Skip to main content
Loading video...

Why Losing In Board Games IS Winning!

Transcript 16:04

g'day everybody it's Danny from board game sanctuary and when it comes to playing board games I think I'm a pretty big loser in fact I think I lose about 75 of the games that I've played I can't even remember the last time I won a game well in this video we are going to be looking at interesting board game designs ones that revealed to players whether they're pulling ahead or falling behind and catch-up mechanisms that games include into their gameplay itself to try and even their game out and keep the tension right up until the very end of the game so I moved the province three spaces down the road to block your access to the three buildings that will produce you the most important resources in the game I like this feeling it feels like winning and this my friend is where you've probably gone astray after we've activated all the buildings on the road I'm going to trade a lot of my resources in to gain the favor of the Monarch which allows me to steal that character tile that allowed you to move the Provost those Extra Spaces I then going to build a monument on top of my residence which gives me 20 victory points immediately so yeah I think the feeling of winning is pretty good foreign decision to sit down and play a board game with a group of family or friends

there are three ways the game can end up either people winning losing or in a fight when it comes to losing out board games there's lots of ways to bounce back from that first thing I like to do is to discuss with my opponent uh their play style and the strategies and the Avenue that they took to find their Pathway to Victory by understanding some of the crucial decisions that they made throughout the game really helps to motivate me and allows me to learn some of the crucial moves that I need to make to adjust my gameplay also discovering the different strategies that a game has to offer employ one particular approach or Vine for one particular scoring condition and then changing my strategy in what I'm vying for in the next game is really valuable for allowing me to see what Pathways I can take in order to win my next game I also love the competitive drive that a game has to offer you know losing at a game by very close margin really fuels my motivation to want to play that game again and try and bet on my previous school that I achieved in the last game that competitive nature is what really makes games so exciting it's like watching a really tense action movie and as you head to the climax of the action movie and trying to you know see how these characters are going to resolve this really tricky situation is something that can be applied to board games where the game feels like it progresses through three different accent as you reach the climax you can see where you how you you know win a stray or how you actually secured a win the last thing I'd like to do is to familiarize myself with all the different options in the

game every decision that you make in a game is a turning point a branching point a potential room for making errors throughout the game if I can optimize the decisions that I make and analyze whether the choice that I'm making in the situation that the board is currently in is the best choice for me then I'm really going to enhance the way that I play the way that I think and the way that I execute the moves throughout my game and this my friends brings me to one of the most crucial elements in a board game showing players how far they've progressed throughout a game progress is a huge factor for determining whether you're winning or losing and how far you're losing behind the winning player whether it be using a victory Point track and calculating the number of victory points a player is a head by or whether it's satisfying a certain number of Victory conditions or objectives in a game progress kind of feels like you know when you're playing Super Mario World and you progress to world three level two you can really see how far you've gotten into the game or whether it might be a game of Street Fighter where their health bar tells you how many Health you've got left for your character before the round ends knowing your progress and giving players that feedback on the progress really helps you to evaluate your current standpoint in the game when it comes to showing how well a play is progressing throughout a game different board games approach this feedback quite differently the first type of game I want to talk about is known known as the marathon Style game which usually involves a race track players working against each other trying to get to a common destination first and whoever does it most efficiently is declared the winner of

the game games like Lewis and Clark where plays are using workers to race to explore a trail which spans along this River across the mountains and whoever gets to Fort Clatsop first or gets furthest past the fort First wins the game and this all comes down to who can manage the resources the best who can then use those resources and the specialty cards most effectively and efficiently to race as quickly as possible then you've got games like steampunk rally where players are building different engines using engine parts and then using dice to power those engines and there's different types of dice in the game like heat Dice and steam Dice and electric dice that power your vehicles along and if you can do that most efficiently without taking too much damage you're going to be able to progress along the racetrack better than the other players and this game the Quest for El Dorado a Dominion style deck building game where plays a racing across different types of terrain which is based on how well they can build their deck by navigating the different terrains more efficiently than the other players and sometimes blocking them off at particular Junctions on the way can really make for a really competitive experience one that's really fun really tight quite creative in terms of how you're going to compose your deck to do the things that you want it to do you can either use them to buy more cards or buy specialty cards that will help you to give you an advantage over the other plays that visual reference of seeing where your player is on a linear scaled

map means that you can determine how far you are ahead or how far behind you are from the other players the next group of board games that I want to talk about are ones where the winner and the losers are revealed at the very end of the game and there's a key reason why a lot of these board games choose to go along this route and that is because that hidden information about how far each player is progress throughout the game means that the tension and the suspense level throughout the game remains High until that very final reveal and a lot of deduction games often use this kind of progress mechanic where you know how far you've progressed but the other players don't know how far into the game you might have gone in the game like Cryptid where everyone has a piece of the puzzle and all players are trying to find the location of the Cryptid monster first this game does it so beautifully well what looks colorful and a little bit dry and Abstract is actually a really great thinky puzzle where you place a little count or place this Pawn on a particular location you ask a player a question and based on their response to that question you narrow down the location of this monster it is a beautiful game which is orchestrated in such an intelligent way it just creates for this aha moment and it feels like you know when you put that final piece in a 1 000 piece puzzle and you finally see the full picture this game does that well and this hidden winner reveal style mechanism also occurs in games like Mysterion which is a Cluedo

slash Dixit Style game where players are trying to solve a Murder by using Vision cards that are given by the ghost of the victim and plays a trainer to narrow down the culprits the location and the murder weapon that was used and there's this beautiful final round where players have to use a final set of Illustrated cards to determine who the actual person was and where it happened and the story that unfolded behind it some board games show you how far you're losing in far more aggressive ways games like Ticket to Ride where players are making connections and connecting routes and destinations the visual nature of the board and seeing it kind of evolve grow and cluster and stretch out over time kind of like someone stretching out in a lounge chair just really shows how far you're losing or winning the victory Point track around the edge of the board is also another gauge of how well players are doing if someone is 20 points in front of you then you're gonna have to do some serious legwork in order to connect those cities together and hopefully draw some more destination cards to swing the game back in your favor and what I think is beautiful about Ticket to Ride is the fact that there's lots of different ways to score you're going to score by the length of the train tracks that you're making or you're scoring based on the different route cards you manage to randomly draw at the end of the game and manage to connect them together different games like this really provides players with so many different ways to get to where they need the next game type that I want

to touch upon are ones where there is a secret objective and a public objective by introducing a balance of both public and secret goals means that there's a level of uncertainty and predictability when it comes to approaching different situations players often travel through these games with a sense of trepidation do they contribute to the collective effort or do they try and satisfy their own desires and own goals did a winter which is kind of like walking dead the board game is a beautiful demonstration of this very fact there's a common goal where all these survivors are trying to work to together but each player has a secret objective and some of these secret objectives have the word Betrayal on it where that player needs to satisfy that win condition so that they win and the other players lose if their secret objective doesn't have that keyword on it they're trying to work together as a group so there's always that sense that someone in the group is trying to sabotage the rest of the group so they don't get to their final goal because of their own greedy desires and that introduces a huge interesting undercurrent that flows throughout the game what players think they're doing is progressing in the game is actually helping out a single player the degree into which players can access certain resources action tiles and also particular bonus effects really reshapes the landscape of the game if a player has access to multiple action tiles that

gives them better options better resources and a more efficient way of getting those resources then that play is going to really break out into the lead and this is a disparaging Gap when it comes to losing at board games sitting there and witnessing someone else with a better engine better way of getting resources and things that you actually want in your engine uh is a little bit frustrating sometimes to watch and quite often when I reflect on a board game experience usually I lose because I make a sub-optimal move or I don't respond to someone else's uh progress at the game effectively to try and stop them from running away a lot of games do have a catch-up mechanic that tries to balance the game and you don't want to invest your time in a three-hour game I don't need to know that by hour one you've already lost the game in this two hours left to go all of sky is a board game that has an interesting catch-up mechanism in all of Sky players are expanding their Clan's Kingdom by purchasing and selling tiles think of carcassone with a little bit of an optioning element to it players are trying to build their map and satisfy a range of objectives at the same time now what's really interesting about the catch-up mechanism here is that from round three onwards however many players are in front of you on the victory Point track you're going to get a certain amount of coins so for example in round five if there are two players Pawns in front of you on the victory Point track you're going to get six dollars in your pocket at first you might think that this game is rewarding players for poor decision making but actually in a game like this which is driven by economy

it's really hard to gauge how much things are going to be worth and this is a really cool integrated grading mechanism that helps to keep things really tight where towards the end of the game players are falling far behind have a chance to win the game and that creates for some really cool tense moments of oh there's a really big tile that I need that will complete this route or this terrain and satisfy that final objective and I'll have enough coins to outbid maybe the winning player games like Suburbia also do this really well and if you haven't played Suburbia it's basically a tile drafting game where players are building a city using these hexagonal tiles and they're placing them in these boroughs to create income increase population and reputation and as players increase their population which kind of acts as the victory points in this game it's kind of thematically linked to the ID that as your city grows the reputation of your city is going to decrease because the city is getting overcrowded so every time a player passes this red line they're going to reduce their income and reputation by one level this little balancing mechanism as you can see as you get further and further up the victory Point track the red lines become more and more frequent this creates an interesting way for other players to kind of keep up with the leading player and I like how in Suburbia they try to link this in a real world sense quacks of credenberg is one

of my favorite games it's one of those bad building games where you draw out little uh ingredients and then put them in your pot hoping that your pot doesn't explode the rat's tail mechanism in this game is an interesting way to keep things really nice and tense what happens is the players who are falling behind the furthest player get to place their rat token out into their pot equal to the number of rat tokens that are between their Victory Point markers on the victory Point track so if I was in second place and the person was in first place and there were three rat tails uh between us on the victory Point track I'd be able to place my rat token three spaces away from my droplet token giving me a little bit of a head start making my pot feel a little bit Fuller giving me a little bit of an advantage uh so I can keep up with the leading player Kemet is a pretty aggressive Miniatures game where players are trying to bid and buy Power tiles to help leverage their troops in order to attack other players in order to gain victory points what I think is really good about camera in terms of how it balances that runaway leader effect is it first of all introduces politics where different uh players might decide to band together to focus on a play that's in the lead but also so the player who has the least amount of victory points and is falling behind gets to determine the turn order for the subsequent round and that might mean knowing what the player is going to do next with their pyramid powers or knowing what an opponent has in terms of

their combo tiles and trying to determine the play order about who's going to get those power tiles in the next round or trying to leverage their troops before a player can attack them by pushing themselves further in front in turn order that power to manipulate the turn order if you're losing the game really helps to keep things even what do you think about losing in board games are you someone who wins a lot loses a lot or you don't care either way I'd love to hear about your board game experiences in the comments section below thank you once again for making it so far with me in this video If you really appreciate the really cool content that I release and share with you guys please don't forget to head over to my patreon page and support board game Sanctuary over there always consider giving us a like and a subscribe and forward to bringing you some more awesome board game content soon from the land down under see you later guys bye

Progress saved