Top 10 Direct Conflict Games
Transcript
Hey, I'm Jamie from Stone Meer Games and I have something special to share with you today. Today's video is in the greater scheme of things is about my top 10 or a top 10 list of direct conflict games.
However, this is also there's a meta element to this video because I've decided that I would like to add what I would call a combative panelist to the Stommyer Games. Um, a range of panelists for these videos. We have a solo panelist, we have a family gamer panelist, we have a digital gamer panelist, and a heavy gamer panelist. These are four categories that I I go into a little bit from time to time, but they aren't my wheelhouse. And so I wanted to better represent them on this channel. Hence why I have these panelists who are so good at replying succinctly week to week when I send them prompts. But one element missing, one other element missing for that is that I don't play a lot of games that are uh combat focused, that have uh negative player interaction, that have uh direct conflict throughout the game. And so I thought why not add a combative panelist to our our uh to the YouTube channel. So um I reached out to Stillmire Ambassadors and I and asked if anyone would be interested in being a panelist for this and 12 people replied. And so I thought let's create a battle royale type situation where I will pro give them a prompt. I have prompted them with a question of what is your favorite game with direct conflict and uh I thought that we could determine based on the results of this video or at least partially who should be the next um the combative panelist at least the one that we start with. This might change over
time. Now I will say there were 12 people who responded yes only 10 actually sent me their pick. So that was one way to eliminate two different people. they've been 10 two people have already been eliminated because they didn't reply. Um I hope it wasn't a spam folder issue but uh that that happens. Um the other part is I did ask them to stick to three to five sentences and so I I won't stick to that too strictly but I do appreciate when panelists are succinct um with their picks because uh it does add extra time to the video. that is uh a part of what I am considering here. And what I'd like you to consider is uh both the games that they picked. Um if you'd like to hear more from a person who likes the type of game that they picked and I'm going to read verbatim what they sent to me. And so if there is uh one or two potential panelists here whose uh descriptions of their game you really appreciate, you like that the way that they phrase their perspective on these games. let me know that in the comments and uh maybe I will have that factor into my decision of who becomes the combative panelists. All of them know that I'm doing this. Uh they they they signed up for this because they are combative gamers. So, let's jump in and start out with the one game.
And I did actually because so one thing that happened here, 10 people replied and there were several duplicate responses. And so, I filled out the top 10 list with a few other games that I really enjoy. And I ranked them based on how much I enjoyed these games. And so, there is one game on the list that I have not played. This is Rifle Squad. And obviously, I won't be saying the names of the panelists yet because none of them are actually panelists. These are just potential panelists. So, here's what uh a person wrote about Rifle Squad. Rifle Squad: The British Home Guard is a midheavyweight war game that is based upon events in World War II that never happened. Namely, the planned German invasion of Britain. Players take the role of a commander of British home guardsmen. Think school teachers, grocerers, laborers who are past their prime fighting years, but prepared to defend their homeland. pressed into service in in middle age to defend portions of the English coast from an airborne and amphibious assault by the German military. I selected this game because it captures two elements of war fighting that I respect as a formal former intelligence officer. The fog of war and the randomness of combat. The game rewards solid planning and pre-eployment of inadequately supplied in manned rifle squad. You are absolutely outmatched. Victory is impossible and all you can hope for is to survive long enough to give White Hall time to mount a real response. You are routinely surprised by aerial attacks and unforeseen enemy troop deployments and movements based upon combat doctrine and ice rolls. Your only
advantage being knowledge of the local terrain. That is the description of Rifle Squad, the British Home Guard. At number 10, at number nine, we have Twilight Imperium Fourth Edition. And we had one potential panelist say the following. I've selected this title because of how complex and intertwined conflict is throughout each game. Many games provide opportunity for player versus player combat with each side amassing armies and positioning them properly to thwart one one another's advances. What makes conflict in TI4 so incredible to me is this style of direct com combat is only one facet of conflict over the arc of the game. More often than not, conflict instead arises via trade disagreements, the forming of en enemy alliances that threaten your own position, non-binding agreements as to the timing of army movements to facilitate scoring opportunities, voting certain ways on impactful agendas, and other more typical soft power engagements. The ripples of each player's interactions echo through the remainder of the game and inform every subsequent decision, all amplified by the sheer complexity and diversity of potential justifications that stem from a game with as many components and a symmetry playing out over such a long duration.
That is Twilight Imperium 4 as number nine. At number eight, we have arcs. And two people chose arcs. The first person, this is arcs part one, said, "I've received mixed responses to arcs from my different gaming groups. Some feel it is too random. Some feel the luck of the draw is too powerful. Others dislike the ambiguous starting additions and the inability to decipher what the best initial [clears throat] move may be. But that is exactly why I love it. In True Conflict, your road is not spelled out for you, the decisions often unclear, and the rules for victory varying over time. You must adapt to win in a greater conflict game and arcs delivers that experience to my table. The second person who chose arcs says, I chose arcs because it is one of those games where I am always watching what everyone else is doing. It is its trick- taking system constantly forces you to adapt and plan in the short term, which creates so much tension to pick the right fights. At the same time, you have to avoid painting a target on your back for taking an obvious lead in an ambition while trying to deny other players from scoring that other ambition other missions and not creating a rivalry that lasts for the rest of the game out of revenge. That combination of calculated risk, table politics, manipulation, and very human grudges makes every game of arcs feel like its own memorable space opera. Combine that with a blighted reach campaign and you get a larger evolving story in which the consequences of those conflicts, alliances, and grudges follow you from one game to the next. That is Arcs at
number eight. At number seven, we had two people choose Routt. At number seven, here's the first one. In route, every ounce of control you have over the map matters, and you must carefully manage how you place and disperse your limited supply of warriors, buildings, and tokens. When you battle, the outcome affects you and your opponent in very different ways, and the game is very asymmetric. As the attacker, you must be careful how strongly you attack the defender. If you remove too many of their buildings, you open a potential opportunity for your opponent to replace them on a future turn to outscore you on the victory point track. If you don't remove enough of their war enough of their warriors, you might forfeit control of that portion of the map. As the defender, you might choose to leave your warriors unprotected in one clearing so that they get removed, allowing you to recruit them elsewhere on the map. How strongly you defend can have a drastic effect on the attacker's progression as well as your own. Sometimes you might manage to go through an entire turn without affecting any of your opponents, and that's part of the fun, too. Lastly, each player also plays with a unique faction, so they each have their own general way of affecting their opponent's games as well as their own.
The second person to choose Root says this. With heavy asymmetry and a heavy focus on area control, Root has players racing to 30 points. Table Talk is a must for this game, and if you get too far ahead in the game, your opponents will conspire together for your demise. Even though the combat mechanism is rolling dice, there are plenty of cards to help you mitigate your defeat. My group loves this game because even if we're trying to defeat each other, at the end of the game, we laugh and summarize where things went wrong, what went right or wrong for us, and how we can use that information for the next game. That is root at number seven. At number six, we have uh my first addition to the list. This is Kmet. KT is a I believe it plays up to five players. It is a tight map where you uh primarily are engaging in combat with the other players. There is also a strong sense of Euro style engine building. There's a bunch of tiles on the table and you can choose which tiles you want like tiles that improve your ability to fight. Tiles that give you special units that only you have like these these uh like this elephant, this uh this giant snake. Um, there are upgrades that make you better at the economy in the game because there is a uh some action points that you're you're spending to to on your turn to take different actions. Um, but what I love about the combat the combat in particular, I am always wary in combat driven games about choosing who to fight and when to fight and uh sometimes, you know, I don't want a player to feel picked on. I also don't want to feel picked on. But in Kemet, the map is so
small. It's designed so that everything is pretty much within the same range as one another. And um when you fight someone and it you're probably both going to lose units. One of the resources that that you play around with in combat using these cards is how many units the opponent will lose. So you can win combat and still lose a bunch of units. And when you get those units back, there's a little piece of compensation when you get the units back. And it's very easy to get them back on the board. So you that combination of a smaller board, a very small board, um with how easy it is to get units back on the board, plus the fact that you are probably going to use lose units in combat. That all works together to make me not feel bad when I'm attacked and to make me not feel bad about attacking other players. Um so yeah, I really enjoyed this aspect of Kemet paired with the idea that there are strong engine building elements that make each game feel very different. Um, that is Kemet. At number six, at number five, we have Star Star Wars Rebellion.
Um, so I probably and I should say this, I probably should have prompted these uh potential panelists to not pick two-player only games because inherently like any two-player dueling game is going to have a lot of conflict between the players. However, I didn't say that and I think so. think that the two selections on this list are fair picks for this and plus some of the other games that I mentioned can be played at two. So, um I think is a perfectly fair selection for Star Wars Rebellion here at number five. The person says, "I picked this one because it's a 1v one or 2v2 as they point out where one player plays as the Empire hunting down the rebels by card play and sending characters on special missions, attacking the rebel forces to gain control of planets, resources, and find the secret rebel base and ultimately wipe them out. The other player plays as the rebels and tries to disrupt the Empire by playing cards and sending characters on secret sabotage missions or diplomacy missions to rally the galaxy to their side and stand against the evil empire.
It feels just like the original trilogy and is asymmetric. And it feels great when you take a planet of resources from the Empire and slow them down. And it also feels great when you send the Death Star out and destroy a rebel planet that's just been a thorn in your side. That is Star Wars Rebellion at number five. At number four, we have Blood Rage. And two panelists picked Blood Rage. The first says, "I really like how Blood Rage encourages players to go after each other, but still keeps the conflict fun rather than frustrating. I also love that with the right cards and strategy, you can actually play to lose fights instead of always trying to win them. The combat cards add a lot of bluffing and reading your opponents, which makes every fight feel tense. Conflict is such a big part of the game rather than something that only happens occasionally. And the card drafting is awesome, too.
The second person who picked Blood Rage says um my selection which I get to briefly highlight in this battle is the combat they're referring to the battle royale is the combat system in Eric Lang's Blood Rage. The combat system in Blood Rage is the central mechanism for success and is highly dependent on players awareness, preparation, and timing. All combat cards are drafted secretly and simultaneously allowing players to evaluate their opponent's interest and power before the battle even begins. Board presence and revealed cards reduce randomness and imbalance as players choose cards by assess assessing the others players motive and access to powerful cards. Wise players can even take a victory in a loss by bluffing which leaves every battle unpredictable. Winnable from multiple angles and genuinely exciting. That's Blood Rage at number four.
Again, the ranking is how I feel about these games. These are the thoughts from the panelists. Uh this is the other two-player game selected. Seven Wonders Duel. And this is the last panelist pick on the or potential panelist pick on the list. They say, "Every action you take in this game is a direct hit on your opponent. You deprive them of resources, make them pay all their money, overpower them militarily, or find a way to snatch away important building blocks of their strategy." The gods in Pantheon, this person did mention, I left out the line, but they like this game particularly with the Pantheon expansion. The gods in Pantheon add to the constant threat. It is a short but heavy battle, and 30 minutes feels intense. That's Seven Wonders Duel. At number three, at number two, we have Rumble Nation. This is a direct conflict game that I adore uh in its simplicity and how you get to watch the battle actually play out in the last five minutes of the game. Um, on your turn, you are rolling three dice. See those three dice here, and you have the option to roll them as well. and you pair up two of the dice to determine um which location on which you will be placing units that for that turn. And the third die determines how many units are going there. It's either one unit, two units, or three units. Uh I I love this system and I love how variable the map can be over the course of any given game because the numbers can shift position based on the game that you're playing. And the reason the numbers matter is that if you win the 12 value region, you get 12 points. the second place player gets six points.
Compared to going all the way down to two, I'm only going to get two points if I win that region. Second place only gets one. However, you you execute the region in the in the last like 5 to 10 minutes of the game. You execute the battle the war um location by location based on number ascending. So, you start with location two, you resolve that. that you see who has the most units there and the winning player gets to add reinforcements to each adjacent territory where they have units. So going after the low numbers in this game um can be can have kind of a a domino effect in the game. Uh where you might have not have originally won the 12 region which is right in the middle of this board. But by the time you get to you get to the 12 region that's the last region to resolve. You have a bunch of reinforcements there and suddenly you are winning that region. I think it's such a clever game. It's it's yeah I I I I adore Rumble Nation. That's why it's my number two pick.
And finally, at number one, we have Dune Imperium and or Dune Imperium Uprising. I'm happy to play either one. What I really like about the combat in this game partially is that, you know, it's going to happen every round. There isn't uh players aren't deciding when combat happens. The game is saying at the end of every round, we are going to do a a conflict. There's going to be a combat in this game. Whether or not you are involved in it is your choice, but there is going to be combat. It's very easy to do the math in the combat. And yet, there are intrigue cards that you can play that can mix things up a little bit, throw opponents off guard. You can even bluff to make opponents think that you have uh intrigue cards that you're going to play into combat and not actually play them. There are also variable rewards for winning combat. So, you can kind of decide, is this a combat is this round's combat one that I want to engage in, or do I want to hold off for the next round where I can actually get some points out of it? Um, and yeah, again, it's very easy to resolve. You just you look at the numbers and a after you all players have played their intrigue cards if any you can see who resolves the conflict. And I really like that most players are generally involved in conflict. So it's all at once. It's not like two players are doing something that's taking a few minutes off of the side and you you don't really care. Most of the times most players care what's happening in combat. And even if you aren't in it, you're probably hoping that the two players will go back or the two or three players will go back and forth and play intrigue cards so that they don't get those cards out of their hand and then you can jump in in the next combat when they have when they don't have those advantages anymore. So I really love the combat system in Dune Imperium. That is why it is my number one game with direct conflict.
So there it is, top 10 games with a lot of direct conflict. I would love to hear a what your favorite game is in this genre, whether it's from this list or elsewhere. And if you had if one of the ways that these panelists uh talked about games and maybe the game that they selected, if that really spoke to you, let me know your panelist pick um in the comments below and I'll see if that factors into my decision for who the combative panelist will be. All right, thanks