Are some games just too long? | TableScraps #65
Transcript
today's topic is taking forever welcome to table scraps short discussions about board card and tabletop gaming submitted by the viewing audience and discussed with the viewing audience hey there everybody and welcome back to another episode of table scraps the show here where we discuss a topic about board card and tabletop games with the live streaming YouTube audience and today today I have another live audience member who's going to be joining me here to discuss the topic and that person is Mr Marty canel of the Rolling Dice and taking names podcast thank you for joining us Marty hey Chaz how's the weather in Oregon the weather in Oregon is fantabulous and you know the only thing that would make it better is if you and trevan were here to enjoy it with me all right I wish we were Marty we are going to discuss a topic uh related to tabletop gaming that was uh submitted by the viewing audience and then we're going to turn it over to the YouTube streaming audience to chat with them about it a little bit more and today's topic is this one from Sakura Draven who asks how do you feel about games that can run a long time like three or more hours I am a with it if the game is fun um and I know that is such a Blog answer
but it but it's true so one one of the recent games I played that was more than that was um a Game of Thrones the second edition with the expansion uh Mother of Dragons and I had an amazing time but that's a game that you're super engaged uh with the players and the game for three to four hours so the time kind of flew I feel that way uh Mansions of Madness second edition can have some scenarios that run long a okay with that but then other games if it gets a little long in the tooth and I get tired of playing then I I wear out pretty quickly uh the example of that was uh it's been a couple years since I played it but Twilight Imperium the previous Edition that game honestly about four or five hours I was like done I was like somebody just please win this game I became disengaged from the game I still played but like when it wasn't my turn I was like oh my gosh just somebody please win and hurry hurry up and win so it all depends on the game and that's a that's a horrible answer for this type of question but that's exactly what it is for me okay okay uh that's funny because I rarely actually rarely get to play a three plus hour game uh it's kind of a rare treat for me and the most recent game like that I've been able to play actually was Twilight Imperium fourth edition and between learning the rules in playing the game we played that game it for 9 hours and we still didn't get done we set a hard stop time limit I
think we got to the eighth of 10 Rounds uh but n and the it kind of I don't want to say flew by but the game it was you we were engaged enough at least I was engaged enough that it went by okay um I was playing I played a game of the original uh Android I think not Android Netrunner but Android the board game which is really interesting but about halfway through that game which I think took like six hours again including the learning time and everything about halfway through I realized that there was even if I played optimal moves there was no way I could even get close to winning and so I was like the whole second half of that game for like three hours or so I just went through the motions on my turn I move here I do this I move here I do this and tried to you know keep it energetic and put on a brave face but inside I was just like just doing pulling levers and stuff now I've had that experience too um where if I felt like I was just out of the game like there's no way I could win and then I I kind of zone out I really really really enjoy games I have a built-in clock even if a game is long if there's some element of the game that eventually will wind down and the game will end I love that because then I know there's no way that game can just continue perpetually so anytime that I see a game that's two hours three hours plus and I scan through the rules and look for know winning conditions and one of them is oh there's something that's going to time out I'm all in the the other the other side of this coin to me is games that
shouldn't take that long but do oh I have tried to enjoy istan buul but the very first time I played it now how long should that game take I I didn't think that was the very last my God it's been years since I played a couple hours maybe yeah yeah my first game of istan was over 3 hours long no yeah that's that's bad yeah and it just it the game it just killed it for me because I you know I wake up cold sweats middle of the night having flashbacks and and the worst part is is that's not because the istan bu that's something else but go ahead well really really long drawn out flashbacks which makes it even worse so yeah so uh but yeah so I when when you have a game that shouldn't be that long but for some reason it turn AP analysis paralysis or something like that lots of interruptions perhaps does that affect your enjoyment of the game yep yeah I mean it it can um and the problem is is I know that I might be prone to the analysis paralysis and and hurting the experience for others and then I get frustrated at myself because I feel like then everybody's watching me and wanting me to hurry up um but let me ask you uh uh what do you think about RP do you I can't remember do you play RPGs because those can go three to four hours long are you okay with something like that see that's a totally different animal um yeah when I play an RPG it's like we're sitting down to tell a story and have fun and it's it's a more of an event you know it's not like we're playing a game
that was designed to play in 45 minutes you know we're yeah so yeah totally totally totally different first off with a suggestion from Christian who says I love long games just as much as a 30 minute one I love Talisman Twilight Imperium 4 and battl Star Galactica oh okay that's a good one I'm so glad that Christian mentioned uh Battle Star Galactica because that is another example of what can happen with a long game I waited like years literally a couple of years to have the opportunity to be in the right place at the right time to play Battle Star Galactica and there was a local convention where I finally there were six people or however many full compliment of people to play it and I got to sit down and I I got to play it and everyone in that group played Battle Star Galactica with each other like every weekend they that's the same group they played all the time so I sat down to play this game and it was I sat down and I watched one person take his turn kind of talk inside jokes stuff whatever do things real quick boom bo boom turns down next person blah boom turns done next guy it ended up well I sat there three four and a half hours and I ended up watching everyone else play a game of Battle Star Galactica and I was stuck there doing it and so that type of experience you know the the people you play with can definitely affect how the game plays out and when you when it get stuck stuck in that situation I mean you are you are there for the Long Haul okay let's move on to
the next Chat thing here from the person who is Kabuki kid who says my opinion is that games that are meant to be three plus hours are great but at 1.5 hour game that runs three plus hours is not quite as fun yeah there you go that's your istan bu right that's my yes that's my istan bu right there we have a consensus here that short games that take forever for some reason not as fun now what if there's a really long game that's supposed to be really long but it's really fast do you think that would Ru it for you no uh in fact what was oh my gosh oh oh I know perfect one so last week I went to um uh tantrum con who's run by tantrum house and I got to play Black Orchestra for the first time that that's a co-op game um that was really big last year first time I ever played it Tony my co-host on on the podcast had played it and said Marty you need to sit down and try this game it is is amazing so I got to sit down with a couple people there including like uh like Richard lonus you know who designed Arkham har oh excuse me let me pick up that name I just dropped down here there it is all right I got it all right um so he taught the game and um and it's one of those things where it runs like seven rounds so it has a clock built into it and the beginning of the game people said you know typically the game doesn't resolve or you don't win by like the fourth or fifth round we won in round two it's
almost like the setup of the game and the rules explanation took more than the game itself and those who had play went this just never happens it's just things just happened to work out with the card draws and everything and the dice rolls to where we want almost instantly and Tony was like upset my my coach because he was like you didn't really experience the game at all and and that's where I felt like I was kind of jilted because some of the people I was playing with uh there's something about being able to uh you get caught by the gapo and thrown into prison and you're interrogated and one of my friends said that's just one of the best mechanics that he's seen in a game in a long time and I never got to see it so I do feel I was kind of jilted and want to play it again to see how that part of the game works but it didn't deter from The Experience though it just makes it feel like this game's not that hard a big deal I've won I don't need to play again what was famous game designer Richard laus's opinion of that who Richard oh hold on Richard lus yeah that guy um yeah so he was stunned he was the one that said yeah we've never won this quick before so he he was kind of shocked too but it didn't hurt it didn't hurt the experience except that I felt like I lost out on seeing something in the game that I I was told I should see that story you just gave us a really good example of that very type of scenario that can play out with with games like that and why it can be good and bad let's go to the next comment which could be good or bad this one from Trevon who says as long as these games are played by appointment rather than spur of the moment it's fine I think good point yeah
yep I mentioned that I I rarely get to play really long games and the reason I actually have uh Twilight Imperium and Android um in my examples is because uh last year I actually set up with a local game group of friends uh a monthly or bonly thing where we actually set up a certain day each month that we're going to play a game that we never get to play otherwise and it's been these bigger meteor games so and then we know it's going to happen we're expecting it and we don't mind as much uh let's continue on from with comment next from Halo who says I love long games emphasis mine specifically with people that are into it emphasis also mine Twilight Imperium and Zia are the longest games that I have played specific especially if there is a player interaction in a theme um I I I I I I'm glad that Halo mentioned Zia as well Zia I I love Zia Legends of a drift drift system um but one time uh the most recent time I played that everyone else went off kind of Eastward to explore the Galaxy and I said well forget this I'm going to go Westward I'm going to see what's this way so I went off by myself and I pulled out you have this stack of space tiles and you pull out a random one and you place it down as you're exploring space and I I drew empty space and then empty space and empty space and literally I had this long I've never seen anything like it there was this long line of tiles every tile that was a planet was over here and
I had this long line and I got down to there was one tile left and and I got to it and I turned it over and it was a planet but I ran out of resources and I got stuck right and so I kind of just floated around next to the planet while everyone else was over here and it made that Zia game a very very long tedious experience and it was my own fault in a way is there is there a game that you like thought you wouldn't like its length but then you didn't you ended up not minding once you started playing it no okay moving on our next question our next question comes from Quan 7 Jack who says long games that have a legitimate way for player to leave early are good oh that's a really good point only game as an example that's coming to mind for me is uh Shadows over Camelot which kind of is built to have people come in and leave oh uh what what can you think of any other games where it's built into it the game itself for people to come and go during the actual game during the actual game no I can't I can't personally I'm sure it's out there uh the next one from cam who says do you think some game Publishers list shorter times than what is realistic on their boxes because they fear the longer time will lead to Less sales fantastic oh so lying to the consumer basically mhm do you think that
happens it does seem like there are a lot of games and the reason why this comes up is because whenever I sit down and play games with my wife and she says let me look at the box and see how how long it takes and if it say if it says an hour she said all right that's hour and a half two hours it's like she just now like assumes that whatever's written on the box isn't exactly right now to be fair you're also learning the rules and playing for the first time Etc um but I mean sure I I think the first game or two is probably always longer than what's listed on the box I I I really I think once you get into it and then you don't know I you assume that they're not including setup time and so you know setup could take a little bit of time and then maybe teaching the rules to somebody so it does tend to go longer than what's written on the box unless just everybody knows exactly what they're doing it's already set up and you sit down and you play that's exactly what I think it is I don't think it's the Publishers being malicious in any way I think it's that those times are based on their play testing and their development games by people who designed the game or know the rules really well from play testing I think that's where those numbers usually come from and it's it's kind of your best case scenario time limit uh next comment is from axent control who says I'd play long games if I and my friends had the time but that rarely happens uh and I think many of us actually are in that same boat um I think like I gave the example that for those longer games we actually had to create a specific like schedule for
them yes it's funny you say that because I have uh some my game group here who has some long games we want to go back and experience again I i' mentioned Game of Thrones that was a special all right like 3 weeks from now let's get this group of people together and play uh Mari nostrom we want to get back to the table so bad cuz we all loved it forbidden Stars we want to get back to the table so bad because everybody loved it and um I want to teach them Starcraft which was the uh uh precursor to forbidden stars because I want to play those two literally back to back to compare how they two are but those both games are 2 to three hours long so yeah I agree you do it well where I am right now with wife kids everything you do have to kind of plan everybody else has to plan to do it that's why I just don't get to do it that often but that's why also conventions are a great place to do it because then you have you know you're there just to play games so it's a perfect time to bring out those longer games that's that's a that's a really good environment for it that's it is a very good environment Chaz you're making fun of me somehow but I can't quite put my finger on how so I'm going to continue on to a couple more questions here the next one from uh B Pike who says games that are 1.5 to 2 hours are more in my wheelhouse but 3 plus still doesn't bother me at all they just require a little more scheduled planning with players and I think that that dovetails right into what we've already already said there and I think so um axent troll or anyone else has problems with it I think scheduling in advance is really the way to go or to
put yourself in the correct environment for that type of game yeah all right and our last question here is gonna or last com our last comment is going to come from Christian says I think it also sometimes comes down to your background mine is from Warhammer 40K axis and allies so I love them just as much but my wife came from yatsi Etc so long games are not for her oh very very true what uh looks like that sparked some some ideas in your Dome there little well no I I think uh no I'm just sitting there thinking you know uh Warhammer 40K can be a a long game and in fact I'm one of those that uh used to love or still to play Miniature games but again uh with games like 40K AG of Sigmar where you got large Point armies that's that basically large Port armies I mean you got a lot of models on the board there's a lot of models being moved around just takes a long time to play a game that's why these uh newer games coming out from like Games Workshop who are smaller skirmish games like Chaz you and I got to play a kill team together uh which is a lot fewer models less less to learn simpler rules and quicker time to play and that game has taken off big time and I think part of the reason is is people now realize oh I don't have to commit three hours to a miniature game here's a nice miniature game that I can play still get that miniature feel in an hour or less absolutely yeah so there might be variations of certain longer games that you can play that would fit into a more reasonable time frame that your the co-players would be
more apt to try almost like a you know a sampling a taste as it were uh the the the Costco sample of game play uh Marty uh for those of anyone who may or may not be familiar with it where can people find you on the intermost web uh if you want to check out our podcast rolling Dice and taking names we have a website where you can go down the download the episodes at roll dicak names.com uh obviously we're also on iTunes and Stitcher Etc or you can uh if you want to chat with us you can do so on Twitter at Dyson names Facebook we're kind of wherever Chaz is we're we're there too actually we're right in chaz's basement right now he doesn't even know it where were you when I was cleaning my kitchen this morning H stay in the basement baby fair enough all right and I'm Chaz Marler from Paradise paradise and you can find me on the YouTube channel that you are watching right now until next time I again have been chz maror from Parise Paradise the YouTube channel you're watching right now thanks for joining us and we'll talk you again hopefully more coherently real soon I doubt it H have you had that experience where you find you you just are sucked into a game you realize I have got to find a bail point I have got to bail on this no hey Marty we have a good rapport why
don't you come join me okay sure I'll do that that sounds fun I have the power of editing I can I can pester you now and then come off clean as a whistle later do you ever go to Costco just to go there and eat just get around and get the samples is that just me yes I do