Skip to main content
Loading video...

Top 7 Board Games | With Designer David Thompson

Transcript 26:32

if you've been playing historical board games over the past 10 years chances are you have played more than one of this designer's Titles since 2016 he's co-designed nearly 30 titles and won dozens of awards for his work in board game design talking specifically about David Thompson whose work includes the spectacularly successful undaunted series as well as the Valiant Defense series from Dan verson games David has kindly joined the channel today not to explore a question specific specifically about his design work however because I've been curious what board games do top designers like so for this conversation David has put together his top seven board games of all time and don't worry in the course of the interview we will also talk about his design work coincidentally a number of the games that David mentions are games that are currently out of print or relatively hard to find so I would be remissed not to mention one of our Channel sponsors which is Noble KN games from Wisconsin they ship all across the planet and they are a great source of used historical games used war games and used board games in general I'll put a link down below and if you do use that link to buy something from the store thank you very much as it does help out the channel let's jump into our conversation with David hi everybody I'm Zilla Blitz and I'm joined here today by one of the most prolific historical board game designers in the world today David Thompson thank you so much for joining us today David thanks for having me good to be here and yes actually let's Jump Right In and get started and although you have designed more than two dozen games the main purpose of this

video is actually is to hear about the other side of your gaming hobby which is the games that you like the most and specifically we're going to do a top seven I think it is of your all-time favorite board games okay yeah let's let's do it this was a fun make and with that and I think also people will be interested in hear in hearing about your designs as well so we'll take some breaks in between as we're going through this to ask you some questions about your designs as well but let's Get Right started with the top seven should we jump into game number seven on your list okay yeah so my number seven is uh Sak gahara so this is about uh the conflict in feudal Japan uh it's a GMT game I'm not it's been out for quite a while now um I thought really hard I'm a big fan of block war games and so I thought really hard about you know which is my favorite and I think Saka gar is is is the standout for me fantastic game fantastic I haven't played that one I've played it's an ancient style gameer it's like command in colors ancients or is it different than that no no no it's not it's not a command in colors it's a it's a block war game so like you know actually the hidden information on the blocks and you have this really interesting uh card play for activations in combat so yeah I mean it still has cards and and blocks like like command and colors but it's a very different system right fantastic fantastic let's Jump Right In let's head on to number six then okay so number six was uh votes for women so um a little bit if if you'll indulge me a little bit of behind the scenes that put this together this list together and uh I had

to I used this system called um Meep meeple Pub meeple I think is what it was and it'll let me do a bunch of side-by-side comparisons and um so a lot of these were very tough but I knew for a fact that votes for women was in my top 10 and it came out as number six I was a little surprised I thought itd be higher than that so this is really tough uh tough but votes for women has been one of my favorite games in the last few years designed by Tory Brown published by Fort Circle absolutely fantastic game for all sorts of audiences in a in a really good entry into historical games right and of course it's the it's the you know the Epic story 80 years story about women's suffrage and corre there's a solo element to this and a two-player element do you have a particular favorite part you can played a lot of different ways so you can play it competitively you can play it solo you can play it cooperatively right all the different versions my daughter and I play it we play it we played it two different ways we play it solo and we also play it two-player Cooperative with us being the you know obviously fighting for women's suffrage we neither one of us wants to play the opposition so we've played it both both those ways we love it both both ways we've never played it I've never I've never actually played the game two-player Cooperative or two-player competitive okay interesting I've got a game going now it's on rally the troops I've got a game going now competitive like that on rally the troops and okay um I am the anti-suffrage which is always like emotionally hard to play but it's it's it's actually like sewing chaos is is kind of like oddly entertaining not that

that's like what I would be in real life but it's but it's kind of interesting in that c and I'm actually I know how hard these lists s to make I'm doing kind of the same thing I'm trying to pick my favorite games over the that I've played over the last two years and that line can be very very subtle and votes for women is actually I won't give away too much but it's in my list as well because I think it's one of the best educational games out there in the world today yeah yeah and there just the audience that it that appeals to and you know engage is is it's hard to compete with that in the historical game Space absolutely yeah okay let's take a little bit of a break we've done seven and six let's take a little bit of a break I want to ask a question about your designs here I'm very curious you again with over two dozen designs you know like three a year for almost or more for the past six seven eight years or so we've been going on quite the streak here but I'm curious what has been both your hardest game to design one question and then what is the game that just flowed it was the easiest game for you to design yeah the hardest meaning like most timec consuming because I I don't know if if it was like hardest in terms of like overcoming design challenges it would take me a lot of time to think about that so the easier answer is like what took the most time to create and that would either be UND daunted Stalingrad or War Story occupied France both of them were multi-year huge time investment projects um for very different reasons obviously andon Stalingrad was just a beast because of its um the the cascading sort

of uh Legacy style campaign this in it and then un and then War Story occupied France just because of the sheer volume of content like it's a novel's worth of text right and just an insane web of how the the entries work flow together so just those two um just from sheer you know multi-year investment as far as the easiest uh I make up I'm I'm not the most talented designer so I just make up for with like dedication and hard work so nothing comes easy nothing comes easy humility I will say you're a very humble designer too so um the one that actually came together probably quickest was General Order so so Trevor Benjamin and I design it together and we we basically designed the the first board for it which is a symmetric board so it's a little bit easier from a design challenge perspective but it took us like about a month um wow so that that came together really quick we had a re we started with what was like a really firm concept so it flowed pretty pretty quickly right and you've also got a working history with him because you've designed oh yeah a lot of games together yeah we work very closely together and and I think what we've learned is when we come when one of us brings like a well formulated idea to the to the two of us like as a pair uh things flow a lot quicker if we don't do well when we sit down and say hey let's make a game it's one of us brings an idea and says hey this is my idea this is the the the concept let's work on it oh very nice yeah let's jump back uh into your list shall we go to uh number five all right

so number five is number five is an older game I 2014 I think is when it came out so not that old but you know in in in board game world it's kind of an older game um but it's new to me because I kind of sort of rediscovered this game this year and that's founding fathers by Christian Leonard and Jason Matthews so um fantastic game obviously you know about the founding fathers um just a really good uh merging of like the historical game space with some like Euro almost like uh majority uh scoring kind of concept so really good game and and again I had played it many years ago once and so uh this year I wanted to go back to it and I I played it again at a couple conventions and I've just played it a ton since then so and can I ask in particular what elements of gameplay bring it into this L I think it does a in my for me at least it does really good job of merging the gameplay with the historical Concepts right so you have in a non in a non warar game um setting like a historical non-war game setting and that's something that I'm getting more and more interested in both from a design perspective and from as a player I want to dig more into historical games that are non war games or kinetic War Games fantastic great yeah let's jump on to number four okay so number four uh land and freedom so anybody that knows me knows that this has been one of my top games it was my top game of 2023 it was the game that you know uh I think it

just it just won the um the uh Summit Award right coming out of SD hison so uh this game is of course about the Spanish Civil War designed by Alex Knight who's a first-time designer and one thing we should mention is uh votes for women also first-time designer Tory Brown some some amazing games in my opinion um from some first-time designers so just a brilliant game it's Landon freedom is you can play at one two or three players I think it shines I Know It Shines at three and it is the really the only semi Cooperative game I've ever played that I genuinely liked but it it like defines the genre for me in terms of semic coop and when you say semi Coop you mean you're you're working together and striving for your own individual as well correct correct and and in almost every other case semi Coop games feel like uh you know you get to a point where like well why bother if I'm going to lose I can just tank it for everybody but but l Freedom doesn't let you do that it's like it brilliant design that that doesn't allow for that and so it's just it's it's pretty much perfect in my opinion in terms of game design like I just I can't say enough about it yeah yeah interesting I've been looking at a 1793 Patriots and Traders sound from from about the French Revolution and that has a similar aspect where you're you've got a number of factions working to keep the French Revolution alive yet at the same time you can't you want to try to individually win so I'm curious to see see how that works I haven't played a lot of games like that but I find like that kind of Cooperative elements in gameplay especially if you're playing with people you don't

know very well it can be a really nice way to get around the table and enjoy a board gaming experience yeah yeah absolutely yep right um let's talk a little bit if we could we'll shift we'll take a little bit of a pause a second pause question I know you're always working on something and it's almost always multiple things so I would love to hear a little bit if you would like what are you working on now that you're excited about okay so um so I'll say a couple of things that are coming soon first and those will be the first two games that I've designed with Liz Davidson so we have a couple of projects in the works uh one's coming from um Fort Circle it's the night witches so people watching this probably have heard about this um but night witches uh an all female Soviet night bomber unit from in during World War II and then the other game we we're working on the design is done now it's called queen of spies and it's about running a spy Network in World War I and that's a much more um sort of not historically based it's more historically inspired I would say but um like I said we just finished that up and actually we just signed it with a publisher so that one should be coming along pretty soon people will hear a lot more about that one um in terms of like what I'm working on right now so literally this morning I was working on uh my first ever American Civil War design so um I never thought I'd work on a civil war game so this has been a surprise even to me to be working on this uh I won't talk too much about it because the the publisher wanted me to kind of keep quiet until they have

some artwork to display and stuff but I will just say that like it's about an extremely Niche topic so people that know my World War II stuff probably won't be surprised by that um but it it looks at a part of the Civil War that I don't think has ever been gained before so we'll see what the response to that is oh very excellent and I know I I think there's there's an element to your game both with night witches I will say and I think also to a certain agree with things like by stealth and SE which is I think one of my favorite games that you've designed I absolutely love the narrative behind that um I think you've done a a remarkable job and it seems a curiosity for you to kind of find these Untold narratives and I think night which you know all female fighter pilot Squadron in the Soviet Union in World War II and to tell that story yeah which I think is just really fantastic well the thing that's been most you know again if you'll indulge me about this American Civil War game is um I don't really care at all about the big operational you know and even the the sort of like large scale battles that interests me not at all um this game has given me the opportunity to dig into some really super deep dive into the stories of some normal like average people that were caught up in the war and so um yeah I I'm really excited about bringing those people's stories you know to to a game I can't wait I I I can't wait I I I I think You' leaked a little bit in a private conversation like a little while ago so I'm going to be perfectly silent to but I can say to the people watching that this is going

to be all I think it's GNA be a great story I'm really I'm excited to yeah um let's uh let's jump back into our top uh seven we have three left how about we jump up to number three okay so um one thing I will we're we're about to do some some interesting Segways here because one thing I will tease is for the civil war game that I'm working on the mechanics in it were heavily inspired by a few Acres of snow and my number three game was a few Acres of snow so um now in my top 15 games probably like eight of them are French and Indian War games uh so that you know in the numbers like 10 to 15 so few Acres of snow is representing them all here my number three spot but uh it's it is uh the single most influential game in terms of game design like it was probably the first deck builder I played it's probably the first historical war game I played so just all sorts of things and I think Martin Wallace I think some of his designs are they could probably use a little bit more development and polish but I think my design perspective he's one of like the Masters um so it's just been a super influential game and it's still one of my favorites of all time and so this was a game that you've played a long time ago that and kind of really sparked some creativity and and absolutely Focus that design yeah I think I think it came out around 2010 I can't remember the exact dates maybe a little bit earlier than that um it's one of the first games I played when I first got into the hobby so around 2011 2012 right you know early on and it stuck with me ever I mean I've played it

more than any other game in the last month or two I played with a a buddy here local so we've played it played it a ton so it's kind of funny you mentioned it because unrelated to this conversation about three weeks ago I forget how it popped up on my radar and it's out of print it's hard to get and and so I was looking for I've been looking for it kind of for an opportunity and there was a local person who had a used copy and I just missed it oh so yeah I'm not helping when I say you definitely need to get it I know we are together maybe I'll bring I'll bring my copy to um Circle DC if you're oh okay yeah I'm hoping to be able to be there yeah yeah that'd be fun yeah absolutely like that yeah well we we've covered uh the next segue question too which was which game has been most inspirational in your design let's slide right up to number two uh your your second favorite Al game of all time yeah so so my number two game is El Grande so it stands out because it unlike the rest of them is not really a historical game I mean it's a very pasted on theme um but it is the in my opinion still the area control game right it's just that is it is it sets the the genre um I don't remember the first time I played it so the game I can't the game's been out for for decades now um I played it probably about seven six years ago something like that and the thing that I thought when I came away from that first play was why did people keep making games after this one because the best game of all time has been made um it's just it's just a brilliant game I think

everybody should play it uh even if you're not really into Euro games because it is really it is a euro game a control Euro game right but uh it's just a brilliant design absolutely fantastic well I actually have a funny story about El Grande because so I've been trying to uh play more games and learn games faster so I've been playing a lot of asynchronous games on board game Marina and one of the things I've been doing is playing before I read the rules right just when someone invites me to a game I'm like yeah sure and I'll just play the game and try to figure out the game and El Grande was a game that I think I played with three or four other people about two or three months ago and I left that game going like what just happened I have no idea what the game was I couldn't get it like not so it's on my list of like okay I really need to read the rules before I try to play that one then when I when yeah when you bring it up here I'm kind of like oh okay I need it's a funny it's a funny game to playing on you said you played on Bo game arena right yes yeah yeah it's a funny game to imagine because it's a it's a very simple game but like some of the rules are very weird if you don't know the game you know like where you can place things and stuff you know like if if you didn't know the rules you're like what is happening why can't I do what I think I should be able to do and also in board gra Arena if you're playing it asynchronously you kind of leave the game in game State one and then you you you get this notification it's your turn that could be you know a day later with three or four players and you come back and it's not a completely new game State it's like this wasn't even the same game I just left it's like how did that get way over there and where did all my pieces go and what's happening it did not work to just like try to play it without reading the rules

that's that way yeah okay um let let's go to a uh so that was number two let's go to our last break question which I I'm very curious about this one which is you know again more than two dozen designs closing in probably on 30 different designs you've designed a lot of games um what is your favorite game not that you've played but that you've designed yeah yeah so this is Def this is of course they're all my babies and I love them all equally but but um I like undaunted Normandy because I designed it for my grandfather right I've mentioned this story before he was you he was part of the 30th ID and that's what the game is about he's got a card representing him in it Etc so that will always hold a special place my heart just because of that personal attachment now in terms of like actually my favorite to to play is probably War chess because my kids like to play it and so you know recently at Christmas I I gave it to my niece because she wanted a copy and I played with my extended family and my my immediate family like 20 times over the holidays you know because they wanted to play it not because I wanted to right that's really that's a really cool experience so so it's probably one of those two and it' be very difficult to pick one out of them yeah and you don't have to yeah you can we can leave it it's your it's your list and it's your answer so there's no right or wrong so yeah I can't say it's been I think the first played undaunted in the summer last summer and I I think I've

mentioned this to you before in other conversations you know it was way better than I expected and for what and I think the reason I for whatever reason I had it in my head that it was a lot more abstract than it is and I just like immediately the way that the way you've got the different hands and the decks and you're pulling in from the supply the different resources and soldiers and the subtleties to think I was wow so I've been playing it pretty consistently now over the past six months just checking out my the soliter version and everyone I've introduced to has loved it everyone I've introduced to is like oh they want to play again and there's so many scenarios and then you know you're mentioning undaunted Stalingrad for I feel like I've got like a whole another two years or so of gameplay before I kind of get through them all I'm really looking forward to kind of exploring that one too so yeah I I can totally see how undaunted especially I didn't know actually the story about your grandfather Yeah that's I could see how that's a well yeah and just I I'll tell you this I'll take one second I'll tell you because this is amazing story so you know I obviously I designed it for my grandfather I went I visited when I lived in the UK I visited all the battle locations and stuff while I was designing the game and it was set in those real locations but after the design was done and while ospr was working on the art um we were naming the individual soldiers and most of them just have random names some of them you know I named one for my grandfather but my wife uh was visiting her family in Alabama she had her family bible which if you're from the south you know the the Family Bible is like a sacred artifact right and so it had been handed down for generations and she was looking

at it and she saw her her grandfather's name and it listed the unit he was in and he was in the same unit and so there's actually a card you didn't know that we didn't know that no we didn't know that and so there's fortunately we had time so there's like actually a card with his name on it in in the game too but they were in the same unit I mean it's POS you know almost certainly they didn't know each other but just the the fact that they could have right what a wild coincidence yep yeah yeah wow that's amazing I didn't know what a great story yeah well let's jump into our uh number one game okay so with a drum roll your your favorite game yeah so this is tough um I will say you know this is the top honestly any of these games could be my number one and and it changes all the time it changes all the time but but do it again in a month well and here I'm gonna tell you this is a way to know that this is truly my number one I don't play long games I'm not a big fan of like once it gets past about two hours I start to kind of like uh maybe I would like to be do something different Maria usually takes about three plus hours to play but it doesn't feel like it time flies by and it's a magical game it is a in my opinion the absolute perfect Fusion of like war game Euro mechanism hybrid historical game it's just it's just the Pinnacle of of like there's political elements to it as political elements it's about the Austrian secession right that's right yep that's absolutely right you're

playing for it's a three-player game there's probably ways to play it otherwise I would never recommend it is the best three player experience you could possibly have in my opinion um but yeah as you said it's about the of Austrian secession and it's just it's just like I said I can play it for four hours and I feel like it's been 30 minutes because you're so engaged the entire time so yeah yeah fantastic yeah well um it's a game that I've heard other people mention as well in terms of being one of their their their favorite games I have I haven't had a yet chance yet to play it I think I'm not sure if it it's out of print as well you've picked a lot well so but but it's on rally the troops now I just got added to rally the troops I did not know that okay well there's my route yeah fantastic okay right well I'll have to get one of those game I have to yeah I didn't think about I didn't think about I'm not doing people a service by picking a bunch of hard to to find games but you know that's not it's it's yeah it's about there I did have a qu kind of here I have a question for you like a final question it's just kind of curiosity for me so most of your games I'd say have a very strong solitire element to them the games I've designed meaning the games that you've designed yes yes sorry the games that you designed but the games that you've mentioned in this list seem to be largely multiplayer games is there a difference then in terms of like the games you that like there's a discrepancy there maybe yeah I don't play solitaire games period almost

almost exclusive so so I played Halls of hegra because it's I love Halls of heer fantastic um it was the only game you know I went through my all my games every one of my games and I threw out everything that I didn't think could possibly make this list it was the only solo game that was on the possible list right when I paired it down to like 15 titles so so Halls of heger is my favorite soliter game and I've said that before um I don't play soliter and what I do a lot is I play solitaire games with my daughter so we play a lot of solitire stuff together but I never cooperatively but I never ever ever ever sit down now I will sit down with a game and like take it out and set it up and kind of like look at it right especially um like war games but to sit and play it almost never do it is so it is strange that I do design solitary games but don't really play them yeah okay yeah an observation is we kind of like thinking ticking things up that's multiplayer multiplayer I mean some of them solitary elements I mean votes for women and Landing Freedom yeah solitary elements to it but most of ones when you start talking about them you're talking about the multiplayer experience getting around the table with people of course like one of the the big elements of too yeah I think too as I hearing your list too I think there is a symmetry of your design and your list in terms of accessibility right like you said those digestible two-hour games that you can play in an evening that you can invite a broad range of people in and let experience the joy of board game yeah that is true and I think the other thing is I think all of my games probably have

at least some Euro influences from a game design perspective right so I think that's and people certainly people that know me know that that's that's a heavy part of my design ethos right yeah yeah the blend of history historical aspects there some wargaming elements and some of them a lot of different mechanics that's that sits right in between that invites a lot of people into it yeah well thank you so much for for your time and going through this list I've learned a lot about you and a lot of interesting games and I think people that watch this will be have a lot of interesting games to hunt down and find too so thank you so much for joining and for for sharing yeah absolutely thanks so much for having me always always great chatting with you yep likewise thank you

Progress saved