14 Board Games Ranked - Episode 16
Transcript
hey everybody and welcome to another month in review so in this series i take a look at all the new to me games i played over the last month and i rank them from my least favorite all the way up to my most favorite i have 14 new games this month and as usual the variety between these games is massive going from the lightest of light up to the crunchiest heaviest of euros um before i get started i want to give a shout out to the show sponsor kianda dot co dot uk who are my go-to online retailer here in the uk and if you use my link in the show notes or the qr code then you can get five percent off your first order additionally i want to wanted to give a shout out to a game that's launching on kickstart or relaunching on kickstarter called the fog escape from paradise so um this game i actually reviewed last year after a prototype copy was provided to me i really enjoyed it and my review is still live so go check that one out and i know i wish the young publisher the best of luck with the new campaign but let's get started on the video at number 14 i have recollect which is by far the lightest game on this list and this is pretty much a pure memory style game and generally memory is not my strong suit not something i'd generally lean towards and however this one did some pretty cool things so this game you're going to start with i believe it's five of these face down tokens you're gonna have a chance to look at these tokens um for a few seconds before you flip them over and when they're gonna have different symbols on them such as you know like ice cream or you know a bottle of wine that kind of thing then all you got to do on your turn is
you're going to choose one of these tokens for your opponent or the person to i think is clockwise order to you to guess what is on the reverse side of that and if they guess it correctly then they gained a point and if you kind of correctly guide them to an uh to a token that they can't guess correctly then you get the points but every single time there's a guess a new token goes down which makes the game harder and harder as the game goes on and that is basically the gist of the game you keep going until the 10 minute timer runs out and whoever's got the most points at the end is the winner now surprisingly we had quite a good time with this one and i played this a couple of times now and i think maybe the reason why we did enjoy it for what it was was because it's something so different to what we normally play you know we're normally sitting down and playing you know two hour euros this is something completely off the left field and um so it felt different and it felt fresh for that reason but you know it is what it is if you like memory you'll probably like it if you don't you don't there was a few issues with the rules and this has been you know nitpicky and nobody's ever going to do this but there was no stipulation to how long you could take on your turn so technically according to the rules um if you've got a head in the game you could just sit back and not do anything when it's your turn so it was kind of broken in that regard so maybe i missed a rule in the rule book but from what i saw that was the case but you know simple memory game it was perfectly fine um production was a little bit iffy but i think the game is relatively affordable anyway at number 13 i have unk gods of egypt so this one i wasn't really planning on playing i turned up to a games night we ended up
dividing into two groups of five and one of the groups of five was a game of ankh so i thought you know i'll give this one a go i tried blood rage i tried rising sun so i may as well try and complete the trilogy now ankh i think is probably a slight well maybe comparable to blood rage in weight but this one it's a it's another area majority style game as you'd probably expect um where you're trying to have influence on these different monument types these different regions and if you have the most then you're going to get a point essentially and you're also going to get a point for um controlling the most troops in that region there's going to be fights and things where you're playing these simultaneous cards now i thought the combat was pretty cool actually because there was almost a benefit for doing everything you know if you wanted to kill your troops you could do and get points for doing so which we've seen before from this designer um and yeah there are some quite cool things going on i like the way that you could divide the board up and create new regions as the game went on but generally speaking i thought there was this was a bit too much of a kitchen sink style game a bit too much going on in terms of player powers everywhere that you could invest in it was hard to keep track of not only what you had to make sure you keep getting the income that you deserve and what you've invested in but also bearing in mind what everybody else has done as well and when you lay on top of that unique player powers from your from your races that you start with that was even more difficult to remember and one of the big no-nos for me was this merge mechanism where at a certain point in the game the players in or the two players lacking behind will merge their team together
and try to you know team up to win the game and because our game was so tight from start to finish i think when this happened there were three players on one point more than the other two players left behind so there's only one point gap therefore when they merged it felt like it really did draw a lot of the tension out of the game because they ended up losing all their influence on the table and pretty much having to start from scratch even though if they if it stayed as it was they had a perfectly viable chance of winning so that felt a little bit iffy and i couldn't quite rack my brain over why this was a rule in the first place so maybe you guys could fill me in at number 12 i have sobek two players so this is a pretty simple almost abstract style game as you have this board full of tiles um in a big grid essentially and all you do on your turn is you are moving this arc piece in a certain direction which is pre-orientated from the last tile drawn so some might say horizontally vertically or diagonally and that's going to show which color you can take next and the tiles you're going to collect in order to get set collection bonuses because you're going to multiply the goods type by the scarabs on those goods but i did quite like this corruption mechanism where if you could if you chose to skip over certain tiles because you might not be interested in them you take those tiles you skipped over as corruption and at the end of the game whoever had the most corruption would um not get a bonus token essentially but if one player really ran away with corruption they could end up taking several um bonus tokens at least the other player could some quite cool things here i think mechanically it worked well
um you know a little bit too abstract strategy for my style of gameplay i don't i tend not to like these kind of grid movement style games um but this one was certainly up there with the better ones of them it looks very nice and it produced very well but one big thing for me that was a big detriment in my opinion of the game was the this um idea of drawing these devon tokens from the bag because sometimes you could trade these tokens um these tiles you collected in to draw a devon tokens which would be these tokens that would range from three points up to nine points and that is purely done on a lucky dip so sometimes you can get three points for doing so sometimes you get nine points and as you could probably tell if that goes in your favor or goes against you that is a big point swing which could definitely determine the winner of the game so that was a bit of a bitter pill for me to swallow but the rest of it objectively i thought it was good if you like these style games you like these cathala um special powers and things i think this one could be up to all up your alley at number 11 i have demeter so demeter is a pretty involved flip and write style game as you have five decks of cards i'm all corresponding to a different color and all you're doing when you're playing you're selecting one of these cards and then taking off this row of cards matching that on your player sheet and you could only ever draw or use the same type of card four times but whenever you use it you get a bonus ability to get stronger and stronger as you go on and what you're trying to do with these cars is you're trying to color in these different dinosaur types and if you color them in you can get
bonus points based on another thing that you invested so you can kind of get these research centers that you can tick off and it's all that kind of traditional multipliers and bonuses that you'd expect from a flip and write style game it was slightly heavier than most of them that i usually play and tend to enjoy um but it works well um there's some good strategy here as you can get some cool multipliers and aim towards the um the end game scoring criteria and one of the things i did actually like about this game quite a lot was the fact that you actually had to invest in these endgame squads end game points rather than just scoring them automatically so like for example if you ended up unlocking a bunch of dinosaurs and then researching them fully that would give you the um you know the ability to score a certain end game goal or you can go up this kind of science research track and if you reach certain kind of pinnacles on it then you can unlock that in-game bonus so i do generally like it when games embed that kind of you know synergizing of the different parts of the game but other than that it was pretty standard fare albeit pretty solid at number 10 i have ganymede so ganymede is a pretty simple engine building style game as you're drafting cards and tiles to constantly improve your little engine and the idea is that you're trying to collect these meeples of different colors shift them from planet to planet and eventually land them on these objective cars and if you ever land i believe it's four or one of each of the different colors on the planet you'll score that objective card or three of the same type i believe um and if you do that um again you're
going to take that objective card put your scoring power which will score based on different things you do throughout the game but additionally you'll draw a new um objective card and put it out there and it's gonna be the first person who completes four of these objective cards and will trigger the end game but one of the things i did like about this game was not only did i have this tension of trying to get things done quickly um you could actually still do quite well if you do kind of take your time and cater your strategy more towards the objective called objective cards rather than just rushing the finish so i do tend to like that when rushing isn't the only strategy to really go for or the viable option but the rest of it was very simple you'll be drawing these cards um adding them onto your little player board and the more of the same cards color that you collect um you get to take multiple bonus actions but additionally if you get all the different card types then you can just complete a card for free so you are kind of incentivized not only to get the same card type but to also diversify but yeah definitely a you know half a step above something like splendor maybe if you're fatigued with a game like that this would be a good one to go for another solid design that i can't really criticize i'm not going to lie it doesn't terribly excite me but it's good for what it is and again and good a gateway plus style game with some kind of crunchiness to stick your teeth into at number nine i have floriferous so this is a very simple drafting and set collection game um we were trying to collect these different flower types and these different kind of bugs and insects but also collect those cars that are going to score with them so i like the
drafting system in this game as you build up these columns of cards and then in player order you are going to move on to the next column of cards and select one of them and everybody's going to follow suits however if you go kind of dive deeper on that row of cards or column of cards then you're going to go last in the next turn and these cards are going to be simple things such as just the you know the cards of the flower types some of which are going to have these insects on as well which is going to be another kind of objective to aim towards um but also you've got these cars that are actually going to score you points in the first place and some of them are going to be based on kind of bouquets of flowers you can build or some of them are based on the flower types or insect types and that kind of thing and there's also some public objectives as well where you want to be hitting them as early as possible because you're going to get more points for doing so very succinct and quick game as you're going to do is going to play i think it's probably five columns and go five back and that's pretty much the whole game so it's nice and snappy and quick it might be back again but it's whatever it is it plays in about 20 minutes very breezy very kind of charming and pleasant um and it's one of those games where i can't really ever see myself rejecting a game of this because it is so nice um but alternatively is it going to really you know again excite me is it going to draw me back in at least make me request to play it um you know often and that's probably not going to be the case because it is very passive okay so let's get into the top eight games and this is where my recommendations are going to begin so at number eight i have a universal truth which is a game that i
believe is only available on gamecrafter at the moment but this is a multi-use card style game as you are racing to complete all the needs of this love interest so you just need to get a certain number of these hearts you're going to need to get a certain amount of female and male friends a certain amount of these kind of skills and also a certain amount of money and the way you collect these cards is based on this rondelle where you i think it's like going to have 10 cards or so and a big wheel and you're going to roll a big bunch uh but bunch of dice and then you're going to draft one of those dies and that's going to show how many um spaces around this rondelle you can move with your player pawn and depending on the card you land on that's the one you're going to collect and add it into your hand then in following rounds you can play those cards in a bunch of different ways again adding them to any side of that character to try and race towards getting all their needs completed and if you are the first person to do it you are going to win but i did like that idea of what cars do i need um you know who's got the most money on them how's the what's what's the best thing for me to draft now is this next guy's gonna be there in the pool for my next draft so i can get this next card that i want and there's even these unique abilities that you can use by playing these cards from your hand and manipulating the bald state into your favor and something i really did like about this game was the ability to tinker the game or tweak the game to your level of complexity so you can play a real basic kind of little tableau builder or you can start embedding in all these tighter and tighter restrictions to make that card play more difficult and that hand management more difficult to
think through at number seven i have pergamon by stefan dora so this is a game i've been really wanting to play for a long time it's been out of print but um eagle griffin did reprint the game so i've managed to get this one to the table at last and i'm really glad i did because i enjoyed this one a lot so this is a pretty simple set collection style game but there is some cool elements of this game i haven't seen before in in other designs and i suppose the main thing about this game is the way that you acquire money because each round is going to be this deck of cards you're going to reveal two of these cards or at least draw two of them and on the back of those cards it's going to have one of two different symbols you're going to have a money bag or a kind of chest and what that means is that on the reverse side of the chest card is going to be a certain amount of coins i think it's ranging between say four and eight and on the money bag is gonna be anywhere between like one and five something like i could be wrong on the numbers but you get the jest and in player order you are going to be placing your basically meeple on this track which means that if you go closer towards the cars you are going to get a lower amount of money but you're going to get the first dibs on that money but if you go later you could end up acquiring a lot more money but bearing in mind that the the money from that pool is going to get depleted for each player before you so it's got this kind of pushy luck system so i love that idea and you know when is the right time to take the gamble and i'll turn this over on top of all that the order in which you place these mobiles is important because it's going to show the different kind of sites that you can draft from
because there's going to be five different rows of these tiles that you can collect each one gets more expensive and but the more expensive ones are going to be worth more points when it comes to curating these items so each of these tiles that you collect have two different artifacts on them and they chain together by you know connecting to each other and then if you want to you can exhibit them in the museum which is how you're going to get points but each time you get points you're going to put them on the scale and almost kick everybody down below you i'm kind of reducing their points they're going to get when it comes to the point scoring rounds um that's pretty much the whole gist of the game a very tight bunch of mechanisms that come together wonderfully very accessible um again different enough to kind of um you know to stand out from the crowd at number six i have sealand so this is another game that is kind of faded into obscurity over the years um but it's a very solid design a little tile placement tile drafter style game um as you're taking these tiles of different types um you've got like ones with flowers on them which score you points and you've also got the ones that let you establish these windmills on the board and the idea is that you want to be um surrounding your windmills with different types of flowers to score the points on them however because these tiles are hexes you can start slotting them into different places and reaching other of other players placements and things like that and the one thing i really loved about this game was the way the money works because you are really um tied um or tied arm to arm really with what the other players are doing because you it's not like in this game
you can stop pal money and save um you are always have money in accordance to what the other players have because in this in this game you have like a i think it's like five or six coins which go on this will system and whoever is at the back is where the last coin is going to be but when the person at the back starts spending money and leaving coins behind them it's going to start kind of leading the path for the people in the front to start spending money again so what that means is that if you've got someone at the back who's never spending money the people at the front are going to have no money to spend so i love that level of interaction and although it probably sounds more complicated than what i've explained it it was so simple and it's very clever but the tire placement part of the game is fun as you're trying to get the right player and slot it in you need to get some variety otherwise you're not going to score any points and there's some very clever design choices here where not only can you try and sneak into spots and get a quick grab of points but you're also rewarded for kind of investing in big points grabs because if you ever score a big chunk of points you mark it on this score track and at the end of the game whoever scored the most points in an individual placement will get more points at the end of the game so i love that and it's a great way of balancing out the two different approaches to the game but the rest of it it feels kind of timeless its data is dated very well in my opinion and i thought this is a lovely game at number five i have rapido so rapido is a re-implementation of a classic rhinocero dice game called xscape this is a pure dice trucker and i believe it
was inspired by the classic game can't stop but this one you are just running a pair of dice which is gonna have i think it's numbered from zero which is kind of signified by an x up to seven on one of them and i believe the other one is x up to six and we're gonna do is gonna roll these dice and try to get the highest number as you possibly can essentially um and once you're happy with your number you can lock it in on this chart meaning that if it gets back round to your turn you're going to move up a number of steps on this track equal to where you are on that chart it's going to be a race to get right to the top of all these steps however this game adds in some very cool player interaction as if somebody is really running away from it you can start placing your dice on a step below the um that person to try and kick them off to make sure they're not going anywhere on their turn but on top of all that um if you ever roll an x on anything but your first roll then you're going to go bust and fall down the steps but on top of all that if you end up rolling a pair either like ones like you know a pair of ones a pair of twos or a pair of threes you will instantly move up those steps and those three things mixed together just add for or to make up a wonderful game i mean extremely fun you know the fun factor on this game is off the charts and to be honest if i was purely basing it on um the fun experiences i've had this one might even be a number one no i introduced this one to my dad who very very plays any games and he had a wonderful time um which is good no this doesn't mean anything to you
guys but to me it's um it's a big statement for this game um it's quick it's fun it's addictive and definitely um up there with one of glitch's best ice games i'm absolutely infatuated with this game i think it is brilliant at number four i have golem which is certainly a step above something like rapido in terms of its complexity so this is a relatively involved crunchy euro by simone luciani who is one of my favorite designers ever and this game actually has a lot of shared dna with another luciani co-design called grand austria hotel because the drafting system in this game is very similar so in grand austria hotel you would roll a cluster of dice and allocate them to different actions based on the pit values this one does the same thing but with marbles you're going to drop a bunch of marbles in this synagogue structure and wherever they filter through is going to line up with a certain action and the more marbles lining up that actually means you're going to take a stronger version of it but of course the ones with the fewer marbles on there means that you might want to get there quicker because there's not so many options available and but you also have to be careful of the color of these marbles because they're going to correspond to these students on the on the main board and these students you want to be running through these streets they come in three different colors and they're going to correspond to these golems that you can build which which you are going to be using to take quite powerful actions i suppose but these are always going to move um kind of passively so you always need to make sure you're moving your students to keep up with them otherwise you're going to be spending knowledge tokens and which is you know a finite resource and if you
can't control them after that then you're going to sacrifice victory points which is a big no-no especially because this game is so tight very little margin for error it's only four rounds i believe and each of those four rounds you're going to draft two marbles and take a worker placement spot um so yeah a little much better as i said a ton of scope to upgrade your player board um different strategies you can go down there different paths um and i did like the ability to combo things together um has all the hallmarks of a of a you know a classic luciani game i suppose so i've only played this game once so this is definitely a first impressions um you know review i suppose um i suppose one of the biggest things that i didn't like about the game was that randomizing element of the synagogue i don't think it worked as well as the marbles did and i think a big part of that is because of the physical component of the synagogue it just didn't divide them as much as i would have liked whereas the dice you can pretty much guarantee that it's going to be random but i can see why they tried to differentiate it from the other games okay so let's get into the top three and these three games are going to be breaking into my top 100 so at number three i have antique two so this is a mac girts war game slash euro game hybrid as you are going on a big conquest trying to conquer the world get resources and make more troops i'm all with the aim of trying to fulfill these objective cards so these objective cards are going to be things such as um have sets of five um cities under your control on the board you know each when
you get five when you get 10 when you get 15 you're gonna get one of these cards so they might be seeing like control the seas or erect these temples and these temples are going to be great because they increase your income when it comes to collecting resources and it also means that you can deploy more troops on these regions and on top of that they are inviting for other players people to come and attack them because another objective is to try and destroy temples so i like the way that all these different objectives kind of merge together um you could really focus on building or you can be a bit more of a you know a warmongering star nation and try to conquer other regions um but i loved the way this game was pretty involved but it all boiled down to that classic mac gert rondelle where three of the spots are just to produce the resources one is to move your troops i think one is to move your boats and you can also invest in these knowledge abilities which increases your nation's ability to do things such as move faster or increase your defenses or to convert resources into other resources what a wonderfully streamlined war game very dry especially when it comes to the combat as it's a very deterministic combat as one troop will catch out the other no dice rolling no randomizing nothing like that so if you if you do like you know meticulously mapping things out then this is certainly a good one and the dice are not going to work against you but yeah i did i did like pretty much everything about it it's certainly not the kind of game that i will i'm always in the mood to play because no i need to be in the right head space to play something as confrontational as this but if i am want
to play something more interactive and more again in your face then um antique is certainly going to be an option because it is so easy to explain but has a ton of depth lots of layers here and different paths you can go down okay so let's get into the top two games here and there's actually only one ranks different between the two so you know depending on which way the wind blows um it could have been any order um because these two games were that close but at number two i have scout so scout is a game that's getting quite a lot of buzz recently after being nominated and it might have even won the uh the spiel de jars this year but this is a a card game it's a ladder climbing gate game as you're gonna have a hand of cards but these cards in your hand are going to be in a fixed order so you're never going to reshuffle them or reorder them um and what you're trying to do is you're trying to play a hand of a hand onto the table um and then every player following you is going to have to try and beat that and they're going to be kind of your traditional it's almost like a poker hand where you're trying to get straight or that you're trying to get pairs or you know triples and so on but each time you're trying to build on the last one and each time you better they the previous hand you're going to click click the previous hand into your scoring pile however a second option you can do is to take one of the cards from the current one on display and add it into your hand in any orientation you would have liked so it means that you can start crafting the the perfect hand of cards or arrangement of cards into your hand and i also love this level of hand management of you know i want to play
this card now so it brings these two cards together meaning that i've got my two eights together and if then if i draft another eight i've got three eights in a row which means i've got a pretty ha a strong bunch of cards here which nobody might be able to beat and you're just going to keep taking these cards until um somebody has shed all their cards in their hand or until nobody can um can better the hand or of cards in the center of the table and then whoever's got cards remaining in the hand i'm just going to end up losing points for them very simple rule set flows beautifully nice and quick great hand management big kind of tension as you want to be relatively quick to get these cars down so not to give your opponent too much opportunity to build a better hand but um not want to go too early because if they trump you you need to have something in your hand to counteract that and i think people will still be talking about this one in a few years because it does feel like a classic card game and we've had an absolute blast playing this one this month and finally the best game i've played this month is acropolis so acropolis is actually amongst the lighter games on this list very simple gateway level tile placement game um but there is a lot of depth here some cool decisions that have to be made as you are drafting these tiles in you can take the first one for free but everyone after that you're gonna have to pay a stone four to jump the queue to draft it onto your player board and what you're trying to do is you're trying to build out your city and um these towers are going to have different um kind of colors on them so you've got like the blue tiles which means that you want to be connecting them all together to build a bigger big residential area you've got
these temples which want to be surrounded by other tiles you've got these kind of red ones which want to be on the border of your of your city you've got these yellow ones that which want to be in isolation so you're constantly trying to map things out carefully trying to abide by all those restrictions as much as possible but you also need to be collecting these star symbols because those star symbols are going to be multiplied by the scoring criteria much like a game like king domino the scoring system is pretty much identical but this game has literally another layer to it and when you draft tiles in the future you can start laying on top of previously placed tiles to increase the multipliers and also to collect more stone to give you more freedom and flexibility to get the tiles that you really want this game that plays in around 25 minutes which in my opinion is an outstanding return on investment in terms of the time it takes um it's fast it's fun um it's just a brilliant game to be honest and the more i play it the more i like it um and yeah very very impressed and this one being completely streamlined there's no rules that don't need to be there and there's even two different modes of the games that you can play where you could start adding a bit more complex restrictions on the different color types but to be honest i think that the base game alone and the basic rules are more than enough um to get enjoyment from time and time again so there we have it those are another 14 games a really good month this month and you know some of these
games are so hard to divide up because um you know as you can see in the rankings they are very close to each other um and this is a really good batch one of the best batches of month of games i've had in many many months if not of all time so um yeah very good month of gaming for me in august uh if you've enjoyed this video please be sure to hit like and subscribe to my channel and check out my other content too i'm also be sure to check out the show sponsor kianda code uk i bet for everybody else i'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye-bye