Top 5 Disappointing Games of 2023
Transcript
some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome back to board games unlocked and Brad are doing our top five disappointing games of 2023 uh if you're not familiar every year we do a disappointing list because not every game is amazing and sometimes we have high expectations and they don't come to fruition and here are those five games um now to me I probably say this every single time to me disappointing doesn't necess necessarily mean that I think these games are bad um they have elements of you know good things about them but then it's mainly more my expectation for them was higher and because we also do a worst of the year they don't belong on that list so it's kind of like a happy medium um where it's like hey guys like you're not terrible but you're not definitely making the great list um and yeah man we got some we got some good ones this this year I think this one was actually pretty easy for me to make yeah mine was was was okay yeah my my top three were definitely my I mean there was a big gap my top three were my big okay there's a there's a big Blank Spot and then my four five6 gotcha yeah all right well without further Ado let's go ahead and get started with a
dishonorable mention this is uh so number six um for me this was a game that basically I expected I had played this game at Gen Con and this has happened quite a few times where the Gen Con experience is a lot better than whenever you actually play it in a more not hyped uh category or or not hyped um situation uh and as I got this game I felt that it was just kind of a whatever game I didn't really like the way it was actually flowing and the just the company that makes it I expect more from so my number six is kapow this is volume one but volume one and two which this this was a game that was made earlier yes but so this might be kind of a reprint from uh now wise wizard games um so this is a dice customizable game where you have your your character's abilities over on the side then you have a generic uh grid of attack defense um and then speci other unique stuff and you take your Dice and you roll them behind your screen yeah immediate and then powerups and after PowerUp stuff uh and the faces on the dice allow you to do various actions uh
initially whenever I had played this I kind of I think I I had demoed this at Gen Con and this was probably around the time where you know dice I was really into dice throne and stuff but as it turns out I don't really like onev one games that rely entire upon luck and this game has that in Spades you want to do an attack well you need to roll attack symbols you want to defend you need to roll defense symbols um I mean I did like that each hero you know their whatever madeup hero had unique ways that they played but at the end of the day you're not really using those a whole lot and you need to still use your generic uh stuff so it's just kind of like oh okay well oh and all this is done behind screens by the way um so when you're rolling behind screens and you're setting the dice you're like boy I really hope they defend um or they or I really hope they don't defend I really hope that so I have this big attack coming and up they got all the defense and there's no way I could have known that uh it just kind of felt like there is a better way to go about this I mean hell dice Throne is I would say is a better way to go about this with just the yatti style rolling dice without interacting except with cards this doesn't have any of that so
ultimately I got rid of it didn't like the randomness of the dice on top of the the dice customizing I just didn't care about when you're like if that's like the major gimmick and it went on a little bit too long for it to uh matter like for it to if it was quicker then maybe but it wasn't really all that quick so yeah that's my dishonorable mention Capal volume one and two yeah this one just never really inded me a whole lot so that's why I never even tried it yeah and I think the fake superhero thing just doesn't really do it for me I was also kind of superhero fatigued M with this uh well dice Throne had Marvel Dice throne but um what was that other one Sentinels Sentinels yeah yeah it's like what like I mean what what what are you gonna make what kind of superhero are you gonna make that's not from a named person that you you couldn't pay for the IP for right yep so yeah all number six well my number six is a game that I went into because it looks cool on the table and I went into expecting it to be a cool Cooperative game um and it just kind of fell blah I mean and and it's I don't even really know how well known this game is it's actually from smirk and dagger games uh okay so they've done their you know several things in the past but this one
was kind of one that just didn't work for me that well and it's Tesseract interesting I don't know anything about this um this one is oh man um so I'm just going to go and flip to the game picture because it's kind of hard to explain unless you see so there's a big oh that does look cool yeah yeah there's like a bunch of dice that make up this Cube and you are working together to try to remove Dice from that and get them placed in the containment area with matching symbols and colors um and you if you do that you win so the containment is this but if you have if this counter ends up going to spot number seven you lose okay um and it's it's just weird like I like you see that you see like the hand holding up the test rack thing and it's really neat looking but then it's just like the actions you're taking and you're the dice you're pulling off and it it just it just didn't work well you know and we played it with four players and let me see it says it's best for two to three so maybe the maybe the bigger player count did stuff but you're going to remove cubes and place them on their in their Labs depending on their uh because this is your player deal so you're gonna take a your lab and in
order to move it you've got to do um let's see it was put three of them in a row I'm just trying to remember I don't know this game it just fell flat I yeah this was one of those ones that the the the coolness factor of looking at it outdid the gamep playay yeah I haven't really heard a whole lot of people enjoying this game either so so I don't know but it was one that's um I actually played this at the Christmas thing because it was one of the secret Santa gifts that one of the guys got and okay and it just kind of just didn't work for me smirk dagger has been kind of one of those companies that uh it's smirk and laughter now well no it's both they have party games it's the smirk and laughter but their dagger is their ones that they still do with um uh [ __ ] they you know like their old cool stuff that that oh like cutro caverns and yes cutthoat Caverns like stuff like that's always what I picture from them yeah they're an odd company they are and you know so I I really don't know what else much to say about this I mean the it looks cool on the table Yeah but the game play Falls flat you know it's just kind of a one of those things yeah not even close to my radar like I have no idea what this is
it wouldn't have been mine if I hadn't played it that at that Christmas party I mean yeah you know it just wasn't a good one sure okay which that sounds like it's like the perfect uh scenery to play a game like this at a Christmas party you know if it's from smirk and laughter well no one was laughing yeah all right that's so stupid all right my number five and this one is such a shame too because I actually finish this campaign and to be fair to this game specifically don't do that do not binge I feel feel like if I had paced this game out over some time I probably would have different feelings towards it but I binged it to play it and man it just got extremely repetitive almost to a point where there it felt like there was a meta so my number five is the legacy of you uh by Garfield games and Shem Phillips and a solo only resettable camp pain so I was like dude this sounds like a slam dunk right like um I mean Garfield games I love most of their games uh but man so yeah like I said this is solo only with a loose story of um it seemed to be yeah this this uh Aqueduct or this River crafting
guy I don't even know if it was based on any history it might have been or by okay so uh going through the trials and tribulations of creating this um God hold on I'll have to look it up so I'm not just butchering exactly um what it was about um yeah plagued by floods eager to put an end to Devastation Yao selected gun to devise a plan after nine years of failed attempts gun's deployment tamed to question after his passing you inherited his father's work uh series of canals to direct the yeah into nearby fields and waterways that's the entire game and the action and gameplay of it is fine like there's multiple ways you can lose like you can be overrun by barbarians which is basically going to constantly be happening over the course of the game you're going to have less and less people to pull into your deck and more barbarians to deal with um you kind of will be going through the same Canal so you can lose if that River wooden piece catches up to your boat and a few other ways but your cards have multi-use which is cool you can either you can you know discard them for their Brown ability like the card on the left in the hand you can get two food you can trash him like put him in the top discard pile for an extra food so three food total um and you're going to be using your workers like you do in all of
shem's games the problem that I ended up having with this was again when you're playing through and the story is very very minor and you have to win you have to win more games than you lose so it's like hey after this many games you know depending on how many you w this is kind of your ending you can have a really good ending really bad ending things like that is eventually this game came down to an efficiency puzzle which I'm not the biggest fan of like I'm all about being efficient in games but whenever you have to be super efficient where no mistakes are allowed that's where it kind of starts to become very tedious for me and that's exactly what this game came around like whenever I found something that worked I never deviated from that and it worked almost every single time so like yeah it's a small footprint it's resetable campaign although I don't know why you would want to reset it um to redo um yeah yeah pretty much so I I mean if people were be say that they liked it I that totally makes sense um hence why it's on the higher end of of this list but by the end of the you know after I was done with it I was so done with it um yeah go ahead I was just gonna say this one is one that uh I haven't played enough to really have an opinion on yet
um only played like two of the little the first first two little things of the campaign just kind of left it at that so right to be determined for me yeah because I feel like if I had played like a game maybe a week or something and I'd like that efficiency kind of thing and be like oh okay yeah what's the new you know new cards that are being added um The Barbarians ramp I think way quicker than I feel like they should and sometimes that deck like it could be completely stacked against you it is entirely possible for you to set up this game and lose um and that I don't like uh which I mean the easy fix is you just reshuffle and just start over you didn't have to play but it's annoying to kind of be like well I lost and technically I played so I have to do the lose condition right and progress forward it's just I mean or you play one card and then it's like okay what's the next Barbarian okay I cannot beat that I cannot deal with that at all so it's just going to cause me to lose way more resources and now I definitely can't win it it it just kind of became a little bit much after playing it over and over um but other than that I mean I really like the art yeah yep yeah one it's one of the rare um uh Garfield games that didn't use um the the mo the moo stuff this is
the same artist I think that did the Raiders of cyia I think they used the same guy with this one I think so um but yeah I mean definitely give it a a shot if you want if you love efficiency puzzles solo only uh this one just kind of got really annoying towards the end so that's my number five my number five is a game that looks really cool on the table and the concept it's Tesseract again no no no uh the concept the concept of this game was really cool sounding um and it was one that uh I ended up picking up because my wife thought it looked looked cool and everything and it ended up being kind of just not living up to the expectations I mean that's why it's a five and not down lower because it's not a bad game inherently but I had my expectations high enough for it because of the whole rolling meeple um aspects oh okay yeah yeah and and um it just kind of was weird and that's Rolling Heights yeah so oh art by Quan Shai Moria see we talked about him earlier um did we I already for he was the guy that did the art yeah but um but uh John declair you know this was kind of a a different type of game for him because you usually he's
more of the whole card crafting you know all the stuff with cards this game is a city city building game and you the the gimmick that got people in with this is that you're rolling meeples and the meeples that are um standing when you roll them you get to do actions with them and stuff uh and the ones that are on their side you know that don't aren't standing up they don't do anything for you so you would think that you'd be a roll rolling me standing up I mean some people think that's easy some people think it's hard I mean it just depends on what happens but the randomness of that aspect um well it was wasn't it because it's been a bit I think if they're standing you got their full effect if they were on their side you had like a half effect but if they were flat they did they did nothing because I feel like I remember there was like a worker that'd be like you get two points if it's standing you get one point if he's on his side I don't well this thing says standing mles work hard that day and provide special actions and building materials while face down mles provide nothing so yeah I think maybe face down they meant um like if they're actually flat yeah yeah yeah so I feel like you got a full if they were officially
standing up it's it's the randomness of that like you know and I mean maybe it's it's I'm trying to math it out in my head like dice you you know what you need to get you know like yeah and these it's like meeples and you're rolling them to try to stand you know I don't know it it was just weird I thought it was going to be a cool gimmick for it the game itself looks pretty cool when you're getting the city building and you're getting the skyscrapers built and stuff like that um so I actually found this game to be super fiddly because those tiles are so tiny and they want those stacks of like 15 [ __ ] blue cubes like next to each other it's like like the amount of times my friend accidentally knocked things over was I mean it was comical so like because I was like every time but it's super annoying yeah yeah it looks cool but it's like you almost need those um what that like old that game that old people play where you like push the disc across like the oh yeah shuffle board you like shuffle board thing like the sticks so you can just never actually touch it but just from a distance you can place those stacks of of Cubes um so yeah ultimately that's kind of the
thing I mean it the idea was there and rolling the meeples was its unique thing you know no other game does that to my knowledge and it just kind of I don't know just didn't work for me yeah that much no I agree was this on my is this on my list it's not it's not on my list but um no but yeah that's a good one that's a really good one number five nice my number four uh originally wasn't going to be on this list I actually had it as one of the best of the year and then we kept playing and then I took a break and then we went back and I was excited to play it again I was like oh cool I can't wait to see what happens and after the first scenario I was immediately over it but we kept playing and then we called it as a series because it got to to just it just has too many things against it than it has going for it but I can't put it at worst because it does have things going for it so my number four is kfire Chronicles nights fall now the way I'm probably going to talk about this game makes it seem like I hate it um um but it has all the issues I have with this game are immediately fixable
but the one thing I'm going to talk about is I like I like the world I like the characters um I like the storytelling I think that they definitely have something here and for some reason every single time I post a video they comment and they're super nice so I can't really dog on them too much it's like uh but we'll see what they say whenever they see our hourlong discussion um um and as far as I can tell this is this company's first game so they can definitely improve but kfire kind of suffers from a lot of like wanting to have your cake and eita too they want it to be very minimalistic but they want the aspect of a campaign of unlocking stuff but the problem is all the upgrades that you get for your characters are just super it's just more and more cards so you have this is okay I was like what why does this look weird this is on I think tabia yeah um but you have one of the things is like you get these random um packs that you get to unlock of bronze silver and gold and I kid you not every time you open those it's not exciting it's like oh more cards more [ __ ] put it in the you know the backpack because nothing ever feels like hey this is for me like they really want you to De construct ahead of time um but if you're just wanting to play the game it kind of just becomes more stuff and you're like well why would I put this
card in whenever everything that I already have is working um imagine if we were playing Gloom Haven you know how you have to have a certain number of cards in your deck for gloom Haven and when you level up you know five scenarios later it's like an excruciating like oh [ __ ] what do I want to put in this sounds really cool but what am I going to take out now imagine if in Gloom Haven you unlock stuff every game like every single time and eventually it just becomes meaningless so that was one thing the biggest thing that this game has against it is it has an initiative chitag of the players and the enemy so the enemy has actions on it that are like certain numbers are associated to a certain action it is entirely possible and has happened that the players can never go because every chip you draw is the enemy it's also entirely possible for the the enemy to never go so it's completely random and unbalanced and it's not exciting like it's not like oh [ __ ] what's it going to be like because in in um aon's end you know that random initiative deck where it's like okay like uh like let's hope we go because we can do some stuff but if the enemy goes we can do with we can deal with it but you know you're going to get to go eventually kfire does not have that
balance it has that just chit bag where it's like okay enem is going again and you lose every scenario if one person goes down so it's like it's it's so random and it's like if it was short and it wasn't a campaign thing whatever it's Unique I'm not against the chit idea but to to have it to where like I like one scenario like they have these condition cards where like they go into your hand and it's like oh whenever um you have to get rid of these you take a damage one scenario we were in I got a bunch of hurt cards in my hand and then we lost and it's like okay and it has a fail forward system where it's like you get to keep going you don't have to restart the scenario but it just it's so aggravating that and because of that you can never strategize because you never know who's going so you're like well like after like three or four scenarios I drew my hand of cards and set them aside because I like what the [ __ ] is the point I can't look at my hand and see what and you tell me what you have and we can be like okay if you go we'll do this if I go we'll do this because you just don't know you like I played this at three um like let's say you were playing a full four-player game completely Poss possible that two people never get to play it's like oh all my chips were drawn all that player chips were drawn you guys having fun it it just had it's so frustrating
but I like the story I like the world the city actions um can be fun and intriguing but all they need to do and I hope they take my discussion to like to heart if they want the chit idea make two bags make an enemy bag and a hero bag and have separate hero and enemy turns because if the heroes get to go you still know you're going to get to go but you don't know who's going to get to go and then when the enemy's turn goes you still know it's going to do something but you don't know quite what so you have imperfect information versus none at all yeah so that's uh those are the two major negatives for this game um like I said if they were to come out with another Chronicle like I mean it's called kfire like another like campaign thing and they made some major tweaks where it's not just here's a bunch of [ __ ] thrown at you and Randomness then I think they got something here I think that they have a very minimalistic cool world here um but those things just those suck they suck so bad so that's M number four can fire Chronicles all right so my number four is a game that I went into blindly and I because I had heard some people
talk decent about it and it ended up turning into a variation of a system of a game I don't like it's it has a pandemic Factor um and then it also has superheroes on top of it so and you know we talked about this before the the Marvel fatigue kind of stuff um so ultimately this one just kind of did not work for me and that is Marvel dagger oh okay um I went in this game thinking it was going to be its own thing um I you know obviously not really looking into it a whole lot come to find out it's a more convoluted pandemic clone um okay but even with more Randomness because there's die rolling to but you like the die rolling pandemic game well but this is this has a I mean you're going to location to location you're rolling dice to try to do a successful successful attack or Mission attempt so okay it it it almost kind of is a cross between the pandemic and like a let's say a Defenders of the realm you know like where you're rolling dice do different stuff but if you play this game with three or four players it's gonna take
three hours oh God it's a long ass game and I just like I said not going into it expecting a pandemic kind of thing and then having the randomness of the dice and then having uh it takes so damn pmic it's so long oh it even kind of looks like pandemic I know that's what I'm it because the cover does not because I I just it wasn't my game I played somebody else's they like hey you want marble dagger I looked at to cover I'm like yeah sure why not it's Marvel game I'll give it a shot and then we set it up and I was like this kind of looks like pandemic and then we start plan I'm like wait a minute you look at the Box you peel off Marvel dagger and it's pandemic well and then it uses eight-sided Dice and and you're rolling those to try to accomplish different things whether it's attacks or or Mission completion and the one thing I can say and its benefit is there's there's 20 Heroes um oh okay that you get to use they're double-sided though so like you know there's 10 hero cards but they're double-sided so you won't be able to use you know just both of them on C obviously but it's just there there's just too much luck and there's even a Threat Level I mean it's just like it's just like I mean it's pretty much is the pandemic thing you know and yeah kind like the epidemic level or whatever they
call it pandemic outbreak I think outbreak level yeah um so yeah this one was just one of those it was my fault for not looking into it more before I played it because if I would have seen what it was going to be like I wouldn't even have played it and then it wouldn't be on this list um yeah but uh but yeah just and and I think the biggest killer if this was a 60 to 90 minute game I probably live with it because it does have some different aspects but when it's a three freaking hour game that's just Bonkers and and you know so yeah I mean that's that's pretty much why it's here okay it's not the worst in the world I mean can tell you know like it it's it's one of those it's not a bad game inherently I mean if you like pandemic and you don't mind longer games you're gonna be okay with this you know but I'm not yeah I uh I mean I think I remember seeing this but I was like I don't care because one of those it was one of those Fantasy Flight games that they just like announced hey we can pre-order Marvel dagger it's our next awesome installment of our Marvel series and then shut up where's more Marvel Champions so anyway that's my number four right Marvel dagger cool cool cool my number three
is uh it's a game I'm not sure you actually have played um it has an IP that I think is fantastic and this out of this designer's repertoire of games of the three games of his I've played it is his best one but at the same time every game of his I've played it's like he just has weird decisions in it and this one I think is kind of one of a a good example of just Kickstarter bloat there's just a bunch of stuff to it that I don't think really adds a whole lot to the game um and I think I man what did I what did I give it hold on let me let me look it up I think they're actually going on to game found for another content thing yeah I mean I gave it a seven so it's like it has good elements but ultimately I was expecting more uh so my number three is Witcher the old world so this uh is a theme that is I mean fantastic The Witcher IP is is awesome and this is actually set hundreds of years I think before the geralt and all that so what is most popular this has nothing to do with it it's just tons of different witchers going out Monster hunting and I will say I got lucky from this because the original enemies that you would have to go fight were the most like not not generic but how you would
fight them like what you would like regular enemies you'd have to deal with as well as like the big trophies you're going after there was no Discerning difference from one another but whenever I played it we played with the expansion that actually makes the the trophy monsters you know dynamic and actually more exciting so uh which unfortunately if you don't have that then all the animates are just going to be the same and [ __ ] stupid but like if you f the Leon it would act a different like a Leon and if you fought like a fiend it would do things like that but in The Witcher um I mean you pick a school that you're going to be in I find the school traits be relatively similar yeah they have like a special power but they're I mean they're they're not that exciting like I never feel like I'm in a part of the bear school or part of the cat school like it's just kind of like yeah I'm I'm a Witcher but the fact that this is competitive is also odd because you can you're trying to get a certain number of trophies and you have to kill a monster to get the final trophy but you can get a trophy by defeating another Witcher you can get a trophy by yeah killing a you know killing a monster that you have to kind of move around the board to uh get potential tokens you don't have to but if you get those that helps you with um fighting it
um the thing about this game that I kind of like to your Marvel dagger point is this game is long and it's always long um and ultimately unless you're going to go out of your way to fight another player you have no reason to have a full player count you have no reason to have any of that because it's like you're doing your own thing which it makes sense thematically um and it is kind of a small deck builder but eventually you have to you always have to start getting rid of cards but you always have to buy Cards and the cards are kind of multi-use I mean they have like icons on them for your movement so each location has like a river or a mountain or a forest and that's how you just have to discard the card that um allows you to travel to that but they do this weird kind of color coding combination thing where instead of matching icons to one another like tainted Grail does they do cards or like hey this card can be combined with uh purple red and blue so if you have that in your hand then you can get combos off but you're not really deck building it's just kind of there you can only use certain number of potions in combat it's just like weirdly restrictive when it doesn't need to be money's super tight uh unless you go gamble um but if you also don't have any money then you're kind of hosed uh until
you can get some so just weird weird decisions that kind of made me never want to like kind of touch this game again um I mean the minis are awesome the production is good uh it does evoke The Witcher but what they also did which was kind of stupid as well is the event cards are they have different types different decks of events but they don't matter like it it doesn't matter where where you're drawing them from so it's not like you can only draw City events when you're in the city you can just be draw and it's just like okay which do you want to draw from because I remember first time playing this I was like does it matter and he's like no it's like why like why would you have a city event deck and a and a Wilderness event deck but then not delineate between the two I'm I think you just need to stop backing this company's games it's the guy balla you didn't like Titans you didn't like this you didn't didn't like um now I did back the one that just ended with The Witcher halfth of destinyy because it's it's the current Witcher so it has like Geral and yenifer and all those guys in it okay and it's like a card driven um type deal so I did go all in on that one because it looks really cool
yeah um but yeah I mean this one I stayed away from this one because I saw word competitive and I didn't it just seemed weird to me so I was like I didn't care for it yeah yep go on board as a publishing type and Lucas vosak is the um designer uh yeah Valhalla was whatever and Titans was glorified risk also weird because none of his games are like horrible right but it's just kind of like why did why did did no one play test this did no one give him any feedback that this is just kind of a little wonky um how did he get this IP anyway I don't know but well I'll tell you how he got the IPS because this this company and that Lucas they're polish oh yeah that's right where this is originated from The Witcher story yeah so yeah so I mean yeah it's it is kind of like it works for sure and like the decisions that they have in it aren't like gamebreaking but they're just kind of what's standing um away from me being like I actually want this in my collection too I'm fine never playing it again yep uh so yeah
that's my number three The Witcher old world all right so my number three is a game that was kickstarted several years ago um and it kept getting pushed back and kept getting pushed back and kept getting pushed back and it finally was delivered this year oh [ __ ] I I actually was gonna be backing it and I I decided not to a friend of mine backed it um and I'm glad I didn't because it just didn't work for me for all the time that they had it they could have been doing better stuff with it and that is oh this was on my anticipated list for two or three years in a row yep same um and I saw Antoine B Bowa being a person with it you I was like you know this it's gonna be pretty sweet you got always saw the pictures of like the the walled terrain you know like the walled tiles and all that ultimately there's nothing special about this game in my opinion ion there's it's it's just another Dungeon Crawl with little gimmicks thrown in and I think that's why it fell off right here um it just has the Egyptian theme is really is really it um because that looks cool yeah it looks cool but it's overly done you don't have I mean the walls and those whatever that I I can't
remember what they call those things like the little temply looking oh like the do yeah I mean yeah they just it It ultimately there was nothing unique about this game other than just the look the game was just very basic um you're just it's a campaign-based game so you're going through and doing all that junk um and it just ultimately just didn't work I mean it brings in the Egyptian stuff I mean you're going through and you're your pyramid diving watching for traps you know this and that fighting certain little monsters and crap like that but but uh I heard there like basically your actions were just super generic like yeah just move you only have like two actions on your turn yeah and and yeah it's just pretty basic I mean that's that's the thing with I I'm assuming what took so damn long for this to deliver was the component [ __ ] like the you know like I mean because the game itself Ian I don't see how they were done designing it in an afternoon well I mean and you know and with having Antoine Bowa on it I I was expecting something a little you know more and I
don't know if like they they were just trying to overproduce the component quality to make it unique in its own right but I mean it just I don't know it it was just one of those weird things I I was looking forward to this so much because I like the whole ancient Egypt stuff and yeah and all that but ultimately it was just basic I mean your comat and everything is just just basic I mean it's just your basic dungeon diver and you know yeah and it feels like when when this was slated to come out 202 I think gosh I can't remember stupid project was but um yeah I ended up selling my pledge to someone so good job uh right so I I guess I got lucky um well and and the weight the BG I mean take it for what it's worth but the weight on BGG is a 1.93 I mean which I mean to be fair some people need there do need to be lighter dungeon crawls no I agree but um they added to the cost because of the having the stupid walled tiles and crap it's like yeah if you're gonna do a game like this don't worry about that just put tiles out and play it it would have been cheaper you could have you know and all that stuff it would have probably got you don't need those right um like I'm trying to find on their page whenever it ended but I oh uh NOP that's
last updated hm I don't I don't know when it ended I can't find it on their page but I feel like this was like this would have probably done a lot better if it came out three years ago oh at least yeah games have changed so much since then so yeah um let's see four years ago it was at Gen Con in preview okay so because I mean even the game I just talked about kfire uh at least it has some different ideas that you can take that for what it's worth here it's like all right gonna move and apparently doesn't have that much replayability either well right exactly it's super super yeah I mean yeah and and yeah so yeah it it it kickstarted the kickstarter project ended four years ago is what I okay and and for now a game like you know I waited three and a half years or three years for my Shadows of Brimstone stuff there's a lot of damn content a lot of Minis and a lot of stuff like right I just don't understand why this one took that long to I'm still waiting on Madness so maybe pandemic slowed it down too who knows yeah yeah I'm still waiting on certain games that I mean it could just be smaller team but at least it
delivered yes yes exact I this one was one that I was like man like okay because I expected it to never ship so I sold my pledge and I was like good luck man um but they actually fulfilled and I was like oh man like a like because the Egypt theme that's never done anywhere uh but then as I started seeing reviews I was like good I'm glad I missed on that so fascinating okay my number two this one is equally disappointing hence why it's on this list because again I don't think this game is bad I actually think it's better than the other one that is on in this new Trilogy that they're making but I gotta say I'm really thinking this company and designer needs to kind of reel it back a little bit because this one just did not do it for me um and so my number two is Scholars of the South Tigers this South TIG Tigress series not doing it for me anymore I initially thought wayf fars was good and then I replayed it and I'm like I just feel aimless every in both of these games I just feel like I have no sense of direction this one does a little bit better actually Wayfair is is kind of like all right start picking [ __ ] uh Scholars at least gives you some s of um kind of a direction and it is a
cool idea where you are translating um different manuscripts uh from you know different types of languages to be able to fulfill objectives um I'll go to the picture because I'll be curious if it's if yes okay if you're color blind I'm [ __ ] sorry because like yeah the colors have different icons but man there are other elements that don't have icons I bet you this is a disaster to play if you are any type of color blind um but essentially what you're doing is you have action cards in your hand that you're placing on your player board uh to do various bonuses so not only do you have different colored workers that are not different from one another uh you have different color Dice and you have um yeah that was pretty much it different color workers different color dice uh and then you have the different colors and and they did like a a a color spectrum wheel to delineate um like combinations of colors because it's like you have your primary colors and you have your secondary colors and to do other actions you have to combine those colors uh so like if you wanted to do an orange action you you would need to do an action that was like also red and yellow to be able to get this orange
action it's interesting design like stuff you I haven't seen in any game before but man is this game kind of just a mess like so you get these you get these workers down at the very bottom those are your not workers um they're like your translators so you have like a little uh wooden piece on that to show that that one's yours and it can translate you know Greek into Hebrew and then you eventually need to make a uh a path from certain uh languages to get to the one that everyone's trying to get it to and I want to say it's uh Arabic but um I could be wrong there uh and so sometimes you have to place workers or pay resources on multiple people to eventually get the correct path to to get it to be able to be translated therefore you can fulfill it and get the get the benefits for that the other thing with this game is you have this weird area control section over on the those buildings the purple orange and green buildings and it's in over on the far right yeah those those are objectives that you can take to try and fulfill um or not take you could you can place them on there to try and fulfill them to get victory points but also you get benefits if you have the most of those tokens on those roofs this game is
just like get off get off the drugs and reel it back like it's like because VI counts and paladins I mean there's stuff going on but it feels self-contained this one just feels way too muddy to get any semblance of like a concept of what is happening um and wayf fars is is even worse like if there was like if people could kind of pick a kickoff point then I would have liked the concept of w far is a lot more but just the way that the mechanisms are done in both of these games and this one just never quite feels fluid like it does in the west Kingdom series even though Architects isn't one of my favorite of that I like it a lot better than these two um and then just the Translating thing just kind of gets old after a while uh because the people that you can hire up at the very top those can be put down and they could be new translators eventually translators will retire you tuck them under your board for a benefit um because you need oh and also by the way you're drawing dice that you roll um from a bag so you have a randomness of what you're drawing from a bag so it's just like like okay what if we had a game about translating and then oh and then there's a color wheel and
it's like whoa Shem like gez dude what are you okay and then like you know who I've always hated the color blind let's make all the colors in the world in this game it's like are we still talking about translating yes and then we'll throw in workers they'll be colored too it's like okay all right put the dude puts out a new game every year so yeah eventually he just needs to take his time a little bit more I think and it feels like that with this one or like let it cook a little bit play test it a little bit more just to be like ah this doesn't need to be here this feels like a little much can we simple like simplify it down um it I don't know I'm I'm obviously in the minority here again I have this at well I don't know what I have this this one at anymore uh Scholars yeah I mean I have it at out of seven and Wayfarers um of the South Tigress yeah I have it out of six but West King like West Kingdom uh paladins and yeah paladins is a nine VI counts is also a nine so that's kind of why with both those games being so high highly rated for me I'm kind of like oh he they can't do any wrong and then the South Tigers series
is kind of Fallen flat don't give a [ __ ] about the third one and then his other games that are like king nezareth or just his other uh themes that I've been seeing around I'm just like H yeah I hear you so that's my number two Scholars of the South Tigers all right my number two is a game that was probably of the games on this list was my most anticipated like my highest you know excited to play um and it falls at number two on this because it's a long game and Randomness is huge in this game so those two don't mix when that is true a long game with Randomness I love the the theme and I would still play this game even though it's disappointing it's just every time I've play I've played this game three times and every time I've played it because we played it with three or four one person just is having a horrible time and to me that just makes it not you know and that is distilled Yep this was my number seven really yeah and for the same reasons I'm assuming were was it the randomness for you probably uh yeah and it
just I now to be fair I've only played it once um really like the theme um but yeah the fact that you succeed or fail through shuffling your deck is stupid it's so stupid well yeah because you need certain components like you you know to make certain alcohols and if you can't find that one component and you're just sitting there you know and stuff coming up it's not that it's like you're just screwed yeah you know and stuff so yeah it's but yeah that's that's the main reason I mean it's a long game when you're playing with three or four people and then having that Randomness and and then adding the fact like I just said a second ago where every time I've played this there's been one person not having fun because of that Randomness yeah because it had some weird element uh where you had to like you had to add God what was it it was you either had to burn the top cards of like like the film of of like your deck or whatever it was supposed to be yeah yeah or you had to add cards I can't remember which one it was but like you basically do something weird with your deck uh before you could even start processing and it's like obviously I'm not a spirit maker um but I go to quite a few distilleries where there were people who were and it's a very meticulous process that this game
for some reason just wanted to be like yeah actually sorry you just didn't get you didn't get it you put it you you wanted you aged it and then it's like all right hopefully you made it yeah um yeah I just I also wasn't as enamored with this game as I thought that I would thought that I would be yeah I was pumped for it like I I was like okay this would be awesome you know the art was cool you know I I thought it was going to be a really sweet game and like I said it's not inherently a bad game you know that's why but it's just having that those two things that Randomness and the length of play just do not are not a good combination yeah I mean this is a theme that I think would kill in like a vetle sort of worker placement style like almost like a con Bon kind of like where it's autom manufacturing but now it's about Spirit making that like that theme I'd go for like because I like the Aging concept like how you had to have certain things and like a better casket uh and you can you know hedge your bets and then have it age longer to get more victory points um but yeah it felt like there was just a few too much Market stuff of items and caskets and and glassware and all that so that was just a bunch of just stuff coming out uh I did like the clipboard element
yes of like what you can build or build what you could brew and and make that that was of variable um and I also like that it had different a bunch of different types of spirits from all over the world and different workers and stuff so it has good elements here but I agree with you I think the length and the randomness of shuffling your deck to draw and hope you distilled correctly it's like that is so against like sometimes you play a game and it's like well that doesn't really like Sky Team for example that does why can't the co-pilot and pilot talk to each other well we wanted to make a game okay okay fair but here it's like well you made a decision that seemed to go completely against your theme that doesn't quite work yep so yeah because I remember playing it uh I never did a review for this because I didn't get it played uh past the first time um but we had the same issues with the shuffling of the of the ingredients and the drawing and it's like oh sorry you failed yeah so and I didn't really I was like I think again this is another seven which I know to a bunch of people is um trash Oh No I gave it a six sorry so which is slightly above average in on my
ranking scale uh seven is um kind of like in the good category but it just depends like this one I felt nothing right yep so that's my number two then we'll you know there's an expansion I think Tom and talked about for it so I don't know what that'll do but we'll see yeah who knows it goes on Kick yeah maybe yeah if it goes on Kickstarter I'll at least give it a give it a look give it the old Gander yeah all right my number one and I'm very curious if it's your number one or if it's on another list uh this was very easily going to be my disappointed because is I very much love the game that this is based on the world that it is in um is absolutely outstanding in terms of its artwork uh but boy this game could not be the more mid than I have ever seen uh I think what hurts it the most is calling it a sequel yep I think we have the same I think we have the same thing we might my number one is boom that's my number one too is it okay yeah probably for different reasons but um well so I actually tried the solo variant for this too um the calling it a sequel to Scythe
is the most cash grab thing and he just for some reason never understands what to put on his [ __ ] box don't don't say tapestry a civilization game because it's not that don't say Expeditions a sequel to Scythe because it's not that they're not related in any way except artwork um the way this game plays is so whatever like I like the people who are kind of like talking about this game I'm like have you played like literally anything else cuz this game is so bare bone I don't find this game all that interesting in fact this is I mean since it's number one on disappointing it's inching closer to worse but it functions and it has some neat ideas the multi-use cards of the you know depending on where you want to put them around your board for its resources or for its special power for its like multi multiplicative effect meteor stuff that can be cool the mechs when they're like I cuz I the metal ones are [ __ ] badass in design the art is Stellar but man I just find this game so boring yes so why is it your number one well I mean that for that reason too I see I went into this because I I'm not a scythe person I don't like Scythe anyway so that wasn't going to be a reason it was
disappointed I I went in expecting you know a scyth kind of thing thing but what disappointed me was knowing what I know about Scythe to having the weird Supernatural angle in this seemed weird um and then of course like I said I only I didn't play anything but the base game of Scythe so I don't know if Supernatural stuff starts creeping in on that last the the campaign final expansion for Scythe or what I don't think it did right I I and I no clue but but the supernatural stuff kind of took me out of it on this plus the randomness of the tiles you know because you being faced down and having to um I know you can you have to move eventually but like you can block places for people um the Tableau building is fine but yeah um being able to spam locations too you can just kind of go back bounce around and go back and do those powerful abilities if you happen to be where you're at and get lucky last to tile that has whatever you need on it that last one I can't remember yeah there's like a tile that like if you clear it off you get one of your stars to put down and it's like man where is that someone could just find it and you're like oh hey thanks and then
you can have the resources to go clear it um I also really hated the fact that placing Stars down was an action was a tile you had to go look for to drop them and set them just automat it's like why why extend this game any longer um yeah I mean the card use is interesting I don't think you need to tuck it around your board but this game is this game is weirdly a table hog as well that I find kind of annoying even though I have a table that can fit any game I want to play it's like this game doesn't justify it being a table hog as it is uh the player or the solo variant was again whatever you just had two mechs that would kind of loop around certain sections of the map and that was kind of it yeah I I really don't find anything about this game particularly exciting yeah um and I'm actually all for the supernatural thing kind of being thrown in I think that's a nice twist but again it's is not done in any way this would that would have worked much better in Scythe when you have the encounter cards that at least you get some depiction of a story and your options are related to what you're seeing this doesn't have any of that and so yeah it was just very meh yeah yeah this is as meh of a game as I've played all all year of kind of uh and to add insult to injury Scythe was
my favorite game um for years uh and to call it a sequel It's like oh [ __ ] what's it GNA add nothing gameplay related to Scythe except you place Stars when you complete objectives y um yeah this this is the one game out of all the games that we've talked about this is the one that blows my mind that people say they really like I know and I think like Scholars I'm like I get it like I can see why that would work for you um Witcher kfire Legacy maybe not kapow but that was more of a dishonorable mention all of those if they were like that was my favorite game of the year I'd be like okay but here like they're like oh it's so [ __ ] good and then they'll like try to explain it you you can play cards to the side of your board it's like is that wow you move your Mech it's probably the people spent the money on the Ironclad Edition and they just don't want it to be bad since they I guess but even the iron CL Edition wasn't all that expensive you know that there's probably going to be expansions to this too yeah but yeah that that one was an obvious duh to be number one Yep this my first one I put on the list same same all right well that is our top five disappointing games of 2023 let us know what games were disappointing for you in the comments
below and let us know what you think of these games also in the comments other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you heyone thank you for watching and I really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever I upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run throughs or reviews or cool top 10 or whatever I feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you