos is crazy do you have any other stories want to share with us from your point of view as a designer I think this is like a great topic to hear more from you about yes I

actually think another Daymond of people you know say is a really dry euro but I think it's it's very heavy like to mcih is a griddle it's just three huh every time I played I feel like a starving farmer who's like just draping around for my family and you know I'm not necessarily making the best decisions but I'm a man I need more towels and Joe keeps taking all the wood yeah so for you guys what do you think some games that really bring out experiences like that are for you well I mean if for me I was just thinking as we were talking about or about about our topics about how a lot of this sort of scary games that I like use the hidden movement mechanic to sort of evoke fear and the sort of sense of like a foreboding sort of like you know evil presence that you can't quite see because like I was thinking of games like you know fear Dracula's one but then you know letters from Whitechapel and then its sequel mystery at Whitehall which both talked about Jack the Ripper and like how and and one player plays as Jack and they're they're not they're not on the board either and the other players are trying to find him and then Nyctophobia is another one that I was thinking of and how like you're supposed to wear the you wear three through you know several the players wear these glasses and then one player plays the hunter who's hunting down these players and so it's all about like what you can't see and so I like how like these I

think you know you have to make clear though those glasses are opaque you can't see through yeah they're there they're blind they're completely blind blacked-out glasses and so they can't see the board and the hunter has to move their hand to their piece and and then at some point sometimes the hunter will will lie to them and like they're they're supposed to lie and like tell them you know whatever they want and they can come up behind them and hit them with an ax or whatever but basically all these games that I that I find fun for for you know scary Nate at night of gaming all use the same mechanic of like you know preventing the some of the players most of the players on the board from knowing what's going and having having not not all the information in front of them and so using that sort of hidden movement to scare people and create a mood I think is really interesting yeah I think even with games like werewolf that are a lot lighter I think they have that same element of the unknown that really can be terrifying at times you know when you close your eyes and werewolf and you're not a werewolf you don't know if you're gonna make it to the morning and that that could be scary mm-hmm yeah yeah and I'm I don't think I just don't think rolling dice makes it very scary I don't think you know worker placement is a good mechanic to use for that scary but me I mean maybe there maybe there is a way to do it that would make a game more scary but I think you know one element one mechanic that I haven't seen used or has underused in horror games I think is card drafting I think in a certain way

like werewolf uses it in some ways to sort of find out what character you are but how about you Christina yeah I mean I think definitely like Nyctophobia is is like all experience I think for sure it was really interesting I know you know the designer wanted to give people that feeling of being blind because she made this game for her uncle or I think was her uncle John yeah yeah which was really really awesome I think for me who is blind yes um I think you know not speaking of the they hit enroll mechanic as much I really like a lot of legacy games these days where where you get that narrative because you start being very invested in your in the player that you are in the character you're playing I always talk about you know when people ask me what's my favorite game my favorite gaming experience was definitely pent at make like pandemic legacy season one it was just so interesting it's like I was playing a movie and like all these twists and turns in the narrative were really really great and oh my gosh like Asia's going down are we going to have to like you know nuke Istanbul oh my god there's always decisions to make and we can't keep everybody alive so what are we gonna do and and I think that cooperative feeling as a legacy game is really really great for me because because you're in it together you're playing with a consistent group and some

of those games are just so interesting and how your experience is so different from you know another playing groups experience mm-hmm yeah that's one where if people aren't familiar what what a legacy game is this is where you play several sessions like or like a season of this campaign and the game changes and you make permanent changes like you might rip up cars you might open up secret boxes you might unlock things that you didn't know we're there previously you might write in permanent marker on the board so it changes but they I don't I don't even understand how you really design this game because it seems so complicated to me like to have to figure out like all right no matter what the outcome is whether you win or lose or win badly or lose badly or win by a lot whatever and then you have to go into the next month of this campaign that it's it's still seamless and they can still add their twists and turns and they still make it work so yeah there's definitely like exciting moments that I still remember from that campaign and then and then when you're done it's like you feel like you just went to battle with your friends and then you just like kind of all sit back and you just have a big smudge it's like well we just went to war together and it's like this huge stressful thing that we played over a few months and now it's over it's concluded and so satisfying that that was a great fantastic experience did you guys buy a Mike and John have you guys played pandemics is Season one no I haven't finished I started it and

then we moved yet I'm in same boat we played it with another couple my wife and I and we've only made it to October I think so we we've been sitting on you know October November December for the last like year I think in general to like like exactly like what she was saying that that shared experience while you're like struggling together is something that sticks in my mind I I mean it also reminds me of course dead winner where there was also that you know yeah is are they really on my side like what are they really doing here and then um Robinson Crusoe also came to mind when I was thinking about this I really liked that mechanic or sort of like the crossroad sort of mechanism but also where if you make a decision it could come back in the later on and and have some consequences that totally narratively make sense but you're like oh crap that sucks uh-huh so I really like that aspect of Roberts increasing it was really hard to so yeah that's a good example of one where gloom Haven had that too where you might have an encounter and you have to make a decision and then later on in the game you might get might come back and say to you like oh yeah um I was it near and far Cristina from Ryan Lockett had sort of the same thing right where I made a decision early on it's my character and then it told me to write this thing on my character sheet in an later on I kept having a specific

storyline only for me because of certain choices that I made because basically I was a killer robot and then and then the game remembered that I was a killer robot and kept presenting me with things that only the killer robot would see so that was really super cool uh I love when games do that and do it well alright cool well that was an awesome discussion thank you very much so we appreciate listening to the podcasts we appreciate any likes subscriptions but before we sign off we just do this quick wrap-up of will go around the table real quickly and just have everyone say a few last words anything you want to talk about like a cool game you might be playing something else that you want to just throw out there real quick not quite a full topic but just a quick little something something so John do you have any last words for us I know it's super awesome to be I guess I do I'm super awesome being here and if anybody will be at meta topia or patch to unplug those are the Mets two conventions over yet so I'd love to play games with anybody who's cool so John is like the nicest person ever so you should totally say hi absolutely please do and then how about you Mike yeah sure just following up with my scary game the fury of Dracula the fourth edition of skew of theory of Dracula is actually coming out in November supposedly according to whiz kids and they just took over publishing duties and it's gonna come with brand new minis that are pre painted so if anybody's looking to get a copy and is

having a hard time then fret not cuz it's gonna be out soon and it's gonna look really good oh I didn't even know about this it's like okay I sold the second edition got the third edition and then now there's another edition coming out there's no point in you playing it you know we're just gonna kill you because you're trakula so last time I won as a hunter so there's that so alright and then Christina any last words from you don't buy the fourth edition of Fury of Dracula alright yeah I don't have much to say other than this game I brought up earlier that I'm really diggin and I guess he didn't like that much my Chi Quan bro I didn't complain I didn't dislike it I just I think you hyped it up a lot so in my head it was maybe a little bit you know overhyped but I and I'm gonna continue to hype it because I just played it again two nights ago and it still brings a smile to my face I play this is like uh we talked about it in an earlier episode so I'm not going to get into it now but if you like heavier European style gains that this with a dry theme but this one has a lot of color to it bright colors which is unusual for games of this genre go check it out there's also the other one Christina you and I played that James Hudson from Jewett City Games introduced to us you say it's Roger Ganges okay yeah so what Thanks

she doesn't believe me when I say it's pronouncing it even weirder than that earlier anyway I really liked it for me I liked it even more than qualm bro which I enjoy but it just had this really interesting win objective instead of just like get the most points you have to get a lot of Fame you're winning with the basically a combination of fame and money and so you could choose either path or do both really well but that's sort of a race to have these two tracks meet which was very different from any other game I've played and I really enjoyed it cool all right well thanks everybody in I'm just gonna throw this out there I'm weird over the show's over but I can't believe we didn't talk about tales of Arabian Nights as a board game experience is a cool game that evokes different experiences did we talk about tales of Arabian Nights in a previous episode we've talked about it a few times I feel like okay yeah that makes me feel better go let's start old episodes go look it up online really great really different kind of game that you can have a bunch of stories coming out of it to talk about for a long time I know it's done that for us check it out if you can it might be hard to find but really cool game all right Jon yeah it's is it what sorry I believe it's not a print right now yeah yeah it's gonna be hard to find but super cool game do you like it Jon oh I love it we actually

for a long time stopped playing it for points because you know in the beginning where you like set your two scores didn't decide who wins we just threw that aspect of the game out and said alright we're gonna play this for an hour and a half and then and our stories mm-hmm that's great and we didn't care about the winning or losing we just cared about telling a good story having fun that's how I preferred it I wish that more people played board games that way because that's that's kind of the way I feel about a lot of games yeah it's a very very cool game alright well thank you all for coming again if you're listening and you like what we're doing we appreciate any shares like subscriptions telling your friends about the show feedback you could find us on social media on Twitter and Facebook at going analog show or you can send us email at letters at going analog show com so thank you for listening we'll be back in a couple of weeks with new topics and we hope you'll tune in then thanks a lot

Progress saved