Skip to main content
Loading video...

Variety Vlog March 2016: Mystic Vale, 5 Families, Firenze and more!

Transcript 24:10

welcome to John gets games this is my variety Vlog for the month of March and I'm going to be covering several different topics as well as a bunch of different games so let's jump right into it the first thing I'd like to cover is General channel news and updates and honestly nothing big happened over this last month it was just a nice steady month for the channel I got six videos out which is really nice the subscriber and viewer accounts were a little under February but still doing really good better than I've ever done before as long as you don't count February and uh one big thing is that on my patreon uh page I now have 23 supporters which is more than I've ever had that comes out to about 60 a month when you take out uh fees and all that kind of stuff and I've actually raised just shy of 600 on patreon over the last eight or so months which is really awesome I've used that to buy T-shirts and uh to buy more games so I can cover them on the channel so I'm excited with how well the patreon is doing and I'm looking forward to seeing where that one goes in the future so I think that pretty much sums up where the channel is let's now jump into the next section and that would be questions and answers although I only got one question over this last month and that was from Spencer Kellis he asked me what are the best game mechanisms that are either fresh and new or at least recently revitalized this is a really big question it's a really good question I'll do my best to answer it from my personal perspective and I did a good bit of thinking about this and I am not able to come up with something new that you probably haven't heard before realistically the biggest thing in new mechanisms in board gaming is narrative storytelling as you're playing the game you know the pandemic legacies and the time stories and above and below that

also came out last year these are games that have good mechanisms behind them but are really all about getting you into a story much more than just reading the first paragraph in the rule book trying to figure out oh what you're supposed to be doing and then jumping into the mechanics of your standard game and I really like that but there are a couple other mechanisms that I've seen get much better over the last year or so it's certainly much more prevalent I don't know if they're necessarily new but one of those is nice pool drafting actually just pool drafting in general I've talked about this on my channel channel before so I am being a bit of a broken record here but you have games where you either roll dice and put them in the middle of a table and people grab from that pool or you maybe deal out a bunch of cards and I love that mechanism and it seems like more and more games are doing that uh especially last game I haven't necessarily seen a swath of those for uh 2016 that have really jumped out at me but in 2015 you had things like uh Elysium you have my Village you've got seven wonders duel and a bunch of others that I cannot come up with off the top of my head and I just love having the randomness of what the dies are rolled or what the cards are that show on the middle of the table but then you can only take specific ones then you have to figure out what your opponents want it's just a wonderful mechanism so to sum it up I think that great thematic storytelling with uh narrative uh gameplay mechanics is a really big thing recently and then just pool drafting in general I love how big those two things have gotten in board games and I'm excited to see the games that come out in the future that really utilize those if you've got a question

you'd like me to answer on next month's variety blog please email it to me at John getsgames gmail.com or send it over on Twitter or Facebook or comment on this video if there's a whole bunch of ways you can get that question over all right now it's time to talk about a game that I'm really excited about and that would be Mystic Veil I had not heard about this game at all until about two weeks ago when the coverage for the gamma trade show started going through and I started seeing pictures of it and I got really intrigued immediately because in this game you have a bunch of transparent cards where only a small section of the card has printed text or graphics on it and what you're doing is you are crafting cards as you're playing the game by stacking multiple of these transparent Cards into a sleeve so that certain sections show up on the different cards so in the beginning of the game you I believe start with 20 cards and many of them are completely blank they're just a card in a sleeve but as you're playing the game you buy more of these cards and you slide it in and you will overlap these cards on top of each other so by the end of the game you might have like three or four cards stuck into a single sleeve that is in your deck and you never add more cards to your deck you were just constantly improving the cards and they've got engineer stuff on it to like get points for doing this or that they've got lots of of buying power to let you buy more cards to upgrade the previous cards you have but they also have Decay symbols on them where if you draw too many of them in this push your luck style at the I believe beginning of your turn or maybe right at the end well that doesn't matter if you draw too many of them you bust essentially and you get to do much less on your turn so the big reason I'm excited about this is the card crafting

idea that is a new mechanism I haven't seen that before there I've definitely been games with transparent cards in the past but usually that's been from a thematic art standpoint where it like kind of like looks cool but from this perspective you are literally you need these cards to be transparent so you can look through the top two and see the text printed on the one that's um you know three cards down and that is just fascinating that when you add into the fact that I really enjoy push your luck games in general and engine building games this one has me super intrigued it might end up not working for some reason or another because it is such a new mechanic but I've got to give this one a try it's getting me really excited and I also heard that Mystic Veil is the first game using this mechanism but they are actively working on a more complicated game using that mechanism that'll be coming out a year from now so it almost seems like Mystic Veil is a a tester for the market like they're gonna put this out see how the mechanism Works maybe even see how it bounces out and use that as like a really big published game version of prototype play testing of a mechanic mechanic that will be in a bigger game later on and they can make sure that it works better for that either way I'd love to give this one a shot I'm pretty excited about it all right now let's talk about the games of note that I was able to play over the last month uh specifically these are the ones that I feel like I have more than usual to say about or they were special for one reason or another so let's start it off with the Legacy expansion so this is the five families expansion to Legacy The Testament of Duke crazy and I gave that a favorable review last year it's a interesting worker placement slash Tableau building game where you start

off as the head of a family and you go through three different Generations ending the game with I believe great grandchildren and as you are marrying people into your family and having kids you are kind of building an engine they will play off each other based off of their different nationalities it's a neat little Euro game so what the expansion does is it gives the game five different asymmetric um families that you get to play It's called five families right but it was an interesting take on asymmetry because usually when you think about an asymmetric faction in a board game it will let you do something for cheaper or maybe give you a special ability uh that you can use throughout the whole game but the way this expansion works is that it gives you a deck of cards which are your cousins as well as maybe some decrees and special actions and after every single turn you draw three of them and then you pick one and you have to offer it to all of your opponents and if none of them take it then then you get to use it so it's a little bit weird you have this asymmetric deck but you have to give the opportunity to your opponents but if they want that card they have to pay you in favor tokens and then you can spend these favor tokens to get bonus actions as you're playing the game which might let you take two turns in a row get special bonus actions or maybe you can just take money or friends from that person who gave you the favor essentially cashing in on those favors so it's a really interesting thematic twist that particular part of the game I was able to play this once it was a three player game now the two other people I played with had never played Legacy at all before so it was a little bit of a slow experience and I don't want to blame the expansion for that at all I liked the idea of these cards but

it felt a little bit clunky in that after every single turn you had to do this pull three cards decide which one and then offer to all of your opponent's thing I like where it's going and I don't have a definitive opinion on it yet I definitely want to play this a couple more times before I will have one but it seemed like it might not be worth the extra amount of time that it added into the game but oh I'm really conflicted because I like the idea of it the other thing that this game brought in is um birth events so if you know anything about Legacy the base game you have these complications at Birth uh cards that can happen when you're having kids and you never know if it's gonna happen and if it does happen then either the baby or the mother dies and you have to decide which one it's a very dark thematic aspect to the game that also puts interesting decisions into the game where you need to decide how badly you want that kid and if the mom dies well do can you remarry and there's all sorts of stuff that goes along with that in the expansion you get rid of all those complications of birth cards and instead you put these 20 or so birth event Cards into the deck and these are interesting because they actually have a different back side to the card so when the top card on the the kids deck is this other kind of side you will know you're about to go into a birth event and most of them are not good or bad they're very neutral they will almost always cost you something but if they cost you something they will almost always get you something as well you might get kind of a bonus action but you lose some money or a victory point or two or that kind of thing and the great part about it is they're very thematic it's like your the father gets drafted to go to war or suddenly you have there's a long lost sister to your family who says that they are part of your family and what do you do with that there are a bunch of

different ones and I love the Thematic twist that they bring into the game and I liked the complications of birth mechanism in the base game but I really like this um thematic twist with having the birth events I think it's less painful especially if you draw them early in the game and uh yeah I just really like that addition to the game in general the expansion also brings in some new asymmetric end game goal cards which I like so in general I have a favorite favorable opinion of the expansion so far I do want to get it played a couple more times specifically with players who have played the base game already so I can really judge to see how those different uh family decks uh turn out the next game I want to talk about is a bit older it came out in 2010 and that's forensic this was picked up by a good friend of mine at a board game auction last year and I finally got to play it just this last month and I really liked several of the things that are going on here automatically what you're doing is building Towers in Italy I believe and mechanically there are several very cool things going on first of all you have an action draft row where you have a bunch of cards that have personalities on them or maybe events and they all go in a row and it gets more expensive to grab the ones later on the row well we've seen that 100 times board games as you pick out the cards they get cheaper okay well we've seen that 100 times as well but the interesting part about it is it has an incentivization structure for making it more painful to take the later on cards because what happens is the resources in the game come in the form of these colored Tower tokens that kind of stack on top each other because you're trying to build towers well every card that comes out on the road is going to have four random Towers put on it but

if you want to buy a card that is farther down the road than the most left you have to put a resource of your choice down on every single card that you skip so each card that you skipped is going to get an extra resource and it will incentivize those cards being taken by other players more as the game goes on some of these cards are just bad they're just really not good for you like a warehouse fire or something like that you're gonna lose stuff but as people avoid doing that they put more and more things on top of it to the point where there will be enough resources on there that it'll be worth it to the person to take the bad event penalty to get all these resources and I love that in pretty much all board games I love it when you take an action in the things that weren't taken get more incentivization stacked on top of it but this adds an extra layer with the player being able to choose what kind of resources to put down on there oh really really cool stuff but then when you also look at the other side of the game it's kind of an area majority thing where you were building these towers and then putting scoring tokens down on these towers on the main board that show you how many points you get and once somebody builds like a four level green Tower then nobody else can and you need to build a level three or level five Tower and the bigger the tower the more points you're going to get but it has a really cool idea where you need to spend uh resources in order to build these towers up and if you ever have a tower that is currently being built up and you don't add anything onto it on a turn that whole Tower gets destroyed which is a really painful thing when I first was taught the rules I thought that sounded really bad but it I think only happened once or twice in the game but what it means is you really have to plan ahead and decide will I have the ability to

get another Green Block to put it on there or do I just cash out now and get some points so I think I've talked about this one enough I am really interested in it I want to try this one again I have no idea how much it is out there I don't really need to buy it because a really good friend of mine owns it but it's got some fascinating stuff going on some things that I really enjoy in board games and if you haven't heard about it before I would strongly recommend you at least look into it a little bit if any of this sounds appealing at all next up is a very new game this is Kodama the tree Spirits which just came out I think I got it last week from the kickstarter fulfillment and in this game you are growing a tree by placing Branch cards down onto a main trunk that you start with and it has a really cool idea in that you kind of organically Branch these trees out you don't put the cards so that they're butting each other like in an orthogonal or diagonal perspective you overlay them in a almost haphazard way so that the tree organically grows in different directions based off of the decisions that you're making as you're playing the game the gameplay itself is really simple you're gonna Place 12 branches down onto your tree before the end of the game and once you place four branches you'll put a secret scoring card down you have a Hidden Hand of cards with some tree spirits and they are kind of guiding you in different ways for how you're going to build your tree the one might say I'm going to give you four victory points for every car that's touching your base trunk of your tree another one might say I'm going to give you two victory points per symbol of these two symbols whichever one's less that kind of stuff which will guide how you are grabbing these branches and putting them down on your tree there is a basic scoring kind of set collection thing where you're trying to get consecutive runs of different symbols on your branches so like disregarding the

those um secret scoring cards and all that you were just trying to get like all your little glow bugs to match up and all your little mushrooms to match up because that's going to give you points as well so mechanically I like pretty much everything that's going on in this game like when I just look at it and I read the rules it's like this looks like a really fun little game and so we played a four player game of it uh just last weekend and it did not go over amazingly well it was a bit of an average lukewarm experience for everyone on the table I think I enjoyed it more than most of the other players and there was the reason for this was a perceived imbalance issue with those hidden cards that get dealt out at the beginning of the game everybody gets four of these cards that's all you're gonna get and you're gonna play them three times during the game now I'm not saying that there isn't a balance between the cards but there was a perceived one and that perception of imbalance really tanked the impression of the game for a couple of people around the table who were really trying to do the best they could with the cards they had and then we would all reveal our cards and they would score like maybe five or six points and then myself and another player would score like 15 or 16 points and and after that happened twice they said let me see the rest of your cards we kind of all showed all of the cards we looked around the table and they were like oh my gosh I didn't even know there were cards that had four points per whatever it is even on them and we looked at their cards and it really didn't seem like they had a tougher Hill to climb in order to get similar points to what we were getting now I've only played the game once so this is not a condom nation of balance in the game it might be very well balanced but that perception of the imbalance they are made those players who felt like they got really much worse starting hands they just had a much less

fun as they were playing it because they felt like they were trying a lot harder to get to where we were at and the person who won was um not me it was a person I left who also seemed to get really high power cards and then I took second place and those two other players were a little bit farther behind so I'm looking forward to giving this one more plays because I really do like the ideas that are in the game I am curious to see how the balance of those hidden uh tree Spirit cards will play out as I'm playing the game I'm honestly a little surprised that the game doesn't have like a hand drafting uh variant even where you get your four cards and then you choose one and pass it so that you can have the players around the table do a little bit of self-bouncing as well but anyway I think I've talked about this one enough it's a really neat beautiful looking game on the table and I'm looking forward to getting more tries of the game to see how it plays with more experiences next up is troll which is another push your luck game from oink games they're the people who made uh Deep Sea Adventure which is The Pusher luck game as well as fake artist goes to New York and a whole bunch of other games that all come in these adorable little boxes they come from Japan and uh I've enjoyed the experience I've gotten out of those little boxes before and I was happy to see that Victory Point Cafe in Berkeley California had a copy to play so that I could try it without spending another like 30 35 on it I enjoy these games but they do seem a little expensive to get them shipped over to California so in this um push your luck game what you are is thieves trying to get gems out of a cave before the trolls come and smack you down and cause you to not get in gems you are trying to steal the most gems you can and it has a really cool mechanic where people are bidding a

certain number of I guess gems that they're going to steal out of the cave and I suppose thematically the more gems you get the slower you are so I might put like a two down and then the person on my left might put three and the next person might put a five and then at the end of the round once everybody's put a chip down you add up all those numbers but you go sequentially so you would start with me and you say two and then you'd go to the next person they have a three so you add those together you get five and at this point you flipped over you know what the troll value is let's say it's a six well five is less than six that's fine but you go to the next player who put a five down and you five plus five is ten you've gone over six and that person who caused the value to go over the threshold for the troll they get smacked down they don't get any gems at all and the people who are underneath get to run away scot-free with the gems it has a interesting thing going on though where the first person who chooses a number gets to know what the troll is they get to peek and see what it is and then choose a number and everybody else has to make a decision they either do a cowardly move where they also look at the troll and then they choose a tile or they could not look at the troll put a tile down and if they're able to get out of the dungeon they will get double the amount of points for doing that and I really like how all this came together it's a neat little game that comes in this little box and there's a whole bunch of decisions there it's got push your luck and it's also got bluffing because one person looks at the thing and they put a tile down maybe maybe they're trying to goad people into doing big numbers because they put a big number down they figure oh the troll must be a 13. maybe it's not maybe the troll is like a five and they put their four down knowing that they'd be safe but nobody else would so a little bit of Mind Games going on here and I was really impressed

with it I don't know if I'll run out to buy a copy of it but I am looking forward to giving it more plays at that Board Game Cafe at Victory point and uh we'll see what I end up doing I I might end up snagging a copy of this if I'm able to find it for like 20 or less at some point in the future all right now we've got above and below which was a Kickstarter that came out last year that I ended up not backing because I was a little worried about it and unfortunate enough to be able to play the copy that they have at Victory Point Cafe um really enjoy being able to play these games without having to buy them before I can try them and this is a pretty cool game I really enjoyed my one play of it where in this game you have these your way things going on where you have these villagers in your village and you are going to get new villagers and the villagers will build buildings the buildings will give you abilities that might make certain actions more lucrative or unlock new actions there's a whole bunch of kind of engine building things that you're doing there but then you can send your Villages down into the caverns below your village and you will do a Choose Your Own Adventure style thing you will roll a die and then somebody gets out this big book and they flip to like number 195 and then they read you a little story they might tell you about a crotch of the old man that you see wandering off to the distance do you chase them down or do you just ignore them and go in a different direction and based off of your decision you will end up rolling dice to see how successful you are you're the villagers you send down there will have different modifiers some of them are just better at exploring than others I suppose and then you will get benefits from it the the benefits that you get are not terribly thematic you usually don't have a great end to the story if you chase down the old man or something like that you might I don't know squeeze some

money out of them and then you just get a resource it doesn't have a great narrative ending to it usually you just get a resource or two but I thought it was really a neat thing going on the game definitely seemed to be motivating you to get lots of villagers and then to do lots of exploration to really enjoy that aspect of the game where you're like reading out the thing and sometimes you might be reading a story and you're like no no don't open the thing but if you open it up Suddenly you expect it to be bad and now it's a good thing and to a certain degree there's a replayability issue there because if you play it again and you happen to get to that same exact narrative in the book you will know how it goes but man there are a lot of entries in that book so I don't think that'll happen anytime soon uh all in all I was really impressed with the game it has beautiful art which is not surprising this is from Red Raven games all of their games have this similar art aesthetic because they are designed design published and illustrated by the same man uh Ryan Lockett and uh so I just like the consistency that you see with the art styles through all of their games and I think I enjoyed this one more than any of his other games that I played like eight minute Empire and empires of the Void this was a really good experience I look forward to giving it a shot again and now for the last game that I'll be covering and it's a little bit of an old one as well this is Thebes the tomb Raiders I got the kickstarter for this I think about a year and a half ago and it's technically a card game version of another game called Thebes which came with the same Kickstarter but I really like the card game version of it what you're doing in this game is your archaeologists trying to excavate and find cool stuff in the ruins of like the pyramids and ancient Greece and all that kind of thing what you are doing in the game though mechanically is it has this time track

Action System which I really enjoy in games where everything you do costs time and you go around a circular track displaying that and whoever is follows back on time takes their turn so you if you take really efficient turns and you're quite far back you you could take several turns in a row or you could spend a bunch of time do a big thing and then probably skip out on several different turns it's a really cool decision that you have there and what you're doing in the game is you're getting more knowledgeable about the four different dig sites and the more knowledgeable you are the less time you need to spend in order to get more stuff out of Excavating them so it has this great build up as you are getting more and more knowledge which comes in the um the the form of these little book cards that you put in front of you and then once you say have like seven or eight knowledge in the purple you say all right I'm gonna go dig on the purple site you have to spend a contract in order to do that you only get one of each of these for each of the zones in a game but you could buy more later and then you say how much time you want to spend but between like 1 and 12 weeks which are you know essentially each time increment is one week and then you draw that many random cards from the stack of um potential uh Gems or also potential like rubble and all the ones that are not Rebel are Victory Point cards that you get to keep and then you can end up curating them into a museum or put on exhibitions there's a bunch of different things you can do here in the game and I've played it several times now and I've really enjoyed it every time I played it definitely brings across this archaeologist digging kind of finding Vibe as you're playing the game like you could do an early excavation if you want

to try and get in there and be the first to potentially get those really big victory Point cards but you will probably only be drawing two or three cards and spending a bunch of time but if you wait then once you have like maybe eight or ten knowledge in that section you might spend much less time and draw way more cards and have a much better shot at getting really good stuff now there is Randomness here you could draw really poorly you could draw six cards and they could all be Rubble that's really unlikely to happen but it definitely could happen which thematically does kind of make sense if you're just digging into the ground doesn't matter how much you know about that spot you might just dig in the wrong area so I think that that is forgivable the game only lasts a little over an hour so it doesn't really overstay its welcome especially if you end up running into a bunch of bad luck anyway I I suggest you give this one a look if you haven't heard of it before I never actually played the thieves board game but I've read the rules and honestly I just like the look of the card game much better it's a much smaller package and it seems to do the same thing so yeah I really enjoyed playing the game I'm looking forward to just continually getting that one out every month or two going forward so that wraps up this variety Vlog again if you have any questions you'd like me to answer in future Vlogs please comment down below or email it over to John getsgames gmail.com and I will put it into the next Vlog so if you'd like to see more videos like this one as well as in-depth board game reviews and full game playthroughs please subscribe to my channel also you can directly support the channel at patreon.com John getsgames thanks for watching

Progress saved