TDG: Top Ten Evolving Board Board Games (March 2026)
Transcript
Hello ladies and gentlemen and welcome to the discriminating gamer. Say, did you hear about that bus filled with Elvis impersonators that got into the crash? No one was injured, but they were all shook up. Ladies and gentlemen, today we're going to go ahead and take a look at my top 10 evolving board games.
All right, ladies and gentlemen, my top 10 evolving board games. Now, what I mean by this is uh games where as you play them, the game board evolves or the play area evolves. Now, every every time you play a board game, things are actually going to change. You're going to add tokens or movement and stuff like that. That's not what I'm talking about. But I'm talking about a game that over the course of the game, uh, you actually grow the board or it it builds or you're revealing entirely new locations and areas. That's what I'm talking about when I say evolving board games, right? The evolving board games. So, uh, I'm just going to go ahead and jump right into it. My number 10 is a game that is all about building up a continent. This is Ekos or Echos, the first continent.
This is a great game. It's got kind of a bingo mechanic to it, but essentially what you are doing is you are creating a continent. You are adding tiles to create land and water around it, different kinds of land. You're adding mountains. You're adding trees. And you're adding different kinds of wildlife. And this can change over time. It grows. It's it's a wonderful game to see the board, as I say, evolve, to see it grow and change over time. It's never the same, you know, play area twice. It's never the same uh group of tiles there that get configured in the same way and so it's always very fun and this bingo mechanic that you know where you're trying to score different cards based on the configuration of the board is excellent. So that is my number 10 Echos the first continent that is from AEG. My number nine is a game that I actually just played a few times again fairly recently, but I played it, you know, I I I owned it, I don't know, 15 years ago and really enjoyed it. At some point along the line, I got rid of it and then I just got the big edition back, big big box edition back. But this is Carcassone currently from Zman Games. Carcassone is a great tile laying game. And essentially, of course, as you're going throughout the game, uh, you are grabbing tiles and you're laying them and you're trying to configure them in such a way that you are making roads contiguous. You are building cities to try to make them contiguous, and you're trying to put down your meeples to score these various locations. It's great fun, uh, you know, trying to score, but so much of the appeal of this game is watching that play area, watching those
tiles evolve right in front of you. I absolutely adore Carcassone. I'm so glad it's back in my collection. So, that is Carcassone. And that is my number nine from Zman Games. My number eight is a game that I played I think for the last I played it last year for the first time. I played it several times since. And this was a game that um it had kind of an earlier cousin that was just kind of a a static board every time you played it. And then this one brought in a way to kind of explore the board. But this is Clank Catacombs. Clank Catacombs is great. It's kind of this this this adventure. You're you're kind of a dungeon raider. You're looking for treasure, a treasure hunter, [snorts] and you're going deeper and deeper into the dungeon, but there's all these tiles that you are laying that move you in different directions, move you into different rooms. There's all sorts of traps and perils, but potential rewards.
It's a beautiful game to look at. Now, I had played the original Clank years ago, and I enjoyed it. I thought it was a fun game, but it didn't blow me away, and I ultimately didn't keep it. Uh, Clank Catacombs is amazing. I love it. And I think one of the reasons why it's so much better than its earlier iteration is because you evolve the board. You lay down the the tiles to create these new areas you're going to be visiting. I absolutely love it. It is tremendous tremendous fun. Uh a great a great adventure game and a great evolving board game. So this is Clank Catacombs. That is my number eight and that is from Direwolf. My number seven is a game that the the base game kind of has some elements of this, but it's really with the expansion that it really takes off and you got this this new great exploring element, but this is Civilization: A New Dawn and of course the expansion is the Terra Incognito expansion. Uh that is an essential expansion. I wouldn't play this game without it. Uh one of the things you can do here is actually as you're exploring the board, if you move toward the edge of the board, you can actually explore and go further and flip over um a new tile. And again, you see kind of the the area around you evolve as you were playing it. So, it's got this great kind of card sliding mechanic, which we've seen in a few other games, but but not many. I'm surprised we haven't seen it in more.
You know, you can take a card in kind of this weak slot and you can play it uh and it doesn't do much for you and it's going to kind of stay there. Or you can take like a card that's kind of in this most powerful spot and you can play it and do something really cool with it, but then it slides to the the weak spot, right? So, you can take any action you want, but depending on where these cards are, uh, you know, the longer they haven't been played, the more powerful they become played, and I really like that. But I love the exploration of this game. I love watching this world evolve that you're all fighting for control of. It's just tremendous, tremendous fun. I I really enjoy Civilization and New Dawn, and it's a great game to watch the board evolve. So, that is Civilization and New Dawn. That is from Fantasy Flight Games. My number six is an IP game and it's based on one of my favorite IPs. And again, it's so much fun to watch the galaxy uh kind of come together [snorts] here, but this is Star Trek Ascendy. In Star Trek Ascendy, you are, you know, depending on what what species you're playing, you know, the the Federation, the Klingons, the Romulons, the Ferangi, the Vulcans, uh the Andorians, whatever Kardashians, you are starting kind of in your home world, and you're creating these kind of warp lanes that then take you to other planets, and you create this just massive playing area filled with um all of these worlds. and some worlds connect to other worlds and other worlds are harder to get to for for different uh players and it's just so much fun.
Again, now this is a great civilization building game. I love Star Trek Ascendy just as a civilization building game, but a big reason why I love it is watching that board evolve and watching all the different space lanes and worlds as they uh come out there. It's so much fun. It's really a great adventure every time I play it. So, that is Star Trek Ascendy. That is my number six. That is from Gale Force 9. My number five is a game. This is another game that I played years ago, like 2011, 2012, thereabouts. Really enjoyed it when I played it. Ah, maybe it was a little bit later than that. Maybe it was about 2014 or 2015, come to think of it. Yeah, I think it was about that time. Um, I played it. I really enjoyed it. I really enjoyed it. Again, it didn't survive a purge. And as soon as I got rid of it, I instantly regretted it. And then here about oh three or four years ago we got a new printing of it that is amazing. This is Clash of Cultures Monumental Edition.
Now Clash of Cultures you do have this kind of board that's got this kind of fog of war on it, right? Or fog of civilization. And during the course of the game, you're actually flipping these tiles over to reveal new areas, new new places that you're going to go to and interact with. And then of course you're going to be building the cities on it. And the cities themselves that you build um are these kind of a city center and then you build these little districts around it and then over the course of the game other players can influence those districts and turn into their color. And it is so cool again watching this board evolve both in terms of the physical space of the board uh in in in in you know revealing these new locations but also too in the stuff you're actually building on the board. It really is a great another great civilization building game. It's you got the different again different peoples that are fighting there, the different groups uh that are fighting there and and and trying to gain supremacy. You got a great technology system here with a with a dual layer player board and again the expansion to it just brings a lot the expansions are baked into this monumental edition that brings some really great stuff to this game.
Wonderful board evolving game. Tremendous fun. So that is number five. Clash of Cultures Monumental Edition that is from Whiz Kids. My number four is another game where we see Space Evolve. Um, a Galactic Evolution board game here. Um, this is a game again, it came out with the first edition. It was one of It was one of, if not the very first board games I ever spent more than $100 on when it came out. And then when I was down in Texas, they did a crowdfund for a second edition, which is even better. This is Eclipse: Second Dawn for the Galaxy. Clip Second Dawn for the Galaxy is this great space adventure and you've got hex's and you are exploring. You go to different locations and you explore and again you're never going to get the same configurations of exploration uh consistently. It's all things are always going to be different and it is so much fun. I absolutely love this game on so many levels. I love researching the tech. I love the fact that it's an economic game, right? You're placing your cubes there which are freeing up your resources. And I love all of that aspects of the game. I It's got starship combat, right? So there's kind of direct dice driven combat. So it's kind of a hybrid of kind of euroeconomic and kind of a thrash dice checking. I really love that aspect. But I love watching how the universe evolves. I love watching how everything plays out. And with the with with the second for the galaxy, you got all the different kinds of each each race has their own specific spaceship.
and they are all look beautiful. I absolutely love this game. I adore it and gosh, I'm thinking about it now. I want to play it so bad. I haven't played it in a long time. Really, I think one of the best um kind of space 4X games out there. Uh absolutely love it. But this is Eclipse Second Dawn for the Galaxy and this is my number four and that is from Laiput. My number three is a horror board game. I love horror board games. It is also an appdriven game. This is from Fantasy Flight Games, Mansions of Madness, second edition. I love Mansions of Madness. And this is cool because of course you're starting out usually in maybe one or two rooms, the the um investigators, and then the app instructs you to place out rooms, but you also have some choices here, which doors you're going to go through. And so again, you can kind of see the map evolve. Now, obviously, again, the computer, the app is is dictating a lot of this, but just watching it evolve on the game board is so much fun. I love that aspect of the game, but again, this is a great kind of mystery game. It's a great cooperative game. It's got these horror elements and you've got battles and you're gaining resources and cards to help you there. It and it's got a great creepy feel. This is one of the best implementations of the Cthulhu theme, I think, ever, right? The the HP Lovecraft theme. It is a fantastic game, much better than the first edition. Uh, and I love watching the board evolve in this game. So, that is Mansions of Madness, second edition. That is from Fantasy Flight Games. That is my number three. My number two is a game that I've
just played recently. I played it for the first time uh oh, a couple of weeks ago. We played it a few times since, and it's quickly become one of my absolute favorites. It's part of a larger series of games. This is the latest iteration, but this one is far and away the best in my opinion. This is Nemesis Retaliation. Nemesis Retaliation is just fantastic. And um you know, it's got all the good stuff from Nemesis, the the basic Nemesis. You got the hidden objectives and hidden traders. You've got the ways you kind of move uh to the different rooms and search and get items that way. You've got really creepy villains. You got noise tokens. And you're dreading the noise whenever you move because you don't want those aliens to appear. But what is really cool about this one and one of the things that makes it far superior to the others is this evolution of the board. As you're moving through the board, you're drawing tiles, you're creating corridors, and the the board is evolving in weird ways. In this last game that we played, um we had to find like our task was we had to kind of secure a line to a certain room in in the C-section. And as we're moving there, the C-section, as we're moving there to section C, um Ry was going and he kind of went around and the board constructed itself in such a way that it was the absolute worst possible configuration for us to secure a line, the longest configuration for us to secure a line to that room. But it was great. I love watching this board evolve in front of me on the game board. Uh it's just so much fun. Uh there's that
there's that little part of your brain that just is so creative and it loves to watch that sort of thing and it just sucks you in. It's just done so well in Nemesis Retaliation which is already such a great thematic game that really sucks you in and then to have it do that in and add this aspect of the game. There was always you know exploration of a sort in the other Nemesis games but in this one it really comes full flower. So that is Nemesis Retaliation and that is from Awakened Realms. That is my number two. my number one game to evolve to to watch the the game evolve on the board. Now, this one's kind of tricky because the first the base game has an element of this and it's an important element of this, but as you get into the expansions, it becomes just visually much more interesting and appealing for this particular idea of watching a board evolve. But this is Space Empires 4X.
Space Empires 4X has a static board. But as you are moving into these unknown regions, you're flipping these tokens and you may just get empty space. You may get dangers or you may get supernovas. Uh you may get planets that you can colonize and you just flip those over. Now, as I say in the base game, some of these things just remain there and that kind of changes the board up. But in the expansions, they actually give these big hex tiles. So the game actually becomes much more, as I say, visually appealing. And you can see now where these planets pop up, where the asteroids are, where the dangers are. Well, not the dangers that are removed from the board, but but the various other kind of stellar terrain that begins to pop up at this time. And as the game evolves, as I say, it's incredibly incredibly visually interesting to see all of that happen.
And the game itself is fantastic. one of the best Forex games, if not the best Forex game ever created. Um, so much uh so many choices, but so much depth and is you only get deeper and deeper with the more expansions. Uh, this is such a great game system and again absolutely beautiful to look at as it is evolving on the board. So that is my number one that is Space Empires 4X and that is from GMT Games. All right, ladies and gentlemen, what do you think? What are your favorite games where you have this kind of board evolution where you see the board grow and change over the course of a game? Please, please, please let me know. What are what are those games that you like? What do you think of the games on my list? Do you not like them? Do you think the order should have been different? I'm always very excited to know what you have to say about my thoughts on this matter. I love engaging with all of you. Now, uh as as always, we'd ask you to please uh like this video and subscribe. And it looks like maybe some subscribers have been automatically uh unsubscribed by the YouTube algorithm. So please if you have subscribed, please check again to make sure you are still subscribed. That would mean the world to me. Now also please please please if you like what we see here, please uh check out my other YouTube channel that is Cody Carlson PhD. We talk about history, military history, books on history, fun things like that. Uh again, it would mean a lot if you would subscribe to that channel as well. And if you do like what we do here on the discriminating gamer, I would humbly ask you to click on the super thanks button and leave a tip. Why do people wear shamrocks on St.
Patrick's Day? Because real rocks are too heavy on my feet again. AND I DON'T KNOW WHERE I'M GOING. AND I DON'T KNOW where I've been. Please help me ground. It's a LONG TIME AND I'LL BE DYING. Once a year I wind up in the I love to fight, but I don't ever win. It's my life. Listen, if you like this review, subscribe to our YouTube channel and leave a comment. And if you don't like it, then keep your mouth shut.